The Lost Tribe: India's Jarawa People | 101 East
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 окт 2024
- An ancient indigenous tribe is on the verge of extinction in India's Andaman Islands. Habitat loss, disease and exploitation could wipe out the 400-strong Jarawa tribe, who still hunt using bows and arrows.
Lapses in policing and continued activity by tour operators, who encourage 'human safaris' where Jarawa women and children have in the past performed for tourists, are partly to blame for jeopardising the tribe's existence.
Many activists want to close the main road into the tribal reserve to protect the tribe from further interaction with the outside world, but it is a lifeline providing food and work for the island's 600,000 inhabitants.
To include or isolate?
101 East's Kathy Hearn reports on an Indian tribe on the edge of extinction.
More from 101 East on:
RUclips - aje.io/101eastY...
Facebook - / 101east
Twitter - / aj101east
Instagram - / aj101east
Website - aljazeera.com/1...
#AlJazeeraEnglish #101East #JarawaTribe
![ARGENTINA vs. BOLIVIA [6-0] | RESUMEN | ELIMINATORIAS SUDAMERICANAS | FECHA 10](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/C3wPtKNbAOA/mqdefault.jpg)
Do not call them uncivilized. They are not encroaching you’re territory, you lost your civility by trespassing their dwelling. Conservation of ancient tribes means preserving their ancient birth place and maintaining peace by not using them as tourists attraction and making money out of their history. They know how to live their lives.
You are right
💯💯💯
I dont think the tourist is using the word uncivilized in a derogatory way. In Thai language too the word uncivilized can now have both its positives as well as negatives.
We understood that there are some same black tribe called ALUR there while in Africa Uganda and DRC are also called the same. We fell down poured if people call them PRITIVE when they are ours. I feel going to stay with them
The native are in the country of India. I believe it’s time to teach them in schools, languages and healthcare, septic systems, and freshwater. Everything changes. Keeping them pristinely wild is just someone else’s idea being thrust upon them. Everything changes
Why do they say lost tribe, lost city . People can't be lost if they being living in the same place for thousand of years . These indo Europeans are lost .
It's lost as in the rest of the world lost touch with this group onof people.
Ur speaking and indo European language and indo European started in asia
I agree...their not lost, they need to be left alone and protected by the government
👍🏾
@@gazinape5851 wtf you talking about indo european started asia are you out of ur stupid brain or what? when asia existed empires like the chinese mongol or indian europeans were living in caves
All tourism should be stopped in this area. Let them live their way of life.
They are your cousin's if you read the Bible you would that thank you for your time and consideration
That's impossible; they are black.
Definitely agree they should leave these people alone!!!
An an east Indian skin colour isn't black?
@@jawest6436 its the heart that matters the skin in this world.....is black or white
These precious people are the history of all our beginnings; a part of all of us. They need to be protected and cherished. The abuse and exploitation is disturbing. I hope they have more protection in 2020 🙏
Nooo their ancestors were taken as slaves. Babu India's also were not educated and if they say that they were educated earlier than white English people, why these things happened. ASIA'S SHOULD CHANGE THEIR BEHAVIORS, THEY SHOULD RESPECT OTHER HUMAN BEING AND GOD CREATIONS. IF NOT. IT WILL BE DISASTROUS. MANY MANY YEARS THEY MAKE TROUBLES, AND GOD REPEATS REPAIR EVERYTHING INCLUDING THEMSELVES. BUT SOME OF THEM ARE BOASTING, AND THEY FORGOT THAT THEY HAVE CHANGED FAITH BOOKS SO THAT NO BODY KNOWS WHAT WILL HAPPENS NEXT AFTER OUR WORLD DEMOLITIONS. I HOPE THEY DESTROY THOSE BOOKS THINKING THAT GOD IS A SIMPLE PLAYMATE MASONRY OR CARPENTER OR A WEAVER. THIS TIME mmm mmm.
Shame on the Director General of Andaman Police and his rotten teeth, justifying the abuse and exploitation of the Jarawa!!
its 2022 dummy
@@ryanbeev Not really 🤔
I wanted to laugh when the woman said they aren't civilized. I am not sure if we modern people are so civilized, if you know what I mean. Leave them alone.
🗣Those “claiming” to be “civilized” have proven to be the MOST UN-civilized
Well, it depends on your definition of civilization. To be civilized today seem to me to be highly organized and materially developed plus technology. Not WAR. You can be civilized and engage in WAR, that's not going to cancel your civilized status. It's more like having infrastructure systems, being able to highly modify your environment, highly organize society with systems like water, sewage, transportation etc.
Amen, words of wisdom and Truth ‼️💯
@@durangobasics6195 praise the LORD GOD FROM WHOM ALL BLESSINGS FLOW. Yes for All .. evil in men and women created that silly faithless brainwashing controlling s doubting evil system to use others yes,
I thank the Lord God for the gift of the internet so that short and tall black and white rich and poor bondage and free can 💑😨😰😕😌👀👀👀👀👀see the PURE HOLY SWEET FREE HAPPY LOVE OF GOD ALMIGHTY amen amen amen
@@durangobasics6195 WHAT YOU LISTED OUT ARE ONLY RELATED WITH THE MATERIAL WORLD BUT CIVILIZATION IS MUCH MORE THAN WHAT YOU MENTIONED HERE.
MORALITY SHOULD BE THE FUNDAMENTAL OR BASIC FOUNDATION AND ELEMENT OF CIVILIZATION. ADVANCEMENT IN TECHNOLOGY OR IN MATERIAL WORLD CIVILIZATION IS NOTHING IN THE ABSENCE OF MORAL SOCIETY BUT THE REVERSE IS NOT TRUE BECAUSE UNCIVILIZED SOCIETY CAN SURVIVE WITGHOUT THESE MEANS OF IMMORALITY.
Right?! She had a lot of nerves to say that. She's the savage beast!!!
The only people in the world that could read the natures signs of the tsunami 2004. they read it ran and no one died! amazing, let the people live alone! let them be!
I remember that!!
actually there are signs that are easy to spot. the sea will retreat back to the deep, and the big wave comming towards the coast
All Abored they,the dead,didnt know what it means and they were caught by surprise. a lot of people saw the water receded it was very obvious to the eye, the just dont know what it meant.
That's amazing.
@@jesuskrisv9761 easy to spot so why so many died then???
Stop! These people have lived thousands of years without your help. Civilized ‘Help’ is never a good.
Shiloh Rose 581 yup! do as you preach and, throw away your phone. run to the jarawas, they have a better life.
@@jesuskrisv9761, very well said.
@@jesuskrisv9761 you're a big fool.
@ you are an even bigger fool.
Orange Lego but, you have a tiny mind.
MAY GOD BLESS THOSE WHO PROTECT THE TRIBES. They are naturally beautiful people. And free of illness. They do not have the horrible things happening to them that we have. They are in peace among themselves.
I wish I could live like this off the land and not off a plastic card
"They are not developed"
They are developed fully like anyone else they eat, sleep, poo, talk, have families and have feelings just like everyone else just because they want to live the way they want to live does not mean they are not "developed"
Absolutely 💯💯
If that where true homeless in America and around the world wouldn't be spat on and kicked around by people working 80hrs a week a paying $3k-$10k for an apartment they cant stand to be in... money let's people get away with a different set of things then not having a money system in place. Original us police where hired by the people that carried out mass genocide. Original lawyers where the ones putting people in prison for that house(castle) worth $100m today...
Exactly
@@michael4772 . Are you saying that billionaires are more "developed" than the rest of us? Make yourself clear.
"Developed" has a very specific meaning in anthropology. It is not the same as calling them "primitive." It doesn't imply that they lack any of the things that you've listed.
May this tribe continue to thrive and grow.
@BLUE DOG they have lived simple the way God intended.
@BLUE DOG its obvious your brain didn't grow either.
@bluedog that doesn't take much brain power either
@BLUE DOG that doesn't take much brain power either lol!!
@BLUE DOG A beverage that tastes that good doesn`t need selling.
Shame on these "tourists". Shame on the government of India.
That's so stupid of them.
It is disgusting and the police are awful. THE DIRECTOR GENERAL SHOULD BE SACKED!!
Big shame to Indian government and people who call others uncivilised. Big shame!!
@@mimigracious6886 💯🎯 I agree!!
Shame on Indians!
"the time has come to make them civilized" lol you gonna include them in your society then discriminate against them when you're done, it's better they stay the way they are they are happy
U are so right!
I couldn't have said it better!
Vidge Sithonga So true
I agree!!!!!!!!!!!
Exactly..
This really has me in tears the way they speak about them when We have so much to learn from them!
Stop disturbing them let them live their life, after all they are humans just like us, living how they know to survive. Respect them !!
I'm glad for all humans happy in the knowledge that none of us are valued less or more than the other in the eyes of God, in that we also share the same expectancies ...Death
We cannot come back and mock each other. We deficate in the same way, feel pain and live with expectations, some of which are denied, I wake thankfully each day, eat, sleep, laugh, cry and am ecstatic. I remember the film Roots, the scene where a newborn baby was raised in his slave father's hands to the sky and as he held him high he said as he cried out to an unseen God ...',Behold No Man Greater than I'. This is so true.... when I'm down and feeling the blues this scene pops up in my head and I battle on ...This is the true spirit of the oppressed to tingle with spirit and live in expectation to soldier on regardless 😉 We must each and everyone of us do this to survive...Gloom dies when light shines ✨️ 😀 😊
I DO NOT LIKE THIS!!!! It is insulting to the Jarawa Tribe!!!!
T
Love u
Yep and doing this to people isn't new but I guess we haven't learned.
How
What part of this mini-documentary is insulting to the Jarawa?
I would say that the police chief is one of the main problems here! The attitude of this guy is absurd. He does not care.
Absolutely! My thoughts exactly. He's very aware of the disgraceful things taken place. He and his policeman are disgusting for the involvement.
I agree, he is not taking his responsibilities serious at all. These people won't be here much longer.
Indian police and their action sucks all over india
It is a disgrace to the Indian government in general and public officials in particular for treating these peace loving people with such disdain purely because of their ethnicity or colour. Talking of civilization and primitive people, what is it to be civilized? It is not the fancy clothes we wear or the architecture of our living quarters and advanced technologies. It is all about human relationships. Do you have love for yourself? If you do, share it with humanity through respect, compassion and co-operation. The Jarawa people have a wealth of knowledge and cultural attributes which have sustained them for centuries that can benefit our so called modern society. Stop treating these people like animals because of your ill preconceived notions of them. Such prejudices have always been stumbling block to a peaceful coexistence.
DO NOT TAKE THEIR LAND from them and shove them into some remote and restricted corner of the land. Land can only be leased to outsiders or entities.
Get the people actively involved in policy making decisions pertaining to their community. They have been isolated because of geographical barriers and now if the government wants to have active dealings with the Jarawa people, the priorities should be in order. Education, Health, Security, Energy, Roads, and Communication systems.
The natural resources of the Jarawa people can be harnessed through co-operative efforts of the people (local government),Govt. at large, and the private sector
These people need all the help they can muster. It can be done but is humanity ready to step up to the plate?
Yeah he shouldn't have been so 'whatever' but there were punishments. Also he still punished the guy for organizing the safari for his family. He's right about his crime not being as serious too because Al Jazeera put the clips here on youtube so they're worse than that guy too.
this makes me sad
this people should be left alone
The oppressor is always interfering...they were happy, healthy and free from diseases....but now the oppressors wants to steal their identity and land...they were quite fine until now...nothing has changed!!
I just finished watching a documentary about human zoos in America, and now I'm watching about human safaris in India. In both documentaries the victims are black .
AfricancoolChic
send me the link to that documentary of human zoo in America !
@@therwandannoble2034 If you copy paste the title you will find it. 'Human zoos: Americas forgotten history of scientific racism'. It is very sad to watch. 😢
@@AfricancoolChic watched it too, so sad and horrifying.
@@kmuturi238 Yes, it truly is.
Sad how they treat the real HUEMANS ... without us it wouldn’t be no them ... I wonder if they would treat God/angels/UFOs the same way
That is the world we live in, my heart pours out to these people whose naivete is taken advantage of by the self imposed superiors
I find the idea of a human safari repugnant in the extreme.
The Jurawas are viewed as zoo animals.
These disgusting tourists cannot seem to stay in their own places, yet they are appalled by the thought of strangers in their neighborhoods.
This kind of behavior is pretty sad and shameful.
The person who wanted to know what they are doing there, does not grasp the reality of someone living in his own domain not having to have a reason or explanation.
Shoshana are you allowed to pet them ?
Yeah this happened to Africans during slavery times. We still on that bull I see.
@@D_M_S_4 be careful..... They will let you when the ALL returns.
Unfair exploitation of a people.
Please leve these people alone and stop exploiting them. They have been eating their food all along and have been healthy. Opportunists!
The road should be closed FOREVER!
Right...build a different one for your trade on an opposite as to not disturb them.also if they have been there for like a billion years OBVIOUSLY they are doing JUST fine without the outside??
The road should be closed indefinitely!!
shame to India people and government !
Exactly! Leave them alone!!
Closed the road so u guys can protect them from tourist and hunters
there were an estimated 6000 Andamanese indigenous people in the early 19th century ... now there are less than 500 from ALL tribes, including Jarawa. several other tribes went extinct already. the Jarawa were incredibly brave even to make contact ... but it is probably because they had no other choice
Don’t like the way they are pulling them and redirecting them in a slave like manner. This is really hard to watch.
Me too, I hated the way that young man was being pulled/pushed. 😪
Slave like manner? Jheeze that’s an over exaggeration
Leave them alone we all know what your humanitarian aide does.
They can send for us in africa.they look like us
@@zamzamabdi5279 I would go. They will not let them come here.
4 sure.
'What are they doing here"? Well for your information Mr. young Indian, you're the intruder here and ask yourself that silly question.
😂😂😀😀😁😁😁 Truth
Sow real and so true
Pls leave them alone...don’t disturb them.. pls keep them happy..
They are not lost thats their homeland 💯
Black man and woman were all over this planet before the Neanderthals
Shame on those people for exploiting those amazing people like that
I think they need a new police Chief he is probably in the middle of the mistreatment of these ppl.
I hope they protect those tribal people.
STRAIGHT UP
They won't, we would have to do it
@Rich 91 😂😂😂
What a shame . Ignorant people / tourists wanting to exploit the beautiful island and their indigenous people. Look at the stupid police chiefs response and his laugh , calling his policemens abborent behaviour as a ‘ mistake’ . Shame. I am sure this police chief is involved in exploitation too , from the way he speaks. God bless the ngo’s and good samaritans working to protect the tribals. More power to them . Lets close the road going thru their territory.
Some tourista called them uncivilised . What a laugh . Its us the so called civilised people who destroy . Those supposedly uncivilised tribes infact are better than us as they protect nature and are one with it .
The ngo's ? 😤😤😤😤😤😤
?I thought I was the only one to catch that.
Lorraine BanathYasharahla u r right , some ngo’s ...or maybe mst of them , are as deplorable ...but i pray that there r a few who are doing a good job
They are upset because they are intuned with mother earth instead of the globalist agenda to destroy the world.
You know yes its all about the glass beads money sad sad.....but God is watching them all
I couldn't watch anymore after the police chief said "it's their natural reaction to dance" WTF
@velveteyes79 nice when racists identify themselves
Yeah that's when I stopped the video...disgusting.
@velveteyes79 Who is "their" ? I'm black and I don't have rhythm nor do I love to dance. Such a racist statement 🙄
@velveteyes79 is this the only way you can get attention? lol so pathetic
@velveteyes79 they were brought from Africa? You sure about that one? Considering civilization begun in Africa and it is thought this tribe originates from the Original Africans who left the continent... who prey tell brought them?
They are humans and they deserve to be treated as such, not doing so is inhuman and uncivilised.
Jarawa needs a human rights representative.
Yes...send old silver back Sharpton.....see how good he does. LOL
@@dapabur1 LOOOOOOL
They are a happy ppl satisfied with their way of life
@@sondralee232 Yes they are and should live their lives
50 cents😂😂😂
These are the real ancestors of the indian people. Another evidence of our origin: Black people.
These are two distinctly different phenotypes.
They have beautiful body structures : Strong, nice cheek bones, skin.
@@lorrainebanathyasharahla1195
And beautiful as in BEAUTY.
Pure and simple.
💯
No they are not. They came to India from south africa when people from India was already there. They are from south africa
VERY SAD TO SEE A HUMAN BEING TREATED LIKE THIS IN INDIA.
They are treated good compared to some other classes in india....
@@morrisbr.5408 no they texted them like animals did u see how he speaks to them. They're innocent 😔 I really kill that guy if I'm from their tribe
Insulting to say they are uncivilized...sure they know how to survive better. Leave them alone..that is one place left for protection, freedom, natural foods. medicine, minerals.
Who's to say they're lost tribe, lost from what?
Those tribes and others would like to be left alone.
respect goes alone way, calling them stone age.
they are who they are.
It 's a pleasure to know these people are here.
These people who are human beings are the original Indians
No they are not. They came from south africa.
@BLUE DOG they are a group of people that heathens can't control, push false religion on, work them for free, can't make money off, push their deadly man made medicine on, feed them their process poisonous food, lie about the real history and identity, the are are black and been protected, that just kills people, leave them alone and worry about wickedness, sickness and corruption going on wherever you live.
We'll I don't who are the original,, Indians claims those are black people yet in their history the southern part has got so many black people there originally Indians, Tamil, Telugu, konkani and many more, so how do Indians explain that?
@BLUE DOG hide behind you're name untill you're exposed and the shut beat out of you're souless carcass
@@ruminaheve9909 south indians doesn't even look African more like a dark caucasian
I am beyond grieved. How long Lord? How long are you going to allow the continous mockery of black people. Mockery from all nations ???
nadine SHEPPARD AMEN
"Until the times of the Gentiles be fulfilled."
THE LORD HELPS THOSE WHO HELP THEMSELVES!!!
@@antarjohnbrown1802 So they're not? How would you even know?
@Diamond Leigh ONLY TRYING TO WAKE UP SOME OF THE MELINATED DEAD IN AMERIKKKA... ONLY A GOD CAN RAISE THE DEAD!!! YOU SO CAUGHT UP LOVING YA DANG ENEMY... SO KEEP YOUR HEAD IN THE GROUND LIKE THE OSTRICH... SOME CAN EXCEPT ENLIGHTENMENT SOME WILL FOREVER REMAIN IN DARKNESS !!!
On another video I saw that they kill invaders that got too close and throw back food that tourist offered. If only Africans had the same practice😘
Remember your HISTORY - -- True history regarding The Africans. Need I say anymore 😤😤😤
that is the sengali people and they fight strong to protect their way of life a civilization over 60,000 years old believed to be decended from the original humans who migrated out of africa I hope they remain strong and continue to fight for their freedom and others will leave them and rise around them and fight for their right to exist in peace left alone!!! they've been wise to remain isolated and protected from the rest of the world nothing but desecration illness and death awaits them should the world intrude on their home it's our responsibility with our knowledge of what awaits them to fight with them from a distance as hidden allies to save them from a history we all know too well.
There is another island called sentinel island. Its banned to go there. Recently a missionary pervert was bowed down.
Hmnmm. 4 sure.
Those are africans. They came from south africa. And alot of tribes in africa did did that. It was just sell outs and the europeans using guns that got them that far
When the colonized become the colonizers.
Nice, everyone has to answer the deep questions himself before judging others' answer.
Define "civilized", this always keeps coming up whenever an African culture thrives through time without the dependence of industrial or chemical manufactures. The authorities and public viewing, visiting or facilitating these safaris bear full responsibilities for invoking the need for rewards the Jarawa people feel; the exploitation of their land and environment runs so deep there’s only enough time to interview mostly the cops and other officials to navigate the Indian’s protection laws. Mainland India is so vast and structured to accommodate its population, the Andaman issue must only be for the people living there and that is all what the interest is about. India was the destination Europeans thought they were going to, now India has to correct their own behavior to demonstrate how "civilized" it is by preventing engaging in the similar fate native Americans experienced.
Maybe you could join the Jarawa people..
@@josephinetracy1485 this reply sounds like you are enjoying the abuse and oppression vulnerable individuals are experiencing.
All humans, no matter how much you wish they did not exist, still they deserve the right to live and thrive with dignity according to their upbringing.
Thank you for your interest.
Maybe you could meet a wonderful local woman with a beautiful short fro
@@josephinetracy1485 oh, I get it, that's your M. O.. Nice going.
@@josephinetracy1485 ur stupid ever🤔
Am so angry right now
Give them a chance to live as they want to..
leave the jarawa alone ... they dont want contact ..respect that
You, resort owner, go away!
@@ivanauletu huh ? was that directed at me ?
@@ivanauletu 😂😂😂
If it's true that they want modernity, the tourists gave them that desire. It is hard to know what they authentically want without them being exposed to what modern life is really like. Many people are dying of stress from poverty, inequality and disease in "modern" cities. What part of modern life would they be enjoying in India's classist, fair hue loving society? I mean no disrespect in saying so, but stop me when I've lied. These people would be poor and in slums, now having to worry about money, buying fruits they used to pick for free, dowry etc. on top of being uneducated, not speaking the language and feeling inferior. For those reasons, they should remain isolated until or if ever there's a sincere plan to make them better, not worse off.
Well said.👏
exactly
Who needs modernity with all the savagery in this world.
The Jawara and the Khoisan people of South West Africa are the living human fossils of the black African ancient people who left the continent hundreds of thousand years ago and give birth to all humans that we see on earth today. Whether you live in the Siberia frozen ice, in China , the far East, Australia, whether you're a Canadian aborigine, Australia aborigine, Arabs from the middle East, Europe, India subcontinent or the Mother Continent of Africa, as long as you're a living breathing human being on this planet, including our ancestors came from the Jawara's ancestors. They don't need any corrupt civilisation. A so called social construct civilisation , a dog eat dog civilisation. RESPECT AND LEAVE THEM ALONE. LET THEM CARRY ON WITH THEIR CULTURE.
@Faiez Cader They know how to live with Nature, they share everything, they don't look depressed, they don't need any education from liers, racist, murdererous theives
Unfortunately, I can only see this ending with devastating consequences for the Jarawa people ☹️
Ha!!! Excellent point. Now tell me who's the ones uncivilized us or them? They have lasted over 60 kya.
😂😂😁😤😤Great Question osiruskat 👍💪👏👏✋💯
They are far better off,they don't live in slums, they are happy
Yes Sir they are clean and pure and priceless. The Goverment shouldn't be making money out of them.
They are far more 'civililized' than the people who come to 'see' them.
As a Human bieng thats very embarassing to see.... instead of any positive interactions these people are feeling very proud when comparing themselves with the Jarawas while in reality they are the true ancestors of human race.
The poor looks down at the natural people, Astonishing 👏
Leave Native aboriginals live in peace!!!
Yes I agree with that to a point. But imagine if you lived in Europe 300 years ago. No painless operations. Sickness that could be cured or helped.those people left to die. Leave them alone but give them tbr oppettunity to avail of some of the progressed made in helping with pain etc. Not comparing them but you wouldn't leave a dog to die in pain if you could help it Balance is what is needed
Modern day slavery this is the way our forefathers fathers fathers was taken
Really? What are they building for their "masters" ?
Why do you want to destroy them 😭 please leave them alone go away.
How right you are. Are you from Sierra Leone or Liberia? You have a blessed day.
From Liberia n u? Am so excited to see such still around, wow God is great.
This is super interesting and I love watching this kind of documentaries... at the same time I wished they'd just be left alone. It's terrible that they're used as a tourist attraction. They should be protected from these settlers.
It's no different from visiting a tourist destination in Europe, The Americas, or SE Asia..... it's ok to go to a Peruvian village in the Andes, or a Vietnamese farm, or the Inuit people, in Alaska, but not the Andaman....Westerners should stop their touris travel if this is the case ... what hypocrisy..‼‼‼🙂🇺🇸
I with you on this subject. I wish people would leave these tribes alone. May God bless them.
Kkkolonizers are gonna Kkkolonized😂😂it’s disgusting and sad ATP
This police chief look corrupt and this video is from 8 years ago can you guys Make an update
couldn't watch it all, so condescending and racist
Its sad most Indians are racist and think all black people are "kachira" rubbish like they like to say,they are insecure have very little exposure about the black race!
Why is the Indian government and the UN allowing this?
@marrues ham Now THAT`S a racist comment.
Ack Phui he does have a point tbf. you know who started this change. before the indian subcontinent never visited the jarawa even though they had advanced ships etc. they had respect. colonial powers came in and changed how the world ran forever degrading these people. let’s look at the aboriginals of africa. before they were said to be uncivilised and neanderthal like. but in the 2000s when europeans were proved to be the closest living relatives to neanderthals, neanderthals were suddenly advanced, front runners in society and powerful. everything is to benifit the white naritive,
@@user-tn7kl3sq2r Har! Maybe so. But ALL cultures have their "skeletons"; the Arabs are still slavers; some of the indigenous cultures here in Canada used to be slavers, etc. Even prior to English invasion, pale complexion was valued in India. The main difference is that the Caucasians had guns and big ships which gave them a huge advantage. Just like the Germans and genocide: many cultures past and present have practised it; it`s just that the Germans were so damned efficient at it. So, yes, colonialism and racism MUST stop- - - - but don`t blame the Europeans as the cause of all evil. Good and evil exist in ALL peoples.
MS. (not Mr.) Willi in Canada.
Human safari, really sounds terrible.
That's because their plans for these ppl are really horrific. God forbid they are convinced to take injections?&:!$%%!
The ppl need to be left alone. It must be something in the soil govt is after
To the lady claiming they're not civilized is wrong civilized might mean different to different people and these people are civilized in their own way.
The disgusting woman who called them uncivilized made me furious. The so called civilized world is awash in crime, violence, greed, poverty and inequality. This story was so disturbing. The Jawara deserve better.
"Civilized" is seen as a positive connotation in the Western world. In reality, "Civilized" is just another word for greed, raping the land, all in the name of tech advances. To me "Civilized" is a negative. Those tribes are probably way happier than we ever will be.
I was shocked by the situation with the Jarawa; but actually, I'm more shocked by some of the comments on this video.
Jarawas are blessed people of God
Which God
Ummer Karappan they are allah’s creation
@@ummerka74 The God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob
The God of Abraham, , Isac and Jacob,
@@ummerka74 The Most High God
"They left Africa millions of years ago", when I heard that comment, I wanted to quit watching. We ALL came from Africa but only after we evolved into the human species. Indians are no different.
@Chola-Mutharaiyar-Valaiyar News Your own DNA proves it. Look it up. DNA of non-African people is a subset of African DNA.
and also they left Africa 70,000 years ago.
We all are descendants of Adam. None of us evolved into humans we were created human.
Thanks to Indian government for protecting them, much love from South 🇿🇦
They are not being protected. They are being violated by the government and the very policemen that should be protecting them
They should not be left alone .... Only by Most ..... Only Special people should go..... take nothing and bring them nothing. .... Just yourself . They are our Brothers and Sisters . God Bless and Keep them in Prayer .
Leave these people alone and don't let the tourist through they are developed people they don't need anything from anyone.
I hope the United Nations gets involved in protecting Jarawa the Island belongs to them, All the Indians need to leave these Islands Should be protected by the International community. Grow up India !
At the very least, all individuals reading the comments should bring this to the attention of the UN immediately! Many many atrocities afflicting Black people throughout the entire Earth! True that other people face bad treatment but the magnitude and the breadth of suffering that Black people encounter is truly shocking!
I felt like the young Jarawa 16:05 he pointed his finger and looked at the camera and said "Gtfoh ✌🏾" leave them People ALONE!
Hundreds of years ago us Indians were treated this way by the British and now these ignorant people are inflicting the same pain that our ancestors had to deal with. Despicable.
This is disgusting and they're being judged and look down on by people like those...
Who have really far less than a good reputations them self..
leave them alone!!!!!!!!!!
You don't need to bother about medication for the tribe, they know how to take care of their health.Its when the civilized people get involved caused them illness. That the place they would fish for food & drinking water...
Of course they need some help with meds, especially to treat diseases like Measles, Tuberculosis, etc etc!
Remember they were only 400 Andamanese. The reason is early death, malnutrition, death during birth, deseases. "Civilized" people are only the majority because their lifestyle assures the highest rate of survival and thus the highest population numbers.
protect them, our system doesnt work. they have survived a couple thousand years, how many wars have taken place here?
Great physical structures and strength.
these people are proving that india has some anti- black issues.
@ben yosep These people are ancient Indians
@@theresasmith5287 actually they are the original Asians…They are only black in complexion
This is horrific.
This guy sumit is only sees money not human
They are already ruined if they want something from the village.
most underated statement here
Sad but true.
The Earth belongs to everyone - free movement of all peoples. No land belongs to anyone.
The tribe has features that are more africians than indians. Guess the movement of humans out of africa is quite true.
Please find a very old map to remember where india was located
Its always been true, Humans didn't just randomly grow in all corners of the world. They all spread from africa many millennia ago.
however on genetic test the jarawa people are related to Indian people
@@razatiger22 the jarawa are not africans
@@theresasmith5287 They are the direct decendents of the Africans that left Africa. They may not be "africans" anymore, but their skin tone and features are African.
I pray that they will be PROTECTED!!!
Media has an important role to play here most people dont know about the suituation here,press on MEDIA!!salute to the editor of andaman chronicle
Leave these beautiful people alone. They are living the way we’re all meant to be living. Using only what we need, working for what they have everyday, family bonds we wouldn’t even know about. Stay away!
Ohh My Ppl I love you Stay Strong I hope government can do something to protect them 😓😭😥❤️❤️🥰🥰💥💥🔥🔥
@@ryanedwards805 Very Sad😭😓💔
Creator please Bless these people n protect them!🙏
That police chief lying through his teeth
These are truly God’s people and it bothers me how they have lived thousands and thousands of years probably millions isolated and these countries refuse to respect their culture and privacy needs. Build another road around the company or change and reroute.. they need more policing to stop this.. these tourists and people will bring others it should be strictly against the law..you have tribes like these living all over including Africa who are completely isolated and their lands are respected by the intruding governments.. that’s the least they can do. There should be strict international law against it.
It make me mad when white mixes know that BLACK SKIN IS NATIVE and((ORIGINAL))TO EACH LAND MASS!!! But they call them African to disconnect the Original from the Land!!
You sound like a hater. Those are africans that came from south africa on they own. Stop trying to make a seem . And stop getting false information from dan cataway or whatever his name is
Hey hey cmon guys ,its true though ,black skin is the mother of every land,,,,,both black couple can give birth to white skin baby but both white couple cannot give birth to a black skin baby, you can check with any qualified doctor
I agree!!
They’re just the indigenous people
You are correct, they are Y DNA D
“The most well-known unique event polymorphism (UEP) that defines DE is the Y-chromosome Alu Polymorphism (YAP) YAP. The mutation was caused when a strand of DNA, known as Alu, inserted a copy of itself into the Y chromosome. Hence all Y chromosomes belonging to DE, D, E and their subclades are YAP-positive (YAP+). All Y chromosomes that belong to other haplogroups and subclades are YAP-negative (YAP-).”
Discovery
The YAP insertion was discovered by scientists led by Michael Hammer of the University of Arizona.[11] Between 1997 and 1998 Hammer published three articles relating to the origins of haplogroup DE.[12][13][14] These articles state that YAP insertion occurred in Asia. As recently as 2007, some studies such as Chandrasekar et al. 2007, cite the publications by Hammer when arguing for an Asian origin of the YAP insertion.[6]
This analysis was based on the fact that older African lineages, such as haplogroups A and B, were YAP negative whereas the younger lineage, haplogroup E was YAP positive. Haplogroup D, which is YAP positive, was clearly an Asian lineage, being found only in East Asia with high frequencies in Japan and Tibet. Because the mutations that define haplogroup E were observed to be in the ancestral state in haplogroup D, and haplogroup D at 55kya, was considerably older than haplogroup E at 31kya, Hammer concluded that haplogroup E was a subclade of haplogroup D.[14]
1. ↑ Hammer MF (September 1994). "A recent insertion of an alu element on the Y chromosome is a useful marker for human population studies". Mol. Biol. Evol. 11 (5): 749-61. PMID 7968488.
2. ↑ Hammer MF, Karafet T, Rasanayagam A, et al. (April 1998). "Out of Africa and back again: nested cladistic analysis of human Y chromosome variation". Mol. Biol. Evol. 15 (4): 427-41. doi:10.1093/oxfordjournals.molbev.a025939. PMID 9549093.
3. 1 2 Altheide TK, Hammer MF (August 1997). "Evidence for a possible Asian origin of YAP+ Y chromosomes". Am. J. Hum. Genet. 61 (2): 462-6. doi:10.1016/S0002-9297(07)64077-4. PMC 1715891
4. . PMID 9311756.
5. 1 2 3 Hammer MF, Spurdle AB, Karafet T, et al. (March 1997). "The geographic distribution of human Y chromosome variation". Genetics. 145 (3): 787-805. PMC 1207863
6. . PMID 9055088. Thessalonians
Why can't the Indian government just stop tourists from going there??? Like just leave these people alone.
3:31 the Indian man said he want to know what they doing here. Imagine someone come in he's house and ask him what are you doing here.
It's making me sick.
The police chief is laughing, they won't be too serious . All safaris through the area need to be stopped. It is obvious that the convoy system is a safari arrangement. There is an obvious disdain for the people and their protection.
We all have to live like Jarawa people. We have to learn from Jarawa and not the other way around, they live in harmony with nature, we don't. We destroy nature and everything that is close to us.
sad to see such an advanced civilization as india treat such a precious and unique tribe like this.India has lost it's soul
The attitude of the so called civilized society but I’m sure the tribe is spiritually more mature because they take care of each other