2024 Ultimate Robot Vacuum and Mop Comparison || Dreametech, eufy, Roborock, Narwal, and Ecovacs
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 май 2024
- I tested every flagship robotic vacuum and mop available in 2024 to figure out which one is the best.
Top Pick: Dreametech L10s Ultra
(AmazonUS): amzn.to/3IQTEzk
(AmazonCA): amzn.to/3URZx6b
(AmazonUK): amzn.to/3MBbF5K
Best Mop: Eufy S1 Pro
(Kickstarter): www.kickstarter.com/projects/...
Hightest Overall Score: Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra
(Roborock): bit.ly/4cMB2Om
Other Robotic Vacuums Tested:
Dreametech X30 Ultra: amzn.to/4axYexW
Narwal Freo X Ultra: amzn.to/4aaxWC4
Ecovacs X2 OMNI: amzn.to/3xmsxsN
*As an Amazon Affiliate I earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no cost to you*
Visit my website: www.TheSmartHomeHookUp.com
Follow me on Twitter: / thehookup1
Join me on Facebook: / 473812443269387
Support my channel directly:
Patreon: / thehookup
Music by www.BenSound.com
00:00 Introduction
00:48 Carpet Vacuuming Performance
05:07 Hard Floor Vacuuming Performance
05:54 Mopping Performance (Dirt)
07:22 Edge Mopping
09:40 Stain Smearing
09:56 Mop Lifting
11:22 Pet Hair Pickup
11:55 Long Hair Tangles
12:59 Long Term Maintenance
13:31 Auto Empty Bin Clogging
14:10 Mopping Capacity
15:37 Mop Drying and Bacteria Growth
16:23 Vacuuming Noise Levels
16:46 Dock Maintenance
17:13 Object Avoidance
18:40 Furniture and Baseboard Damage
19:18 Map Creation and No-Go Zones
20:16 App Scheduling
20:37 Privacy Issues
21:30 Alexa and Google Home
22:16 Home Assistant Integrations
22:42 Conclusions 
Наука
Lots of questions and comments about the Eufy X10 Pro OMNI. It was supposed to be included in this video but unfortunately didn't arrive on time. I've run it through the vacuuming tests with the following results:
• Carpet Pickup: 19g of 40g (47.5% pickup)
• Hard Floor Pickup: 37g of 40g (92.5% pickup)
• Auto Empty: 2g left in bin.
This would have put the X10 Pro OMNI in 5th Place for carpet pickup and tied for 5th for hard floor pickup. I won't be repeating the mopping tests because all of the mud solution needs to come from the same batch to make it a fair comparison, but it appears that in the $699 price category the L10S is still the right pick.
Thanks!
What is your overall experience with the x10 pro omni?
Do you think the mopping is comparable to the other spinning mop models? Is the navigation and obstacle avoidance comparable to the s1 pro?
I just ordered the x10 omni pro today for 600 (l10s ultra is 700). Do you think it is a good product for that price?
It's comparable to the other spinning mops, not better than the roller mop though.
@@TheHookUpwhat about the dreame l20 ultra? 👀
Wow surprising results, another reviewer ranked roborock badly, saying the changes from previous model made it worse, and obstacle avoidance was bad… while dreame seemed to be the best at obstacle avoidance… very dif results… firmware maybe?
@@Dawho99 I said the same thing. Roborock S7MaxV Ultra has better vacuuming performance than the S8 MaxV, but S8 has better object avoidance. Dreame object avoidance is definitely not better than Roborock. All firmware is completely up to date.
Finally someone who compares and tests the performance of the robots instead of just a sponsord video of the list of features. Considering that most of the robots on the list are either brand new or not yet available in my country.
Vacuum Wars is also good for this
@@chrisogrady28 I know but his reviews come months after the sales start of the robots
This! A proper comparison of new robo vacs and not just the usual paid sponsored videos. Thank you!
Rgay said the eufy S1 does seem like the best option 😕
Thank you for your feedback!❤ We strive to provide valuable and informative content to our viewers. If you have any questions about the performance or features of our product, feel free to reach out. 😘
Man, if there was a video that could convince anyone that you aren’t pushing the latest hype, this would be it… Thanks for doing all this work for us! I’ll be sticking with my L10S Ultra as well.
Would you even recommend acquiring the L10S as a first vacuum and mop robot, instead of going for any of the other robots?
Results show s1 pro is better ..
Thank you for taking the time to review our product! We appreciate your thorough assessment and valuable insights. 🤩🤩
I can not believe that some companies will charge you almost $2.000 for something that hardly does what it is supposed to do. What a waste of money. I was ready to go after the X30 Ultra, but now I'll go for the Dreame L10s Ultra, as you suggested. Thanks for your dedication and time to making this video. Saved me some $$.
…exactly my thoughts after watching this great comparison video!
Being a backer on the Eufy campaign this is a very helpful and highly appreciated comparison/review. Thank you for that.
Keep up the good work. This is one of the only trust worthy smarthome/tech channels left. Almost all other are just doing tedious sponsored infomercials now, spouting crap like “this changes everything” and “game changing” which just make me a little bit queasy.
I bought an L10 last year per your recommendation & have been very pleased. Glad to see it's still holding strong in 2024.
I got the notification that you posted this and had to stop everything and watch! Great job as always, I love the scientific approach and NO SPONSORED REVIEWS!
WOW. Insanely detailed comparison! Thank you! Although now I seem more confused on what to get! Decisions.. decisions.. decisions..
I feel like I should wait another year to see if others adopt the eufy roller mop
The issue is that in a year there will be another innovation that will be worth waiting a year for.
The only proper and fair review I could find on youtube. Thanks a lot much appreciated ❤
Holy shhhh man you are entering Project Farm Level Testing!!!!!! 👏👏👏👏 Amazing level of attention to detail! im glad you are doing the most, that way we have an independent view from Vacuum Wars (no shade)
Thank you. You are simply the best at doing in-depth reviews of these products.
Good tests. You're one of the only reviewers who noted the Ecovacs X navigation issues. I had 2 and they were both terrible at navigation and needed constant baby sitting.
OMG! This review is so incredible. Thank you for putting so much effort into making this video.
Sir, I appreciate the effort you put into this video. Drying Florida mud with a hair dryer for every single test? You're the man!
Bro, I never saw someone do a comparison like this, amazing. Thank you.
Thank you for validating my month old L10s Ultra purchase. Great content as always.
Same, got mine over Black Friday for 550. Been really good
I still can't believe how you manage to get into so much detail. Crazy. Great work Rob.
Thank you for taking the time to make such an amazing review. Trustworthy and detailed. We kept coming back to see your results and after a lot of reading other reviews we purchased the Dreamtech L10S Ultra as we felt your review was the most in depth and reliable source.
Congrats, best comparison video I have ever seen!
How I wish the Dreame X40 (with swing-out and lift corner cleaning side brush) was a part of it but it just came out a week ago in Germany.
Now THIS was the video I was exactly looking for! Unbiased and very real world. Thanks!
After researching all month this video in particular helped narrow down my final choice in a robot vac/mop for my parent’s home, which mostly consists of hard floors and no carpets. I’m definitely going for the L10S Ultra. I do love the self cleaning mop on the Eufy S1, but you can set the L10S to frequently clean pads in the app. Not to mention hand/machine wash the pads when needed and easier to replace when they wear out compared to a full sized mop roller. Filter has a large surface area so a little more resistant to clogging up with all the desert sand they get in. Being able to drive it around in the app to check on the pets and house is a big plus. Parts look readily available too!
The dedication you have and depth you go to on these videos is always astonishing. I can't imagine how much effort (and money!) goes in to each video and I can't thank you enough for it!
Immense respect for the amount of work and time you put into this video. I meaen diting the floors before each robo and cleaning between each of them to ensure accurate results. Plus real performance analysis as opposed to only feature talks.
Thank you so much for taking the time to do all that work to provide an accurate assessment. I love that you approach everything scientifically and always include security.
FANTASTIC review, as usual.
Amazing study, so thoroughly made and detailed results! Thanks a lot for this!
Great Video! I appreciate the attention to detail. This should be on everyone’s watch list!
This is an amazing test indeed! Thanks for your time and effort!
Great video, a wonderful comparison! I took my chances on the Eufy S1 before videos like this were out and got on their kickstarted campaign. I am happy with what I see with it. I am not to worried about carpet vacuuming seeing as my house is mainly vinyl flooring.
Insanely thorough analysis. Subscribing
Thanks for that SENSATIONAL test!
You doing a great job. It is levels above other reviewers. Thank you
Woooow! What a great comparison! Thank you very much! keep up the hard work.
gosh this is the most comprehensive test I have seen on youtube. Thank you.
Your reviews are really great! Thank you
This work is just pure gold!!))
Thanks for making a fair comparison instead of most RUclipsrs that just became a big infomercial as they are sell outs.
Wheel motor(s) apparently died on my Ecovacs deebot T8+ so it was time for a replacement while I try repairing the Ecovac for use elsewhere. Certified refurbished Dreame L10S Ultras with a two year warranty are only $399 at the moment. So it was a no brainer. Thank you for the thorough review!
Thanks for the honest review. It greatly appreciated! I’m still leaning towards the tested Roborock or Dreametech L20.
Really well done. You provide excellent information. Very relevant tests.
Super thorough review, nice! Got the S1 pro on kickstarter.
I pledged for the s1 pro but debating on pulling my pledge and getting the L10 not sure what I want L10 is better at vacuuming carpet but the s1 will avoid dog poop better and thats a big deal to me because I wouldn’t want it dragged through my house if my dog has an accident.
Mostly interested in the s1 mopping feature
Wow this review is incredibly thorough 😮
I love your content. Thank you! Really, I appreciate what you do. Your science background shows!
I just told my wife I'll literally buy anything you recommend. 😊
Amazing review! Thank you.
Fantastic, highly detailed video. Thanks very much for this 👍🏻
Amazing review, already looking forward to the 2025 one!
Just got an L10s Ultra and I'm glad that it's seems a good choice. Waiting for it to arrive but hopefully it seems that I won't be disappointed
Oh my god thank you so much for doing the test with a LOT of hairs!
No joke I get SO MUCH hairs captured at home
This REALLY helped me with my choice that became VERY easy
This was very useful. I have a large PVC floor without any carpets, so it needs quite a bit of mopping. Eufy Pro seems to have been a good backing at Kickstarter :) Thanks for the extensive review!!
Great video! Luv the detail thank you
Your the best smart home reviewer, hands down, Good job.
Thank u very much for this incredible review
What a great and extensive review, thanks!
Great video, thanks you for your comparision
backed the eufy s1 pro thanks to your review. hope it doesnt disappoint!
Using L10s for last few months now (6+) and don't regret it. One thing that I surprised me is how much maintenance it actually requires. I'm vacuuming and mopping almost every day, we own a dog as well. This means that every week I need to:
- clean the dock base with handheld vacuum and wet cloth
- wash the mop pads in the washing machine (I have spare ones)
- untangle hair and remove dirt residue from the brush and other elements underneath the robot
When it comes to clean and dirty water I need to replace it usually every 2-3 days. Leaving it for longer leads to unpleasant smell. The dirty water tank needs to be washed with detergent at least every 2 weeks as well.
Moreover, the original accessories are quite expensive. The detergent is prohibitively costly compared to generic vacuum robot cleaning solutions. It's worth to have several mop pads and replace them regularly. Washing in high temperature should be enough to get rid of the smell.
Great vid and not sponsored. #Salute
A very thorough assessment.. very good
Bravo just bravo!! Amazing video!! You are really good! 👍👍👍👍👍
This is the best comparison video I've seen, thank you so much! I'm very grateful
Thanks for this! I just returned the Narwhal, it was a nightmare and honestly even heart breaking experience 😅 I wish I found your video first!
What specific issues did you have? I'm really confused by what happened with the FreoX Ultra because my Narwal Freo has been pretty flawless.
Thanks for an extremely good test comparision.
Next video you could talk slightly slower with some pauses between the sentences and sections, that would make the long video less exhausting to follow, and you would have an even longer video with more payback on.
Don't worry, people will watch to the end anyway since the content is so well done.
Actually I had to mute the sound at some parts since the amount of information read up become to much.
Thanks for a great job, one of the most valid test and comparision I ever seen on RUclips.
This was fantastic thanks so much. Hope you plan on testing out the Samsung Bespoke JetBot when it comes out. Thanks again for a great review.
Love how in-depth you reviewed these and in such a better way than any kind of lab testing too. Real case scenarios is the best. Any reason why you didn't include the Roomba Combo j9+ which does vacuuming and mopping with auto empty?
In my opinion Roomba is not relevant in 2024. They haven’t innovated or improved in the last 4 years and have fallen completely behind.
I got the x10 pro omni for $599 with coupon at rollout. I love it and find it hard to believe these flagship robots are 2-3x better. I hope we continue to see more mid-level offerings as these flagship prices are way out of reach of most consumers budget.
Your videos are great as always! Just watched your latest robovac comparison thing, and honestly, I think the S10 should be added to the BEST robot of the year selection because it seems by far the most automated, and cleans the best! I mean, come on... look at the price gap! Thanks for the more in-depth, honest, and most importantly REAL content, it helps a lot.
S10 is pretty darn good. If it were just a little better with vacuuming and object avoidance it would be an easy pick over the Eufy S1 Pro. L10S Ultra remains the most powerful vacuum under $700 though.
Backed the Eufy S1 Pro on Kickstarter, so this video was a great comparison.
There has been a lot of comments on KS about the Eufy S1 Pro vacuuming levels, with Eufy themselves stating that they have changed some things, including the brush roller, and distance to floor etc. to improve it's cleaning. They even sited this channel and this review as part of the reason for the changes.
Time will tell if these changes make any difference, I hope you do anything review of the Eufy S1 Pro after it's official release.
Good work. Keep up this class comparison videos.
I don’t know why eufy is not testing himself such things.
I think the main issue in Eufy S1 Pro is that the main brush doesn't hide/rise in the mopping mode. When something is spilled on the floor, it can get into the main brush. Also the side brushes are always on when mopping, so they are smearing the liquid.
@@manaenbk Eufy S1 Pro cleans the mop on the fly, didn't you see the soy sauce test and the white a4 sheet?
@@dejedejssonI wasn't saying about the mopping system but about the main brush and side brushes. When robot is cleaning some liquid, for the first the side brushes run over it, then the main brush and finally the mopping system. This means that the side and main brushes get dirty because of this liquid, because they cannot turn off or move up.
@@manaenbk yes, exactly! You are paying attention. I hope this company is taking notes as if they are hungry for insights, the info is here and they could rise above in 2025 with some minor improvements. Listen to the people, and they will buy your automated vacuums! I was an early adopter of the Roomba (first gen) for my clean freak/always in pragmatic motion mother. I had hoped she'd take some time for herself while the vac was working away. Skip town, a trip to Aruba while her house cleaned itself. A Nancy Drew novel like she used to in her early years or her adult version of that. Something fun other than everything necessary. But alas. NOPE. She was not a fan. It was new technology and awkward like any fledging newborn taking its first steps. It had not integrated defaulted wall encounters yet. It zoomed around and hit all the incidental spots like a bumper car ramming into its neighbor. Except the sport was designed to avoid its neighbors so fun wasn't built into this design. Still, it was the first of its kind so it earned its way into the National Museum of History, but my mom's heart is not as easy of a sell. I think she sold hers in a Tag Sale.😂 In any case, I still believe, and want to own something I can take home to my home, my mom. Rooting for you Eufy, but auto vacs in general I implore you: competition is the capitalist necessity of innovation: so f'ing delight us! Here is some free UX advice: no mud, no dirt, no tangled long hair, no brush rollers so we can vac our pet-friendly rugs with glee, and for gosh darn sakes, raise your rollers so they don't inhibit the mixed use application of hybrid flooring households (carpet/rug/hard wood or similar/tile/etc) and do better on your hard floors! You could win retired hearts, even my mom's.
The test after wiping with the white cloth is great. You can see how much residue there is. top 👍🏻
It would be great if the wiping roller in the station could be cleaned with hot water
You did a great job and review…. This is way more professional than the professional
Congratulations on yet another fantastic comparison video. I truly appreciate your dedication and hard work. I remember watching your comparison video from last year, but I can't recall if the Dreame L20 was included. We initially decided on the Dreame L10 based on your video, but then Dreame released the L20, which ended up winning most comparisons by the end of 2023. I was disappointed not to see the L20 in your 2024 video, as, in my opinion and based on personal experience, it was the champion of 2023.
Additionally, for future comparison videos, it would be beneficial to include the unique mop detach function from the L20/X30 when discussing mop lifting. This feature effectively addresses the debate on how the mop can be lifted and completely eliminates the possibility of getting the carpet wet at all.
Best wishes from Australia 🎉
Mop drop was mentioned a few times, I think it’s a great feature.
for the mop drop the mopping has to finish first and then go out again for vacuum, then it's pointless to just do mopping first. If you vacuum first then you dont need this useless feature
I just bought a new L10s based on your recommendation as a gift and worried this video would make me regret that. I'm definitely not regretting it now. Thanks.
Still a great choice.
@@TheHookUp Please help! Unfortunately, I did not observe any examination of other Dreame models. What will be your ultimate choice?
Dreame (X40 Ultra, X20 Ultra, X30, X10s, L10s Pro Ultra Heat, or Roborock S8 MaxV?). If I narrow it down to two, I'm thinking of the Roborock S8 MaxV and the Dreame X20 Ultra. According to your study, X40 and S8 MaxV roborock are not excellent. Or?? So, which out of two Dreame x20 or dreame x40 ?? Carpets, hair, and all-around cleaning functions are crucial in my opinion. Thank you for such an excellent video. This final piece of input will be quite helpful. Thank you!
@@HimanshuJoshi2015 i would stick to his recommendation L10 but get the best of L10 which is the L10s Pro Ultra Heat. but it does add a 300usd additional cost to it. the L20 x30 x40 have smaller filters, which prevent suction according to the review
Awesome job bro!
I appreciate your dedication to testing sir.
Excellent video!
Appreciate this video! - No sponsored video
All i have to say is that this video is amazing. Thank you for your test and time investment. Such a good review. Like I asked last time if possible will be really cool if you could take a look at the cloud replacement open source project.
L10s supports valetudo now, but requires a special PCB to do the flashing, so I think that is a significant barrier for entry to most people.
20:32 The 30 Ultra vacuum leaving behind its mopping pads for a vacuum only run is honestly a feature I would love.
That feature was released on the L20, and I agree it’s a great one.
or you know.... vacuum before mop? most stupidly hyped feature
Thank you ! Very helpful
Love the videos and how in depth you go. Would appreciate any insight you have on the Roborock Q Revo - it’s the highest rated out of robot vacuums carried at Costco. Always looking forward to your content
Same! I am torn between a couple from this video & the QRevo
Thanks Rob for the detailed and objective comparison! Some of these vacuums are amazing and have lots of great features. But unfortunately the mandatory cloud connection is a deal breaker for me. I really don’t see any need for a vacuum to connect to the internet. The privacy and security implications can be devastating.
Amazing review! 🎉
Hello, long time follower, Thank you so much for your effort in reviewing these vacuums. I can only imagine the stress and time it takes. Please do you mind releasing your spreadsheet, or at least have it up on your website.
Thank you.
I can probably make that happen. The overview at the end with the grades has all the info for now.
@@TheHookUpThank you 😁
Sir, we have to salute you commitement and hardwork again on this one.
your reviews are so thorough and complete - thank you for making these!
This review was so helpful as I look at upgrading from my Roomba i8+. I was originally looking at the new Roborock S8 Max Ulta - the non-V version as I don't think the extra bells and whistles are worth it by adding the V on it (You can get the non-v version for $1399 if you buy direct from Roborock from 4/22 - 4/28) but this review may have sold me on the Dreamtech L10. Although, I don't NEED a new vacuum right now so perhaps 2025 may be a better time to look. Make a Dreamtech with the mopping capabilities of the Roborock (Edge mopping/Lifting) and Eufy.
Yes, I'm waiting until all the big manufacturers offer similar mop technology like the Eufy S1 Pro, maybe already at the end of the year, certainly next year.
crazy impressive testing!🤯 I hope to be this good and hardworking if ever I become a content creator near future. Watching this video I realized that mopping could actually be the best feature on a robot vac. thing is, you still need a powerful vacuum over carpet where ideally should be done at least a week. on hard floors, a weak vacuum and weak mop is all you need for daily floor maintenance(hardly visible dirt debris) which robot vacuums do well already. The eufy is taking it on another level which uses a design similar to wet vacuum mops unlike the cringey implementation of spinning rugs.
The Eufy mop is great. Switchbot S10 and Eureka J20 are also similar designs coming out this year, hopefully they will also be great.
@@TheHookUp Great! I knew the Eufy is on early adopter phase with its $1.7k price
Thank you so much for your video! So indepth, organised and easy to digest. I'm from Australia and can't see an Amazon link that's AUS? I'd definitely support you if it was available!
This is the best robot vac mop review vid I’ve seen.
Would love to see a comparison between the s1 pro and the new x40!
Wondering if the improved the carpet vacing in the x40.
But it seems like if like me you have 90% hard floors and are not too worried about edge cleaning, the s1 is the one.
Thank you
For those who prefer manual vacuums, my Rainbow has been great. I live in a small space without a lot of stuff, which can be vacuumed top to bottom in less than half an hour. A little on the pricey side, but you can get them refurbished for a little less, and they can last a long time if properly cared for.
Great video and appreciate the real world tests. For the Voice Assistant capabilities, can any of these robots follow a command to "vacuum" only or "mop" only specific rooms? My S7 MaxV only allows to "vacuum and mop" a room. Sometimes i only want to vacuum or only want to mop. Thanks in advance.
Love your videos, so helpful! I read 100s of customer reviews on Amazon, Reddit, and seller sites and they were so conflicting. Consumer digest magazines are worthless (somebody rated Bissell and Braava Jet as top moppers, how unserious). After watching your videos, I went with L10s Ultra as the best match for my needs (no carpets, no messes), which cost less than $600 with promos, and I've been so pleased and impressed with it. I'm going to keep watching! Very interested to see successors for Eufy S1 since I have a feeling that the first version is going to have too many bugs. I might still stick with spinning pads, though, because they buff old scratched-up wood floors into mirror-like shine like they were just refinished.
Glad it was helpful, and glad the L10S is working well for you!
Overall and excellent review!! The only thing that would make it better is to take your top two robots from 2023 and add them into the mix which you did kind of, on some tests.
Dreametech L10S Ultra was the top robot from 2023, it was in all the tests :)
@@TheHookUp was iRobot in your 2023 line-up? Maybe I should go find that video. But I still see iRobot as the benchmark that all others are measured against.
Great video!! Thank you very much! What about L10s Ultra vs L20 Ultra? Any recommendations?
Great video but something to take in consideration for the first time owner of a robotic vacuum is your robot doesn’t have to do a perfect run every time because you can set it up to run as much as you like every day or even twice or 3 times a day. So inevitably your floor will be clean.
Great review 👍🏾
I do wish you'd have summed this against the older vacuums as well. As you've shown, those seem to have sweet-spotted really well in many ways.
L10S was the winner of last year’s video and provides the reference for older vacuum performance.
@@TheHookUp Am I incorrect from what I saw though that a great many of those vacuums are better than this years?
@@Deveyus The S7 MaxV Ultra was better at vacuuming, but did not finish first in other areas and had pretty poor mopping performance.
Can you please tell me what's the best and cheapest projector screen i can buy for Nexigo Pj40 Gen 2 and Nebula Mars 3??
This is an exceptional analysis. It will be very interesting to see how the Migo Ascender rates in your evaluation when it is released. Thanks for such great work.
I'm also excited to see how the Ascender performs!
Nice comparison! Finally someone scientifically comparing them!
Great job, I can only wonder how mich time it took to test all of them in this detail
Thanks! This video took around 90 hours start to finish.