Ask An Electric Car Expert: Fuel Costs, Charging in HDB Carpark, Driving To Malaysia | TP Extra
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 июл 2024
- In this #TalkingPointExtra Q&A, Electric Vehicle (EV) advocate Paul Welsford, vice president of the Electric Vehicle Association of Singapore (EVAS), answers your questions and comments trawled from CNA Insider’s Facebook, RUclips and Instagram community.
FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM: / cnainsider
00:00 How do I charge an electric car in an HDB car park? Are there enough chargers?
01:42 Certificate of Entitlement (COE) for EVs - is it a 10-year entitlement?
01:57 Average fuel costs of an electric car (Hyundai Kona) vs a petrol car (Hyundai Kona 1.6Turbo) based on vehicle efficiency and average annual mileage of 17,500km.
02:57 Cost of replacing an EV battery? How long is the warranty?
04:08 Can an EV battery be recycled? How are EV batteries disposed of?
05:10 Is it possible to swap out the EV battery by yourself?
06:36 What if an EV battery explodes - like battery fires involving Personal Mobility Devices (PMD) and e-bikes?
07:39 What if my EV battery dies in the middle of the road or highway?
08:19 Can I drive to Malaysia (Johor or even Kuala Lumpur) in an EV? Are there charging stations along the North-South highway? (Tip: Download Plugshare)
09:16 Why should I switch to an EV if it is not carbon neutral?
The Singapore government has announced its vision for all vehicles run on cleaner energy by 2040.
Watch #TalkingPoint episodes on electric vehicles:
Switching To Electric Car: Is It Worth It?: • Switching To Electric ...
Can Electric Vehicles Really Be Zero Emission?: • Electric Cars: Can Veh...
WATCH: More behind-the-scenes and post-episode commentary on Talking Point Extras:
Ate Fried Chicken For 14 Days - But Would I Try Going Vegetarian?: • Ate Fried Chicken For ...
Tray Return Debate: The Comment That Got Diana Ser Riled Up: • Tray Return Debate: Th...
Intermittent Fasting Made My Dad Cranky: Lucy & Steven Chia Spill The Beans: • Intermittent Fasting M...
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider
Going to KL in one go. Forget EV I need a backup tanker even for my petrol car, all thanks to the super efficient immigration on the other side and the wonderfully underestimated A2 highway.
Hybrids are The Best Choice.
Can Reach even the Thai Boarders in 1 tank without any Hassel of looking for charging point
Love this, please have more and more exposure to the public about the advantages of EV, on top of the advancement of EV today, benefits like significant better local climate, reduce heat island effects, better ambient air quality & etc, there are indeed many more knowledge sharing and educations needed to the people so we can all be more well informed
very insightful
Hi Paul and everybody reading this, this video is very encouraging to make the switch to ev but 1 thing that's holding me back is the possibility of the insurer to write off in the event of a damage in the batteries, be it minor or major , your thoughts pls🙏
Malaysian watching...
At this stage, EV might be cheaper to run compared to ICE but in no time they will increase the electricity charges. And the cost of running a EV become expensive again. Just look at our house hold electricity charges.
You are right.
Three years ago petrol here was $2.1/l. Now it’s over $2.4 and rising. In essence the cost per km for petrol cars is also rising, and at a higher rate than cost per km for BEVs over same period.
You can make electricity prices stable by using renewable energy.
can the grid handle evening peak times? bi-directional charging maybe? With Singapore committing to greener energy sources and PARIS accord quotas, where do we get that from?
the grid can handle more than we can use:) search it up. with greater efficienies, less natural is used to generate power, more efforts have also been taken with solar panels in our rivers
I am more concerned about the explosion of batteries during charging, not driving, but charging. You can say BMS all you want, no car manufacturer, especially Tesla will want to touch you once your warranty expires. Another scenario of concern is when u get into an accident, I foresee most car manufacturer will charge you for the entire battery$$$$$.
Until these stupid issues get sorted through standardization, I won't touch EVs with a ten foot pole.
I'm more worried at the state of webcams than I am for EV charging locations xD
I think we should really reconsider how we are pushing this movement and the people involved, it seems as if it’s currently pushed by people who may have a biased view on this matter, transparency is greatly valued when it comes to new initiatives, some examples are the points regarding possibility of fires, maybe be more upfront regarding how spontaneous the fire is and the relative possibility of escape etc
And yes, EVs are pushed by a biased view on this matter, the same way the "biased" government with a huge stake in our oil industry are also pushing for EVs too.
Lanjiao lah what you smokin ah dey, simi logic one. And it appears you have been going on many EV videos and posting your anti-EV hatred everywhere lmao.
Like abang we get it lah, you don't like EVs. But you need to keep making so many of the same comments on these type of videos meh?
It's obvious you're another troll account.
Spacecraft Carrier dont come and talk rubbish and call ppl troll, our govt with a huge stake in petroleum products won’t be affected much even if we use EV because that’s an exported good…want to talk get educated on the matter first dont just Tesla Tesla Tesla EV EV EV then everything is super good and cannot have any cons
Spacecraft Carrier wanna make a guess how is some of the electricity generated? Petrol bro lol joker…0 tail pipe emissions only doesn’t mean 0 emissions, have u even watched the full length version?
@@ryantan1022 You can watch Donut Media discuss this topic, and in fact even though EVs use a coal power plan, EVs are still more environmentally friendly than internal combustion engines.
@@ryantan1022 This
ruclips.net/video/G67i_Z8ukD4/видео.html
Would also like to ask if the presenter is really reliable and neutral in his inputs, we should not have a person with vested interests in the EV market that could potentially be backed up by large corporations, kind like the lobbyist in the US…wtv his intentions are
His speech sounds vested to me.
What i see from fb, are mainly comments by people who have not done their due diligence in the field. mainly about batt degration, fires. these answers can be found if they did a search online
Alwin Lim yup tbh should really just do a proper check etc and decide don’t just watch some person sounding educated because of his foreign background then take his word for it
TAURUS SG yup can look up the speakers name, while he is a chair of some EV association he has other dealings that seem to benefit monetarily from the widespread adoption of EV
i meann all the fossil fuel and traditional car companies have lying to us and using incentives to trick us to to use more fuel and stay away from EVs. ICEs are not that good either. also banks are also backing up the fossil fuel companies, how is that better for the climate?
I worried that if its all electric cars isn't that would be CAT B COE why don't have CAT A
One of the "advantages" at least for current batteries is that they contain a lot of rare materials. This is an advantage because it very quickly becomes too expensive to dig up making recycling cheaper by comparison so I expect this will go pretty well. The need for batteries will only grow and if recycling is the most profitable way to get new ones that's where the investment will go.
By the same logic, batteries will get more expensive and they constitute the main cost of an EV. So the EV now will costs more, then will you still buy? Assuming petrol cars costs comes down due to competition from EVs, will you still consider them? 🤔 just a thought
just take a look at plug share, most MY charging point are those 3 pin house socket, you are definitely not charging your EV to 100% in a few hours time
Without a doubt, EVs will eventually rule the roads. In the meantime, hybrids are the best option. Nissan has the E-power.
Hybrids are the worst. Additional load with an engine and a battery .. makes no sense..
@@ShirtPapa Not if you are to travel long distance with no ev chargers for miles.
@@ShirtPapa Usually better design, more efficient more mileage from a single tank, less CO2 emissions etc. Just choose a model suitable for your needs
11 month old video, charging is now 55 cents instead of 6 cents. That's almost a 100% increase in a year. 2 more years more expensive than petrol already.
There is an additional $700 tax per year for fully electric cars.
The EVs come with free home charging point including installation. Anyone knows if the charging is possible for another car make?
Most EV chargers are interoperable, in fact within SG itself...they are standardized to use type 2 (AC) and CCS2 (DC). Hence, you can head down to Shell / Greenlots, SP Charging or even fall back on 3 pin plugs to charge your EV. Hope that clarifies it! :)
@@alwinsingh4879 I agree with you. My worry is whether the dealer will use this as an excuse to void the 8-year battery warranty?
The connecting heads of the cable are not standardised. Each EV maker has their own design. The are adapters provided in the aftermarket segment but it’s no sense to carry a bag of adapters around in your boot.
@@tsgu8728 I have 2 cars and plan to change both to EVs. Some dealers include home chargers as a part of package but I don’t wish to install 2 different wall chargers at home. That’s why I am wondering if charging will void the battery warranty of a different make.
@@CalvinK300 I would say look into the 2 cars you plan to get. Majority of the EVs out there are cross compatible (E.g. BYD, Hyundai, Toyota, BMW i3) and the IEC has also set out EV guidelines to standardise charging (Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3). If you plan to get a Porsche, Tesla, etc, you may find compatibility issues. Nonetheless, common brands as mentioned above are cross compatible. The above would also justify why SP Charging Stations and Shell have standardized on using Type 2 (AC) and CCS2 (DC) inlet
What about hydrogen powered cars as an alternative?
its dumb, it takes much more energy to convert air into hydrogen then convert them to eletricity stored in batteries and then to fuel cells to drive the motor losing 80% of the energy.
compared to pure ev of an efficiency of 80% and above
@@staph8022 Hydrogen costs r huge. India is going to revolutionize Green Hydrogen
Not so convince about battery safety In case of accident , more on that aspect perhaps?
current numbers based on Tesla records since 2012 is 1 fire in over 200 million miles driven. Based on US gov records, the petrol vehicle equivalent stat is 1 fire in every less than 20 million miles driven. The odds of a fire statistically in an electric car is, numerically speaking, substantially lower.
insideevs.com/news/501729/number-tesla-vehicle-fires-2020/
He already answered your question why are you asking again. Watch this video carefully.
@@paperhouse6282 there's not enuff figures to tell the real picture as electric car ownership is still low locally, not just becos it's in video. It's a valid concern to look deeper when your whole family rides on one.
@@whizkid4690 I do carry my family in a bev. The numbers have been accumulated over close to a decade based on hundreds of thousands of cars traveling hundreds of millions of miles. To me, those are sufficient numbers. I’m not sure what ur threshold of sufficiency of numbers is. But 6 digit number of cars and 8-9 digit number of combined mileage is quite substantial.
@@whizkid4690 You're just an EV hater,
then why do you ask, what a dumb
Maybe be more upfront regarding how spontaneous the fire is and the relative possibility of escape compared to petrol car, while the end result is the whole vehicle may still burn, petrol ICE cars generally provides for more time to escape upon detection than EVs which spontaneously combust
And also don’t bs us with “a tank full of highly flammable liquid”, go check out yourself, petrol stored correctly especially with a full tank with a low air mix is actually pretty safe and hard to combust instantly by itself, even in aviation fires, planes don’t just go boom full of jet fuel, however their “Sophisticated battery tech” does just combust spontaneously just like with some 787s
No escape. When Li-ion batteries ignite, fire intensity is tremendous. Besides the fire will burst out from the sides of the car thus when you open the doors, you get fried instantly.
Not Unknown for EVs to spontaneous Self Ignite n Burst into Flames esp on Impacts
look at the number of ICEs cars that caught fire everyday or every second. and see how many EVs had this problem. ICEs that caught fire is so normal to one's eyes and once an EV caught fire, they get mega media attention and is criticised like hell wth.
*Laughs in coe*
i'm way too early
Better than to late. 😉
This will slap all the EV haters in the face
Not really. EV is still bloody expensive for the avg joe in sg. You can't get an EV even with the new reorganized CAT A under $140K
Tesla, not surprisingly elite
Price also elite.
EVs are known to Self Ignite n Burst into Flames esp on Impact
Are the EV charging plugs able to be physically locked after plugging in? It will be awful if you were supposed to charge it overnight but have some prankster unplug it. Or maybe even another inconsiderate EV owner who wants to use the charger and decides to unplug yours
Don’t worry, enterprising pranksters will detach your cable and leave a note for you to pay for it if you want it back. The charging cable isn’t cheap…. It sells for €500 in Germany 🇩🇪
@@tsgu8728 it locks on both ends. At vehicle and at charger. Ema requirements
EV buyers must make sure the products or its parts are not tainted
- with the Uyghur forced labor in China🇨🇳.
Use a Tesla as an example, aren’t gonna convince much ppl to transit with all these other shitty EV brands.
thats right, model 3 is a much more compelling car with all better aspects from range, performance autopilot and lastest features ota updates etc
Lol. You're a boomer eh? Other EV brands are catching up and Tesla owners will tell you tesla interior looks cheap and some have poor QC out of the factory. You evidently never update yourself beyond.