Breaches the time barrier by use of slingshot warp around a star. Bringing a Scimitar type warbird to REALLY mess things up! "I'd rather have Tasha than her annoying hybrid daughter Empress Sela!"
You should try it from the C perspective. Also 1701D coming back could have also ruined peace talks. It would have appeared to be a super weapon and the klingons might have rearmed for war and could have sparked another romulan war too. 1701D alone could beat those 4 warbirds, but it definitely would take a beating.
Don't think the D would take as much beating as you think. 20 years is a long time for technological disparity, so the D would likely make quick work of those warbirds. In fact, if they leveraged the use of all their phaser strips to concentrate firepower on a single ship, its likely they'd be able to destroy one like that in the first shot while releasing a Sierra pattern volley onto another one. I'd surmise that the Romulan shields might be able to absorb 3 or 4 of ENT D torpedoes, while the remainder would have destroyed them.
I don't remember how he did it, but one time, he played the battle using only the C. He actually won, so I made jokes about either Daniels or Captain Bruce McGill (I forget his fake name 😀) would want to have a word with him.
@@deksroning125 1701D, in cannon, would get beat up by 2 warbirds, especially pre borg. My understanding of 1701c was that it too could multi-target phasers. It was designed to act as a temporary starbase. The gap in offense and defense between the Ambassador and excelsior is far greater than Ambassador to Galaxy. Ambassador is UP Galaxy is OP in the mods.
That torpedo based "No u don't!" The D gave you there at the end. The second i noticed you did not react to the incoming phaser fire, i knew you would get nuked by torpedoes.
Keep in mind that the "Yesterday's Enterprise" Galaxy-class was built to be a Battleship by that timelines Starfleet. Meanwhile the prime universe built the Galaxy-class to be a Multi-Purpose Exploration Cruiser. One can only imagine that the "Yesterday's Enterprise" Enterprise-D would be closer to the Dominion War Retrofit Galaxy (sans Quantum Torpedoes obviously :()..
It would be interesting to compare the two Enterprises. On one hand, War with the Klingons would have made the Enterprise a tougher ship, but would have it been a more advanced ship?? Resources would have been tight during the war, given how badly it was going for the Federation according to Cpt Picard.
Remember what geordi said in that episode, the only way for the enterprise c to survive was to upgrade it to their level. Unfortunately a lot of people forget that the federation had been at war for 20 years. That's a lot of motivation to increase weapon and shield power
Yeah, the Enterprise-D that went back in time was not the same ship that we know from the regular timeline. It would be more adapted for War and not exploration.
@@Elurin We don't know that. The ENT-D was a power house in the prime timeline still. Just because its primary purpose was exploration, it doesn't mean its weapons would be weaker than the Battleship Enterprise D.
@@chriscepec1655 yes, but the dominion war tales place years after yesterday's enterprise. Starfleet was in full upgrade mode for all its ships and stations in season 3 of ds9, especially following the Borg invasion and with starfleet also knowing what the dominion was capable of (post Odyssey destruction). The USS Lakota was upgraded to almost rival the defiant after all. The galaxy class was already very powerful but the dominion had an advantage of intelligence about federation and aq technology from the first 2 years of them sending ships to the gamma quadrant... That's why they were able to overpower the odyssey in the first place and why it failed. Before the war began a starfleet was able to retrieve a dominion big fighter after all which likely helped them in insulating their shields from dominion weapons. Basically the UFp managed to finally acquire piece of dominion technology just like the dominion had in the first 2 years of ds9
@@deksroning125 true but remember that in a time of war all resources are spent on war material. The enemy has a strong defense you research better weapons and so on. Just look at wars on earth; as the war goes on new weapons, armor and a host of other war related items progress. We didn't see much of that in that episode because of the budget and story. I think that enterprise was stronger than the refit
Someone wrote a short story titled, 'Tomorrow's Enterprise'. The Ent-D traveled back in time with the Ent-C and engaged the Romulans at Narendra III. The D easily destroyed 3 of the 4 warbirds.
😲🤔 Crikey.. this would have been a conundrum.. cause if Ent D went back.. yes the Romulans faces lol wipe the smirk off .. lol. and they would have retreated and yet still save the Klingon outpost, but no was back cause the battle was making that fissure in time.. But Ent C going back put the timeline back.. but still would have the cesse fire with the Klingons.. hmm gosh I have a headache just thinking about that.. eeh. Question.. if so many ships battling, hmm how come no other fissures opened like the Dominion war, Sector 001, Voyager, hmm quantum mécaniques is giving me a headache.. sorry Admiral.. lol. you did great and love how the Ent D flew in front, just like a movie.. yes interesting battle and makes you think.. if or not.. hmm.. sorry I just took 2 Advil's.. lol.. love the Battle Admiral..! 😊🖖
Cool battle! Also, random fact, I worked with Eric Stillwell in the Oregon Capitol for a number of years, and many years before that, I had him sign my Yesterdays Enterprise card.
So I can see the Romulans retreating after one of their ships were destroyed, but not before taking many detailed sensor scans of the Enterprise-D. They then report this to the Tal'Shiar. They have a new battleship that the Romulans have no counter for. So, they develop the D'deridex class as a response. So! The Enterprise is to blame for the huge warbirds. Oops.
Remember, the version of the Enterprise D that would have gone back is NOT the D we all know and love. The timeline it came from was a warzone. That version would likely have had a few weapons upgrades, perhaps a couple more phaser arrays. After all they added two "tactical podiums", one on each side of the bridge.
Ent - D is the killer rabbit the Roms did not expected so... Run Away! Run Away! ruclips.net/video/7FPELc1wEvk/видео.html "I've gone and soil me armor!"
I thought that the alternate D was more of an upgrade kitted out for war. Then again, it was also probably beaten up fairly badly at that point. I guess that between the ship having been badly pounded, the crew being a bit battle hardened and the fact that the ship was designed after a generation of war, it all probably evened out.
2:46 I personally like Venom Geek Media's take that these warbirds don't use quantum singularity warp drives yet (which were still in development). That would mean a MASSIVE gap in terms of power generation for the D'deridex-class warbirds. The real time strategy game "Star Trek: New Worlds" also has it that the technology is not ready to be deployed aboard starships yet. Unfortunately canon often neglects to take the opportunity to codify such technological advances which makes them seem too easy.
Out of pure curiosity how come you didn't actually use the Enterprise-C model instead of this one? I THINK had the Enterprise-D saved both the Enterprise-C and the Klingon outpost the Klingons still might have been impressed with Starfleet and the Federation and might have improved relations with the Federation. I bet had the Enterprise-D returned to its own time things would have been different. I THINK Garret in the Section 31 movie is going to be BEFORE she took command of the Enterprise-C but not sure.
It wasn’t available 🤣. Seriously the ones I have in remastered, there is no C. At least in my current build 😮. Yes, you’re right, it’s when she was younger apparently. You never know through, we may get a glimpse of the C under construction? 🖖
Would had thought that the Ent-D had gotten the EchoPapa307 drones&deploy them once they emerged from the temporal rift. Or at least give the Ent-C several planetary defense satellites to defend NerandraIII. Maybe deploy some recon satellites too showing the battle so the Klingons know that the Romulans were attacking the Klingon colony&Starfleet showed up to defend it.
For another episode from next generation season 3. The defector. If there had of been a battle between the enterprise D and at least 3 klingon birds of prey vs 2 romulan warbirds. Shall we die together?...
Ooooof what a video ... ty for the video and LLAP I think destroying the romulan surviving and saving the colony will be alot more then dieing for them....
Technically the Enterprise from this timeline would have been more powerful than the Enterprise D from our timeline from the same time. This timeline had been at war for 20 years.
It's inaccurate to say that war hastens development, more like the *threat* of war does. Once _at war_ all effort tends to be on more near term and Next Step tech while research into the "next next step" things like jets, atom bombs and stealth all started well before the respective wars where each made their debut. Since this war is alleged to have been going on twenty years it's certain to have all but completely stoped investment into the sort of 'pure research' that only pays dividends in unforseen breakthroughs years later. Not to mention that the Federation is unlikely to have been doing any deep range exploration if it was holding on by its fingernails which would have cut them off from allies or technology picked up from or developed in response to tech that aliens they never encountered had in the Prime timeline. I think this alternate timeline Federation and Enterprise are less advanced and weaker.
@@johnassal5838 during wartime weapon systems are continuously upgraded so the weapons and shields of the Enterprise d were probably upgraded at least once or twice especially if they were starting to lose. The federation would have started looking for any technological edge they could have gotten over Klingons. You see this in the development of weapons during world war II world war I hell right now in Ukraine.
It would definitely make for an interesting split timeline. Maybe the federation would at first want to hide away all the future technology but I could see them reconsider if the romulans begin advancing their technology in response and become a bigger threat in that era, leading to the enterprise D just being to valuable a ship to leave out of the situation. I could also see the crew taking it upon themselves to fix the mess that they caused, especially as they came from a timeline where the federation was losing a prolonged war (maybe having to deal with some prejudice against klingons as they go).
Daniels is definitely gonna have a talk with you this time. 😆 I still can't believe that you won once using only the C. That video was over a year ago, I believe.
The Enterprise-D would have had a massive effect on the battle if it had indeed been at Narendra III, alongside the Enterprise-C, its shields & far more powerful phasers to fight against the Romulans ships of the era.
This battle went a lot better for Starfleet than your Battle of Narendra III recreation from last year. Was it increased STBC playing experience, a better Enterprise D, or a combination of the two? (I'm guessing a combination).
A 20 year gap in terms of tech can make a substantial difference to weapons and shields. So, yeah, if the ENT-D went back with the C to the past, the Romulans would have likely engaged them both at first (not knowing how advanced the D was). The D would likely be able to destroy 2 of the Romulan ships, and the other 2 would definitely try to retreat after witnessing just how outmatched they were. In fairness, I don't think the Romulans would have been able to take that much of a barrage from the D's weapons as seen in this simulation. 20 years is quite a long time, especially for exponential developments. Remember that the ENT-D was similarly comparable to a single D'Deridex class at the time it was released into active service... hence why I think these old Romulan ships wouldn't have stood a chance. In fact, if the D timed its firepower effectively, it would likely be able to quickly destroy or severely damage all 4 ships. Just go into 'overload' mode with phasers by leveraging all phaser strips to fire at all 4 ships at the same time, then simultaneously release 6 torpedoes into 2 of them (aka, three per each). Quickly repeat, and the Romulans wouldn't stand a chance. The problem I see here is that the timeline would end up being changed because the Romulans would now be exposed to a much newer design from Starfleet... but in turn, if the ENT-D gives its knowledge and technology to the Starfleet of the era, they'd probably be able to retrofit their ships easily and fast... especially in terms of torpedoes. Plus the D likely has schematics of all the upgrades SF made to older classes of ships and how they did it... so in effect, they could easily stay ahead of the Romulans like that (remember that OBSERVING the more advanced tech in play would not by itself give the Romulans the advantage - they may be MOTIVATED to develop better technology sooner as a result, but that would only matter if the ENT-D left to return to its own future without giving SF of the past anything).
The C doesn't need to be destroyed if all the Romulan ships are for the Klingons to see the act of bravery. Their coming to the aid of the Klingon people and giving the Romulans hell matters a great deal to the Klingons, and falling back and gaining support isn't an unknown move even for Klingons. It might not be the same level of enthusiasm given the federation flagship didn't sacrifice itself and it's crew entirely for them, but I feel like the sentiment would still be there.
Was this the Enterprise from the Klingon War timeline sir? She would be, more than a match for these Warbirds no? I mean they could even beam troops over no?
@@MisterMarin Lol I would highly suggest seeking the film out if able. While dated, The Final Countdown is an interesting film where a 1980 nuclear aircraft carrier finds itself in the Pacific on December 6th, 1941...
@@MSR-1701 Hmmm... [googles] Hey! I recognize the poster. [watches trailer] Scratch my previous statement. I have seen it once or twice. It's been awhile, though. It has nuclear vessel(s)! 😁
I would imagine, Enterprise C might have still been destroyed, due to all the battle damage she still had. However, I'd like to think alternate timeline Enterprise D would have tried beaming the survivors off the ship, finished off the warbirds, and maybe tried to disappear. Maybe joining up with Section 31 or DTI, to keep from interacting too much with the timeline anymore than they already had.
It's possible the time vortex stayed open while this Enterprise D was in the past. Then re entered the vortex once more disappearing forever after the battle was over.
@@1stprinceoflite They would most likely go to either the original timeline, before the Enterprise C had emerged from the past, or a timeline very similar. I doubt they'd return to the same timeline they left.
should have used a slightly tweaked enterprise d because the alternate timeline d weapons and shield were more powerful it probably would have been on par with the dominion war galaxy
The Enterprise D was in a bad way, trying to protect the C and if it had managed to go back, would surely have been destroyed or maybe captured and then the Romulans would have had a Galaxy class starship 22 years in the past and then where would we be ?
the real question would the klingons have seen the enterprise d and decided that starfleet was too powerful and secretly started negotiations with the cardassians as counterweight to the federation and romulans. also what would temporal investigations male of this whole debacle since they have changed the timeline because sela no longer is born. so now picard would have a different romulan to face off against in the klingon civil war. also what about the fact that would be two different picards floating around in the same universe one i command of the alternate enterprise d and the other on the stargazer. so imagine an alternate universe where there are two picards and two rikers running around plus we have lore and data. in fact there are likely 3 rikers if riker still has his transporter hijinks. also two laforge's and two yar's. temporal mechanics makes my head hurt.😂
Let's pretend enterprise d had gone back...... klingons would likely be at war with Romulus.... Kitomer massacre may not have occurred and worf would likely not enter starfleet
Great point that the future Enterprise would have knowledge of the Romulan vessel weaknesses and tactics that the C did not.
Nice move from the Enterprise D, it really looked like it wanted to protect the C.
3:04 dispersal pattern sierra worked very well!
😄with the rolling of the ''R'', sierrra.. lol. just saying..!
@@stevelapierre4776 ¿Por qué no? Así lo digo en mi lenguaje natal. 🇲🇽
[clicks fingers and restores default timeline] There. Tasha gone, carry on. 🖖😛
Breaches the time barrier by use of slingshot warp around a star. Bringing a Scimitar type warbird to REALLY mess things up! "I'd rather have Tasha than her annoying hybrid daughter Empress Sela!"
I understood that reference.
@@masere Attaboy. 😀
I am Jean Luc Picard in command of the USS Enterprise NCC 1701-C 6:20
You should try it from the C perspective.
Also 1701D coming back could have also ruined peace talks. It would have appeared to be a super weapon and the klingons might have rearmed for war and could have sparked another romulan war too. 1701D alone could beat those 4 warbirds, but it definitely would take a beating.
Don't think the D would take as much beating as you think. 20 years is a long time for technological disparity, so the D would likely make quick work of those warbirds. In fact, if they leveraged the use of all their phaser strips to concentrate firepower on a single ship, its likely they'd be able to destroy one like that in the first shot while releasing a Sierra pattern volley onto another one.
I'd surmise that the Romulan shields might be able to absorb 3 or 4 of ENT D torpedoes, while the remainder would have destroyed them.
I don't remember how he did it, but one time, he played the battle using only the C.
He actually won, so I made jokes about either Daniels or Captain Bruce McGill (I forget his fake name 😀) would want to have a word with him.
@@retluoc I still think 1701C gets very underrated in these mods. But 4 of those is a tall order. Temporal authorities need to do an investigation.
@@deksroning125 1701D, in cannon, would get beat up by 2 warbirds, especially pre borg. My understanding of 1701c was that it too could multi-target phasers. It was designed to act as a temporary starbase. The gap in offense and defense between the Ambassador and excelsior is far greater than Ambassador to Galaxy. Ambassador is UP Galaxy is OP in the mods.
That torpedo based "No u don't!" The D gave you there at the end.
The second i noticed you did not react to the incoming phaser fire, i knew you would get nuked by torpedoes.
Keep in mind that the "Yesterday's Enterprise" Galaxy-class was built to be a Battleship by that timelines Starfleet. Meanwhile the prime universe built the Galaxy-class to be a Multi-Purpose Exploration Cruiser. One can only imagine that the "Yesterday's Enterprise" Enterprise-D would be closer to the Dominion War Retrofit Galaxy (sans Quantum Torpedoes obviously :()..
It would be interesting to compare the two Enterprises. On one hand, War with the Klingons would have made the Enterprise a tougher ship, but would have it been a more advanced ship?? Resources would have been tight during the war, given how badly it was going for the Federation according to Cpt Picard.
This is what most people over looked thinking it was the very same vessel. The hull had to be at least up to 30% stronger at a minimum for this war.
Remember what geordi said in that episode, the only way for the enterprise c to survive was to upgrade it to their level. Unfortunately a lot of people forget that the federation had been at war for 20 years. That's a lot of motivation to increase weapon and shield power
Yeah, the Enterprise-D that went back in time was not the same ship that we know from the regular timeline. It would be more adapted for War and not exploration.
@@Elurin We don't know that.
The ENT-D was a power house in the prime timeline still.
Just because its primary purpose was exploration, it doesn't mean its weapons would be weaker than the Battleship Enterprise D.
@@deksroning125 I hear ya but just look at the dominion war refit galaxy class
@@chriscepec1655 yes, but the dominion war tales place years after yesterday's enterprise. Starfleet was in full upgrade mode for all its ships and stations in season 3 of ds9, especially following the Borg invasion and with starfleet also knowing what the dominion was capable of (post Odyssey destruction).
The USS Lakota was upgraded to almost rival the defiant after all. The galaxy class was already very powerful but the dominion had an advantage of intelligence about federation and aq technology from the first 2 years of them sending ships to the gamma quadrant... That's why they were able to overpower the odyssey in the first place and why it failed.
Before the war began a starfleet was able to retrieve a dominion big fighter after all which likely helped them in insulating their shields from dominion weapons. Basically the UFp managed to finally acquire piece of dominion technology just like the dominion had in the first 2 years of ds9
@@deksroning125 true but remember that in a time of war all resources are spent on war material. The enemy has a strong defense you research better weapons and so on. Just look at wars on earth; as the war goes on new weapons, armor and a host of other war related items progress. We didn't see much of that in that episode because of the budget and story. I think that enterprise was stronger than the refit
Someone wrote a short story titled, 'Tomorrow's Enterprise'. The Ent-D traveled back in time with the Ent-C and engaged the Romulans at Narendra III. The D easily destroyed 3 of the 4 warbirds.
Cool! Thanks for your comment, never knew about this 🖖
😲🤔 Crikey.. this would have been a conundrum.. cause if Ent D went back.. yes the Romulans faces lol wipe the smirk off .. lol. and they would have retreated and yet still save the Klingon outpost, but no was back cause the battle was making that fissure in time.. But Ent C going back put the timeline back.. but still would have the cesse fire with the Klingons.. hmm gosh I have a headache just thinking about that.. eeh. Question.. if so many ships battling, hmm how come no other fissures opened like the Dominion war, Sector 001, Voyager, hmm quantum mécaniques is giving me a headache.. sorry Admiral.. lol. you did great and love how the Ent D flew in front, just like a movie.. yes interesting battle and makes you think.. if or not.. hmm.. sorry I just took 2 Advil's.. lol.. love the Battle Admiral..! 😊🖖
Cool battle! Also, random fact, I worked with Eric Stillwell in the Oregon Capitol for a number of years, and many years before that, I had him sign my Yesterdays Enterprise card.
That's so cool 🖖
This was a brilliant idea for a battle! What fun! Thank you. I love these What-ifs.
So I can see the Romulans retreating after one of their ships were destroyed, but not before taking many detailed sensor scans of the Enterprise-D. They then report this to the Tal'Shiar. They have a new battleship that the Romulans have no counter for. So, they develop the D'deridex class as a response. So! The Enterprise is to blame for the huge warbirds. Oops.
That was sweet. Thank you!
Remember, the version of the Enterprise D that would have gone back is NOT the D we all know and love. The timeline it came from was a warzone. That version would likely have had a few weapons upgrades, perhaps a couple more phaser arrays. After all they added two "tactical podiums", one on each side of the bridge.
Ent - D is the killer rabbit the Roms did not expected so...
Run Away! Run Away!
ruclips.net/video/7FPELc1wEvk/видео.html
"I've gone and soil me armor!"
I thought that the alternate D was more of an upgrade kitted out for war. Then again, it was also probably beaten up fairly badly at that point. I guess that between the ship having been badly pounded, the crew being a bit battle hardened and the fact that the ship was designed after a generation of war, it all probably evened out.
2:46 I personally like Venom Geek Media's take that these warbirds don't use quantum singularity warp drives yet (which were still in development).
That would mean a MASSIVE gap in terms of power generation for the D'deridex-class warbirds. The real time strategy game "Star Trek: New Worlds" also has it that the technology is not ready to be deployed aboard starships yet. Unfortunately canon often neglects to take the opportunity to codify such technological advances which makes them seem too easy.
Thats like easter and Cristmas at once 2 videos with the ambassador class at the same time posted
Out of pure curiosity how come you didn't actually use the Enterprise-C model instead of this one?
I THINK had the Enterprise-D saved both the Enterprise-C and the Klingon outpost the Klingons still might have been impressed with Starfleet and the Federation and might have improved relations with the Federation. I bet had the Enterprise-D returned to its own time things would have been different.
I THINK Garret in the Section 31 movie is going to be BEFORE she took command of the Enterprise-C but not sure.
It wasn’t available 🤣. Seriously the ones I have in remastered, there is no C. At least in my current build 😮. Yes, you’re right, it’s when she was younger apparently. You never know through, we may get a glimpse of the C under construction? 🖖
That was seriously cool!
I like this romulan ship design. More compact.
Would had thought that the Ent-D had gotten the EchoPapa307 drones&deploy them once they emerged from the temporal rift. Or at least give the Ent-C several planetary defense satellites to defend NerandraIII. Maybe deploy some recon satellites too showing the battle so the Klingons know that the Romulans were attacking the Klingon colony&Starfleet showed up to defend it.
Simply give them improved torpedoes.
No witnesses.
For another episode from next generation season 3. The defector. If there had of been a battle between the enterprise D and at least 3 klingon birds of prey vs 2 romulan warbirds. Shall we die together?...
Ooooof what a video ... ty for the video and LLAP I think destroying the romulan surviving and saving the colony will be alot more then dieing for them....
that was a fun one, this channel is my new ASMR :)
Technically the Enterprise from this timeline would have been more powerful than the Enterprise D from our timeline from the same time. This timeline had been at war for 20 years.
It's inaccurate to say that war hastens development, more like the *threat* of war does. Once _at war_ all effort tends to be on more near term and Next Step tech while research into the "next next step" things like jets, atom bombs and stealth all started well before the respective wars where each made their debut. Since this war is alleged to have been going on twenty years it's certain to have all but completely stoped investment into the sort of 'pure research' that only pays dividends in unforseen breakthroughs years later. Not to mention that the Federation is unlikely to have been doing any deep range exploration if it was holding on by its fingernails which would have cut them off from allies or technology picked up from or developed in response to tech that aliens they never encountered had in the Prime timeline. I think this alternate timeline Federation and Enterprise are less advanced and weaker.
@@johnassal5838 during wartime weapon systems are continuously upgraded so the weapons and shields of the Enterprise d were probably upgraded at least once or twice especially if they were starting to lose. The federation would have started looking for any technological edge they could have gotten over Klingons. You see this in the development of weapons during world war II world war I hell right now in Ukraine.
It would definitely make for an interesting split timeline.
Maybe the federation would at first want to hide away all the future technology but I could see them reconsider if the romulans begin advancing their technology in response and become a bigger threat in that era, leading to the enterprise D just being to valuable a ship to leave out of the situation. I could also see the crew taking it upon themselves to fix the mess that they caused, especially as they came from a timeline where the federation was losing a prolonged war (maybe having to deal with some prejudice against klingons as they go).
Daniels is definitely gonna have a talk with you this time. 😆 I still can't believe that you won once using only the C. That video was over a year ago, I believe.
These are different ship mods. Temporal investigations keep leaving comm messages… maybe if I bribe Braxton they’ll go easy on me 😉
The Enterprise-D would have had a massive effect on the battle if it had indeed been at Narendra III, alongside the Enterprise-C, its shields & far more powerful phasers to fight against the Romulans ships of the era.
Wounder if there would be any difference with the Probert Enterprise C?
those romulan warbirds kinda look like a precursor to the d'deridex class judging by the design
This battle went a lot better for Starfleet than your Battle of Narendra III recreation from last year. Was it increased STBC playing experience, a better Enterprise D, or a combination of the two? (I'm guessing a combination).
This enterprise d could fire more torpedoes, it was the one from Generations. I don’t think I had the v’melak in the last simulation.
A 20 year gap in terms of tech can make a substantial difference to weapons and shields.
So, yeah, if the ENT-D went back with the C to the past, the Romulans would have likely engaged them both at first (not knowing how advanced the D was). The D would likely be able to destroy 2 of the Romulan ships, and the other 2 would definitely try to retreat after witnessing just how outmatched they were.
In fairness, I don't think the Romulans would have been able to take that much of a barrage from the D's weapons as seen in this simulation. 20 years is quite a long time, especially for exponential developments.
Remember that the ENT-D was similarly comparable to a single D'Deridex class at the time it was released into active service... hence why I think these old Romulan ships wouldn't have stood a chance.
In fact, if the D timed its firepower effectively, it would likely be able to quickly destroy or severely damage all 4 ships. Just go into 'overload' mode with phasers by leveraging all phaser strips to fire at all 4 ships at the same time, then simultaneously release 6 torpedoes into 2 of them (aka, three per each).
Quickly repeat, and the Romulans wouldn't stand a chance.
The problem I see here is that the timeline would end up being changed because the Romulans would now be exposed to a much newer design from Starfleet... but in turn, if the ENT-D gives its knowledge and technology to the Starfleet of the era, they'd probably be able to retrofit their ships easily and fast... especially in terms of torpedoes.
Plus the D likely has schematics of all the upgrades SF made to older classes of ships and how they did it... so in effect, they could easily stay ahead of the Romulans like that (remember that OBSERVING the more advanced tech in play would not by itself give the Romulans the advantage - they may be MOTIVATED to develop better technology sooner as a result, but that would only matter if the ENT-D left to return to its own future without giving SF of the past anything).
The C doesn't need to be destroyed if all the Romulan ships are for the Klingons to see the act of bravery. Their coming to the aid of the Klingon people and giving the Romulans hell matters a great deal to the Klingons, and falling back and gaining support isn't an unknown move even for Klingons. It might not be the same level of enthusiasm given the federation flagship didn't sacrifice itself and it's crew entirely for them, but I feel like the sentiment would still be there.
Was this the Enterprise from the Klingon War timeline sir? She would be, more than a match for these Warbirds no? I mean they could even beam troops over no?
Enterprise D-AF Alternate Future. This Enterprise was built to be tougher than the Original D. Because of the war with the Klingon Empire.
Have you ever seen the made for TV movie The Final Countdown? 😂
No, but I have seen the marvelous breadfish, swimming in the ocean water. 🍞🐟🌊
@@MisterMarin Lol
I would highly suggest seeking the film out if able. While dated, The Final Countdown is an interesting film where a 1980 nuclear aircraft carrier finds itself in the Pacific on December 6th, 1941...
@@MSR-1701 Hmmm... [googles] Hey! I recognize the poster. [watches trailer] Scratch my previous statement. I have seen it once or twice. It's been awhile, though. It has nuclear vessel(s)! 😁
@@MisterMarin 😎😂
Perfect analogy.
Great battle, although Picard would never have gone back in time, because he'd be altering the past, and therefore his own time.
"BOOM! yup that's good"
Aahhh!! Thank you!! I don’t believe it!!
Those Romulan V'melak ships are space junk, too quickly. What were the Romulans thinking? 🖖
Awesome space battle!
Thanks 🖖
Why do your video now show 1701D capable of launching 10? KM or BCRM? What changed? What am I missing!?
This is Wiley Coyote’s version. It’s the one we saw in Generations.
I would imagine, Enterprise C might have still been destroyed, due to all the battle damage she still had. However, I'd like to think alternate timeline Enterprise D would have tried beaming the survivors off the ship, finished off the warbirds, and maybe tried to disappear. Maybe joining up with Section 31 or DTI, to keep from interacting too much with the timeline anymore than they already had.
It's possible the time vortex stayed open while this Enterprise D was in the past. Then re entered the vortex once more disappearing forever after the battle was over.
@@1stprinceoflite They would most likely go to either the original timeline, before the Enterprise C had emerged from the past, or a timeline very similar. I doubt they'd return to the same timeline they left.
nice video
Thanks 🖖
Where can you get the updated armada patch and stuff
It wouldn’t have been a normal Galaxy class Enterprise it would’ve been a MILITARIZED Galaxy class Enterprise. Stronger shields and weapons.
Ok, that was a great battle!
should have used a slightly tweaked enterprise d because the alternate timeline d weapons and shield were more powerful it probably would have been on par with the dominion war galaxy
What if it had been the Mirror universe Enterprise D?
Wouldn't it be more accurate to use a Terran enterprise d?
The results would be exactly like the Prime timeline except that everyone in the present would have a tribble.
🤣🤣🤣 I like it 🖖
The Enterprise D was in a bad way, trying to protect the C and if it had managed to go back, would surely have been destroyed or maybe captured and then the Romulans would have had a Galaxy class starship 22 years in the past and then where would we be ?
it would insult the klingons having d go back. it is better to sacrifice one self for the betterment of all than to alter pass events for false glory
So what if this is the real reason for the upgraded warbirds?
What do you mean, why the Romulans developed the D'Deridex?
@crownprincesebastianjohano7069 there was no reason for them to make bigger ships, they don't care about exploration and they don't carry families.
Weren't there bird of preys
the real question would the klingons have seen the enterprise d and decided that starfleet was too powerful and secretly started negotiations with the cardassians as counterweight to the federation and romulans.
also what would temporal investigations male of this whole debacle since they have changed the timeline because sela no longer is born. so now picard would have a different romulan to face off against in the klingon civil war.
also what about the fact that would be two different picards floating around in the same universe one i command of the alternate enterprise d and the other on the stargazer. so imagine an alternate universe where there are two picards and two rikers running around plus we have lore and data. in fact there are likely 3 rikers if riker still has his transporter hijinks. also two laforge's and two yar's.
temporal mechanics makes my head hurt.😂
Where can i find these mods?
Gamefront 🖖
How do I get this game?
GOG sell it 🖖
The Enterprise Could won the Battle if Fleet got the Bugs out
What game is this?
Star Trek bridge commander
Let's pretend enterprise d had gone back...... klingons would likely be at war with Romulus....
Kitomer massacre may not have occurred and worf would likely not enter starfleet