Why Nal se Jal Mission is a Modi 2.0 idea that worked. Winners & losers among states, some surprises
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 июл 2024
- #NalSeJal
Modi government's 'Nal se Jal' has been a landmark project since 2019. Shekhar Gupta looks at the present status of the project and its implementation throughout India. Where does this ambitious project stand and how does it explain Modi's staggering popularity. Episode 903
Brought to you by @KiaInd
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the full report here: jalshakti-ddws.gov.in/sites/d...
Watch ‘How India Voted: Making Sense of the 2019 General Election - Shekhar Gupta’ here : • How India Voted: Makin...
Read ‘In India’s Water-Stressed Villages, Modi Seeks a Tap for Every Home’ here: www.nytimes.com/2021/12/21/wo...
Read all our ground reports about ‘Nal Se Jal’ here: theprint.in/tag/nal-se-jal/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
![Veeze - F.A.F (ft. Rylo Rodriguez) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7hlz2S2GmIY/mqdefault.jpg)
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RUclips channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ruclips.net/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
Is there a way to pay yearly membership for the print RUclips channel.
Chattisgarh is going back if you see the map.
Shekar ji Kerala is not done well because almost 80% there own well because we get alot of rain we have ground water all year around but government has put in all the infrastructure like it connected all the villages and town's with pipes and all but like for example there is pipe and infrastructure in my area but like for 10 house only 1 or 2 use this water and we don't use it our home to but if want to we can just call them take connection its simple we just need connect pipe and meter with existing system underground
1 lakh 42 thousand crore rupees spend on nal se jal scheme,
Pappu be like - "ये तो कुछ भी नहीं
in manmohan singh's UPA 2 , itni value ka to sirf Scam hi hota tha..." 🤣
@@Shaan887infact True bro
My ancestral village is in naxal affected region and this water issue is solved by this scheme. The best thing is that the pumps are powered by solar panels. We got paved roads in 2014 before general election and after UPA we got electricity and water in NDA rule.
I think this is the story of many villages in Bihar as well, including mine.
@@AbhishekKumar-tv8qy as fellow Bihari I can vouch for it.
It's remarkable what can be done.
What is still pending is large scale Industrialisation in the state. So that educated and hard working men and women don't have to leave home.
I'm from Jharkhand. Things have changed after 2013, before 2013 only a government school was in my village because of 'sarv shiksha abhiyaan' now we have electricity, paved roads and water. My village was in a remote area now it doesn't seem remote.
@@shubhamkumar6689 I remember that people with motorcycles would not venture outside the village after dark.
With road network and rural electrification. The change is now remarkable, with mobility nearly 24 hours a day.
My only issue with Bihar government is the lack of focus on bringing industries to the state. They have done all the hard work. By improving law and order, rural electrification and building road network.
Now, the government has to encourage industry.
@@pratyushojha unemployment is a major problem in India, especially in Northern and eastern States.
I am from Haryana, I can vouch for it that the progress in Infrastructure and sanitation has been remarkable. Mr Rakesh Jhunjhunwala has been saying for many years now that the progress in drinking water facilities is a gift to the nation and the efforts put into it must be appreciated.
Also toilet and banking
But in haryana every billage had water vonnection since 1990s
Haryana has now 100% tapwater supply
I am from Bangalore. Our gardener was telling us about how this scheme helped his home in rural Karnataka. Most homes in his village did not have tap water, and they used to travel 4-5kms every day to fetch water back to their homes.
Really unfortunate that after 70+ years of independence we are still talking about basic necessities.
Kudos to Modi for this fast paced implementation.
Today I am writing these comments at 04.22 in the morning. It’s cold but I can’t stop myself for writing.
I have tears in my eyes and it gives me goosebumps when I listen to this story of the success of the nal se jal scheme! Something is working in my otherwise chaotic country! Some change is coming in the lives of the unreported millions who live in the rural hinterlands! The ladies are being relieved of the drudgery of fetching potable water from distant sources! It’s a miracle! A change is happening on the ground for anybody to see and check!
Believe me ……if the nal se jal scheme can deliver what it promises….. the 2024 elections are already in Modijis bag! The silent majority will speak when it matters and deliver the gaddi to those who deliver!
I’m from bihar. Atleast I can verify that the data seems pretty correct for my state. My village has tap water connection in each & every home. I was even surprised when I visited my village 2years back. I live in Bangalore. Even electricity is better than ever in bihar. I have acknowledged around 20 hrs of electricity in my village. Certainly thanks to modi govt
Let us make village and city with the same facilities. Modi is doing that
Bhai bhul mat jana support karna bjp ko ane wale time me
I am from Bihar and my village is in Rohtas district. This pandemic gave me the opportunity to travel to my village after 15 long years and I was quite impressed with the development done in the village. The most surprising was smooth road till the house door, Electricity almost 22 hours and tap water in every household. Also the street light and telecom towers with proper 4G internet. Kudos to the government for the execution on ground.
Bro as u r in Bangalore. Can u speak kannada?
@@nknkannadiga9742 No, I can’t.
I m from rural himachal pradesh and one of the beneficiary of this scheme. The whole village have there personal connections now thanks to the government ❤️
Make sure they vote for double engine bjp
Hmne to 2 lgva rkhe
Say thank you Modi.
One thing we must all acknowledge about Modi is that there is no confusion in his thought process. He is amazingly good in execution. If you look at his speeches on Independence day or his party's manifesto, you will hardly find any areas where he has not delivered.
Execution is poor. Prooflies in demonitisation, GST implementation, labour code implementation an much more. Areas not delivered: doubling farmers income, 5 trillion dollar economy, uniform civil code and much more
@@vaibhavtambade3287 bro do you think without farm reforms you can double farmer income?? Can't. I want them to do that in state level. Northern farmer earn more then a southern farmer and this inequality has to erase.
And I support UCC. Covid just destroyed the flow of reforms.
@@vaibhavtambade3287 Don't you aware of latest news. GST is breaking records. One thing you need is patience. Keep patience and see upcoming changes. BJP bring things silently implement it slowly and make outstanding changes. Whatever you are talking about mst be fulfilled. It's not modi government but people of india is making true in the name of atmanirbhar and sabka sath sabka vikas by modi govt (BJP ideology).
@@ChoCoMoCo69 Covid is helpful to. This accelerates our coutries atmanirbhar ambition, improves healthcare. Only thing that gone wrong is price/inflamation.
@@alokprakash2017 Agree that covid helps on ground level like water, electricity and houses. Simply cuz these are practical reforms unlike labour or Farm reforms.
I really appreciate what Modi has done for the poorest of the poor.. Gas connection, water, housing, electricity.. Basic necessity which were never given for last 70 years... He knows for a nation to develop, you have to give basics to the poor..
Lie.. Promotional work
Gas connections were freely and cheaply given together with a subsidy. Now price has gone up,
.no subsidy is forthcoming and many have given up the gas connections
Don't want to pay ehh? Are you below poverty line?
@@mnbiar3760 no need to subsidize Pakistan 🤣
These direct benefits is why , BJP keeps winning. Plus devlopment, defence , open market.
Open market works but They don't do enough of Open market
Don't agree with the "open market" thing you said. BJP is still a socialist party to a great extent
@@nandi7772 well most Indians still have a socialist mindset. For them privatization and open market is selling the country. India was not sold till 2014 why was so much poverty still prevalent lol
@@mizisawesome8442 but they have done a lot in that aspect , can't turn India into china in just 7 years. The whole system needs to be fixed , mindsets need to be changed
Open market idea may work in favour of Bjp in Gujarat Maharashtra, Karnataka etc, but it will severely damage bjp's vote in up,Bihar,wb etc.
I am from rural Muzaffarpur (Bihar) and it's indeed true that the most part of the rural area is now being provided with tap water. However, the whole project is marred with corruption as one would expect; even though the work has been largely executed through Panchayti Raj Institutions.
One of the reasons that Bihar has done well on this count is because the State govt had already started the same scheme under the ambitious project of Mr Nitish Kumar "Saat Nischay-1". Therefore, when it was reinforced with Central government support since 2019, by and large it worked well and is on the verge of universal coverage.
Ayy my man, from which area brother?
I have lived nearly 6 years there, near Neem chowk.
@@tejamaihunmarkidharhai774 That's the urban Muzaffarpur 😊 near Aghoria chowk...right?
Agreed! I'm from Samastipur and we get potable tab water twice a day thanks to nal se jal scheme.
@@curiouscase Haan bhai, kaha se ho tum ?
Are bhai. I am from bairiya, Muz. Where are you from in rural muz, curious case
I have observed this scheme being successfully completed in deep interior villages of Bihar...Had been to Village "Chorhar" on banks of river Kosi(Near Naugachia).. Every Household has tap water supply... There are small clusters in villages where borewell is installed and Large tanks are installed. One responsible person is given the charge of refilling the overhead tank twice a day. In case there is some mechanical work required, the panchayat is informed who further inform the BDO to take up the matter... Great Governance Displayed...Kudos
This is what people living in urban region don't understand about the BJP work. I am from a village in bihar, let me tell you we never worried or worry about economy either in Congress or BJP period. But obviously, BJP has changed our life style a lot. In fact, for us, it's a party for individual growth.
BJP is doing so good for India. I am so depressed seeing this. I am going to go and vote for Yogi and bring him to power again to ease my pain.
Get friends to feel the pain too 😂😂
*impressed
😂😂😂
I was in my village in Bihar 2 weeks ago. We got a tap in our home it's legit.
Just 3 years ago we got formal electrification (all houses have meter now).
How a simple idea is made to work for all I don't understand why they blame , government being communal. It's narrative built by Lutyens media.
What I appreciate about Gujarat is that it is one of the driest regions in the country with rainfall far less than the national average yet, it has managed to keep itself on water sufficient list. It also has a big portion of its total area as desert, both that and kutch. This is because of efforts by both govt and people.
Toilet/Bijli/Pani/Direct transfer etc - all basic necessities for human life in all corners.. toughest of projects to implement but least appreciated otherwise - just because these are basic necessities!
75th year.. someone had to make it happen - Congratulations.. where it is due
My village in Northeast got the connection, Since we are the most ignored region. If we are getting it, the scheme is working
Though percentage is less but we can see establishment of pipeline and other stuff
Same here in odisha too.. my village is just near the bengal border. Just a few years ago people of my village got toilets and tap water connection..... I was surprised since I live in the capital and was not even aware that there were problems such as these in present times.
Let's BE HONEST. Water, electricity, sanitation, and cooking gas are BASIC NECESSITIES that should have been given a long time back. A post-2014, Narendra Modi wasn't supposed to do it. CONGRESS NEEDS A DEEP INTROSPECTION AS TO WHAT THEY ACTUALLY ACHIEVED FOR THE POOR.
Congress what people to depend on them not empower them
Congres divide and rule. Continued where British left off
@@Gappasappa So does BJP and every other party.
Congress never cared about Indians. They were busy lining their own pockets!
Slogans of Garibi Hatao. Thats it.
The example of Gujarat is very apt. My relatives posted in Gujarat also bought these Narmada Bonds. Add to my surprise they encased Rs50k for only Rs3k. It turned out to be a best investment where you are also doing something good for the society. Excellent scheme. That what makes politicians worth remembering. Thanks.
Narmada water scheme was not a bjp govt initiative
@@shernagandhy8547 have I mentioned any party here ?
This too proves how good the TMC govt is!! Didi's ultra hatred for BJP is proving to be a disaster for the common poor people here in Bengal. This is why most of the central funded schemes have not reached here to the masses and for this ego of Mamata the common people are here suffering. May GOD give some wisdom to all those who voted for didi..!!
My paternal village is Belahri (this area is just as rural as Bihar can get) in Buxar district and my maternal village is Nanho in Rohtas district. I asked my parents about this tap thing and I was shocked to know that tap were installed 2-3 years ago. Every household has 5000lt-10000 sintex tanks.
In bihar it's mukhyamantri nal jal yogna so does in telengana bhagirath project.
Modi hai to mumkin hai
Tap water to everyone house is part of nitish kumar flagship scheme saat nischay
Great job! Of course it leaves the field open for Kejriwal to announce free water for all in the next elections!
I am from Bihar, and they have really done well at tap water and electricity. Kudos to Modi.
Nitish Kumar started Nal se Jal scheme in 2015 way before Modi Nal se Jal . He also needs some acknowledgement
@@AjeetKumar-qe7hm 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 wo sab dhakosla hai... Khatam kon karta hai wo important hai
@@AjeetKumar-qe7hm that's why Bihar was in orange category till 2019 (4yrs by your claims) and jumped to dark blue in just 2 yrs.
After tis episode i can die peacefully that journalism is back in safe and patriotic hands.
Completely true. Fact based coverage.
I'm from a rural area in Northern Bihar and I agree with the findings. There are still a lot more loopholes, but at least a Govt did something.
My professor in Panjab University & Columnist of the Print, Mr. Rajiv Lochan was one of those experts who suggested Jal Jeevan Mission long time ago in his work "Jal Swaraj" which was taken positively and actioned upon by the govt.
Wow! If it weren't for your professor, no one would have figured out that tap water to every household would be a great idea! FACE PALM
@@omnicurious2949 😂😂
@@omnicurious2949 Goals of tap water & full household water connectivity have always been there. What govt falters at is realising how poor its own policy objectives ,missed targets and processes are. Often policies are introduced for the sake of introducing new policies. Effort in that book in 2009 has been to highlight those positives as well as flaws & suggest in the case of Maharashtra and its different areas. Just see another example : govt started with IRDP from 1980 went upto 2000 . Like a mad dog drained 1000s of crores into the scheme(like giving loans to poor people without education & monitoring) and in the end turned out all that had been lost - only 16% of the target population ever made an effort to come out of poverty . That's how bad the potential of a bad policy design/implementation is thanks to a Bureaucracy with a colonial mindset with closed eyes & ears & leaders with no vision & not bothering either
@ Indeed. The sort of socialism that has been there for the last 70 years is elitist - with the bureaucratic elite having near the monopoly of advice, squarely even of implementation & what not. The leadership hardly bothered about collaboration with the people & almost all talk of citizen-centric administration remain on the Planning Commission papers. Also, an information system was just too poor(an example I just gave for another scheme in @Omni Curious reply & many more) . Some sort of an effort(with results on the ground) is happening since 2014 to correct them & COVID just doubled those efforts . We can see a good multi-stakeholder collaboration & better information systems just like the ones Shekhar described above..
@@omnicurious2949 , actually I have been suggested this "Jal Swarajya" book many times by different people.
Quite popular but I haven't read yet.🙁
I am from Bihar and In my village every homes have tap water. No need to cross checking and it got completed 1 year ago.
Btw i am not in support of BJP on some policies. But yeah it's true that this is the first time when the poor people are really getting things done. In my district in west UP we got new highways and will be getting a new railway station with more tracks and platforms and probably can get high speed rail network with delhi (which i am quite excited abt) and from nearby districts now time is just 1/4th approx of wht it used to be earlier. Even in the village where my mother is a govt. teacher has got pakka roads for the first time. I hope the govt. Spend more on infra and particularly to border areas.
Vote bjp
And I also want govt to make nairmala sitaraman out and put finance ministry to such guy like gadkari ji. I really look at him like awe how any politician has such an in-depth research abt building infra and all its economics behind it.
@@akshatgoel2174 no no no Nirmala is doing a great job. Probably the best finance minister we’ve had in a long time. If you think the pli scheme is good then realize it wouldn’t have happened without her.
@@Motivation-qf5gg exactly, finance ministry is not easy job. You will hate gadkari as well once he is heading it. Infact, Madam sitharaman has handled it best possible in current scenario.
@@akshatgoel2174 Looking at the all time high inflation in US in last 40 year, we're very fortunate that our government did not print cash during pandemic and did not put money in the hands of people for Demand Pull.
Despite the fact that there was immense pressure from Imminent economists like of Nobel prize winner Abhijeet Banerjee, Raghuram Rajan and P. Chidambaram etc. last year to do the same.
This would have been literally like nuking the economy.
Unpopular opinion is, Nirmala Tai and RBI handled it well. Still to be seen, whether we can sustain this growth for next half decade or not. Every economy go through cycle, it can never grow at 4% forever, neither it can grow at 10% forever.
Currently Inflation in India is on rise due to supply chain disruption because of Covid but still it is low in comparison to pre-2014. So no issue on current inflation
I belong from a village Kot in district Pauri, Uttarakhand which has been in news for quite a time for ghost villages. Roads have barely made it to the end of the village. But this scheme has reached there and I've seen it in action!
Lingwal ji I am also from Pauri (gram sabha Dhandri ) and yes we do have tap water and roads linked to our village now. Though we used to get natural water from our dhara/pandera. But still the scheme is doing wonders in villages.
Several factors leading to Telangana’s stupendous success are
* states own scheme (mission Bhagiratha )in tandem with Center funds
*large investment in lift irrigation (kaleshwaram project)
* construction and renovation of water bodies (mission Kakatiya)
#Another interesting thing they are laying optical Fiber along with pipelines all over state so Telangana will soon become probably world’s best fiber covered state)
Yes. They gave a parallel connection to those houses which were already having piped water costing hundreds of crores to Government and enriching contractors
It's already done in Andhra.. most villages and hamlets already have AP fibernet.. thanks to Chandrababu Naidu. In my little hamlet in Prakasham Dt, I have 2 LAN connections for 600 (all inclusive) a month. This includes TV connection and WiFi connection too..
@@settipallimadhava3789 the govt is not doing internal piping ,but supply to your door front..How is it redundant? Every house in town have bore water as well as municipal water supply .Nothing new
No center funds, it's absolutely ZERO. GO AND CHECK IF ANY DOUBTS
@@ajaybeast_7461 Where to check? It will be good if you can post any link here.
You can consider making 'Ideas that worked' a weekly/biweekly thing under CTC.
+1
@@yavanshi Point.
@@yavanshi there are so many good ideas that have worked that he can have programs for the next 3 years and by that time, modi would have added many more
I am 26 and my village got electricity and water tap connection way earlier, probably before my birth. Thankful to various Haryana Governments.
Now i know from where funds came for a big tank which was constructed near my house 2 years back.
Really surprising results. States utilised central funds in a better way than before. Kudos to those states which made real progress
West Bengal as always even lagging behind Bihar. Truly phenomenal development TMC, truly phenomenal .............
@Soshan Ihsan-Otty
Except for water connections, WB is better than BIMARU States in most cases in fact sometimes it is better than Maha and Haryana.
Check out the NITI Aayog report on multidimensional poverty
Because mamata don't want that central scheme promoted in her state if it promoted then people will vote for bjp
@@aranyasadhukhan9899 once a great state is competing with backward state from freedom time.Compare with south gujrat Maharashtra
She doesn't allow central schemes to benefit the local populace, else how will she win? Her party has been in power for so long, has she provided clean water across the state? But if the central scheme manages that, then next election, TMC will disappear like INC
Nal Se Jal could eridicate 40-50 % of diseases in our country especially in rural areas which is the bulk of India.
Kudos to the central government for the idea & 🤞 that state govt works on it till every citizen gets tap water.
Yes, you're right about the coverage of this scheme in Bihar. I have seen it with my own eyes. My ancestral village is in the remotest area of the Gopalganj district of Bihar and, as per my observation, all the households have a tap water connection. Best thing about Nitish Kumar is that he never plays politics with centrally sponsored schemes and implement all the schemes with full enthusiasm although some rebranding is always there.
I never thought in my lifetime that water would come from tap in my village. But I got shocked to see running tap water in every house. I was literally in tears to see electricity,tap water and 4 lane road in my village . Thanks nitish kumar and modi ji ❤️❤️
“Once people start paying for it, they become responsible and feel like they are stakeholders” This is exactly what Dr Manmohan Singh was worried about a decade back because people here are so used to freebies and no govt will dare to ask them to pay for services. Kudos to this govt for doing that.
Ever heard about 1000/ month scheme from AAP?
@@nishant4262 no please explain
@@harisundar8698 Just another set of cash incentives announced by AAP in Punjab, Goa if they come to power...to give each woman 1000/month
Modi is so powerful that he doesn't even care about such backlashes
@@palmarum9634 powerful due to the work he is doing
In UP, things are changing at major pace .. be it water, road or infra. At this point I can say.. UP in is the fastest developing state give the level of under development it has under gone in past.
Negative point:- Most people in UP vote for caste and not development.
Positive point:- BJP is favourite to win even by caste voting
Usually other parts of india disrespect up and bihari people of migration now its time to state should be top
I feel UP always gets the short end of stick comments by Shekhar Gupta. This is in part due to the oversized contribution to the parliament and also due to the upcoming elections. Moving from a 0-10% scale to 10-20% is roughly a 100% growth. I think most states are in the same category of a100% growth. A better yardstick is the growth and intent of the state in taking full advantage. UP in % will always lag behind smaller states; especially since their starting point is so far behind
@@udaybanavath agreed . As a tamilian I was shocked when I saw maharshtrians making so much fun of biharis in utube videos . As A high schooler I find UP people to be pretty friendly and nice too (dont have a lot of bihar friends )
Good to know 😌
Fact is Modi has done what previous govts did not do for 70 years. People had computer and net but no electricity, toilets and tap water. Modi is doing the harder work.
Some of Modi's work is good, but i feel like his time is up. Only diminishing returns from here on out. Wish congress would step up. Hope not everyone is genuinely overtaken by the hindu in danger narrative
@@aagantuk7370 lmao "his time is over"😂keep aside that religious part and think bjp is doing all the things that China and other developed world did in there developmental phase..BJP's time to transform india has just began.. next 1 2 terms are of BJP.😌
@@anandkhond5474 still a better option, but unless they get the economy back on track I hope people vote them out
@@aagantuk7370 - Economy is lagging globally due to Pandemic, not due to BJP. And economy cannot be the lone criteria for a successful government, development too is a criteria
@@GameboyZoneRocks 👍
Modi has delivered what no one expected. And that too without any bais. In UP 18% are muslims but 40% of the UP population comprising muslims are benefitted. The scene of rural housing is the best thing happened in villages
I love the stories that Print covers... Despite all the odds, India works and India moves forward... Best thing is no debates..
Edit 1: pls cut UP some slack, it's too big and it'll take time getting better
Edit 2: absolutely no excuses for WB. It is a water rich state
@@aashishgupta9392 I don't think you understood " cut UP some slack"
@@aashishgupta9392 true, all it needs is time and hard work
@Real CEO provided Yogi gets a second term
@@anooppattat7911 oh he will, no question...
@@aashishgupta9392 You are from UP?
My home is just 3 km from towm but we don't have tap water. I have a car, a bike, water filter system but no tap water. And now govt is making a water house finally. Thanks to modi govt.
Which state?
Few years back, in my village in Maharashtra, people (especially young girls) used to go near the river to fetch drinking water. The river used to dry up during summer and I think the water used to be stagnant. Also the villagers used to wash their clothes nearby. This was definitely one of the reasons for many diseases. But now EVERY HOUSE IN THE VILLAGE has access to piped drinking water and this has drastically changed the lives of people there, especially young girls who now can go to school instead of staying at home to fill water from far away places.
I am so glad to see these changes maybe small on charts and graphs but they are playing a huge role in poor people's lives. May the government keep up the good work. It's a pity that people in urban India do not choose to notice the good but constantly keep fixating on unnecessary things that matter little.
This is a perfect example of success in democracy, policy by center, execution by states and positive reporting by The Print. Hopefully those states which missed out understand importance of this project and participate more positively.
Unfortunately UP is doing the worst among all states in Jal jeevan mission which is unexpected because its a BJP ruled state.
Punjab, Bihar, Gujarat are doing better than others.
While 6 states and UTs have already got 100% achievement.
1 in every 5 Indians stay in UP. Even for some UP districts to have transitioned to a lighter yellow is in itself worth celebrating. While in absolute terms, this might actually amount to the total tap connections of many Northeastern states.
The districts bordering Nepal are even worse than Mali. The only districts with a decent standard of living are Gautam Buddh Nagar and Ghaziabad just because they are close to Delhi. The rest of UP is just as worse as Bihar.
In North Eastern states, central government is investing heavily, specially in Assam,Arunachal.
UP should be divided into 4 parts
To facilitate good governance
Funding for Up is also more than that of many other states. It's more about capacity to work and reform thing. We just can't hide behind population figures all the time.
Please read more information about SARAYU CANAL, it took from 1978, 40 years to build 50% of the Canal but in 2 years now being completed, water is flowing through thousands of villages and tens of thousands of farmers are benefiting from it's performance.
UP had been at disadvantage to have not been able to perform in this scheme as not had much to distribute.
I am sure it will, like other lagging states complete 100% in next two years of target 🎯 date.
All states will achieve it except communist states ( WB, KR) who don't want center money nor support.
Iam from Bihar and I acknowledge this achievement, it's been remarkable, also during its implementation it created lots of employment opportunities.
When everyone loves to bash Modi government, it's good to see Shekhar talking about what all Indians want to hear. Real progress and development. From the noise of caa, nrc and farm laws etc, all this good work gets ignored . Thanks for sharing this on your platform.
I'm having goosebump throughout this video
God bless modi dada...
I live in Bihar and recently visited my village, all Electricity connection and water connection does exist in all village in my area, although i would not say as it is perfect or reaches all houses.
Telangana under Harish Rao has been doing good work with respect to water management with lake cleaning and rejuvenation. But, I didn't know that the schemes were also funded by centre. Irrespective whatever work is done, is good work. Hope the whole country has access to clean drinking water soon..
Yes this is way better than center state tussle
The water grid of Gujarat was inspiration for mission bhageeratha here
The erstwhile kakatiya rulers usage of tanks for irrigation was inspiration for mission kakatiya
Also sabarmati river front was taken as inspiration for cleaning musi but it didn't happen
Cleaning of Hussain Sagar also didn't happen
So yes few positives and few negatives here
Last I went to Hussain Sagar 2 years ago, it was stinking. Have there been changes there as of today? If no then I wish they did. All of Hyderabad and secunderabad are polluting that place like anything. It's really sad.
Bhageeratha mission will get huge money for trs contractors
@@explorer6990 no change probably even worse, but from next year ganesh visarjan is banned there.
I completely agree with you on charging people for development schemes no matter how small to make sure people feel that they are stake holders and act responsibly
Modi government have given home, Toilet, Gas connection , Bank accounts, Direct money in bank accounts to poor, roads and Highways, electricity to the last village...what more Modi will do... These things should have been done many years back itself. And rapid Vaccination, when many advance nation has not able to do.
But still some Indian people are running behind the dynasts.
Unke piche bhagenge nai to unka rozi roti Kahan se ayega😂
Thanks Modi, BJP, and RSS......
Jai Hind.
i hope tap water is secular, else people may not want water that is fascist.
@@pankajsharma-fn8cf from Modi vaccine to Modi water😂🤣
😆😅🤣
It's hindutva tap water. All anti hindutva forces should avoid this water and start buying water from other sources and demand the secular parties to pay the bill😁
Akhilesh Yadav will now have to say
Modi ka Pani meh nahi peeyuga😂😂🤭
@@classoppressorbourgeoisie8416 nahi wo bolega paani ki discover maine hi ki thi
I am very surprised that media is taking notice of the achievements of BJP govt. like Jal Mission. Usually they find these things after the election while analysing why BJP has won.
Perfectly summed up. Mainstream media just does not bother about any of the functioning scheme.
Media per se is pathetic ...doing no ground level work, keeping on BJP's good side lest they be raided and harassed. We really have no idea of what is really going on. A few journos trying to get a sincere picture like in this video does not tell the whole story
puppets were tamed/well paid to down about Modi ji/BJP but truth is truth no use coating jahar on pure AMRIT realizing/fearing their existence at stake tuning towards right/truth. Welcome
😂😂
@@shernagandhy8547 Pure rubbish. I have never seen a single story in the mainstream media about the policies of any opposition party whether it is TMC in Bengal or SS in Maharashtra or CPI(M) in Kerala. There is no criticism of their policies, how they have fared. But Yogi's government is criticized every single day. So stop your BS on this. There is literally no policy criticism about any of these governments even when they were accounting for more than 50% of Covid cases. Or the lack of any meaningful initiatives in any of these states.
Living here in the US, i can only say that the PIO/OIC transfer process was so easy!! The red tapism during the previous regimes was the stuff nightmares are made of.
These are the #real factors which gifted Modi 303
Gas,electricity,house,water,bank account,toilets,good roads should have been basics yet it took 70 years to have these....what kind of governments were the previous one....shameful
It is not just in hinterlands of India where basic services are being delivered efficiently with use of technology, it is also happening overseas with basic service like passport renewal. In 2011 it took me 16 weeks to get passport renewed with multiple trips to embassy. This year I made just one trip and got my new passport home delivered in 3 weeks flat!
same for me and my family passport in UK
3 weeks, please write to MOEA, here in UAE, we get in 5 working days and Tatkal in 1 working day
In some counties, Consulate have less staff and need more. Just write them.
Once I wrote a strong letter to one state CM, I never thought I would get response, but also got results and issues resolved.
I am from Bihar and every house in my locality is equipped with tap water. I have witnessed this in all the villages i visited in recent times.
In my district nalanda, tap water has reached Almost every household
I live in Bihar and there is a great progress about it in this state.....
I am happy to be part of this scheme implementation in Karnataka. We are doing a lot of awareness activities. A daunting task of engaging community in planning, implementation, operation and maintenance.
We are using innovative methods for awareness
I am from haryana. Sirsa district. Almost Whole sirsa city now got new water pipeline giving us water of bhakhra dam and my micro scale factory in rural sirsa have a even better water supply line going along the main road that has better quality tap water then RO water
Sir Shekar Gupta much respect to you. It is endearing to see a man share his reading list. It is like charisma and honor has vanished in this country but you stand as a beacon to recall for us youngsters.
And everytime you go through an article or when you slip into explanations, I am reminded of my grandpa, who was a history teacher, and his endearing lessons, like how I still cherish and carry them with me even now.
Thank you! Always a fanboy!
Hi Allan, always wonderful to read your comments. Do keep writing in.
Because of "Mission Bhageeratha" from the TRS manifesto on tap connection for every house, Telangana is on point in it & they fulfilled their promise.
My mother went to her ancestral village in Bihar few days ago after many many years . They get tap water in their homes there. We live in Delhi. It’s a very big thing. Kudos to govt. Har Ghar Nal ka Jal. Jai Hind.
Working as a water supply project engineer from 8 years and done water project at 3 States. Its best satisfaction of my life to see the joy of villagers when water came out from the tap. They are relieved and sometimes can't really believe their own eyes that the decade old problem gone just like that . 🙏🏾
Sir my ancestral home in remote area of Bihar in Chapra District. Last year we got tap water connection. In month of November 2021 my mother visited home in Bihar and found getting tap water 3 times in day. We must acknowledge that pace of development and leadership of Modi ji
Didn't expect this early. Dinner plans shattered 😀
As a fellow Bihari I can say that our village which is surrounded by hills and jungle where we are not having good roads and mostly effected by naxals (dist jamui) .we are having every house with electricity and tap water...
The idea of the government about water to every household is a winner. They had the vision and they have implemented it successfully , where as many previous governments did not even envisage this type of project nationally
Data are real gems... Modi govt. should publish much more data about different parameters so common citizens should know where we are laggering
Thanks to our Telangana CM KCR vision, he made whole telangana (which is notoriously famous for drought) a water surplus state. Only medium size state in india which achieved SDG - 5 Goal and 100% water coverage.
That 100% coverage is really not true
There are places where tap water is still not available
But on larger scenario it's pretty much successful
@@tarungcherukuri obviously there will be some grey areas in every scheme. Delivering the last mile challenges is a biggest task for any government.
@@tarungcherukuri The aim of scheme is to provide access to tap water to village level ..and not to gone level..If some colonies/house holds are not getting..it is fault of local panchayat/ municipal bodies
May the Nal se Jal mission flourish & reach its happy conclusion. Kudos to everyone involved.
Don't know about other states, but Telangana had schemes called Bhagiratha and Kakatiya for providing drinking water to each household, rejuvenating water tanks respectively. So when the implementation of States sync with the Union's (partially State's) money for the same purpose, it works wonders...
🎅🏻Modi be like : kyun? hila dala na? 😂😂😂
70 yrs after so called freedom and we are talking about these type of issues,
Thanks to Congress.
Thanks to ppl n their priorities.. not any specific party. End of the day, the politicians are as good as the ppl choosing them.
In TN, we have had these facilities done effectively like 30 years ago.. Before u tag me a Congress supporter, let me share an interesting fact.. TN has never elected Congress in state elections too for decades now.
YES!!! We need an Ideas that worked series!!! Making a one time contribution just so we can have series like this!
We must avoid a 10 legged coalition on ventilator in 2024 at all costs.
I would be interested to know whether West Bengal has at all taken the money from Central Govt on this…
Being from that state, and knowing the political situation, chances are the Central Govt money has been refused, and Mamata Banerjee is trying to construct her schemes on this.
She is focused on divide and rule
Why mamata have done ma in islamic history
She doesn't care about you. The best thing for her would be if the Hindu bongs leave the state so that she can focus on the Muslim bongs and create another Bangladesh
Bihar 80% played key role in state elections.... This is happening along with election schedule... This is good news though and just for information,I happen to be a Bihari UPSC CSE Officer staying in Gift city in Gujarat
It is quite refreshing to see this analysis based on primary data. Will be great if both positive and negative news ( analysis) is backed by solid data like this. I am very keen to understand how infrastructure ( roads, rail, seaports, airports and power) has improved in the last few years. I see a lot of news on the development on roads - but a comprehensive analysis will be very helpful to objectively assess the state of infrastructure development.
I am a huge fan of Modi's....but facts are facts.
Telangana did not achieve tap water to 100% households due to Modi's 'Nal se Jal' project but LONG BEFORE that project was initiated. KCR has launched his own project called 'Mission Bhagiratha' under which Telangana achieved 100% tap water coverage to households without any assistance from the Center.
Wrong information.
@@sajithakalathil5098 Mission Bhagiratha started in 2016, while 'Jal se Nal' in 2019. Also, you can't just yak 'wrong info' without giving details on what exactly is wrong.
Mr yogi must focus on this , tap water is good thing . in our village we have one well(kua) and in summar it dried up so people are dependent on govt tanks and sometimes they drink 5-6 days old water .
The reason of poor UP performance is not that they don't want to focus when both center and state was BJP but fact that there was really not enough water to distribute to home when farmers didn't have much and farming was priority for water distribution than home.
From 1978 to 2017, it took 40 years to do 50% of Sarayu Canal. past two years and now 100% complete, water is flowing to thousands of villages and tens of thousands of farmers.
Next is Water to every home.
Please note when Yogi Ji took this state, coffer were empty and was called bimaru state.
Now highways, electricity, water Canal and airport are being built, 2014, UP will achieve it target 🎯 date.
All other states will achieve it except for the communist states of WB and KR
UP has developed significantly in all fronts , one cannot expect all fields at one go
Modi Ji: You have shown path to this country that how next generation politicians have to work.
Jo bolate hain woh karate hain 🙏
Sekhar ji. With due respect to your Journalism, your expression still a biased delivery of your report. Please have some heart to give credit to Modi Government. In Past 7 years, Modi government has made progress which previous 65 years of Government could not do in almost all Front. If Modi stays PM for Next 10 Years, India will definitely be the third largest economy with no Doubt.
In Bihar, Govt has really spent a lot of money on water resources including cleaning of reservoirs/lakes and having tap water in every rural household. But there is also some flipsides to it. In some of the districts of Bihar which gets submerged in water during flooding, they deploy very poor quality of pipes and other infrastructure (hence corruption) and during floods, everything gets destroyed (easy escape from the corruption) and they will build it again next year (more corruption). This is one scheme, where at one hand, we are definitely having some progress and but at the other hand, opens door for corruption (that could also be one of the reasons of such a widespread coverage).
I believe Bihar needs to spend more money on other social issues (Centre can encourage it) like human resource development, infrastructure like better schools, colleges, universities, hospitals and more business/entrepreneurship friendly support/incentives, rather than spending it on water as ground water is readily available in almost every village of Bihar. Clean water is also extremely important but it should be seen in terms of collective development.
Judging from the many comments made by ppl from Bihar, I think it is high time you change your representative. The others have mentioned that all is good, so if you are facing any issue, it's your representative who is responsible. Har cheez Modiji karenge to tum kya karoge, vote soch samajh kar do
Glad to see a “What’s Working In India” report from you. Such reports compels me to buy subscription. Looking forward to more such reports. Great Job !
I can confirm for om Odisha that many of the very remote villages also getting availed this facility. More fascinating thing is many of my unemployed friends are getting employed by this scheme.
National water Grid should be layed along National Highways, Railway Tracks and State Highways.
Why?
@@HimanshuSharma-oe4mk my question was why it has to be along railways, highways? It’s hard enough to repair/ maintain road and rail.
@@minimeguju6868 it also helps with flood control
@@kapilkumarsharma4401 understood
SG Sir and team ThePrint,
The success of Bihar in terms of tap water connection is also bcz of Nitish Kumar's "Saat Nishchay Programme" (one of which is tap water connection to every household) rolled much before Jal Jivan mission. With Jal Jivan Missions, the constraints of finances was also resolved.
With Bihar state elections due in Nov 2020, Nitish Kumar worked on a mission mode...for the success of this scheme. Every district administration were given quantifiable targets to b achieved bfr election.
However in many rural areas, with incompetent PRIs, the suppy of water has stopped, or even hv never started at all. But yes, the infrastructure remains in place.
That's my fear about this system
there should be a ecosystem to maintain water supply
Govt should provide infra and develop the ecosystem with private players/community based (if possible) to sustain this for long term
My village in Tamilnadu (TN), which is 300 KM far from Chennai and 200 KM far from Coimbatore had tap water 30 years ago. We use to get water alternate days.The source of water was from local borewell, apparently dried after 5 years. Later sourced water from nearest kaveri basin was good for a few years. Now , infra is there but no water. Currently , people in village are economically doing well so they are able to buy water from tankers again in is borewell and some wealth in village have private borewell. Starting to drying up. Ground water level are so low and near by water bodies are dried. there are lakes around and all are dried.
Looking up the district wise chart in your video, TN, the 2019 and 2021 chart show mid part of TN which Madurai, Theni, Ramanathapuram district are not in blue. Historically and geographically those are driest districts in TN. Ramanathapuram is know as "Thanni iella kadu" literal meaning "no water driest land". They were getting some amount of water from Mullai periyar Dam. After decreasing the limit , it is hard to get any water in the Ramanathapuram district. It required ground breaking plan to get source of water in next 10 years. Laying pipelines, building water tanks and installing tap in street alone not going to help. Those infra already in place which required source of water. Ground water is not option. From your, video that Telungana shows blue , is that mean there is infra and water is flowing in tap? or just tap been installed using the fund and temp waterbody will dry after two years like my village.
Historically, In TN, people always think or made to think that any water related infra works are state funded and implemented by state government. There could be fund from union government but never highlighted by state representative of ruling party of union government which includes BJP. This name (Nal se Jal) itself never heard in TN giving poetic Tamil name may help to publishing. Atlest it gives some publicity. The swachh bharat heard most in TN.
Nevertheless, In TN and many states looks really invest time, effort and money in water body improvement program. Just for your information, a 1100 year old man made water tank en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veeranam_Lake (Veeranam) still major source of water to Chennai built by Chola. The king mentioned in his scription that I will do pooja to his leg if anyone who maintain and save this waterbodies. Note, he did not mention that he going to punish if someone going to damage. Still tank give water to public.
In TN, 30 years back, we got this tap water/water tank at every small village for free and it is still working fine. when you portray this scheme as major achievement, 3 things strike me.
1) How far southern states developed when compare to other parts of India
2)How Congress government failed in these initiatives though they had many other good initiatives
3)Small low hanging fruits like tap water scheme make a big difference to poor Indians and definitely Modi will very good policy benefit out of it.
Boss.. government is not giving tap water connection for the first time...it is providing water connection where it don't have access...prior to 2019 roughly TN got 40% tap water connection..this means lot of people still don't have access to Tap water...plus providing tap water is not low hanging fruit...you should tell that your friends in shivaganga and Ramnad district 😁😁😁😁
Probably you are mixing some lies here. I used to live in Adayar Chennai, there was no tap water we used get water by tanker every morning
@@thunrou exactly...that guy thinks that ..you fix tap in house and water will flow..... 😁😁😁😁
Is that why chennai has such massive water problems, that offices have to close down because water isnt available? Maybe its because southern states have developed so much. Also did your 100% literacy rate prevent you from understanding the map in the video? tamil nadu is clearly far below telangana, andhra and even karnataka. So what are you so proud of ?
You think TN got 100% tap water connection. Pitty you. Still many places in there are no tap water in tamilnadu
3 years back when I had visited my village there were only 2 Taps in our neighborhood This year I noticed there A Tap outside EACH of Cousins House
Nice to know about initiative by former Gujarat CM Chimanbhai Patel. Revives my faith in politicians.
Shankarrao Chavan did it too. Modi magic is a combination of a number of things
I am from rural area of Bihar , and yes my whole village has got tab water connection
It was the election promise of KCR to supply drinking water to every household in the villages of Telangana under the scheme named
“Mission Bhagiratha” when the new state was formed out of AP. He focused on most of his promises & mission Bhagiratha is successfully implemented with huge financial allocation. This scheme was picked up by the BJP for the election manifesto 2019 & now under implementation. It to the credit of KCR that the scheme is planned & very well implemented by him between 2014 & 2019. KCR is a visionary & so is Modi. They are thinking of fulfilling the basic daily needs of the masses. We r proud of these leaders. If everyone of the State Governments could take a leaf out of the success of KCR & Modi, India would become a powerhouse & become a developed country. Jai Bharat !
Well said. shocking to see states which they have not followed