I never understood this. The film clearly shows they would not have been able to do it. Jack tries to get on, but realizes rather quickly that is not going to work. This shot is in the film. It’s not a plot hole. It’s there.
I've thought this so much. Of course it looks to us like he could fit. He and Rose both thought he could fit too, which is why they tried to have him fit... But they, like us, realized they were wrong.
That's what I was just thinking. It's one of the most viewed movies in the world. How do people not see that. I haven't even watched the whole thing but I saw that part.
Such class. I’m amazed at the originality and creativity of her expression of response. Who on earth would ever have thought of using the f word, especially when there are so few clean and decent adjectives in the English language?
There was a real experiment type test where James Cameron did a “mythbusters” with 2 actors similar in size to Kate and Leo. They wore similar costumes and were given a prop board for both to get onto. They were In cold water too. Their body temperature was measured and when both actors got on board their bodies were submerged enough where their temperatures were decreasing.
I love how Kate is aging naturally.. and therefore looks like herself still.. so natural and gorgeous. Unlike the previously beautiful women who end up looking like caricatures of themselves- and all that remains, are those classic, tiny beaded eyes- filled with fear...
I agree! Bc even when was just Rose on the boat the there was already a layer of water on top as well. And the idea was to be out of the water as much as possible.
The Mythbusters tested this! It was a question of buoyancy rather than size. ‘Cause, if you remember, Jack did try to get on with her but the door tipped over
I've seen that episode Mythbusters also knew what they were testing, they knew what they went into and they could get out of the water right after Jack and Rose had no idea what they were in for, how to handle a situation like that and had to try and not freeze to death They weren't able to think of anything other than the pain of that water with hypothermia setting in
Yes and if you remember James Cameron addressed the issue in the Mythbusters episode saying that Jack was *always* going to die one way or another and his biggest regret was not making the damn headboard smaller so he wouldn't have to field this question over a thousand times since the movies release in 1997.
The mythbusters also used a ballistic jelly mold of Adam filled with copper piping to simulate a circulatory system and proved that if they had both been on the door the several inches of sub freezing water that they would have exposed to was enough to kill them both before the rescue boat arrived.
Not just them, it seems most people don't remember. That's why this dumb question continues to be asked even though it was clearly answered in the movie.
You could actually see when Jack tried to get on the door when Rose was already on it, that the door began to sink and srarted to flip over It was obvious they could not both get on the door at the same time Miss Winslet is correct, of course 👍
YES 👍 Honestly, I seem to learn something new every time I watch this movie , but I did pick up that seen the first time I saw it Always wondered why they question why they both didn’t get on the door , or headboard 😀😀😀😀
I just love how Kate is doing nothing to change herself, aging gracefully & beautifully, oozing class & inner confidence - credit to her parents & upbringing.
Had he not sacrificed, it wouldn't have been so rooted in our hearts. It takes a lot to sacrifice your life for someone you love..when you have just started... It doesn't matter how long you lived rather how happy you were while you existed.❤
I feel like that scene in Titanic is like a litmus test of age. When i was a kid and saw the movie I remember thinking it was silly that she said “I’ll never let you go” and then literally let him sink into the ocean. As an adult I fully understand physically parting with someone you love and years and years later, holding onto that sentiment whether they are there with you or not. a child can never understand that type of deep lifelong hold. as a woman, I admire Rose for her courage to live
If you watch the movie, Jack did try to get on the door, but it immediately started sinking with both of them on top of it. So, he got off to save Rose. On the show Mythbusters, they addressed this scene, confirmed that the door would have sunk underwater with two adults on top, and discovered that the door would have been buoyant for two adults if they had thought to put their life vests under the door. Given that their ship had just sunk, people were around them splashing in a panic, the water was freezing cold, and neither Jack or Rose were all that knowledgeable about buoyancy, I doubt they would have thought to put their vests under the door in that circumstance. 🎤 ⬇️💥
Perfectly answered :) Yes, the scene of him trying to climb on is in the film. It never bothered me because they addressed the issue and like you said, even if there was another solution they wouldn't be thinking clearly in icy cold water with people screaming all around. Case closed although it should have never been opened 😅
@@pokemonitishere202 that's the point.O oo,maybe I didn't understand you.she looks to you like smth beautifull.She is!But the role she plays is not like that.she plays stupid girl"next door" and she is very very smart,intelligete in serial and she do not wanna to know enyone arond her what she's really like
I just love her sense of humor. She could be really good in a sitcom. She is so talented. Leo too of course. She makes me smile when I see her in interviews. Her emphasis on the word fucking. She’s right though the door would become unstable and parts of her body would have been in the water and she would suffer hypothermia.
I absolutely love their chemistry. When you see them in person you see they have a strong connection. They are soulmates (which doesn’t have to be romantic)
Did everyone go blind at the perfectly clear scene when Jack tried to get on the door and it immediately started sinking so he decided to stay off?! That’s your answer! And what’s more surprising is that Leo and Kate don’t even mention that!
I think they forgot. I did also until people like you mentioned it they I remembered oh yeah he tries to get on then gets a worried look on his face then gets back off it.
I think the question stems from our deep regret and heartache that he had to die to save her. The whole world seeks an answer to that incredible loss we felt for all those who died. That is where this question really stems from. Our hearts can never accept such a great loss.
She's scientifically right. I'm a scientist and because of the water displacement, the door with both of them might have held them up buoyantly enough so they didn't sink all the way down, but the door would have been just underneath the surface of the water, which would have frozen them eventually. The reason Rose survived is because she stayed outside of the water but more importantly, she stayed dry (relatively speaking).
@@lacatracha8649 they were barely surviving. it was about staying dry and conserving energy. the thought of them wet and having enough energy to take turns is nice, but not realistic.
Archimedes' principle states that the upward buoyant force that is exerted on a body immersed in a fluid, whether fully or partially, is equal to the weight of the fluid that the body displaces. Water is 62.4 pcf, say 120 lb body on a standard size door 3’x7’, the door would sink 1.1” into the water. This assumes perfectly centered mass on the door. 120/62.4=1.92 cu ft 1.92/(3x7)=0.092 ft 0.092x12= 1.1”
Mythbusters tested this myth. You are wrong. You're not a good scientist if you conclude before testing your hypnosis. On the episode both Mythbuster adult men could float on the door. Two teenagers would have had an easier time.
Jack not getting on that board made sure that other drowning passengers won’t compete for that board. Jack assured the stability and protection of the Board and her survival.
It's actually not even a door, but James Cameron did an experiment -- in recent years -- to prove that only one person could have stayed on that piece of paneling. A second person immediately starts to flip the paneling over and causes the entire thing to dip below the water, so it was absolutely impossible for Jack to get up there alongside Rose. Cameron finally did that experiment on camera, because he was tired of constantly hearing the "Jack could have lived/why didn't he get up on the 'door' with Rose" crap over the course of two decades or so. The entire episode is here on RUclips, and he does the experiment with the wood paneling and debunks a few common misconceptions, too. Another experiment he did with the lifeboats actually changed the way I viewed certain aspects of the actual sinking of the Titanic.
Thank God for the logic! Cause this is exactly what I always say. Jack initially does try to get on with Rose and it causes the door to tip over. So when he successfully gets Rose on alone he knows, with both on the door would've submerged or capsized.
I recall bill paxton address this 2 so many angry serious titanic fans,saying "i think jack would have fit the door,too,but the script says he has to die for dramatic effect. Anyway,calm down,guys,we're talking of 2 fictitious characters.." something like that.
Actually the Mythbusters show tested this. It was possible to fit both on the door, but the weight of them both sank the door under the water enough to expose them to enough cold water for long enough where they would both eventually die of Hypothermia. So yes it is possible, for both to fit, but almost unlikely they both survive.
I remember we tried calculating it in a physics class Assuming the door was either mahogany or oak, which are the most common types of wood used in that period, they could have stayed on technically, space-wise, but the board would have been a few centimeters underwater because of their combined weight
Watching the movie the first time, I was screaming that he could fit on the door! I recently took my 18 year old son to the theater to see tge movie for the first time, and we both sat there and cried when Jack died. Yes, even though I've seen the movie countless times, I cry every single time. My son cried, too!
James Cameron has addressed this issue numerous times over the years saying that Jack was *always* going to die one way or another and his biggest regret was not making the damn headboard smaller so he wouldn't have to field this question over a thousand times since the movies release in 1997.
I agree 💯% with her and have thought that since the beginning. But people get heated and won't listen to logic. So, I'm glad it was said by Rose, herself.
I remember watching the film and i was like Let me see if they had enough space for both of them. Truth is even in the film, jack tried to climb up that board but ended up pulling them down so he decided what he thought was best and what was in the script.
@Nor Qaisara Hazrin - It's not that he didn't like the movie but how would *you* feel being asked the same ridiculous questions over and over again for over two decades? Leo was 22 years old when he made Titanic and has acted in well over a dozen other movies in the 27 years since but everything always comes back to Titanic. I'd be pretty frustrated and exasperated at this point too, answering the same questions about the same movie over and over again.
I always wonder why Leo and Kate never ended up in real life. They seem to have so much chemistry and love for each other and a similar attitude towards this question. lol
I remember when this movie came out and all my peers would wear t shirt with the characters face on it. It's been so many years later and I still haven't watched that movie
Kate answered as she was still Rose and Leo is jack ,and as like the rose came to an interview... this shows how much the movie close to their heart and the bestest of their film career.
Hi, I know it's been 7 months, but i had to answer. The waters were below freezing temperature that night, and most people in the water died of hypothermia in about 15 minutes. If they took turns, they both would have died since getting back into the water would have accelerated Rose's hypothermia, and Jack was basically doomed by the time Rose noticed that it was getting quiet.
They keep saying "I don't know" but y'all can't tell me there's not one time they both sat on that door waiting for directions from the director/producer 💀💀😭 y'all were treading water the WHOLE TIMEEm
@Dana Guilbeau so you were there behind the scenes? I'm saying for behind the scenes they must have both sat on that door while waiting for directions or something. They know the truth they just don't wanna say
The point of the scene was never that they both couldn't fit on it. The point was the board wouldn't hold both of them afloat. That's why Jack doesn't get on it. I don't know why people keep saying that Jack could have fit on it when that wasn't even the point.
@@tabora_ considering they were in a swimming pool it’s absolutely possible they didn’t sit on the door whist waiting for directions, they could just stand in the water… or on the side… Also, the director of the movie said multiple times the piece wood could not hold them both, they tested it
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
What do you think? Make sure to watch my full chat with Kate here! ruclips.net/video/L22JpW6an-o/видео.html
I think....she's so tired of the whole discussion 😂😂😂😂😂
@@bethcushway458 to quote Murtaugh "I am too old for this shit"
Put life jackets under the door
Methinks Kate needed a "Jack" to help with the buoyancy 🚪 😂
I wish people would stop giving her hate for that scene and her body type at that time I hate it I hate it
That is literally what I have been thinking all these years
Me too!!!!
Same here🙌
YES
MythBusters tested it, if you really want to know
They even show it in the movie, the door bounced when Jack tried to get on
1. It's not a door, it's a piece of panelling.
2. It's not a matter of space, it's a matter of buoyancy.
Yes! People are confusing surface area for buoyancy.
Sorry, but I don’t think it was a piece of paneling because apparently paneling will not hold a child much less a grown adult
I will take a guess that it was a headboard to a bed
Who cares
Plus even if it did stay afloat wouldn’t the water have just been on the surface and froze them anyway?
I like James Cameron's answer to this
" No he couldn't have fit on the door because it's written in the script that Jack had to die "
I thought that straight away its in the script
He said my movie my rules basically
..Means, you can deny even the existence of God if you want . .but you can never deny what's written in a final movie script !
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@A.Netizen.Since.2010STFU
Leo and Kate have fantastic chemistry on screen and they are still good friends.
Also Kate is still stunning as ever
one of the only cebrarbrity women l still fancy Kate Winslet
What about Leo???
Shame about her swearing there was need for that.
@margueritahancock5472 Satan is always watching you. Be very afraid.
In the movie, you can clearly see that he tries to get on the door and they’re both too heavy for it
thanku I stg people don't pay attention how is this even a question we saw it tip when he tried 😂
No they are not too heavy but leo delibratley turns it over to make it look like it cannot hold both of them
Everyone forgets that!
@@mattluszczak8095that's the director's idea cuz it's part of the plot.
You can also clearly see it's not a door either. Yet people always call it a door.
I never understood this. The film clearly shows they would not have been able to do it. Jack tries to get on, but realizes rather quickly that is not going to work. This shot is in the film. It’s not a plot hole. It’s there.
Thank you! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I've thought this so much. Of course it looks to us like he could fit. He and Rose both thought he could fit too, which is why they tried to have him fit... But they, like us, realized they were wrong.
That's what I was just thinking. It's one of the most viewed movies in the world. How do people not see that. I haven't even watched the whole thing but I saw that part.
👏 Sensible guy/girl
Exactly
"I don't fucking know!" best answer ever
All she knows is...... 😂
Such class. I’m amazed at the originality and creativity of her expression of response.
Who on earth would ever have thought of using the f word, especially when there are so few clean and decent adjectives in the English language?
The most British answer 🤣🤣😮💨
And British too
I wish she had said that in the film when Jack asked her whether she would have jumped.
She still identifies with the character. She said, 'we would not have survived'. Wow!
Does she.
@@letsdiscussitoversometea8479she does , read about it , she fought and campaigned for to get the role
@@letsdiscussitoversometea8479im in your walls
I think she was being sarcastic there
There was a real experiment type test where James Cameron did a “mythbusters” with 2 actors similar in size to Kate and Leo. They wore similar costumes and were given a prop board for both to get onto. They were In cold water too. Their body temperature was measured and when both actors got on board their bodies were submerged enough where their temperatures were decreasing.
The movie was NOT filmed in cold water, though. Obviously.
I love the quiet exasperation in her voice at the first answer.
I love that she’s aging naturally and looking so comfortable with herself ❤
Famke jennessen çomes to mind as instead of aging gracefully and being beautiful she literally looks like a 49 year old lizard.
Love how shes so totally over having to answer that question like ffs ask James Cameron not me 😂
Stop commenting on how a woman chooses to age.
@Shoshanna Keam if someone sees something unhealthy or abnormal it's normal to comment on it. Hence the comment section
@@russell8388 Their comment wasn't to do with anything abnormal
What a smart diplomatic answer and honestly totally agree
It’s not smart it’s basic knowledge💀
I love how Kate is aging naturally.. and therefore looks like herself still.. so natural and gorgeous. Unlike the previously beautiful women who end up looking like caricatures of themselves- and all that remains, are those classic, tiny beaded eyes- filled with fear...
She’s beautiful!
Like Courtney cox still not over that she used to be super pretty!
Botox has destroyed so many faces
@@TheMaskedChef7 Jennifer Aniston as well
@@kimabrahams1940Megan Fox also
I agree! Bc even when was just Rose on the boat the there was already a layer of water on top as well. And the idea was to be out of the water as much as possible.
This woman has never lost not one single percentage from all her beauty. She's so beautiful!
@@WorknWonderful-
That's correct!
Bad language lets her down.
@@jsemplefelton5348
That's not nice coming from a lady!
Ikr I was just noticing its like she’s more beautiful as she ages!
@@stephanieschannel777
That's true!
The Mythbusters tested this! It was a question of buoyancy rather than size. ‘Cause, if you remember, Jack did try to get on with her but the door tipped over
I've seen that episode
Mythbusters also knew what they were testing, they knew what they went into and they could get out of the water right after
Jack and Rose had no idea what they were in for, how to handle a situation like that and had to try and not freeze to death
They weren't able to think of anything other than the pain of that water with hypothermia setting in
What if they had tried again and got on from the right respectively the left? Or was it that the mythbusters tested and that also failed?
Yes and if you remember James Cameron addressed the issue in the Mythbusters episode saying that Jack was *always* going to die one way or another and his biggest regret was not making the damn headboard smaller so he wouldn't have to field this question over a thousand times since the movies release in 1997.
The mythbusters also used a ballistic jelly mold of Adam filled with copper piping to simulate a circulatory system and proved that if they had both been on the door the several inches of sub freezing water that they would have exposed to was enough to kill them both before the rescue boat arrived.
@@MangindDerous They're odds were WAY better than IN the water, though. And you have combined body heat.
I have a more pressing question!!! How come BOTH of them don't remember the scene where Leo does try to get on and the door almost flipped over?????
I WAS THINKING THIS LMFAO
Not just them, it seems most people don't remember. That's why this dumb question continues to be asked even though it was clearly answered in the movie.
EXACTLY. I keep telling people he tested it out and it didn't work. He TRIED.
I'm sure they do, how are you going to tell thousands of fans that they're dumb lol
Yes but the question is...did they try hard enough?
You could actually see when Jack tried to get on the door when Rose was already on it, that the door began to sink and srarted to flip over
It was obvious they could not both get on the door at the same time
Miss Winslet is correct, of course 👍
This is something I noticed when I recently rewatched the movie.
YES 👍 Honestly, I seem to learn something new every time I watch this movie , but I did pick up that seen the first time I saw it
Always wondered why they question why they both didn’t get on the door , or headboard 😀😀😀😀
This is correct, Jack realised that Rose would not survive if he got on the door with her. You can tell by his face.
Exactly
@@eimsmarieb3084 yes, he is even nodding like somehow accepting it
Kate's British accent is my favorite of all the dialects in England. I could listen to her all day. I dont know where she's from but it's so lovely.
How can someone be so effortlessly graceful!!!
Kate “I don’t f know”
Also Kate: morphs into a floating emergency door technician 👩🔧
Lol
Brilliant. Thank you for making me lol 😂
😂
😂😂😂
She literally talked about a paddle board.
I just love how Kate is doing nothing to change herself, aging gracefully & beautifully, oozing class & inner confidence - credit to her parents & upbringing.
I love Kate Winslet so much. She has remained herself from the beginning. Shes unapologetically herself, and unapologetically british 🤣💜
I love you
Gotta love the down-to-earth yet somehow graceful way Kate handles the question.
She's spot on about paddle boards and they're door sized!
My jaw drops everytime I see Kate, she is a natural actor.
Had he not sacrificed, it wouldn't have been so rooted in our hearts. It takes a lot to sacrifice your life for someone you love..when you have just started... It doesn't matter how long you lived rather how happy you were while you existed.❤
Exactly if they both survived, it would never be such a legendary movie
Even though there is logic stating that he couldn't, the emotional part is important too.
She is aging naturally still so pretty and gorgeous and love the way she explains the ending perfectly . love her and really look up to her always ❤️
I feel like that scene in Titanic is like a litmus test of age. When i was a kid and saw the movie I remember thinking it was silly that she said “I’ll never let you go” and then literally let him sink into the ocean.
As an adult I fully understand physically parting with someone you love and years and years later, holding onto that sentiment whether they are there with you or not.
a child can never understand that type of deep lifelong hold.
as a woman, I admire Rose for her courage to live
Yes, I think that is a sensible answer, Kate! Wise & intelligent woman!
I just love her. She is so beautiful, so warm, so gentle and also a great actress. I adored her in The Holiday and The Mountain Between Us.❤️❤️❤️
I like you
@Michaela Sykorova
..I really liked the both movies you've mentioned but what about Labor Day, The Reader & Jude?...Have you seen them?
If you watch the movie, Jack did try to get on the door, but it immediately started sinking with both of them on top of it. So, he got off to save Rose.
On the show Mythbusters, they addressed this scene, confirmed that the door would have sunk underwater with two adults on top, and discovered that the door would have been buoyant for two adults if they had thought to put their life vests under the door. Given that their ship had just sunk, people were around them splashing in a panic, the water was freezing cold, and neither Jack or Rose were all that knowledgeable about buoyancy, I doubt they would have thought to put their vests under the door in that circumstance. 🎤 ⬇️💥
Perfectly answered :) Yes, the scene of him trying to climb on is in the film. It never bothered me because they addressed the issue and like you said, even if there was another solution they wouldn't be thinking clearly in icy cold water with people screaming all around. Case closed although it should have never been opened 😅
also they risk drowning if they take off their lifevests
He didn't even wear a vest if I remember correctly.
Yes,she is always look like"girl next door".beautifull,smart,everything.I just love her
She is amazing. ❤
Young Rose was nowhere near "the girl next door". She looked as if she was straight out of a beautiful renaissance painting.
@@pokemonitishere202 that's the point.O oo,maybe I didn't understand you.she looks to you like smth beautifull.She is!But the role she plays is not like that.she plays stupid girl"next door" and she is very very smart,intelligete in serial and she do not wanna to know enyone arond her what she's really like
@@pokemonitishere202 oooh,you like her,you love her ,you gonna married(sorry remaind me on song at USA)
Time has travelled so far ,
But.... My memory of your Titanic still lingers.
I just love her sense of humor. She could be really good in a sitcom. She is so talented. Leo too of course. She makes me smile when I see her in interviews. Her emphasis on the word fucking. She’s right though the door would become unstable and parts of her body would have been in the water and she would suffer hypothermia.
Exactly. He even tried to get on the door to begin with but it wasn't working so he just let her stay on it. Do people forget that?
Yup just like they forget it’s wall panelling not a door lol
they just want to create fights and controversy tbh
I absolutely love their chemistry. When you see them in person you see they have a strong connection. They are soulmates (which doesn’t have to be romantic)
Did everyone go blind at the perfectly clear scene when Jack tried to get on the door and it immediately started sinking so he decided to stay off?! That’s your answer! And what’s more surprising is that Leo and Kate don’t even mention that!
I think they forgot. I did also until people like you mentioned it they I remembered oh yeah he tries to get on then gets a worried look on his face then gets back off it.
Good serious answer to a stupid question. And her follow-up about the buoyancy was good too.
I think the question stems from our deep regret and heartache that he had to die to save her. The whole world seeks an answer to that incredible loss we felt for all those who died. That is where this question really stems from. Our hearts can never accept such a great loss.
She's scientifically right. I'm a scientist and because of the water displacement, the door with both of them might have held them up buoyantly enough so they didn't sink all the way down, but the door would have been just underneath the surface of the water, which would have frozen them eventually. The reason Rose survived is because she stayed outside of the water but more importantly, she stayed dry (relatively speaking).
Exactly!
Thanks for sharing, I’m curious about the science behind this. what about if they had switched and taken turns being on the door?
@@lacatracha8649 they were barely surviving. it was about staying dry and conserving energy. the thought of them wet and having enough energy to take turns is nice, but not realistic.
Archimedes' principle states that the upward buoyant force that is exerted on a body immersed in a fluid, whether fully or partially, is equal to the weight of the fluid that the body displaces.
Water is 62.4 pcf, say 120 lb body on a standard size door 3’x7’, the door would sink 1.1” into the water. This assumes perfectly centered mass on the door.
120/62.4=1.92 cu ft
1.92/(3x7)=0.092 ft
0.092x12= 1.1”
Mythbusters tested this myth. You are wrong. You're not a good scientist if you conclude before testing your hypnosis. On the episode both Mythbuster adult men could float on the door. Two teenagers would have had an easier time.
She’s soooo classy!! Love her so much
Jack not getting on that board made sure that other drowning passengers won’t compete for that board. Jack assured the stability and protection of the Board and her survival.
Maybe.
@@kathleen4376 wdym maybe. It's literally in the movie. That's what happened.
I believe it’s her first time answering that question seriously. What she said was honest and true
It's actually not even a door, but James Cameron did an experiment -- in recent years -- to prove that only one person could have stayed on that piece of paneling. A second person immediately starts to flip the paneling over and causes the entire thing to dip below the water, so it was absolutely impossible for Jack to get up there alongside Rose. Cameron finally did that experiment on camera, because he was tired of constantly hearing the "Jack could have lived/why didn't he get up on the 'door' with Rose" crap over the course of two decades or so. The entire episode is here on RUclips, and he does the experiment with the wood paneling and debunks a few common misconceptions, too. Another experiment he did with the lifeboats actually changed the way I viewed certain aspects of the actual sinking of the Titanic.
Leo said, im not answering this damn question again
This is what I've been saying the whole time!! It wasn't about space it was the weight!
Thank God for the logic! Cause this is exactly what I always say. Jack initially does try to get on with Rose and it causes the door to tip over. So when he successfully gets Rose on alone he knows, with both on the door would've submerged or capsized.
It's not whether two people would fit on the door, it's whether the door was buoyant enough to keep two people's combined weight above the water line.
Great answer! Good on ya, Kate!
I love how Kate just ignored Brad's stupid comment
“I don’t fucking know.”
- Kate Winslet (idk what year)
she’s a queen we love her
I recall bill paxton address this 2 so many angry serious titanic fans,saying "i think jack would have fit the door,too,but the script says he has to die for dramatic effect. Anyway,calm down,guys,we're talking of 2 fictitious characters.." something like that.
Actually the Mythbusters show tested this. It was possible to fit both on the door, but the weight of them both sank the door under the water enough to expose them to enough cold water for long enough where they would both eventually die of Hypothermia.
So yes it is possible, for both to fit, but almost unlikely they both survive.
I remember we tried calculating it in a physics class
Assuming the door was either mahogany or oak, which are the most common types of wood used in that period, they could have stayed on technically, space-wise, but the board would have been a few centimeters underwater because of their combined weight
And a few cm of freezing water for hours means both would have died.
I wish we had such a interesting physics class
THANK YOU KATE! I was having this same argument with my dad a few days ago. 😂
I like you
And THAT IS EXACTLY what I’ve been saying for YEARS! 😂❤ love her
She is so down to earth and funny 😂❤
Watching the movie the first time, I was screaming that he could fit on the door! I recently took my 18 year old son to the theater to see tge movie for the first time, and we both sat there and cried when Jack died. Yes, even though I've seen the movie countless times, I cry every single time. My son cried, too!
James Cameron has addressed this issue numerous times over the years saying that Jack was *always* going to die one way or another and his biggest regret was not making the damn headboard smaller so he wouldn't have to field this question over a thousand times since the movies release in 1997.
To me it looked like the door was barely floating i.e. even if he squeezed on, it would have sunk under them.
Exactly, they both would touch water and get cold
What a classy way of saying "fuck off" 😂
Now I want to see a video of Keke Palmer reacting to Kate’s conclusion 😂
I agree 💯% with her and have thought that since the beginning. But people get heated and won't listen to logic. So, I'm glad it was said by Rose, herself.
I remember watching the film and i was like Let me see if they had enough space for both of them. Truth is even in the film, jack tried to climb up that board but ended up pulling them down so he decided what he thought was best and what was in the script.
The way people have been losing their minds over this for years😂😂😂 love her
For me Kate Winslet was and still is the most beautiful woman on earth
Without a question
Without a question
I love Kate so much, she’s so incredibly talented and hilarious in her normality
Leo seems so sick of that question.
@Nor Qaisara Hazrin - It's not that he didn't like the movie but how would *you* feel being asked the same ridiculous questions over and over again for over two decades? Leo was 22 years old when he made Titanic and has acted in well over a dozen other movies in the 27 years since but everything always comes back to Titanic. I'd be pretty frustrated and exasperated at this point too, answering the same questions about the same movie over and over again.
😂 i'm watching this in December 2023, i saw Titanic in February 1998 and i can't believe that this question is still plaguing us 25 years later 😂
Kate, i definitely admire your sense of humour and distance 😍
I always wonder why Leo and Kate never ended up in real life. They seem to have so much chemistry and love for each other and a similar attitude towards this question. lol
Because he doesn’t date women over the age of 25
He prefers what I like to call: "women's best 7 years" (the years from 18 to 25)
Becayse Leo's gay
I like you
The door: "Yes. I got laid by Rose Dawson!! Bye, Jack." 🥶☠️
Love the earrings!
Kate has a great personality.
Genuine.
I love you, Kate! You are the real deal!!!
She is so cool and is aging so beautifully! Truly an inspiration for those of us who don't want to put needles or have surgery on our faces
Ahh Kate got real
That's just what rose has been telling herself for years to make her feel better for not moving over
Lol
It's a MOVIE
@@ohmthepoet8428 👍
To quote Murtaugh "I am too old for this shit"
After almost 30 years....thank u! I bowed down & say thank u Rose!😂❤ i told ya! & let that go!
I absolutely love Kate Winslet. Definitely my favorite actress.
I remember when this movie came out and all my peers would wear t shirt with the characters face on it. It's been so many years later and I still haven't watched that movie
Congrats
@@radhiadeedou8286 thank you
I think Jack didn’t get on the door on purpose because saving Rose was more important to him than saving himself.
Well obviously
Kate answered as she was still Rose and Leo is jack ,and as like the rose came to an interview... this shows how much the movie close to their heart and the bestest of their film career.
The way that Leo is sitting there cracking up and then says, "No comment" always gets me
Thank you for FINALLY settling that!!! Got it sorted❤
The real question should hv been" why didnt they both take turns on that door?
Hi, I know it's been 7 months, but i had to answer.
The waters were below freezing temperature that night, and most people in the water died of hypothermia in about 15 minutes. If they took turns, they both would have died since getting back into the water would have accelerated Rose's hypothermia, and Jack was basically doomed by the time Rose noticed that it was getting quiet.
If you think getting yourself wet and then lying motionless in freezing temperatures is a good idea you must live in a warm climate.
The fact that's she's aged this much, makes me realize how old I'm becoming
its amazing and terrifying at same time..
Whatever she needs to tell herself to sleep at night 😂😂
I love how he continues to ask the question after she's done answering it
I love her vocabulary so much.
She’s an intelligent woman.
They could have taken turns. He wouldn't have frozen to death
They had a hard time moving I don't think that would've worked out
They keep saying "I don't know" but y'all can't tell me there's not one time they both sat on that door waiting for directions from the director/producer 💀💀😭 y'all were treading water the WHOLE TIMEEm
They did not get on the board at the same time
@Dana Guilbeau so you were there behind the scenes? I'm saying for behind the scenes they must have both sat on that door while waiting for directions or something. They know the truth they just don't wanna say
The point of the scene was never that they both couldn't fit on it. The point was the board wouldn't hold both of them afloat. That's why Jack doesn't get on it.
I don't know why people keep saying that Jack could have fit on it when that wasn't even the point.
@@tabora_ considering they were in a swimming pool it’s absolutely possible they didn’t sit on the door whist waiting for directions, they could just stand in the water… or on the side…
Also, the director of the movie said multiple times the piece wood could not hold them both, they tested it
We do have this discussion regularly in our family so thanks for answering it Kate x 😂
I love what keke palmer says about this "girl, you didn't think to take turns?!"
They just needed a Tulkun whale…
The scene was conveying hypothermia and how incapacitated you become.
Correct answer