Yaesu FT-DX10 HF Transceiver - Is it Right for You?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 131

  • @rogerm8557
    @rogerm8557 3 года назад +10

    The FTDX10 uses a hybrid SDR architecture, while the IC7300 uses a direct sampling SDR. The hybrid SDR delivers better performance in the presence of strong signals in the passband, because the narrow roofing filter attenuates those signals before they can overload the A/D converter. In the 7300, the A/D converter is wide open to the entire passband. I'm in CM97, which has an extremely high concentration of hams, so I have a lot of strong local signals. I'm also an old American ham, but as an engineer, I've been learning new tricks all my life. Maybe it's not for everyone, and I respect that, but the FTDX10 looks like it is the right radio for me. I'll be upgrading from a FT-450D.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      I did cover this in a previous video. Don’t assume nybrid is better. FlexRadio is right at the top of the Sherwood Engineering list. 73 Peter

  • @C4H6As
    @C4H6As Год назад +2

    One thing to do is make the external screen high res to fully use 1920x1080 for spectrum, waterfall, decoder etc. all at once. External monitor should also be independend from the small screen and freely configurable for maximum usability. I think, we will have to wait 3..5 years for that.

  • @marshred
    @marshred 2 года назад +1

    The Best HF Radio! Got mine a week ago on sale for $1299 US. Absolutely love it!

  • @acestudioscouk-Ace-G0ACE
    @acestudioscouk-Ace-G0ACE 3 года назад +5

    Your point regarding a general high level of performance being a given and the features making the difference is very valid. I'm a photographer by trade (ex Amateur Radio Magazine) and the story is the same with the 3 big camera manufacturers.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Many thanks for sharing that. 73 Peter

  • @bunston1000
    @bunston1000 3 года назад +6

    Hi Peter, nice honest review. I have always been, pretty much a Yaesu customer for most of my ham radio career. After a break of many years, like many others, I came back into ham radio because of lockdown. I got out my FT747GX, and off I went. The realisation soon became apparent, that maybe something more modern was required. I bought a Yaesu FT991a and have to say I was delighted with it, and the FT747GX was then relegated to Hf standby. Just recently I got the Icom IC9700 for 2m/70cm/23cm, probably the first marque change in all of 35years. Sadly, the FT747GX lost its drive, and I replaced the driver transistors, only for them to fail again. So I needed to back up the Hf side of things, and am eagerly awaiting the arrival of my FT10DX this Monday. I have now experienced the major changes in ham gear from many, many years ago to the present date and have to say how amazing these modern transceivers are. Anyway Peter, once again for a very fair review, take care. 73’s Geoff. (G4SQJ).

  • @johnratcliffe6438
    @johnratcliffe6438 3 года назад +7

    If it had an RF out to connect to an SDR, then it'd be pretty perfect. As it is, the ability to reduce QRM/QRN is insanely good and the DSP is spectacular. I really wish ICOMs were half as capable. And I own ICOM.

  • @andywharam4846
    @andywharam4846 3 года назад +2

    What a nice guy Peter is, a knolagable & informative enthusiast, I'm new to radio communications, it's a hobby I've been thinking 💭 about getting into for many years,, problem been affordability, it's a fascinating & a fantastic pass time ,I love gadgets, got many of them, when I get my inheritance I will definitely be getting something like the YAESU FTdx10 or a YAESU FT DX 3000 as it is now being discontinued, hopefully the price will drop🙏, I know in order to start this fascinating hobby requires me to get a license & of course legally must pass a set of upto 3 exams, that's the challenge, but I'm confident at passing the 1st one, wish me luck🙏🇬🇧

  • @RA4FOC
    @RA4FOC 3 года назад +5

    Thanks Peter! I was very interested in your opinion! I changed my ft-450 to ftdx-10 and have no regrets!

  • @JosephAnthonyJosefius
    @JosephAnthonyJosefius Год назад

    I recently acquired this rig, it was an upgrade from my FT-991A which I got as my first rig. Now that I'm into CW as my main mode, I wanted a rig that could use a hardware roofing filter for CW without breaking the bank. I love it so far. Thanks and 73 de AI5DD

  • @jedidiahsmith3
    @jedidiahsmith3 2 года назад +1

    Thank you for such a great unbiased look at the FT-DX10 vs the competition and thoughtful consideration of its operation. I just pulled the trigger on one. Might be a little step up from my FT-857D :-)

  • @ipklondonuk
    @ipklondonuk Год назад

    My Next Radio for sure, recently had a play with one and that DSP is awesome to say the least

  • @davidshermanlittle919
    @davidshermanlittle919 Год назад +1

    You are so fair and honest.

  • @imaflatpicker3066
    @imaflatpicker3066 3 года назад +3

    Peter you are the best! Love your videos. You bring a smile to my face. Thank you!

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      Wow, thank you. Much appreciated. 73 Peter

    • @brian.7966
      @brian.7966 3 года назад

      you will bring a smile to his face if you buy anything from his shop lol.

  • @brianspilsbury8953
    @brianspilsbury8953 2 года назад

    I appreciate your reviews and discussionsm Your wisedom gained from 50+ years of experience makes the difference. So many RUclips channels are all about flash, fancy editing and thinly disguised stab in the back tactics that even when they have knowledge, their delivery negates the message. Keep it up!

  • @mbarreto64
    @mbarreto64 3 года назад +3

    Probably one of your best videos!
    In my humble opinion, an interesting setup is to have ic-7300 with PTRX-7300 and FTdx-10 together :) . At the moment I have a 7300 and an ft891, and undecide between swap the 7300 by a 7610 or add ptrx-7300 and ftdx-10. Leaned more to have both radios :)

    • @alexalonso2093
      @alexalonso2093 3 года назад

      WHAT IS AN PTRX-7300?

    • @mbarreto64
      @mbarreto64 3 года назад

      @@alexalonso2093 You can see it here: www.radioanalog.com/ptrx-7300/

  • @mirkocaserta
    @mirkocaserta 3 года назад

    It is a pleasure to watch your videos Sir. Thank you very much for sharing your wisdom.

  • @adzbasslines268
    @adzbasslines268 3 года назад +2

    Great video Peter, I do really like this Yaesu. I feel that owning a IC-705 may bring user interface familiarity to instead buying a IC-7300. But what I benefit from HAM radio as a hobby is buying different radios that offer other features. So I think the FT-DX10 suits me best for what I also want to do.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      Many thanks for sharing. 73 Peter

    • @Юрий-я7ы
      @Юрий-я7ы Год назад +1

      @@watersstanton какая цена Yaesu FTdx10 в вашем магазине?

  • @g0fvt
    @g0fvt 3 года назад

    I had to pore through the manual to find out a few things, which will be high priority for some potential buyers, the RS232 port is for CAT control, the USB does two functions, CAT control and internal USB sound card. With a SCU-LAN10 a lot of functionality is available for remote operation via ethernet. Very handy for those of us who want to play digital modes while pretending to watch television with the Mrs.... Firmware updates and recordings/configurations use SD cards.

  • @benrubery8056
    @benrubery8056 3 года назад

    Very nice was thinking of buying one for the shack i like the external display monitor and coulor screen water fall looks amazing and different coulor function ❤

  • @JayN4GO
    @JayN4GO 2 года назад

    Tnx for a stellar review. I’ve compared this rig with the 300hz filter on Cw and it edges the k3. The 7300 doesn’t even compete with the 2. However the 73 has brilliant audio out. The dx10 is the Cw contesters dream rig for what it is. It’s just the menus that make the k3 a great rig even though it’s getting long in the tooth. The rxer on the 10 is just a joy. Since I listen more than talk, i left the flex and icom collecting dust. Hehe. 73 Peter and stay well

  • @dreupen
    @dreupen 2 года назад +1

    I was wavering on a new purchase fro some time now. But with this year's Black Friday specials I just could not pass up on the FTdx10 shipped for $1,300. I purchased it from a smaller online vender saving extra including no state taxes($100 saving). I enjoyed the review, but the FTdx10 blew me away.

  • @Scif64
    @Scif64 3 года назад +1

    Nice look into the radio Peter. I might be on the lookout soon for a more permanent home base soon and use the 705 as a portable vhf/uhf setup. It certainly looks like a nice radio. I don't have any loyalty to any brand, but I used to use yaesu and kenwood back in the 80's and 90's and the 705 is my first icom. All the best and be well. 73s

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Sounds great! Many thanks Steve. Take care. Peter

  • @radicallyrescued7916
    @radicallyrescued7916 3 года назад +1

    Great. review without going into too many tech specs.. thank you ..

  • @andyhearn9240
    @andyhearn9240 3 года назад

    Excellent review Peter, well balanced, sorely tempted to replace my 8 month old 7300 with the FTdx10 now.

  • @dougtaylor7724
    @dougtaylor7724 3 года назад

    Very good review. I’m a little disappointed in the single antenna connector but the display hookup feature is very nice

  • @ehayes5217
    @ehayes5217 3 года назад

    I've had the 7300 for a while now & even though I'm not looking to change right now, I really enjoyed ur review; tnx es 73 de WA4ELW in TN

  • @joaquinnunez33
    @joaquinnunez33 2 года назад

    Good and detailed explanation, thank you very much.

  • @timhague882
    @timhague882 2 года назад +2

    I recently bought the FTdx10 , I’ve been able to do a direct comparison with my IC7610, I’m afraid the dx10 receiver is superior to the Icom, the filtering and noise reduction is such that I could easily copy signals on the dx10 that I couldn’t on the 7610. I wish it had a transverter low level output and a second antenna socket for 6 and 4M but that’s about it.

    • @biltztom2685
      @biltztom2685 Год назад

      I also have a FTDX 10 it really works superb, since I connected a mouse to it, the user flexibility is far better, al the parameters you can touch and change them. I understand that using a mouse with the ICOM gives you only frequency and spectrum scope capabilities.

  • @mikes6844
    @mikes6844 3 года назад +1

    I agree with your analogy, would I notice the technical differences between the DX10 and say the IC7300? I don’t think so, so I would go down the user route, how easy is it to tune, change band, filters etc. With the exception of Elecraft a Windows based PC is needed to upgrade them. In 2021 and with the resources available I would not expect this to be so. I have a FT3000 and it remains a fantastic piece of kit, but for a Mac OS based man it’s a lot of hassle to upgrade the rigs software to the extent I cannot upgrade everything on mine. Many rigs have a monitor connection point but again the software is Windows based. So I’m not seeing a compelling case to change unless it’s a night and day difference in performance. Great review Peter thanks for posting. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Hi Mike, I am also Mac based. . Know the problem. 73 Peter

  • @samscement
    @samscement 3 года назад

    An absolutely great and honest review Peter, well done, love your reviews, cheers, Sam, 🇦🇺

  • @nigelbrooks7744
    @nigelbrooks7744 3 года назад +1

    Great video very useful info , it looks a great bit of kit

  • @robertallbright
    @robertallbright 3 года назад +1

    Excellent Peter
    73 Rob

  • @markericksen6900
    @markericksen6900 3 года назад +1

    This was a fantastic review. I believe the Yaesu FTDX-10 has a three-year warranty vs the ICOM 7300 that has a one-year warranty. Could you comment on how the length of a radio warranty might enter into a purchase decision? How would customer service ratings on factory warranty repairs enter into the decision?
    Thanks Great job.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      The Icom warranty is 2 Years. I would not base my choice on warranty, but rather product suitability. 73 Peter.

  • @radicallyrescued7916
    @radicallyrescued7916 3 года назад +1

    Great Review person like me .. don’t have to go crazy with the tech specs .. thank you

  • @mikeoswald8053
    @mikeoswald8053 3 года назад +1

    Another great review, with good insight into the usability of the FTDX-10. I agree that it will be the replacement for the FT-101ZD. Oh, loved that radio! Purchased an FTDX-10 here in the states on Friday and still reading the directions before turning it on. Thank you Peter! 73 KB7HFS

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      Thanks for watching! Nice to hear from you Mike. 73 Peter

    • @alexalonso2093
      @alexalonso2093 3 года назад

      would it be too heavy for POTA activations 7 3

  • @jackK5FIT
    @jackK5FIT 3 года назад

    Another great review. Considering either an IC-7300 (I am an ICOM believer) or an FTdx10 for a new radio. This will help with the decision. Thanks! Jack K5FIT

  • @alan4cars
    @alan4cars 3 года назад

    Another great video. You would be my ham store if I lived in the UK. Very unbiased. 73 WA6MOW

  • @johnnyrebellion8672
    @johnnyrebellion8672 3 года назад +7

    I hate touching the screen. It is awkward. The ability to use a mouse on the FTDX10 is a leap forward.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Good to hear. 73 Peter

    • @W1KAB-9
      @W1KAB-9 2 года назад

      I was definitely making note of that. I’ve got “fat fingers” so between the mouse and the monitor, not to mention hearing that this radio is a lot better receiving CW signals, I think I’m sold!

  • @karrlrichardson3641
    @karrlrichardson3641 3 года назад

    A great review, well covered. Maybe time to replace my ft847
    g7aay

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Thanks for sharing. Give Sales a call and quote the video. 73 Peter

  • @SteveG4YTK
    @SteveG4YTK 2 года назад +1

    Hi Peter, I have the FTDX10 I think its amazing transceiver, but after cutting my teeth on a KW200B 35 years ago. I am mainly into CW, and sota chasing. My question is, would It be worth me buying the 300 hz roofing filter. Is there any difference in using 500hz filter down to 50hz and the 300hz down to 50hz, chasing ghosts stations ? Interested in your thoughts or maybe a video would be great

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  2 года назад

      Well I personally would stick with 500Hz - I prefer to get any extra selectivity using my eRs. But others may not agree! I can’t remember if the FT-DX10 has an audio filter? My old Elecraft K3 did and I always rated that as the best for going lower than my 400Hz filter. Not sure if that helps ? 73 Peter.

    • @SteveG4YTK
      @SteveG4YTK 2 года назад

      @@watersstanton Thankyou for your time and advice. I think I will save my money for now because £160 for the 300hz filter is not cheap for little return. The 500hz filter digitally reduced to 50hz is very good especially with the APF or Contour. Steve g4ytk

  • @WilliamParmley
    @WilliamParmley 3 года назад

    Thank you, very helpful.

  • @radionb3i
    @radionb3i Год назад

    can the Yaesu FT DX 10 interface directly to a computer without a TNC for RTTY and digital?

  • @AudiophileTubes
    @AudiophileTubes Год назад

    How much better is this radio (FT-DX10) compared to my Icom 756 Pro3? Especially the receiver's ability? Thanks.

  • @mrx-no4fn
    @mrx-no4fn Год назад

    Hi does the dx10 cover all of the shortwave bands I’m thinking of getting one for shortwave listening only because there don’t seem to be any decent communications receivers out there within my budget thanks in advance 73s

  • @btbaltesflorent
    @btbaltesflorent 2 года назад

    super video thanks. 73's

  • @ianmccabe68
    @ianmccabe68 2 года назад

    That's how to do a review, thankyou

  • @steelcityman9767
    @steelcityman9767 3 года назад

    Very good review..as are all your reviews ... when are you going to open a store in Yorkshire? Am radios are up here as well you know. Would love to come and browse (and buy) in your store

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Hi there. Great to hear from you. Lots of things on hold at the moment because of Covid! 73 Peter.

  • @enzofalzone1124
    @enzofalzone1124 3 года назад

    Please, can you tell me if it is normal that the outer ring of the clarifier is a little lossy compared to the main one ? I noticed it moves a bit if you try to pull towards you. Thanks in advance. Enzo

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Sorry, I do not have tge radio now. It is not usual to get a small amount of movement with dome of these dual controls. If there is no issue then I wiukd tend rpto simply register this with tge dealer to cover yourself for a possible warranty ckaim. But orobably normal

  • @gerdh.5636
    @gerdh.5636 3 года назад

    Peter the FT101 was introduced in the early 1970s

  • @howardparker6342
    @howardparker6342 3 года назад

    Peter you said the IC7610 performance was not substantially better than the IC7300, 2nd receiver and other features apart, would you say the same for the FTdX10 performance v FTdX101, 2nd receiver and other features not with standing? Great review, thank you.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Basically yes but as I have not used the FT-DX 101 I am basing this on the soe. 73 Peter.

  • @timgoad5750
    @timgoad5750 3 года назад

    Keep up the good videos.

  • @docpearson
    @docpearson 3 года назад

    Could you please help me with something. I have been searching everywhere to see if the ftdx 10 has the VC tuner in it like ftdx 101D has. It is the VC-tuner that makes the 101D so fabulous and everybody wants it. They say the little brother 10 edition it’s also good at tuning in a station I cannot find any picture that shows the VC-tuner on the ftdx 10 Version. Do you know anything about this could you help me please

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      THE fT-DX10 is a stripped down version of the FT-DX101 and so many things are not included. 73 Peter

  • @MONTY-YTNOM
    @MONTY-YTNOM 3 года назад

    Bit confused, the link goes to a DX101D , the ability to hook up to a monitor grabs me, being partially sighted. But as a newbie some of these vidoes are talking to 'experts' not learners like me :) But I still want a DX10 :)

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      Hi there. Sorry about the link. This has been corrected. 73 Peter

    • @MONTY-YTNOM
      @MONTY-YTNOM 3 года назад

      @@watersstanton Not a problem :) it was easy enough to find the DX10 on the site

  • @ianbevan5183
    @ianbevan5183 2 года назад

    Thank you for a good review. G0YAP.

  • @MichiganPeatMoss
    @MichiganPeatMoss 3 года назад

    First ten seconds: I have the 101EE in mothballs. Was there a significant difference between the 101E and 101EE?

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Many thanks 73 Peter

    • @kungfucommando1642
      @kungfucommando1642 3 года назад

      The EE was the “economy” version, identical to the 101E save for a speech processor. One could be added after purchase, making it functionally identical to the “E” version.

  • @sergiodelta
    @sergiodelta 3 года назад +1

    Gracias, buen video. LU7BSE

  • @forgetyourlife
    @forgetyourlife 3 года назад +2

    Waiting for the left handed version.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +3

      Interesting! Mind you there are no left handed pianos so you may have a lomg wait, 73 Peter.

  • @larryak0z672
    @larryak0z672 3 года назад

    If you can narrow the bandwidth to say 50Hz, why would you want the optional 300Hz roofing filter? No one seems to know for sure!

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +2

      Because the roofibg filter is much earlier in the receiving chain and cleans things up long before a much broader signal is sent further down the chain to be cleaned up at the end of the hain with the associared problems. 73 Peter.

  • @matthewdavies2057
    @matthewdavies2057 3 года назад +1

    It's more traditional looking, but who wants THAT? Small buttons, crowded display. Not made for old American hams. Is it an SDR like the 7300?

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Thanks. 73 Peter

    • @KD8GKR
      @KD8GKR 3 года назад +3

      Yaesu calls it a Hybrid SDR. Easy explanation, they do a few more things with signal before the analog to digital converter unlike the 7300.

  • @Justin-bd2dg
    @Justin-bd2dg 3 года назад

    So basically this is an improved 991-A with the UHF/VHF removed?

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      No. The design concept is not the same.

    • @kungfucommando1642
      @kungfucommando1642 3 года назад

      Not at all. This is an SDR hybrid. According to Yaesu, this is a single receiver version of the FTDX101D.

  • @kungfucommando1642
    @kungfucommando1642 3 года назад

    Yaesu stated the FTDX10 is a single-receiver version of the FTDX101D. If that is the case, it should have the same Sherwood results. I’m intrigued!

    • @85rockhound
      @85rockhound 3 года назад

      The 101D is #1, the FTDX10D is #3 per Sherwood testing.

  • @michaelscoofield
    @michaelscoofield 3 года назад

    No ext. RX antenna port, no separate 6m antenna socket, no PIN diode T/R switching (yes in 21st century still used relay) just sewing machine sound on CW, annoying menu…no chance to join my setup!

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +1

      …apart from that it sounds ideal for you!

  • @Homer19521
    @Homer19521 3 года назад

    "Good radio" - puts it right in the middle of the pack for WS.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      Many thanks. 73 Peter

    • @Homer19521
      @Homer19521 3 года назад +2

      @@watersstanton The DSP DNF & NB have been a disappointment for me. Both create excessive distortion, even on the lowest settings. I hope Yaesu fixes this.

  • @Team-fabulous
    @Team-fabulous 11 месяцев назад

    It might be a fantastic radio but most blokes like a radio to look like a radio... That means lots of buttons please..

  • @RobB_VK6ES
    @RobB_VK6ES 3 года назад

    Not a fan of modular mic plugs as they have poor strain relief and require specialist tools to repair.

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад

      We have not noticed that problem at all. It's becoming more and more popular in other fields as well.

  • @pierreberube7022
    @pierreberube7022 2 года назад

    Radio is not accessible for blind ham canine EYE

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  2 года назад

      Ham radio is most certainly available to blind hams.

  • @richarddegen6184
    @richarddegen6184 3 месяца назад

    Got one a month ago, really not that impressed,awkward touch screen, too many things to fool with, and video game display...my FT920 does almost everything as good or better, with simple front panel controls, and a menu driven cat system to customize fine tuning, should have saved the $1400. Tiny controls that it has are crowded and easy to punch up wrong one by mistake.

    • @richarddegen6184
      @richarddegen6184 3 месяца назад

      and the DSP/bandpass and IF shift are as good or better than the DX10

  • @riottaba
    @riottaba 3 года назад

    The op interface is a right pain in the a*se so I wont be buying one!

  • @donnymazon8516
    @donnymazon8516 3 года назад

    No antenna tuner for 1,700 bucks they should put a tuner in it they can keep it I will pass I would buy a 2nd ft 891 before I buy that radio

    • @watersstanton
      @watersstanton  3 года назад +4

      There is an interbal ATU. The socket is for an optional wider range external one.

    • @donnymazon8516
      @donnymazon8516 3 года назад

      @@watersstanton okay

  • @vladimirdmitriyev5287
    @vladimirdmitriyev5287 3 года назад

    BS

  • @steverasmussen8997
    @steverasmussen8997 2 года назад

    Excellent video really enjoyed 73 WB4JVP