Why All Bed Levelling Probes Suck - Eddy Modding and Testing

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024

Комментарии • 53

  • @SilentRush420
    @SilentRush420 2 месяца назад +5

    I have 5 cartographer3d eddy sensors, any no issues. Just started using their version of tap z off set 😊

  • @Okuhno
    @Okuhno 2 месяца назад +14

    Beacon is pretty good :) especially now that it has contact. i've never had better first layers. Not to mention if you go full contact strong magnets don't matter :)

    • @WhiteG60
      @WhiteG60 2 месяца назад +2

      I was shocked when I used Beacon Contact the first time. I was like 'There's no way this just works... holy crap. I didn't have to set an offset. I didn't have to do ANYTHING. It just... worked.

  • @HyperMakes
    @HyperMakes 2 месяца назад +5

    This is actually a very good insightful video. Detailed testing results with rankings and personal opinion. Thanks for sharing with us.

    • @rubenb.molina6968
      @rubenb.molina6968 2 месяца назад +2

      Second this thought. Halfway through the video I decided to subscribe and queue a bunch other videos. Dude didn't only share very insightful thoughts, but I had fun listening to them. Cracked a number of laughs as I identified with a lot of the issues listed.

  • @boothybuilds
    @boothybuilds 22 дня назад

    Thank you for this video, I really enjoyed it. One thing that perhaps can be expanded upon is the types of probes relative to the build plate size. Most probes work on the large beds you were demonstrating. No so good on a 120 x120 bed due to large offsets because certainly in the case of the Voron 0 or similar you can only get to probe two thirds of the bed. The new klicky and it`s cantilevered predecessor will score here. Also perhaps the new E3D PZ, I am waiting for one to arrive to test. For example I spent months developing a condensed tap for the Voron 0 to achieve full build plate cover. Anyway, many thanks again for an interesting video, well done

  • @eastcoast8435
    @eastcoast8435 23 дня назад +1

    I do an adaptive heightmap for every print at fast speed after everything heats up. Takes very little time. Eddy has been great, my Bltouch was old and losing accuracy.

  • @tylerlane6808
    @tylerlane6808 Месяц назад

    im having issues with mine, can you supply your config so i can compare to mine? its not doing a rapid scan, it prompts me for manual probe locations.

  • @oscaraglio3305
    @oscaraglio3305 3 дня назад

    Why using metal scraper on a magnect PEI plate ?

  • @spasticjackson9578
    @spasticjackson9578 2 месяца назад +1

    8:18 Funny.. I must witness the first layer also !... it's very educational to watch that layer be applied. Nice video !

  • @Iisakki3000
    @Iisakki3000 Месяц назад

    What about the way creality does it by having a strain gauge in a corner of the bed and using a probe for meshing?

  • @MisterkeTube
    @MisterkeTube Месяц назад

    My Bambu P1S seems to know how to get the nozzle clean and the probe with the nozzle and some sensors under the bed. So far it has given me perfect first layer on every print. On my Sapphire Plus I have a home-made servo + optical sensor probe and on my Ender 3 I have a home-made modified unklicky style. Both are ok, but nowhere near what the P1S delivers. And despite lots of attempts tweaking my Klipper startup code, neither is getting its nozzle anywhere nearly as clean as the P1S before the actual print starts ...

  • @3D_Printing
    @3D_Printing Месяц назад +1

    Let's wait for a Build Surface LIDAR scan :) Instant, near enough speeds, full build plate at once, etc

    • @garymendoza494
      @garymendoza494 Месяц назад +1

      Ive been waiting for this to be a normal statement!!

  • @TheHanutaXD
    @TheHanutaXD 2 месяца назад +5

    For Nozzle cleaning, I looked at how Bambu Lab printers do it.
    They perform some strange movement, but the more interesting part. They Heat the Nozzle to 250ish no matter the material and just let it droop out the filament remaining in the nozzle.
    I applied this to my print start and the results are amazing. It takes 2-3 minutes of oozing, then the nozzle is clean and can be used for homing.

    • @KaminarisTech
      @KaminarisTech  2 месяца назад +3

      Here is the thing. Bambu have super short melt zone compared to like the Goliath hotend which i have and it drips for a LOOOOOOOOOOOONG time :)
      Still, 2-3 minutes is pretty long time to wait just for z-homing.

    • @TheHanutaXD
      @TheHanutaXD 2 месяца назад +2

      ​@@KaminarisTech yea right 2-3min works for my dragon highflow. But the wait is worth it for me :D

    • @Grearson
      @Grearson Месяц назад

      ​@@TheHanutaXDcould you Provide the start Code for that?

    • @Todestelzer
      @Todestelzer Месяц назад

      I don’t care about how long it takes. It has to be accurate.
      I use tap and a Bambu hotend on my Voron. I clean the nozzle with a wiper and then clean and cool down the nozzle on the build plate while going back and forth 10mm with z-0.2mm to scrape over the build plate.
      No z-offset issues anymore.. I tried the inductive probe then clicky and tap is the way to go. I use 3 measurements for each point.

  • @ahw5hcgfyj
    @ahw5hcgfyj 2 месяца назад

    I just ordered an eddy after having a horrible experience trying to set up my 2024k1 max which dug holes into 5 bed plates and knocked 2 nozzles loose, and bent the x rod trying to get through the initial calibration. One of the belts was loose and another was rubbing out of the box. Creality sent me some replacement strain gauges, a belt a bed plate and some boards but I am traumatized by the physical probing. I'm hoping eddy can solve this issue!

  • @paulstephenson5311
    @paulstephenson5311 2 месяца назад

    Thanks for your interesting take on this tricky subject.
    Here's my input:
    I have a Voron 2.4 with CNC TAP. It's reliable, in fact it's pretty close to Fire and Forget when it comes to printing. What it isn't is fast!, but that's not a problem for me.
    I was going to change (I won't use the term upgrade because it might not be) to a Cartographer (see below for my Cartographer experience).
    You can change your PRINT_START so that the nozzle temp is set at 150 before bed meshing - there is a either a cool down time or a warm up time - time for me is not an issue.
    I haven't done this change, so mine probes the bed with the nozzle at print temp (260 normally).
    It has not marked the bed (over 500 hours of printing). It does leave little blobs/snots at the probe mesh points if you print PETG, but they can be scraped off.
    Cartographer - I fitted a Cartographer (USB) to my VzBot 330 AWD, it didn't play well! I think it was down to the magentic sheet on the build plate. On my Voron there is only one "field" or band of magnetism, on the 330 there are many bands of magnetism (N/S/N/S/N.....) (See my short - ruclips.net/user/shortszoDxIrudB4w). No matter what I did, I could not get a reliable first layer.
    So then I bought a Beacon H - this was working fine, good reliable first layers. But, last night after about 5 hours of printing the first layers all went to hell in a handbasket. I tried recalibrating the Z probe - that didn't work. I don't if the Beacon got "cooked" slowly over the 105c heat from the bed. I'm going to try it again tonight to see if the stability has returned. If it has, I'll subject it to another 5 hours of ABS printing and see if the problem arises again.
    My experience with the automatic calibration of Beacon did not end well, I had to go back to the beginning and do the manual calibration.
    For my 330 I'm probably going to spend a lot of time getting the bed parallel to the frame, this will mean ditching the silicone stand offs and replacing them with a mechnical "bottle jack" type of device which would give the ability to raise/lower the bed corners individually. The bed on the 330 is seriously thick (8mm) so it should be stabile enough.

    • @KaminarisTech
      @KaminarisTech  2 месяца назад +2

      Your experiences is just a confirmation that no probe is S-Tier :)
      as for the VZ330 i suggest checking out Tripple-Z mod, made a vid about it.

  • @draconpern4132
    @draconpern4132 2 месяца назад

    Been thinking about building a voron, but I was surprised there isn't a design for trident nor 2.4 for a bed loadcell design like the way bambu does it.

  • @mikecrane2782
    @mikecrane2782 2 месяца назад +1

    Interesting comments, smiled at the brass brush nozzle cleaning, as been there done that years ago, and it really sucked, because the ooze set on the “bristles” and caused mis-steps. Shame you couldn’t get a Beacon, as I was waiting for that one. Good work on the BTT Eddy 👌

    • @KaminarisTech
      @KaminarisTech  2 месяца назад

      In my case brush also didn't do anything with petg, nozzle just grabbed chunks of it anyways and stringed away, dragging giga blob across build surface 😂

    • @yvesinformel221
      @yvesinformel221 2 месяца назад

      ​@@KaminarisTechyes PETG is a pain to clean and so is TPU. Have to do it manually

    • @yvesinformel221
      @yvesinformel221 2 месяца назад

      I have tried different inductive probe. Kicky and TAP. So far for me the TAP is the most precise one. But I had to change the X rail and the mini TAP rail for medium preload rail to get consistent. But yes it is bulky and heavy.

  • @mysecondaccount7887
    @mysecondaccount7887 2 месяца назад

    You could always use a pair of regular touch probes on either side, if they fit.
    And maybe touch probe accuracy could be improved if it gave analog readings over an interval of time with small timesteps, that could be processed by klipper? Bit of Machine learning maybe? Can't hurt

  • @Todestelzer
    @Todestelzer Месяц назад

    I use Voron tap. 3D printed. Wiping the nozzle clean on the build plate like on the Bambu;ab printers, first layer is always perfect now.
    I use a nozzle wiper with bucket too.
    I used clicky before and hated it. Z offset was always a hit and miss.

  • @habiks
    @habiks 2 месяца назад

    Using bltouch/crtouch since they exist.. and even before that I made my own touch probe using a pin and optical sensor.. 0 problems, repeatability in range of 1 microstep. bltouch had minimum problems with heated chamber, but crtouch doesn't.

  • @mmakam3
    @mmakam3 2 месяца назад +1

    Beacon contact puts it into s tier, but doesnt work well with g10 plates due to variations in surface versus the underlying spring steel. Contact allows you to switch to nozzle touch when neeeded. All you need to do is run at 140c nozzle and you never have to clean the nozzle. BTT should implement contact also and I'll be a customer.

    • @KaminarisTech
      @KaminarisTech  2 месяца назад

      Unfortunately imo it is not S-Tier, has the same drawbacks as strain gauge. With added benefit of quick height maps. S-Tier solution would be something that is truly hands free and works on all surfaces.

    • @mmakam3
      @mmakam3 2 месяца назад +2

      @KaminarisTech how is it not hands free? Axis twist is only an issue if you have mechanical issues like loose rails.

  • @winandd8649
    @winandd8649 2 месяца назад

    I do not have a metal build plate, so probes like the Eddy don't work.
    I print on a plate of FR4. Why?
    - I only print high temp materials, mainly ASA, and ABS so I don't want to rely on a magnetic surface which will loose it's magnetic properties after a few weeks printing on a 100 degree or above bed.
    - It is dead flat and much cheaper than a machined alu slab.
    - Is does not expand or contract when heating and cooling down.
    - Because FR4 self releases the print completely after a bit of cooling down, I just take it of the bed. No need to touch it with my fingers.(and no glue stick required)
    - Because I never touch the bed and FR4 is such a stable material, I never have to reprobe a bed mesh, I'll be printing in a few minutes (yes, it heats up to 240/100 C in 3 minutes)
    I have used a servo deployed probe for many years and that worked fine most of the time. Only issue as the servo not deploying 100% sometimes. Since a few years I use a 3D touch probe which serves me well.. on *any* surface.

    • @KaminarisTech
      @KaminarisTech  2 месяца назад

      Indeed eddy probes won't work on non metallic surfaces but It never occurred to me that someone would try this without metallic liner. Because in case you don't know, as long as you have something ferromagnetic beneath FR4, eddy current probes will work. You do NOT need magnets anywhere in the bed, just ferromagnetic metal :)
      Unfortunately:
      - You do not need to rely on magnets with powder coated PEI spring steel either, I just used clips for quite some time.
      - FR4 being "fiberglass-reinforced epoxy laminate" expands and contracts similarly to aluminium, it's thermal expansion coefficient is somewhere around 14-17, its nowhere near granite or cast iron
      - PEI does not need glue stick either, never in my entire 3D printer career I have used glue on build surface
      - FR4 will eventually bend like a banana, it is only a question of how long will it take. This is a common problem with it if you take a look at old BGA electronics repair like PS3 PS4. At some point it's impossible to resolder GPU/CPU back because circuit board is permanently bent.

    • @winandd8649
      @winandd8649 2 месяца назад

      @@KaminarisTech Thanks for your reply.
      I don't know about Inductive probes reaching through a thick FR4 sheet? Coul work, but just touching it with a probe means you could switch out different plate thicknesses without recalibration (but I don't really do that)
      Of course you can also use clips on a PEI sheet. But these sheets are so thin that ABS could probably pull it up when there is no magnetism.
      FR4 might expand a bit when heated up, and that is probably why parts release when the plate cools down, but it does stay totally flat. (I believe I use 2mm thickness)
      I did not say that PEI needs glue stick, I only said that I never use glue stick on FR4.
      About the bending of FR4; PCB are thinner thus less glass fiber layers. They're also bonded with copper traces which have a different expansion rate. In an electric device, the components at the top heat up a lot, so that could all contribute to warping. None of that with an evenly heated FR4 sheet.
      I'll defenitely stick with printing on FR4, works like a charm for me

    • @KaminarisTech
      @KaminarisTech  2 месяца назад

      @@winandd8649 For inductive probes FR4 simply does not exist. Unless its one with copper layer.
      Yes it is not immune to nozzle change.
      As for FR4 thermal expansion i suggest you check out that phrase in google. It is eventually going to be a banana, normal electronics don't heat the "PCB itself" to 80deg.

    • @winandd8649
      @winandd8649 2 месяца назад

      @@KaminarisTech Thanks, I'm happily printing for 5 years on the same FR4 plate at 100C which is still dead flat. Works for me..

  • @chlpdf
    @chlpdf 2 месяца назад

    personally i like the microprobe and i see at as a better bltouch being easy to set up , accurate and tiny. works well for me

  • @imst4722
    @imst4722 2 месяца назад +1

    My favorite combo so far was a v2.4 with a properly flat bed and physical probe like klicky, quickdraw, or bltouch. It's incredibly reliable compared to anything else I've used. I've worked with 7 machines on similar setups, and they're incredibly reliable. Currently running a cartographer on one machine and omron inductive probe on the other (no kinematic bed/gantry mounting), and they're nowhere near as reliable.

    • @imst4722
      @imst4722 2 месяца назад

      Beds are all stock 6mm alu from formbot

    • @imst4722
      @imst4722 2 месяца назад

      Carto works great for mesh leveling, but z offset can be iffy. I'm going to swap to a nozzle endstop like on the v2 for now, but I'm hoping the nozzle tap feature works properly, like on the beacon.

    • @imst4722
      @imst4722 2 месяца назад

      Thermal drift kills most non physical probes. Even with a heat soak macro that read the carto coil temp to make sure it meshed and homed within a 5c range and running the temp compensation macro, it still drifts a bit.

    • @KaminarisTech
      @KaminarisTech  2 месяца назад

      Indeed, kinematic bed + physical probe seems to be best accuracy and reliability wise as z-endstop. Unfortunately they suffer greatly from axis twist and they are very slow for heightmaps. I wish to try cast iron bed one day :D

    • @imst4722
      @imst4722 2 месяца назад

      @@KaminarisTech that'll be pricey 😅

  • @SianaGearz
    @SianaGearz 2 месяца назад

    You can put your build plate on adjustable stilts. Ditch the springs, replace them with a nut that locks the bed to the top of the bolt.
    Then put two nuts around the bed carrier. You can adjust them once, then jam them against the carrier and never need to touch them again. I use nuts in flat large printed thumb wheels.
    Springs are bad because they respond with vibrations. Furthermore every time the spring oscillates, it nudges the bed adjustment nut just a little to unscrew itself.
    You still want a bed mesh to compensate for bed shape weirdness which might well be temperature dependent, but you might not even need a probe unless you have several print surfaces that you swap in and out.
    Wanna know what i use for a bed probe? For a time i had a microswitch button probe that i attached to the carriage magnetically manually; now i use a 9g servo which swings a leg, on the leg is a mouse microswitch. I used to use a 3.7g servo but i broke its gears. I currently use it mostly to balance out the Z axis dual independent motors, and to home because i no longer have a spot to mount the Z endstop. I didn't want to pay the price of a good touch probe, and i think the microswitch is better anyway.
    I actually don't want inductive since i use glass plates and will probably be using all sorts of clip-on bed type things.

  • @meslammer1744
    @meslammer1744 2 месяца назад

    IR PROBE CLAIMS YET ANOTHER FULL SWEEP RAAHHHHH 💯💯💯

  • @deeply999
    @deeply999 Месяц назад

    A bit late but cnc tap is still far better than klicky. secondly beacon is about as top tier you can get as of now.... Revo new nozzle is nice as well

  • @Krautech
    @Krautech Месяц назад

    If you think BTT eddy is good boy have I got news for you regarding Cartographer 😂 might wanna get one and try it and you'll have no opinions on BTT Eddy.

  • @MrGarkin
    @MrGarkin 2 месяца назад

    bed pressure sensors at mount points => top notch
    next best thing is automountable klicky on top of nozzle
    everithing else is just a mess

  • @hdragoon1710
    @hdragoon1710 2 месяца назад +3

    Eddy is worse than Cartographer

  • @Tedlasman
    @Tedlasman 2 месяца назад +3

    Just buy a beacon and be done with it.