Blowing in the wind
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 окт 2021
- Όταν έγραψε το «Blowing in the wind», ο Μπομπ Ντύλαν ήταν μόνο 21 ετών. Άλλοι νεαροί στην ηλικία του πάθαιναν υστερία όταν άκουγαν τον Έλβις, τον Λίτλ Ρίτσαρντ, τον Καρλ Πέρκινς. Εκείνος εύρισκε το ροκ εν‘ ρολ ρηχό. Η αλήθεια βρισκόταν, πίστευε, στο λαϊκό τραγούδι. Τον Γούντυ Γκάθρι είχε για πρότυπο. Κι από τον Ουαλό ποιητή Ντύλαν Τόμας δανείστηκε το όνομα και έγινε από Ρόμπερτ Τσίμερμαν, ο διάσημος Μπομπ Ντύλαν. Στην ταραγμένη δεκαετία τού ‘60, τα ανθρώπινα δικαιώματα, η ελευθερία, η ειρήνη, ήταν από τις πρώτες έγνοιες τού Μπομπ Ντύλαν. Ο ψυχρός πόλεμος καλά κρατούσε ακόμη. Έβραζε κι ο πόλεμος τού Βιετνάμ. Σύντομα το Blowing in the wind θα ταυτιζόταν με το αντιπολεμικό κίνημα, στο οποίο πρωταγωνιστούσαν με τα τραγούδια τους ο Μπομπ, ο Φιλ Όκς, η Τζόαν Μπαέζ. Στο βίντεο που θα δείτε, το τρίο Peter, Paul and Mary τραγουδά «Την απάντηση φίλε μου την παίρνει μαζί του ο άνεμος». Απόσπασμα από εκπομπή τού BBC τού 1965. Από τους τρείς, μόνο η Mary Travers (1936-2009) δεν είναι πια εδώ. Οι άλλοι δύο είναι. Ο Peter Yarrow/Peter και ο Noel Stookey/Paul.
Кино
![MORTAL KOMBAT 1 - KOMBAT PACK 2 REVEAL TRAILER!! [REACTION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Mi2M58zEQVc/mqdefault.jpg)
A generation of singers that spoke out for human rights.Proud to have been part of that era😍😍😍😍😍
where are they now
Sometimes it feels like we lost and the Bad guys have taken over.
feels like that today
I was just a little girl back then l but loved these songs.Listening to this in 2024 gives me goosebumps.
Nothing has changed.
Nothing at all.
4561s my number keep the beautifull flag ov peace flying high in the friedly sky
Where has beautiful music like this gone ??? Today it's rubbish like life in general !!!!
N we let it hapen trajic
This song, and "Where have all the flowers gone"--- bring tears to my eyes--- as a Vietnam veteran, it strikes home in so many ways--RIP Walter Soutar--my friend and fellow soldier.
Americal Division and the 101 Airborne 1968-1969.....People today have no idea how precious this democracy is and what price has been paid for it. They have no idea how hard it would be to get it back if they lose it.....Well, my friend, we made it back but we are still dodging and weaving.
Hand salute and thank you.
@@lurking0death
As a daughter of a military veteran whose father fought in WWII and the Korean and Vietnam wars, your words speak volumes about our democracy and today's people. Thank you for serving our country.
@@lurking0death are you calling this ploutocracy a democracy?
With all due respect and as we can see the world today, Vietnam wars were not made for the democracy
So glad you made it back
66 years old and as I recall to my 7 year old eyes and ears Mary Travers and this song were the most beautiful things ever...still are.
This song will be played and sung as long as human beings are around. A song that represents an era of time. Beautiful and timeless.
contradiction ! you're correct saying this song will be played and sung "as long as human beings are around". But how can it be that it "represents an era of time" ?????? don't get overwhelmed by emotion, which is perfectly understood. you're right with the 1st statement.
@@monoecumsemper Representing an era of time is a concept that can't really be explained. When you get older, you may understand. God bless.
Mary death was a great. Loss to great group of greatest singer's
The 60's could have ascended the human race to a higher vibe due to the music of the era, but the generals and politicians sold out for wars to keep us enslaved for another 60 years. Now is the harvest going on and the generals and politicians and their handlers will get the noose they deserve.
@@monoecumsemper One of my favorites growing up but unfortunately it is forgotten by most now as these horrible times are progressing. I had faith in humankind in the sixties but the times have changed like Dylan said.
I still listening to this old song together with "Where have all the flowers gone". Their message remain stuck in my mind and heart ❤️. I'm 70 years old now.
Beautiful song. I'm 68 years old now. I'm sad that we haven't made more progress. Still blowing in the wind.
It's worse, w're blowing in a Huracane
Perdón por mí Inglés
I understand why people are risking everything to immigrate here.
@@davidnelson7565 it's truly a sad situation
But there's good things in the world too and i hope more people can find those things
I do too. Imagine what you would do if the situation was reversed. Thank you for the reply
We marched , prayed and organized to this song! Never let the anti-democratic forces win--never!
Yes, I totally agree! Living as a West-German in East Germany since ten years, I know what I am talking about! It will take two to three more generations to overcome dictatorship in people's heads! So sad!
60 years on and it still brings chills, goosebumps, and your heart in your throat…..quality prevails…🙏❤️🎶🎭
A timeless song.
Amen ☁️🎺👼💒🙏🌹✨
As a Vietnam veteran who volunteered to serve and supported our cause, I still enjoy this song decades later.
This next generation I'm that generation your next generation it matter humongously
😊
Thank you for your service 💛
I'm Japanese
It's my favorite song I've heard for 50 years
I was part of that era. I'm 70 now and there is still war everywhere. Will I see peace before my time has come?
If you know Jesus as your Saviour my friend you will have peace for eternity God bless you
Peace is a fiction that people believe only because of the occasional brief gaps between wars.
No war under Reagan and Trump😊. 78 born in Mill Valley CA
@@Geezerelli Born in Maastricht, the Netherlands.
I'm 47 and I love it..She was a very beautiful woman. God bless USA.
Always knew this song first heard in the 60s had questions that still have not been answered to this day in 2022.
The answer is still blowing in the wind. Mankind has grown more violent, bitter, mean, rude, hateful, jealous, disrespectful, arrogant, two face, narcissistic, selfish, greedy, sinful, on and on and on. The answer blowing in the wind will be revealed soon as mankind destroys itself. Good luck filling up your gas hog land yacht's at $9 a gallon gas coming soon in summer! USA TITANIC now sinking fast!
The answer is all these wars, conflicts, hardships, etc., experienced everywhere were no accident. The "invisible government" were pulling the strings during all those time up until now. Most will not understand (yet), but will eventually. Most won't be able to handle the truth, but it has to be revealed anyway. Sooner than you think.
I have heard... it is said and it must be done... hmmm...
Can't be answered. Evil is always present. I hate that, too. It's Biblical.
You're absolutely right about that.
My goodness ❤❤❤❤ lm a 66yr old Australian and remember such great memories and music ❤
Music memories..❤ same age as u. Trying not to cry.. 😮 too many strikes
I'm a 66-year-old busker and perform this most days. Neither gone nor forgotten.
66 year old American here with similar emotions and memories. Keep making memories as long as we can.
4561 s my number i hav a grandson hendrix yup life is good time is the only thief that never gets caught peace
Sóc una catalana de 62 anys i tinc els mateixos sentiments, tristor per veure que el món no ha millorat i molt bons records d'aquesta música tant bonica.😊
If Bob Dylan had written only one song, this one would have been sufficient.
How many roads must a man walk down
Before you call him a man?
How many seas must a white dove sail
Before she sleeps in the sand?
How many times must the cannonballs fly
Before they're forever banned?
The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind
The answer is blowin' in the wind
How many years must a mountain exist
Before it is washed to the sea?
How many years can some people exist
Before they're allowed to be free?
How many times can a man turn his head
And pretend that he just doesn't see?
The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind
The answer is blowin' in the wind
How many times must a man look up
Before he can see the sky?
How many ears must one man have
Before he can hear people cry?
How many deaths will it take 'til he knows
That too many people have died?
The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind
The answer is blowin' in the wind
thanks Bob
Look at how young Mary looks. Saw her in concert in the 6th grade. Her vocal stylings were so powerful, it moved me to tears. I was only 11, but she moved me to the core. ❤
Hello. how are you doing over there?
You are a true music lover to be moved like that.
And boy, wasn't she a hottie! I meant that in good taste. Beauty and talent - gold!
@@phineasp.quimby3162 Thank you
Very much. CORP Robert Isidore.
@@matt01506 Thank you so much,..
Robert.
When I was 16 my best friend and I used to go to the roller rink, there was a guy in his early 20’s and he looked exactly like Gary Puckett
I wonder how many times I listened to this song when I was a teenager in the 60’s!
its writen in tha wind the anser wy friend
Linda, You and I must be almost the same age. I graduated HS in 1960
Brings back memories. I was 3 months in Groote Schuur hospital in Cape Town following a motorbike accident in 1977. A young nurse who could sing snd play guitar used to sing this to us off duty. Beautiful person all round.
Rest in Peace... Mary! Thanks for so many years of great music and thanks Bob for writing the song.
One of my favorite songs I am 72 years old and it is very memorable to me as I am in the Autumn my life now and it is still relevant
It is a beautiful rendition, timeless and relevant now today. We see it everywhere today just like we did as young men and women in the turbulent 1960s. Peter's opening words prophetic.
I was teenager in the 60s and the Vietnam War that took many Youngs life of our country. That song was really tighten to those events that we lived in that era.
A great musical masterpiece. After all these years the answer is STILL blowing in the wind...but mankind's greed for power and materialistic wealth seems to mask the truth. Sad, but we live in hope.
Yes Ringo Star,I second the motion.
Thank you.
The Truth is Jesus...
mankind is fine........it's the 1% elitists seeking power and materialistic wealth that is the problem.
U got it right//
I l9ved this music in the early 60's as a high school student.
Mary ... was just beautiful 😍 ❤
Thank you, Bob, for one of the greatest Folk Songs, "Blowing in the wind". And I believe, the most beautiful versions sung by Peter, Paul and Mary and Joan Baez! I love them all!
I agree with you from Japan.🌻
❤
I couldn't agree with you more. Greetings from Oz.
De BOB DYLAN
It's not Joan Baez there
Such a brilliant stripped back to basics heartfelt version of this song. Modern day performers take note…two acoustic guitars and three great voices…that’s it !
Don't forget Dick Kniss, the stand up bass player.
@@jimthep9411 0ĺ
And no cell phones needing to "record" what is already being recorded.... People really present!
I love how gently they sing. Lovely!
And the lyrics can actually be HEARD AND UNDERSTOOD above the musical accompaniment! Try THAT with today's ear blasting noise!
THIS SONGS SAYS IT ALL. WE ALL WILL STAND BEFORE GOD WHEN WE DIE AND WILL BE JUDGED EACH ACCORDING TO HIS WORKS,HERE ON EARTH. THERE WILL BE NO TALKING OR DEAL MAKING " THERE WILL BE WEEPING AND GNASHING OF TEETH"!
A frightening scenario; but a reality.
Still brings tears to my eyes at 68 yrs old. Ex Boardng School , Mil Vet, watching my friends fade away. Alas age is cruel
Same here, served 20yrs, now 69 and my class of 76 thinning out so quickly. Music and poetry my escape, didn't need substance or Alchohol to get a high. Adrenaline does that still.
For me too, but maybe it takes death to truly appreciate life.
Bob Dylan hit it right on the head with this song. I wish we had listened to what he was saying, not just the words.
Yes, back then singers could actually sing. Beautiful.
I was a single mother who raised a son and when I hear this song, tears come to my eyes…my son is a professor at a well-known college and is 56 years old.
*They gave their heart to the music and audience and to this day this song brings tears to my eyes* 🥰
A song you can be drawn into by its purity and truth,love the way it’s sung,and love the power it portrays ❤
This song is so far ahead of it's time.
Another timeless classic that continues to be relevant with all the insanity going on in the world - “How Many Times…” is the question that nobody seems to be able to answer…
True Donald but its putin its all the same
Ahead of their time. Never more apt than right now in 2022. Fantastic song for all generations
Yes so it is
just a few notes in and i'm humming the tune... singing along, one of the best of my youth, the lyrics are timeless and the performance is straight to the heart...
Loved hearing it again
Fabuloso!!!!!!
@@jw97404 l
5
Alyssa ficktgut
I've always loved this folk song.
@@pamelemonroe5769 I loved the 1960s folk music when it first came out even though I was still in elementary school. I knew there was something special about it. Eventually rock and pop took over but I always preferred the folk music of the early-mid 1960s.
This poetry truly deserved a Nobel
Bob Dylan, America's poet.and writer of this song was awarded the literature Nobel prize in 2016,for his life achievement in American folk poetry.
From a special moment in history and must be celebrated. Definately deserved a Nobel
Well said
Shovanlal tienes toda la razón es un grato poema y por ello el trabajo de Bob Dylan es maravilloso un fuerte abrazo desde peña alta Tláhuac CDMX Luis Carbajal pro de tenis 2023. Enero 28.
I sat in the rain 2 or 3 different summers at the Carter Barren amphitheater to hear them sing and play every time the rain let off. They were the voice of my teens and the spirit of the 60s. Dylan was the poet.
Hello. how are you doing over there?
Life is a multi colored spectrum, we don't understand the true value of our existence until we are old. I love all who are positive
I had a substitute teacher that sung this for us in elementary school, never forgot about him
A hymn that does not lose its validity. poetry in its purest form
AMEN !!!
And that's why Bob Dylan deserved the Nobel Prize, and why he's the greatest songwriter who ever lived.
One of the best song of all time ever!
I love This song ... like many songs in The 1960s and 1970s ... so deep with simple lyrics ... gentle rhythm ... my Era
I first heard this song back in 1969 and thought about it and I now listen to it about twice a year or so and it still makes me stop and think about these questions. As long as people want what others have the cannon balls will continue to fly. The questions are ones that should be answered, but people just do not think.
One of the most impactful songs of my teen years! I've asked these questions throughout the years and today the answer I've found is in Jesus Christ! He knows and I have peace!
Thank you for sharing our Lord with everyone as the only path to peace. Perhaps someone reading your comment might come to know Him as we do. He is the way, the truth and the life. If more people opened their hearts to Him there would be less senseless death and no more wars. In this world we will have tribulation but He has overcome the world and in Him we can be changed and violence will cease. The answer my friend is no longer blowing in the wind, it is in Jesus Christ, the Savior of the world. Come everyone! Time is short!
@@ellenpearl6466 your reply is 100% right, God bless all my brothers and sisters in Christ Jesus from all around the world;
Amen
Where have all the flowers gone is probably my favorite song
Harmony, meaning and great song writing,,, the 70s grew up in the 50s and encompassed both worlds
One of my favorite folk songs from the early 1960s from one of my favorite folk groups of all time; Peter, Paul and Mary.
Greatest folk band ever, God rest peter, Paul and Mary
A era in music that's timeless
It won't be the same for another century
@@alanparedes2034 never
Remembering my Sweet past. This song touchs always my soul.
Hey how are you doing today?
I was so young ,I loved this song. I just knew someday soon we'd have the answers...I'm 70 the answer is still blowing in the wind.
Hello how are you doing today…?
Everyone should be made to listen to this song! I get chills every time I hear it.
Amen!!!!
@@greg2976 especially the russki
This and the last 3 generations should here music like this .they wouldn't understand music played from the heart and soul like these and few others like this group Noan Baez especially ❤
So true
Returns me to an earlier era when we tried to make a better world. We're still trying.
Thanks, Brings back a lot of memories...
A Golden song from a Golden time where the only thing that mattered was finding peace within yourself...
Judith was a gift She battled through so much physical hardship but yet reward us all with her music She found her home with The Seekers and they toured the world playing on all the stages Judith told her family she would do as a young girl Just a beautiful human being she was She ll be very much missed There video they made in the song Turn Turn Turn is wonderful Judith Journey with us is over now but on her new Journey she ll sing to the angels free of pain The soul never dies and Judith’s voice will continue among as all Good Night Judith It was truly our honor
I was blessed enough to have listened to this music while very young and still listen to it at 66 years.
I remember these days, watching them. Amazing.
Hey how are you doing today?
Sixty years later we are still asking the same questions and still no answers. And even less freedom.
This song reminds me so much of my daddy every time I listen to folk music from the 60s and early 70s . Im only 34 but road trips and sad times my dad would play this n i now understand why
the best trio ever i listen all thetime and never had Eyxaristoume giorgo Papastefanou gia tismousikes epiloges sas
Me trae muchos recuerdos y paz,gracias de corazón.
Great song
Can i listen first please
The answer my friend is blowing in the wind x
For me, this is the best cover of Blowin in the wind. The first record was just with Peter, Paul and Mary, a wonderful threesome. I love this song and this interpretation.💖💖💖💖
Not to be a perv, but maybe "trio" is a better word than "threesome" in this situation. lol
@@dcc1974 😊😊Hello, Doc! I am not very expert in English, so I used trio, because threesome... sometimes can be... perv....😍😍
Bob Dylan deserved the Nobel Prize.
I grew up on the music of the Fifties n Seventies ….and the Nostalgia brings tears to sooth my heart n my being ……..Bijoy K Roy from India
Stellar performance of a timeless piece of music with a powerful message. ❤
Hello Anne.. How are you doing today?
And people will still be asking these questions for millenia; until the next astroid hits.
What a beautiful voice nice memories still listening I love this song. How are you Anna ?
Agree
Wonderful words
i grew up in 80's but my father use to play this and i like the song so much, i even like it when i understand the meaning of lyrics , love this.same question i got in my soul.☺️,
A Big Reminder For Today And tomorrow!!!😢😢😢😢
This song deserves a very high rating. It is one of best songs to be produced by a singer.
When I was in the 5th grade in the late 60s our music teacher was a a true to the core hippy! She taught us all the protest songs from Dylan to the Kingston Trio. I remember we went to a nursing home to sing to the folks ( all the protest songs we learned) I don't think the WW2 vet's liked our teachers politics rubbed in their faces. I do agree as a veteran myself that that was wrong of her but I loved her anyway and I still dig these old songs!
I joined the USA when I was 18 and did intel. Went for my BSN on GI bill and transitioned from Warrant Officer to 2LT. Made Major in the AF but only recently have I come to understand the anti-War movement. I also do not think Snowden and Assange are traitors because they revealed the illegal doings of the swamp.
@@xanaduladylara I agree for sure on the Snowden thing, he really did take a huge chance exposing the dirty little secrets.
Well hell Thisolddog, LUV it that you had a true Hippiechick for a teacher! Protest tunes were right for those times, dontchaknow... you guys did just fine!
@@ArborsguyTX indeed my friend, indeed!
Objecting to fruitless imperialistic actions and having our troops killed in not lack of support for our soldiers.
Such beautiful harmony by three great artists ❤
Loved Peter Paul and Mary!! Folk music was the best!!!
This song still breaks my heart. Nothing has changed. 😢
My God she was beautiful.on top of that masters of their art
History starts and ends. For good or for ill, what part have you played? For Eternity your choice has everlasting consequences.
Born in the 50's and loved this group!
Peace now! 🕊🙏💖
Same here, This is when we had real Music.
Me too........life goes soooo fast.... be well.
PPM played at Gustavus Adolphus College St Peter, Ann in the mid sixties. It was AMAZING. Peter and Paul stayed the night in St Peter. I and a couple frat brothers took Mary to MPLS to catch a flight home. I will never forget!!!!!
My husband loves this group ❤️ 💕 💗 😍
Just a beautiful song! Always loved it. Nothing beats good music = Oldies!!!
I heard this haunting song, when I was around six. The year was around 1964.
Since then & now listen to this soothing lullaby, it restores the soul of everyone, in these difficult times & happenings !!!
Everyone believe in your God & his son Jesus Christ, they will keep us safe.
Kevin Phoenix
Imposible olvidar esta canción mobstruos
I love Peter Paul and Mary ! Rest in peace Mary !
I actually knew someone who named her triplets Peter, Paul and Mary !! True story !!
After listening to them that's what I was reeling& feeling hope someone understands what I'm saying because it was difficult to express my feeling and put them to words life takes action not words that's why we need what moves us into action like music doess
The vision of Dylan converted into music defies description-a genius.
One of my most favorite singers!! Classic music that we won't see again!
Hey how are you doing today?
The trio created such a beautiful sound!
If you miss the train I’m on, you will see that I have gone….Does anyone know which Peter, Paul, and Mary song those words are from ? It’s a very beautiful song from the 1960’s.
@@laurencejones8977 “500 Miles”
Such a beautiful song & so very relevant right now.
Can someone tell me the nationality / language of the person posting? I've been studying Ukranian & it looks similar, but some characters are not on the Ukranian keyboard.
Thank You and greetings from Germany !!!
Peter,Paul&Mary💖🕺👫🌟🤩
Great!🎼🎵🎸🎤📀🎧🎥👍👏
From Hong Kong🙋♀️🌏💝🌺🥰
Hello. how are you doing over there?
First time i heard the song i was not 20 years old now im 76 and still listening to it
Interesting History of a song and it's performers from a time in the past ! Wonderful song !!!!!!
Any question why Dylan was awarded the Nobel Prize for literature?
I was hoping he would win the Nobel for 10 years before he did.
We watched them perform in one of the stores in Illinois in 1993. We were in the front and they were so appreciative of our presence.
Was in 3rd class when i forst heard this loved it then still do at 60
81, and still very relevant. Written by Bob Dylan. So Many Groups have sung Dylan's songs. That's why he received the Nobel Prize. But Dylan wrote so many other songs. Rolling Stone, Mr. Tambourine Man, Desolation Row, etc. The last poet that could compare was Shakespeare in a different century.
I will never forget them singing this Song at Festival Hall in Brisbane. I feel it was an honour to be in the presence of Brilliance. Them and Bob Dylans Song combining.
Hey how are you doing today?
What awesome, incredible and beautiful voices and harmony that God has gifted these people with! It just cannot be more beautiful!
Hello. how are you doing over there?
@@stefandieter4044 Heartfelt Thanks! There's something so beautiful that comes to my heart everytime I hear your song; which to me is a simple answer. Namely "The answer to all questions are found in Jesus Christ alone." The answers are not always for me to know but His answers are always there & they come in His time and in His ways as He only knows & holds my destiny in His Hands. God continue to bless you & keep you in His care. Love, Lynn
@@lynnhilgendorff3337 Amen. where are you from?
@@stefandieter4044 Actually my message (so, I thought) was going to Peter, Paul & Mary Group, but something went wrong. I'm from L'Ange Gardien, Quebec.
@@lynnhilgendorff3337 I live in San Francisco california, do you enjoy You Tube?
Anche il vento cesserebbe di soffiare sentendovi cantare..e ascolterebbe in silenzio...❤
Época dos verdadeiros talentos e música de verdade