Hey all, it was brought to my attention that the "Product Punch-out" name was already used by Mike over at Modern Man TV. I have extended my apologies to Mike for using the same title, which was completely unintentional and just an oversight on my part. I am a fan of Mike's channel and I certainly did not mean to steal content or anything of the sort. I've updated the thumbnail and title for this video to "Hair Compare" - and this will be the title for future episodes of this series. Thank you all for your understanding.
Would be fun to see a new comparison between these two products, as the formula have changed quite a lot for both claymation and cavalier since this video was published.
+Modern Man TV Thanks so much man, that really means a lot! Again, sorry for the title - I definitely did not mean to steal your series name haha. Not sure how I missed it when I was trying to figure out a unique name for my own!
thanks matt, well done. for me, application is huge - time is takes to get the product in, styled and done. and even - which you touched upon - application ease. Claymation has less pull than blumaan or baxter which i like about it but the hold isn't equal to either. meanwhile, hate the pull of baxter - feels like its pulling my hair out! so not workable enough; actually uncomfortable to use. 'time and ease of application' is right up there for me with 'hold'. appreciate the video!
Ow shit this was a really cool video, this is a really great idea (sorry Robin but i think this was better because it was more in depth ) ,the editing was really well done did you do it yourself ? , please Carter supply flux vs Blumaan meraki ! or morris motley vs ....
I am glad that you favored Cavalier Clay at the end of this video. Cavalier Clay has more a matte textured look and meanwhile claymation has more of a semi matte look. The hold on Cavalier Clay lasts way longer on my straight thick hair than Claymation. With claymation I would have to use hairspray to lock my hair in place. This is why I love Cavalier clay better than Claymation. Also this is also one of my favorite videos from yours Matt.
because i've recently just spent a lot on a Morris Motley product, i wanted to give myself a ban on purchasing more hair products but damn this video is really tempting me to get the Cavalier Clay!
Finishing with HDF style lock hairspray really helps set the hold perfectly. It never dries out my hair and I can still move it around throughout the day if I need to and reshape it.
Hey Matt haven't been very active commenting on your videos recently but I'm loving the new hair! Getting my own Zac Efron haircut in 3 weeks wondering if you have any advice for what to ask for thanks dude loving the new content!
OK Fifa Thanks so much! If you're going for the Baywatch cut, I'd say go for a disconnect undercut with a tapered top, max length in the front around 5 inches. Bring pictures too!
Yes! A comparison between these two products by someone with similar hair as me (unruly wavy)! Trying to go for a medium length all round (near shoulder length) slick back. Hopefully the cavalier will be enough. Keep up the good work!
I hate claymation, I'm just trying to finish it, it makes my hair straw like and it has a terrible hold, I will buy Cavalier after I finish Claymation and I hope it'll be an improvement
Diego Olea I used that product for two years but overtime I got tired of the product and trust me if you have thick hair then I would suggest you go buy cavalier clay because of the longevity of the hold lasts so much longer man.
Good video matt! Don't listen to hater's saying you stole video idea, just cause caesy neistat is biggest vlogger doesn't mean no one else can vlog, same principle with hair videos! Also you should take a look at the pete & pedro line for reviews too.
+1admac Thanks man! I don't think anybody is really hating, I just didn't realize that someone else had already used this series title. No big deal, I'll be changing it up. Glad you liked it though!
forget the Issue I asked you about in your other video, I give up at this point but maybe after using the clay it could help because it could be the products I used that caused the problems, I have a thick hair and grows fast, would clay be good for my hair, I go to school for about 7 hours so I really need the hold
Hey, just a heads up: Modern Man TV launched his comparison series a while back with the exact same name - Product Punchout. Maybe you should find a diffrent name for your series
Ah, thanks for letting me know. Somehow I didn't realize that when I was searching for similar series to make sure I didn't have the same name. :/ Bummer!
Best things to do are avoid shampooing every day (better to do 3-4 times per week), make sure when you do shampoo, you use a sulfate-free one, and try using some nourishing styling products that include natural oils to keep your hair moisturized :) If you need help with anything specific, let me know!
Thanks for the comparison, Matt. I hope you can answer two questions that I have. In your original Cavalier Clay video, you said that the scent dissipates quickly. Has your opinion changed since then? Another reviewer said that the scent lingers all day. I prefer unscented products and I would hope that Cavalier would become unnoticeable within an hour or so of applying it. Secondly, do you have any opinion on which of the two is better at creating a more "piecey" type of texture? Thanks again!
GaijinMo Thanks! Personally I don't find that Cavalier's scent lingers, no. If someone else were to stick their nose into my hair halfway through the day, they would probably still be able to smell it, but it's not something that I myself can smell after a few minutes. Some products smell so strong that you get whiffs now and then, but I don't find that to be the case with Cavalier. And yes, I definitely think it can create more texture and a piece-y look if desired. Hope this helps :)
hey matt i dunno what you think of this but maybe you could weight some of the categories, e.g. packaging is probably less important, and more subjective than hold/longevity/reworkability (scent is similarly subjective) to give a final score more reflective of how much 'better' one product is than another? It's not something I've seen much on other channels and it might help differentiate this series from similar ones. On the other hand it's a bit more work and makes it less obvious, but I'm not sure what the better way to quantify a comparison like this is other than points-based
You're definitely right, and Robin actually mentioned this same thing in his recent Brand Battle of these two products. I'm definitely trying to come up with a better ranking system for future Hair Compare videos. I just hope people don't think I'm stealing all of Robin's ideas lol 😂😅😭
Wow, this battle was so comprehensibly and going deep! The only point, wich interests me futhermore, is the build-up, so how your hair feel, if you only wash out the product with water. This is interesting for second day hair, sometimes your hairstyle will benefit from a build-up! :)
Hey! I have thick and short hair and I use claymation which tbh I do like it a lot, but I do agree with you that sometimes through out the day it looses its hold a little. So I plan on buying this now, so is there a better feel with the hold than cavalier clay?
How good will the Cavalier be for thin hair? I know it's designed for thick+wavey hair but does that mean it'll just be okay for thin hair or like awful? I've been using Claymation for almost 2 years now and although it's decent the hold isn't that great and it gives off an unwanted shine. Any feedback would be appreciated!
TheShakz10 I think it would still work well for thin hair as far as hold and finish. Just be careful not to use too much, because of all the texture it might create a bit too much separation. However it should also be a bit plumping for your hair because of the bentonite. Hope this helps!
Be careful Robin James, TDM Style is coming. Maybe it is time to abdicate the throne for claymation. Packagin category doesn`t make sence but other categories are important. Thank you for video.
Vanilla Glad you enjoyed the video 🙏🏻 I like to have packaging in there mainly for the amount of product you get, but also for aesthetics. Who wants a big ugly jar on their shelf 😉
Something that offsets that.. is having 10 categories instead of 5. That way the packaging is only 1 point and doesn't affect too much since there's so many points in other areas to come. Robin was thinking for season 3 to make some points less important.. but just adding more categories seems better and more simple. Also more info.. even though all those 10 categories are usually mentioned in his videos, making them actual categories on their own is good. Then you're sure to not forget to mention certain things.
I just purchased claymation like a couple of weeks ago, I like it but the hold is not enough for me. I am thinking about cavalier but I hope it works for me. Or I will be really disappointed for spending so much on hair products.
Osama Khalid I know the feeling. It really sucks when you spend a lot on a product and it ends up not working for you (I have several of those in my cabinet lol). I hope the Cavalier works for you!
I found claymation to be really oily on my hair. Is cavalier the same? Also, is application hard with cavalier? I currently have quicksand, and it's a hassle to apply it onto my hair and style since it's so sticky and rough.
+Jared Cavalier will definitely apply much more easily and smoothly than Quicksand. The diatomaceous earth in Quicksand makes it super drying and gritty. Cavalier is a more traditional clay, and very easy to apply. However if you found Claymation to be oily for you, you might have the same issue with this. It doesn't get oily for me unless I use too much, but I have a coarser hair type that needs the extra smoothing from the natural oils in it. Hope this helps!
Would you recommend cavalier or hybrid cream for fine hair? Cuz last time i use clay is from claymation and dynamite clay and i never find those product work for my hair type.
+Kevin Karnoto Hybrid would be better for you - that one is designed more for people with fine hair since it's so light, but still behaves like a clay.
Krizvel 2700 Cav lasts longer than HdF for me but it gets oily af by the end of the day. Over both of these I’d recommend something else like Clutch clay or Stickmore Clay Fiber if you want a hold that will last all day and not get greasy.
The texture is good but by the end of the day the volume drops out and it feels really oily for me. Claymation on the other hand seems to evaporate a little bit. If you watch my Clay Killer video comparing both to Clutch you can see a better idea of each one throughout the day.
TDM Style In short, clutch from the firm Clutch and keeps the hair as a calm day and does not lose glue and does not make them fat and vks day matte effect?
+Jason Guzman Tbh it was not my greatest work and the more I looked at it, the less I liked it. So I ended up taking it down. Maybe I'll remake it someday.
Yeah ok nah one smells of nothing, one smells of playdough. And you say you like the smell of playdough more? Why would you want something that smells like playdough when it can smell like nothing..
+Oscar Chang The same reason you prefer the smell of "nothing" - because I personally like the smell. And mainly I prefer Cavalier because it strictly works better for my hair.
+Opeezy Just because one product won over the other doesn't mean I'm biased lol. Like you said, Claymation is a fine product. It just so happens that Cavalier works a lot better for my personal hair type, so it won most of the categories. Doesn't mean that Claymation wouldn't beat out other clays that I've used (which it does).
![[DOKKAN BATTLE] Worldwide Campaign Announcement Video](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zxfEiMksZQs/mqdefault.jpg)
Hey all, it was brought to my attention that the "Product Punch-out" name was already used by Mike over at Modern Man TV. I have extended my apologies to Mike for using the same title, which was completely unintentional and just an oversight on my part. I am a fan of Mike's channel and I certainly did not mean to steal content or anything of the sort. I've updated the thumbnail and title for this video to "Hair Compare" - and this will be the title for future episodes of this series. Thank you all for your understanding.
TDM Style how bout calling it tdm product arena
please compare one of these with kocaine klay!
Would be fun to see a new comparison between these two products, as the formula have changed quite a lot for both claymation and cavalier since this video was published.
Cool series dude.
Major apologies man, I honestly did not realize that you had your own series with the same title. I'll be changing mine up. Love your channel!
TDM Style no worries bro I appreciate that and you got my sub!
+Modern Man TV Thanks so much man, that really means a lot! Again, sorry for the title - I definitely did not mean to steal your series name haha. Not sure how I missed it when I was trying to figure out a unique name for my own!
Can you compare the Cavalier Clay with the Baxter of California Clay Pomade?
Cavalier has more oils so that fits your dry hair
My hair naturally gets oily quick so the dry claymation may work best for me
Same
thanks matt, well done. for me, application is huge - time is takes to get the product in, styled and done. and even - which you touched upon - application ease. Claymation has less pull than blumaan or baxter which i like about it but the hold isn't equal to either. meanwhile, hate the pull of baxter - feels like its pulling my hair out! so not workable enough; actually uncomfortable to use. 'time and ease of application' is right up there for me with 'hold'. appreciate the video!
Keep it up! Looking forward for more videos from you, don't stop!
Thanks!
Great video man, really enjoy it. I think u deserve alot more likes and subscribers 👌
+Stephen Chinapen Thank you so much man, I appreciate that!
Ow shit this was a really cool video, this is a really great idea (sorry Robin but i think this was better because it was more in depth ) ,the editing was really well done did you do it yourself ? , please Carter supply flux vs Blumaan meraki ! or morris motley vs ....
KingdomRohan Thank you so much! I'll def keep those products in mind! And yes I did do the editing myself :)
I am glad that you favored Cavalier Clay at the end of this video. Cavalier Clay has more a matte textured look and meanwhile claymation has more of a semi matte look. The hold on Cavalier Clay lasts way longer on my straight thick hair than Claymation. With claymation I would have to use hairspray to lock my hair in place. This is why I love Cavalier clay better than Claymation. Also this is also one of my favorite videos from yours Matt.
Thanks man, so glad you liked it!
Great video I was really looking forward to this 👏🏿👌
+Jose Lopez Thanks! Glad you liked it :)
because i've recently just spent a lot on a Morris Motley product, i wanted to give myself a ban on purchasing more hair products but damn this video is really tempting me to get the Cavalier Clay!
+Hyperanium Haha I know the feeling!
Please review Morroconoil texture clay,pleaseeee
Lucky Smith It's on my list!
Finishing with HDF style lock hairspray really helps set the hold perfectly. It never dries out my hair and I can still move it around throughout the day if I need to and reshape it.
Daimon Barber Texture Clay Vs Claymation?
I bought the cavalier clay, thanks to your recommendation on one of your videos. I love it! Thank you so much
Glad you like it!
Hey Matt haven't been very active commenting on your videos recently but I'm loving the new hair! Getting my own Zac Efron haircut in 3 weeks wondering if you have any advice for what to ask for thanks dude loving the new content!
OK Fifa Thanks so much! If you're going for the Baywatch cut, I'd say go for a disconnect undercut with a tapered top, max length in the front around 5 inches. Bring pictures too!
Yes! A comparison between these two products by someone with similar hair as me (unruly wavy)! Trying to go for a medium length all round (near shoulder length) slick back. Hopefully the cavalier will be enough. Keep up the good work!
I hate claymation, I'm just trying to finish it, it makes my hair straw like and it has a terrible hold, I will buy Cavalier after I finish Claymation and I hope it'll be an improvement
Diego Olea I used that product for two years but overtime I got tired of the product and trust me if you have thick hair then I would suggest you go buy cavalier clay because of the longevity of the hold lasts so much longer man.
Diego Olea Yeah I know what you mean. I definitely think Cavalier will be a better fit for you - hope you like it!
Bro u also commented on luca stangelo
Cavalier clay >>>>>>>>>>>>>>overrated rated and over hyped hanz de fukboii
Preok Saha Nah the hold is shit for thick hair ! Fuck Hanz de Fukboii
I like cavalier clay better than claymation too 👌
Good video matt! Don't listen to hater's saying you stole video idea, just cause caesy neistat is biggest vlogger doesn't mean no one else can vlog, same principle with hair videos! Also you should take a look at the pete & pedro line for reviews too.
+1admac Thanks man! I don't think anybody is really hating, I just didn't realize that someone else had already used this series title. No big deal, I'll be changing it up. Glad you liked it though!
forget the Issue I asked you about in your other video, I give up at this point but maybe after using the clay it could help because it could be the products I used that caused the problems, I have a thick hair and grows fast, would clay be good for my hair, I go to school for about 7 hours so I really need the hold
Please suggest me a clay for thin hairs
Hey, just a heads up: Modern Man TV launched his comparison series a while back with the exact same name - Product Punchout. Maybe you should find a diffrent name for your series
Ah, thanks for letting me know. Somehow I didn't realize that when I was searching for similar series to make sure I didn't have the same name. :/ Bummer!
I wish I could get cavalier clay on eBay or amazon :(
hey TMD style I cutted my full hair now I want to grow it healthy and strong without any hair fall plzzz help mi with this...
Best things to do are avoid shampooing every day (better to do 3-4 times per week), make sure when you do shampoo, you use a sulfate-free one, and try using some nourishing styling products that include natural oils to keep your hair moisturized :) If you need help with anything specific, let me know!
TDM Style tysm bro
Thanks for the comparison, Matt. I hope you can answer two questions that I have. In your original Cavalier Clay video, you said that the scent dissipates quickly. Has your opinion changed since then? Another reviewer said that the scent lingers all day. I prefer unscented products and I would hope that Cavalier would become unnoticeable within an hour or so of applying it. Secondly, do you have any opinion on which of the two is better at creating a more "piecey" type of texture? Thanks again!
GaijinMo Thanks! Personally I don't find that Cavalier's scent lingers, no. If someone else were to stick their nose into my hair halfway through the day, they would probably still be able to smell it, but it's not something that I myself can smell after a few minutes. Some products smell so strong that you get whiffs now and then, but I don't find that to be the case with Cavalier. And yes, I definitely think it can create more texture and a piece-y look if desired. Hope this helps :)
Mike Smith is that you?
Love this series. Especially how you have a similar hair type. Unlike other series like this.
+BeachLessIsland Glad you like it! Got another episode coming soon ;)
Ok thanks a lot please review it , Love you alot
Can you try claymation( Hanz de Fuko) vs ocean clay( shevhoo) plz.I am struggling with which clay to buy,with much thanks
hey matt i dunno what you think of this but maybe you could weight some of the categories, e.g. packaging is probably less important, and more subjective than hold/longevity/reworkability (scent is similarly subjective) to give a final score more reflective of how much 'better' one product is than another?
It's not something I've seen much on other channels and it might help differentiate this series from similar ones. On the other hand it's a bit more work and makes it less obvious, but I'm not sure what the better way to quantify a comparison like this is other than points-based
You're definitely right, and Robin actually mentioned this same thing in his recent Brand Battle of these two products. I'm definitely trying to come up with a better ranking system for future Hair Compare videos. I just hope people don't think I'm stealing all of Robin's ideas lol 😂😅😭
and can these products keep the hair all day long?
Thx for the review! Now I'm going to get the cavalier instead!
JandreTV Glad it helped!
It's amazing how dramatic youve changed your tune on Cav Clay...you should rewatch some of your old videos, you might like it again 😉
Haha that’s exactly why I started the Product Revisit segment 😉
I do still think Cav is better than Claymation though lol
Totally..
Love the channel, keep up the good work!
Thanks!
good series
Thanks!
Nice vid! Do either of these two products feel heavy in your hair?
+jerry chaseman Thanks! Either one can if you use too much, so just start with a small amount and build :)
Wow, this battle was so comprehensibly and going deep! The only point, wich interests me futhermore, is the build-up, so how your hair feel, if you only wash out the product with water. This is interesting for second day hair, sometimes your hairstyle will benefit from a build-up! :)
Thanks so much! I'll have to consider that for the next one :)
saile ihgrahs Washability is one of my favourite things about claymation. Just water and you're good.
Hey! I have thick and short hair and I use claymation which tbh I do like it a lot, but I do agree with you that sometimes through out the day it looses its hold a little. So I plan on buying this now, so is there a better feel with the hold than cavalier clay?
+Mike Capalungan For me I definitely find a lot better and longer lasting hold with Cavalier. I think it will work great for you!
How good will the Cavalier be for thin hair? I know it's designed for thick+wavey hair but does that mean it'll just be okay for thin hair or like awful? I've been using Claymation for almost 2 years now and although it's decent the hold isn't that great and it gives off an unwanted shine. Any feedback would be appreciated!
TheShakz10 I think it would still work well for thin hair as far as hold and finish. Just be careful not to use too much, because of all the texture it might create a bit too much separation. However it should also be a bit plumping for your hair because of the bentonite. Hope this helps!
Yh that's helped loads thanks dude! Keep up with the great content
even in the video it seemed to me that hdf makes hair greasy than cav
Be careful Robin James, TDM Style is coming.
Maybe it is time to abdicate the throne for claymation.
Packagin category doesn`t make sence but other categories are important.
Thank you for video.
Vanilla Glad you enjoyed the video 🙏🏻 I like to have packaging in there mainly for the amount of product you get, but also for aesthetics. Who wants a big ugly jar on their shelf 😉
Thanks for the shoutout. Good to see my series has inspired you to create your own.
Robin James Thank you kindly! 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Something that offsets that.. is having 10 categories instead of 5. That way the packaging is only 1 point and doesn't affect too much since there's so many points in other areas to come. Robin was thinking for season 3 to make some points less important.. but just adding more categories seems better and more simple. Also more info.. even though all those 10 categories are usually mentioned in his videos, making them actual categories on their own is good. Then you're sure to not forget to mention certain things.
KEVIN ROUGH RIDER!
I just purchased claymation like a couple of weeks ago, I like it but the hold is not enough for me. I am thinking about cavalier but I hope it works for me. Or I will be really disappointed for spending so much on hair products.
Osama Khalid I know the feeling. It really sucks when you spend a lot on a product and it ends up not working for you (I have several of those in my cabinet lol). I hope the Cavalier works for you!
I found claymation to be really oily on my hair. Is cavalier the same? Also, is application hard with cavalier? I currently have quicksand, and it's a hassle to apply it onto my hair and style since it's so sticky and rough.
+Jared Cavalier will definitely apply much more easily and smoothly than Quicksand. The diatomaceous earth in Quicksand makes it super drying and gritty. Cavalier is a more traditional clay, and very easy to apply. However if you found Claymation to be oily for you, you might have the same issue with this. It doesn't get oily for me unless I use too much, but I have a coarser hair type that needs the extra smoothing from the natural oils in it. Hope this helps!
TDM Style thanks for the reply! Love your videos
Would you recommend cavalier or hybrid cream for fine hair? Cuz last time i use clay is from claymation and dynamite clay and i never find those product work for my hair type.
+Kevin Karnoto Hybrid would be better for you - that one is designed more for people with fine hair since it's so light, but still behaves like a clay.
TDM Style oke then , i"ll try hybrid when its available to purchase. Thanks man
+Kevin Karnoto Any time! If you haven't seen the email from Blumaan yet, Hybrid will be available Wednesday July 12!
TDM Style Wow its just only 2 day from now lol thanks man for your info.
but what better keeps the hairstyle? clay from blumaan or hanz de fuko claymation?
Krizvel 2700 Cav lasts longer than HdF for me but it gets oily af by the end of the day. Over both of these I’d recommend something else like Clutch clay or Stickmore Clay Fiber if you want a hold that will last all day and not get greasy.
TDM Style ie the cav holds all day but the hair seems fat and wet eh?
The texture is good but by the end of the day the volume drops out and it feels really oily for me. Claymation on the other hand seems to evaporate a little bit. If you watch my Clay Killer video comparing both to Clutch you can see a better idea of each one throughout the day.
TDM Style In short, clutch from the firm Clutch and keeps the hair as a calm day and does not lose glue and does not make them fat and vks day matte effect?
West
I'm gonna try cavelier although I didn't enjoy original to much
+Norman Bates Original is totally different from Cavalier, so if you're looking for a clay, give it a try!
what happened to the Andrew Garfield hairstyle
+Jason Guzman Tbh it was not my greatest work and the more I looked at it, the less I liked it. So I ended up taking it down. Maybe I'll remake it someday.
TDM Style you should definitely think about remaking it again it was the best tutorial on RUclips
+Jason Guzman I appreciate you saying that man. That video got a lot of hate so it's nice to hear that at least somebody liked it haha
Somthing with Arcadian Clay Pomade
Sorry but you stole this title idea from Mike Smith over at Modern Man TV.
Totally didn't realize that when I was trying to come up with a name. I'll have to change mine.
TDM Style No problem, just giving you a heads-up
I appreciate it!
Try the name of clash of brands instead
It’s like a sponsored to cavalier loool
This video is also 5 years old and I don't like either of them anymore lololololllollfaoskdfjlisdjl;aksdjflkasj
Cavalier clay has too many oils and weighs down your hair not good for fine thin hair.
dang cavalier destroyed hdf haha. nice series
also you should do prestyler matchups like original vs blank
+josh shneyder Thanks!
I really love your videos , you're a great RUclipsr, but please review Morroconoil texture clay once
Yeah ok nah one smells of nothing, one smells of playdough. And you say you like the smell of playdough more? Why would you want something that smells like playdough when it can smell like nothing..
+Oscar Chang The same reason you prefer the smell of "nothing" - because I personally like the smell. And mainly I prefer Cavalier because it strictly works better for my hair.
Screw Hanz de Fuko
Nope
This was so bias LOL I like Cavalier better but stilll, claymation is decent lmao
+Opeezy Just because one product won over the other doesn't mean I'm biased lol. Like you said, Claymation is a fine product. It just so happens that Cavalier works a lot better for my personal hair type, so it won most of the categories. Doesn't mean that Claymation wouldn't beat out other clays that I've used (which it does).
Ok
Claymation or gold digger?
Claymation golddigers stick y
Boring