Suede with Siouxsie Sioux - Caroline Says II (Lou Reed cover)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
  • At a fan club-only gig in London (12 July 1993), Brett takes a break while Siouxsie Sioux and Martin McCarrick of Siouxsie and the Banshees join the band for a cover of Lou Reed's "Caroline Says II"

Комментарии • 110

  • @Danyhg92
    @Danyhg92 11 лет назад +71

    Going to a Suede concert and getting the surprise of having Siouxsie Sioux cover a Lou Reed song, sounds like the perfect combination to me.

  • @simbrand
    @simbrand 14 лет назад +56

    These kind of things make you realise how lucky we are to have RUclips

  • @synthvault
    @synthvault 5 лет назад +9

    Sioux, Smith, Bush, Morrissey, Curtis, Anderson...where are the artists with serious artistic weight today? I mean, I like a lot of current artists but they aren't exactly breaking new ground or burrowing into my soul to help me with emotional issues.

    • @andyisdead
      @andyisdead 5 лет назад

      emotional pop music is out of fashion right now

    • @dynamite3690
      @dynamite3690 5 лет назад +1

      Give Norwegian singer Aurora a try. ...

    • @synthvault
      @synthvault 5 лет назад

      @@dynamite3690 Just listened to her on your recommendation and she gets a big thumbs up from me. I hear kind of a mix of Feist and Kate Bush in there. Thanks for the tip!

  • @alexlamas6324
    @alexlamas6324 7 лет назад +34

    Siouxsie Sioux is always amazing! A true rock goddess.

  • @jadefacetiger
    @jadefacetiger 10 лет назад +43

    Nobody does covers better than Siouxsie. Spectacular!

    • @jackal59
      @jackal59 7 лет назад

      Based on this, I'm all for hearing nobody instead.

    • @no_wire_hangers
      @no_wire_hangers 4 года назад +1

      jackal59 this is not the best yes, check out The Passenger, Dear Prudence, Hall of Mirrors, to name a few.

    • @paulashe7460
      @paulashe7460 4 года назад +4

      Stage presence and concerts were an event you traveled to. She was the coolest person in the 80’s .

  • @4herstory
    @4herstory 6 лет назад +14

    woooooow....but of course she NAILS it. i didn't think it could be done better. but siouxsie is perfection. THANK U to whoever recorded it as well as whoever posted it here. without u, she was just ...pissing in a river. ;) now, if we could only see her cover simple twist of fate (johnette's, natch) for all eternity, likewise, i think i could die peacefully.

  • @fabienh3943
    @fabienh3943 8 лет назад +24

    what an unbelievably beautiful song from a Masterpiece amongst the masterpieces. Berlin...

  • @kalevala29
    @kalevala29 5 лет назад +5

    Siouxsie's personality is so English. Yet she can cover a Lou Reed song, who was a quintessential Long Islander.

  • @tita4ewaz
    @tita4ewaz 5 лет назад +9

    And THAT is how you cover a song. Superb

  • @karllux-d6g
    @karllux-d6g 2 года назад +1

    Otherworldly cover... at 4.13, when Sue quotes ''she put her fist through the windowpane'', why would she be moving her fingers like that? It's the sound of shattering glass, tiny little crystal smithereens flying, suggested on the original by windchimes. Besides being a Rock goddess, she's a Rock encyclopaedia too, hardly missing a detail. I was lucky to see the Banshees that year, closing on their professional apex.

  • @kalevala29
    @kalevala29 10 лет назад +10

    "You can hit me all you want to but I don't love you anymore..."

  • @girasol5998
    @girasol5998 3 года назад +1

    ITALIAN VERSION:: ALASKA- SINGER PATTY PRAVO--- GREAT SUEDE---- I PREFER THIS VERSION......❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @simoom37
    @simoom37 12 лет назад +5

    The video projections are taken from Derek Jarman's Last of England. Great discovery for me!

  • @oovii808
    @oovii808 8 лет назад +9

    She was quite beautiful.

  • @forestdowser
    @forestdowser 14 лет назад +5

    I was so excited when I came across this while looking for the original, as I love Suede and S & Bs, how lucky! I thought it was good, inevitably suffers from the fact that Lou Reed's original is so understated, which I think makes it very powerful; his phrasing is beautiful and fragile, but there was one bit which really stood out in this performance, where Siouxsie sings "this is a bum trip", the fury within just lets rip; that bit was worth the whole song.

  • @scythrop
    @scythrop  17 лет назад +4

    Martin McCarrick. Best known as a cellist, he played various instruments (primarily keyboards, I think) for Siouxsie and the Banshees from 1987 until the break-up in 1996.

  • @jurgens.8019
    @jurgens.8019 11 лет назад +8

    Siouxsie at its best!

  • @kingywhu
    @kingywhu 3 года назад +1

    Here guys, a fantastic band from Dublin called Whipping Boy absolutely smash this song ...........also listen to their 2nd album Heartworm...........you can all thank me later

  • @misfit2022
    @misfit2022 3 года назад +4

    Siouxie Sioux - punk rock icon and Berlin what a great album.

  • @LunaSeaSane
    @LunaSeaSane 17 лет назад +3

    Brilliant album. "BERLIN" by Lou Reed (just so the younger ones don't forget).

  • @alanvegaz
    @alanvegaz 8 лет назад +6

    Angel Sioux

  • @gondola33
    @gondola33 13 лет назад +4

    en tiempos de depresion caroline says me hace llorar

  • @2432081
    @2432081 17 лет назад +2

    this is fantastic i have never heard siouxsie sing this before after seeing her loads of times in the 80s,she so beautiful im pleased i named my daughter after her.......................

  • @MrRaffles
    @MrRaffles 17 лет назад +4

    Unbelievable. Absolutely superb. Siouxsies voice is unique.

  • @Properdrainage
    @Properdrainage 7 лет назад +5

    She has truth in her being,

  • @ElWeasle
    @ElWeasle 16 лет назад +3

    I'm 14, and I'll never forget Berlin, don't worry. :D

  • @jurgens.8019
    @jurgens.8019 10 лет назад +3

    Die geilste Frau im Pop ever!Vom Gruftie zur ernst zu nehmenden Singering !

  • @gomerasub
    @gomerasub 15 лет назад +2

    Stephanie Says is on the velvet's VU album, Caroline Says is on Lou Reed's Berlin album.

  • @MOJOMANSON1964
    @MOJOMANSON1964 15 лет назад +3

    Siouxsie Sioux I will always love you!

  • @dhowellbassist
    @dhowellbassist 13 лет назад +1

    @FranklyMisterShankly This is Bernard. The dates match up to his time in Suede, and you can just tell from the playing style.

  • @olfameocorde
    @olfameocorde 15 лет назад +1

    pretty stupid thing to envy about siouxsie

  • @plutodrvv
    @plutodrvv 17 лет назад +2

    I agree Siouxsie is amazing! So happy to say I have seen her in concert 3 times.

  • @grandjeanolivier4770
    @grandjeanolivier4770 2 года назад +1

    What a magical moment... Thanks for capturing it!

  • @pikkuhassu
    @pikkuhassu 17 лет назад +2

    siouxsie is so beautiful i love her expressions

  • @scythrop
    @scythrop  16 лет назад +1

    I don't think Jon Klein made it to the end either; I seem to remember Knox Chandler as their guitarist on the 1995 Rapture tour.

  • @mediapuzzle
    @mediapuzzle 17 лет назад +3

    lou and Siouxsie - what a marriage!!@

    • @ForARide
      @ForARide 4 года назад

      Nope, she´s more into John Cale!

  • @davidh.7150
    @davidh.7150 9 лет назад +2

    Absolutely fantastic!

  • @MATTDAY
    @MATTDAY 16 лет назад +1

    I was there, a day day b4 my bday, what a night, thanks to my Dad..love ya x

  • @67Willydark
    @67Willydark 8 лет назад +3

    Unica !!!

  • @Takac1979
    @Takac1979 11 лет назад +2

    RIP Lou you wrote a fantastic song!

  • @Takac1979
    @Takac1979 15 лет назад +1

    AWESOME!!!
    I had this on a crap sounding bootleg CD for ages...
    Superb rendition!

  • @siouxie1968
    @siouxie1968 Месяц назад

    I love her

  • @drsioux
    @drsioux 6 месяцев назад

    The projection behind Siouxsie is a scene from Derek Jarman's film The Last of England (1987). The woman ripping off her wedding dress (visible only at the very beginning) is Tilda Swinton.

  • @aps4264
    @aps4264 4 года назад +1

    One of a kind!!! Only 1 Siouxsie.

  • @dirtyweekendinbrighton5660
    @dirtyweekendinbrighton5660 9 лет назад +2

    Great Version.

  • @dominica4799
    @dominica4799 2 года назад

    What year is this

  • @nonaayusaputri2376
    @nonaayusaputri2376 6 лет назад +1

    Everytime I heard Karen O voice..I don't know why..but always remind me of Siouxsie's...

    • @dannyhaobam9858
      @dannyhaobam9858 5 лет назад

      Exactly. Btw Siouxsie's dance moves in the video for Hongkong Garden probably inspired Karen O's performance or her signature moves.

    • @carljules3123
      @carljules3123 2 года назад +1

      @@dannyhaobam9858 wharever karen o is quite a coward ; she's ungrateful as she never gave a kudo to siouxsie

  • @tinelismiper
    @tinelismiper 11 лет назад +3

    ..."are you sitting or standing uncomfortably?...then it's about time then"...Haha! Yes Mistress...I remember seeing her when I was in college in Boston, late 80s and during the show someone tried to get on stage, she, in time with the song, took her mic and bonked this person in the head, may have said 'f*** off', and pulled the mic back and continued to sing the next verse. Priceless...I had the flu with probably a 104 degree fever, and by the time I left the concert, I sweated it out.

  • @dr.weaklicksofcrashedcurse4535
    @dr.weaklicksofcrashedcurse4535 4 года назад +1

    This is good!

  • @wildysary
    @wildysary 16 лет назад

    oh my god!!I love you!!Thanx a million for shared this treasure...I had neever watched this video before.But I know this magnificent song and I love Suede and Siouxsie.She made a fantastic interpretation with a great voice.You made my...night!thanx thanx thanx

  • @scythrop
    @scythrop  16 лет назад

    Oh, I think it must be. He didn't leave until 1994 and was certainly with them the month before this was filmed when I saw them in D.C.

  • @redbeki
    @redbeki 4 года назад +1

    Beautiful..

  • @crybanshee
    @crybanshee 16 лет назад

    Martin McCarrick was Siouxsie & the Banshees cellist/keyboardist :) Besides the obvious exceptions of Siouxsie, Steven Severin and Budgie, he was the longest-lasting member of Siouxsie & the Banshees.

  • @simoom37
    @simoom37 11 лет назад +1

    you bet !

  • @thisblender
    @thisblender 18 лет назад +1

    YES!!!

    • @valiantv2897
      @valiantv2897 5 лет назад +1

      just saw this comment from 13 years ago, are you still listening to this ?

  • @chekybeetle
    @chekybeetle 13 лет назад

    Does anyone know where i can find the full or longer version video of this concert? I loved how Suede played She's Not Dead in this concert:P
    any help would be appreciated!!

  • @flirdy776
    @flirdy776 17 лет назад

    Oh God ! Siouxsie and Suede singing together in a fan club. What a great idea.
    Scythrop you are lovely I won't forget you.
    Thanks a lot !

  • @SheilaZeke
    @SheilaZeke 6 лет назад

    playful animosity (hopefully) before and after the song from two of the most shining british stars.

  • @markc-ru4qz
    @markc-ru4qz Год назад

    I could listen to her sing the phone book ❤ Siouxsie!

  • @WegrennerX
    @WegrennerX 15 лет назад

    Stephany says bij Velvet is a bit similar but altogether a different song.

  • @AshtonArcher
    @AshtonArcher 17 лет назад

    The song is Caroline Say II, people.

  • @jorispeeters5039
    @jorispeeters5039 11 лет назад

    See my version as a tribute, under Joris Peeters Caroline says II.
    Great song RIP Lou.

  • @stevieuk99
    @stevieuk99 17 лет назад

    That woman is amazing! Amazing! everything about her is fab! Siouxsie rules!

  • @jerryskid1
    @jerryskid1 14 лет назад

    She's not afraid to die.... Berlin is such a great album.

  • @tlng13
    @tlng13 17 лет назад

    OH I love that version!!! and I love Human Drama's Pins up...

  • @WoodRatGirl
    @WoodRatGirl 15 лет назад

    Very powerful version of Lou Reed's song.
    Well done Siouxsie!

  • @paulashe7460
    @paulashe7460 4 года назад

    She loved taking songs and doing her stuff.

  • @simoom37
    @simoom37 13 лет назад

    siouxsie goddess... meetin lou reed god !!! perfect

  • @draped_in_black
    @draped_in_black 18 лет назад

    A very good performance.

  • @solwolfpunk
    @solwolfpunk 17 лет назад

    The best

  • @BRASISEX
    @BRASISEX 17 лет назад

    lovely drama..dama siouxsie

  • @stevieuk99
    @stevieuk99 16 лет назад

    this is just lush. siouxsie! wow

  • @666satansbro
    @666satansbro Год назад

    Awesome love it

  • @punkrocker1974
    @punkrocker1974 Год назад

    Bellissima

  • @blahdavid
    @blahdavid 16 лет назад

    I love Martin!

  • @musicalix
    @musicalix 16 лет назад

    Amen.

  • @seanscaff
    @seanscaff 16 лет назад

    bosh

  • @emmezeta
    @emmezeta 18 лет назад

    GREAT SONG

  • @StrummerLivesxxx
    @StrummerLivesxxx 15 лет назад

    Just lovely.

  • @theblahman
    @theblahman 13 лет назад

    Great cover

  • @HitheLineFighton
    @HitheLineFighton 18 лет назад

    Sublime!

  • @jpgamer2382
    @jpgamer2382 7 лет назад

    lindo lindo lindo

  • @brankaostojic369
    @brankaostojic369 5 лет назад

  • @perlaSberla
    @perlaSberla 15 лет назад

    ils:)

  • @66horace
    @66horace 13 лет назад +1

    No,Siouxie, "I"'ll love you for the rest of my life...

  • @troylecroix
    @troylecroix 17 лет назад

    Absolutely superb. I am an ardent Siouxsie fan and have never seen this or heard her sing it. I agree with the previous comment - Beautiful. Thanks

  • @plastixidol
    @plastixidol 13 лет назад

    still think the best cover of this was done by Human Drama on their "Pin Ups" album.. check it out.

  • @simoom37
    @simoom37 11 лет назад

    I don't think so, sorry... :(

  • @riverplate0101
    @riverplate0101 14 лет назад

    Great see through top. Thanx Sioux. Besos.

  • @drillbitch
    @drillbitch 15 лет назад +1

    She doesn't need to wear a bra even at 50 I envy her so much.