What a great team of comedians.This type of slapstick comedy was so good and they did not have to be nasty to try to be funny like some do nowadays.Great home spun entertainment,and something the kids could watch.Thanks Rick,good job.
Moe could get pretty "nasty" in those films, and I don't mean just when he would hit the other two Stooges, but also when he used to call them insulting names like "feather-brained imbeciles," "knuckleheads," "chowderheads," "lunkheads," etc, etc. All the fights they would get into, either among themselves or with others, were rather nasty too. As for their shorts being a show "the kids could watch," it should be remembered that a lot of parents objected to these movies because they were "too violent," because they feared that they might encourage their children to imitate the way Moe would whack the other Stooges on the head, or twist their noses or ears around, or poke them in the eyes, and so on. In reality, there's very little evidence of any child aping the behavior of this famous comedy team.
@@michaelpalmieri7335 That's why Moe is my least favorite Stooge; he could dish out the abuse, but he couldn't take it, unless it was from a non Stooge, plus I didn't like his name calling.
@@rickninegcan you prove any of this because what your saying is they literally spliced together part's from old movies so unless your weird well you are but unless you just sat there watched every single one to see if you might notice some same sequences your just stupid
Yes the stooges brought countless hours of fun, Their ability to make people laugh was priceless. Hard to believe they are all gone now. And we their viewing audience is all grown up.
Most people that saw these shorts (first run) are gone as well. The first short was 90 years ago. (and you'd have to be old enough to remember watching them, add 10 years?) I got my Stooge addiction in the 70's, from Sunday mornings, WSBK TV 38, Boston. Good times.
@@kurtbarlow9402 I know about that Boston channel. When I lived in Yonkers, NY, our cable TV system picked up a few out-of-state stations, including WSBK, which was referred to as Boston's "superstation," in other words, the equivalent of Ted Turner's TBS. I remember watching the 3 Stooges on WSBK, just as you used to do.
I'm quite aware of how the Stooges reused old footage. This is probably because Harry Cohn, the head of Columbia Pictures, which made the Stooges' films, was known to be a bit of a tightwad who would look for any way of cutting back on the studio's budget. He figured that it was cheaper to reuse old stock footage (especially when Moe, Larry, and Shemp would remake some of their older shorts with Shemp using Curly's lines) than to film new footage. As a matter of fact, the last four films featuring Shemp as the "third stooge" (including the one discussed here, which was the very LAST one) were made around the time or shortly after he had passed away (one or two of them were released in 1956, the year after he died). How, you may ask? Well, the studio, with Moe and Larry's help, simply reworked some of their earlier Shemp shorts by using or combining stock footage from the older films, and then adding in new footage that would either show Moe and Larry alone or where they would use a stand-in for Shemp. This was done with their 1956 short called "Commotion On The Ocean," which made liberal use of scenes from two films from the late 1940s, "Crime On Their Hands"and "Dunked In The Deep." "For Crimin' Out Loud," the film talked about here, was also a reworking of an older short. I forget which one, though.
It wss called "Who Done It?" It was filmed in 1949. "For Crimin' Out Loud" was one of several 1950s Stooges' shorts recycled from earlier shorts featuring actors who were deceased including Duke York, Simona Boniface, Ted Lorch, and, of course, Shemp and Curly (Booty and the Beast).
he was underrated than the others, he didn't try to be like curly he tried to be himself, come up with his own acts and expressions, so yeah was good when it came to be part of his own character, it's just too bad joe besser couldn't do any better, but at the same time he was just a quick replacement, even though they also had joe palma as fake shemp for 4 shorts before they brought besser, but still curly in my opinion is always the star for all fans to enjoy, each stooge had there own characters.
“Early Curly”! Love the chart! Great work on this video. I can definitely see the footage differences and understand why they had to use this in their creative process. It is a bit distracting to me visually, but the overall comedy of the Stooges helps overcome that. It would be interesting to see you do another type of this video, if not the Stooges, maybe regarding another subject. 👍🏻
I know you will come up with some amazing idea, you’re good like that! If not the Stooges, perhaps the Marx Brothers or Laurel and Hardy, 2 shows you’ve covered previously on the channel? 🤔
Shemp had several solo shorts by Columbia Pictures as well; all worth watching. My favorite is called "Mr. Noisy" & it's here on RUclips. You'll recognize much from The Three Stooges in those films, believe me !! 🚬😎
Thanks for the great stooge content. You are the only one on RUclips that does them justice with your careful analysis, obviously all done with great love for the boys. I hope to see many more like this!
It's crazy that they had so much older footage that they could actually use to fill in and keep enough continuity with the newer footage to create that short. I think it all matched up pretty nicely, considering the fact that I never knew they did that until watching your video right now. And Ive been watching the Three Stooges off and on for many years. I think that their shorts also offer a fascinating glimpse into the Los Angeles area of the past. Rick, this is a great video. You give some very interesting information that I didn't know, but am very interested in learning about. I'm officially your most recent subscriber, and I'm looking forward to watching more of your work. Thank you.
Curly was a treasure...Larry was my favorite. After Curly, it took me awhile to get used to Shemp, I'll be honest here. But after a few shorts, he grew on me. When I watched his final short, I did notice some differences in the scenes, but...it worked!!! Thank you for the video!!!
I know what you mean about Shemp. I was 4 years old when I saw films featuring Curly. Then after a few months, I saw films featuring Shemp and disliked him for the "unforgivable sin" of not being Curly. And what kind of a name was Shemp? As a teenager, I came to like Shemp, but he'll always be a close second to Curly.
Another excellent job of research, Rick. I knew that Columbia used stock footage in some of the Stooges shorts, but had no idea that they used that much! I guess as the Stooges aged, they figured the younger versions had more energy and were more appealing as your pointed out in addition to being much cheaper to produce. Your posts are a welcome addition to all Stooge fans!
Who Done It? was the last time Duke York (the goon) appeared in a Stooge short. He died by suicide January 24th, 1952 at the age of 43, six days after the tragic death of Curly Howard.
It's a sad fact that Duke York (aka the Goon, Angel, Lupe the Wolf-Man, the angry boss who said "You'll get your wings and the harps with 'em!") was one of several actors appeared posthumously in Stooges' shorts.
I remember going to the cinemas to see ‘Hardly Working’ with Jerry Lewis in 81..before the movie, they played a Stooges short..Flagpole Jitters ! They certainly laughed louder with the Stooges, as opposed to the main feature! Thanks Rick.
Hey Rick, I saw the 3 Stooges perform live , onstage at the RKO Proktor's Theater in New Rochelle NY . It was 1962 when they released the film " The Three Stooges Meet Hercules ". Moe, Larry and Joe Derita were making personal appearances at movie theaters showing their new film. I remember Moe telling us kids from the stage NOT to poke anyone in the eyes. He showed how they poked eachother above the eyes. I recall them waving goodbye to us all outside from the windows of their tour bus which was one of those old buses with the round ends. It was not unusual for actors to appear live onstage at the old RKO Proktor's Theater. I have seen a newspaper Ad from 1951 that showed Bela Lugosi was appearing live onstage there to perform his " Big Horror and Magic Stage Show " . It was also used in the days of Vaudeville. Eddie Foy was known to appear there with all his kids. That was an easy show for him because Eddie Foy lived in New Rochelle with his big family. I remember as a kid seeing the old run down Foy home on Shore Road. It eventually was knocked own and the family donated the land to the City with the proviso that it be used a park for children.
Know it well Bill, just south of North Ave, Heard Lou Gerhig and Jimmy Durante lived in the same area. I remember when the Stooges appeared at the RKO Castle Hill in the early 60s , my folks wouldn’t let me go. God Bless Officer Joe!
It's great when you find these treasures. I've seen the episodes many times and you are pointing out things I hadn't noticed before. Thank You for sharing/posting!!
I watched this Stooges episode last month while recovering from surgery, I laughed so hard I thought I have to go back to the ER!!! The scenes in the drawing room with Shemp and Christine McIntyre are some of their most hilarious 😂 Yessir, Shemp really knocked it out of the park in his final performance
Hope you’ll get around to covering Joe DeRita. He toured with Larry and Moe to promote “Have Rocket Will Travel” and the three walked onstage together at the end of the film, which my parents took me to see in Brooklyn NY. One of my fondest memories of my childhood.
I saw the Stooges live on stage at the RKO Proktor's Theater in New Rochelle NY. It was in 1962 when they were promoting " The Three Stooges Meet Hercules ". Do you remember Moe telling us kids NOT to poke each other in the eyes?
Excellent detective work. I knew “Half Wits Holiday” was Curly’s last short, but didn’t know Shemp’s. I think it’s impressive how the new footage matches the old footage in regards to lighting and other technical stuff. Columbia had a talented production crew.
Ron, I think you hit on something important here. Everyone was very talented considering this is mid century. Lighting, mood, even the grayscale coloring is exactly on point. Imagine making a movie and then replicating everything 10 years later to match exactly as possible. Quite the challenge
I always thought Shemp and Christine McIntyre scenes were hilarious. They appeared to work so well together despite the broken nose (brideless groom). Did they work together in Shemps solo career?
I am glad you showed the difference, I never payed attention to the difference. Curly was way Ahead of his time. Shemp was fantastic in his roles. Of course it was silly comedy but everyone needs some comedy in their life. We loved them when I was young but now I appreciate them now.
It's been a while since I saw this particular episode of the Stooges. Still classic comedy by them. I do like the use of the stock footage at times, as it gives them a different angle on the episode, where they can put in a little more acting. "Commotion on the Ocean" and "Dunked in the Deep" are good examples of the use of stock footage, as when the remake came about, Shemp had passed on, and Moe even eludes to "I wonder whatever became of that Shemp!" I think "Tricky Dicks" also used stock footage from "Hold that Lion", and they give us a little different angle on the episode.
Shemp was the original “ third stooge “ having broken in the vaudeville act in the 1920s with younger brother Moe and friend Ted Healy as the “ boss “ stooge…they added Larry after finding him performing in another act. By the early 1930s, they even had a movie under their belt, and after Shemp left the group around 1930 for a solo career,( he couldn’t stand Healy) he was replaced by Shemp and Moe’s kid brother Jerome ( Curly). When the boys parted ways with Healy in 1934, they signed with Columbia Pictures to make two- reelers ( 20 minute shorts) At this time, they were already in their mid to late 30s… When Curly’s health started to decline in the early 40 shorts,you can see his weight start to lessen, by 1945, they had to pad him up so he could look heavier than Moe. Notice as his health diminished,the creases in his face grew deeper, and his speech started slurring. More of the funny bits were given to Larry. After Curly became too I’ll to perform, older brother Sam ( Shemp) rejoined the boys. At this time he was 50. Years later when Columbia went on the cheap, the Stooges were pushing 60 and intercutting footage used up to 10 years earlier, yea, you can notice the difference…By the way, some of that pie fight footage goes back to earlier Curly shorts. Another Great Video Rick!
Nice summary of the Three Stooges' history from their beginnings with Healy in the 1920s through the later Shemp years of the 1940s/1950s. Regarding the trio's ages when they came to Columbia in early 1934, Moe was 36, Larry was 31, and Curly was 30.
STOOGES 2 … Shemp died suddenly in 1955 and Curly had died a few years prior. The Stooges still had a couple of years left in their contact…Columbia pictures big shots were ready to drop them ( hardly any studios were showing shorts in front of the main feature anymore ) The boys rode out the last years with Joe Besser, a comic who at that time had a series of third rate comedies ,also with Columbia. The chemistry just wasn’t there, no matter, the studio disbanded the short subject division and their contracts were up and the Stooges were out of work for the first time since 1934. Television was all the craze by the late 50s. Studios were willing to dump their cartoons,serials,westerns,and shorts for a quick buck. Anyone with a TV can now enjoy the same comedies and cartoons that their parents enjoyed 25 years earlier. This actually revived the careers of stars of the past like Hopalong Cassidy and Buster Keaton. When Columbia Pictures sold these Stooge shorts packages to local TV stations…guess what happened? The boys were more popular than ever…but they were at retirement age…Now Columbia wanted them back! More to Come
I have been watching The Three Stooges for years and never did I know that old footage was used along with new scenes. Rick you certainly have a sharp eye and do your research.;
Good video - very illuminating. I note how Larry's hair was so much darker in the earlier segments that were recycled. Through all those years Moe retained his high energy & was able to deliver his lines flawlessly while the other Stooges declined just a bit. But their humor never aged one bit. Love my Stooges!
Haven't seen it in a while. No I HAVE to go watch it. Yep! None of them were any spring chickens by then. Shemp being the oldest. All of that physical comedy taking its toll. Indiana Jones once said "It ain't the years, it's the mileage!"
True enough! Of all the Stooges, Curly was the youngest during the Columbia years, being only 30 at the start. But the "mileage" he put in his personal life off screen made him burn out just as he entered his 40s and left him dead before he could reach his 50s. So sad.
Potting some of my wording. I was a little bit off when I said about the Three stooges but what I got about shemp boxing match I think was the truth at the time. Thank you.
Did not notice difference when originally saw short in the 1960s. Was a big fan but just enjoyed this short. NOT examining each footage. Kudos for vid. Anticipating ur next one.
I've always wondered - What did they do in the opening as shown first second above - cut out Curly's head and put in Shemps ? I wonder how difficult that was 100 years before computers and copying./ pasting
Shemp's last TV appearance was on The Eddie Cantor Show, which was filmed April 30th, 1955, shortly before Flagpole Jitters and For Crimin' Out Loud commenced.
I remember reading in one of many books about the Stooges that Shemp had a minor stroke (if you can call a stroke minor) at some point in the early 50s. Back then I doubt the stock footage would have stuck out to the casual Stooge fan but now that we can watch them at will, it is very obvious and you wonder how Columbia got away with it. The stock footage is often noticeable (take the pie fight footage from both "In the Sweet Pie and Pie and Half Wits Holiday for example) and it is clear a new short could probably have been cobbled together in a few hours. Shemp was looking haggard towards the end, don't forget he was 50 when he rejoined Moe and Larry and 60 when he passed and yet for most of his tenure he still had a lot of energy and wit. I always wondered if any interviews with him were made or exist.
For Crimin' Out Loud may have been the last short containing new footage of Shemp, but Blunder Boys was last one released in his lifetime (November 3rd, 1955), and the last one of two that wasn't a remake (Mummy's Dummies being the other).
I appreciate your in depth coverage of this subject. Especially the graph. I noticed recycled scenes in different episides but mostly thought they blended well, with some exceptions. Also there is an episode where both Shemp and Joe Besser played the same part. It’s mixed. With Joe playing it, you can see the lips of a woman mouthing “Shemp” but it is voiced over, “Joe” Don’t know the title but is a Christmas time setting and Larry is conniving to get the girlfriends away from Moe and Joe. Hope that makes sense. As TV was on the rise, the shorts department’s got smaller. Larry Fine said that as soon as Mr Cohen was out as head of Columbia, so were the Stooges.
Shemp was 1/3 of the original trio. Babe took his place after Shemp took off to Hollyweird, staring in Columbia pictures. He came back in January of '45 after Babe's stroke.
Shemp was an original stooge before his youngest brother Jerome (Curly) replaced him when he went on to do some movies. So he was indeed one of the three originals before Curly came around.
It's true that Curly replaced Shemp in Ted Healy's act. However, it's only Moe, Larry, and Curly parted with Healy and signed with Columbia that they officially became known as "The Three Stooges". That makes Curly the original third Stooge of the Three Stooges. Even in their first Columbia short, they were billed as Jerry Howard, Moe Howard, and Larry Fine.
I didn't know shemp Howard made a apperance in the three stooges short for crimin out loud don't remember flagpole jitters cool I need to watch this one cool interesting facts I watched the three stooges so he passed away from a heart attack that sucks hate to hear that Rick thanks for sharing the info on this great video Rick thanks 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍love watching and learning this interesting rick love seeing new footage the stooges changed when they got older
@Cade Evans also Cade are you aware there were a few attemps to revive the Three Stooges in the 1970's but sadly Larry's paralizing stroke in the midst of filming a pilot for a new Three Stooges tv series never reached frution. Larry Finn died from a series of strokes in 1975. Unsuccessful attempts were made to revive the Three Stooges with long time supporting actor Emil Sitka in Finn's role in 1970 and 1975, but this attempt was cut short by Moe Howards death in 1975. Before Larry's death the Stooges were scheduled to co-star in Blazzing Stewardesses featuring Mo, Curly and Joe with Emil Sitka in the middle spot as Harry, Moes brother. The team was signed and public shots were taken, but one week prior to March's filming date, Moe was diagnosed with lung cancer and the Stooges had to back out; he died on May 4th, 1975. Producer Sam Sherman breifly considered having fromer Stooge Joe Besser take his place, but ultimately decided against it. As for the original repleacement Stooges Joe Besser died in 1988 of heart failure, followed by Joe DeRita of pneumonia in 1993, Emil Sitka was announced as a Stooge but never performed as such; he died on January 16, 1998 six months after being disabled by a stroke. 😢🪦🙏
About Shemp's passing...On November 23, 1955, Shemp went out with his friends to a boxing match at the Hollywood Legion Stadium. After the fights were over, Shemp hailed a taxicab to take him to his North Hollywood home with friend Al Winston. Shemp set back and lit up his cigar and told a joke when suddenly he slumped over into Winston’s lap. Shemp had a heart attack and was dead at the age of 60.
Love this video! I read an article (possibly apocryphal) that Moe and Larry wanted comic Mantan Moreland to be the next Stooge after Shemp died, but that Cohn said "no" to the idea. Almost anyone would've been better than Besser IMO.
At first I was confused by your chart, but as you explained it, various Stooges shorts with recycled footage came to mind. Prime example: "In the Sweet Pie and Pie". Not only does this short recycle the scene with the dance teacher from 1935's " Hoi Polloi ", but footage from this short was used in two later shorts.
Shemp was a dear too; great video Rick; never knew about the recycle footage which was a smart production idea; on another note Rick; did you see the new movie "Being the Riccardos"?
It's very interesting to know of the Shemp History(ies) like when Joe Palma had to fill in for him and succeed him for parts of the last 4 Shemp Features.
Mr. Rick how many of your subs are over 60? When I was 5-8 yo (EARLY 60's) I got up at 0600 every Sat to watch an hour of my Stooges, I thought they were reusing some content but being a kiddo I didn't know it was possible.
Oh my I watched these films decades ago when I was thirteen years old back in the late 1970s . My Mother did not exactly approve but back then there was very little to watch on television.
I never noticed most of these edits and cuts using old & New footage. We use to watch the Three Stooges at Strawhat Pizza Parlor,on Fridays as that was Pizza Night,& they had one of the first Huge Rear Projection TV’s
Love all your videos, I watched a lot of your I Love Lucy videos and just discovered the Stooge playlist. I've loved them my whole life. The Joe Besser video was fascinating, never knew about the "secret contract." Have you ever done any research on Curly Jo. (I personally never cared for him). My understanding is he pretty much joined them begrudgingly.
On your chart @2:27, you compare percentages with a speedometer, which is miles/kilometers per hour. You cannot compare these two types of numbers. You can go more than 100 miles per hour, but NOTHING goes past 100%. Terrible analogy. On another percentage, I choose Shemp over Curly any day, but Larry's, my favorite☺️!!!!
I read somewhere that although Shemp had a quick, massive heart attack, Moe suspected Shemp was getting slower in his mannerisms in his last 2 years. Moe hinted that Shemp may have had a small stroke his last year, but who knows? They were all slowing down. They were funny.
I remember this short, Rick. But when I saw it, I think it was renamed. I remember the ghoul character behind them. Is why I say that. Did they rename shorts over the years? Just wondered. Interesting information though about Shemp. Good video as always. Take care
I think the 'Goon' character was in several shorts, but was addressed differently. Maybe that's why you think this short was called something else? Just a notion.
This isn’t his last episode it was flagpole Jitters it was actually filmed after for crimin’ out loud. Flagpole Jitters was the last short produced that included new footage of Shemp Howard. For Crimin' Out Loud is commonly thought to be the last film featuring new footage of Shemp. However, the new footage used in For Crimin' Out Loud was filmed on June 30, 1955: Flagpole Jitters was filmed the next day on July 1. Shemp died on November 22, 1955, before any new films were produced.
As a kid, when these were on every morning before school, we watched them on a black and white tv that didn't have the clarity for wrinkles as those of today. Christine McIntyre was huge for us young guys and apparently Shemp with his camera work.
MY FAVORITE EPISODE. HERE I AM MOE. HE HE NEVER KNEW THERE WAS OLDER FOOTAGE MIX IN. WOW THEY AGE DIDNT EVEN NOTICE. THANKS FOR PIONTING IT OUT. LIKE WHEN SHEMP SAYS NEICE IS NICE. LOL. WHO PLAYED GOUL. .HE LOOKS FAMILAR AS ON OF GANGSTERS IN OTHER SHORTS.
Christine was a gorgeous woman and yea she had a great singing voice But she never made it very big Her beauty and singing voice should have taken her higher in her career
Shemp was absolutely hilarious. I love every short he is in.
He was the most awesome Stooge, and the shorts with him are the best!
What a great team of comedians.This type of slapstick comedy was so good and they did not have to be nasty to try to be funny like some do nowadays.Great home spun entertainment,and something the kids could watch.Thanks Rick,good job.
Moe could get pretty "nasty" in those films, and I don't mean just when he would hit the other two Stooges, but also when he used to call them insulting names like "feather-brained imbeciles," "knuckleheads," "chowderheads," "lunkheads," etc, etc. All the fights they would get into, either among themselves or with others, were rather nasty too.
As for their shorts being a show "the kids could watch," it should be remembered that a lot of parents objected to these movies because they were "too violent," because they feared that they might encourage their children to imitate the way Moe would whack the other Stooges on the head, or twist their noses or ears around, or poke them in the eyes, and so on. In reality, there's very little evidence of any child aping the behavior of this famous comedy team.
@@michaelpalmieri7335 That's why Moe is my least favorite Stooge; he could dish out the abuse, but he couldn't take it, unless it was from a non Stooge, plus I didn't like his name calling.
Poor Shemp. He's really underrated. RIP
Very underrated. He was the GOAT
Legalize Shemp.
@@rickninegcan you prove any of this because what your saying is they literally spliced together part's from old movies so unless your weird well you are but unless you just sat there watched every single one to see if you might notice some same sequences your just stupid
In fact, before Curly, he was the original stooge with Ted before moving to his solo acting
Yes the stooges brought countless hours of fun, Their ability to make people laugh was priceless. Hard to believe they are all gone now. And we their viewing audience is all grown up.
Most people that saw these shorts (first run) are gone as well. The first short was 90 years ago. (and you'd have to be old enough to remember watching them, add 10 years?)
I got my Stooge addiction in the 70's, from Sunday mornings, WSBK TV 38, Boston.
Good times.
@@kurtbarlow9402 So true where does the time go...
@@kurtbarlow9402 - got mine in the early 80's, TBS i believe. Countless hours of laughter and my son loves them too
@@brianstrutter1501
Passing down the tradition, good man.
@@kurtbarlow9402
I know about that Boston channel. When I lived in Yonkers, NY, our cable TV system picked up a few out-of-state stations, including WSBK, which was referred to as Boston's "superstation," in other words, the equivalent of Ted Turner's TBS.
I remember watching the 3 Stooges on WSBK, just as you used to do.
I saw this in the late 60's, early 70's and as a child I really didn't notice the age difference. Quite interesting, thanks Rick!
Hey Rick, I find this fascinating, I never realized how much the Stooges reused footage!!! Thanks for sharing this video!! 👍👍🙂
I'm quite aware of how the Stooges reused old footage. This is probably because Harry Cohn, the head of Columbia Pictures, which made the Stooges' films, was known to be a bit of a tightwad who would look for any way of cutting back on the studio's budget. He figured that it was cheaper to reuse old stock footage (especially when Moe, Larry, and Shemp would remake some of their older shorts with Shemp using Curly's lines) than to film new footage.
As a matter of fact, the last four films featuring Shemp as the "third stooge" (including the one discussed here, which was the very LAST one) were made around the time or shortly after he had passed away (one or two of them were released in 1956, the year after he died). How, you may ask? Well, the studio, with Moe and Larry's help, simply reworked some of their earlier Shemp shorts by using or combining stock footage from the older films, and then adding in new footage that would either show Moe and Larry alone or where they would use a stand-in for Shemp. This was done with their 1956 short called "Commotion On The Ocean," which made liberal use of scenes from two films from the late 1940s, "Crime On Their Hands"and "Dunked In The Deep."
"For Crimin' Out Loud," the film talked about here, was also a reworking of an older short. I forget which one, though.
It wss called "Who Done It?" It was filmed in 1949. "For Crimin' Out Loud" was one of several 1950s Stooges' shorts recycled from earlier shorts featuring actors who were deceased including Duke York, Simona Boniface, Ted Lorch, and, of course, Shemp and Curly (Booty and the Beast).
@@radicalross7700
Thanks for the information. I appreciate it.
In my opinion, Shemp was the funniest of all the Stooges. He was always my favorite.
he was underrated than the others, he didn't try to be like curly he tried to be himself, come up with his own acts and expressions, so yeah was good when it came to be part of his own character, it's just too bad joe besser couldn't do any better, but at the same time he was just a quick replacement, even though they also had joe palma as fake shemp for 4 shorts before they brought besser, but still curly in my opinion is always the star for all fans to enjoy, each stooge had there own characters.
Shemp Howard was a comedy genius
“Early Curly”! Love the chart! Great work on this video. I can definitely see the footage differences and understand why they had to use this in their creative process. It is a bit distracting to me visually, but the overall comedy of the Stooges helps overcome that. It would be interesting to see you do another type of this video, if not the Stooges, maybe regarding another subject. 👍🏻
I would be happy to do another video like this. Maybe Stooges or another show. I’m trying to think of another where footage is reused like that
I know you will come up with some amazing idea, you’re good like that! If not the Stooges, perhaps the Marx Brothers or Laurel and Hardy, 2 shows you’ve covered previously on the channel? 🤔
Shemp had several solo shorts by Columbia Pictures as well; all worth watching. My favorite is called "Mr. Noisy" & it's here on RUclips.
You'll recognize much from The Three Stooges in those films, believe me !!
🚬😎
I watched some of those as well. He was a great solo actor.
Thanks for the great stooge content. You are the only one on RUclips that does them justice with your careful analysis, obviously all done with great love for the boys. I hope to see many more like this!
Shemp was my favorite one!
It's crazy that they had so much older footage that they could actually use to fill in and keep enough continuity with the newer footage to create that short. I think it all matched up pretty nicely, considering the fact that I never knew they did that until watching your video right now. And Ive been watching the Three Stooges off and on for many years. I think that their shorts also offer a fascinating glimpse into the Los Angeles area of the past. Rick, this is a great video. You give some very interesting information that I didn't know, but am very interested in learning about. I'm officially your most recent subscriber, and I'm looking forward to watching more of your work. Thank you.
Curly was a treasure...Larry was my favorite. After Curly, it took me awhile to get used to Shemp, I'll be honest here. But after a few shorts, he grew on me. When I watched his final short, I did notice some differences in the scenes, but...it worked!!! Thank you for the video!!!
I know what you mean about Shemp. I was 4 years old when I saw films featuring Curly.
Then after a few months, I saw films featuring Shemp and disliked him for the "unforgivable sin" of not being Curly. And what kind of a name was Shemp?
As a teenager, I came to like Shemp, but he'll always be a close second to Curly.
Another excellent job of research, Rick. I knew that Columbia used stock footage in some of the Stooges shorts, but had no idea that they used that much! I guess as the Stooges aged, they figured the younger versions had more energy and were more appealing as your pointed out in addition to being much cheaper to produce. Your posts are a welcome addition to all Stooge fans!
I love shemp he's my favourite stooge in every short and curley always.
Can’t help but love Shemp.
It’s cool to hear the specifics regarding Shemp’s last Stooge short. Thanks for the video Rick, keep up the great work!
commotion on the ocean was his last episode
Who Done It? was the last time Duke York (the goon) appeared in a Stooge short. He died by suicide January 24th, 1952 at the age of 43, six days after the tragic death of Curly Howard.
Very very sad
It's a sad fact that Duke York (aka the Goon, Angel, Lupe the Wolf-Man, the angry boss who said "You'll get your wings and the harps with 'em!") was one of several actors appeared posthumously in Stooges' shorts.
I remember going to the cinemas to see ‘Hardly Working’ with Jerry Lewis in 81..before the movie, they played a Stooges short..Flagpole Jitters ! They certainly laughed louder with the Stooges, as opposed to the main feature! Thanks Rick.
Hey Rick, I saw the 3 Stooges perform live , onstage at the RKO Proktor's Theater in New Rochelle NY .
It was 1962 when they released the film " The Three Stooges Meet Hercules ". Moe, Larry and Joe Derita
were making personal appearances at movie theaters showing their new film. I remember Moe telling
us kids from the stage NOT to poke anyone in the eyes. He showed how they poked eachother above the eyes.
I recall them waving goodbye to us all outside from the windows of their tour bus which was one of those old buses
with the round ends.
It was not unusual for actors to appear live onstage at the old RKO Proktor's Theater. I have seen a newspaper Ad from 1951 that showed Bela Lugosi was appearing live onstage there to perform his " Big Horror and Magic Stage Show " .
It was also used in the days of Vaudeville.
Eddie Foy was known to appear there with all his kids. That was an easy show for him because Eddie Foy lived in New Rochelle with his big family. I remember as a kid seeing the old run down Foy home on Shore Road. It eventually was
knocked own and the family donated the land to the City with the proviso that it be used a park for children.
Must have been nice to see the 3 Stooges as live performers as opposed to 2-D black and white images on a TV or movie screen.
Know it well Bill, just south of North Ave, Heard Lou Gerhig and Jimmy Durante lived in the same area. I remember when the Stooges appeared at the RKO Castle Hill in the early 60s , my folks wouldn’t let me go. God Bless Officer Joe!
It's great when you find these treasures. I've seen the episodes many times and you are pointing out things I hadn't noticed before. Thank You for sharing/posting!!
I watched this Stooges episode last month while recovering from surgery, I laughed so hard I thought I have to go back to the ER!!! The scenes in the drawing room with Shemp and Christine McIntyre are some of their most hilarious 😂 Yessir, Shemp really knocked it out of the park in his final performance
You have done it again! Thanks Rick9g!
Hope you’ll get around to covering Joe DeRita. He toured with Larry and Moe to promote “Have Rocket Will Travel” and the three walked onstage together at the end of the film, which my parents took me to see in Brooklyn NY. One of my fondest memories of my childhood.
Wow! That is incredible! How lucky you were to actually see them in person!
I saw the Stooges live on stage at the RKO Proktor's Theater in New Rochelle NY.
It was in 1962 when they were promoting " The Three Stooges Meet Hercules ".
Do you remember Moe telling us kids NOT to poke each other in the eyes?
that's awesome!
Excellent content as usual.
Rick, Thank you for being such a stable creator, and the content is super pure in these ages which I really appreciate.
Interesting I knew they used some but didn’t know they reused so much older footage.
Excellent detective work. I knew “Half Wits Holiday” was Curly’s last short, but didn’t know Shemp’s. I think it’s impressive how the new footage matches the old footage in regards to lighting and other technical stuff. Columbia had a talented production crew.
Ron, I think you hit on something important here. Everyone was very talented considering this is mid century. Lighting, mood, even the grayscale coloring is exactly on point. Imagine making a movie and then replicating everything 10 years later to match exactly as possible. Quite the challenge
commotion on the ocean was his last episode
Curly was my favorite, my dad loved Shemp. He would practically go into convulsions watching the Stooges.😆
I always thought Shemp and Christine McIntyre scenes were hilarious. They appeared to work so well together despite the broken nose (brideless groom). Did they work together in Shemps solo career?
Yes they did!
I am glad you showed the difference, I never payed attention to the difference. Curly was way Ahead of his time. Shemp was fantastic in his roles. Of course it was silly comedy but everyone needs some comedy in their life. We loved them when I was young but now I appreciate them now.
It's been a while since I saw this particular episode of the Stooges. Still classic comedy by them. I do like the use of the stock footage at times, as it gives them a different angle on the episode, where they can put in a little more acting. "Commotion on the Ocean" and "Dunked in the Deep" are good examples of the use of stock footage, as when the remake came about, Shemp had passed on, and Moe even eludes to "I wonder whatever became of that Shemp!" I think "Tricky Dicks" also used stock footage from "Hold that Lion", and they give us a little different angle on the episode.
Thank you Rick. Never noticed it
How great, this is neat
Shemp was the original “ third stooge “ having broken in the vaudeville act in the 1920s with younger brother Moe and friend Ted Healy as the “ boss “ stooge…they added Larry after finding him performing in another act. By the early 1930s, they even had a movie under their belt, and after Shemp left the group around 1930 for a solo career,( he couldn’t stand Healy) he was replaced by Shemp and Moe’s kid brother Jerome ( Curly). When the boys parted ways with Healy in 1934, they signed with Columbia Pictures to make two- reelers ( 20 minute shorts) At this time, they were already in their mid to late 30s… When Curly’s health started to decline in the early 40 shorts,you can see his weight start to lessen, by 1945, they had to pad him up so he could look heavier than Moe. Notice as his health diminished,the creases in his face grew deeper, and his speech started slurring. More of the funny bits were given to Larry. After Curly became too I’ll to perform, older brother Sam ( Shemp) rejoined the boys. At this time he was 50. Years later when Columbia went on the cheap, the Stooges were pushing 60 and intercutting footage used up to 10 years earlier, yea, you can notice the difference…By the way, some of that pie fight footage goes back to earlier Curly shorts. Another Great Video Rick!
You are a well of information. You should team up with Rick. How awesome would that be,!
Nice summary of the Three Stooges' history from their beginnings with Healy in the 1920s through the later Shemp years of the 1940s/1950s.
Regarding the trio's ages when they came to Columbia in early 1934, Moe was 36, Larry was 31, and Curly was 30.
STOOGES 2 … Shemp died suddenly in 1955 and Curly had died a few years prior. The Stooges still had a couple of years left in their contact…Columbia pictures big shots were ready to drop them ( hardly any studios were showing shorts in front of the main feature anymore ) The boys rode out the last years with Joe Besser, a comic who at that time had a series of third rate comedies ,also with Columbia. The chemistry just wasn’t there, no matter, the studio disbanded the short subject division and their contracts were up and the Stooges were out of work for the first time since 1934. Television was all the craze by the late 50s. Studios were willing to dump their cartoons,serials,westerns,and shorts for a quick buck. Anyone with a TV can now enjoy the same comedies and cartoons that their parents enjoyed 25 years earlier. This actually revived the careers of stars of the past like Hopalong Cassidy and Buster Keaton. When Columbia Pictures sold these Stooge shorts packages to local TV stations…guess what happened? The boys were more popular than ever…but they were at retirement age…Now Columbia wanted them back! More to Come
I have been watching The Three Stooges for years and never did I know that old footage was used along with new scenes. Rick you certainly have a sharp eye and do your research.;
You certainly know your 3 Stooges. Thanks for the video.
Good video - very illuminating. I note how Larry's hair was so much darker in the earlier segments that were recycled. Through all those years Moe retained his high energy & was able to deliver his lines flawlessly while the other Stooges declined just a bit. But their humor never aged one bit. Love my Stooges!
I wonder why there hasn't been more biographies on Shemp Howard's life? He had quite a career.
I knew they recycled scripts and stories, but I didn’t know they used old footage too.
I’ll keep it in mind when I see their short films again…
Haven't seen it in a while. No I HAVE to go watch it. Yep! None of them were any spring chickens by then. Shemp being the oldest. All of that physical comedy taking its toll. Indiana Jones once said "It ain't the years, it's the mileage!"
True enough! Of all the Stooges, Curly was the youngest during the Columbia years, being only 30 at the start.
But the "mileage" he put in his personal life off screen made him burn out just as he entered his 40s and left him dead before he could reach his 50s. So sad.
Potting some of my wording. I was a little bit off when I said about the Three stooges but what I got about shemp boxing match I think was the truth at the time. Thank you.
Did not notice difference when originally saw short in the 1960s. Was a big fan but just enjoyed this short. NOT examining each footage. Kudos for vid. Anticipating ur next one.
Great insite. Love it!!!
I've always wondered - What did they do in the opening as shown first second above - cut out Curly's head and put in Shemps ? I wonder how difficult that was 100 years before computers and copying./ pasting
Shemp's last TV appearance was on The Eddie Cantor Show, which was filmed April 30th, 1955, shortly before Flagpole Jitters and For Crimin' Out Loud commenced.
I remember reading in one of many books about the Stooges that Shemp had a minor stroke (if you can call a stroke minor) at some point in the early 50s. Back then I doubt the stock footage would have stuck out to the casual Stooge fan but now that we can watch them at will, it is very obvious and you wonder how Columbia got away with it. The stock footage is often noticeable (take the pie fight footage from both "In the Sweet Pie and Pie and Half Wits Holiday for example) and it is clear a new short could probably have been cobbled together in a few hours. Shemp was looking haggard towards the end, don't forget he was 50 when he rejoined Moe and Larry and 60 when he passed and yet for most of his tenure he still had a lot of energy and wit. I always wondered if any interviews with him were made or exist.
I always noticed they re-used a lot of older footage and I always wondered why they did it.
For Crimin' Out Loud may have been the last short containing new footage of Shemp, but Blunder Boys was last one released in his lifetime (November 3rd, 1955), and the last one of two that wasn't a remake (Mummy's Dummies being the other).
I think "Blunder Boys" was a parody of "Dragnet."
It absolutely was, from beginning to end.
I appreciate your in depth coverage of this subject. Especially the graph.
I noticed recycled scenes in different episides but mostly thought they blended well, with some exceptions.
Also there is an episode where both Shemp and Joe Besser played the same part. It’s mixed.
With Joe playing it, you can see the lips of a woman mouthing “Shemp” but it is voiced over, “Joe”
Don’t know the title but is a Christmas time setting and Larry is conniving to get the girlfriends away from Moe and Joe. Hope that makes sense.
As TV was on the rise, the shorts department’s got smaller.
Larry Fine said that as soon as Mr Cohen was out as head of Columbia, so were the Stooges.
Columbia Pictures headed by Harry Cohn treated the Three Stooges like toilet paper.
Used them and discarded them.
Shemp was 1/3 of the original trio. Babe took his place after Shemp took off to Hollyweird, staring in Columbia pictures. He came back in January of '45 after Babe's stroke.
Shemp shows up; I belly laugh.
Shemp was an original stooge before his youngest brother Jerome (Curly) replaced him when he went on to do some movies. So he was indeed one of the three originals before Curly came around.
It's true that Curly replaced Shemp in Ted Healy's act. However, it's only Moe, Larry, and Curly parted with Healy and signed with Columbia that they officially became known as "The Three Stooges".
That makes Curly the original third Stooge of the Three Stooges.
Even in their first Columbia short, they were billed as Jerry Howard, Moe Howard, and Larry Fine.
Thank you for uploading this! Please do more Stooges videos! 😊
Sir, here's your order of "final Shemp", would you like a side-order of "early Curly" with that? 🤣🍽
LOL!!! 😂😃😀
I didn't know shemp Howard made a apperance in the three stooges short for crimin out loud don't remember flagpole jitters cool I need to watch this one cool interesting facts I watched the three stooges so he passed away from a heart attack that sucks hate to hear that Rick thanks for sharing the info on this great video Rick thanks 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍love watching and learning this interesting rick love seeing new footage the stooges changed when they got older
@Cade Evans also Cade are you aware there were a few attemps to revive the Three Stooges in the 1970's but sadly Larry's paralizing stroke in the midst of filming a pilot for a new Three Stooges tv series never reached frution. Larry Finn died from a series of strokes in 1975. Unsuccessful attempts were made to revive the Three Stooges with long time supporting actor Emil Sitka in Finn's role in 1970 and 1975, but this attempt was cut short by Moe Howards death in 1975. Before Larry's death the Stooges were scheduled to co-star in Blazzing Stewardesses featuring Mo, Curly and Joe with Emil Sitka in the middle spot as Harry, Moes brother. The team was signed and public shots were taken, but one week prior to March's filming date, Moe was diagnosed with lung cancer and the Stooges had to back out; he died on May 4th, 1975. Producer Sam Sherman breifly considered having fromer Stooge Joe Besser take his place, but ultimately decided against it. As for the original repleacement Stooges Joe Besser died in 1988 of heart failure, followed by Joe DeRita of pneumonia in 1993, Emil Sitka was announced as a Stooge but never performed as such; he died on January 16, 1998 six months after being disabled by a stroke. 😢🪦🙏
About Shemp's passing...On November 23, 1955, Shemp went out with his friends to a boxing match at the Hollywood Legion Stadium. After the fights were over, Shemp hailed a taxicab to take him to his North Hollywood home with friend Al Winston. Shemp set back and lit up his cigar and told a joke when suddenly he slumped over into Winston’s lap. Shemp had a heart attack and was dead at the age of 60.
Oh my! Hopefully, he didn't feel much pain.
Love this video! I read an article (possibly apocryphal) that Moe and Larry wanted comic Mantan Moreland to be the next Stooge after Shemp died, but that Cohn said "no" to the idea. Almost anyone would've been better than Besser IMO.
Thanks s9 much! Glad you liked the video
At first I was confused by your chart, but as you explained it, various Stooges shorts with recycled footage came to mind. Prime example: "In the Sweet Pie and Pie". Not only does this short recycle the scene with the dance teacher from 1935's " Hoi Polloi ", but footage from this short was used in two later shorts.
Rick, I love how you catch so much in these things! Keep making fantastic videos and I'll keep watching!
The first 4 stooges were all wonderful.
I never had to take sides on the Curly/ Shemp debate, because Larry is my favorite Stooge.
Yes, Larry was sometimes overlooked. But, after the slapstick, listen to their lines, particularly Larry's. He had some great lines.
@@dianetheisen8664
Moe :
Larry, if you're a good boy, I'll give you some C-A-N-D-Y.
Larry:
Ah, go on. You know I don't smoke.
Very interesting, thank you for your insight of the Greatest Comedy Trio
Fascinating, thanks for all the A-B comparisons. I guess this wouldn’t work with Our Gang.
Shemp was a dear too; great video Rick; never knew about the recycle footage which was a smart production idea; on another note Rick; did you see the new movie "Being the Riccardos"?
@BeJoyful the name of the movie sounds like the name of a Reality Show or sitcom?🤔
It's very interesting to know of the Shemp History(ies) like when Joe Palma had to fill in for him and succeed him for parts of the last 4 Shemp Features.
Interesting, I never knew they used recycled footage from prior shorts. Guess thats typical Hollywood being cheap..
8:30
Um, that is also reused footage from the original short, from the looks of it
Columbia did this , so they could charge for a new release. Never realizing, the identical films could show up, close together on tv.
Wow I never noticed and I didn't know that tid bit. You are correct. I will pay more attention to that. Thanks again.
Excellent video
Thanks Steven!
Mr. Rick how many of your subs are over 60? When I was 5-8 yo (EARLY 60's) I got up at 0600 every Sat to watch an hour of my Stooges, I thought they were reusing some content but being a kiddo I didn't know it was possible.
I just looked it up. 23% of my audience is 65+. I love you all! I’ve got the best supporters
@@ricknineg Looked it up? Does YT keep track of those stats? Or did you ask in a post?
@@ricknineg And I'm one of the them. Or will be in 2 years.
That's very interesting.
Very much so
Rick, after Shemp passed away ,did the other two ever consider just continuing with just them or maybe ending the act all together?
That thing, the goon, he's a coming!
Great line!
Moe-We'll have to establish the time.
Larry-Ok, but you'll have to wait 'til I go to the pawn shop, then he gets a nose tweak from Moe.
I didn't really noticed the difference at first because I saw this short first before I saw the other short with similar footage.
I love them I love watching TV
Oh my I watched these films decades ago when I was thirteen years old back in the late 1970s . My Mother did not exactly approve but back then there was very little to watch on television.
Interesting! I never noticed that before.
Shemp was my 2nd fav stooge!!! Ty for making such great videos .!!
If I were to list the Stooges according to how much I like them, it would be (1) Curly (2) Shemp (3) Larry (4) Moe (5) Joe Besser (6) Curly Joe DeRita
Angel, there's strangers in the house.........
I never noticed most of these edits and cuts using old & New footage. We use to watch the Three Stooges at Strawhat Pizza Parlor,on Fridays as that was Pizza Night,& they had one of the first Huge Rear Projection TV’s
Love all your videos, I watched a lot of your I Love Lucy videos and just discovered the Stooge playlist. I've loved them my whole life. The Joe Besser video was fascinating, never knew about the "secret contract." Have you ever done any research on Curly Jo. (I personally never cared for him). My understanding is he pretty much joined them begrudgingly.
Love the Stooges to this day, I am 65!😉
On your chart @2:27, you compare percentages with a speedometer, which is miles/kilometers per hour. You cannot compare these two types of numbers. You can go more than 100 miles per hour, but NOTHING goes past 100%. Terrible analogy.
On another percentage, I choose Shemp over Curly any day, but Larry's, my favorite☺️!!!!
I read somewhere that although Shemp had a quick, massive heart attack, Moe suspected Shemp was getting slower in his mannerisms in his last 2 years. Moe hinted that Shemp may have had a small stroke his last year, but who knows? They were all slowing down. They were funny.
I remember this short, Rick. But when I saw it, I think it was renamed. I remember the ghoul character behind them. Is why I say that. Did they rename shorts over the years? Just wondered. Interesting information though about Shemp. Good video as always. Take care
I think the 'Goon' character was in several shorts, but was addressed differently. Maybe that's why you think this short was called something else? Just a notion.
Actor Duke York played different "monstrous" characters in Stooges shorts as well as ordinary bullies, thugs, and angry bosses.
This isn’t his last episode it was flagpole Jitters it was actually filmed after for crimin’ out loud. Flagpole Jitters was the last short produced that included new footage of Shemp Howard. For Crimin' Out Loud is commonly thought to be the last film featuring new footage of Shemp. However, the new footage used in For Crimin' Out Loud was filmed on June 30, 1955: Flagpole Jitters was filmed the next day on July 1. Shemp died on November 22, 1955, before any new films were produced.
The term "Fake Shemp" is where another actor stands in for the original actor who is unable to reprise their role.
As a kid, when these were on every morning before school, we watched them on a black and white tv that didn't have the clarity for wrinkles as those of today. Christine McIntyre was huge for us young guys and apparently Shemp with his camera work.
i heard that shemp used to do abbott and costello movies but his scenes was cut out because lou costello was jealous of shemp because he was TOO FUNNY
Curly was the funniest but Shemp had his own brand of comedy slapstick.
Awesome video
Yes I've seen all 190 the three stooges shorts I love them very funny in my opinion.
MY FAVORITE EPISODE. HERE I AM MOE. HE HE NEVER KNEW THERE WAS OLDER FOOTAGE MIX IN. WOW THEY AGE DIDNT EVEN NOTICE. THANKS FOR PIONTING IT OUT. LIKE WHEN SHEMP SAYS NEICE IS NICE. LOL. WHO PLAYED GOUL. .HE LOOKS FAMILAR AS ON OF GANGSTERS IN OTHER SHORTS.
The Stooges after Shemp with Curly Joe, they didn't do a lot of hitting in those.
Christine was a gorgeous woman and yea she had a great singing voice
But she never made it very big
Her beauty and singing voice should have taken her higher in her career
Very sad but true. She was extremely gifted
@@ricknineg when she died and how old was she
@@garyperkins3208 1984 aged 73
@@jimmyswearengin She was such a beautiful woman very beautiful
@@garyperkins3208 indeed she was
Sometimes instead of getting into "analysis paralysis" (that would be a good Stooges short), it's just good to sit back and enjoy the show.
Exactly
Poison can surely age someone! :)