Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Guilded vs Discord (Revisited)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 авг 2024
- Sponsored by Ugreen. Get your Ugreen 100W GaN Power Strip in the links below!
Amazon: amzn.to/3ek0DEu
Official Website: bit.ly/3KQHXbx
Get 24% off with code 15UGREEN100W
Roblox acquired Guilded.gg not too long ago and it made me wonder, is Guilded.gg a good alternative to Discord? Guilded has a ton of features for free that Discord hides behind their nitro paid subscription. Furthermore, Guilded has a lot of advanced features that Discord is simply missing. While Discord has the upper hand on polish, guilded has the upper hand on features. Who will win this intense adrenaline pumping battle....
GUILDED LINK
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
(referral for the meme) bit.ly/3QY3QXM (bit.ly since RUclips messed up the link)
(non referral) www.guilded.gg
SOCIALS
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discord Server
/ discord
TIMESTAMPS
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
00:00 - Intro
01:00 - Free Nitro Features
03:02 - Free Server Boost Features
03:30 - Not available Server Boost Features
04:01 - Guilded Bots
05:11 - Integrated XP Bot
05:24 - Integrated XP Roles
05:50 - Gradient Roles
06:25 - Self Roles
06:52 - Performance
07:13 - Premium Subscriptions
08:13 - Guilded Profile
09:38 - Cool Channels Introduction
10:08 - Advanced Voice channel
11:13 - Calendar Channel
11:32 - Scheduling Channel
12:10 - Announcements Channel
12:21 - Forums Channel
12:30 - Documents Channel
13:01 - Lists Channel
13:20 - Media
13:32 - Server Applications
13:48 - Server Groups
14:19 - Partnership Program
14:45 - Summary
Thank you Ugreen for sponsoring this video! Get your Ugreen 100W GaN Power Strip in the links below!
Amazon: amzn.to/3ek0DEu
Official Website: bit.ly/3KQHXbx
Get 24% off with code 15UGREEN100W
ugrin
Click da link people, give him money
@@Arvl. m o n e y
Guess who asked
@@_lun4r_ I did
It's great to hear you revisited Guilded, and thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts in this awesome video. We appreciate your feedback and have shared your video with the team. Thank you. 💛
Hi guilded
Great to see the devs themselves being open to feedback like this!
open source when
Yooo hiii guilded
Didn't see Discord doing this in any video
EDIT: also give bobux
the selling point for me is the media file limit. Discord's 8mb limit is a joke
True, sometimes I want to share images but they take so much space only after compressions they would fit in this. It makes no sense literally.
I sometimes just compress files into 8MB zip parts, and send them all.
It's a bit annoying, but Discord loses in the end, so I'll continue doing it
There’s a website called 8mb or something which compresses any video or image to 8mb, 50mb or 100mb
@@masteryooda9087 "conpress" aka make ur video look bad as hell
@@inforced tbh it’s really not that bad
I just hate how Discord recently is just stealing features from Guilded. I have seen so many features on Guilded way before Discord even started talking about adding them
and besides that discord doesnt even tell anyone about adding features, u just get a generalized "changelog"/announcement half a year after its been added, it annoys me so much
That’s what discord has been doing forever back then it was stealing from better discord
@@hi-kt3qr better discord is a mod for discord..
Ermmm.. guilded litterally copied discords color scheme, ui layout, domain name extension, permissions, bots, the way replies look, animated profile images and basically any unique discord feature. I think this might even go to court.
@@MrJellekeulemans damn so discord owns the idea of a chat app? discords ui was literally based off of a couple irc clients mixed together, its not like discords is original either
Really nice to see other people making high quality Guilded - Discord comparison videos. Keep up the good work!
no
XMPP/Matrix
@@fishypugbruh Stop
All you're doing is annoying people and turning them away from XMPP
14:40 my concern with this is discord originally was "the homies" and slowly became this evil corporation thing over time, so I’m concerned this might happen with guilded too.
Plus the fact they got bought by a certain corporately evil games platform that lately hasnt been listening much to its playerbase and instead decided to do stupid things..
likely wont happen with guilded because it has no expectation of making any money, roblox just dumps like a billion dollars into it and calls it a day. but with discord they always have to be making profit
@@-fv this is the most stupid thing i've ever heard
@@EggdogGuy Tbh Discord is also doing that. So yeah, Discord ain't homies, they are at least as evil as Roblox ... I do want to know what Guilded plans to do with the users' data. Discord is shit at that, Guilded could do better and it would be a great selling point to me.
@@Guarrow don't think that much user data is actually sold, but sure as hell it is collected. Discord may want to liquidate that asset down the road.
Hopefully they grow more. Discord needs competition or else they're gonna keep making terrible decisions
I agree
Yeah I actually wanna use Guilded but it's just NOT popular
@@chillbizz74 and still just sue stuff that feel like beta testing
@@chillbizz74 people are too arrogant to try new things and yeah thats exactly my case, i wanna use it so bad bc its so GOOD but not much people use it and the rest just dont wanna
look whats happening right now 💀
Guilded is an amazing alternative to discord and I much prefer it but my only issue with Guilded is that it doesn't have the same size because you can give almost anyone a discord join link and they can join but if you give them a Guilded link they are very unlikely to join it
yea
slighly
XMPP/Matrix
@@coolgu3stlance344 [HYPERLINK BLOCKED]
This is exactly why I don't wanna switch to it yet
That mindset is why it's small, but it is growing rapidly this year. @@TheReal_Vaxeal
thank you so much for making this video, I honestly thought Guilded was just a blatant Discord ripoff with fewer features - this has almost convinced me to switch tbh
if Guilded does begin to actually get on a similar level to Discord in terms of popularity, I would absolutely switch
hi inabakumori pfp
@@stratoshine 👋
Same, I'll probably switch if Guilded gets popular
same for me, if peoples getting on guilded, i'll switch with no problem
To all the people saying they will make the switch if it gets popular: Why not do it now? People need to switch to get it popular, you can still use Discord along it and start a community in Guilded
I actually like and preffer guilded, its more comfortable even if it feels a bit over stuffed with things
Tbh currently the 1 thing holding me from going to guilded is the lack of people i will make an account but the process of making alll my friends switch too is so hard near impossible even though it is better so i will wait to fully switch to guilded
Still, the network effect, more people use discord, less on guilded
@@Arvl. maybe because discord is more popular
@@Arvl. that is mostly why i like it, its more calm idk
@@LegendaryITA That’s what the network effect is, as they mentioned
Guilded is the best. Been using it ~2 years now. Absolutely nothing is better and more convenient for organizing my community and the games we play together. From whispers to broadcasts, scheduling tools and calendars, setting up my voice chats in trees as well. Idk anything else that can fit my needs, especially not for free.
Roblox alt
@@newguy999_ I don't play Roblox.
@@newguy999_ Look at my mans profile lol. He has zero roblox games and like 40k subs so how is he an alt rofl
@@newguy999_ bro rlly shares jjsploit scripts 💀💀💀
@@LegendaryITA LMAO
I think that if it got popular enough they would totally paywall some of this stuff with the good old "sorry our server space is limited, we have more users now so we have to make cuts" scenario. They would probably still make the free option more compelling than Discord to lure in new people.
if both are populor it will make incentive for them to make it better
I'm pretty sure roblox's funding is making their service more free for everyone. Which, i like.
Guilded just gets better and better as time passes. The best thing about it is that Guilded doesn't really need as much revenue from subscriptions, as Roblox's revenue is likely doing the heavy lifting. It's practically a full access platform at no cost. Too bad that Discord steals every idea they make and profit off of it half of the time.
That's business my guy, you call it copying they call it marketing and competition and they're right because as CEO you are responsible for making sure your work doesn't get leaked. It's all about what company has the most trustable structure and the most stable one.
@@natman_bad How are they supposed to implement it without it getting "leaked"?
every business decision is a way to make profit. roblox bought guilded because they know it will be profitable one day. when it gets popular enough, enough to actually be a threat to discord, they will 100% make a paywall for guilded
@@amogoose2971 That is unfortunately, how most companies that seem like they have a lot of potential end up turning out
I think that Guilded is very good and in a lot of ways better than discord, all the different channel types are great and I would use them all the time. But the thing that Discord has and Guilded hasn't is people. Once you got all your friends on discord and you have a server with them, you can't just get them to move on guilded. Why would they change for guilded when discord works well for them. Having all my friends on discord is one of the only few things that make me stay on discord.
Same
Personally I think that this is entirely possible because guilded is already funded, with better budget and all that.
For which I see as an absolute win, Btw.
On the other hand, discord needs to constantly monitize to be where it is, which creates a uhhh YK annoyance among free users.
no
XMPP/Matrix
But the funding for Guilded probably comes from Roblox Monetisation.
@@rodolfo9876a yes
but it doesnt come from guilded
they recently added role icons. literally guilded at this point is free discord and I'm here for it
It's so much better than discord
The only reason I won't make the switch is because barely anyone uses it
I've improved my member base by over 600% switching to guilded. Across my servers I have over 1,000 members. The thing about guilded is there's not an over saturation so you can find communities or get people to join your community easier.
@@Xyphien Oh
Nobody I know has it other than me so yeah, do you think I should consider using it?
@@strikeyz I'll be the more honest Guilded guy here. Yes, you should defintiely try it...but when you use it for long enough you start to realize that members just join then leave and never come back again. So most of Guilded is pretty much dead, there are only 3-4 communities that are actually alive and doing well, but even they don't have that many members talking, just the same like 10-30 people. So maybe....wait a bit or join a BIG community when you want to see how users take advantage of the features, it's insane how creative people can get.
@@strikeyz I'd say so tbh. You can always bring people over, show them videos like this and get them to join.
Fr
I tried getting my friends to use Guilded last year, since its SOOOOO much better!!!
Unfortunately, only 3 jumped over, and eventually jumped back, since nobody else hopped over.
Still, I absolutely love it, and would hop over in a heartbeat if I could!
Well...if you join the more popular servers like the official Guilded server and one cool server called Anime Island (it's more general than an anime server lol) then you'll have a great experience, these two guilds are pretty active, they can compete with some smaller Discord servers.
no
XMPP/Matrix
If guilted had more people using it I’d genuinely switch to using it
yea
i see typo
Same, maybe ill switch to guilted
Same
100%
Hi, i would love to have a comparison between both platforms' privacy pls. As this is usually ignored by most of users but is really important for some. Hope a video about that will come out soon
If you're worried about privacy, don't use either. And, for that matter, stop using the internet.
The biggest thing on Guilded is the file limit, you literally have to compress some images to upload them on Discord, and yet to the naked eye the image literally looks the same.
no
XMPP/Matrix
@@fishypugbruh Can you specify on why this matters
i remember downloading guilded last year and genuinely enjoyed using it. the hard part is getting people to transfer over... its honestly great for group/club organization with the whole time table thing
at first the roblox acquisition was a deal breaker for me but now i'm genuinely torn after seeing all the cool features
no
XMPP/Matrix
@@fishypugbruh based
cant wait for forced roblox account linking, roblox rich presence and roblox items on profile to be rolled out 😒👍
@@quultime traveller spotted
@@JustLostMyCarKeys oh my…
Sadly, even if it has better features, nobody will use it because everyone just defaults to discord
Plus, no rich presence and less support for official account linking.
So I'm not switching mainly because everyone just uses discord
ui is surprisingly better than discord one, you can see someone's level in their profile (if you have levelling bot enabled)
only problem is lack of users
in my opinion, guilded is a better app than discord because it focuses on the one thing that discord was made to be but rarely focuses on that anymore: being a social platform, as the data limit, everything being free, and low customisability with bots prove this, it also does better with innovative features that stray from the social platform goal, yet because everyone stays on discord, i cant make the switch, and i wish it was the other way around.
Personally, I prefer guilded, and discord does have its own advantages to guilded, thats all I can say but awesome review man ❤
@li1ven Ya homie has to rock the classic Xbox live halo pic
no
XMPP/Matrix
When I heard that Roblox bought out guilded, I was kinda panicked because of how Roblox has been going. I half-expected Roblox to straight up turn this into either an addon for Roblox, or make it insanely monetized. Thankfully though, that wasn’t what happened.
Yeah I can’t believe roblox did something good
Knowing the type of company roblox is, there is no way I would use any software associated with them. If I want a company tracking what I'm done and logging all my messages, I would have just stayed on Discord.
I would def switch to guilded if it wasn't for the lack of people tbh
It's quite hard since, I would move to heart beat but all my connections and communities are on discord, It would take so long to move people to guilded so that's pretty much the only reason why I am use discord.
If roblox starts integrating and promoting it actively on their website, it might have a big potential
Let’s just hope they don’t censor every single word in the dictionary like they do on roblox
@@HCProductions_ Since it isn't really aimed at the kids, i dont think this will be the case necessarily.
@@cr4his yeah like who bases something off of discord and makes it for kids
God, I hope Guilded becomes popular enough to actually threaten Discord.
The only reason I stay with Discord is because all my friends use it.
So awesome to see that you made an updated video on Guilded and that you recommend it as well. Hope to see you around!
no
XMPP/Matrix
after this recent news of discord recording our calls, I need somewhere else to roam.
i wish people used Guilded more
no
XMPP/Matrix
I really wish I used Guilded more. It's hard to make people or your friends move over to another platform altogether. I really like Guilded and its features.I love the group feature where you can add game-related topics and channels. Guilded, to me, has a lot going for it, and if more people used it, I think it could potentially make good competition for Discord in the future
@@Etherrite buddy i have some news for you
@@Etherrite every corporation collects a ton of data on you
@@Etherrite why would discord be the only mega-corporation to not collect data on their users lol
@@Etherrite, following your logic, Discord also does. Discord is a thousand times more corrupt than Guilded (not ROBLOX).
@@Etherrite, every big company collects your data. But Guilded ain't big? Yeah, but the data they collect is within its privacy policy. Selling it is a different topic.
I love how on guilded you can create more 'servers' for different games on your server
Not gonna lie, I normally dont care about ads in videos but this is actually something I need lmao
no
XMPP/Matrix
Kinda crazy how Guilded started off as a discord bot and years later, it literary turned into a social media.
Tbh Guilded already looks a lot better than Discord in terms of features.
I’m really hyped towards seeing it as the new go-to as a gaming socializing and communication service. Sadly it lacks the user base and it really is what makes a social media skyrocket since what makes people wanna register is actually the knowledge that the platform already has a big user base to connect with.
Right now as I said Guilded is better than Discord in terms of functionalities and features but nobody is going to actually use it if they can’t actually talk to their friends on it.
So what I think Guilded needs to do right now is actually not focus on making a better chat feature than Discords, but actually provide some features that are exclusive to Guilded that Discord does not provide and that gamers really need.
That is, to build the user base.Then and only then the chat features come in handy.
If I had to suggest some features I’d recommend these ones:
- LFG (Looking for Group) features. I really want to stress this point since this is something I would actually use more than Discord itself, that massively synergies with the chat features and that Discord doesn’t have, at all, and that community servers try to integrate by making channels that kind of do it, but that aren’t really great at it.
Guilded should make some really advanced, kind of matchmaking feature that allows players to filter players by game, age, gender*, long/short term, scopes** as well game specific features (really important stuff, almost main one)***.
If Guilded achieves it, it may become big.
- Native mod support. A good api for developers that should be retro-compatible, easy to use and to make mods on.
Discord actually does not approve clients like BetterDiscord, and allowing the community to make its own stuff is really great.
Also I hope that Guilded should be trying to focus on not being too much centered to a specific age group. All of this could get ruined if for example Guilded makes mandatory chat restrictions as Mojang did to Minecraft.
In this regards, Guilded should be really listening to its community, by for example collaborating directly with Content Creators (Wanna see ntts on stream ;D) who kind of represent the community in a way, or implement its own way of representing it directly inside the app, making the community kind of decide when it can.
* Regarding LGBT stuff, to make it simple, make it only male-female by default, and add something in the settings for LGBT related stuff toggleable in the settings so that everyone is happy. Toggleable because most people won’t need it and if it is there it kinds of takes space you know but it should be available if someone wants it.
** Casual, Ranked, Tryhard, Practice, Looking for friends…
*** Examples:
League of Legends should have elo, role, main champs, etc.
Minecraft could have servers, type of gameplay, game mode (server ones mainly) etc.
Fortnite could as well have game modes, arena points, etc.
Only problem is that guilded is very niche
Which is why i still use discord because most of my friends know nothing about guilded
The biggest difference is discord collects all your data, even messages you don’t sent. And guilded doesn’t, both owned partially by tencent but the fact that guilded doesn’t collect all your data is the big one for me
too bad it's so hard to migrate Discord friends to Guilded.
I think it's a great platform with a lot of potential (especially the customizable bots and media features)
But beating an established brand like Discord is difficult as long as Guilded is still so niche...
Guilded isn't niche, it's really the same as Discord but way better. It's meant for gaming communities.
when the company that roblox bought is 120x better than roblox itself
Yeah, ROBLOX sucks but Guilded's sick!
Thanks to your channel I'm actually looking into creating a sizable D&D community on Guilded, and hoping to make it into something worthwhile.
And? How's it goiŋ?
I would be genuinely stoked if Roblox Added Guilded integration in game, such as Voice Chat
uhh i dont know how to tell you this
@@duckonaroll1913 how we tell em?
Video camera in Roblox
@@jaypolas4136 cant wait for the 56 yo man to open his video on a
@Bedanta Dey there already is vc, I was wondering how to break it to him and it was a meme
This is one of the best channels I've discovered while looking for discord scams to watch out for. Thanks for sharing this! I would've never discovered Guilded on my own in the first place but now me and my friends use this app for when we play horror games!
no
XMPP/Matrix
Well I'm officially sold now on switching to Guilded and getting away from Discord 😄🙌 thanks for this review; I'll definitely be spreading the word to friends.
honestly i just think the lil knight guy is a cuter mascot than wumpus lol
Want to get a role on a Guilded server? Just add it yourself, no need to interact with a bot.
in my opinion, guilded is extremely underrated, the only reason i dont switch to guilded is because community is very small compared to the discord community
I’ve used this app for about a month and I love it way better then discord! It’s great with all the features you get. Compared to discord where you have to pay for everything. This app is dedicated towards gamers and communities alike!
no
XMPP/Matrix
As awesome guilded is, I unfortunately won’t be using it any time soon just due to the fact everyone has discord, not so much guilded. I pretty much use discord exclusively as a means to talk with friends, and I can’t exactly ask them all to switch to this new playform. It’s the same issue with RUclips: it’s a shit platform but because it has so many users you’d be missing out by using something else.
2:42 Alright guys lets remember this video for when he reaches 1 mil sub
While Guilded seems so nice to use and to transition to, everyone else I know owns discord sadly, so even if I were to move, I won’t have much to talk to because Discord became a universal call app.
no
XMPP/Matrix
@@fishypugbruh, Discord is currently way more popular than Matrix and XMPP, so you spamming this all over the comment section makes no sense.
You have friends who own Discord? For real? That's insane. How do I get in on owning Discord and getting a slice of their revenue?
Oh, you mean "everyone else I know USES discord". My bad.
@@Dyanosis Not sure why you took the time to not only try to belittle someone whose first language isn’t English, but also sass about it, already knowing what I meant.
Especially on a comment that was already 2 months ago.
If this is your form of entertainment, to be a grammar police on the internet, then man you must have a lot of time on your hands.
Not sure what triggered you, if you’re just having a bad day or not, but hope it gets better at the very least.
You forgot to mention how guilded doesnt take literally all of your data unlike discord that tracks everything you do and saves it somewhere, even messages you dont send discord collects
Guilded looks good but I'm 99% sure that people will not change to guilded because people doesn't like changes we are used to discord 😔
no
XMPP/Matrix
That's what people said of TS and Vent, where are they now?
Thank you for giving Guilded the recognition it deserves
no
XMPP/Matrix
@@fishypugbruh huh?
@@gamertike, they've been spamming this everywhere.
From all these comments, especially, it looks like there's a bit of a Catch 22 going on with Guilded right now. A lot of people seem to want to use it, but individually don't want to because there aren't other people joining in to use it as well. Funny, huh.
Personally, I'm already using it for planning out a project with my friend, as the organizational features are so much better than anything Discord has to offer right now. But that's a personal server. I dunno, how would you guys solve the "no new users because those people want other new users" problem?
reminds me of the "chicken or the egg" problem
better term would be the Network Effect
Dunno, Just wait until roblox advertised it with their game ig
I mean, Discord managed to get through it, especially considering the fact people moved from TeamSpeak to Mumble to Skype to Discord.
the main reason for me switching was ToS reasons. Discord has permission to read all your private messages but guilded does not. They only store deleted messages
If they store deleted messages, then doesn't that mean they have access to your private messages?
Wah Wah. What a fail.
@@Dyanosis and u haven't read replies lol or know about it lol. It read ur priv msgs they need to say straight up like discord. But all private msgs will be encrypted until needed lol
One thing I really wanna know about Guilded though is it's historic with moderation like how does the team handle illegal groups and users? Especially dangerous hate groups considering Discord doesn't even care about them!
Based on a quick (definitely out of date) Google search. A Tencent subsidiary has 49% stake in Roblox so they could become like Discord anyway depending on Tencent's power over Guilded. Discord is being funded by Tencent more than it's subscription just to sell our info so maybe not but who knows.
Most companies have to sell part of themselves to tencent just to get into Chinese market which is kind of stupid honestly what more than likely that's probably what you're looking at here, and since it's not over 50% they don't have much to speak on the company besides it's Chinese variant and even if they did tencent enjoys having independent Developers
Based on that 49% number, I think you're referring to the Roblox China/Loubu project, which was a partnership to develop a Roblox alternative for the Chinese market. This project ended in 2021, and never involved any transfer of control or ownership of Roblox to Tencent; both remained separate entities.
@@somefriggnidiot Thanks for clarifying. I'll say it's out of date.
Oh shit not tencent
The emoji for roles part doesn't matter, But you can put a default emoji before the role is one way. Also whatever emoji you have for your status will show up next to your name in chat either way.
Yeah he just probably didn't know
no
XMPP/Matrix
Guilded seems much better, considering they have discord Nitro features for free, just need more people then I'd love to switch
2:42 finally after soo many videos gave me a reason to subscribe
Discord is going to probably lose some members from this video lmao
no
XMPP/Matrix
Roblox: Time to ruin this platform quickly-
it’s been a while and Roblox hasn’t ruined guilded.
@@HaryanviKashmiri we’ll see
Nah, seems Roblox bought it for a passive income money
@@Arvl. guided me ie r l x I 4 guid giild gi guilded riad roan robl
literally roblox bought guilded for more money. thats all. changed nothing and cant change anything
The real question is, do they have ways for anyone to make bots? Do they let their bots read all messages? Can the bot devs choose a unique prefix?
I’m trying out guilded. I wanna see how much better it is over the current discord community build.
I’m also curious to know if guilded has a betterdiscord kind of thing where you can have themes and plugins or other functions similar to betterdiscord.
@@DarkSansTV Look up "ReGuilded." Should be what you're asking for.
I think it can be good for good competition for Discord. Maybe if guilded gets so popular and have all the nitro features free, Discord might rethink some of their features and make it free at least higher quality screenshare free, pfp and banner animated free and higher upload size to begin with which can be pretty good. Discord is so big and the only site of its kind so they dont have any competition in the market place . Althought Guilded does look really similar to Discord and I wonder if that can be a lawsuit waiting to happen becuz so much of it looks similar and identical to Discord
Guilded and Discord are completely different in terms of design, no way Discord could sue them with all the changes they made. Also worth mentioning that Slack was made way before Discord and had similar design but they never Discord.
@@Pazee ahh gotcha. Well I tired pc version of Guilded and yeah you can see the differences but it really is insanely similar to Discord, although mobile seems a lot different. And didnt know about slack even existed lol. Also I was saying sue becuz companies sue like all the time over the dumbest things as copying design. I said that becuz its something that has happened literally hundreds of times.
has anyone counted the amount of features discord just took from Guilded? cuz its way too many and its just sad people dont know guilded has all of them already and had it before discord :
well to be fair discord basically gets sponsored for free because of youtubers and game creators promoting there server on discord so discord would basically be more well known then guilded and people would most likely stick with discord instead of guilded because people mostly use discord to talk to there friends so guilded would be below discord until one of them sue and who ever wins is basically getting the other shut down due to copyright
I thought that I had to cope or be forced to make my own discord alternative but now knowing that guilded exists as something separate from discord I will use it right away. My only concern is that Roblox has some of the same exact issues discord has with the roblox game
this video made me actually switch to guilded and make a Soulsborne server
I deadass want to use this but I know none of my friends will switch 😭😭
It seems like Guilded blows Discord out of the water in every important part of what I would want from a platform. The only reason I haven't switched is that more of my friends are on Discord... Eventually, I'll probably convince them to use Guilded instead, and then we can switch.
Why don't we make a discord alternative
Lol I wanna do this but my friends are hard to convince
Im thinking about trying out Guilded, is it still worth a shot?
I have 17 Friends on guilded and they all use discord. Only main complaint is the emoji are way to small compared to Discord, links for YT and Twitter could be better
I swear guided would be the best messaging app ever IF discord didn't already ha e so many people using it
Guided only has these features for free because they are less popular, trust me if they were to be the more popular platform you'd vet that they would do the same
The major thing I will like is the file feature when I send a video to my friends it has to be less than 11 seconds for it to not reach the limit. Also the fact I have my video quality on the minimum.
no
XMPP/Matrix
we need to make Guilded bigger
The only issue I've noticed with Guilded while using it was the fact it eats up a lot of Memory... At one point, it took a few minutes for the downloadable program (Not Browser) to go from 100MB to 700-750MB... And just stayed fluctuating there... Once they fix this issue with memory and performance... (Don't bother talking about Mobile Guilded)... It'll be on the right track!
But the downloaded version of guilded is also a browser, just like discord
I didn't even know Guilded was actually bought by Roblox until this video lol
They bought it independently, which means they just financially support it and not develop it / manage it.
Why is no one using this. This is 1000 times better than discord
4:01 YOU MADE ME SCARE WITH THAT ADS 😭😭
This app with be more successful if they had a focus on privacy and freedom of content
I'm already in a middle of a transition from Discord to Guilded and I'll tell ya, there's a lot of much better stuff, better server organizing and what I love the most is how you can sort specific categories in groups, so your main section of the server isn't filled with metric fuckton of categories and channels. I also like how you can have more than 50 emojis and how you can also use even your custom emojis EVERYWHERE without any stupid Nitro. So from my point of view, Guilded is DEFINITELY better than Discord in most aspects.
BEST thing about guilded is that there is no mee6 LOL
I'll be honest, I laughed at every joke of urs.
If more people used Guilded i would switch. I love the tings Guilded have, like the calender, emojis, profile and all the other good shit. I hope that it gets more attention, and they work continue to work on it.
Bit sad that its roblox that owns it tho
Just saying that ROBLOX can't change stuff inside Guilded. Everything is up to the Guilded developers.
@@bolekinds That's true, they are independent...like a sub-company so don't worry about it too much.
Without Roblox Guilded wouldn't be able to continue bruh
@@axi5724 yeah but Roblox are just investors that helps the development of Guilded... Guilded was already here before Roblox invest in them, the fact that now they are here to support the Guilded development team just says that Guilded will become even better.
@@fairytale_lol It might be true that they are just a sub-company / investors, but as an investor you expect to get something out of your investment. So if it dosent go that way they can push to make things differnet, and make more profit insted of making it good. I do get what you are saying tho :D
But how do they make money.
This all sounds great and having Nitro features for free is nice, but how do they make money?
As good as it is, you have to question this before or you will be disappointed when they slowly but surely strip you down of these free things and put them into a subscription.
Guilded is overall better than discord at this point, the problem is that its way too underrated and people often choose discord over it, i get it, i am a discord user myself and i've been using discord for nearly 2 years now, i've had nitro too but guilded gives you that nitro feeling for free actually, when i switch i'll try to convince my friends to use it too. :)
Yo, is streaming on Guilded good yet? I stream my DVD's to my friends and holy moly streaming is the only reason we haven't swapped over yet
Im 100% sure that discord will steal all of the guilded features
"steal" while they copy and paste from discord
@@H3rraM4juri They reworked it from scratch, only made it look like discord, what are you smoking
@@Vaczil but it is owned by roblox which means the worst moderation team ever lmao
@@H3rraM4juri worst moderation is still better than having eveything paid, at least they are not like low level company that has lowest security, and there is a low chance of a data breach/leak
I hope roblox doesnt ruin it like they are doing with their platform.
But this seems really cool I might try this app out!
they literally bought it a couple months ago, there has been no difference
@@gn2bstutorials382 It takes time and popularity for issues to arise, like with Twitch, Apple, Google, Discord... or Minecraft. Remember that whole ordeal? It's commendable to want a global moderation system but, unlike Roblox, Minecraft servers mostly consist of people or other companies that self-host rather than Microsoft or Mojang doing that themselves which is why the huge backlash occurred. People still wanted the fireflies, since it helps the ambiance of the game, but once pointed out that the frogs/toads get poisoned by them IRL they removed them entirely instead of disabling the feature for that mob. They claim to listen to the community and they seem to have started ignoring them when it's controversial. Modders were concerned about the EULA Microsoft had for the mappings of the Minecraft .jar files they provided, so they requested that some parts of it were made clearer so they were protected from Microsoft's lawyers; fortunately they did. Apple was and still is known for it's *mostly* quality hardware, but started going down the hard to repair route; funny that Steve Wozniak even despises this choice. Alphabet makes money off of it's services mainly ads and analytics, basically they are the tyrant of the internet now (though, in what better way could they make money and stay alive?). Microsoft had that Embrace Extend Extinguish (EEE) way back in the day. Google Chrome's manifest V3 stifles ad blockers, since Google Chrome AND it's base Chromium are leaders in browser market share (you could just keep the V2 fork, update it to include the rest of the V3 features, but who knows how long that will last for?). Intel sat on their asses for years, like Discord is doing right now, until AMD came with Ryzen. It seems that these larger companies *work slowly* to make/keep things worse or to become more anti-consumer. Just give it some time. For the time being we can enjoy the free features and the competition it brings.
Though some of these I could be wrong or not have the whole picture on (for example the EEE), do your own research.
@@somerandomstuff9239 , simple answer: no. Reason being is that ROBLOX owns them INDEPENDENTLY, which restricts them from developing/managing it. They just support it financially.
They aren't, and are instead making it better. Also, keep in mind that ROBLOX owns them INDEPENDENTLY, which restricts them from developing/managing it. They just support it financially.
Though, Guilded is great, i prefer discord just because it's not so targeted to gamers, because good luck trying to find a server on your favorite movie series, or fandom stuff, anything else too in Guilded other than games.
I understand what you're saying, but Guilded has expanded to more communities. Though they're still small, I've seen other diverse communities out there. They're still growing so I wouldn't just drop Discord completely. I would just stick to both for the time being, rather then replace it.
And where do you think discord started?
@@pliat I do not carr where it started, and thank you, but I'm very aware. I use discord for what it is, not what it was.
The thing that makes this video good is the review, but the jokes are just so funny lmao
Except for a few annoying and missing basic things and lags... yes, Guilded is in every possible way better than Discord. Too bad no one is on it and Discord is copying one feature after another
Finally, someone else who addresses the fact that Discord's been taking features from other platforms.
The problem with Guilded is that it's too similar to Discord. I'd rather use something that actually respects my privacy and I can bring my own client to.
That sounds like...Matrix 👍
Can you tell me more about guilded’s privacy policies?
@@merulox, they have their own privacy policy on their website. Just search it up.
If you want something open-source, use Matrix or Revolt, but similarity shouldn't be the primary reason why you would choose one over the other. Keep in mind that Discord took inspiration from Slack's UI, and it turned out to be a success...
Are we not talking about how he said: "I don't want to turn on my camera or else this would turn into some sort of sick twisted Twitch stream where I'm in a hot tub with a bra" and the text above says "Sounds like a wonderful 1m special"??????
this looks way better, but i still wont use it because i know all of the servers i care about are way too established on discord (which is very unfortunate)