Just wanted to say - NOT the only option. There are tons of competing "closets" out there, so you can buy only the closet thingy in any size you want, and use it in your own suitcase. That makes life easier. Instead of buying this suitcase just for the closet, in case you don't need a new suitcase and you like the one that you already have - just buy the closet and use it. You just have to make sure you buy the right size that fits your suitcase. Another thing to remember is that these closets can be used in your checked luggage as well - it will fit better, you'll have plenty of room around it and then it just serves as a big compression cube. So to whoever travels with checked luggage - buy a closet that fits your suitcase and you can enjoy it.
I have spent quite a bit of time looking for a hanging, compressible closet and haven't found many options. Amazon and Alibaba are filled with hanging closets, but none that feature good compression straps. The closest I could find was an LL Bean 'Personal Organizer Hanging Packing Cube' for $70. Do you have any hangable, compressible options or are you just saying?
@@notreal5311 There are many RUclipsrs who tried the suitcase with and without the closet inside. They all say and show the same thing - the same suitcase can hold much more without the closet, the closet is heavy and takes way too much space. So all that compression and features they show you - they just look good, but not very useful in real life. I see no point in paying so much more for that closet, sorry. Compression packing cubes work much better. If one wants a closet, there are plenty to go around.
@user-jg1hq8io6y I get that, but this poster replied and said there are a plethora of competing "closets" out there that do the same thing. This isn't correct, I've done a lot of research and there is maybe one that is similar. Sometimes you are willing to trade space and weight for convenience. If I wanted to carry max clothes I'd roll them and use packing cubes etc. But having all your crap in a closet (especially for shorter trips with a lot of one night stops) could be worth it.
I am so glad you did the comparison of packing the case with and without the closet insert, thank you for that. It proved what I had suspected, that the infrastructure of the closet system uses up a lot of space that could otherwise be used for what you're bringing. Especially since (for women at least) shoes and toiletries take up at least as much, if not more, space than clothing. I've been looking at this bag for quite a while, and your review told me EXACTLY what I needed to know. Extremely useful, thanks so much.
I love my Solgaard. I was never really a big luggage person before. My wife bought me one in 2022 for Christmas and I absolutely love traveling with it now.
I have this bag. I have used it for the past 2 years, and the closet is super helpful to unpack and repack and easily see the items you brought without having to unpack it into traditional drawers or hanging in a hotel. That being said, the key to maximizing both sides of the suitcase is to be strategic about how you pack the closet and are able to compress the closet so that the closet is able to get flatter. I can utilize the space inbetween the handle bars and pack the closet and then fully utilize the other side. My last trip just finished with 2 weeks in Italy and here is what i fit into my suitcase Closet: 4 pants, 10 shirts, 10 socks and underwear (each), 4 workout outfits, 1 pair Jean shorts, 2 pairs pajamas, bathing suit. Fit a hair straightener, hair turban, 4 belts, 2 pouches with makeup brushes and hair ties and other odds and ends inbetween the handlebars. The other side I put in a pair of ankle booties, sandals, heels, toiletry bag, 1 blazer and 1 cardigan (i put each of those into their own vacuum bag to really save space. It took a little effort, but it closed, and unpacking was a breeze. I had to move 2 times during the trip, so it was a godsend to already have things ready to pack up. It is a lot of trial and error, and I think packing cubes will still yield more items, but I have found a way to really maximize the closet while using the other side of the suitcase.
I used it for a 12 day trip to Europe, went to 4 cities with a backpack and it made traveling so easy. Especially with having to pack and unpack so frequently. I even bought gifts and a few extra sweatshirts and I was able to fit everything in. Really happy with the purchase!!!!
Touring musician here and I have the venture backpack and just recently got the big carry on…all my bandmates of wound up getting a Solgard…it’s super handy going from venue to venue, switching green rooms constantly to have the closet..keeping everything separated is such a lifesaver
I have the original and to be fair, Solgaard has a ‘Lite’ version now too to solve the weight problem. I don’t like that because they went to zippers. I love the zipper free version. And I don’t have to pay for checked luggage so I’m a fan of the original. I love the closet. I love not having to unpack/pack when traveling!
I have the carry-on closet medium and, after traveling with it once, and I agree with your assessment. I really liked using the closet on a solo trip I went on for work. I was able to fit stuff in the opposing side of the suitcase from where the closet fits in and didn't feel like I was sacrificing the things I needed. It is great for one person. However, if I were to use the suitcase to pack for more than one person, I probably wouldn't use the closet insert and instead use packing cubes to organize things better for more than one person. It does seem sort of silly to get this luggage if you were not going to use the closet feature. I did get it on sale.
I have that. But the first trip I decided to pack it without the closet feature. My only other observation is that the suitcase is heavy for a carryon and the closet adds almost two more pounds empty. I love how it looks and it seems really sturdy. I am 71 and I am now looking for a lighter carryon!
With all you mentioned in mind, I think this would be great for someone that’s camping in a tent, for one OR someone on a road trip and is hopping from one hotel to another and doesn’t have time to unpack in everplace. Last one would be for someone that doesn’t want to unpack in hotel drawers for fear of example, bed bugs - at least ypu could hang the closet in the middle of the hotel closet and have acces to all your stuff OR for people that are really uncomfortable about unpacking in a hotel, put your luggage in the bathtub and hang your closet from the handle - safest way ever!
Husband purchased one for each of us & we love ours. We have been successful in packing both sides using the compression of the closet leaving plenty of space on the other side and also, while the channels are deep for closet side, they work great for packing/adding smaller/flatter items. We like the “no zipper” and the secure fit and don’t worry about weather. We have the smaller carry on size and it’s worked well for 7-10 day trips for us, we also each have a backpack. They were purchased on sale, fast delivery & glad we selected. Thanks for your review.
Thank you for reviewing this! I made a request for this review, and I’m sure many others, and now I’m leaning towards it after your honest and thorough review. Really looking forward to my first hard case for domestic travel!
I travel for work for months at a time and I’m going to try this because I’m so tired of the chaos. I love that I can pull out the closet and see everything I have. This will be one of my two suitcases. I have a separate closet thing but it’s too rickety. Usually I travel with cubes and the cubes end up empty with everything stacked on top of them. I just can’t make the cubes work yet I still pack with them twenty years later. I LOVE the no zipper construction of this bag and that it’s waterproof. I saw one that was run over and crushed and those locked clasps still held. Amazing.
Thanks. I'm a retired pilot and hate "unpacking" my bag after years of spending just 12 hours or less in a hotel room. I appreciate the honest appraisal that you can get a bit more space without using the portable closet feature. This looks awesome. Great review.
I love my solgaard. Super love it. I can pack a lot of clothes and still use the closet system. You have to pack it a certain way. I’ve removed the closet system a couple of times. My favorite part is the latches. No dumb zipping anything. I usually carry on so I can’t comment if the latches survive the checked baggage abuse but the 3-4 times it’s been checked there were no issues.
Love mine. Just bought a bigger one for checking. I agree with 100% of your review, siding that I am one of those people who use and love the insert. I love getting to my hotel room, pulling it out, hanging it up and being done. And having everything organized without having to pack and unpack. I am also a avid ultralight backpacking person, and the techniques I used to pack my backpack at the same techniques I used to pack the insert. So it’s very normal for me. My only issue with the bag is that if you put too much stuff into it, it does limit the handle extension. You touched on it when you mentioned how far sticks out into the bag. If you overpack, the handle becomes useless.
Thanks for making this luggage review! Literally am looking at my first hybrid trunk right now and I was contemplating this one and I love and have watched a ton of your videos.
Great idea! I imagine this would be quite useful in accommodations where clothing storage is unavailable. You would essentially be bringing a portable closet. 👌🏻
Do you have the medium or the Large? On the website it says the large will work for all domestic travel, but the medium is good for international. I was wondering (Assuming you have large) were you still able to use it as a carry on for your internatinal flight?
The key for me in buying this suitcase, which you dont mention, is that tbe closet solves the age old clamshell issue of not working on a luggage rack. Similarly they dont work with one side up the wall. I end up always having my clamshell fully open on the floor and taking up valuable space in the room. I have no interest in fully unpacking into a dresser unless im in one place for at minimum, a week. Now i dont ever have to.
Thank you! I am getting this bag. I am going on vacation next year where I will be visiting 3 islands. This bag with the carry on closet will serve me very well because will be staying 2 to 3 nights at each island. Filling it up each section to about 70% and compressing it so it lays slightly sideways should help to use the other side.
Way too heavy for me to lift into overhead, and Amazon sells similar 'compression hanging shelves' for those who want that. Thx for the review! 😊😊 Black interior made it hard to see too. 😅
I don't have the Solgaard, but I have had my carry-on closet for years. I love using it with checked luggage. Once I get to where I am going I just take it out and hang it up.
I have and use the Solgaard Check in closet size. It’s a touch bigger and I can put larger amounts of liquids as it is checked. I have PLENTY of space on the non closet side for shoes, toiletries and a heavy jacket. More than enough room on the closet side to tuck additional items. There is no power pack availability due to regulations about batteries in checked baggage. I love this bag!
I bought one- mostly because I tend to hotel hop throughout the week and packing cubes have always been such a hassle to me. I haven't put a ton of miles on it yet - really just two weeks of flying, but I do like it so far. I don't pack the closet full (I'm usually only gone for 3 nights, so there's really no need), and i sort of shimmy it in the suitcase so that it lays flatter. I don't compact the side straps all the way- I get the bottom and top of the closet to just fit in the suitcase, and then lay both the top and bottom solid piece toward the middle. With a little manipulating I can get it to lay fairly flat. I can use the other side of the suitcase 100% for my dopp kit, shoe bag, and a jacket or two. I can't speak to the durability of the bag, yet, but I don't have any issues yet. I thought I had some scratches after the first week, but it turns out it was just paint/plastic transfer from the overhead bins. It wiped off with a little liquid and elbow grease.
Your suggestion is excellent about laying it flat. I can't lay it flat with my workout clothes, so I'm going to try travel cubes so I can close the Suitcase easily. I do think the carry on doesn't have a deep enough well to add a makeup bag on other side.
There are so many different luggage options out there but I’ve had this and use it frequently. I use the check in closet and I absolutely love mine! I ended up getting them for my sister, my mom and my girlfriend and they love them as well. Highly recommend.
Great review. I was wondering about that feature. One major drawback with the closet system is you can't quickly open the suitcase and grab one item (like a pair of socks). I can see how useful it could be, but like you, I have learned how to "live out of a suitcase" and don't think I would trade in what I have now for this feature. Good to know, thanks!
1. Obviously, if you have packed a case to the max, you can't expect to get all of that stuff AND the closet hanger. The hanger will take away some usable space. 2. If you loose-fit belongings in the case, it would seem that you would be better able to utilize space in/around the bars. 3. Using the closet system would certainly better isolate your belongings from potential insect infestation. That and convenience seems the best selling points.
I have the large one. It has served me well and I've managed to use the closet feature and put quite a bit of items on the other side of it as well. However, in my opinion it is suitable for shorter trips where you don't need as much or will have access to laundry. Because of this I will use it without the closet feature for my 2 week trip this summer.
7:38 I think pack the suitcase on both sides as you would normally. And purchase one of those collapsible closet organizers and place it in the suitcase until you get to your destination
Good review overall but, as a Solgaard user, I think you missed the larger point. The issue is really leveraging the compression ability. In short, the closet feature has FAR more capacity than what you attempted to use with the compression straps. I suspect that if you attempted to put significantly more clothing in the closet you would understand why Solgaard has so many ardent fans.
I wish I had seen a review like this before I bought it. Excellent job! I agree with your assessment. Neat idea, but the closet didn't work for the type if travel I do.
I agree. I have the large carry on, and with the closet, I can't put my makeup bag on other side. It's very difficult to close. I'm going to try my travel cubes.
Closet aside, I actually like the case itself. It is the only zipperless bag I found that uses a single system rather than two separate TSA locks, which to me is just crazy as you have to input your pin twice. The only other one was Floyd but these are a bit too expensive for me.
I really like my Solgaard but as a pretty good sized guy it is tough to bring shoes using the closet feature. I really like the ability to just hang the closet organizer when i pack and when I get to a hotel but I do have an issue finding a place to fit shoes
I have the Solgaard original 22" carry-on and the original check-in closet. I purchased because of the hanging closets, but almost never use them as they ackwardly take up packing space. The little corner anti tip strap does nothing to keep the carry on from falling over while packing, which is frustrating. They're both heavy bags at over 9 and 11 pounds. I like the look and briefcase close, but wish i had done my homework before buying.
Your thorough review has given me second thoughts, because basically it doesn’t change the amount one can pack. Another luggage item I hope you and Allie will review in the near future is the Garment Duffel from Halfday (if you guys haven’t already). I’ve seen many ads pop up for them and their claim to fame and one of the considerations is a. The weight, b. Exactly how much one can pack and c. Does it keep your basement as wrinkle free as one would think? Cheers!
@ugoeze7360 I can tell you that bag is a) quite cheaply made and b) my suits got wrinkled the first two times I used it, so I kept bringing the steamer. To me it was useful for one night business trips as it means no separate garmentbat, but I struggled with a two day stay as you have to completely deconstruct the bag to get to the suit, i.e. you need to unpack all your stuff and then back it back...
Hey Nick. Nice luggage review of the Solgaard medium carry-on. I'll be traveling internationally twice this year and need new luggage. I've been thinking about this particular luggage and their check-in. I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts on their medium carry-on original (shown here) vs. their lite model. From what I can tell, the closet system is wider and has a folding board. I think it uses a zipper system with the TSA lock system, but I don't know more. The reason is I think you're right. The person who unpacks and uses the drawers at the hotel (yup, that's me) finds this appealing. I'd rather uncompress, hang up, and go! Thoughts? Thanks again for a great video. Times have changed; it's not "Oh, what Samsonite version do I want" anymore... ;)
Great review! I have been on the fence about a hard sided case and my eBay roll on is still in great shape after 10 years, but I am ready for something new. Not sure I will pay $345 and may downside my budget to $200 or less. I will say this hard shell looks well made!
Kudos on your objectivity. As always a great assessment. Unless you can confirm otherwise, this Solgaard is the least expensive piece of luggage that has absolutely NO zippers for its closure, at least it was when we bought ours. There may be more and cheaper offerings now that I am not aware of. Someone like yourself could do a video on THAT (zipperless luggage) for your followers. I must take you to task. When you review other bags, you focus on their weight, whether they qualify as "carry-on" and other good things. What you routinely FAIL to comment on is that every bag, EVERY bag with zipper closures is vulnerable to tampering using as little as a ballpoint pen. This is the major FLAW in every bag which closes with zippers, TSA locks for the pull-tabs not withstanding. We have watched friends but have not endured it ourself. Their airline declared their piece (zipper closure) not elligible for carry-on. Their bag was tampered with and contraband inserted. The agony, the embarrassment, the exhorbitant legal and financial costs they endured convinced us that we would never again travel internationally with zipper-closure luggage. What we love about ours is in fact the closet. For those of us who tend to travel on those two-week coach tours ("If It Is Tuesday, This Must Be Belgium", lol) the closet is a wonderful convenience. With the exception of packing (which is no more fiddley than using compression cubes), one does in fact unpack in seconds and repack in only a little more time. For seasoned travellers, one solid pair of walking shoes is enough. There is no need to fuss packing around shoe bags. We have loved our Solgaards, whether travelling on a cruise, or on a coach tour.
I like the men's options for rain jackets and puffer jackets by Eddie Bauer, Allie swears by the patagonia houdini (which also comes in mens and womens).
I think a good compression insert would be my preference (happy for suggestions), given most airlines have a weight restriction on carry on (between 8kgs and 10kgs depending on airline), using half that allowance for the bag and insert makes it unusable if you have even one book/journal/planner/heavy item
I recently purchased the carry-on and check-in luggage- large. I watched a short 4 min tutorial on youtube on how to pack the luggage and closet insert, etc. You didn't mention that the draw string bag that the luggage comes in can also be used as a laundry bag.
Maybe take the packing bag with u and use it as your own draw when you get to your destination in case that hotel has no draw. Or use it as a laundry bag.
I bought something similar from Oregami... the Discover... in the end it's a carry-on with a custom packing cube system... if you enjoy the carry-on without it you'll enjoy the carry-on with it
I purchased the medium & small (international) carryon size and the large checkin size of these bags not quite two years ago, when the hype first started. I tried using the closet inserts for all three when I first took them on a trip. I’ve gone back to regular and compression cubes for more efficient packing. Also over a few trips in the intervening time they all have developed cracks in the case. I don’t love my duct tape solution for this and I’m suitcase shopping again. I may just dig my tried and true soft side expandable Briggs & Riley pieces out of storage and use them. The problem is: how do I dispose of the “eco-friendly” cracked Solgaard cases and inserts?
I get the point of the classic (for me, the Lite doesn't function any differently from the hanging shelves sold at Amazon) and I can see practical uses for it. I don't see a use for it in my travels, though.
You can lie the closet flat and compress it down with just the suitcase's compression straps, that way just one side is filled with clothes and the other is free to use, you should try that and maybe tell us if you found it more useful that way😇
in regards to your comment on the pull up handle. I am handicapped and use a motorized scooter. So with a carry-on i am pulling it next to me. Do you think this is a good carry-on for that purpose? Currently I have a 10-15 year old carry-on, i don't travel much, but I am going to the UK in May and looking for a better carry-on. I will still take a checked bag for clothes but in carry-on I pack all medication and supplements, neck pillow for plane maybe a light blanket etc. I liked this bag because no zippers, looked likesd it rolls nicely. Mine now does not have the swivel wheels so it is always weaving and tips over sideways when rolling - a pain in the butt. What do think? or do you have another suggestion? My second choice was the Nobl carry on. thanks also if this bag is choice do you think the medium over the large since not packing clothes?
This bag is for people like me, I travel only max 4 days at a time. All I need is 2 pairs of shoes, my toiletries, and my clothes. Most hotels I stay in I have my own washer and dryer in my suite’s.
I purchased this bag and I hate the closet feature. I took it out and left it at home. I did several practice runs this summer staying in a hotel before I takeoff to Southeast Asia. I’m bummed that I bought a hard pack suitcase. It’s a nice suitcase, but for Asia I’m switching my gears to a backpack checkable backpack and that’s it I’m going to try to sneak in a Crossbody Chrome Sling bag. I figure I’ll bring a couple of shopping bags that are made out of nylon. They’re actually Key Chain size. I’ll buy a bag over there. If I need to check something home I don’t plan on buying a bunch of souvenirs. If I need some extra clothes, I’ll just buy them and then give them away or throw them away or leave them in the room for the maid service. I really think I can do this trip with a transport book bag and just buy everything. I need over there and leave it behind when I come home.
I want one really bad but i need to make sure you can install a J hook on it and i really dont want to have to do that using the handle. Any ideas from the group?
Hey Nik, quick question, one thing you really took into account while making your conclusions was its price point, right now I found a deal for $225, would that change your thoughts on it now?
If you travel and stay at one hotel for a week then pack traditional, but if you travel a week and each night is a different hotel, then this is the way to go imo.
I just wish the closer system was optional. This system works for summer packing, and for people who dont layer or have many accessories. I prefer my Monos Carry On Plus. I just got both and am SHOCKED at how much i was able to pack. A LOT. And for winter packing with bulky sweaters, layer tops skirts, dresses, work and day pants. And using their Weekender for my shoes makeup and toiletries. Im a heavy heavy packer and for the first time, would be able to do carry on only. And i know i over packed but was testing to see how much i could go and close it. Tho i wish it was expandable. Im returning my solgaard today tho i love the color options they offer.
I purchased the larger version. I managed to use both sides. No issues with the closet. He over packed the smaller version and I don’t think he properly compressed the closet.
Nik, I would like to add a positive use for this bag that I don't think you mentioned. This bag would be ideal for someone who is going on a long trip or tour in which they're staying in a different hotel every night.
I did a 12 night/10 different hotels trip in Germany in my 22" Solgaard carry-on. I had to leave the closet at home to get everything into the suitcase. Totally defeated the purpose of the bag for me. Everything would simply not fit into the hanging bag....
It really does not work well for larger people. I'm 6'3" and could not pack much of anything that would stay in the closet. Small daughter packed everything and likes it. We did the backpack version at Costco has same system, returned it.
I personally think the company would do better if they did the following 2 things. 1. Offer it without the shelf insert at a small discount if the buyer doesn’t want it. 2. Offer the insert separately for either this bag or any other piece of luggage the buyer has. But it will most likely never happen in either case.
Just wanted to say - NOT the only option. There are tons of competing "closets" out there, so you can buy only the closet thingy in any size you want, and use it in your own suitcase. That makes life easier. Instead of buying this suitcase just for the closet, in case you don't need a new suitcase and you like the one that you already have - just buy the closet and use it. You just have to make sure you buy the right size that fits your suitcase. Another thing to remember is that these closets can be used in your checked luggage as well - it will fit better, you'll have plenty of room around it and then it just serves as a big compression cube. So to whoever travels with checked luggage - buy a closet that fits your suitcase and you can enjoy it.
Hey Gur, do you have a closet that you recommend by any chance? Will end up shopping around, but hoping to copy off your homework if possible 😅
I have spent quite a bit of time looking for a hanging, compressible closet and haven't found many options. Amazon and Alibaba are filled with hanging closets, but none that feature good compression straps. The closest I could find was an LL Bean 'Personal Organizer Hanging Packing Cube' for $70. Do you have any hangable, compressible options or are you just saying?
Yes, I would love to see some of these too. I just bought a new set of luggage, so I would rather only purchase a closet insert.
@@notreal5311 There are many RUclipsrs who tried the suitcase with and without the closet inside. They all say and show the same thing - the same suitcase can hold much more without the closet, the closet is heavy and takes way too much space. So all that compression and features they show you - they just look good, but not very useful in real life. I see no point in paying so much more for that closet, sorry. Compression packing cubes work much better. If one wants a closet, there are plenty to go around.
@user-jg1hq8io6y I get that, but this poster replied and said there are a plethora of competing "closets" out there that do the same thing. This isn't correct, I've done a lot of research and there is maybe one that is similar.
Sometimes you are willing to trade space and weight for convenience. If I wanted to carry max clothes I'd roll them and use packing cubes etc. But having all your crap in a closet (especially for shorter trips with a lot of one night stops) could be worth it.
I am so glad you did the comparison of packing the case with and without the closet insert, thank you for that. It proved what I had suspected, that the infrastructure of the closet system uses up a lot of space that could otherwise be used for what you're bringing. Especially since (for women at least) shoes and toiletries take up at least as much, if not more, space than clothing. I've been looking at this bag for quite a while, and your review told me EXACTLY what I needed to know. Extremely useful, thanks so much.
I love my Solgaard. I was never really a big luggage person before. My wife bought me one in 2022 for Christmas and I absolutely love traveling with it now.
I love my Solgaard carry on! I usually travel with a couple of people and having my stuff organized and hung in the hotel closet is great.
I have this bag. I have used it for the past 2 years, and the closet is super helpful to unpack and repack and easily see the items you brought without having to unpack it into traditional drawers or hanging in a hotel.
That being said, the key to maximizing both sides of the suitcase is to be strategic about how you pack the closet and are able to compress the closet so that the closet is able to get flatter. I can utilize the space inbetween the handle bars and pack the closet and then fully utilize the other side.
My last trip just finished with 2 weeks in Italy and here is what i fit into my suitcase
Closet: 4 pants, 10 shirts, 10 socks and underwear (each), 4 workout outfits, 1 pair Jean shorts, 2 pairs pajamas, bathing suit.
Fit a hair straightener, hair turban, 4 belts, 2 pouches with makeup brushes and hair ties and other odds and ends inbetween the handlebars.
The other side I put in a pair of ankle booties, sandals, heels, toiletry bag, 1 blazer and 1 cardigan (i put each of those into their own vacuum bag to really save space.
It took a little effort, but it closed, and unpacking was a breeze. I had to move 2 times during the trip, so it was a godsend to already have things ready to pack up.
It is a lot of trial and error, and I think packing cubes will still yield more items, but I have found a way to really maximize the closet while using the other side of the suitcase.
What size do you have?
@@Fleo12 I have the carry on closet plus, so the larger version of the carry on, which I think is by about 2 inches.
Thanks
I used it for a 12 day trip to Europe, went to 4 cities with a backpack and it made traveling so easy. Especially with having to pack and unpack so frequently. I even bought gifts and a few extra sweatshirts and I was able to fit everything in. Really happy with the purchase!!!!
Touring musician here and I have the venture backpack and just recently got the big carry on…all my bandmates of wound up getting a Solgard…it’s super handy going from venue to venue, switching green rooms constantly to have the closet..keeping everything separated is such a lifesaver
I have the original and to be fair, Solgaard has a ‘Lite’ version now too to solve the weight problem. I don’t like that because they went to zippers. I love the zipper free version. And I don’t have to pay for checked luggage so I’m a fan of the original. I love the closet. I love not having to unpack/pack when traveling!
@Away together, it would be nice to see a review of the 'Lite' version that is comparable to the original version with both packing styles.
I have the carry-on closet medium and, after traveling with it once, and I agree with your assessment. I really liked using the closet on a solo trip I went on for work. I was able to fit stuff in the opposing side of the suitcase from where the closet fits in and didn't feel like I was sacrificing the things I needed. It is great for one person. However, if I were to use the suitcase to pack for more than one person, I probably wouldn't use the closet insert and instead use packing cubes to organize things better for more than one person. It does seem sort of silly to get this luggage if you were not going to use the closet feature. I did get it on sale.
I'm airline crew, love how quick and easy it is to unpack and repack. Only works if you're disciplined and don't over fill the case.
I have that. But the first trip I decided to pack it without the closet feature. My only other observation is that the suitcase is heavy for a carryon and the closet adds almost two more pounds empty. I love how it looks and it seems really sturdy. I am 71 and I am now looking for a lighter carryon!
With all you mentioned in mind, I think this would be great for someone that’s camping in a tent, for one OR someone on a road trip and is hopping from one hotel to another and doesn’t have time to unpack in everplace. Last one would be for someone that doesn’t want to unpack in hotel drawers for fear of example, bed bugs - at least ypu could hang the closet in the middle of the hotel closet and have acces to all your stuff OR for people that are really uncomfortable about unpacking in a hotel, put your luggage in the bathtub and hang your closet from the handle - safest way ever!
Husband purchased one for each of us & we love ours. We have been successful in packing both sides using the compression of the closet leaving plenty of space on the other side and also, while the channels are deep for closet side, they work great for packing/adding smaller/flatter items. We like the “no zipper” and the secure fit and don’t worry about weather. We have the smaller carry on size and it’s worked well for 7-10 day trips for us, we also each have a backpack. They were purchased on sale, fast delivery & glad we selected. Thanks for your review.
Thank you for reviewing this! I made a request for this review, and I’m sure many others, and now I’m leaning towards it after your honest and thorough review. Really looking forward to my first hard case for domestic travel!
I travel for work for months at a time and I’m going to try this because I’m so tired of the chaos. I love that I can pull out the closet and see everything I have. This will be one of my two suitcases. I have a separate closet thing but it’s too rickety.
Usually I travel with cubes and the cubes end up empty with everything stacked on top of them. I just can’t make the cubes work yet I still pack with them twenty years later.
I LOVE the no zipper construction of this bag and that it’s waterproof. I saw one that was run over and crushed and those locked clasps still held. Amazing.
This comparison review you made has been very helpful, thank you!
Thanks. I'm a retired pilot and hate "unpacking" my bag after years of spending just 12 hours or less in a hotel room. I appreciate the honest appraisal that you can get a bit more space without using the portable closet feature. This looks awesome. Great review.
I love my solgaard. Super love it. I can pack a lot of clothes and still use the closet system. You have to pack it a certain way. I’ve removed the closet system a couple of times. My favorite part is the latches. No dumb zipping anything. I usually carry on so I can’t comment if the latches survive the checked baggage abuse but the 3-4 times it’s been checked there were no issues.
Thanks for the honest review! We value feedback from travelers like yourself 💌
Love mine. Just bought a bigger one for checking. I agree with 100% of your review, siding that I am one of those people who use and love the insert. I love getting to my hotel room, pulling it out, hanging it up and being done. And having everything organized without having to pack and unpack.
I am also a avid ultralight backpacking person, and the techniques I used to pack my backpack at the same techniques I used to pack the insert. So it’s very normal for me.
My only issue with the bag is that if you put too much stuff into it, it does limit the handle extension. You touched on it when you mentioned how far sticks out into the bag. If you overpack, the handle becomes useless.
Yes.
Thanks for making this luggage review! Literally am looking at my first hybrid trunk right now and I was contemplating this one and I love and have watched a ton of your videos.
Great idea! I imagine this would be quite useful in accommodations where clothing storage is unavailable. You would essentially be bringing a portable closet. 👌🏻
I love my Solgaard carry on closet. I used it for my 3 week trip from California to Scotland.
Do you have the medium or the Large? On the website it says the large will work for all domestic travel, but the medium is good for international. I was wondering (Assuming you have large) were you still able to use it as a carry on for your internatinal flight?
@@GeranoGelato I bought the large and did not have any problem having it as carryon on the international flight.
Well now you have GOTTA review the Solgaard LITE, since it actually looks more useful and “normal” (and lighter). Looking forward to it!
The key for me in buying this suitcase, which you dont mention, is that tbe closet solves the age old clamshell issue of not working on a luggage rack. Similarly they dont work with one side up the wall. I end up always having my clamshell fully open on the floor and taking up valuable space in the room. I have no interest in fully unpacking into a dresser unless im in one place for at minimum, a week. Now i dont ever have to.
great candid review thanks Nik!
Thank you! I am getting this bag. I am going on vacation next year where I will be visiting 3 islands. This bag with the carry on closet will serve me very well because will be staying 2 to 3 nights at each island. Filling it up each section to about 70% and compressing it so it lays slightly sideways should help to use the other side.
thanks for the honest and thorough review.
I’ve used an insert from Amazon for years. Sometimes I love it and other times I pack the regular way. It’s great when moving hotels frequently.
Way too heavy for me to lift into overhead, and Amazon sells similar 'compression hanging shelves' for those who want that.
Thx for the review! 😊😊 Black interior made it hard to see too. 😅
I don't have the Solgaard, but I have had my carry-on closet for years. I love using it with checked luggage. Once I get to where I am going I just take it out and hang it up.
I have and use the Solgaard Check in closet size. It’s a touch bigger and I can put larger amounts of liquids as it is checked. I have PLENTY of space on the non closet side for shoes, toiletries and a heavy jacket. More than enough room on the closet side to tuck additional items. There is no power pack availability due to regulations about batteries in checked baggage. I love this bag!
I bought one- mostly because I tend to hotel hop throughout the week and packing cubes have always been such a hassle to me. I haven't put a ton of miles on it yet - really just two weeks of flying, but I do like it so far. I don't pack the closet full (I'm usually only gone for 3 nights, so there's really no need), and i sort of shimmy it in the suitcase so that it lays flatter. I don't compact the side straps all the way- I get the bottom and top of the closet to just fit in the suitcase, and then lay both the top and bottom solid piece toward the middle. With a little manipulating I can get it to lay fairly flat. I can use the other side of the suitcase 100% for my dopp kit, shoe bag, and a jacket or two. I can't speak to the durability of the bag, yet, but I don't have any issues yet. I thought I had some scratches after the first week, but it turns out it was just paint/plastic transfer from the overhead bins. It wiped off with a little liquid and elbow grease.
Your suggestion is excellent about laying it flat. I can't lay it flat with my workout clothes, so I'm going to try travel cubes so I can close the Suitcase easily. I do think the carry on doesn't have a deep enough well to add a makeup bag on other side.
There are so many different luggage options out there but I’ve had this and use it frequently. I use the check in closet and I absolutely love mine! I ended up getting them for my sister, my mom and my girlfriend and they love them as well.
Highly recommend.
Great review! I’m planning on an intl trip & this is so helpful!
Seems this would be great for someone who travels to multiple cities in a week as a business traveler.
I own the larger version and used both sides with the closet feature. Works great.
Great review. I was wondering about that feature. One major drawback with the closet system is you can't quickly open the suitcase and grab one item (like a pair of socks). I can see how useful it could be, but like you, I have learned how to "live out of a suitcase" and don't think I would trade in what I have now for this feature. Good to know, thanks!
What do you use now and why do you like it?
1. Obviously, if you have packed a case to the max, you can't expect to get all of that stuff AND the closet hanger. The hanger will take away some usable space.
2. If you loose-fit belongings in the case, it would seem that you would be better able to utilize space in/around the bars.
3. Using the closet system would certainly better isolate your belongings from potential insect infestation. That and convenience seems the best selling points.
I have the large one. It has served me well and I've managed to use the closet feature and put quite a bit of items on the other side of it as well.
However, in my opinion it is suitable for shorter trips where you don't need as much or will have access to laundry.
Because of this I will use it without the closet feature for my 2 week trip this summer.
7:38 I think pack the suitcase on both sides as you would normally. And purchase one of those collapsible closet organizers and place it in the suitcase until you get to your destination
Good review overall but, as a Solgaard user, I think you missed the larger point. The issue is really leveraging the compression ability. In short, the closet feature has FAR more capacity than what you attempted to use with the compression straps. I suspect that if you attempted to put significantly more clothing in the closet you would understand why Solgaard has so many ardent fans.
What a great review! I didn’t consider that the case itself would weigh 7 pounds, wow!
Saw this in Sierra Trading Post today, nice and sturdy looking luggage but on the heavy side as carry on for overseas travel.
I wish I had seen a review like this before I bought it. Excellent job! I agree with your assessment. Neat idea, but the closet didn't work for the type if travel I do.
Awesome video as always! Could you do a video comparing multiple bags that can be used as personal item on air travel?
Added to the list!!! Thanks for watching
I got a purple one for $99 at tjmaxx. Good deal?
Great video!
So many other things you need to pack besides clothes and zero room for that.
Exactly
I agree. I have the large carry on, and with the closet, I can't put my makeup bag on other side. It's very difficult to close. I'm going to try my travel cubes.
Just boight 2 on sale. Carry on large for 99.99 and check in large fpr 129.99. Is that a good deal?
Thx for review. Been looking in FBM for an affordable used one. Will read comments; curious about the stability of hanging on handle as shown in ads
Closet aside, I actually like the case itself. It is the only zipperless bag I found that uses a single system rather than two separate TSA locks, which to me is just crazy as you have to input your pin twice. The only other one was Floyd but these are a bit too expensive for me.
Great video! Very unbiased. :) Kindly review MVST.
I really like my Solgaard but as a pretty good sized guy it is tough to bring shoes using the closet feature. I really like the ability to just hang the closet organizer when i pack and when I get to a hotel but I do have an issue finding a place to fit shoes
Joy Mangano had a similar idea many years ago, which she sold on HSN. I think she called it the travel closet.
I bought mine on black Friday sale for $230
I have the Solgaard original 22" carry-on and the original check-in closet. I purchased because of the hanging closets, but almost never use them as they ackwardly take up packing space. The little corner anti tip strap does nothing to keep the carry on from falling over while packing, which is frustrating. They're both heavy bags at over 9 and 11 pounds. I like the look and briefcase close, but wish i had done my homework before buying.
Your thorough review has given me second thoughts, because basically it doesn’t change the amount one can pack.
Another luggage item I hope you and Allie will review in the near future is the Garment Duffel from Halfday (if you guys haven’t already). I’ve seen many ads pop up for them and their claim to fame and one of the considerations is a. The weight, b. Exactly how much one can pack and c. Does it keep your basement as wrinkle free as one would think? Cheers!
@ugoeze7360 I can tell you that bag is a) quite cheaply made and b) my suits got wrinkled the first two times I used it, so I kept bringing the steamer.
To me it was useful for one night business trips as it means no separate garmentbat, but I struggled with a two day stay as you have to completely deconstruct the bag to get to the suit, i.e. you need to unpack all your stuff and then back it back...
Really great review. Thank you!!
Nick I do not know if you do duffles but I would like to see an honest review on the wool & oak nova duffle. Especially the nylon one.
Hey Nick. Nice luggage review of the Solgaard medium carry-on. I'll be traveling internationally twice this year and need new luggage. I've been thinking about this particular luggage and their check-in. I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts on their medium carry-on original (shown here) vs. their lite model. From what I can tell, the closet system is wider and has a folding board. I think it uses a zipper system with the TSA lock system, but I don't know more. The reason is I think you're right. The person who unpacks and uses the drawers at the hotel (yup, that's me) finds this appealing. I'd rather uncompress, hang up, and go! Thoughts? Thanks again for a great video. Times have changed; it's not "Oh, what Samsonite version do I want" anymore... ;)
Great review! I have been on the fence about a hard sided case and my eBay roll on is still in great shape after 10 years, but I am ready for something new. Not sure I will pay $345 and may downside my budget to $200 or less. I will say this hard shell looks well made!
Kudos on your objectivity. As always a great assessment.
Unless you can confirm otherwise, this Solgaard is the least expensive piece of luggage that has absolutely NO zippers for its closure, at least it was when we bought ours. There may be more and cheaper offerings now that I am not aware of. Someone like yourself could do a video on THAT (zipperless luggage) for your followers.
I must take you to task. When you review other bags, you focus on their weight, whether they qualify as "carry-on" and other good things. What you routinely FAIL to comment on is that every bag, EVERY bag with zipper closures is vulnerable to tampering using as little as a ballpoint pen. This is the major FLAW in every bag which closes with zippers, TSA locks for the pull-tabs not withstanding.
We have watched friends but have not endured it ourself. Their airline declared their piece (zipper closure) not elligible for carry-on. Their bag was tampered with and contraband inserted. The agony, the embarrassment, the exhorbitant legal and financial costs they endured convinced us that we would never again travel internationally with zipper-closure luggage.
What we love about ours is in fact the closet. For those of us who tend to travel on those two-week coach tours ("If It Is Tuesday, This Must Be Belgium", lol) the closet is a wonderful convenience. With the exception of packing (which is no more fiddley than using compression cubes), one does in fact unpack in seconds and repack in only a little more time.
For seasoned travellers, one solid pair of walking shoes is enough. There is no need to fuss packing around shoe bags. We have loved our Solgaards, whether travelling on a cruise, or on a coach tour.
Thanks for all your feedback! Great point. Wow that must have been tough for your friends. Appreciate you taking the time to type all that out!
Great review, thanks! What lightweight packable rain jacket and puffer jacket do you both use?
I like the men's options for rain jackets and puffer jackets by Eddie Bauer, Allie swears by the patagonia houdini (which also comes in mens and womens).
I would love a review of Roam and how well it actually hold up.
I think a good compression insert would be my preference (happy for suggestions), given most airlines have a weight restriction on carry on (between 8kgs and 10kgs depending on airline), using half that allowance for the bag and insert makes it unusable if you have even one book/journal/planner/heavy item
Hi, just bought this and it is great.. disagree completely on wht he said… this is great. The insert works beautifully
Have you ever reviewed the Away carry on suitcases? Curious in your thoughts if you had.
I tested and reviewed the away carry on in this video! ruclips.net/video/LPg-X4AzYFY/видео.html
Thank you for your video.
I recently purchased the carry-on and check-in luggage- large. I watched a short 4 min tutorial on youtube on how to pack the luggage and closet insert, etc.
You didn't mention that the draw string bag that the luggage comes in can also be used as a laundry bag.
great review
Can you review the Tramora next
Maybe take the packing bag with u and use it as your own draw when you get to your destination in case that hotel has no draw. Or use it as a laundry bag.
I have this bag & like it. Moves easily but agree can be heavy
Thank you, I was considering it until I saw the price. But your video made me realize I would not use the closet feature.
It’d have been interesting to see you use it on a trip. Maybe you can test it that way?
I bought something similar from Oregami... the Discover... in the end it's a carry-on with a custom packing cube system... if you enjoy the carry-on without it you'll enjoy the carry-on with it
I purchased the medium & small (international) carryon size and the large checkin size of these bags not quite two years ago, when the hype first started. I tried using the closet inserts for all three when I first took them on a trip. I’ve gone back to regular and compression cubes for more efficient packing. Also over a few trips in the intervening time they all have developed cracks in the case. I don’t love my duct tape solution for this and I’m suitcase shopping again. I may just dig my tried and true soft side expandable Briggs & Riley pieces out of storage and use them. The problem is: how do I dispose of the “eco-friendly” cracked Solgaard cases and inserts?
Lifetime warranty 😊
I get the point of the classic (for me, the Lite doesn't function any differently from the hanging shelves sold at Amazon) and I can see practical uses for it. I don't see a use for it in my travels, though.
You can lie the closet flat and compress it down with just the suitcase's compression straps, that way just one side is filled with clothes and the other is free to use, you should try that and maybe tell us if you found it more useful that way😇
in regards to your comment on the pull up handle. I am handicapped and use a motorized scooter. So with a carry-on i am pulling it next to me. Do you think this is a good carry-on for that purpose? Currently I have a 10-15 year old carry-on, i don't travel much, but I am going to the UK in May and looking for a better carry-on. I will still take a checked bag for clothes but in carry-on I pack all medication and supplements, neck pillow for plane maybe a light blanket etc. I liked this bag because no zippers, looked likesd it rolls nicely. Mine now does not have the swivel wheels so it is always weaving and tips over sideways when rolling - a pain in the butt. What do think? or do you have another suggestion? My second choice was the Nobl carry on. thanks also if this bag is choice do you think the medium over the large since not packing clothes?
You can literaly buy thes wardrobe collapsible shelves anyway I have them in my wardrobe where I needed more shelf space
This bag is for people like me, I travel only max 4 days at a time. All I need is 2 pairs of shoes, my toiletries, and my clothes. Most hotels I stay in I have my own washer and dryer in my suite’s.
Have you reviewed the half day or voyabag?
I purchased this bag and I hate the closet feature. I took it out and left it at home. I did several practice runs this summer staying in a hotel before I takeoff to Southeast Asia. I’m bummed that I bought a hard pack suitcase. It’s a nice suitcase, but for Asia I’m switching my gears to a backpack checkable backpack and that’s it I’m going to try to sneak in a Crossbody Chrome Sling bag. I figure I’ll bring a couple of shopping bags that are made out of nylon. They’re actually Key Chain size. I’ll buy a bag over there. If I need to check something home I don’t plan on buying a bunch of souvenirs. If I need some extra clothes, I’ll just buy them and then give them away or throw them away or leave them in the room for the maid service. I really think I can do this trip with a transport book bag and just buy everything. I need over there and leave it behind when I come home.
I want one really bad but i need to make sure you can install a J hook on it and i really dont want to have to do that using the handle. Any ideas from the group?
Hey Nik, quick question, one thing you really took into account while making your conclusions was its price point, right now I found a deal for $225, would that change your thoughts on it now?
How much did it weigh with just the empty closet insert inside… and how much did it weigh with the closet insert fully packed?
Yup. 2 Shoes, curling iron, toiletries. Love no zippers but wish it was lighter.
I'll stick with my soft backpack that weighs 2 lbs and now packing cubes thanks to you. And less than $80
I’m not sure anyone asked but what brand compression bags are you using in this video
If you travel and stay at one hotel for a week then pack traditional, but if you travel a week and each night is a different hotel, then this is the way to go imo.
This seems to be the lightest zipperless? Excluding the unknown brands from China though.
I just wish the closer system was optional. This system works for summer packing, and for people who dont layer or have many accessories. I prefer my Monos Carry On Plus. I just got both and am SHOCKED at how much i was able to pack. A LOT. And for winter packing with bulky sweaters, layer tops skirts, dresses, work and day pants. And using their Weekender for my shoes makeup and toiletries. Im a heavy heavy packer and for the first time, would be able to do carry on only. And i know i over packed but was testing to see how much i could go and close it. Tho i wish it was expandable.
Im returning my solgaard today tho i love the color options they offer.
Wait you packed 9 shirts but only 1 pair of pants and 1 pair of shorts? How many times do you wear the same bottoms?
They have a newer closet version in which I wonder if it’s any better
I purchased the larger version. I managed to use both sides. No issues with the closet. He over packed the smaller version and I don’t think he properly compressed the closet.
Nik, I would like to add a positive use for this bag that I don't think you mentioned. This bag would be ideal for someone who is going on a long trip or tour in which they're staying in a different hotel every night.
I did a 12 night/10 different hotels trip in Germany in my 22" Solgaard carry-on. I had to leave the closet at home to get everything into the suitcase. Totally defeated the purpose of the bag for me. Everything would simply not fit into the hanging bag....
Thank you for this review!!
It only works if the traveler actually uses it as it is designed to be used like with any travel gear.
It really does not work well for larger people. I'm 6'3" and could not pack much of anything that would stay in the closet. Small daughter packed everything and likes it. We did the backpack version at Costco has same system, returned it.
I personally think the company would do better if they did the following 2 things.
1. Offer it without the shelf insert at a small discount if the buyer doesn’t want it.
2. Offer the insert separately for either this bag or any other piece of luggage the buyer has.
But it will most likely never happen in either case.