Waymo Self Driving Car + Heavy Rain = Disengagement | JJRicks Rides With Waymo #19

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 окт 2024

Комментарии • 98

  • @movax20h
    @movax20h 3 года назад +35

    7:35 Disengagement. The car would probably would pull over safely, if there was not a driver. Hell, looking from the visualisation, it looks like it could safely continue whole ride, but they switched to manual just to not risk anything. Hope the rain season will give them plenty of data to work on improving their vision system and making sure it is confident.

    • @konrad3
      @konrad3 3 года назад +11

      Lidar dosn't work in rain. Not much you can do about that.

    • @tjejojyj
      @tjejojyj 3 года назад +1

      @@konrad3 So it’s a fair weather system? ... which is why they are only operating in a city in a desert state.
      I can’t see why cameras would do better. This is why FSD might never be achieved.
      I found this for anyone interested.
      www.theengineer.co.uk/heavy-rain-hinders-lidar-sensors/

    • @kruemelfelix
      @kruemelfelix 3 года назад +2

      @@tjejojyj Cameras will do way better in rain if they are placed right.
      While Tesla's FSD Beta 9 isn't out yet which will introduce Tesla Vision (and should be a biiiiig improvement) even the current version has no real trouble whatsoever with rain, snow and dirt roads. Lidar is easier to get working in the first place (that's why Waymo also chose it), buit a Neural Net which can rely on 3d data from vision will work better in rain. I mean you can also drive in rain just with your eyes ;)
      Waymo however can still figure this out.

    • @hpekristiansen
      @hpekristiansen 3 года назад +1

      @@konrad3 Do not spread misinformation based on your own incredulity.

    • @mirandagavrin5644
      @mirandagavrin5644 3 года назад +1

      @@kruemelfelix The current version of Tesla FSD requires a human driver to be in control of the car at all times. It has "no trouble" with disengaging on rain/snow/dirt roads because it's already disengaged. Tesla isn't trying to solve the same problem as Waymo is, so comparing them doesn't make sense--Tesla is basically a fancy cruise control, not an attempt at L4/L5 driverless operation.

  • @fowl85
    @fowl85 3 года назад +29

    That’s interesting it had to disengage for rain. It didn’t seem like it was coming down very hard at first.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +5

      Yea definitely odd, but the safe option I suppose

  • @ipottinger
    @ipottinger 3 года назад +22

    I suspect that the system would have (and did) work reasonable well despite the rain but disengaged out of an abundance of caution. Why risk a spotless record, especially with a living passenger inside. Testing during inclement weather is best done without putting customers at risk.
    You can see in the video that the system continued to sense its surroundings and plan its route even though it may not have been steering the vehicle.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +7

      Yea exactly! That's what had me confused, was how smooth and consistent the visualization still was. But indeed, definitely not worth risking it

    • @ipottinger
      @ipottinger 3 года назад

      @@JJRicks Oops! Is the contents of this video suppose to be secret? I watched before you set the premiere date. Should I delete my message above?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +2

      Nah don't worry about it, if I didn't want people to see i wouldn't have put it in the playlist haha

    • @slash196
      @slash196 3 года назад

      Plus good training data.

    • @ipottinger
      @ipottinger 3 года назад +1

      @@kuthegorix Yours is an often stated claim, but you might be interested in checking out:
      • LIDAR Rain 1: ruclips.net/video/LlA2KpCP2IY/видео.html
      • LIDAR Rain 2: ruclips.net/video/TNUHjb5fbqs/видео.html
      • LIDAR Rain 3: ruclips.net/video/VYwS-gtAJMo/видео.html
      • LIDAR Fog 1: ruclips.net/video/aTv19KRk1-s/видео.html
      • LIDAR vs Cam: ruclips.net/video/7QQKaurQW0Q/видео.html
      • LIDAR vs Cam: ouster.com/blog/lidar-vs-camera-comparison-in-the-rain/

  • @ivanbreak
    @ivanbreak 3 года назад +4

    Car thinks humans are God, it say : Resolve computer issue - Weather

  • @ru95
    @ru95 3 года назад +25

    The safety drivers really don't like small talk do they haha

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +29

      Nah I'm not technically supposed to talk to them haha

    • @DerKatzeSonne
      @DerKatzeSonne 3 года назад +17

      I guess I wouldn't want to small talk, either, if I was being filmed at that time :D

    • @nonconsensualopinion
      @nonconsensualopinion 3 года назад +14

      Probably a rule to guarantee focus and safety.

    • @CookiePepper
      @CookiePepper 3 года назад +3

      @@nonconsensualopinion It has a (safety) driver monitoring camera.

    • @ivok9846
      @ivok9846 3 года назад

      can women do much talk while driving?

  • @benjamincorgi
    @benjamincorgi 3 года назад +5

    Aw crap couldn't make it to the premiere, but its so good to see how friendly the drivers are if you have one, and if there wasn't one would you have to pull over and get another one? And how would that car leave? I guess maybe roadside assistance.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +4

      Yea probably either roadside assistance would finish the trip or I take Lyft haha

  • @arizonaelevatorsandmore2778
    @arizonaelevatorsandmore2778 3 года назад +5

    Do they make the cars with the self driving equipment on them or are they just regular Pacificas with the self driving equipment added to them?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +6

      Hybrid Pacificas retrofitted with the equipment, yes

    • @DerKatzeSonne
      @DerKatzeSonne 3 года назад +2

      There will be retrofited Jaguar i-Paces at some point.

  • @eastcostzen7887
    @eastcostzen7887 3 года назад +2

    Call seems unnecessary if there's a driver in the car, which they should know there is.

  • @HardKore5250
    @HardKore5250 3 года назад

    Level 5 autonomous is the holy grail I think earliest that could be achieved is 5 years max would be 10 years. Level 5 the car drives itself anytime in any conditions there is no higher level.

  • @RubenKelevra
    @RubenKelevra 3 года назад +6

    Don't know but this "support calls" sounds so strange to me as a foreigner. 🤔

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +2

      How so?

    • @notmyfaultthisishappening3795
      @notmyfaultthisishappening3795 3 года назад +2

      Maybe it's less formal and more casual? Still pretty professional

    • @RubenKelevra
      @RubenKelevra 3 года назад +2

      @@JJRicks just cringe. Dunno what exactly it is.
      As an example, he asks the safety driver if she's comfortable to continue the drive. I mean, should she say no and let you walk in the rain instead? 🤔 😁
      Also he got a notification from the car and takes like 30 seconds to understand what's going on, I mean it's raining and there's a safety driver operating the car.

    • @space-gaming1417
      @space-gaming1417 3 года назад

      @@RubenKelevra i think he asked her if she is confortable to continue the drive, to know if the storm was to heavy and if she would like to stop and wait a little to better wheather '-

    • @RubenKelevra
      @RubenKelevra 3 года назад +1

      @@space-gaming1417 if so she's probably old enough to make the decision on her own, don't you think? 🤔

  • @DerKatzeSonne
    @DerKatzeSonne 3 года назад +4

    What is that big red area at 12:05?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +7

      A place where it's not allowed to go

    • @DerKatzeSonne
      @DerKatzeSonne 3 года назад +1

      @@JJRicks so it bascially can't go this road the other way round? Hmm weird.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад

      @@DerKatzeSonne yep!

  • @truthteller4442
    @truthteller4442 3 года назад +1

    Got a ride from a car with someone behind the wheel.....so, a taxi?

  • @paulhyland7456
    @paulhyland7456 5 месяцев назад

    It's a bit like a cybertruck. You can't use that in the rain, either.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  5 месяцев назад

      Yes you can. This video is old

  • @HardKore5250
    @HardKore5250 3 года назад +7

    In 5 years these vehicles are going to be so advanced.

  • @Travelinmatt1976
    @Travelinmatt1976 3 года назад

    I wonder if they'll have auto wipers when the cars are able to handle rain. I'd feel nervous if I was riding in one and couldn't see out the windshield.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  Год назад

      Now they do, I believe

  • @dmoney937dyt
    @dmoney937dyt 3 года назад +1

    Alrite man you know i got questions. That car disengaged the moment it started raining and went into manual with no warning, wat happens if there wasnt a driver in that seat on a normal day when the rain comes outta nowhere?
    Also why was the video speed up several times in wat seemed like an attempt of masking what the safety driver had to say or do, i only ask this part because i heard you say something about turning off the cameras at the start of the ride?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +4

      Alright alright here ya go:
      1. It disengaged only because the safety driver told it to. What the car was about to do was pull over in a safe location.
      2. Not masking anything, you can slow it down and see for yourself. I just sped up the boring manual driving and pointless small talk

    • @dmoney937dyt
      @dmoney937dyt 3 года назад +1

      @@JJRicks it seemed like it just gave up it happened so fast and then immediately after support called as if there was a major issue so i wasnt sure wat happened or how

  • @TheWinstn60
    @TheWinstn60 3 года назад +5

    Why is there a safety driver? Is it because it’s raining

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +4

      Yes

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +5

      @@Thepewdiepiebro5 idk man I'm just getting in a car and pointing a camera out the window

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +3

      Except as you'll see in the video, the LiDAR point cloud still perfectly represented the environment

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +1

      On the rider screen. And is still saw all the cars too!

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +1

      @@Thepewdiepiebro5 well to be fair I didn't really show the screen in this video, but I do in my other videos. It's the screen that sits on the back of the driver's/passenger side head rests and gives the rider info about what the car can see and what it's about to do. On the rider screen it will also show the LiDAR point cloud, which represents what the LiDAR can see in realtime

  • @arizonaelevatorsandmore2778
    @arizonaelevatorsandmore2778 3 года назад

    I noticed that there’s aftermarket tint on the front windows, why do they put window tint on the front windows of the car? I thought most fleet vehicles don’t have aftermarket tint, what window tinting company did the Waymo windows?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +2

      Edit: I'm an idiot you're not talking about the windshield. Yea not sure on that one :P

    • @arizonaelevatorsandmore2778
      @arizonaelevatorsandmore2778 3 года назад

      @@JJRicks During the day you can see the aftermarket tint, it’s not very dark but it’s definitely aftermarket tint, they never put tint on the front two windows at the factory, if you notice that the front windows look tinted, it’s aftermarket tint. I noticed the tint on the front windows of the Waymo. Look very closely at the front windows.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +1

      Yeaaaa I'm silly sorry about that haha, totally misunderstood what you were saying. That's an interesting catch!

    • @arizonaelevatorsandmore2778
      @arizonaelevatorsandmore2778 3 года назад

      @@JJRicks What window tinting company did the window tinting for Waymo?

  • @ipottinger
    @ipottinger 3 года назад +5

    Hi. I don't know why Feedly is letting me see these videos early. It has perplexed me. The only clue I've had that something strange is happening is when I click the link in Feedly and the video is tagged "Unlisted" with "No views." The is no indication beforehand distinguishing it from your publicly listed videos. I've gone back, from time to time, to see if a video has since been listed, but, surprisingly, most have not.
    I've not shared any of these videos. That would be antithetical to the "Unlisted" tag. The only way I see I could avoid these videos is to remove your feed from Feedly, which would be a shame. Feedly is my main gateway to the internet. If I removed your feed, I would likely miss most of your videos.
    Sorry for any unwanted intrusions. No harm was intended. --- Ian

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +3

      Hey no worries! :D I'm adding these videos to the playlist on purpose just so anyone who cared enough could watch them as soon as I upload instead of once every 3 days. Only reason I knew it was Feedly was because of my RUclips backend statistics, typically the day after I upload the video it says 1 view, from external source "Feedly" haha. So keep on doing what you're doing, I think it's great 👍

    • @TheDiplomat27
      @TheDiplomat27 3 года назад

      @@JJRicks I look forward to the video to see what happened. Although, I will be disappointed if the car disengaged for just some little light rain. The sensors should be able to handle light rain. I would imagine it disengaged because of more heavy rain where there was some visibility issues.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +3

      Yea bit of heavy rain, but I was also kinda disappointed honestly. Hopefully improves over time and whatnot

    • @TheDiplomat27
      @TheDiplomat27 3 года назад

      @@JJRicks Thanks

    • @sonichedgehogtheyoutuber
      @sonichedgehogtheyoutuber 3 года назад +1

      @@JJRicks I already subscribed you and I followed you on Instagram I can't wait to ride in those cars

  • @charlesalexanderable
    @charlesalexanderable 3 года назад +1

    Time stamp?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +1

      7ish minutes

  • @lordfrazerirwin990
    @lordfrazerirwin990 3 года назад +1

    Switching to manual. What if the passenger does not have a driving licence? Sounds too iffie for me.

  • @petecoventry6858
    @petecoventry6858 3 года назад

    Unless its a ghost someone was driving with a mask on at 0:20

  • @teslascoop2177
    @teslascoop2177 3 года назад +4

    "We have some issues with some weather" LOL.. Probably because sensor pack on top doesn't have any wipers on it? Also what's up with the driver? I thought they were already advanced enough to do pre-mapped areas without one?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +7

      Rain precautions, at least that's what they said in the announcement. Also you must have missed it in my bonus clips video, there's definitely wipers lol

    • @teslascoop2177
      @teslascoop2177 3 года назад +1

      @@JJRicks Do you know if they have any way to get rain/snow off sensors? They probably thought about this.. or maybe not.. Tesla AP can drive through pretty heavy rain with very low visibility and doesn't even feel it.. Waymo got LIDAR so it should be even more resistant? Or maybe it was something else, for example Tesla AP sometimes complains side cameras are blinded by aftermarket HID headlights at night and AP disengages..

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +3

      @@teslascoop2177 Yes ruclips.net/video/MpDbX1FViWk/видео.html

    • @DerKatzeSonne
      @DerKatzeSonne 3 года назад +1

      @@JJRicks But only the dome lidar has wipers, right? Wondering if the other lidars would have problems maybe?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +2

      I think if we look closely the wipers are only actually wiping the cameras, I'm not sure ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

  • @darthclide
    @darthclide 3 года назад +1

    Maybe you know better after using it before, but are you sure that100% of the picture on the screen is real time data? And not simply cars + stop lights that are realtime?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад

      Yup! through observation I am 100% confident

  • @topofthegreen
    @topofthegreen Год назад

    I dont think Uber drivers have anything to worry about, these wont be sucessful.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  Год назад

      This video is almost three years old. They've launched an entirely new generation of cars and software since then

  • @markhuotari8665
    @markhuotari8665 3 года назад +1

    Is that a safety driver driving

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +2

      They were not driving in the beginning, then once it says manual they are

  • @bearcubdaycare
    @bearcubdaycare 2 года назад

    That's not heavy rain. I've seen rain heavy enough to limit visibility to ten meters, on multiple occasions.

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  2 года назад

      Congratulations

  • @michaelsecker8653
    @michaelsecker8653 Год назад

    If thats heavy rain whats light rain then?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  Год назад

      It's a RUclips title, give me a break dude.

  • @HardKore5250
    @HardKore5250 3 года назад

    Ask her when can it drive on the highway?

    • @JJRicks
      @JJRicks  3 года назад +2

      It used to, but not anymore. I've heard it was too difficult

  • @AmyInArizona
    @AmyInArizona 3 года назад

    For some reason, I think I’d feel safer riding in one of those.

  • @tammyfretz7346
    @tammyfretz7346 3 года назад +1

    After watching enough of your videos I think its safe to say Waymo(Google?) has dumped way more money into this project than it will ever make back (Being they dont sell any patents developed and are just taking money in from riders)