AtlasOS vs ReviOS vs Tiny11 - Which is the Best Custom Windows 11?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 дек 2023
- AtlasOS vs ReviOS vs Tiny11 - Which is the Best Custom Windows 11 OS for Gaming? Today we find out for ourselves...
LIKE and SUBSCRIBE if you're new! Hope you guys all enjoy :)
In today's video I compare AtlasOS vs ReviOs vs Tiny11 and see which one is the best! I recently tried out the NEW Atlas OS with Windows 11 support which I was impressed by so today I am going to compare it to other operating systems lots of people have been telling me to check out.
Lots of people use AtlasOS thanks to my videos on it but is it the best option out there? we're going to be finding out in this video on my Low-End PC
I also answer come questions a lot of you had in my last video: The NEW AtlasOS For Windows 11 - Best Custom Windows Experience? all OS featured are Optimised versions of Windows with minimal background Processes, Reduced latency and will help improve our FPS and performance on Minecraft, Playbooks used to install Atlas and Revi are open source and Tiny11 can be built yourself using the Tiny11 builder and its installed slightly different to other OS that I've featured on my channel
All operating systems are custom versions of Windows 11 which optimise Windows settings, removes all bloatware from the OS and removes privacy intrusive telemetry services from Microsoft.
The specs of the PC I'm using to try these:
Intel Core i5 4460 CPU, 8GB DDR3 RAM, GTX 1060, 500GB SSD
Links:
AtlasOS: atlasos.net
ReviOS: www.revi.cc/revios/download/
Tiny11: archive.org/details/tiny11-2311
My Socials:
X: / xnotrodan
Discord: / discord
Instagram: / notrodanyt
Tiktok: tiktok.com/notrodanyt
───────────────────────────────
I do not own the music in this video
┇258k┇
Thanks for watching!
- 𝓝.𝓭 
Игры
3:45 the difference in startup between w11 stock and Atlas might be because Atlas desables quick startup that doesn't let the system turn on and off properly and completely, it functions almost like the "hibernate" function that saves the image of the active system as is to the disque and restores it on startup.
I have disabled quick start-up/hidden hibernate in my Windows settings and it takes significantly longer to turn on.
I heard is also lighter on old pc
Yes, Fast Startup and "Sign-in Info" are toggled off in Atlas.
The reasoning behind is because Windows doesn't actually restart every time and can create instability over time.
@@griffin1366 To add to that, if Windows installation actually damaged and your OS are password protected, getting the data back from it are kinda impossible.
If Fast Startup are turned off, at least we can rescue the data via Linux live USB.
Next time you should test all OSs in the same world and looking to the exact same area in Minecraft, that way the FPS won't fluctuate between all OSs, like it wasn't fair for ReviOS coz there were many trees and vegetation around while on atlas it's almost just the sky with some sand, and looking at the sky gives more FPS...
It was pretty fair. Tiny 11 os is Windows 11 but naked. Of course it would win 💯 I have two twin laptops currently one is on Atlas and the other Tiny11. Isn't much of a difference in day- to day except the ram take up. Tiny 11 even has community support
Windows X - Lite is better
yeah
@@-coldheartcentral-9696 Tiny11 is basically stock though. It has a few pre-installed things disabled.
Interesting comparison! I appreciate the detailed breakdown of each OS's performance and features. It's helpful for anyone considering a switch. Keep up the great content!
AtlasOS 0:42
ReviOS 6:29
Tiny11 10:37
Thank you!
your more usefull than the creator
Thank you!
So which one is better?
Which one is everyone using?
@@davebassi7340 They about the same. I'm using ReviOS and I really enjoying. Try it and see if you like it.
Keep up the good work I haven't seen someone do it on a REAL computer. Thank you because I want to go back to windows because Linux is unsupported in a lot of things. I turned off my adblocker for this video.
Wow thanks a lot, glad you found it helpful
AtlasOS is the best os, i installed it on a core 2 duo laptop and performance increased by ~30%
Me too bro, glad iam not the only one with garbage core 2 duo, atlas os definitely boosted my computer
All customOS’s steal info bro
@@metal9s27 wdym
And atlas is is very stable on my core 2 duo
@@metal9s27 are u fr?
Gave AtlasOS a try. Fresh SSD, win10pro, 22H2.
After some tweaking with all drivers installed I'm at 39 Processes, 1.6 gigs of ram usage, around 5 seconds boot time after post.
I'm my estimation, it's a new machine. Insanely fast compared to before.
AtlasOS is impressive, but I had to put in many hours to slimline win10 further to my liking.
you use any debloater script like chris titus or similar?
@@nghile6821 I also ran O&O Shutup, then used Autoruns to check what was left. Removed some startup item relating to videocard drivers such as their tools panels. I want those on manual, and only use it on troublesome games, which is rare. Then I manually double checked the services disabling items such as braveupdate services and other useless things. I don't like autoupdates especially if it messes my settings or disables plugins to the point I have to go get new versions.
Side note I also disabled services relating to the "store" and also services relating to "networking sharing", printing etc. Currently I'm running 29 windows processes, and windows runs fine so far. I'm currently debugging to see what is broken, but so far so good. It was lower but I had to re-enable a few services, example disabling AppXSVC killed access to some settings panels like THEMES. I kept the clipboard running, also oddly turning off Windows Event Log service will mess things up, keep that on.
I decided I would run another vanilla windows in virtualization just in case. I thought qbittorrent might have trouble with ports or working because of everything I disabled but nope, it works fine.
what tweaks did you do?
Anyone seeing this, keep in mind win11 is a bit more bloated compared to win10. Lowest I've gotten mine without major breakage or disabling core functionality is 48 processes, while that same number (or lower) is pretty trivial on win10.
Bro, I really admire what you did on this video, Which is benchmarking these OSs on a low-end PC.
Because it's the low-end ones who really show a big difference when It comes to optimized windows.
Thanks I downloaded revi os and its an absoloute beast i am now having 1 percent cpu on amd a4 4400 or smth like tht earlier in win 10 without doing anything i got 35 percent
It would be interesting to see a comparison of gaming OSes based on meringue Linux BazziteOS vs Nobara vs Chimera vs PopOS
Plz keep doing these videos with other os as well
interesting, I know about Tiny 11 but not heard of the others, so nice run through review thanks
Does revi OS come with all the visual studio stuff for games? If not, where can I get the latest package i need. Do i need all of them? thanks
I installed on a virtual machine Windows 10 Ghost SpectreOS and then used cris tech tips windows 10 debloater removing everything i could, and got it down to a around 700/800mb ram and 52 processes
Maybe a more fair comparison would be a reboot instead when trying to check the speed. Great video anyway.
really good and well produced video! amazing job!!!
Thank you, I took my time with this one so I'm glad you enjoyed it
Hi, just wanted to offer some constructive criticism in the hopes of helping out with improving the content.
This video works very well in terms of giving a general overview of each custom OS and showing the average user experience for people with low-end PCs. It is clearly *not* a benchmark (I saw some people getting mad about that, even though the video is clearly not one), but the Task Manager analysis might be inaccurate, and even misleading in some cases. There's many different factors that can help measure performance difference between each test, such as latency, 1% lows, and so on. The point of this and many other videos on this channel is increasing performance, so proper benchmarks could've helped here, and could also attract a different audience or keep the current one more engaged.
That's all, keep up the good work, and I hope your channel does well.
Thank you so much for taking the time to offer your constructive criticism. It's great to hear that the video gave a good overview of the custom OS options. I'll definitely work on improving the accuracy of the Task Manager analysis and consider incorporating proper benchmarks in future videos.
@NotroDan yeah the minecraft test could of been good if it was the same world and doing the exact same things on each OS, like saving a demo file or something, as the test was innacurate as atlasOS world was just sand and sky compared to tons of trees etc in ReviOS
turn off the computer completely without saving the current state to disk...
3:33 Atlas might have fast startup disabled by default, though base win11 has it enabled
Yes. But i couldn't find a way to enable it.
I really like Ghost Spectre OS. It has almost no reinstalled apps, and you don’t even need to install a browser, you can just use a command line tool built in
Bro your comparison between minecraft in stock and atlas is not fair because the world in stock windows is such a small world like just this world has just two lands but in atlas u are doing the test on full world so basically atlas use more of the requirements (I'm sorry for bad english😅)
People time saving: windows 11 or windows 11 pro only can upgraded if the pc is 5 years old
did your background music turn into a filter/flange at the end? no music but voice is pitched to music? or I gotta go back to the doctors?
Great video, I just think It would have been better if you choose 1 minecraft seed for all your benchmarking
I have a similar system, with the hd4600 igpu. The way I fixed those massive stutters on new versions was install Linux mint.
I have medium-high end pc and even tho my motherboard manufacturer says windows 11 ready, it performs better on Linux (Fedora) than on Windows 10 or 11
Linux might be the next thing to test then :)
@NotroDan please cover Nobara or Garuda or pop os 😁
How to install any of them without OS activation? I want to check it on VM before switch on working host. I don't want to pay for licence I don't need
I use revios for stability and compatability
I have an 4090 and 7950x so im not doing it really for performance
Bro I saw your name on Minecraft I thought I could subscribe lol
slow boot on atlas and revi is because of the default settings with hibernation and fast boot disabled on both of em',
wanna compare boot speed
restart all of them and count
You are really so good notro
You helped me a lot to play with higher fps
Thanks and nice vid legend :)
im first
@@retrowave9922idc
Thank you @IIDreamy
don't worry, there's no difference in the FPS between those "OS"es. The dude does not know how to measure them correctly
Good vid as always
Thanks!
Is my files and games safe if i transfer from stock windows 11 (ASUS laptop) into AtlasOS? Will my warranty be voided?
6gb ram ddr3
intel hd (r)
2 gen
rn using windows 10
upgrading to ssd
what should i use
for the GPU 5:58
it is good when it's fully loaded because otherwise you lose FPS
Atlas don't use the full potential from the GPU
Notrodan bro how did you make your own client can you tell that or can you make a video of that 😅....... please......😅
nice seeing this comparison... for me just stay on wind10 ur not missing out on anything in 11 matter fact ur being forced to change a lot of things to make it look like 10 or 7 . plus don't get fomo where u see ur process above 120 it's normal to have them running in the background doing things stopping processes often ends up breaking things like functionality and scaling issues i noticed that every time i make a christech titus deblaot my workflows gets laggy for some reason i just stay on windows 10 default settings for me download the iso open rufus sett the default and when the pop up open asking you with check boxes what u want say remove privacy skip questions and make local pc user (offline account ) that's my 2 cents here i feel we get stuck in our own ways trying to make things what are not just get a beefy pc 32 ram minimum that 8 ram is not gona cut it in 2024 i gave 9 things open in the same time most of the time
The fps difference between mc versions is totally normal. 1.20 is feature packed where as 1.8.9 has less features to drive. :)
You should have used all of their ISO files on internet archive. These playbook versions are inferior compared to the real ISO files which were actual ISO edits done before install. The only reason they stopped releasing the ISO files is due to Microsoft sending out cease and desist letters to all of these groups. telling them that making ISOs without express permission was forbidden. (threatened with lawsuits). The actual ISO files give much better performance and are streamlined. They were forced to use Playbook because they had no other choice. the only option was to stop doing releases all together or just use the ISO. and the reason that Tiny is still an ISO is because the main developer of that is in Russia and he is outside of the sanctions of the US legal system, they wont ever stop him from releasing his files in ISO format.
do you have the link to the atlas iso? which one should i choose?
bro, he just told you - "internet archive"@@138b32n
bro how do i get iso version of revios.
@@sachinmajotra9665there is a link in Reddit bro Im downloading it now
Thanks !!!!
@NatroDan Try Ghost Spectre Custom Windows .iso Also From Next Time, It Will Be A Great Addition To The Comparison
Does it improve Laptop battery life?
You should make a new comparison that includes ChrisTitusTech's WinUtil made MicroWin ISO.
Interesting I will have a look at it
serious question: if you use tiny11 as base and customize it with Atlas, Revi or both what would happen?
Wait that’s crazy I gotta try that
@@MicahDaRhulerwhat happened bro tell me
@@rudrakshart6996I haven’t tried yet as I literally reset my windows a week ago, I’m gonna need to find or buy a drive, or maybe use vm. I’ll keep you posted tho
u can use Revi OS tweak instead AtlasOS
how did you disable "Virtualization" on task manager cpu section in 2:23 , i can't find it on my BIOS settings even tho i update to lasst version ~
disabling virtualization doesn't impact on performance. if you disable it, you can't play games on emulator like bluestacks or gameloop. also, you can't use virtual machines (virtualbox, vmware, hyper-v etc.), wsa and wsl.
yea i dont use any virtualizations apps at all, so its not big deal for me if i disable it
@@md.rafsanislam2929
Can you do a test for Windows 11 X-Lite Optimum
can you show instalation guide for atlas/revios ?
Ghost spectre 11 is also a great os, i run it in a 7 year old intel pentium 4gb ram laptop. The os only uses 30% ram usage at startup.
I was able to boot my laptop in 23 seconds which used to take 1 minutes and 30 seconds on the original windows 11.
If you want to update try ghost spectre 11 too.
Can you still play/use all software and games you normally can when using a costum windows11?
Obviously.
If not why would anybody use it if softwares don't work
Yes, you can, but keep in mind that some may not work and u have to install other libraries and vcredist etc
I don't know why but when I install atlas os on windows 11 they asking me to put the key windows one and it doesn't install
Hello Sir I've installed Atlas OS and want to enable feature updates any method
If you were to install Atlas with secondary drives would those drives get wiped? Follow up question, would it be safe to take out the secondary drives and then plug them back in after the install?
it doesn't wipe any drive or anything
@@vengie3029 thank you so much for the reply, was hoping for the best and thankfully it was :)
My CPU Prozesses show me 99 im installed Altas After all the win 11Updates, is it normal ? And Im Use Steam to
Bro among these os, which on is best for gaming
how did you make your cpu speed over than the base speed? ive got the same cpu
I'm not sure honestly the PC may of come overclocked
does anyone know if i install a different atlasos or revios do i have to activate windows again
I use now Atlas OS, clean install, Mod it, use it perfect.
Dont need anything else now.
Can I remove the OS in my 2018 hp envy laptop and install this?
you should use the same seed next time, either way, like!
I tried to but for some reason when changing versions the worlds got regenerated :/
Should have used the same map seed for Mincraft FPS tests
Hey man, can you make microwin iso from christitus tool and show its statistics as well compare it too
Yep its on my list to check out!
The Best MOD OS is by far Ghost Spectre ! Build 23H2 22631.3085 Update 5 ! Nothing beats it !
you should try Ghost Spectre Windows 11 Superlite best of all the windows you mention
lol ghost spectre is just stock windows with removed bloat
@@franisagod so is tiny
@@kidpoker9408 nah the thing is tiny 11 is also very small in size but not good in optimisation while ghost is small and optimsed but not more than atlas or revi and also ghost lost its presence because various security issue found but still people use it
are there any home editions in these custom os
is it possible to install tiny 11 and install revi os and atlas os on it just combine all of it
3:54 it aslo depends on the ssd!
Still i cant configure which is the best
Where you find these?
now you should compare to ghost spectre lite
Dan I have a problem every windows I try I don't have audio input devices/drivers, I can't install them because it gives error and legacy software doesn't work. What I can do?!
PC or Laptop?
Yo is Windows 11 open source or something? How do guys make these custom ones?
this was good can u do a video for win 10
kinda unfair comparison you used different hard drives the hard drive speed affects it too
Fair enough criticism, they were the only SSDs I have at the time. But I'm sure either way there isn't too much startup time difference between them
Man that Revision Tool makes Revi more tempting.
Try Ghost Spectre and compare it
Installed AtlasOS about 3 times and each time BSOD appears.Installed ReviOS and that boots 👍
which is better?
Which Is better from gaming? Atlas or Rev?
Any news about Notro Client
Im instal Revi on Tiny.😊
Ive found Ghost Spectre to be the best
I just want the wallpaper from ReviOS
4:30 "60FPS, actually good for integrated graphics" New intel iris xe is performing well with 1000+ fps in 1.20.2 on 16 chunks loading. I am using arch linux.
Does stock windows 11 has hibernation enabled ? (Fast startup)
I don't believe so, it could be that the SSDs used were not the same which affected this result
What about Windows X-Lite 'Optimum 11 Pro' v3?
can we install AtlasOS after tiny11 ?
Why is revios discontinued?
Atalas works better for me than the others
fps comparison using mincraft with different scenes on every test very 1 to 1 comparison and genius of you. couldn't even use a single player game that you can at least load a save a be in the same scene.
i have tiny 11 with rev playbook tweaks applied
I Wish atlas os intall allows check if notifications are turn off or on i was force fix that by hand
Tiny 11 is too good for others man
U haven’t tried XOS which is better than all of them
How do yk theyre safe and dont cobtain viruses
so which so i download?
time to switch to one of these now that 11 has ada
i use tiny11 because its the easiest to setup and its the fastest.
I use 8 gb ram and tiny11 makes me feel like im using 32 gb ram.
I used to use windows 10 on the pc im using rn but now im using tiny11 i hated everything about windows 10 but loved everything about windows 11.
tiny11 is just a faster version of windows 11 and theres nothing else that new.
I really hoped tiny11 was the fastest.
Bro your device support win11 official ?
no
Placebo.
Tiny11 is virtually stock but with a few changes, so pre-installed stuff removed.
Anyone knows why some old programs like the old Win 7 games collection (spider solitaire etc...) doesn't work in Tiny 11? They just not starting without any errors. Probably they needs some deps which are ripped off, but still can't understand which one...
they are meant to run on Windows 7
older OS use direct 3D Just grab some files from Windows XP system and put them into the system 32. That's what I did,
Also compatibility mode helps.
Or try looking for unofficial patches.
Tiny11 disables IE, Media player etc. which is probably why.
Is it safe to install atlasOS?
What ago it Ghost Spectre?
how do u get windows 11 on a i5 4th gen
hmmm the best is Ghost Spectre for me
Atlas has a custom power plan out of the box that’s why it wins in fps, which the other ones don’t provide, Atlas is the winner