This is supposed to be a Monster Hunter Competitor
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- Not enough companys try to make a Monster Hunter like game.. i wonder if it is just not worth financially, too hard to make or both of them.
Dauntless, Wild Hearts all just failed miserably, but we really need a good MH like game. The soulslike franchise has really good competitors, but when it comes to Monster Hunter there is nothing i can really suggest.
📧Business Inquiry: Chilledtiger16@gmail.com
📸Twitter: / chilledtiger
🎮TikTok: / chilledtigeryt
💗 Leave a like and Subscribe if you enjoy my Videos: / @chilledtiger 
Игры
![[Game Designer Explains] The Healer's Burden: Why Nobody Likes Playing Healers](/img/1.gif)
Honestly the concepts in this game seem pretty fun, just terribly executed
Aint it still in mega early access?
@@Sightss_yeah, but there’s a few pretty horrible mechanics that you can’t blame on early access and will only change if the creators listen to fans which is very, very unlikely lol. Like unnecessary craft times. Kinda seems like they’re setting themselves up like Dauntless, which isn’t good because of the pay to skip features which require real money.
I agree, I can see the potential but it's unlikely that it will ever be realized. Still, one can always hope.
Crafting times? Hell nah
I will Not gonna play this game because of that long crafting time
@@idkman6496 crafting time in survivals are ok if really short OR if you can automate it. like, take palworld: that game has some crafting take like 10 irl minutes to do manually, but get a decent pal and boom, 5 seconds. automation is what makes it enjoyable, not having that and having long times AT THE START it's terrible
Tethering looks pretty dope. This definitely feels extremely early access though
It is extremely early access
So Wildhearts was the closest MH-like we ever got huh?
Man that game could've been something special, but sadly EA fecked it up :/
FR they actually could’ve made a monster hunter competitor if they gave the game its time or maybe if they established it as a series, and i think they might’ve had ideas for sequels or dlc, because the peacock and the tiger kemonos (i don’t remember their names) they both said they were from different regions of the world like a land to the east or one to the west and I honestly so badly want to see another game to see those other regions
@@memeyxll2364 Agreed, they had a solid foundation in terms of worldbuilding and the gameplay was unique in its own right. Shame good things are ruined by greedy execs at the head of bloated companies like EA.
I hate the fact that I’m gonna say this
But
It was a monster hunter with Fortnite building with a lot of quirks to the point it’s its own thing
god eater is really good
@@25w-g6c Love that game wonder what new weapon they'd add if there's a 4th game coming up maybe a new gun or shield type
The only good MH-like so far might be Wild Hearts. Never heard of any other (maybe Toukiden if I remember correctly)
dauntless was nice too
it has a gunhammer 😈
god eater 3 was pretty good too
And what about God Eater ?
@@RauschenPaulithe whole trilogy is pretty nice
Wild Hearts was a lot of fun despite it's flaws, too bad EA killed it.
Toukiden is alright but the combat just isn't that good. I love the mitama system though for build variety
seems like more of a Dauntless-like than a MH-like. Still looks cool tho
Youll never guess what Dauntless is
A MH-like 😮
@@rainer9931 a mh like...
are you slow?😭
Yea
Yeah, that game is going nowhere. This is the first I'm seeing it but it's immediately obvious that they are running the whole thing on a premade asset store player controller and there's no way they're making a MH level combat system on that, no matter how much more time they spend on it. The animations and movement are just gonna be Like That.
Capcom should add an oiled up monster 😈
Hunting P Diddy????
What if instead of Monster hunter, it was Freak Hunter?
Gemma the Smithy :V
I mean... Gogmazios is right there
Ooh, and Radobaan.
A yes, a monster hunting game where the worst part about the game is hunting the monsters, truly a competitor to the MONSTER HUNTER series
Can't wait to see you on wild😊
7:06 That's because it's so difficult to make a game like monster hunter. Dauntless tried to reasonable success, but it's not monster hunter. It's not like someone saw a platformer and wanted to make another platformer, and it's not just a boss rush. You hunt the thing, get the things parts, and use them to make equipment to hunt the bigger thing. But monster hunter has been perfecting that formula for decades at this point, no other game will come close, at least not in the feel or detail, let alone the LIFE of the series.
This really reminds me of genshin for some reason.(Zelda too ofc)
But especially Like that one region in liyue with all the mountains with bridges between them
I feel it's a little misleading to call every game taking inspiration from Monster Hunter a "MH Competitor". I think _any_ developer no matter the experience would understand how pointless it is to try to make a "Competitor" to a series running for already over 2 decades. It's just not something feasible. I get that it's what gets the clicks, but it's important to understand that trying to make a joke out of someone's attempts to turn their passion into a tangible playable game, even if admittedly not very clean attempts, is nothing but harmful in my eyes really
"Dear diary..."
Kinda seems like they tried to incorporate too many aspects from other games into a MH formula. The overall early version jank isn’t doing it any favors, but hey, something new I guess.
Some decent ideas but overall, this aint it. That being said, I wouldn't mind a MH game that allowed me to invest in the village/city allowing me to build it up.
Can they make a game with monsters we don't feel bad about killing
Horizon west forbidden dawn
who's we, I need to get my cool looking Armor and weapons somehow
That sounds like a personal issue. I would do anything for another armor set.
The execution here is obviously very poor but I do like some of the ideas here; especially the hunting monsters/gathering to build up your town/settlement. I like the idea of using monster materials to upgrade more stuff other than just your weapons/armor. MH doesn't really give you a reason to go back to hunting lower rank monsters or non endgame monsters in general once you've progressed past them other than if you just really enjoy bullying them.
Dauntless' close beta for it's biggest update ever just dropped yesterday and looks promising so far, hope you make another video on it when it goes public in November
Yet another open world slop again.
Like I don't understand, why they keep making a huge world knowing they haven't even nail the mechanic yet? I feel like they just try to copy all popular genre and mash it into 1 game with 0 direction or any polished quality.
So the hammer claw is a dog thing. It doesn't hammer or anything like that though? So why hammer claw? Shouldn't it have like big hammery claws?
Wildhearts and dauntless are the closest. Dauntless needs to change it back to picking a hunt and hunting that monster. Not…. This open world aspect
I think there isnt much comepetition for MH simply because it takes too much creativity and money to monopolize.
i feel like this is more a survival game
i hear persona music
i am standing on the walls dancing
there is no in between
i refuse to think these are the games sound. wtf are the noices when hitting, going close to the portal and flying. that cant possibly be the in game sound 😅
Given the state of the game I'm fairly sure those are mostly placeholders.
Ngl I think it would be awesome if you covered more “MH Likes” in this format.
It's Gayshin Impact all over again
The only game series ive seen be anywhere similarly successful in the same vein of monster hunter, *that i also play* , would be God Eater, but even then God Eater is quite niche in comparison to monster hunter i guess.
Its a lot more openly dark, and is much more anime in terms of artstyle for those interested.
I've seen this game, and oh boi, is it rough. But I have hope for it. About the 1 hour thing. It's talking about in game hour. Which is 1 min. Oh. And it's really more fair to say this is a game like ark, a collany sim type game with the combat from mh. If it gets good I'll enjoy it. But God eater or toukiden is a far closer comparison to a mh game. A hunting RPG.
6:35 aw it looks so defeated
If u guys want a MH-like game, I suggest the God Eater Trilogy. Pretty much anime MH similar to how Code Vein is anime Dark Souls. GE1 and GE2 offer better stories and people would say that GE3 has better gameplay.
I personally prefer GE3. Buying God Eater 2 Rage Burst gives u God Eater resurrection (GE1) for free so definitely give it a try when u find it on sale.
PS: GE1 and GE2 is on eng dub and can't be change. GE1 can be patched to get JP dub but not GE2RB as far as I know
Ah yes, Genshin: World
I really enjoyed Wild Hearts when it came out. It had interesting monsters, very satisfying combat, and a great art direction. Even their post-launch support was pretty good, with additional end-game hunts and weapon balance changes. I haven't picked it up in a while, but I still remember my Bladed Wagasa combos :) If it didn't have *abysmal* performance issues at launch, I think that it would have done pretty well as a MH competitor.
I think the main fault of this game is that it tries to be too many things, and as such can't pay enough attention to implementing what makes those things good in the games they originate from. The gliding from every open world adventure game since BOTW, city building and inhabitant management from (presumably, among other things) Palworld, gravity pulling from a variety of games, and monster hunting from Monster Hunter, among other things as well, like Dauntless and Wild Hearts. These all did well in other games, because there wasn't so much of a focus on variety. It's also understandable that what is presumably a small studio can't get their mechanics nearly as good as large studios like Capcom and Nintendo.
However, I do believe the main fault of the player base is thinking that this game is meant to be a "Monster Hunter competitor". The game calls itself a 'monster-hunting game', but it does not try to compete with or be Monster Hunter. If we're calling everything that Steam recommends 'because you played this game:' a competitor of that game, Bloons TD6 would be a competitor of Payday 2. Steam's algorithm just looks for common tags, it's not chosen by the developer or accurate to product quality. It would be like saying that Breath of the Wild is a competitor of Minecraft, since they're both open world survival/adventure games.
Check out freedom wars remaster when it comes out.
The biggest contenders for the monster hunter like games were unfortunately locked to the sony handhelds namely God eater, Freedom Wars and my personal favorite Soul Sacrifice.
God eater has successfully left the handheld and is on consoles and I think pc and has 2 sequels and a decent anime.
They shadow dropped the Freedom Wars remaster now we just need bluepoint to remaster soul sacrifice delta and my life will be complete lol
This game has potential for the concept, but shear number of bad executions tear it apart. There’s so much room for QoL adjustments makes me not want to look at it for 5 years and see what happens.
The best thing games like this can do is steer clear from being compared to MH. Even good games that try and do similar stuff to MH get ripped to shreds because of the comparison before they even release.
WildHearts is a good game, the fight with that "sakura fox" (murakumo I think) is still in my top 3 favorite fights in any game
Not even in the same competition as MH. MH is in the Olympics and this isn't even in national competitions.
Ngl the whistling when you're flying sounds like someone's literally just whistling with their mouth lol.
well, it is an early access... I guess that having a survival game that has a bit of cool hunting in it is kinda nice. eh, I hope they improve it a lot
may come as a surprise but a monster hunter like game doesnt need to copy all of mh. they can do different things
game is hot garbage i bought it and couldn't even endure playing it for more than 10 minutes then refunded it
Tbh I would probably get it to tide me over until Wilds but that would be it at most
This game is just rip off palworld with a little bit of monster hunter on top of it. Not very impressive
I go back to Dauntless every few months just to check it out. But nothing compares to MH really.
Took wild hearts for granted, a sequel to that game could’ve been something
Timed crafting? Yeah imma head out from trying this game. 😑
looks cool but with all due respect, wait time for upgrades= no.
the wind whistles literally sound like a bunch of dudes trying to whistle
Like craftopia meets dauntless meets monster hunter but the execution needs more polish
doesn't look so bad with more improvements it has potential
when monster hunter Wilds comes out theres no reason to play anything else!!
Why do these assets look like theyre from the same store Palworld got there's from 😂
It didnt felt as a competitor as much as it felt like an omage, nice vid
The game looks very janky, but I do love those hitsounds
yea more like a dauntless competitor lol
the game looks awful but your editing is fire as always
It's like Palworld and Dauntless had a baby😅
This... Doesnt teslly look that good. Even with your edits.
05:07 missed the Shadowman walking in the sky
bro bought an unfinished early access game to roast it for being a unfinished early access game....content in 2024 i guess
It looks like another SEO word salad asset flip with nothing original to it. What do you mean early access? The game is complete, they just need to update it when they can afford better assets from the Unity store.
Damn PalWorld got pretty cursed ngl
Can’t compete if its not on console just saying
Looks more like Craftopia then MH
Massive potential just needs a bit of time
graphics look like genshit, lmao
Lol it looks like a mobile game
MH with useless clash of clans mechanics
Nice high quality mindless hate video man!!! Feel free to stop 😊
cant wait for your wilds content !
This video is too funny. 😂
Thanks!
You are the MVP. Thank you
@Chilledtiger Just helping a good content creator in this economy , My apologize it's just a small amount, I wish I could give you more. 🫡
WTF i watched jajajjajaj
hmm i like it tbh
Honestly I'm still on the notion that Wild Hearts was the closest we'll ever get to a true monster hunter competitor. It's unfortunate EA didn't give them enough of a shot to really develop into that before shelving it
Wrong, Soul Sacrifice
@@elk3407 ok I had to look that up and I watched a Gaijin Hunter vid on it. Definitely not, don't get me wrong this game looks absolutely sick, I wish I could have played it. But as far as a Monster Hunting game I wouldn't consider it a competitor, at least not in the way I'm thinking of one.
When I think of a hunting game I think of something that gets as close to actual Monster Hunter as possible. This game is definitely a Monster hunting game but it's WAY too fantastical for me (personally) to think of it as such. Like in Monster Hunter the whole gameplay loop was fighting "monsters" but they're really just really strong animals that are part of the ecosystem, and then using their various parts to create weapons and armor all for the sake of protecting the ecosystem and/or humanity. In my opinion wild hearts sticks much more to that than this game.
But this game definitely looks sick though I would have loved to play it. I'm going to see if I can find like a playthrough or something, maybe my opinion on that will change
@@Tech_D3mon I think we're just looking for something different in a MH competitor. I love the ecology of Monster Hunter. In fact, that's my favorite part. But what I'm looking for is a similar game feel. Wildhearts has a completely different game feel, and the dynamic between hunter and monster feels not quite right for a hunting game, and it all comes down to the Katakuri system being too important in combat for the fights to have the right back and forth. I might change my mind because I haven't actually finished Wild Hearts, but it just doesn't hit the right note for me combat-wise.
In fact, I mostly end up playing the Katakuri staff and think of it more like Nioh switchglaive
@@elk3407 yeah I definitely see what you're saying. In my opinion if the Katakuri system wasn't in the game then it would damn near be a monster hunter clone. I liked it because that's what made it different from Monster Hunter, but everything else was definitely all Monster Hunter, which is why it is probably going to be my favorite monster hunting game other than actual Monster Hunter. On that note though, I'm glad you put me on to Soul Sacrifice I'm currently watching Rurikhan's old playthrough on it now.
goated video
Play God Eater it's just like Monster Hunter, but anime.
Financial viability is definitely the biggest hurdle to makng an MH competitor. It's popular but still a clearly niche series (to the point where even for MH games only a couple of them have truly found audiences outside of the usual hardcore fans) and on top of being a niche its also a niche revolving around sinking tons of hours into one game. It's the Destiny Overwatch "live service" issue of there are only so many hours in a day, just in this case with an actual game rather than a skinner box addiction product. What this means is you need to REALLY be bringing something to the table to justify the player investment and usually that means having variety, scale, AND polish, not just some combination of the three.
I feel like there's definitely so far when it comes to MH-likes been two very distinct categories. Wild Hearts is one category, Dauntless is the other, and this definitely goes in the Dauntless Category.
Does God Eater count as an MH like...?