Can The Pokémon Manga REPLACE The Pokémon Anime?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
- Today we're gonna take another look at the Pokémon Manga becoming an Anime to really see is it a genuine possibility
Follow Me On Twitter: / vee_volt
#pokemon #pokemonadventures #pokemonanime
Thumbnail Art By x.com/SergiRomero
Music Used:
Route 1 (Unova)_ Remastered ► Pokémon Black & White Music By Zame
DREAMYARD_ Remastered ► Pokémon Black & White By Zame
Relic Castle (Remix) _ Pokémon Sun & Moon Style By Zame
OPELUCID CITY_ Black Version (Remaster) ► Pokémon Black & White By Zame
Bomberman Hero Milky Theme (House RMX) By Lil Shawty B
Pokespe Animation by kanikou_7
Honestly, I don't care if it replaces it or is just another show. i just want it animated.
SAME! I’ve been wanting to see it animated ever since I started reading it in first or second grade and saw a couple of those “Pokémon Adventures Special OP” videos (one of them I believe having Code Geass’s 「Colors」), so about 16-17 years! It would be really cool to get to see a bit more of the more mature side of Pokémon! Plus, just *imagine* what it could do for the sales of the manga from a business perspective!
No thanks
Pokemon origins was so good. What is that based on? The games??
@@papacitoloko1117 Yes. It’s based on the Red, Green, and Blue games, but also with a Slowking shown in one of the pictures of one of the previous Champions in the Hall of Fame.
@@davidspraguedragonman6479 to be honest i don't need maturity in my Pokemon Anime
Or just go watch other Anime
i don't need the Pokemon manga adventures I'm fine on my own
I’d honestly love a anime series based off the manga. Especially since it has a much more mature theme
Although, if they were to give the regular "Pokemon" anime treatment they will more than likely Censor the more mature themes
@@shelbybayer200funny enough that’s what made the early movies so good and memorable both Mewtwo’s and Lugia words of an individuals worth and the general themes are mature topics that’d be hard to find in the anime
I'd watch it just to not see Ash turned into a goofy idiot that isn't even a half decent trainer; the Anime did him so dirty.
I think the Jojo route is easily the best possibility, and I don't think having an Adventures anime run alongside Horizons would confuse people. I didn't see anyone confuse Generations, Evolutions, or Origins with the main anime. Not only that, but an anime would probably do wonders for the recognition and sales of the manga itself. Adventures is weirdly niche for it being a part of Pokemon, so anything to give the series a push would be appreciated.
Pokemon Adventures: The Animation - Part 1 The Kanto Dex Holders
- Part 2 Johto Dex Holders
So on and so forth.
Heck, they make Exclusive anime only Filler stories if they want.
As long as they don't Censor out all the mature content from the Manga
Might need to bring in the notion that the Pokemon Adventures animd would be for a the Older kids and the adult fans who still play Pokemon but love the more Mature tone the Manga has better.
They can even have the "Swearing" text from the manga being adapted into Silly Pokemon world swears.
I just want a More Mature full 60 minute series for Pokemon
@@shelbybayer200 I agree that if they adapt the manga, it needs to be as close to the original story as possible. They'd still probably change a few minor things, like the regular animals that appear in the RBG arc, but otherwise they should absolutely keep everything the same.
I think the main reason they wont do it is bc Pokemon Horizons views would more than likely drop and they're already lower bc many miss ash
If they did do it i can assure the fans would LOVE it
dude i WISH they made the manga into an anime
it would literally be peak
I would personally like to see the Pokémon Adventures be adapted into a Main Series Anime. Just imagine all of the Pokemon Adventures Merchandise such as figures of Red, Green, Blue, Yellow, Gold, Silver,Kris, Brock and Misty.
"Shut up and take my money!"
This brings me nostalgia when Maazaki Iwane posted an animation for the manga on his birthday and Satoshi Yamamoto said maybe manga into an anime might be possible in the future on twitter.
Have you seen the franchises with multiple shows running simultaneously? Two Pokémon animes can work. Just make it known they’re not connected.
Preferably by making the Adventures anime Definitively the MATURE anime
Pokemon is the highest grossing media franchise in the world surpassing Disney even after acquiring Star Wars and Marvel. They can have more than one show run concurrently just like how they could have polished their games more. With how much shovelware isekai WN adaptations come out every season, there is no shortage of animators.
Can you imagine Mappa doing Pokémon? That’d go crazy.
I could imagine it would not be worth the spending money for Pokémon company, would probably cost more than the regular anime they are making
Ruby and Sapphire final battle With Mappa level of animation will go crazy.
@@Yoshizuyuner Pokémon company is one of the richest companies out there they could do it if they wanted to, I do agree though that the way they currently do it is more profitable.
The animation wouldn't be that good because the pokemon anime puts episodes out weekly, mappa works by taking years and months to make a full season and then releasing it.
I have always wanted the Adventures manga in anime form. They can have a different studio or whatever to animate it. Pokemon Origins style would be amazing.
I'd settle for an OVA. Anything to give this manga the recognition it deserves.
Better yet an OVA SERIES
OVA 1 Kanto Saga
OVA 2 Johto
You get the idea from there.
We kinda sorta almost did though it’s mostly on the game events not the manga I’d be happy to see a new movie series about the manga
Kevin Conroy probably could’ve made a convincing Giovanni
He would have been a good Giovanni. Rest in Peace Kevin Conroy, he will always be Batman.
Maybe the pokemon franchise is actually aware of how loud of a financial success can a pokemon manga animated web series (like pokemon origins or generations) can be.
They might be just waiting for it produce it at the right time like 30th pokemon anniversary probably or at a time when maybe Liko retires? I dont know
But several anime franchises have done this in the past for example, Doraemon reanimated the manga chapter and old 1980 movie (steel troops) into a new version Doraemon : Nobita and the Winged Angels in 2010 and it was a very massive success in Japan.
Lets just hope pokemon manga gets a seasonal web series with each chapter covered.
I am not saying an animated web series based on pokemon manga will be very very successful, but atleast it will be popular for a while and sure a reasonable victory for the franchise. Thats why they havent produced it as an animation yet.
Yes please! Make this the definitive canon.
The main canon would still be the games
@@eleonorepb4565 not MastersEX or the sh!tty online animations
@@phoenixblade8315it is what it is
Yeah I would prefer to just be animated itself but just with keeping the main anime we have but I liked the idea of being a web series, it could have the audience interested in reading the Manga, and a Netflix Adaption would be fine Aswell
I think it's unlikely that Adventures will ever have an animated counterpart, but imo a Generations/Evolutions-type series is the most likely option if it were to ever happen.
I've always dreamt of Adventures getting an anime adaptation, but the longer we go without one, the less likely I think it is of happening.
I always thought of it being a long running series, but if we ended up with a web series that covers key chapters from the first 3 generations as you suggested, I'd be very happy with that as we get (arguably) the best parts of each arc animated while it still promotes the manga for people to find out the full story if they don't already know.
Also, if it's successful, they could do the next 3 Generations in the same way, and this would be the best way to do an anime now that I think of it.
I would just like it to be animated. At least just having the first three arcs getting animated.
This video reminds me of a video I watched a few weeks ago. A fandub channel made a full-blown Anime style-like opening for the series for the Gold and Silver arc of the series. Proving the fandom is still strong as well as the love for the series. We need videos like this and VeeVolts channel to blow up and show the company we love this series and its potential is not being fully utilized. Thank you for making these videos!
Honestly just want ruby and sapphire to get adapted 🥺
it's my favorite content from the franchise. i would love a faithful animation. especially through the sinnoh region.
I really believe that making an animation based on the manga would bring some new people to enjoy Adventures, even if it was, like, one episode for each arc
Can’t wait for the complete story part 4 bro
I did wish for a seasonal adaptation with a little filler to flesh things out but the netflix idea sounds good IF they dont cram a whole season in like 8 episodes. Something like generations is a hell no for me. Like red starts his journey now and next episode he raises the trophy? Are you serious?
I think the ship has sailed on this one unfortunately.
Honestly, I don’t like any of these ideas. The assumption is that it will just be a one to one recreation of all our favourite scenes. Realistically it will be a watered down version of those scenes at best, or completely rewritten plots in an attempt to 'fix' it. I don’t think anyone wants that.
There should be an anime about the pokedex holder tournament.
My head canon Red is voiced by Rika Matsumoto in JPN and Veronica Taylor in English 😅
I say straight to Blu-ray release
Considering that there have been old animes that have gotten remakes in recent years I don't think it's impossible for pokemon adventures to get a anime even if it doesn't fit with the most recent game so I could see after horizons ends them doing pokemon adventures anime the question is will the studio notice the demand for it to make it
Whole wave of card collections on Red and blue arc will be $$ though.
If there ever was an animated series based off of the manga, it would be significantly better than anything the anime has ever produced. The closest thing to it would be the animated shorts like generations or pokémon origins. In terms of storytelling animation, it would be top notch and a lot of the characters from the manga are better than any singular character from the anime
3:26 This scene makes me fall for Gold so bad! I can’t believe myself to think that Gold is that cool and handsome. However, I am sure that if Pokémon specials were to become an animation, it would be no less popular than Satoshi‘s series! I’m waiting for them to be animated.
I saw that Reddit post! I commented on it.
given that the franchise has confirmed there are multiple dimensions it'd be easy to make a series with both different characters and the same ones hell ash traveled to an alternate reality where he met another version of himself that acted completely different than he did
If we have season tackling a chapter of the manga, that would mean we have to wait longer to see Scarlet eating that sandwich.
Hell, i'd watch pokemon with red and his journey to all of the regions AND HE WILL ACHIEVE ALL OF HIS GOALS AND FULLY EVOLVE ALL OF HIS POKEMONS
I think I saw this post on the PokeSpe Reddit, knew he was cooking something
The gen 1 portion of the manga is so out there compared to the anime now. It would either need to be heavily remade or at least have changes that match the current era.
I wish it could but it won't.
Never say never 🥲
At best we'll get an Origins, Generations type series of the manga. An abridged version of the manga.
I like the idea of them being made into movies like 2 or 3 movies for the Red and Blue, 1 Movie for Yellow, 2 movies For GSC, and so on longer arcs get more into them. And released like one or two a year.
If this happens it'll break the internet 😂
If it did become an anime I'd really hope for some story changes to make the story flow better.
Honestly, the majority of the first few arcs are so good that one or two episodes each just wouldn’t cut it, they deserve more. My ideal structure would be a miniseries where each arc gets ten episodes at most, and if that wasn’t possible with the budget they have, then five could work well enough as long as they had the usual 20+ minute length that the main series gets.
As much as I think it'd be cool for it to be animated, I doubt it would happen. Green uses a Porygon on his team, which can probably never see the light of day on television again after the seizure episode. And then there's all of the Ground-type moves that would have to be censored due to all of the earthquakes that happen in Japan.
Now, if they wanted to make some animated shorts in the vein of Generations, that might be more feasible.
The Pokémon company would never allow it. Too many mature themes.
You sound like Pokespe is NGE levels of mature. It's not bad compared to nowadays shonens.
Yea it is coz its feels like anime not cartoon like anime
if they put the Manga Characters in the Show that would be cool, I Especially like to see Leaf in the show.
She's called Green or Blue in the manga
Depending on Which version
Japanese text Blue
English version Green
@@shelbybayer200 Oh ok Thank you
Maybe, if they change the story a bit, added all of the pokemon, had references to Ash Ketchum and have the classic plot, it could happen
As for voice actors
I do got one at least
Robbie Daymond as Red
He's got a few really good characters under his belt with amazing Acting at that.
He's Goro Akechi from Person 5
And
Spider-Man/Peter Parker in one of the previous Spider-Man cartoons
Easy answer yes and while Ash is the anime “counterpart” to Red their stories are vastly different so the experience will be different and I definitely want to see Brendan and May and Calem and Serena’s stories animated properly they’re probably my favorite stories of the Pokémon manga so far
I think pokemon adventure would fit the more typical 12/24 episode season approach than every week year round like Ash's and Liko's anime
While i never read the Pokemon Adventures manga (but i really want to do) i would like if the Netflix reboot is an adaptation of the manga instead of a rerash of the anime or the games.
I just want a Pokemon adventure anime
Personally i'd like to see a full adaption.
The big problem is the Yellow arc because it portrays Lance and the Kanto Elite Four as straight up villains, which fundamentally contradicts their more streamlined characterizations in other media. A mini-series covering just the best moments would confuse those unfamiliar with the source material, as other non-protag characters are also portrayed differently (some in not-so-appropriate ways). Green especially would have to go through some major changes by toning down her femme fatale tendencies and other overtly sexualized instances.
Really, the real big issue is that the original arcs were able to get away with a lot of stuff back in the 90s that just won't be tolerated today. The Lavender Tower zombies is the best example, as nowadays you can't just decapitate a Pokemon on a children's show. And yes, children will be watching this purely because of brand recognition, no matter what platform its on or how it gets promoted. Some may even sit down with their parents expecting another fun time with pokepals, only to get caught off guard by a Psyduck's skin melting off or an Arbok getting slashed in half. If you take out all those gruesome details, then what you're left with is the second episode of Pokemon Origins, which is not only redundant but also defeats the purpose of making such a show in the first place. The edginess is a big selling point of the manga, even if it isn't really there as much as some fans exaggerate it to be.
At the end of the day, Pokemon's big focus has been and always will be the games. Every other storytelling medium is just an auxiliary means of expanding the brand, each free to do with the games' content as they will. And of all those auxiliaries, the manga is arguably the most niche of them all. There have been manga adaptations of the anime in the past because the anime is more recognizable and therefore warrants the occasional (and always short-lived) experimental adaptation. But the manga itself---whichever one you're talking about because Adventures is only the most talked about one---is rarely ever advertised and has a much smaller fanbase.
A special music video is the best we can hope for that this point. But commercially, there's no incentive.
Exactly
But, that's what makes Pocket Monsters Special SPECIAL
It's not the same Media
Hell, Sabrina, Lt Surge and Koga are freaking evil in the manga until Team Rocket disbands originally
Pokemon Adventures SHOULDN'T be like the regular anime
To me it NEEDS the mature tone and themes to say
This isn't the Kid's anime
This is for the older fans (Teens mostly)
In fact, Pokespe's fanbase is not much smaller. It's just that there are relatively few compared to other Pokemon media. It's sales even entered the top 100 Japanese mangas (More than 30 million copies sold internationally). Some of its popular characters were even trending on Japanese Twitter on their birthday. Its popularity also led French publishers to ask if they could introduce it to France, and let VIZ decided to introduce it to the US again, where it is now being publish steadily. Pokespe is less well-known simply because it's not animated, while if it were another work(manga/light novel) with the same score, it would be animated. And many shounen manga adapted into anime have undergone proper censored, Pokespe can be treated accordingly.
They really had a missed opportunity…this new Pokémon horizons honestly could’ve just been the old manga turned into the anime, which honestly should have happened
Pokémon adventures deserves better
The manga has some of the best storytelling in the entire franchise and I would love to see it animated at some point!
My studio pick is Kyoto animation
They made a silent voice and miss kobayashi's dragon maid
I hope not, because I still want some form of Pokemon anime.
i don’t think it will sadly :(. i really really hope im wrong and it does happen, I think fans just need to be as loud as we can haha
I'd love adapted Pokemon Adventures
With the More mature themes
Specifically a series for the older fans
With the Regular anime being more for kids
Pokemon Adventures: The Animation
Can be more PG13 as opposed to The TVY7 rating given to the Regular anime
I agree Pokespe should not replace the anime but it deserves a highlights webseries to make people invested in reading.
Pokemon Manga fans would love to see this happen.
The Manga was not supposed to replace the anime but the manga is amazing i think this should be animated
(Sorry for the bad grammar)
Pokémon horizon is amazing show than 2019. But I would love Pokemon Adventure becoming an Anime!
Can it have a anime? Of course. Can it replace the first series? HELL NO. Not only it doesn't have enough content to last as long or be as profitable as the original series, the ideia that they killed the 20+ series to give adventures his own anime, would make the pokemon manga become the most hated piece of pokemon media in history.
We need a shounen pokemon anime and the closest we got to that is pokemon xy and z
I know they wouldn't.....but having Adventures adopted as anime I'll be able to die peacefully, literally one of my dying wish
If you give Studio Trigger the rights to the Pokemon Manga, it's Pokeover for Horizons.
I always thought SOMETHING has to happen with the pokemon adventure manga, even if they make film adaptations in the style of detective pikachu I'd be happy, but I just want to see SOMETHING done 😩
I realy hope it
It would be so awesome
I would support the Pocket Monster Special OVAs existing.
If Pokémon decides not to animate the manga (which I don't think it ever will) it would be interesting if a different studio could get permission to do so. Also unlikely thou
I would like to see a trilogy of movies about the Red Blue, and Green arc (also each character would be voiced over by Chris pratt)
I can see Johnny Yong Bosch voicing Red, Yuri Lowenthal voicing Blue, Christina Vee voicing Green and Christine Marie Cabanos voicing Yellow.
@@Eric-gp3hi nah, let chris pratt voice em all
I Love Blue and Yuri Lowenthal
That would be great ❤️
@@Eric-gp3hi
Yeah, Yuri definitely would be my pick for Blue
Christina Vee as Blue....... Ok, That just freaking fits
Though, my pick for Red would be Robbie Daymond
@@thatoneaxolotlguy9969
No, that's just boring
The voices will just sound like Chris Pratt trying to SOUND like them.
He works for Mario but ONLY because he makes it work
I just can't Hear Chris Pratt's Voice from Red's mouth
I would think Red would sound more Arrogant and Hot headed
Not calm and collected
Pokemon have books? 😮
i hear two options: main stream anime, and short few episodes.
why not just do short episodes in a main stream format that only does a couple chapters at a time or so?
like 8-10 min episodes that air like main stream animes but not the full length of main stream animes.
Yes, the manga should replace the main anime! Plus, it would follow the games better!
I wish they could've just adapted the mangas instead of starting Pokemon Bland after concluding Ash's journey, at last. The biggest problem I have with the Pokemon anime is the severe lack of any and all tension. The monotonous Pokemon Horizons showed promise of having tension with the Explorers being a real threat to the unexperienced Liko, but then the writers chickened out and handed her an easy out with a powerful Gary stu like Friede swooping in to babysit her, stifling all the tension. Of course, they just HAD to give the Gary-Stu the extremely overrated Charizard, as if it wasn't bad enough the mascot was forced down our throats while also being Gary-Stued.
The writers really don't understand it's not just any Pikachu fans fell in love with, it's Ash's Pikachu. You can't just throw any random Pikachu at us and expect him to have the same impact, especially since the Gary-Stu Pikachu has had none of the struggle and character development that made Ash's Pikachu so iconic.
Captain Pikachu feels incredibly cheap. Words can't express how much I despise his character. It feels his sole role is for the writers to go, "Hey, look! It's Captain Pikachu! Check out that aura!" It feels cheap and undeserved.
The series would be all the better if the Rising Bland Tacklers never entered the picture and had Liko just escape the Explorers through her own wits & cunning. Liko having to flee the Explorers each time would lend her a resourcefulness that would truly make her a compelling protagonist. We could've gotten an inverse of Team Rocket where instead of the villains disguising themselves to trick Ash & co, she has to cleverly disguise herself to give the Explorers the slip, motivating her to grow stronger with every close call.
She can even recruit Dot & Roy & even a weak Pikachu that grows with her to form her own crew that'll eventually go head-to-head with the villains.
That would've been way more fun than the trio just being babysat by uninteresting 2-D adult characters.
I would prefer if the whole series got animated into different seasons :)
Pretty sure they could have made a pokemon adventures anime after the adventure with ash Was over but now that we have pokemon horizons i dont think we can get one
I’ve always said a Pokémon Adventures anime would be one of the best anime’s ever made and I always will
Why not both? More pokemon is always good
Replace it? No, nor would I personally want it to. Its own series? Maybe, likely as a short series like what we’ve been getting.
Honestly it sounds interesting but realistically it would just all depend on how they go about adaptating it and im with the last part u said on how it shouldn't be followed exactly considering the manga has shown in detail of pokemon and kids dying on the manga along with a mass genocide also for some reason theres occasional nudity. Seeing as how pokemon's main target audience is 10 year olds it would be a really bad look but i do wanna see the other characters that u can play in the games but have never seen in the anime since we got to see serena, and may.
I definitely thought Netflix
Gamers/Anime only pokemon gonna be so confusing when they found out half of the cast in the game/anime characters turn evil in the manga 💀
It is really weird if you think about it.
Normally the anime comes after the manga is done or after the manga has been going on for quite a while.
But the pokemon manga and the pokemon anime are to completely different stories.
Why didn't the manga follow the anime or vise versa?
I feel like the only way we could get the pokemon manga animated, is for the pokemon show to have a complete reboot where it follows manga canon instead of anime only canon.
Uh
Dragonball, Naruto, One Peice, Bleach were all Manga first
So was Yu-Gi-Oh, Sailor Moon
Hell, HyperDimension Neptunia was a GAME first before it got an Anime OR a Manga for that matter
@@shelbybayer200
What is weird is that pokemon is one series I know where the anime and the manga are two completely different stories even though they started around the same time.
It is really weird.
Heck if we follow normal source material logic.
Then the manga looks more canon than the anime because the manga is more related to the games then the anime is.
When compared the source material of the games, the anime looks like a spin-off with a oc main character instead of the actual story.
I'd love to see adventures get animated and be geared more towards teens/adults, I get that pokemon is aimed at children, but the adventures manga is definitely not for children, not with all the d3ath in it, pokemon and human alike, but even if it just becomes a webseries, I'd love to see it happen eventually
I feel yes cause People who were following Ash have quit the Series well majority
Ok My Boy Ash I Still Love You But I Want The Anime To Be Replaced By The Pokemon Adcentures Anime Please.
If it does get animated then some scenes from the manga will surely be censored for it
Thought of making my own Pokémon comic series. New protagonists, new antagonist, Old protagonists (Gen 1-5)
Good luck with it 🫡
@@VeeVolt ah thx :D
@@VeeVolt finished season 1. Moving onto season 2
Where can I read your comic ?
I'm quite curious
@@shelbybayer200 uhhh….its on my channel…
It actually should by this point in certain respects. In regards to the portrayal of some characters, for instance.
Whatever we get (if we get anything at all), I’d be THRILLED, since I’ve been waiting over a decade and a half for something like any of these (it’s probably my most wanted anime project other than a Soul Eater reboot that’s like Hellsing Ultimate or Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, where they reboot the series but tell the complete story)! I remember in first or second grade watching all these great animated fan videos set to various anime OPs! I would absolutely ADORE getting to see some of the more mature moments in Pokémon history animated! And if anyone wants an idea of what some of a Pokémon Adventures anime could look like, I’ll link a short animation of what one of the Pokémon head animators, Misaaki Iwane, did a few years back: ruclips.net/video/KfKQTnx9T34/видео.htmlsi=k7CTXuDMZ2w1Lq3I
Pokemon adventures is perfect for an anime they can milk it for a while too with all the arcs and different Protagonist but if they did it probably be after horizons
Make two different distinctly DIFFERENT series with different studios
One studio does the Kid's Anime (The Current one) the studio that is already making it work on this one.
While they have a Studio known to tell more mature stories but still make it at least good for kids to watch might be an even better idea.
The Studios that work on Yu-Gi-Oh
Toei Animation could be hired to make the manga an Anime.
Any of these ideas could work
You could even have an easy airing time
Pokemon the Series can be more so a Saturday morning style series
While Pokemon Adventures: the Animation
Could be more of an anime you'd see air on Toonami or something
I want it so baddddd
yess it can the very first time i read the manga it was 10000x better than the anime
It should but it won't