All carwow savings correct at time of publishing. Head over to our deals page to find all the latest offers - Audi A6: www.carwow.co.uk/Audi/A6/deals?RUclips&Make-Audi-Model-A6-Type-deal BMW 5 Series (2017-Present): www.carwow.co.uk/BMW/5-series/deals?RUclips&Make-BMW-Model-5-series-Type-deal Mercedes E-Class: www.carwow.co.uk/mercedes/e-class/deals?RUclips&Make-Mercedes-Model-E-Class-Type-deal
I just test drove a used 5 series and I found a reasonably thicc stick in the door bin, so if anyone annoys you, you can beat them to make them feel bad. I hope the current owner includes the thicc stick (and a physical BitCoin) in the car post sale...
You all prolly dont give a shit but does anybody know of a way to get back into an Instagram account? I was dumb forgot my password. I would appreciate any tricks you can offer me!
+Ali RS iv drove a c class, but I drive for the driving experience I think bmw and audi diliver a good experience and not just a "comfortable one" and it's not like I can afford c63
I love how these cars are really different. - Audi - as opposed to mid 2000s, they do not float anymore, but actually you can feel what is happening on the road. Good all rounder, tries to do everything a little bit - classic VW tactics. Make car that is decent in all areas. - BMW - sporty ride, fun to drive and engaging, good for people who enjoy driving and going into turns just a little bit faster. - Mercedes - this is what you would call an Executive car. Luxury, comfort, quietness, basically a budget S class. I love the style of new Mercedes cars. Is Mercedes still considered brand for people of age 40 / 50 +? Because I feel like it is a little unfair, they have such good looking cars. I agree with that review 100%, but I would choose BMW for myself since I enjoy sporty ride. I do not feel like sitting in floating quiet cabin.
+The Truth False my man BMW 5 Series is always the king it beat the old E Class and the new 5 Series will rape the new E Class just wait until it comes out
Mercedes is nothing like BMW Before BMW always beat MB in sport and in Luxury MB will beat BMW But now BMW is raping MB in both I mean look at the new 7 Series It raped MB S Class in Sport and in Luxury ATTESA ET-S 東瀛戰神 R35 GT-R nismo N-ATTACK A-kit
Great review! I've been looking to upgrade from my 328i and you answered all the questions. I was all set to go with a 535i Msport but then I saw the E class and was just mesmerized by its looks. The more research I do the more I'm starting to lean towards the E class.
Mercedes looks so elegant and materials are so noble, metal on the doors and attention to detail, compared to the other two, it's like is twice as expensive. Would go with my eyes closed for the Merc if I had to choose.
But it feels cheap as shit and squeaky everywhere...get old fast and boring. All that glitters is not gold I've been in them all and the BMW feels like it's 10K LBS but drives like it's 2k lbs
The Mercedes looks way better internally, but the metal is actually plastic with chrome coating. Mercedes are awful for cost saving deception internally now
I test drove all three of these. The Audi A6 was the least of my favorite. Even though I planned on staying with Audi as I was upgrading my A4 I just hated the drive. It's has a beautiful interior but drove the worst out of the 3. Honestly to didn't really give MB a chance as I hate the way it looks. The interior was so intrusive with a huge digital display that screams "hey look at me I'm modern and hip!" Maybe my tastes haven't "matured" enough to appreciate MB. The BMW 5 has a solid interior and great exterior. Very little plastic and what is plastic feels very solid. The drive was the best out off all of them in my opinion!
Thank you, hundred percent agree about merc two large screens stuck together doesnt look "Luxurious" especially when you see the gap behind the screens..
A fair verdict, and I prefer BMW in general amongst the 3 Brands, but the new E-Class has taken the first(next) step which naturally is a step higher up and quite a step it is. The Interior is a marvel in design with character, no other interior looks like it, even slightly. And the exterior oozes of class, history and gentleman stability - Well Done Mercedes!. The AUDI in this trim in fact looks fairly cool and composed exterior wise - This A6 size fits the AUDI DNA rather well, enough surface to gain some toned down mix of power and minimalistic elegance and good stance. The BMW surely gains in attraction when it drives - it simply looks better moving than standing still - But to shine it´s good drivability it needs more sporty and slightly larger wheels. Seeing forward to a review of the next gen.
Mat where is the style of carbuyer we used to see video for small, cheap,family cars, like Renault ,ford , mazda, seat , vw some hatchbacks in this new channel you are aiming fancy luxury cars people who buy this kind of cars don't have time to watch those videos with all my recpect I'm a huge fan you have a great style presenting cars i looove it try to present some economic classe cars and thanks
As a twenty-year-old looking for a used german executive car, my biggest priority is fun haha! So, it looks like I'll be buying a preowned f10 this summer! I'm super excited to own my first BMW, summer can't come any sooner.
My dad is a Uber driver here in the UK. He's been searching for a new car now and came up with 2017 Mercedes E300, 2015 Volkswagen CC, 2015 Audi A6. I prefer that my dad goes with the E Class due to keeping its price more than the other cars and the comfort is outstanding.
15 years ago, the 5 Series was probably the most fun, especially the E39, which was probably the best car of the new millennium. However, nothing is more refined than a Mercedes-Benz, and no Mercedes-Benz is purer, save the S-Class, than the E-Class. The W123, W124 and W211 are legends of their times. AMG kept things interesting, but the M5 was probably the most desired drivers Executive Class car. I believe that changed with the pre-facelift W212 E63 AMG. The model was still bested by the 5er in performance, as it was only in rear wheel drive. However, that particular E63 was faster, more powerful, and it proved to be better that the E60/E61 M5 in overall refinement. The real turning point was the facelift W212 E63 AMG S Model. Now with optional 4MATIC, the car was more confident and fun to drive than the M5, now being the F10. It was also better looking (IMO), was still more powerful and was now quicker off the line with 4MATIC. The W213 E Class vs the F10 and upcoming new 5er will be interesting to watch, not only from a performance standpoint, but from a technical standpoint. The W213 is the most aerodynamic car in it's class, is obviously the most technically advanced, but now there will be not one, but two AMG models that BMW will have to fight off: The E43 and still to be debuted E63. As for the Audi A6/S6, I've always considered the car as a drivers car. Audi has, naturally, been AWD, therefore more confident. Audi is getting sportier than it has been, and is catching up to MB in terms of technology. It was be exciting to see the next A6 come out. Obvious winner is the E-Class. A car company that has successfully migrated from ultra luxury saloons to full on sport sedans , while maintaining it's refined driving and innovation, among other things, deserves a number one spot.
Another fine review, Mat. (You should've been on the shortlist for Top Gear IMHO!) One question - you usually make a point of mentioning the offset steering wheel in Mercedes' cars, most recently in the review of the current C-Class. Do I assume, then, that since you haven't mentioned it here, Mercedes have finally succeeded in converting to RHD without this annoying compromise? Many Thanks.
Which between the Audi A6 40 TDI and the BMW 520d is better soundproofed? And which one gives a greater sense of solidity (when closing the doors, etc)?
Ive owned all of these and now drive in a full option 3l petrol a6 from 2016 and i have to say that its the most fun out of the 3 its fast as hell and luxurious with the air suspension
This 5 series was introduced in 2010. It's hard to say it's fair comparison. But still keeps it up great with the rivals. We need to wait for an update of car
It is interesting to watch after 8 years. I feel like the Audi, despite the initial critique of their design, has aged the least of the brands and that is both for A4 and A6 lines.
The a6 is one hell of a car in this generation, i have the 2011 a8 and even compared to that its amazing in its own way. I would like to drive the s6 of this generation
The reason for the hard plastic at the back in the merc is because that's the place where people's feet tends to rub while scooting across the seat. Hard plastic is easier to clean.
Hey Mat, I'm really enjoying the many reviews so far. I would really like your opinion on the BMW 530i e60 2008, I recently bought one, and it's absolutely fantastic in my opinion. keep up frequent uploads.
Something I've noticed is that Merc have really upped their interiors and infotainment systems. Even though they're nowhere near the best drive, it does make them feel so much more... Can't wait (and I hope) BMW and Audi up their game.
Audi have been updating quite a bit of the interior we have a 2014 A6 black edition and there are around 6 changes I can think of with the interior like the gear shifter the door trim and the air conditioning controls as well as the new touch pad, when BMW facelifted the 5 series they only changed the bumpers and lights that's why the A6 still looks modern inside
In my country, The base model Audi A6 with 3.0L engine costs $75,000 The base model BMW 5 series costs around $145,000 The base model Mercedes E class costs around $175,000 What would be best to buy *Carwow* ??
Great channel. I appreciate your in depth reviews that aren't horribly formulaic like some others I've seen. Cheers. Keep up the good work. The A 6 just looks too much like a Volkswagen. Last gen A6 and A8 were stunners relatively speaking.
and also they looks like the shrunken versions of their bigger brothers; 7 series, S-class and A8 yeah because thats the point -,-, luxury comes in different size and class lol
Good thing in my eyes. This way luxury is available at lower prices and people that want exclusivity will shop elsewhere anyways. Other than that you do notice the difference in interior quality when you campare an a4/a6 to an a8 or a 3/5 series to a 7 series or c/e class to an s class. I can't see what's wrong with that from a consumer standpoint.
+MS there is a good reason for: If you look At IAA, Genf, Detroid etc you See that modern Cars look more and more similar, also the "cheaper" car producers and the upper segment of BMW, Audi and Mercedes try to Be silhoutted against the others.. Sad for the E and S class, 5 and 7 series and A6 and A8 drivers who can't Show Off that much anymore..
I don't know, but it looks to me it's not right to compare BMW's interior with Mercedes's, maybe because of the version or something. There 5 series that looks really nice inside, with nice colored leather and dash...
ding dong that's your opinion but I don't think they are remember not everyone likes BMW or Mercedes but still the BMW and the merc. are nice cars though looks appeal to everyone in different ways I think the Mercedes was not all that to look at they seem to over design the the car and tend to spoil the look of it give me your feed back I like to hear your views and opinion thankyou and peace out there
Again the merc is just unbeatable& untouchable!!!! I honestly feel the Tesla model S competes with such cars and should be included in such comparison reviews, not the Big daddy's; S class, 7 series, Bentley's, Rolls, Maserati's etc
I never thought I'd say this, but I feel the Audi is the best of the bunch, despite being old. (also here in Canada, it comes standard with Auto, and gas engines)
You need to sack whoever's in charge of sound editing. in all your videos, i have to turn the volume way all the way up when Matt's talking to the camera and then way down when he speaks into the mic
So your comparing the older 5 series and older A6 with the latest Merc? Not surprised the result is what it is. You also stated the MPG but the 5 series had a 3.0 litre engine and the merc had the 2.0 engine, hardly comparably
love the Audi's exterior, the Mercedes's interior and the BMW drivability... Personally I'd take the Audi due to its everyday usability and nice exterior, but the BMW is way more fun to drive (especially compared to the FWD Audi) and the Merc makes you feel royal even on small trips to the store for milk! it seems Audi managed to come somewhere between the sporty BMW and the luxurious Mercedes which makes it more of a mass market car for everyone, but at the end of the day, you have to admire and respect all three brands for staying true to their fans and innovating the automotive world at the same time... Love and admire all three, but gun to my head?... Audi...
A car of that size never feels sporty. I tend to think of sporty as light weight and none of these cars are really sporty. I own a Lexus GS and it is just smooth, reliable and clean to drive and yet have people telling me about the driving experience of BMW and I truly do not get it.
+Kevin Daskal Mercedes the same? only C and Eare similar and only from exterior and only from back side. A, B, CLA, CLS, S, G, SUVs....not even similar cars....now look at audis....especially from A4 to A8.
The A4 and A6 are the only ones that have similar interiors, while the A8's is nowhere near similar in aesthetics. When I look at Mercs from C class to S class, and aside from some SUVs, I see the same round vents with curvy flow and a long dash screen going across. Don't get me wrong, I think it's a wonderful design, but the similarities are still there for all to see. I used to own an A8L and the interior was a lot different in terms of button placements, ventilation positions, and all around design and materials used from the S4 and S6/S7 models that I test drove. The word "boring" that you used, I would assume would be more prominent in a more luxurious setting as opposed to a sporty environment, and would be more at home describing a luxury car's interior such as Mercs. I personally don't find it as "boring" as the BMW's interior, but beauty lies in the beholder's eyes, and what one may find "boring" others may not... It's all about differentiating, and I'm glad not all car manufactures use only one design, or one concept when implementing new models.
Why do car journalists constantly compare their current MPG to the manufacture MPG. The official MPG is based on a standardised test so you can accurately compare the performance to other engines run under the same European test. The MPG would vary depending on driving style, driving conditions and terrain, under these conditions it is impossible to standardise a test and make an accurate comparison. What a journalist get in London may different to what Jim gets in Yorkshire, this tells the consumer absolutely nothing. This is why the standardised test exists, it is not the manufacture lying to you as almost all journalists insinuate.
I was on the bmw bandwagon for over 10 years. I was going to get another one until the salesman I purchased 3 bmw's from tried to screw me over. so I went across the highway to the Mercedes dealer. big difference in cars. Mercedes is all about a luxurious, classy experience. for over 10k less than the 5 series I wanted to get, I got my first Mercedes. I never checked out a Benz before. IMHO, the bmw's interior leaves a lot to be desired. it's average. but the MB's interior is impressive! I'm glad that salesman tried to screw me. lol Because I'm very happy with the e300. you may get better handling with a bmw, but the overall experience with the MB is simply blissful. This is my first, but won't be the last.
best seat ive ever sitted is bmw 3 series individual, they was so comfort only better is new 7 series, but Daimler uses shittiest leather on market people complain lot of them
Guys just shutup, the e class despite the sake of a few grand is still king and always has been in my eyes, the only thing people think the BMW has on the e class is handling but you know what, I've drove both 4 years back before upgrading to an s class and believe me the e class handles easilyyyy as well as the 5 series anyday.
Doing +- 40 000Km / year mostly highway. I'd like to have confort, not having noise such as wind, and good reliability ! Which one these 2015 diesel 6 cylinders 100 000Km cars would you recommand and why : 5 Series - E class - Audi A6 - CLS ? Thank you for your answers Florian
I've driven both, personally I prefer the BMW 5 series over the Mercedes E-class. But you can't go wrong with either. I never liked Audi, but to each their own.
Front wheel drive in an Audi A6? Come on.... :( A Audi must come with Quattro AWD If not you should rather buy a golf instead of an Audi, because its much cheaper and also has FWD
All carwow savings correct at time of publishing. Head over to our deals page to find all the latest offers -
Audi A6:
www.carwow.co.uk/Audi/A6/deals?RUclips&Make-Audi-Model-A6-Type-deal
BMW 5 Series (2017-Present):
www.carwow.co.uk/BMW/5-series/deals?RUclips&Make-BMW-Model-5-series-Type-deal
Mercedes E-Class:
www.carwow.co.uk/mercedes/e-class/deals?RUclips&Make-Mercedes-Model-E-Class-Type-deal
in a previous test you said the bmw 5 was better than the E class. how come the e class it the best now?
Or do you mean Mercedes e class
I just test drove a used 5 series and I found a reasonably thicc stick in the door bin, so if anyone annoys you, you can beat them to make them feel bad. I hope the current owner includes the thicc stick (and a physical BitCoin) in the car post sale...
I know this was 3 years ago but my 5 series right now is averaging 54.8 mpg efficient dynamic 520d
You all prolly dont give a shit but does anybody know of a way to get back into an Instagram account?
I was dumb forgot my password. I would appreciate any tricks you can offer me!
3:53 "the Mercedes offers good head..." I was like Bruhhh😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
+Ridash you talking to me?
+Ridash Don't talk about yourself like that... 😆😆 not my fault you have a shit phone that can't post emojis. It hurts doesn't it😊😂
iPhone 6s Plus here, kid. You can act thought, but you're a bunch of 15 year olds.
+Ridash Samsung Galaxy S7 if we're putting it out there, and are we acting 'thought'.
E-class is luxury. Bmw is sporty af. Audi is 50/50
Audi is sh*t your right
You are sh*t!
@@jas197 stfu
@Anas Amrani stfu you probably don’t even have a car
@Anas Amrani I have the S400dL amg line exclusive premium + something you will never afford so stfu
£51,000 for the e class because the optional extras... That's a bit unfair
Mercedes will still win anyway
+Ali RS It won't
+Ali RS even though I prefer the Audi I think the BMW should have won
Have you guys ever ridden in Mercedes saloon car? e.g. the current C,E,S, class?
+Ali RS iv drove a c class, but I drive for the driving experience I think bmw and audi diliver a good experience and not just a "comfortable one" and it's not like I can afford c63
Mercedes was obviously going to win? 5 series and A6 are due for replacement very soon! So this test needs to be Re-done when they are on sale
I dare say we could manage that
+carwow where was there Jag??
volvo s 90 is a worth to review
Dezz9820 i
bmw close to replacement, not audi
BMW 5-Series - easily the most athletic exec saloon in the business. Impressive rivals, however the 5er still the daddy. Sales figures attest to that.
I love how these cars are really different.
- Audi - as opposed to mid 2000s, they do not float anymore, but actually you can feel what is happening on the road. Good all rounder, tries to do everything a little bit - classic VW tactics. Make car that is decent in all areas.
- BMW - sporty ride, fun to drive and engaging, good for people who enjoy driving and going into turns just a little bit faster.
- Mercedes - this is what you would call an Executive car. Luxury, comfort, quietness, basically a budget S class. I love the style of new Mercedes cars. Is Mercedes still considered brand for people of age 40 / 50 +? Because I feel like it is a little unfair, they have such good looking cars.
I agree with that review 100%, but I would choose BMW for myself since I enjoy sporty ride. I do not feel like sitting in floating quiet cabin.
Great comparison the 2.0 Audi v 3.0 BMW very useful.
lol
5 series all the way, especially G30.
The newest car is the best. Who would have thought?
And the most expensive.
Not always the case.
+The Truth
False my man
BMW 5 Series is always the king it beat the old E Class and the new 5 Series will rape the new E Class
just wait until it comes out
Mercedes is nothing like BMW
Before BMW always beat MB in sport and in Luxury MB will beat BMW
But now BMW is raping MB in both
I mean look at the new 7 Series
It raped MB S Class in Sport and in Luxury
ATTESA ET-S 東瀛戰神 R35 GT-R nismo N-ATTACK A-kit
it is not always . just like new 7er compare to two years old S class
Great review! I've been looking to upgrade from my 328i and you answered all the questions. I was all set to go with a 535i Msport but then I saw the E class and was just mesmerized by its looks. The more research I do the more I'm starting to lean towards the E class.
Hope you went with the 535i.lol
Drove many w213, own a F10 535i. No comparaison, since the W211, the E Class isn’t worth it anymore.
Mmh, Jag XF not here? Though my fav is the 5 Series.
the e-class is the best all-around... because it's the newest... love the interior so much
It's better than the new Volvo s90 too. Fact
The best all arounder is the Audi. The most luxurious is the e class.
The best driver's car is the bmw.
+Tomislav Zvonimir Audi is trying to be that...but audi is boring for me.
Taras Tab Drive one first..
Mercedes looks so elegant and materials are so noble, metal on the doors and attention to detail, compared to the other two, it's like is twice as expensive. Would go with my eyes closed for the Merc if I had to choose.
But it feels cheap as shit and squeaky everywhere...get old fast and boring. All that glitters is not gold I've been in them all and the BMW feels like it's 10K LBS but drives like it's 2k lbs
The Mercedes looks way better internally, but the metal is actually plastic with chrome coating. Mercedes are awful for cost saving deception internally now
I test drove all three of these. The Audi A6 was the least of my favorite. Even though I planned on staying with Audi as I was upgrading my A4 I just hated the drive. It's has a beautiful interior but drove the worst out of the 3. Honestly to didn't really give MB a chance as I hate the way it looks. The interior was so intrusive with a huge digital display that screams "hey look at me I'm modern and hip!" Maybe my tastes haven't "matured" enough to appreciate MB. The BMW 5 has a solid interior and great exterior. Very little plastic and what is plastic feels very solid. The drive was the best out off all of them in my opinion!
Thank you, hundred percent agree about merc two large screens stuck together doesnt look "Luxurious" especially when you see the gap behind the screens..
A fair verdict, and I prefer BMW in general amongst the 3 Brands, but the new E-Class has taken the first(next) step which naturally is a step higher up and quite a step it is. The Interior is a marvel in design with character, no other interior looks like it, even slightly. And the exterior oozes of class, history and gentleman stability - Well Done Mercedes!.
The AUDI in this trim in fact looks fairly cool and composed exterior wise - This A6 size fits the AUDI DNA rather well, enough surface to gain some toned down mix of power and minimalistic elegance and good stance.
The BMW surely gains in attraction when it drives - it simply looks better moving than standing still - But to shine it´s good drivability it needs more sporty and slightly larger wheels. Seeing forward to a review of the next gen.
Plpp
I remember when Matt done a group test on carbuyer, he said the A6 was better than the E class and 5 series
Although I have a 2013 Audi A6, I would rather have that new Mercedes. Great interior I must say.
Right now I would too, but next gen A6 should be really interesting.
rude
Would you consider 2014 and newer as next gen A6? Did you change vehicles yet?
I still prefer the Audi's interior quality
I have a 2012 A6 3.0TDI S Tronic with all top spec and i say it's better than both BMW and Mercedes-Benz
But.. bmw is almost 8 years old
but they still sell it
Ali RS Because there is nothing to improve - it even look like designed tomorow with m package
yes its a nice car I have to agree, very stylish but uncomfortable
Ali RS In every bmw u need to buy "sportsitze" option to sit comfortable
true
BMW for me. It looks the best and drives the best. Its also the most fun to play with while spec'ing it up.
Looks the best?
a6 is the cuttest
Mat where is the style of carbuyer we used to see video for small, cheap,family cars, like Renault ,ford , mazda, seat , vw some hatchbacks in this new channel you are aiming fancy luxury cars people who buy this kind of cars don't have time to watch those videos with all my recpect I'm a huge fan you have a great style presenting cars i looove it try to present some economic classe cars and thanks
+Karim FL they are coming. This week was the Suzuki Vitara and similar. Plus Focus, Astra and Golf soon.
+carwow
can you do one for the new Bugatti Chiron, just placed an order- From a fancy car buyer.
+carwow thank you for the response great joob keep going , best of luck for the new videos peace
Watched this video before I bought an e class... So I did have time...
+Daniel Mwai I've heard it's crap. Better get your money back.
As a twenty-year-old looking for a used german executive car, my biggest priority is fun haha! So, it looks like I'll be buying a preowned f10 this summer! I'm super excited to own my first BMW, summer can't come any sooner.
Oh the A6 looks like the A8 ? what a surprise. Like not all Audis look exactly the same...
Ghassan Halboni and bmw's as well
Im getting deja vu, i swear i watched this weeks ago!
exactly! thought I was going crazy.
me too, but i think it was the A4 vs 3series vs C class
My dad is a Uber driver here in the UK. He's been searching for a new car now and came up with 2017 Mercedes E300, 2015 Volkswagen CC, 2015 Audi A6.
I prefer that my dad goes with the E Class due to keeping its price more than the other cars and the comfort is outstanding.
All these brands still chasing Mercedes & they probably forever will
The best of Audi A6 was when I (own a retail store chain) fitted 8 boxes (each containing 2 2m high fans in parts) into a 2010 model's trunk :D
15 years ago, the 5 Series was probably the most fun, especially the E39, which was probably the best car of the new millennium. However, nothing is more refined than a Mercedes-Benz, and no Mercedes-Benz is purer, save the S-Class, than the E-Class. The W123, W124 and W211 are legends of their times. AMG kept things interesting, but the M5 was probably the most desired drivers Executive Class car.
I believe that changed with the pre-facelift W212 E63 AMG. The model was still bested by the 5er in performance, as it was only in rear wheel drive. However, that particular E63 was faster, more powerful, and it proved to be better that the E60/E61 M5 in overall refinement.
The real turning point was the facelift W212 E63 AMG S Model. Now with optional 4MATIC, the car was more confident and fun to drive than the M5, now being the F10. It was also better looking (IMO), was still more powerful and was now quicker off the line with 4MATIC.
The W213 E Class vs the F10 and upcoming new 5er will be interesting to watch, not only from a performance standpoint, but from a technical standpoint. The W213 is the most aerodynamic car in it's class, is obviously the most technically advanced, but now there will be not one, but two AMG models that BMW will have to fight off: The E43 and still to be debuted E63.
As for the Audi A6/S6, I've always considered the car as a drivers car. Audi has, naturally, been AWD, therefore more confident. Audi is getting sportier than it has been, and is catching up to MB in terms of technology. It was be exciting to see the next A6 come out.
Obvious winner is the E-Class. A car company that has successfully migrated from ultra luxury saloons to full on sport sedans , while maintaining it's refined driving and innovation, among other things, deserves a number one spot.
Lol. Look at them now, 6 yrs later. Merc has lost its soul
The classic BMW films with Clive Owen made me want to own a BMW and I'm glad I own a BMW now😇
Another fine review, Mat. (You should've been on the shortlist for Top Gear IMHO!)
One question - you usually make a point of mentioning the offset steering wheel in Mercedes' cars, most recently in the review of the current C-Class. Do I assume, then, that since you haven't mentioned it here, Mercedes have finally succeeded in converting to RHD without this annoying compromise?
Many Thanks.
I know this video is old and so the newer versions weren't out but it pains me to see you compared the new E-Class to the old 5 Series and old A6 😔
Which between the Audi A6 40 TDI and the BMW 520d is better soundproofed? And which one gives a greater sense of solidity (when closing the doors, etc)?
The Audi is better in both.
@@TheGaang
Thank you. 👍🏻
Ive owned all of these and now drive in a full option 3l petrol a6 from 2016 and i have to say that its the most fun out of the 3 its fast as hell and luxurious with the air suspension
This 5 series was introduced in 2010. It's hard to say it's fair comparison. But still keeps it up great with the rivals. We need to wait for an update of car
It is interesting to watch after 8 years. I feel like the Audi, despite the initial critique of their design, has aged the least of the brands and that is both for A4 and A6 lines.
Gonna miss the BMW 550i.. Just a random V8 for the program!
The a6 is one hell of a car in this generation, i have the 2011 a8 and even compared to that its amazing in its own way. I would like to drive the s6 of this generation
Mercedes is the connoisseur of interiors, Audi specialise in quality and technology and bmw focuses on a sporty and fun drive.
where you drive sporty in a crowded city?
The reason for the hard plastic at the back in the merc is because that's the place where people's feet tends to rub while scooting across the seat. Hard plastic is easier to clean.
Haha, in Denmark the e-class starts at 90.000 pounds!
In Turkey monthly wage is average 3000 liras e class is 600000 liras at least
Hey Mat, I'm really enjoying the many reviews so far.
I would really like your opinion on the BMW 530i e60 2008, I recently bought one, and it's absolutely fantastic in my opinion. keep up frequent uploads.
Well, it is no wonder Mercedes won as it is the newest car of the three. Both BMW and Audi are due for replacement.
Something I've noticed is that Merc have really upped their interiors and infotainment systems. Even though they're nowhere near the best drive, it does make them feel so much more... Can't wait (and I hope) BMW and Audi up their game.
Audi have been updating quite a bit of the interior we have a 2014 A6 black edition and there are around 6 changes I can think of with the interior like the gear shifter the door trim and the air conditioning controls as well as the new touch pad, when BMW facelifted the 5 series they only changed the bumpers and lights that's why the A6 still looks modern inside
Of course the new E class is the best because it's new, it is going to be a challenge for BMW and Audi to match this with the new 5 series and A6.
In my country,
The base model Audi A6 with 3.0L engine costs $75,000
The base model BMW 5 series costs around $145,000
The base model Mercedes E class costs around $175,000
What would be best to buy *Carwow* ??
You live in AUDIenia or what? XD
+Darius Remington lol
Very big taxes on all cars!
+Gamer Doctor May I ask which country?
Pakistan Josh Justin
Great channel. I appreciate your in depth reviews that aren't horribly formulaic like some others I've seen. Cheers. Keep up the good work. The A 6 just looks too much like a Volkswagen. Last gen A6 and A8 were stunners relatively speaking.
Honestly they all look like stretched versions of their smaller brothers; 3 series, C class and A4
+MS I do too.
and also they looks like the shrunken versions of their bigger brothers; 7 series, S-class and A8
yeah because thats the point -,-, luxury comes in different size and class lol
Good thing in my eyes. This way luxury is available at lower prices and people that want exclusivity will shop elsewhere anyways. Other than that you do notice the difference in interior quality when you campare an a4/a6 to an a8 or a 3/5 series to a 7 series or c/e class to an s class. I can't see what's wrong with that from a consumer standpoint.
How does a 5 series look anything like a 3 series??
+MS there is a good reason for: If you look At IAA, Genf, Detroid etc you See that modern Cars look more and more similar, also the "cheaper" car producers and the upper segment of BMW, Audi and Mercedes try to Be silhoutted against the others..
Sad for the E and S class, 5 and 7 series and A6 and A8 drivers who can't Show Off that much anymore..
How about Audi's optional air suspention? Is it significantly less comfy than Merc's?
"Like an s class" all mercy all twins now...which really suck for s class owner. Coming around a Corner or direct at you, you can't tell them apart...
Well done mate!!! You were detailed and covered the most important aspects. Thanks!!!!
Audis are special but this is so unfair you guys are comparing base models of one car and then a little higher version of another car..
Gautham Satheesh that's exactly what I was thinking.
best thing to compare would be either top specs cars or just the basic specs cars, would be nice to know who offers more on basics :P
Talk about the a6 getting a quarto can get the Benz in 4matic and the beamer has something similar as well. will set you back another 5 to 7 K
This just further solidified my choice for an A6 - such a great car 😍
Enjoy that volkswagen 🤣🤣
@@ALPINE_M4GTS it’s an Audi that makes Volkswagens. So it’s viceversa. If u drive VW you are driving an Audi goofy.
@@brianrenteria9181 VW owns audi moron, go back to driving ur busted ass civic
I don't know, but it looks to me it's not right to compare BMW's interior with Mercedes's, maybe because of the version or something. There 5 series that looks really nice inside, with nice colored leather and dash...
Aren't the 5 & a6 due for a redesign?
Yeah, we reckon they'll be out in 2017...
+carwow then why you had the need to do this video?
+archangel z
Exactly
bet the new 5 Series will rape both the MB and the Audi like how it always does
Keep dreaming complexed kid. :D
ding dong that's your opinion but I don't think they are remember not everyone likes BMW or Mercedes but still the BMW and the merc. are nice cars though looks appeal to everyone in different ways I think the Mercedes was not all that to look at they seem to over design the the car and tend to spoil the look of it give me your feed back I like to hear your views and opinion thankyou and peace out there
Again the merc is just unbeatable& untouchable!!!! I honestly feel the Tesla model S competes with such cars and should be included in such comparison reviews, not the Big daddy's; S class, 7 series, Bentley's, Rolls, Maserati's etc
+carwow the bmw is definitely going to get you to a meeting first cause you never have to use indicaters and there's no speed limit on bmw cars aswell
Appreciate your in-depth looks and ...humor.
Making a metaphor of the three. The Mercedes is a mansion. The Audi is a high end apartment. The BMW is a council house.
I never thought I'd say this, but I feel the Audi is the best of the bunch, despite being old. (also here in Canada, it comes standard with Auto, and gas engines)
Mercedes- BMW- Audi, Jaguar - Land Rover, Porsche, Maserati.
You need to sack whoever's in charge of sound editing. in all your videos, i have to turn the volume way all the way up when Matt's talking to the camera and then way down when he speaks into the mic
3:50 Mercedes offers good head looooool
Hahahahaha
So your comparing the older 5 series and older A6 with the latest Merc? Not surprised the result is what it is. You also stated the MPG but the 5 series had a 3.0 litre engine and the merc had the 2.0 engine, hardly comparably
"mercedes offers good head"
xBuzz996 oohhh yeah
congrats matt your independent channel is now fully established
love the Audi's exterior, the Mercedes's interior and the BMW drivability... Personally I'd take the Audi due to its everyday usability and nice exterior, but the BMW is way more fun to drive (especially compared to the FWD Audi) and the Merc makes you feel royal even on small trips to the store for milk! it seems Audi managed to come somewhere between the sporty BMW and the luxurious Mercedes which makes it more of a mass market car for everyone, but at the end of the day, you have to admire and respect all three brands for staying true to their fans and innovating the automotive world at the same time... Love and admire all three, but gun to my head?... Audi...
A car of that size never feels sporty.
I tend to think of sporty as light weight and none of these cars are really sporty. I own a Lexus GS and it is just smooth, reliable and clean to drive and yet have people telling me about the driving experience of BMW and I truly do not get it.
audi is boring, all the same.
So by your terms, the BMW and Mercs are also boring, considering they're also "all the same" cept for the SLS and i8...
+Kevin Daskal Mercedes the same? only C and Eare similar and only from exterior and only from back side. A, B, CLA, CLS, S, G, SUVs....not even similar cars....now look at audis....especially from A4 to A8.
The A4 and A6 are the only ones that have similar interiors, while the A8's is nowhere near similar in aesthetics. When I look at Mercs from C class to S class, and aside from some SUVs, I see the same round vents with curvy flow and a long dash screen going across. Don't get me wrong, I think it's a wonderful design, but the similarities are still there for all to see. I used to own an A8L and the interior was a lot different in terms of button placements, ventilation positions, and all around design and materials used from the S4 and S6/S7 models that I test drove. The word "boring" that you used, I would assume would be more prominent in a more luxurious setting as opposed to a sporty environment, and would be more at home describing a luxury car's interior such as Mercs. I personally don't find it as "boring" as the BMW's interior, but beauty lies in the beholder's eyes, and what one may find "boring" others may not... It's all about differentiating, and I'm glad not all car manufactures use only one design, or one concept when implementing new models.
Why do car journalists constantly compare their current MPG to the manufacture MPG. The official MPG is based on a standardised test so you can accurately compare the performance to other engines run under the same European test. The MPG would vary depending on driving style, driving conditions and terrain, under these conditions it is impossible to standardise a test and make an accurate comparison. What a journalist get in London may different to what Jim gets in Yorkshire, this tells the consumer absolutely nothing. This is why the standardised test exists, it is not the manufacture lying to you as almost all journalists insinuate.
BMW- 3,4,5 series, Mercedes- S,Cls class
I was on the bmw bandwagon for over 10 years. I was going to get another one until the salesman I purchased 3 bmw's from tried to screw me over. so I went across the highway to the Mercedes dealer. big difference in cars. Mercedes is all about a luxurious, classy experience. for over 10k less than the 5 series I wanted to get, I got my first Mercedes. I never checked out a Benz before. IMHO, the bmw's interior leaves a lot to be desired. it's average. but the MB's interior is impressive! I'm glad that salesman tried to screw me. lol Because I'm very happy with the e300. you may get better handling with a bmw, but the overall experience with the MB is simply blissful. This is my first, but won't be the last.
the black edition doesn't even have a chrome grill haha
My thoughts exactly hahaha 😂
+Jack Costigan great jacks think alike haha
+Jack Caskie all the great people of the planet are named Jack. Jack Mandela, Jack Gates, Jack Ali, Jack Bryant. I mean the list goes on 😂😂
+Jack Costigan jack ali :DD
+Jack Costigan what about Mats. It was my bloody joke!
But there's a new 5 series in 2017. Why are you using the old one? Misleading title tbh
Mercedes > Audi > BMW
BMW used to be hands down my favourite but what are they even doing anymore.
“The Mercedes offers good head..........................and leg...”. Your timing is....hilarious Matt!
bmw change your leather seats they are shit same with dash materials. ive seen better in chevy
True that
Not rlly
They've always been shit. Look at a used 10 year old BMW seat, they're FUCKED. The leather doesn't even look or feel good. It's too "waxy" looking.
best seat ive ever sitted is bmw 3 series individual, they was so comfort only better is new 7 series, but Daimler uses shittiest leather on market people complain lot of them
Well i dont think so i got 320i and it got no cheap plastic? Its good ans hard plastic notone audi uses or should i say what comes from vw
My Fathers A6 is on 20s on the Sport suspension and I find it rather smooth but sporty!
why compare cars with different configurations? thumbs down buddy
Agree 100%
exactly
Obeckk They can only review car which the company gives and so it is extremely hard to get the equivalent trim levels.
Guys just shutup, the e class despite the sake of a few grand is still king and always has been in my eyes, the only thing people think the BMW has on the e class is handling but you know what, I've drove both 4 years back before upgrading to an s class and believe me the e class handles easilyyyy as well as the 5 series anyday.
Hang on wheres the XF?
German cars...
+Scuf Records lol
the XF is a good car, but really? you think it can even compete with the Mercedes?
Why would you compare the new E-Ckass to the not so new A6 and 5 Series???
I like the audi but it's so expensive
"The mercedes offers good head"
Family has a 5 series, good to drive but horrendous comfort.
Just an opinion, what about the Lexus GS 2017? It looks fun to drive and also very comfortable.
MERCEDES is BENCHMARK..
A Class over the rest..
Test Audi A6 with a QUATTRO and 3.0t option and you'll change your mind haha
That's the old version of series 5 not the 2017 ver.
Doing +- 40 000Km / year mostly highway. I'd like to have confort, not having noise such as wind, and good reliability !
Which one these 2015 diesel 6 cylinders 100 000Km cars would you recommand and why : 5 Series - E class - Audi A6 - CLS ?
Thank you for your answers
Florian
A6 is clearly the best looking.
Dumb
Please, write what colour specification have the Audi A6 in this video! Thanks!
Neutrally, from this video it seems like they're ranked as
1. Mercedes E Class
2. Audi A6
3. BMW 5 series
The S6 would rape the e class and 5 series
S6 would be compared to the e43 amg and bmw bmw 540i, the S6 would rape them in the ass
And if you want to compare the E63s and 760li, you can compare it to the Porsche panamera turbo s
Oh in that case, the Bugatti will rape them both
@@fairraffles jeez mate no need to hate bmw or merc that much
One of the best car reviews i've seen in the last 4 years or so! Great job!!!
Mercedes and his cockpit with 2-3 (cheap) Tablets joined together
Well said
The Truth it say that others dont use Tablets inside
The Truth for few months it will come new A6 and new BMW 5
+The Truth No
The Truth E -class is not best selling cars in that segment
I've driven both, personally I prefer the BMW 5 series over the Mercedes E-class. But you can't go wrong with either. I never liked Audi, but to each their own.
Front wheel drive in an Audi A6?
Come on.... :(
A Audi must come with Quattro AWD
If not you should rather buy a golf instead of an Audi, because its much cheaper and also has FWD
What, no petrol engines for the A6? Here in Finland you can have 1.8TFSI 190hp or 2.0TFSI with 252hp.
He means they are same Cylinders
This new E Class is great. The 2016 model and prior were horrible in comparison to Audi and BMW
Not when it came to the AMG E63
W212 with 2013-2016 facelift is one of most beautifull mb cars ever. E63 amg rocks.
Please do a comparison review of their bigger brothers: the S class, BMW 7 and the Audi A8
Yea 30k worth of extras on the merc. I thought that car looked too good for the price. Add some extras to the bmw and it will beat it
Not sure why I hate the font on the Mercedes displays so much?