Old Top Gear 2001 - MINI One vs Rivals

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 ноя 2016
  • Tiff Needell tests the new MINI One against the Ford Ka and the Volkswagen Lupo
    Taken from an early 2001 episode of the old format Top Gear
  • Авто/МотоАвто/Мото

Комментарии • 72

  • @aleksanderprzytua
    @aleksanderprzytua 3 года назад +8

    20 years later I still have my 2001 Cooper

  • @pauljakeman
    @pauljakeman 2 года назад +6

    Wow. Cars that were sub £15k.
    How things have changed!

  • @Alejandro_Palomo
    @Alejandro_Palomo 4 года назад +15

    Actually, that was the last final clip of Tiff Needell for Top Gear, and the last episode aswell of the show before Tiff moved to Fifth Gear, and Top Gear reborned again with Clarkson just for compensate the born of the show in Channel 5.

  • @derekholland9091
    @derekholland9091 Год назад +7

    My mini one is totally nuts tbh😂 Ive modified it quite a lot tho. It now has 153bhp and sounds and goes like an old rally car . I love it

    • @lyphstylez4849
      @lyphstylez4849 Год назад +2

      What do you have done to it? 🤘

    • @derekholland9091
      @derekholland9091 Год назад +4

      @@lyphstylez4849 dunno where to start tbh . A good remap , carbon fiber air intake with ported R53 aluminum intake manifold and the bigger ported R53 throttle body. Bigger fuel injectors . Newham fast road and rally cam shaft and stronger valve springs.. Equal length exhaust headers with sport cats and bigger non resonated exhaust system. I'm sure the list the goes on..

    • @AutumnChicken1
      @AutumnChicken1 Год назад +2

      @@derekholland9091 how much?

  • @bid84
    @bid84 7 лет назад +62

    Hard to believe the mini is 15 years old already

    • @WhinedUp2004
      @WhinedUp2004 4 года назад +7

      The car on the video is now 20 years old. What a timeless design, for a first effort, full marks to BMW

    • @ricoricardo4850
      @ricoricardo4850 3 года назад

      - no on RUclips is a Video from the designer of the new mini

    • @xxdark-angelxx7967
      @xxdark-angelxx7967 3 года назад

      Well, in the year 2021 this is my first car

    • @SpitfireFortyFour
      @SpitfireFortyFour 3 года назад +1

      @@WhinedUp2004 It was more Rovers work. BMW asset stripped it away from them.

  • @LordDragunov
    @LordDragunov 3 года назад +9

    19 years later MINI is still cool and desirable...

  • @Nombredeusuario1030
    @Nombredeusuario1030 7 лет назад +42

    Y-Reg, new shape Mini. That's rare!

    • @Renegade666
      @Renegade666 7 лет назад +9

      was thinking the same thing. this must be a very early production press model

    • @lucylocket4740
      @lucylocket4740 7 лет назад +1

      When was the first registered I wonder?

    • @kieranwhite6647
      @kieranwhite6647 6 лет назад +5

      There's a Facebook group for Y Reg New Mini's if anybody is interested facebook.com/groups/MINIYREGister/

    • @PeteS_1994
      @PeteS_1994 4 года назад +2

      Nombredeusuario1030 2001

    • @debbiepeter112
      @debbiepeter112 3 года назад +2

      I have an October 2001 car. Some very early ones still around (May 2001)

  • @s.m.2868
    @s.m.2868 7 лет назад +60

    In my opinion the Ford Ka is tremendously ugly, truly one of the worst. The Mini on the other hand looks great (a real masterpiece by Frank Stephenson) and it also retains its value much better than the Ka.

    • @can-am7915
      @can-am7915 7 лет назад +1

      Stefan Micsa Some "functional" Ka's are 400 euros in my country 😂

    • @ahmadzayn8776
      @ahmadzayn8776 2 года назад

      i know Im asking randomly but does any of you know of a way to log back into an instagram account..?
      I stupidly forgot the login password. I would appreciate any tricks you can offer me!

    • @beckettzakai6070
      @beckettzakai6070 2 года назад

      @Ahmad Zayn Instablaster :)

    • @aidy6000
      @aidy6000 2 года назад

      ah but have you ever driven one?

    • @_zigger_
      @_zigger_ 10 месяцев назад +1

      Both are for girls

  • @ScottD_
    @ScottD_ 7 лет назад +25

    The old shape mini is WAY nicer than the new shape , the new shape's lights are too big almost bug like

  • @ashleyholroyd91
    @ashleyholroyd91 7 лет назад +19

    This was filmed in Leeds

  • @6ettinold
    @6ettinold 5 лет назад +3

    The first time I saw I e at the Motor Show ( 2000 at the NEC ), I was asked by a bloke on the stand what I thought. I owned a lovely mk1 Morris Mini Minor at the time, so I wasn't very nice about the BMW effort. I thought this bloke was a punter like me. Turned out he was on the design team and took my comments quite personally.

  • @mk3a
    @mk3a 5 лет назад +12

    The Mini Cooper S from 2019 hasn’t changed much excluding the interior. What bothers me is the countryman and clubman

  • @emilycoates3347
    @emilycoates3347 6 лет назад +13

    I just went from a 2001 Lupo 1.4 S to a 2002 1.6 Mini One, and the mini feels so much more solid than the lupo

    • @angelotorres8051
      @angelotorres8051 5 лет назад +1

      Emily Coates do you still have your mini ?

    • @nikko6883
      @nikko6883 5 лет назад +1

      Emily Coates I’m about to buy one for myself. If you’re still active, I’d appreciate your thoughts on your experience

    • @archiebrown6407
      @archiebrown6407 3 года назад +2

      The 1.6 mini is my first car.

    • @debbiepeter112
      @debbiepeter112 3 года назад +2

      I am on my 5th Mini. Love them

  • @smogmonster1876
    @smogmonster1876 5 лет назад +7

    I own a Mini and it’s the best £14,200 I’ve ever spent.
    It’s a fabulous car.

  • @NB-qr2rt
    @NB-qr2rt 3 года назад +2

    My mum had a Ford Ka. Mechanical problems were common, but more so was the rust (and the plastic bumpers on the car discoloured and faded pretty quickly).

  • @sutherlandA1
    @sutherlandA1 4 года назад +4

    If he thought the original BINI was big he must think the current one is appalling

    • @RWL2012
      @RWL2012 Год назад +1

      and the Countryman. I saw one parked next to a Honda Civic and the Civic was smaller.

  • @davidhayes4814
    @davidhayes4814 7 лет назад +5

    The new mini one was little more expensive than the old mini. This was over £9500 in its final form. The new mini was a bigger, more accomplished car and really very good value..... just stay clear of any option other than the tlc £100 package, which was a no brainier.....

  • @fossilfueled27
    @fossilfueled27 5 лет назад +5

    Ford ka... Ford ka... rings a bell... Oh wait! I remember! That's the rusty death-trap shitbox that fell to pieces after about 5 years!

    • @oyku.akbulut
      @oyku.akbulut 5 лет назад +3

      It was quite safe for it's class when it was launched. It handles great and moreover, that rust thing is total bullshit from housewives who never bothers to wash the undercarriage of the car for years.

    • @fossilfueled27
      @fossilfueled27 5 лет назад +3

      In the UK, almost every 1st gen Ford Ka rusted through thanks to completely subpar galvanizing. You shouldn't have to wash the undercarriage of a car if it isn't assembled by cheapskates. I only say this from experience working in garages - Kas simply rust more than everything else the same age, regardless of how well they're cared for. Having driven one, they handle okay. No better or worse than anything else the same size.

    • @gabrielcooper2044
      @gabrielcooper2044 4 года назад

      @@oyku.akbulut I own a Ka and can confirm it rusts terribly. You can't defend that. Fun to drive though

    •  4 года назад

      @@fossilfueled27
      I don't believe galvinising is a common practice for most manufacturers but Audi did employ it for a while.
      I think you mean rust proofing, same idea but not via galvanisation.
      The Ka was happy to rust unfortunately. Funny looking but nice to drive with a good tight little chassis and willing engines based on older tech units.

  • @denon7474
    @denon7474 2 года назад

    Not BMW's first FWD design - Rover 75, with which the MINI R53 shares a key shell, was

  • @shankarbalan3813
    @shankarbalan3813 2 года назад

    I vastly prefer the Mini’s looks. The Ford KA might have been cheaper but its design is a bit polarising. I’m glad Mini came to India and I was able to get a second gen R56 S, used….

  • @soundseeker63
    @soundseeker63 5 лет назад +21

    Seems funny to think that in 2001 they criticised the new Mini for not being mini enough....now compare with the bloated oversize monstrosities that carry the Mini badge today!! I did actually quite like this second gen Mini but BMW have since trashed the brand with their ugly, oversized and overpriced newer models that are totally pointless.

    • @oliverkalamata2753
      @oliverkalamata2753 5 лет назад

      Not only that but compare the MINI badge from the 1st gen to the 3rd gen. Yeouch!

    • @mk3a
      @mk3a 5 лет назад

      That was the case with the Clubman and the Countryman. I didn’t understand the point with the countryman

  • @RedLP5000S
    @RedLP5000S 2 года назад

    I've only seen 1 Ford Ka here in the States. Must've been imported.

  • @stewartmcminn7773
    @stewartmcminn7773 3 года назад

    @5:06 - it's over anykin!

  • @KariIzumi1
    @KariIzumi1 7 лет назад +1

    yeah...MINI is continuing to go more upscale. The new Countryman is $4k more than the outgoing model. :/

  • @SpitfireFortyFour
    @SpitfireFortyFour 3 года назад

    Lots of banging on about BMW doing a good job when the car was designed by Rover....

  • @Tylerpierre99
    @Tylerpierre99 4 года назад +1

    The Ka was good for 1996 when expectations were not as high. It was safe (then) and handled decently. It's looks were devisive but it endeared itself to affordable motoring. Then Ford coasted on the Ka for too long. It was poorly constructed and prone to rust and mechanical faults galore. They tried to keep it competitive but other brands came along and wanted a slice of the action. The Ka was really outdated under that design and starting the engine at 6am on a cold February morning made it sound like castanets
    They were better purchased as new or second hand. Older models that passed 3 hands had more faults and problems than was worth spending the money required for such a cheap car. People expected more and the equipment on the Ka was stingy and basic. It didn't help that it was considered a girly car and suitable only for handbags. The sexist sentiment repelled men with a hint of uncertainty about their masculinity and with the cars faulting and breaking down, it wasn't uncommon to see a female stood at the side of the road at rush hour with a broken down ford Ka.
    They relaunched but it didn't work. Ford confused buyers looking for a small car. Other cars became safer and thus larger and male and female buyers gravitated towards the newer Fiesta hatchbacks instead. Leaving the ford Ka as a slow plodding granny car or a single late-middle aged woman's car who reuses her Hessian tote bags and lives with a cat and only used it to take tom to the vet or shop at Marks and Spencers.

  • @raftonpounder6696
    @raftonpounder6696 Год назад

    The Ka rotted badly. The MINI does not. I have a 21 year old one and it’s in perfect condition.

  • @RoadCone411
    @RoadCone411 4 года назад

    I can’t believe that the new Mini is almost 20 years old! 20! Don’t see many of the original BMW Minis on the road here in the US, I think they’re largely gone now. Too expensive to maintain and they had a reputation for poor reliability and bad electrics (keeping with the British character of the car, most likely.) I know the wheels were really bad on the US roads, and replacing those alloys isn’t cheap. Too bad because I always liked them, drove a friends many times.

    • @RoadCone411
      @RoadCone411 4 года назад

      I never read replies So I cannot criticize cars from elsewhere? Believe me, I call it as I see it. A POS from anywhere is still a POS.

    • @sunray2818
      @sunray2818 3 года назад

      Motorweek presenter John Davis has a first hand R50 Mini, and he is still driving it today, being very well maintained.

    • @ch-jc1mp
      @ch-jc1mp 3 года назад +1

      i have an r53 cooper s in california. it’s only had one issue in my 3 years of ownership (harmonic balancer failure). other than that i just change the oil every 3-4k. electrics are perfect and the little bugger still looks new too. fantastic car. not exactly camry reliability, but not as awful as many people say

  • @marcusthestarlord4936
    @marcusthestarlord4936 3 года назад +1

    How can you compare a shitbox like the ka with the mini???

  • @5340robert
    @5340robert 10 месяцев назад

    God Leeds in 2001

  • @pswitch9553
    @pswitch9553 7 лет назад +1

    0:01 Windows XP!

    • @jeff4362
      @jeff4362 5 лет назад

      ?

    • @RWL2012
      @RWL2012 Год назад

      ​@@jeff4362 that song was in an advert for it

  • @casperocee
    @casperocee Год назад

    So their is a spare tire. The hardest thing to get to like a lot of things. a delightful car to drive, tire changes ? Ass

  • @TheMelonhead360
    @TheMelonhead360 3 года назад

    the mini has fucked power steering

  • @mariadigiovanna5535
    @mariadigiovanna5535 4 года назад

    Yes is a good car but the shift is a shit!

  • @crazyxyful
    @crazyxyful 7 лет назад

    That lisp is annoying

  • @jigrodrigues
    @jigrodrigues 7 лет назад

    New mini's for wankers

  • @JackBandicootsBunker
    @JackBandicootsBunker 7 лет назад +1

    BMW *BUTCHERED* the MINI.