Moshe Safdie Reacts to Israel-Hamas Conflict
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 сен 2024
- Moshe Safdie, global architect and world citizen, speaks on the risks, hopes and challenges for Israel as it faces consequential choices about Hamas and hostages.
This conversation was taped remotely on October 12, 2023.
Charlie, we missed you so much. No one in the current American media universe can cover important events and people with professionalism, depth, and knowledge as you do. Thank you.
Eat me, we didn't do anything. This guy has abused women for decades. What if he abused your daughter? Get a spine.
Those were all allegations, nothing was proven. There was no abuse, I heard his side of the story as well. And I make my decision about it based on the facts that I hear. To answer your question, anyone touches my girls - dies! My spine is firm and I make my own decisions about the events. Weinsteins and Epsteins should be executed for rape and pedophilia, Charlie Rose was a victim of disgruntled employees who stained his reputation. If facts come out and prove the opposite of it then I’ll change my opinion. But from what I heard from both sides, I don’t consider him as abuser.
The last issue was a sexual comment that he would like to see from his second floor his assistant bathing naked in his swimming pool. Other than this comment, I did not hear any scandal. Yes, I miss him in the main stream-he is a solid intellectual.
@malikahmad8170 While you obviously aren't aware of the case against him, just because you pay people off doesn't make you not guilty or innocent. What if your daughter was molested by Charlie? Would you tell your daughter " honey he's so smart, who cares if he violated you ".
@@NSGca what a nonsensical comment requiring an emotional response. He was inquired on ethical grounds and let go. There was no legal issues which were settled or reported in the media. Other than some loose sexual language, there was nothing else found. Immature mind like you should not watch such programs.
Charlie, It's impossible to express how much you have been missed. Welcome Back! We need you so much more now than ever.
It's so good to see you again, Charlie. Your interviews are always illuminating.
thank you, Charlie and Mr.Sofdie; very interesting and explanatory at this confusing time. Charlie, we need you back!
so good to see you again, Charlie. Please keep at it, as long as you can!
I can’t wait to watch more, Charlie! I’ve always loved the Charlie Rose show. Your interviews were well thought out, great questions you always allowed your guest to answer uninterrupted! I loved the wide range of Guests from Presidents to musicians like Robert Plant, who you didn’t drill about reuniting! Asked and answered… moved on to the next 50 years of his singing career! I hope you come back and keep going! You’re missed!
charlie, it's fantastic to see you again. you were missed. i've gone back to your old interviews so many times. donna tartt and david foster wallace and nicole kidman and angelina jolie. the possibility that there might be more conversations on the way brings me so much joy.
Such a needed interview and a challenging, yet wise perspective … thank you both Charlie and Moshe 🙏🏽
Mr. Safdie, I am pleased to hear your thoughts. Tragic events are not an excuse for becoming unhuman.
Damnit I miss this guy so much.
Welcome back Charlie
These are very sad days for Israel, and for the world, but I agree with your guest, this might be an oportunity for something that should have been done all these years, but it wasn't, a step in front and not backwards.
But I'm fearfull that an assault on Gaza and excesses thereof , could put the possibility of peace even further.
Very dificult situation.
Thank you to both of you
As always, an excellent interview, Charlie Rose.
Good to see you back Charlie!! Thanks for your sensitive interventions...
Tack så mycket för detta samtal med många kloka tankar
I've missed the Charlie Rose show and I'm glad to see it back. I enjoyed listening to the guest. There are things I agree with and things I disagree with. Free Palestine.
Moshe Safdi may be a good architect, but he ignorantly lacks understanding of the truth about the Israeli reality. He brutally distorts the truths of life in Israel and the understanding of the political reality in Israel. Shame on you Sepdi.
My husband and I love your show. It is a great surprise to see you again. You was a fresh breath to see you and your interesting interviews with the amazing people!
We missed you Charlie.
Thank you for the truth this man is talking it.
The most interesting part of this interview is the fact that Charlie Rose is still alive.
Good point about traveling giving you deeper humanism and appreciation for varied points of view. Travel is so educational.
Learning this in real time, my young family is on country 23 in last 18 months, it’s been a real blessings beyond what I would have imagined. Walking through and interacting with people in foreign places makes one hate war and all of these old folks with the string in their hands even more than before. War is stupid, we’ve met nothing but good people around the world in rich and poor places.
Excellent interview, Charlie. And your guest is amazingly smart, experienced and articulate. Thank you both!
I really admire these reasoned voices from Israeli intellectuals in these difficult times. Nuanced, informed and looking for acceptable outcomes. I miss that to some extent on the other end of this conflict. Both parties need to stand in each others shoes and see the humanity in each other. A confederate state is no brainer: all the land for all the people, Israelis elect a government in Tel Avid and the Palestinians a government in Nablus. It does not have to happen overnight and it can proceed over a decade while trust and cooperation is established.
Will Israel still be safe from extremists?
You reveal your bias. We elect our government in Jerusalem, not Tel Aviv.
Welcome back, Mr Charlie Rose. You are irreplaceable 🌹
Glad to see you making more videos. Like the nod to your old show set. How about bringing on a nice old oak chair?
What to do about the Israel-Palestinian conflict? Is a federated union possible, or is a two-state solution the only answer? Either way, Hamas has to go. 75 years of conflict won't end easily, if at all.
American cohesion has been breaking down for several years, too. It's hard to talk people out of destroying their adversaries when they get on that trajectory. Personally, I think only a third party could help this country out. It looks like we're in for another 4 years of the same anxiety if we have a Biden-Trump contest again. How long can this go on. We need a fresh face and a new attitude. No Labels is my choice.
It would be great to see insight on the candidates for the 2024 election with much time given to alternatives. A lot of channels do news video from other channels (when permitted) with commentary - an easier schedule - with someone in the background of the story. You always excelled interviewing people in the background who are usually very frank, knowledgeable, and willing to share their insights freely making great conversations. Nobody would do it better.
Just another viewer wanting more of your time and expertise. 🙂
Good interview 👍! Mr. Rose! Thank you! Missing you! Wishing you coming back to TV programs again.
This attack was a "rage against the machine", a revolt against the intolerable human conditions into which the Israelis forced and segregated the Palestinians, stole their land and drove them from their homes. It is downright ironic, but very sad, that the nation on which the Holocaust was perpetrated uses the same methods of ethnic cleansing on its Palestinian cousins who are not of the same faith. And one more thing, to have a music festival next to the fences of the largest concentration camp in the world, which is Gaza, is cynicism of the worst kind. It's like the Nazi youth having their Oktoberfest at the gates of Auschwitz. And the last thing - I'm Jewish.
Or maybe Hamas just wants all Jews out of their homeland, forever, at any price, no justification or other reasons needed.
Your argument does not hold water. Any Jew who can think this is not much of one. If anything , a delusional, self hating one, the lowest of the low. You should be banished for all this damaging shameful nonsense. This post is absolutely preposterous and I have read quite a bit of rubbish.This really takes the cake!
Yes. Agree. Thanks Charlie. Miss your interviews and insights.
The world needs you Charlie!
Wonderful to see Charlie Rose is back in the media... I signed up with you to hear you more and more in the days to come.
I was thinking about you Charlie on and off ... missed you on many topics and great conversations ... hope you stay active with the news media... you are a great journalist .... Thank You
I have been waiting a long time to see Charlie and his amazing interviewing skills back in action!!! Good to see you back, bummer it took something so horrible to have it happen.
Charlie this is such a fascinating, informative, critical interview. Thank you. You are so missed and I hope to see more interviews soon.
The best interviewer in history. So good to see him back. Hope to see the wood table ronde back also
Welcome back Charlie. ❤🎉
Moshe Safdie seems to be a very smart and thoughtful man.
glad to see you back Charlie. but you got to do something else with that background. Also where's the famous wooden circular table. dude?
Charlie Rose was the best show on TV
Yes.. He is human. Liked pretty girls. But that's not a sin. My favorite interviewer forever ~ 🌹 A 🌹 is a🌹
It;s amazing that no mention of self-determination for Palestinians in West Bank and Gaza! A defacto annexation is taken for granted and the Palestinians have to either accept a life of servitude as second class citizens, leave or die (according to Ben Gvir and Smotrich).
An insightful interview indeed. We would be interested to hear his latest commentary after almost a year into the genocide and destruction of Gaza, and now also the West Bank.
Safdie, great architect and human being!!!
Excellent. Thank you. We suffer with Israel. Sh'ma and We are listening.
Egypt and Jordan no longer suffer with Israel, and you, too. can end suffering.
@@nuqwestr I do work towards ending suffer an individual commitment right now to tzedakah as part of partipation in our global mtizvot of tikkun Obama and dedication to social action. There is not much left for me in life to gather much personal happiness or joy from. As well I continue to heal from pain associated with a car accident some few years ago. However, I recognize that there are not only others who suffer like myself but are others far worse of than I am. I have been fortunate in this situation to have had much help from the kindness of strangers and myself participate the same as they by passing along housing, medical information and food, as I am able, to others. I have worked as a teacher and case manager (QMRP) of children (Deaf) and adults with disabilities, with organizations like Volunteers of America once associated with the Salvation Army (where I learned about community resources for the homeless and detox programs from addiction) so that I bring these experiences into the broader span of my daily experience. As well, I have learned to listen more than I speak though the study of some Eastern meditative practices. Yet at the end of the day, I do believe that in standing with Israel and the Jewish people as a light among the nation we must remember that we were once aliens in a foreign land and have an obligation to treat the alien in our midst as God is said to have treated us...with tzedakah (charty/loving /kindness, fairness, and law (justice).
Hi Moshe, I'm glad to see you. Maybe you don't remember me but I'm Joe Baumholz's daughter (from Montreal but now living in Vancouver). I hope you and your family are all well.
The events of this past week have had me remembering my dad even more than usual, and hearing you makes it even more so. Whatever has happened to Labour Zionism?
❤ Living legend!!! Moshe Safdie!!!
at last , the truth is clearly stated. I pray for my beloved people.
I would be interested in an update on this now that 5 months have passed.
Dear God I'm well to hear Charlie Rose's voice ~ my shoulders drop to relax ~ Knocking on Heaven's Door ~ Charlie's voice takes me there ☮️🙏🕊️
Moshe is my new hero! Well said.
Thank you @charlierose for a great interview!
Blaming the victim since 1948.
Thank you America for taking care of the families and friends 💟.
New York Thanks God you back,Missed a lots Welcome back Please say something about Armenian if you have chance Thanks again and you appearances one of the good news in our crazy world
Glad to see Charlie back, but please let the guest talk!
His voice is the voice of hope.
Hamas is NOT "the Palestinian perspective"
KEEP THAT IN MIND
What is your evidence that Palestinians do not share the Hamas perspective? Clearly the Muslim demonstrators throughout the world supported Hamas unequivocally. Why would you say Gazans or other Palestinians think any differently?
We missed you Charlie!!!
Good to see Charlie back. What is Israel's exit strategy after taking over Gaza? Years and decades of military occupation?
Good to see Charlie back. Nevertheless, the guest suggests not going into Gaza after Hamas. I honestly don't know if holding back would work better.
Right ~ Cannot leave your country to be overrun ~ Thank God Netanyahu is in charge ~ for a short time some one else was running Israel ~ he was fired ~ Goes back to WWII ~ the British dividing countries & not knowing right from wrong ~ Gaza did need protection ~ Does need protection ~ Always needed protection ~ Civilians living in total fear always ~ Netanyahu is tough & strong & the best ~ cannot have a wimp ~
Moshe 1972 OLYMPICS MUNICH
Shame on you ..Israel is an apartheid state ...its not up to you to decide how Palestinians fight back and resist the long genocide land theft and apartheid they have been living under
Welcome back
Agree with the guest
Safdie holding nothing back. Interesting perspective trying to reach a long term solution
How about a two state abstract with an UN federal edifice.
Charlie...you have your pants on. How refreshing.
the deference to Thomas Friedman in this
is grossly misapplied
Hamas is finished, but ideology of dead is not.
Charlie Rose is back ?
Yes.
Very interesting conversation. However to blame Trump for rising antisemitism is absurd. As to Safdie's conversations in Britain that show antisemitism, that is not surprising. I grew up in Britain in the 60s' and it was prevalent.
Hate crimes tripled under Trump. Nazis marched the streets and white nationalist groups exploded with new recruits. It's not absurd at all. His own rhetoric repeats Hitler quotes.
May I be this sharp and vibrant at 85.
Don't play the SMALL games, guys.
"A multinational rail and shipping project linking India with the Middle East and Europe has been announced on the sidelines of the G20 summit in New Delhi in a step seen as a challenge to China’s economic ambitions in the region.
The corridor, which would include India, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Israel and the European Union, would help boost trade, deliver energy resources and improve digital connectivity". - Al Jazeera
Charlie is back???
I call it justice not revenge. A consequence to criminal behavior
Another cancelled talent. The world owes you an apology, Charlie!
Did bejamin know and ignore it, knowing the retaliation would be enormous and possibly drive out palestinians from Gaza, forever. Cynical but so is west Bank land takeovers
I think Lex Friedman should listen to this interview. His recent interview with Kutchner is so confusing (about his position)
Gubmint is a key word ❤
This guy is very honest i think, don't agree with everything he says but the federal system he speaks of how would that work tho, 1 man 1 vote?
Are we just going to pretend like Israel isn't an apartheid ethnostate that manages the world's largest concentration camp? The recent attacks on Israel are vile. However, you can't expect a country that behaves as immorally as Israel to not experience a reaction.
Not an apartheid state, not a european colony. Jews were majority in Jerusalem from the 1880s until the 1920s until the British supported Arab faction in killing Jews. Jews have been there since before Islam was created in the early 7th Century. Arabs are 20% of the population of Israel and serve in government. Show me something comparable in Gaza or the West Bank?
Yes, Israel is "apart" from those who work toward a Caliphate where Sharia law rules all non-Muslims. Egypt and Jordan want nothing to do with that, either. The Saudis are working with India to build an economic corridor that includes the Middle-East. Gaza could be a PART of that, with 40 kilometers of coastline on the Mediterranean. It's ideology like yours which keeps them living in the past.
How many jews live in Iran?
"Reaction" is a merciless slaughter of thousand civilians in cold blood? One by one, car by car, house by house... Executing, torturing, burning alive, cutting throats. Ten killed, onto the next house and murder ten more, children with their mothers.. Old people, unborn babies, young unarmed kids with fathers. Husbands and widows, no mercy for anyone.
This is your description of "REACTION"? The attack was vile but defending such an incredible inhuman attack is nothing short of evil. Accepting that such behaviour is 'ok' and therefore giving freen light for similar "reactions" in the future, enabling mass murderers and their vile deeds. You should be ashamed of yourself.
You should ask yourself: if Israel committed such an inhuman attack towards the Palestinians, how far would the Palestinians go?
Yes, that's how far Israel will be going! So strap in and hold on to your hat cause this ride hasn't even started yet!
@@jamesfrench4337 How many Jews AND Iranians live in the US, Canada, the UK, France, Germany, Spain, Australia, Italy, etc...?
Safdie reveals his anti-religious socialist prejudices here, speaking about religious people fleeing the state. What would he say about the hundreds of hareidi youth who have volunteered for military service?
12:29
Safdie is making some bold claims about Israel's govt here with absolutely no evidence to back it. It's like a conspiracy theory show.
I do however like his architecture.
Yeah, Moshe has a Classic Liberal Western education and now somewhat "Woke" infected. A shame.
Excellent video that speaks volumes about the state of both the Israeli and the Palestinians Governments.
The Palestinians of course do not have a State which has encouraged this wayward extreme Israeli Government to expand the Israeli territories, almost like Hitler tried to do but on a much smaller scale. Now it is pretty pbvious that Gaza will be bombed to hell and into total surrender with the possibility of clearances and the expansion of Israel.
The unfortunate Palestinians with their wayward extreme Government in Gaza which has only one objective of eliminating the Israelie State.
History shows that a State of Palestine was never allowed and will never be allowed, leaving Israel as the only State or Country .
This is pure madness, surely the Palestinians should have a State called Palestine, but I fear this will never happen for one very obvious reason, Iran and Russia.
Therefore there is no solution other than "gpod" governments democratically elected on both sides.
How on earth did the Israelies and Palestinians elect such extreme almost fascist governments.?
Hint
"the plan" Must Be to win the hearts & minds of Palestinians
Not thru zero-status, apartheid conditions of living, occupation etc etc etc
Do Israeli's have the deep morality for that challenge?
This man speaks in circles ~ Netanyahu best to do the. JOB ~ Charlie explained the situation so well ~ 🌹for Charlie ~ Elegant & Savoured for Eternity 🌹
Charlie, though a good interviewer, seems to imply in some of his questions/comments that essentially, Israel has only themselves to blame for the Hamas slaughter. Quite a blind spot.
He was looking for reasons for this horror. Well, the main reason is their extremist view that Israel must not exist, ever. That is the main reason.
Does anyone have a known-good BITCOIN address for Palestine?
💡 @CharlieRose..,
It would be super-helpful to hear you converse with #ShikmaBressler - to find-out what is her current perspective (after the October/07/2023 terrorist massacre).
Im a millenial.... the only thing we have seen our entire lives is the one sided treatment of israel vis a vis the Palestinians.....its simple why they feel the way they feel.....
עם כל הכבוד הממשלה3:45 שקמה היתה מצויינת. יכלה להיות יותר גדולה אבל להגיד שבגלל הממשלה שקמה😮 תפסיק ללכלך על ישראל גם בשעת מלחמה. לא אמשיך לצפות בתוכנית!!! לא יודעת איך ביידן יכול לתמוך גם עם חילוקי דיעות כאלה ואחרים ואתה ישר הממשלה(יפה לך שכך עשיתם כשנודע שהבגידה שלכם במדינה נתנה רוח גבית למחבלים ממש כל הכבוד תזכרו בספרי ההיסטוריה, תמשיכו להקי את עצמיכם החוצה שכולם יראו וישמעו שום דבר לא נמחק היום הכל מתועד. עם ישראל ומדינת ישראל וממשלת ישראל 🇮🇱 אני נותנת תמיכה מלאה❤😢❤
After a few minutes of Moshe trashning the Israeli government, so disrespectfully, I stopped listening. I left Monteal nearly 50 years ago to be here, not to pontificate from the comfort of my armchair.,
So, there is an urgent need to have Palestinian represented by a state government who could govern the people and obtain the justice and fair deals for people in Gaza. And Israeli could not continue the suppress of Palestinian people .......
Hamas was not democratically elected. They killed palestinian authority political opponents prior to the ' election's.
Wish this would have been viral. 2 weeks later? The hawkish impulsive far-right reactions have been allowed to lead…..
Doing exactly what the enemy ( -Iran)
wanted.
15:26 thats crazy
insider job as it was 911
My dream would be that you return to PBS to again take your rightful place as the top American interviewer. But it is clear that mediocrity is well-entrenched and would resist the return of intelligent discourse.
9:06 Tom Friedman is so partisan its disgusting
This generation of young people see how Israeli forces kill innocent Palestinian children indiscriminately and they sympathize with them and don't understand how Israelis don't have that sympathy. They also can't grapple with what Hamas did. The same young people will tell you they don't support Hamas violence by any means. Young people are much more enlightened and human. They don't understand why Palestinians and Israelis can't live together like normal people in one land, whereas secular living is common in the USA and in many other countries. This indicates to them something intrinsically wrong about the Israeli and Palestinian world view. History does not matter for young people, future, hope, harmony and love matters to them more. Maybe, all of us, old hags, should all learn from them.
Schlomo Sand! De-Abo
Ahh! That dark background is back!
I really hate the old Charlie Rose, years ago, he let people talk, guide their points with key questions, but letting them talk. As he grew old, he increasingly wanted to be the center of attention and kept injecting his points of view or agenda, I care nothing about what Charlie Rose thinks about any issue, and thats the way it should be, he is the interviewer… or just until he ousted. Let the people talk…
ur wrong he is smart n well reherse
30:35 women should leave hard subjects to men
Lets not blind ourselves, analize islam scriptures and how deeply violent they can be toward judeo christian west.
Old white men say What...
Ya, chuck bye.
How is this a one hundred year conflict...
try 2000 years worth of sky fairy hate.
God is dead
Ever since he killed every thing
That was not on a boat...
you all are a sad joke
Post-modern race essentialist who blames the White European Patriarchy for it all. Got it.