UPDATE 10/24/24: ruclips.net/video/79VdFldr-c0/видео.htmlsi=zrpIKHiLYihwVPqQ Details/ Full Complaint: thecivilrightslawyer.com/2024/10/10/shocking-arrest-during-city-council-meeting-bodycam-released-lawsuit-filed/ The Supreme Court has made clear that “one of the most precious of the liberties safeguarded by the Bill of Rights” is the sacred promise to every American, enshrined in the First Amendment, that citizens enjoy the freedom to complain about their leaders. Lozman v. Riviera Beach, 585 U.S. 87, 101 (2018). But the city of Surprise, Arizona and its mayor, Skip Hall, broke that promise, arresting Plaintiff Rebekah Massie in front of her 10-year-old daughter for criticizing a public official at a city council meeting.
John, you should make your viewers aware of which political party you support: the RW-extremist Repubs or the moderate-RW Dems. Both parties are bought, owned, bribed, & controlled by the corrupt wealthy-class & their corrupt RW-politics. So, if you have voted for either party, you have literally voted for the corruption in this video to be allowed. Any intelligent viewer would want to know which of the two tyrannical RW-parties you're voting for this time.
The cop sounds like he's been drinking a lot of soy. He'd be no match for the average citizen inside of an MMA ring...he only acts tough behind that badge of authority while strapped with a Sig Sauer.
hopffuly that tyrant gets thrown in jail for the next 25 years. and he has to pay all of his retirement fund to her. along with the tyrant cops that arested her..
the people of that county would be in the right to invoke the 2nd amendment and remove the tyrants in the body cam footage from power. its people like that is one of the main reasons we have the 2nd amendment.
Her arrest is proof that the city attorney should be fired rather than getting a raise. A legit city attorney would had stepped in and protected the lady's right to speak even with her speaking against him.
None of them do, and they never will. They're there to support the city's unlawful actions and then continue as they bleed taxpayer court decision payouts.
Agreed but only if the person who files the lawsuit has the money to do so. How many of us citizens have the money to do so and who will step forward to file legal charges against them?
@@whatilearnttoday5295 I looked it up - it's already a Federal crime. Federal statute 18 U.S.C. § 242, which states that willfully depriving someone of their constitutional rights is a criminal offense.
My name is "Richard" and people are always asking me if I have a "nickname". Yes, it's "Richard". But if you want to call me a "Dick", I can be one too, but you're not going to like it. 🤣
I feel that an exceptional city attorney would have told the mayor that the arrest was unconstitutional, he sat by and said nothing. America is getting worse day by day.
He could sentenced to the Death Penalty including conspirators. Title 18 U.S.C. Section 242 Title 18 U.S.C. Section 241 Title 18 U.S.C. Section 1001 Workforce Investment Act of 1998
More like a room full of men. Old dude is trying to shut her up because she is a smart woman who is a threat to those sleazy men and their raping of tax dollars. We are getting closer to the Handmaid’s Tale being a reality.
@@BillySBC I resent the idea that Arizona is not part of the US. Local officials being grossly over paid happens everywhere in the US. This woman was pointing one case out. Do you remember the California city officials who were paid millions until they were caught?
She wasn’t lodging a complaint! She was speaking to the reasons she believes that man doesn’t deserve a raise! The lengths they will go to silence the people! It’s disgusting!
nobody can take criticism any more. Special interest groups have turned this country into a weak former shell of itself. Protecting the feelings of all to the point that words are criminal. Everything is a crime, personal expression is an artifact, and free speech a ghost. Tyrant public officials control everything with iron fist and no expectations other than to just get in office. Most of the folk have been silenced, incriminated, imprisoned, alienated to the point your on your own to defend yourself against the tyrants. Backs turned against them after they were seemingly of no use anymore all for progressive clueless whiners with one track minds. The me too society gets to reap the consequences of there actions under the rule of authoritarians. Pick up a shovel and stand by for more orders and dont hold your breath for a savior out of this mess
Even if she was filing a complaint against a city employee she should be able to do it there too. If you can congratulate a city employee for doing a good job. then you can criticize one to.
Even if she were lodging a complaint, those terms and policies were unconstitutional to begin with. What is the point of a public comment, if complaints are not allowed?
@@asitiswritten12have you read the document she signed? You think she signed a document that reads “hereby I’m waiving all my rights”?!? You need to read the document before you defend their actions. Until you haven’t read it you can’t argue something unconstitutional is legal unless you lick boots.
@@k.k.9571The document doesn’t matter if it’s unconscionable, which this one clearly is. No one can enter the public meeting without signing the document, so the only way to speak in the public forum is to agree to their rules where you can’t criticize them. That’s unconscionable.
Infuriating. Why else would you go to one of these stupid meetings other than to complain about officials? Sue that M'F'er mayor and these officers personally.
If you got on your knees there and kissed their behind they would clap in approval but if you obey the law and the constitution and criticize them legally they will abuse the law and authority , have you arrested and in the end punish the public for their crimes as nothing happens to them . Must be nice to be a government mafia member
That council room is where ALL the backroom deals are made into reality, allowing property forfeitures and most every illegal action taken against it's own constituents.
@@terrylandess6072 We have this stuff in the UK, for example, a company via the local council & in conjunction with the council try to take possession of an entire street of dwellings at compulsory purchase bargain basement prices by fraudulently claiming toxic waste ground contamination. The council tried aggressively to shut up any truth telling objectioners during the process. Criminals.
The officer is a fool. Why do these police officers think they "have" to arrest someone because they are told to? They take an oath to uphold the Constitution. He deserves all the shame. Pathetic.
You think the public cares? The idiots of this community probably love their cops and city. They will gladly accept the inevitable tax increase that comes with the law suit if it means their scumbag city government can keep on being corrupt with impunity.
They are order followers, even if it means treading on your rights. People have Don't Tread on My Rights flags, American flags all over their property, and thin blue-line flags. I think they are confused because one of those flags doesn't go hand in hand with the other two flags.
Thank you. City Council in Bend Oregon has been pulling this crap forever and has twice shut me down for it, once I was actually complimenting... we are 'only to address the council as a whole' we may not address a specific member, use anything they deem to disrupt decorum, including addressing specific members of council. This is a GREAT talking point for the next meeting.
@@iRedacted is that a threat against officials he was in the wrong but the second amendment doesn't constitute the right to just shoot people unless your person is in immanent danger of death
@floopnoopian679 the 2A is to ensure a free state. When politicians and their enforcement officers become tyrants, it is necessary to use the 2A to ensure a free state.
@@floopnoopian679Lmao, do you even know why the second amendment was created??!! Let me help you out here. One of the reasons the second amendment was created Counteract tyranny The Second Amendment was proposed by James Madison to allow the creation of civilian forces that could counteract a tyrannical federal government. Did you attend school in the USA? If so, have you never attended a History class? 🤦🏻♂️
It doesn't matter when you cattle get out of line it's our job to teach you a lesson as cops. These cops were very professional and hopefully the rest of you cattle can learn a lesson from this.
She proved why the City Attorney doesn't deserve a pay raise as he sat there and let her first Amendment rights get violated by the Mayor during a public meeting. I wish her luck on her slam dunk of a case.
Not only that but even if his job is solely to protect the city from being sued; he failed by not shutting the mayor up or the cops from arresting her. He is a total failure all around.
That the policy even exists at all shows the complete incompetence of the city attorney.... the fact he sat and allowed this to take place suggests that his bar card should be looked into being revoked as he seems to be incompetent to advise on legal matters let alone practice law...
And the stupid city attorney who, as a lawyer, should know better and should’ve stood up for her. She was correct - he is certainly not worthy of a raise for being “exceptional”.
@@EmilyGloeggler7984 You realize there are ppl that would love to donate the money to help her. And yeah, I realize that. I think most ppl know now days nothings free and lawyers need to get paid too.
And they'll all be re-elected in a landslide because it's a safe voting bloc for them, and their voters like when other Americans are mistreated and their rights are limited. "Law and order" and all that.
Police don't give people rights. Our rights are inalienable, given to us by our Creator. The US Constitution RESTRICTS GOVERNMENT FROM INFRINGING UPON SAID RIGHTS.
@@aarondale1852exactly. It trains people that there is a caste system. And they love that that lady was arrested in front of her 10 year old. The 10 year old now becomes fearful of government.
@@richardbutkis fear of govrrnment, or groups of like minded people who hold power should be taught in school but is not in my 53 years. Too many Reagan lovers and people making money from war on drug users and those that love them.
This is what happens when the Mayor is… First name: Adolph Last Name: Hitler It’s obvious to me that’s exactly the case here. He even said, not exact words, You can’t criticize or enter in any complaints about us! Why was she charged with the crime of trespassing? Was it because she was using incredible brutal violence and use of force against her “victims”? Or was it because there’s a Hitler-in-charge here?
@@excel111lf Might not actually apply in this particular situation. Since the actions that we're taking are not technically legal.Since they were trying to staple her first amendment protected right and they have no legal basis to do so there's a good chance they might not have qualified immunity.
Yuo these officers just agree with the council without enforcing the law. How ironic.. no wonder people hate cops. And they straight out tell her " she is trespassing from this public hearing".
Law Enforcement Officers (LEOs) and all veterans & these scumbag politicians took an oath to uphold The Constitution against ALL enemies both Foreign and Domestic! These tyrants need to be held accountable NOW!
@@glee21012 No, he is technically the mayor until his term ends on Dec 31, 2024. Since he is still serving his term he would be a lame-duck mayor, an interim mayor is appointed to fill the balance of someone else's term.
Mayor: Skip Hall: Report him to the US DOJ Civil Division. *1st, 4th,* 5th & 14th amendments. 42 USC § 1983, 18 USC § 242 City Attorney: Robert Wingo. Report him to the AZ BAR. Ethics violations below- File your complaint virtually and physically to ensure delivery, and keep receipts/proof of your complaints. You do not need to be a citizen of Arizona, this is a federal issue. Surprise, Arizona -Failure to Report Misconduct -Violation of Duty of Loyalty to the Public -Complicity in Unlawful Conduct -Failure to Ensure Justice and Fairness -Conflict of Interest -Failure to Uphold Constitutional Rights -Improper Legal Counsel Case Law
Everything in the US is illegal these days, bu they don't ever make corruption illegal. Yeah sure there is things like embezzlement and fraud, but its really only used to protect the already rich from lesser citizens (us) from cheating them. They are the only ones that get to cheat people.
@@jimmyrichards5595 She held up a mirror in front of them. They were so frightened by their own reflection that to them it probably did feel like excessive force on her part. I wish I could say that's wholeheartedly sarcasm but considering what they did to her and their supposed reason it's uncomfortably closer to the truth than to sarcasm.
Unbelievable that thin-skinned city councils are still ruling from their feelings instead of the law. I hope this lady maintains her resolve and fights them in the courts. Bravo to her for speaking up and not accepting their illegal behavior!
Hes just bowing down to his boss because he doesn't know the difference in the law😢. Then he took it out on her by not letting her move or have a drink of water. I'm surprised they didn't try to call child protective services and take her child for the night.
@@PORSCHE_COUNTRY.She could have founD* somewhere else to speak, but you’re missing the point. She had a RIGHT to speak at the city council meeting. And why do you care what shirt she wore? ( I’m going to have to look at the video again because I paid no attention to her clothing.) Your opinion that the people violating our rights mostly come from California is ridiculous. I’ve see so many videos of LEOs and government officials violating people’s rights. This happens all over our country, and I assume from some of their accents that they didn’t come from CA anytime in the last 50 years or more. And the word is “clique” not “click.”
No one hates the constitution more than LE. That's why every time someone stands on their rights they say they're uncooperative, combative, or just want to be difficult. LE are order followers, they hate liberty with a passion.
Assault by the officer, several counts. Numerous civil rights violations by several officials. AND she was neither attacking nor bringing charges, but was speaking in opposition to business at hand, giving reasons thereto - the very purpose of public comments.
Law Enforcement Officers (LEOs) and all veterans & these scumbag politicians took an oath to uphold The Constitution against ALL enemies both Foreign and Domestic! These tyrants need to be held accountable NOW!
I may have missed one. But I was scrolling through the comments, looking for content like that. Agree, not one person of the 5 or 6 that were there said anything! I don't care if there were 1 or 2 people there. One person should have said something!
The exact definition of corruption. I hope all auditors take it upon their selves and expose all corruption and protect all their constitutional rights as well as all their amendments.
Yes because you cattle need to learn your place. Your job is to pay and obey us cops. It's amazing to see you cattle get out of line, then put back in line.
Looking from the outside in , many council meetings are being used to curtaile government decent. Leroy truth. Regan Benson 69 shots, Guerrilla Publishing. And many many more post videos like this. This is how a police state operates.
There are only imagined rights in the entire country.. if Trump gets elected again, he's promised to give cops absolute immunity.. that'll be even more fun..
@@tonyparson4392exactly the opposite actually. Those people destroying the constitutional rights of the woman in the video are Trumpsters. They are the reason I will not live in Arizona and why I love California. I have more rights here than anywhere else. It amazes me how people like you are swayed by social media BS. The right is stripping away rights in many states right now and all you can do is blame the other side. smfh
Notice the attorney sitting there saying nothing he wants a raise saying he is the best they have but says nothing about the unconstitutional wrongs in what they were doing. Like a cop standing there as another cop mistreat a suspect and do nothing.
@@viclunaanthc3274Of course he’s not. They want these toadies in there. Muppets. Nothing more. Those are the kind of automatons that a perfect kind of creatures for the job.
Cops, in general, dedicate themselves to the service of others, even at great personal (and family) sacrifice. But, generally, they will obey orders given to them by those with more authority. And, while usually that is a good thing, sometimes it isn't.
These PUBLIC servants are out of control. How is this even happening in this country? So glad she has a suit against that city. We all need to wake up to what These crazy people are doing 🙄 🤯
She was calm, respectful and effective in her communication. And she was physically assaulted and falsely arrested. My hope is that she never gives up. God bless.
All the citizens of Surprise, AZ need to pack the next council meeting and show these tyrants who is really in charge. They need to all get up there and tell that mayor and city council what a dictatorship of a job they are doing.
I found it shocking when I read the paper out here in Phoenix and saw that they're trying to outlaw complaints against city officials up there. The next council meeting SHOULD be in an uproar over this.
She wasn't attacking the City attorney directly what she was doing was addressing the reasons why she believed that the City attorney shouldn't get a pay raise.
UPDATE 10/24/24: ruclips.net/video/79VdFldr-c0/видео.htmlsi=zrpIKHiLYihwVPqQ
Details/ Full Complaint: thecivilrightslawyer.com/2024/10/10/shocking-arrest-during-city-council-meeting-bodycam-released-lawsuit-filed/
The Supreme Court has made clear that “one of the most precious of the liberties safeguarded by the Bill of Rights” is the sacred promise to every American, enshrined in the First Amendment, that citizens enjoy the freedom to complain about their leaders. Lozman v. Riviera Beach, 585 U.S. 87, 101 (2018). But the city of Surprise, Arizona and its mayor, Skip Hall, broke that promise, arresting Plaintiff Rebekah Massie in front of her 10-year-old daughter for criticizing a public official at a city council meeting.
John, you should make your viewers aware of which political party you support: the RW-extremist Repubs or the moderate-RW Dems. Both parties are bought, owned, bribed, & controlled by the corrupt wealthy-class & their corrupt RW-politics. So, if you have voted for either party, you have literally voted for the corruption in this video to be allowed. Any intelligent viewer would want to know which of the two tyrannical RW-parties you're voting for this time.
The cop sounds like he's been drinking a lot of soy. He'd be no match for the average citizen inside of an MMA ring...he only acts tough behind that badge of authority while strapped with a Sig Sauer.
hopffuly that tyrant gets thrown in jail for the next 25 years. and he has to pay all of his retirement fund to her. along with the tyrant cops that arested her..
the people of that county would be in the right to invoke the 2nd amendment and remove the tyrants in the body cam footage from power. its people like that is one of the main reasons we have the 2nd amendment.
SCOTUS has also made it clear that time, place, and manner restrictions on speech, which are content neutral, are entirely Constitutional.
Her arrest is proof that the city attorney should be fired rather than getting a raise. A legit city attorney would had stepped in and protected the lady's right to speak even with her speaking against him.
Yup. City Attorney had an opportunity to demonstrate their worth and save the city a lawsuit. Instead allowed the Mayor to act as his bulldog.
💯
None of them do, and they never will. They're there to support the city's unlawful actions and then continue as they bleed taxpayer court decision payouts.
Thus stopping a lawsuit before it happened.
I wonder if they'll still think the city attorney deserves a raise after he loses this civil rights violation case. ??
Enjoy the lawsuit assholes, she is 100 percent right. That cop needs to prosecuted as well.
There might be a payout, but these criminals will never see the inside of a jail cell outside of extremely exceptional circumstances anyway.
No qualified immunity as there are numerous cases on the books for this.
They follow the antichrist, obviously, whether they realize it or not.
I'm willing to go further than arrest
That shit makes my blood boil!
That mayor and the entire council need to be charged criminally.
Yes they do. Another dirtbag city council that has forgotten who they work for.
Agreed but only if the person who files the lawsuit has the money to do so. How many of us citizens have the money to do so and who will step forward to file legal charges against them?
We should start petitioning our Federal Government to make it a crime to deny someone of their rights. People will learn them really quick.
What with?
@@whatilearnttoday5295 I looked it up - it's already a Federal crime. Federal statute 18 U.S.C. § 242, which states that willfully depriving someone of their constitutional rights is a criminal offense.
The first mistake was electing a mayor who calls himself Skip.
seriously underrated post!
My name is "Richard" and people are always asking me if I have a "nickname". Yes, it's "Richard". But if you want to call me a "Dick", I can be one too, but you're not going to like it. 🤣
😂
That never ends well 😂😂😂 still living in his high school days
What about Skips
That lawyer makes $260k a year to not recognize this mayor violates someone civil rights. Yeah, I'd say that isn't exceptional.
I feel that an exceptional city attorney would have told the mayor that the arrest was unconstitutional, he sat by and said nothing. America is getting worse day by day.
She should sue for twice that amount.
Oh, that is exceptional! Give that man a raise! Who else do you know making $260/yr arresting people for talking in a public forum?
Also, if cops were smart, they wouldn't need qualified stupidity.
Exactly
In my opinion, the mayor should be removed permanently, charged with deprivation of rights under color of law, and sent to prison for 10 years...
beside the city or the police getting sued why cant she sue the mayor also and take all his property also then he cant be mayor that way?
He could sentenced to the Death Penalty including conspirators.
Title 18 U.S.C. Section 242
Title 18 U.S.C. Section 241
Title 18 U.S.C. Section 1001
Workforce Investment Act of 1998
With no parole
That's the problem here. Government officials almost never face criminal charges for violating our rights anymore.
Only in a just society... 😢😢😢
What you just witnessed was one courageous woman in a room full of oath breakers.
Turns out ignoring the rules is profitable... to the tune of a quarter million for that city attorney.
Oath breaking cowards.
Swamp rats don’t just live in DC !
More like a room full of men. Old dude is trying to shut her up because she is a smart woman who is a threat to those sleazy men and their raping of tax dollars.
We are getting closer to the Handmaid’s Tale being a reality.
It was shocking to see NOBODY speaking up for her. Everyone needs to be removed.
She wasn't attacking anyone. She was expressing her disapproval of why someone should get a raise from the taxpayers. Tf?
disagreeing with communists is an attack 🙂
WTF...you cannot criticize your public employees in a public forum??!?!
Insane. Unconstitutional.
This Mayor needs to be in jail.
Their families need to face prosecution too. They benefited and encouraged their criminal behavior.
It's Arizona, it's not America, please reconsider this reality and re-post.
Criticism of government is what the 1st amendment is for!
The actions of the council is the qid essential definition of a civil rights violation!
@@BillySBCarizona is part of america
@@BillySBC I resent the idea that Arizona is not part of the US. Local officials being grossly over paid happens everywhere in the US. This woman was pointing one case out. Do you remember the California city officials who were paid millions until they were caught?
She wasn’t lodging a complaint! She was speaking to the reasons she believes that man doesn’t deserve a raise! The lengths they will go to silence the people! It’s disgusting!
This is how totalitarianism creeps in.
'They'? You mean those that were democratically Elected to office by The People themselves? Who's to blame here exactly..? 😅
nobody can take criticism any more. Special interest groups have turned this country into a weak former shell of itself. Protecting the feelings of all to the point that words are criminal. Everything is a crime, personal expression is an artifact, and free speech a ghost. Tyrant public officials control everything with iron fist and no expectations other than to just get in office. Most of the folk have been silenced, incriminated, imprisoned, alienated to the point your on your own to defend yourself against the tyrants. Backs turned against them after they were seemingly of no use anymore all for progressive clueless whiners with one track minds. The me too society gets to reap the consequences of there actions under the rule of authoritarians. Pick up a shovel and stand by for more orders and dont hold your breath for a savior out of this mess
Even if she was filing a complaint against a city employee she should be able to do it there too. If you can congratulate a city employee for doing a good job. then you can criticize one to.
Even if she were lodging a complaint, those terms and policies were unconstitutional to begin with.
What is the point of a public comment, if complaints are not allowed?
Not one person employed by that city stood up for our constitution.
Not one cop not one city council member.
A sad day in America.
No one in the audience stood up for her either, which really can make a difference.
@@victoriasfire Be the change, etc
Its not like they know their own rights. Most people lack this simple knowledge
@@TonkaFire2019 doesn't matter. when they come to take you to jail there's no fighting back
Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely
Good for her. Well researched, well informed, well said, in spite of being scared to death. She brings up solid points and should be taken seriously.
The officer escorting her out is as much of a tyrant as the city council
How are they tyrants if she agreed to waive her Right to speak freely and they have proof?????
@@asitiswritten12have you read the document she signed? You think she signed a document that reads “hereby I’m waiving all my rights”?!? You need to read the document before you defend their actions. Until you haven’t read it you can’t argue something unconstitutional is legal unless you lick boots.
But they’re the “good guys”, right!?
@@k.k.9571The document doesn’t matter if it’s unconscionable, which this one clearly is. No one can enter the public meeting without signing the document, so the only way to speak in the public forum is to agree to their rules where you can’t criticize them. That’s unconscionable.
@@asitiswritten12 lol she signed under duress, not on her own free will.
Infuriating. Why else would you go to one of these stupid meetings other than to complain about officials? Sue that M'F'er mayor and these officers personally.
They keep trying to convince us that our enemies are overseas, when really they're right here in the US
If you got on your knees there and kissed their behind they would clap in approval but if you obey the law and the constitution and criticize them legally they will abuse the law and authority , have you arrested and in the end punish the public for their crimes as nothing happens to them . Must be nice to be a government mafia member
It certainly explains why she was the only citizen speaking and the nearly non-existent attendees.
That council room is where ALL the backroom deals are made into reality, allowing property forfeitures and most every illegal action taken against it's own constituents.
@@terrylandess6072
We have this stuff in the UK, for example, a company via the local council & in conjunction with the council try to take possession of an entire street of dwellings at compulsory purchase bargain basement prices by fraudulently claiming toxic waste ground contamination. The council tried aggressively to shut up any truth telling objectioners during the process.
Criminals.
The officer is a fool. Why do these police officers think they "have" to arrest someone because they are told to? They take an oath to uphold the Constitution. He deserves all the shame. Pathetic.
Most likely to avoid getting fired.
Just like Nazi soldiers during WW2. Just doing what their told.
You think the public cares? The idiots of this community probably love their cops and city. They will gladly accept the inevitable tax increase that comes with the law suit if it means their scumbag city government can keep on being corrupt with impunity.
they are morons
They are order followers, even if it means treading on your rights. People have Don't Tread on My Rights flags, American flags all over their property, and thin blue-line flags. I think they are confused because one of those flags doesn't go hand in hand with the other two flags.
Thank you. City Council in Bend Oregon has been pulling this crap forever and has twice shut me down for it, once I was actually complimenting... we are 'only to address the council as a whole' we may not address a specific member, use anything they deem to disrupt decorum, including addressing specific members of council. This is a GREAT talking point for the next meeting.
You are under arrest for speaking your mind and using your 1st amendment rights!!
How dare she
@@iRedacted we as citizens have to decide when enough is enough, then follow threw with it.
@@iRedacted is that a threat against officials he was in the wrong but the second amendment doesn't constitute the right to just shoot people unless your person is in immanent danger of death
@floopnoopian679 the 2A is to ensure a free state. When politicians and their enforcement officers become tyrants, it is necessary to use the 2A to ensure a free state.
@@floopnoopian679Lmao, do you even know why the second amendment was created??!! Let me help you out here. One of the reasons the second amendment was created
Counteract tyranny
The Second Amendment was proposed by James Madison to allow the creation of civilian forces that could counteract a tyrannical federal government.
Did you attend school in the USA? If so, have you never attended a History class? 🤦🏻♂️
She was not criticizing him personally as was noted. She was criticizing him in a professional capacity which was relevant to what was being voted on.
She was very matter of fact, direct and to the point. She's kind of a superhero.
Doesn't matter, her she had the right to do either.
It doesn't matter when you cattle get out of line it's our job to teach you a lesson as cops. These cops were very professional and hopefully the rest of you cattle can learn a lesson from this.
@@Damitsall WTF are you smoking. The cop did NOT do his job at all
@@Damitsallyou’re a idiot -the police violated the oath they took and the constitution.
She proved why the City Attorney doesn't deserve a pay raise as he sat there and let her first Amendment rights get violated by the Mayor during a public meeting.
I wish her luck on her slam dunk of a case.
Not only that but even if his job is solely to protect the city from being sued; he failed by not shutting the mayor up or the cops from arresting her. He is a total failure all around.
Oh she don't need luck, lol
by the looks the city got his pay rise for not respecting peoples right. what other dodgy shit is he doing
That the policy even exists at all shows the complete incompetence of the city attorney.... the fact he sat and allowed this to take place suggests that his bar card should be looked into being revoked as he seems to be incompetent to advise on legal matters let alone practice law...
No such thing as a slam dunk case in a tyrannical government. Remember, judges are part of the system. Sad.
Thanks for having the courage to speak the truth!! Please...never stop.
Typical Police State behavior. There should be charges filed against the mayor and the arresting officer for false arrest.
And the stupid city attorney who, as a lawyer, should know better and should’ve stood up for her. She was correct - he is certainly not worthy of a raise for being “exceptional”.
There should be a lotta things--ain’t gonna happen, though
This RW-politics in action. Stop voting for RWers.
By who ?
I hope to GOD she sues the shit out of EVERY single person involved.
You realize that costs money?
@@EmilyGloeggler7984 For a 1983, not really.
@@EmilyGloeggler7984 You realize there are ppl that would love to donate the money to help her. And yeah, I realize that. I think most ppl know now days nothings free and lawyers need to get paid too.
@@EmilyGloeggler7984Foundation For Individual Rights And Expression are representing her in the case.
@@EmilyGloeggler7984So what?
You can tell the corruption is deep-seated by how casual they are about publicly arresting someone for criticizing them.
Yes, and how quickly the Mayor wanted to shut her up, while council members allowed it. Corruption is obviously relevant here.
This RW-politics in action. Stop voting for RWers.
*…and IGNORANCE.*
And they'll all be re-elected in a landslide because it's a safe voting bloc for them, and their voters like when other Americans are mistreated and their rights are limited. "Law and order" and all that.
Absolutely
Those officials should be charged with treasonous acts period.
This mayor and every police officer involved should all be arrested and charged with kidnapping, false arrest, imprisonment, and child abuse.
Absilutely!!!
Absolutely-
“You need to take a couple of deep breath’s and submit to our illegal instructions “ - is what the cop was really saying .
And sued
Stripped of all pay and retirement.
This girl is a American hero standing up for all Americans.
As an aussie I totally agree
Yep.
Wow. The brain rot in this comment section.
Woman, but yes.
woman...are you a boy?
Sick of people saying respect the police when the police are NOT giving people their constitutional rights
They deserve no respect. Period.
They don't want respect. They want fear.
Police don't give people rights. Our rights are inalienable, given to us by our Creator. The US Constitution RESTRICTS GOVERNMENT FROM INFRINGING UPON SAID RIGHTS.
Respect is earned. Cops don't earn it and don't give it either.
Why is rubing alcohol still on the shelves? The answer explains our society. Alcohol does not need pioson added to it!!!!
Sue the council, sue the cops and sue the city.
Prison for those who violate rights! The whole council needs prison!
Short drop and a stop
But they're NOT! But good effort on your idea.
I disagree. That it punitive to taxpayers. There are quicker, more signal-sending, permanent solutions. Those are the ones that should be implemented.
@@jasonshults368 How is prison hurting the citizens? They are already hurting them by denying free speech!
Agreed. Denying someone of their rights should be criminal, and I'd say a FELONY.
One thing is for sure. Her 10 yr old should be proud of her mother. Standing up to corruption is scary when they hold power and abuse it 😢
Agreed I was thinking the same thing. So heartless about a 10-year-old girl, makes me very concerned about child trafficking going on there.
It is too bad that you are describing everything from local school board up to the Prez in this police state.
Them forbidding criticism is totally unconstitutional.
Wow their swells in the power dept.
First amendment violation
@@curtisj2165 Don't worry, it's perfectly legal, they passed a city ordinance suspending Constitutional rights during public meetings. :P
Kinda like russia, china, and north korea?
Yet they do it with impunity. They do it in all cities and all states in the Nation. Good luck rebels!!!
TCRL, thank you. You are doing a great service to the American public in exposing government tyranny.
So what’s even the point of a city council meeting if you’re only allowed to promote fluff pieces about the city officials?
...too appear Democratic
To train you to accept anything they do
@@aarondale1852exactly. It trains people that there is a caste system. And they love that that lady was arrested in front of her 10 year old. The 10 year old now becomes fearful of government.
@@richardbutkis fear of govrrnment, or groups of like minded people who hold power should be taught in school but is not in my 53 years. Too many Reagan lovers and people making money from war on drug users and those that love them.
This is what happens when the Mayor is…
First name: Adolph
Last Name: Hitler
It’s obvious to me that’s exactly the case here. He even said, not exact words, You can’t criticize or enter in any complaints about us!
Why was she charged with the crime of trespassing? Was it because she was using incredible brutal violence and use of force against her “victims”? Or was it because there’s a Hitler-in-charge here?
Should file charges against those officers for kidnapping and assault.
Yes I agree!!!
This happens way more than people think
And who will arrest them?? Lol.. there all CRIMINALs!!!
Qualified immunity!
@@excel111lf Might not actually apply in this particular situation. Since the actions that we're taking are not technically legal.Since they were trying to staple her first amendment protected right and they have no legal basis to do so there's a good chance they might not have qualified immunity.
these mayors across the country are acting like dictators
That's why they become mayors. Psychopaths, sociopaths, narcissists.
"Small" government like this is every single piece of evidence anyone needs to know that government is not needed.
City councils and school boards too.
They've always acted like this, we are now seeing it.
@@bayonetred7508WevWe'already known about it.
They should be sued PERSONALLY
its actually crazy how quickly the cop agrees to violating her rights.
The Nazi’s said the same thing in World War II during their trials.
They don’t even bother to think
Cops primary job is to protect government from those pesky tax payers.
Yuo these officers just agree with the council without enforcing the law. How ironic.. no wonder people hate cops. And they straight out tell her " she is trespassing from this public hearing".
Its the same mindset as those that filled the trains cars to the showers
She should run for mayor and fire the police chief and all officers involved in her assault and arrest.
I SECOND YOUR PROPOSAL!! ( Even though I love in the Pacific NW) 😊
Plus all the council members for not intervening.
Great idea!!! 👍👍
@@ricken21 You can't fire elected officials.
I hope she sues them for a million dollars. Why nobody comes to her defense against the goons that call themselves police officers. Happens to often
*Can The Mayor fit seven figures on a re-election Yard Sign!?*
She will be suing the taxpayers, who will be on the hook for the heinous crimes of these so-called authorities. That isn't a solution.
But doesn’t the money come from the publics pockets?
@@jasonshults368
"...That isn't a solution"
Only if the Citizenry allows it to persist!
@@jasonshults368The taxpayers deserve to pay it if they allow this to keep happening.They voted the Idiot.
Tyrant in.
Bless this woman!
It's difficult to be calm when being kidnapped by domestic terrorist.
Law Enforcement Officers (LEOs) and all veterans & these scumbag politicians took an oath to uphold The Constitution against ALL enemies both Foreign and Domestic!
These tyrants need to be held accountable NOW!
Amen.
This RW-politics in action.
Exactly 💯
@@matthewingersonno it’s just corruption
That town needs a new mayor. Send him packing!
He is interim mayor, they already elected someone. Learn to read.
New town lawyer.
@@glee21012 No, he is technically the mayor until his term ends on Dec 31, 2024. Since he is still serving his term he would be a lame-duck mayor, an interim mayor is appointed to fill the balance of someone else's term.
@@glee21012 Shitty town, no need to read.
Mayor: Skip Hall: Report him to the US DOJ Civil Division. *1st, 4th,* 5th & 14th amendments. 42 USC § 1983, 18 USC § 242
City Attorney: Robert Wingo. Report him to the AZ BAR. Ethics violations below-
File your complaint virtually and physically to ensure delivery, and keep receipts/proof of your complaints. You do not need to be a citizen of Arizona, this is a federal issue.
Surprise, Arizona
-Failure to Report Misconduct
-Violation of Duty of Loyalty to the Public
-Complicity in Unlawful Conduct
-Failure to Ensure Justice and Fairness
-Conflict of Interest
-Failure to Uphold Constitutional Rights
-Improper Legal Counsel
Case Law
The DOJ paid him to hush the voting records, so not going to happen while being occupied by a foreign country.
Good on you
Done. Used civilrights.justice.gov/report/
If Trump wins, this would get thrown out
@@amorl4520prison time
Fire, sue and jail.
That Mayor and policeman should be arrested for assault.
And kidnapping.
@@PS5820-wv7kk absolutely 👍🏻
Koala pied him unity.
treason!
Do these council members ever get charged for violating 1st amendment rights?
They don’t get charged for open corruption, I’ve been following a city planner that has bounced about 6 cities. Nobody looks at references either.
No.
Its not a crime, but it should be a Felony.
Everything in the US is illegal these days, bu they don't ever make corruption illegal. Yeah sure there is things like embezzlement and fraud, but its really only used to protect the already rich from lesser citizens (us) from cheating them. They are the only ones that get to cheat people.
@@TurnerMillsDesignIt is a crime, always has been.
She wasn't Trespassing. The City Counsel Meeting is a Public Building.
If anything, don't they seem more like the ones who are trespassing?
And an established public forum! Skip messed up. REAL bad 👍🏻
Yes, and she was never actually asked to leave - just to stop talking.
She was charged with the crime of trespassing due to the brutal violence and use of force she was perpetrating upon her “victims”. /s
@@jimmyrichards5595 She held up a mirror in front of them. They were so frightened by their own reflection that to them it probably did feel like excessive force on her part. I wish I could say that's wholeheartedly sarcasm but considering what they did to her and their supposed reason it's uncomfortably closer to the truth than to sarcasm.
This is a great video!!! This girl is prepared and organized and rebellious!!! Love it. ❤❤❤❤
Unbelievable that thin-skinned city councils are still ruling from their feelings instead of the law. I hope this lady maintains her resolve and fights them in the courts. Bravo to her for speaking up and not accepting their illegal behavior!
What’s worse is Skip Hall is a Vietnam Veteran. He’s a disgrace as is those on the council and he needs to be impeached.
They let hra karens into office, this is what they are like.
The officer should have arrested the mayor for making an unconstitutional demand, instead of assaulting this woman.
Order followers. The leading cause of death during the 20th century was order followers.
Hes just bowing down to his boss because he doesn't know the difference in the law😢. Then he took it out on her by not letting her move or have a drink of water. I'm surprised they didn't try to call child protective services and take her child for the night.
Translation: “You can’t call out facts against the city attorney and the corruption! SURPRISE!! Straight to jail!”
@@PORSCHE_COUNTRY.If it causes change it is worth it
@@PORSCHE_COUNTRY.She could have founD* somewhere else to speak, but you’re missing the point. She had a RIGHT to speak at the city council meeting. And why do you care what shirt she wore? ( I’m going to have to look at the video again because I paid no attention to her clothing.) Your opinion that the people violating our rights mostly come from California is ridiculous. I’ve see so many videos of LEOs and government officials violating people’s rights. This happens all over our country, and I assume from some of their accents that they didn’t come from CA anytime in the last 50 years or more.
And the word is “clique” not “click.”
therefore the law suit
Cyberbullying the government@@synnove1046
@@synnove1046 There's a great Norman Rockwell painting about this very thing
DOJ should investigate the mayor & any other official
Doubt that would happen with our current DOJ…
So much for the officer that sworn to uphold the constitution!
Officers: "Constitution? What Constitution?"
They are all Traitors IMHO
No one hates the constitution more than LE. That's why every time someone stands on their rights they say they're uncooperative, combative, or just want to be difficult. LE are order followers, they hate liberty with a passion.
Same for the mayor and the members of the city council. All elected officials in the US must swear an oath to defend the Constitution.
Most of these goons have never read the Constitution. They should be required to have training and pass a test every year.
Assault by the officer, several counts.
Numerous civil rights violations by several officials.
AND she was neither attacking nor bringing charges, but was speaking in opposition to business at hand, giving reasons thereto - the very purpose of public comments.
Tyrants being tyrants.
Rebellion to tyrants is obedience to God,,,,,,,,,,Ben Franklin
That’s a Surprise!
That's RW-politics.
@@markgray6982❤
Vote them all out, Arizona!
Not only did the cop follow the city council’s policy over the constitution - he was unsurprisingly a jerk about it and a gaslighter.
Law Enforcement Officers (LEOs) and all veterans & these scumbag politicians took an oath to uphold The Constitution against ALL enemies both Foreign and Domestic!
These tyrants need to be held accountable NOW!
He's garbage.
I have never seen such a strong example of why a city attorney doesn't deserve a raise or a job at this point.
That’s why the city attorney doesn’t deserve a raise or his contract to be renewed. He sat there and did nothing proving her point.
You have zero idea how things work . lol
Sure thing. I’ll do more research on city meetings so I can be smart just like you.
Sue! Sue! Sue!
The entire council should be removed from office.
Nobody tried to stick up for her, because nobody was there? They must be afraid already! Get the Mayor off his High Horse, put him in jail!
I may have missed one. But I was scrolling through the comments, looking for content like that.
Agree, not one person of the 5 or 6 that were there said anything! I don't care if there were 1 or 2 people there. One person should have said something!
It must be a small town.
I live near Surprise, AZ and this has not gotten the media coverage it deserves. Shame!
She wasn't stating a complaint, only given facts.
Ironically he definitely will not win the case against Mrs Massy. There goes his exceptional performance.
What a bunch of spineless cowards!
All democrats are
All of them!
Thank you for exposing the corruption.
The exact definition of corruption. I hope all auditors take it upon their selves and expose all corruption and protect all their constitutional rights as well as all their amendments.
That cop swore under oath to protect people’s rights, he should be the first one charged!
He denied her water. Sick and evil.
When you fear integrity and accountability, you are NOT the good guys!!
This is honestly the type of situation that the whole city, town, and state needs to stand against and remove all crooked members involved period!!!!
How convenient for local public officials to create a policy that their constituents can never criticize them in public meetings.
Yes because you cattle need to learn your place. Your job is to pay and obey us cops. It's amazing to see you cattle get out of line, then put back in line.
Seems like there were some people like that one time. We called them Nazis
This is astonishing that this could happen with a government attorney in attendance!
Surprise! No rights in Arizona!
Arizona is turning into a mini California!!
Looking from the outside in , many council meetings are being used to curtaile government decent. Leroy truth. Regan Benson 69 shots, Guerrilla Publishing. And many many more post videos like this. This is how a police state operates.
There are only imagined rights in the entire country.. if Trump gets elected again, he's promised to give cops absolute immunity.. that'll be even more fun..
@@tonyparson4392exactly the opposite actually. Those people destroying the constitutional rights of the woman in the video are Trumpsters. They are the reason I will not live in Arizona and why I love California. I have more rights here than anywhere else. It amazes me how people like you are swayed by social media BS. The right is stripping away rights in many states right now and all you can do is blame the other side. smfh
Mass fraud in elections there. I hope everyone is exposed there soon!
WOW!!! WOW !!! WOW !!! What a cut-and-dry case of a 1st Amendment violation! Please keep us posted.
Notice the attorney sitting there saying nothing he wants a raise saying he is the best they have but says nothing about the unconstitutional wrongs in what they were doing. Like a cop standing there as another cop mistreat a suspect and do nothing.
The City Attorney is the “best they have” ? Mental note to self, never even drive through Surprise Arizona. I have no Constitutional Rights there.
The lowlife was probably once canine himself.
Shame on the officers
Corruption everywhere. So sad😢
Neo-liberalsim is the root of this fascism, it is an entire generation directly responsible.
It's by design. This is centralised power.
Small towns are the worst.
Most corrupt people in America are county sheriff's
6:08 “this is factual information”
“It doesn’t matter” WOW
This woman is ON TOP OF THINGS 💯👏 I hope she gets justice
This cop should be sued, fired and given a jail sentence
Were her charges dropped for the arrest? I noticed the so-called city attorney sat there and did nothing. His license should be revoked.
Let’s just say he’s not a very bright attorney.
@@viclunaanthc3274 but very well paid
@@viclunaanthc3274He's VERY Bright. He's protecting his pockets!
@@viclunaanthc3274 He's exceptional........ I would buy that, in the negative way. Those taxpayers are getting RIPPED OFF.
@@viclunaanthc3274Of course he’s not. They want these toadies in there. Muppets. Nothing more. Those are the kind of automatons that a perfect kind of creatures for the job.
What trash. This pisses me off so much. No one in office here and the officer needs to be charged and jailed.
Leave coward
It is ALWAYS the COPS who make tyranny a reality.
The government monopoly on violence is real
No. Its the ones who write the laws.
Here we are back in North Korea, SHAMEFUL SO MANY PEOPLE GOING ALONG WITH IT
And yet there are certain persons out here who get angry that cries to defund the police aren't going away.
Cops, in general, dedicate themselves to the service of others, even at great personal (and family) sacrifice. But, generally, they will obey orders given to them by those with more authority. And, while usually that is a good thing, sometimes it isn't.
You can speak if you only say what we want to hear
And praise our greatness!
She just won the lottery!
Hold them accountable
These PUBLIC servants are out of control. How is this even happening in this country? So glad she has a suit against that city. We all need to wake up to what These crazy people are doing 🙄 🤯
Public SERPENTS not servants
It's happening all across our country. It has happened twice in the last 2 County Council meetings in Madison County, Indiana
If words are an attack then you literally cannot speak without fear of government reprisal.
He can't tell her what charges, because there are none.
She was calm, respectful and effective in her communication. And she was physically assaulted and falsely arrested. My hope is that she never gives up. God bless.
Thanks for covering this.
Very good presentation and explanation. Thank you
All the citizens of Surprise, AZ need to pack the next council meeting and show these tyrants who is really in charge. They need to all get up there and tell that mayor and city council what a dictatorship of a job they are doing.
Agree
I found it shocking when I read the paper out here in Phoenix and saw that they're trying to outlaw complaints against city officials up there. The next council meeting SHOULD be in an uproar over this.
That whole town council is corrupted.
We are seeing this more
Where the government isn't allowing free speech in these meetings
This has got to end
And John Kerry, Bill Gates, media, Kamala Harris.
@@chilloften None of those was a public forum. But nice try.
More? More than when? It's been the norm since I was a teenager in the 90's. Probably the 80's too, but I was too young to even care then.
@Xerou a city council meeting, IS a public forum 🤡
@@Xerou The thing is, they don’t want to hear any opinion, thoughts, feelings, desires, hopes, other than their own.
Psychopathy!
That mayor needs to be dragged away in cuffs.
The 10 year old daughter needs to witness how the state operates. That was a good thing for that child to learn.
She’ll never look at cops the same. Earning the hate…again! 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
She wasn't attacking the City attorney directly what she was doing was addressing the reasons why she believed that the City attorney shouldn't get a pay raise.
She literally addressed him by name, directly referencing them. I'm on her side but you're wrong about what happened.
She is right about him giving himself a pay raise. @@TRDiscordian
@@TRDiscordian It still wasn't a personal attack, you twit.
That was.
Wow I am looking forward to this lawsuit. They just keep digging a deeper hole. You are unlawfully arrested.
charge for assault conspiracy kidnapping and mischief.