I had the same dilemma, which dive computer will fit my needs. Full disclosure, I’m a new diver. Already registered to get my advanced open water, so I decided to get my dive computer, I was locked in to get the peregrine, I have been researching the peregrine dive computer for a while. Everything changed at the dive shop, after having both in my wrist, the Aqualung i330r felt natural, it can even be use as watch, I’m learning all the functions and can’t wait to try in my next dive. If you get the i330r just set the Bluetooth on and use the dive app to set all settings. Thank you for this video, I feel better about my dive computer.
The difference in Europe is actually quite a lot more than "a hundred dollars". Cheapest I330 option I found was €280, whereas the Peregrine can be had for €470.
Want to buy aqualung, but prices is around 350. Everywhere. Where is possible to buy it for 280?? Is it without taxes and delivery ? That way - without everything,you can find prices lower than 300eur. Or I am mistaken ???
Peregrine: Standard Bühlmann ZHL-16C with gradient factors. No lockout for dive plan deviations. i330R: Proprietary "PZ+" algorithm - how does that work? How do you adjust conservatism or match it to your buddy's computer? Is the setup menu available during the dive? Does it lock you out if you don't follow the plan?
Aqualung updated their website and it states in the i330R manual that it uses ZHL-16C, rather than their Z+ algorithm. It's odd though since the i770R does use Z+
Thanks Mark for the comparison! I originally purchased the i330R after watching your comparison and several other promotional videos of the i330R. But after only 4 dives in Belize, the "first" i330R died and the dealer very quickly and graciously replaced it. The second one died after 22 dives and the third one died on dive #7 in Cozumel 2 weeks ago. Fortunately, I was working with a very responsible AquaLung dealer. Yep, purchased the Peregrine - hoping it's more reliable for this this 5,000+ dive Recon Marine - who started diving before computers and REALLY don't want to go back and memorize dive tables!
Do you so stupid to understand, that you doing something wrong ?! Do you really think like 3 times in a raw you get bad quality watch ?! Not your fault in that ??? It is impossible!!! Really, man, do you know anyone who have the same problems ?? Even in hole world any one else changing his I330 diving computer 3 times ?! Are you from America ? Main strange situations and people living there usually.
Great review as always, just pity that the algorithms were not compared, understandably because this is a review more focused to newer divers, but mentioning the differences between the algorithms and the possibilities in growth that GF of peregrine offer during your diving evolution would be a great plus to the review especially for the people looking to move towards Tec, the peregrine will do perfectly until you feel the need to get into Trimix whilst the aqualung will be trickier in terms of dive planning with your pairs.
I just bought the I330R and did 4 dives with it, including 2 NITROX ones. Very nice dive computer. Happy with it. Very easy to change the settings with the iPhone App
Buhlmann ZHL-16C in the Shearwater makes it an easy choice. Shearwater also has awesome customer service in case there would be any problems and when the time comes to level up to more advanced models (Perdix, Teric, Petrel, Nerd) they work in the same way so minimal confusion
One thing not mentioned is that Shearwater uses the Qi standard to charge their computers. So you don't need a special cable, that you can easily forget or lose. I personally have never used any of the Shearwater chargers with my Terics, I use the same charger that I use with my phone.
I've just brought the i330r. Haven't dived it yet but it looks great. Been using the i300 for a while so this will move to my back up. I found the gas switching function on the i300 a bit fidely. I'm hoping it will be easier on the 1330r. Will post a full review in a couple of weeks
There is a huge difference in these two. If there is an issue and you call or email AL you will get crickets chirping, if you call or email Shearwater you will get great responsive customer service.
I‘m using the i330R since two and a half years now. No issues, works very well for me, really good display. However, two caveats: The Bühlmann 16-C algorithm can only be run with three preset GF settings: 90/90, 35/85, and 35/75. And it does not synch with Subsurface (or any third party software) due to a f*cked up pairing protocol. If these are non-issues for you, I highly recommend the i330R for its functional value for money.
I have this computer. In surface mode, the world screen appears in green, white and blue. But in dive mode, my screen is red and orange. Why ? You can help?
I've got the i330r now as my main (right wrist) and my i300 in the console with the SPG and compass. It's proving to be a great combination for recreational diving at a good price. The i330r was a lot cheaper in AUD than the Peregrine was, about $150.
Watching now but a few other things to consider: Shearwater uses Buhlmann Algorithm vs Z+ of Aqualung. Shearwater also works with Subsurface. (i330R may work with subsurface if they didn't change their spec)
Thx for the video. I bought the i330r but unfortunately died less than 2 years (my previous one was a mares and died 3 years after) . Aqualung looks reactive. the alarms are quiet annoying and the screen is small but all informations are on it, except the ascent speed. good visibility of the screen despite brightness (i dive in tropics). The Iphone app is very simple to use and it's very easy to change parameters of the computer (depth of deep stop, the pf factor to more or most conservative...). the nato bracelet is excellent and very secure. If I could change, I'll probably take the peregrine but i won't mind keeping the i330R if they repare it.
I'm on the fence of buying a new dive computer and if I do I tend to gravitate towards a shearwater teric (that's Shauns fault). I currently use a aqualung dive computer and I'm quite happy with that but i just want one that has a few more options. After this comparison now the peregrine also a contender. What are your thoughts on teric vs peregrine. I know that there is a huge price difference but is it worth it?
@mark Hey Mark i saw in one of your videos you setting up the Bungie cord in the shearwater and i can not find it to set mine the same way. I thought i saved it but.... I love the tossing you did but can't remember how you congested it and it was awesome. HELP!!! Thank you
#askmark Hey Mark, banks for giving us this comparison video. Last year I purchased the aqualung i200c with the nato band and I enjoy using it as my dive computer. I noticed that the i330r and i200c are at a similar price point; would you be able to do a brief comparison of those two ? I am not thinking of upgrading anytime soon, it’s for the benefit of other divers I know. Keep up the good work.
So many comments taking the price into account, before saying if the I330R fits their needs and future needs better than the Peregrine. I don’t say that one is better than the other, but purchasing such an important piece of gear, based on 100 or 200 €/$ difference makes no sense to me. Especially, knowing the cost of all the other gears we have and not to mention the cost of the dives and classes we pay for. We are not doing a cheap leisure and diving computer is such such important for our safety.
The price is not really a 100 diference from one to the other. Your online shop is a good example of that, while the aqualung is at 300€, the shearwater is almost 670€
Tariffs, he is comparing the US price. Shearwater comes out more competitively in the US market than the European market. A good example is comparing the Suunto D5, in Europe is well positioned at around 500 Euros. But in the US the price is absurd at around $900. So it is hard to justify it over superior technical computers from North American brands like the Teric, Perdix, Ratio, or Garmin.
Hey small question about the vibration. I dive in coldish waters, got at minimum a 7mm wet suit and considering going for a dry suit for the winter. Will there we any problem for picking up on the vibration alerts or is it strong enough?
Thanks for the review, I am really hesitating between the two but one of my main questions remain on the "vibration" alerts. I like the idea, but I dive in colder waters with a 7mm wetsuit, I don't like my dive computers to be very tight around my wrist and I'm afraid I won't notice it. How hard is the vibration? Regular phone call style? Game controller going crazy style? Would love some input on that...
If I were in the market, I'd save a bit longer and get the Perdix. I'm considering getting a Peregrine as a backup computer although the cheaper i330R might be perfect for that. Thanks for the comparison! I guess the only remaining question is how good is the software. The Shearwater Cloud software shows some unfortunate warts on both the phone and on high resolution / scaled displays.
While it does serve its purpose, I tend to agree it can be awkward to use. I believe mostly because of their choice of cross-platform framework (or the amount of polish given). As I software developer, I occasionally think "man I'd love to make this better" but I've never seen a job opening at Shearwater in that area and they probably outsource it or leave changes to interns (not to mention I'm gainfully employed and my experience isn't 100% applicable - but Shearwater, if you're looking...).
Thank you. I didn’t think about the haptic option. I was looking at the AquaLung i470tc (for the AI) as a daily wear, but very few reviews online and I will think more about the haptic option now. Thanks again.
If you are a new diver I would recomend to start with a cheap puck size computer, then if you continue to dive, start saving more money and buy a Perdix.
@@djknauss1 yes if you know that diving is something you really want but for a beginner with a limited budget it might be a good priority to get in the water as often as possible before spending 8-900 euro on a fancy perdix. By the way I LOVE my perdix;)
First thing I did on my DC, turn off the audio and for specific reasons. 1) with the hood on I can't hear it, no I'm not deaf or anything 2) saves battery? 3) it forces me to check it, and when I'm near max depth I tend to check it even more. You know safety and stuff.
This is tough for me. I love the screen of the peregrine. I guess AI is just a fancy addition I really don't need. Especially since I'll have to use an SPG anyway. I love that the peregrine vibrates. But they don't have compass'. Also I worry about the size being too large for me. I have a Geo 2.0 and I love that it's my watch.. decisions decisions...
OOOPS - US CONSUMER PRODUCT SAFETY COMMISSION HAS RELEASED THIS STATEMENT- “Aqualung Recalls i330R SCUBA Diving Computers Due to Injury and Drowning Hazards”
Do not buy the i330R at the moment. They have issued a recall on all their i330R's because of a faulty internal seals. Mine has gone back because it died and now the demo unit that I was borrowing whilst they were fixing it has died too. This recall is also taking a loooong time because of the global component shortage that is happening right now.
![Top 10 Best Dive Computers in 2024 | Tested while Diving [Side-by-side] #scuba #divecomputer](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4kxeB6tR4oo/mqdefault.jpg)
*Peregrine* - bit.ly/3zHg4wR
*I330R* - bit.ly/3qfij6d
So which one do you prefer and why? Let us know in the comments.
I had the same dilemma, which dive computer will fit my needs. Full disclosure, I’m a new diver. Already registered to get my advanced open water, so I decided to get my dive computer, I was locked in to get the peregrine, I have been researching the peregrine dive computer for a while. Everything changed at the dive shop, after having both in my wrist, the Aqualung i330r felt natural, it can even be use as watch, I’m learning all the functions and can’t wait to try in my next dive. If you get the i330r just set the Bluetooth on and use the dive app to set all settings. Thank you for this video, I feel better about my dive computer.
The difference in Europe is actually quite a lot more than "a hundred dollars". Cheapest I330 option I found was €280, whereas the Peregrine can be had for €470.
Want to buy aqualung, but prices is around 350. Everywhere. Where is possible to buy it for 280?? Is it without taxes and delivery ? That way - without everything,you can find prices lower than 300eur. Or I am mistaken ???
@@nauvofact993 280€ was 2 years ago … !?!
The peregrine has factory installed screen protector and the one in the box is an extra.
Yes and double price of i330. May be in some idiotic country it is difference in 100 USD, but in real aqualung 2x time cheaper!
@@nauvofact993 Here, now, the i330 is €399, and the Peregrine is €499.
Peregrine: Standard Bühlmann ZHL-16C with gradient factors. No lockout for dive plan deviations.
i330R: Proprietary "PZ+" algorithm - how does that work? How do you adjust conservatism or match it to your buddy's computer? Is the setup menu available during the dive? Does it lock you out if you don't follow the plan?
Aqualung updated their website and it states in the i330R manual that it uses ZHL-16C, rather than their Z+ algorithm. It's odd though since the i770R does use Z+
Thanks Mark for the comparison! I originally purchased the i330R after watching your comparison and several other promotional videos of the i330R. But after only 4 dives in Belize, the "first" i330R died and the dealer very quickly and graciously replaced it. The second one died after 22 dives and the third one died on dive #7 in Cozumel 2 weeks ago. Fortunately, I was working with a very responsible AquaLung dealer. Yep, purchased the Peregrine - hoping it's more reliable for this this 5,000+ dive Recon Marine - who started diving before computers and REALLY don't want to go back and memorize dive tables!
Do you so stupid to understand, that you doing something wrong ?! Do you really think like 3 times in a raw you get bad quality watch ?! Not your fault in that ??? It is impossible!!! Really, man, do you know anyone who have the same problems ?? Even in hole world any one else changing his I330 diving computer 3 times ?! Are you from America ? Main strange situations and people living there usually.
Great review as always, just pity that the algorithms were not compared, understandably because this is a review more focused to newer divers, but mentioning the differences between the algorithms and the possibilities in growth that GF of peregrine offer during your diving evolution would be a great plus to the review especially for the people looking to move towards Tec, the peregrine will do perfectly until you feel the need to get into Trimix whilst the aqualung will be trickier in terms of dive planning with your pairs.
I just bought the I330R and did 4 dives with it, including 2 NITROX ones. Very nice dive computer. Happy with it. Very easy to change the settings with the iPhone App
Buhlmann ZHL-16C in the Shearwater makes it an easy choice. Shearwater also has awesome customer service in case there would be any problems and when the time comes to level up to more advanced models (Perdix, Teric, Petrel, Nerd) they work in the same way so minimal confusion
I was asking myself this question a year ago, in the end I got the Peregrine and haven’t looked back since.
One thing not mentioned is that Shearwater uses the Qi standard to charge their computers. So you don't need a special cable, that you can easily forget or lose. I personally have never used any of the Shearwater chargers with my Terics, I use the same charger that I use with my phone.
I've just brought the i330r. Haven't dived it yet but it looks great. Been using the i300 for a while so this will move to my back up. I found the gas switching function on the i300 a bit fidely. I'm hoping it will be easier on the 1330r. Will post a full review in a couple of weeks
I went for the aqualung thanks to your review. The differences don't support the price difference that is 200€ in France
There is a huge difference in these two. If there is an issue and you call or email AL you will get crickets chirping, if you call or email Shearwater you will get great responsive customer service.
I‘m using the i330R since two and a half years now. No issues, works very well for me, really good display. However, two caveats:
The Bühlmann 16-C algorithm can only be run with three preset GF settings: 90/90, 35/85, and 35/75. And it does not synch with Subsurface (or any third party software) due to a f*cked up pairing protocol. If these are non-issues for you, I highly recommend the i330R for its functional value for money.
Compare this two models is so smart! 3x difference in price, screen size, etc.
I went for aqua. It works out so much more than 100 usd in the uk. All the places selling are selling it for more than its worth in pounds.
I have this computer. In surface mode, the world screen appears in green, white and blue. But in dive mode, my screen is red and orange. Why ? You can help?
I've got the i330r now as my main (right wrist) and my i300 in the console with the SPG and compass. It's proving to be a great combination for recreational diving at a good price. The i330r was a lot cheaper in AUD than the Peregrine was, about $150.
Watching now but a few other things to consider: Shearwater uses Buhlmann Algorithm vs Z+ of Aqualung. Shearwater also works with Subsurface. (i330R may work with subsurface if they didn't change their spec)
Thx for the video. I bought the i330r but unfortunately died less than 2 years (my previous one was a mares and died 3 years after) . Aqualung looks reactive. the alarms are quiet annoying and the screen is small but all informations are on it, except the ascent speed. good visibility of the screen despite brightness (i dive in tropics). The Iphone app is very simple to use and it's very easy to change parameters of the computer (depth of deep stop, the pf factor to more or most conservative...). the nato bracelet is excellent and very secure. If I could change, I'll probably take the peregrine but i won't mind keeping the i330R if they repare it.
I'm on the fence of buying a new dive computer and if I do I tend to gravitate towards a shearwater teric (that's Shauns fault). I currently use a aqualung dive computer and I'm quite happy with that but i just want one that has a few more options. After this comparison now the peregrine also a contender. What are your thoughts on teric vs peregrine. I know that there is a huge price difference but is it worth it?
Get the Teric you will be kicking yourself later if you don’t
just got the perdix, couldnt be happier
@@djknauss1 GREAT !!!! You won’t regret it
Does anyone know if there is a successor to the i330r, or one planned in the near future?
When you compare a €300 computer with a €550 computer, it tells a lot of good things about the €300 one!!
@simplyScuba Whats your preferred two options that HAVE A.I integration ? Perdix?
@mark Hey Mark i saw in one of your videos you setting up the Bungie cord in the shearwater and i can not find it to set mine the same way. I thought i saved it but....
I love the tossing you did but can't remember how you congested it and it was awesome. HELP!!! Thank you
#askmark Hey Mark, banks for giving us this comparison video. Last year I purchased the aqualung i200c with the nato band and I enjoy using it as my dive computer. I noticed that the i330r and i200c are at a similar price point; would you be able to do a brief comparison of those two ? I am not thinking of upgrading anytime soon, it’s for the benefit of other divers I know. Keep up the good work.
So many comments taking the price into account, before saying if the I330R fits their needs and future needs better than the Peregrine. I don’t say that one is better than the other, but purchasing such an important piece of gear, based on 100 or 200 €/$ difference makes no sense to me. Especially, knowing the cost of all the other gears we have and not to mention the cost of the dives and classes we pay for. We are not doing a cheap leisure and diving computer is such such important for our safety.
Maybe they've updated the model (typing in 2023) but my Peri beeps and vibrates...
The price is not really a 100 diference from one to the other. Your online shop is a good example of that, while the aqualung is at 300€, the shearwater is almost 670€
Tariffs, he is comparing the US price. Shearwater comes out more competitively in the US market than the European market. A good example is comparing the Suunto D5, in Europe is well positioned at around 500 Euros. But in the US the price is absurd at around $900. So it is hard to justify it over superior technical computers from North American brands like the Teric, Perdix, Ratio, or Garmin.
HA! I got the Peregrine, so the peregrine wins! Great Review Compare. Thank you Simply Scuba, Im always on top of all the new gear.
Hey small question about the vibration. I dive in coldish waters, got at minimum a 7mm wet suit and considering going for a dry suit for the winter. Will there we any problem for picking up on the vibration alerts or is it strong enough?
Thanks for the review, I am really hesitating between the two but one of my main questions remain on the "vibration" alerts. I like the idea, but I dive in colder waters with a 7mm wetsuit, I don't like my dive computers to be very tight around my wrist and I'm afraid I won't notice it. How hard is the vibration? Regular phone call style? Game controller going crazy style? Would love some input on that...
My question too - I wear a dry suit. did you get it?
If I were in the market, I'd save a bit longer and get the Perdix. I'm considering getting a Peregrine as a backup computer although the cheaper i330R might be perfect for that. Thanks for the comparison! I guess the only remaining question is how good is the software. The Shearwater Cloud software shows some unfortunate warts on both the phone and on high resolution / scaled displays.
shearwater cloud app is pretty disappointing
While it does serve its purpose, I tend to agree it can be awkward to use. I believe mostly because of their choice of cross-platform framework (or the amount of polish given). As I software developer, I occasionally think "man I'd love to make this better" but I've never seen a job opening at Shearwater in that area and they probably outsource it or leave changes to interns (not to mention I'm gainfully employed and my experience isn't 100% applicable - but Shearwater, if you're looking...).
Thank you. I didn’t think about the haptic option. I was looking at the AquaLung i470tc (for the AI) as a daily wear, but very few reviews online and I will think more about the haptic option now. Thanks again.
waiting on this
If you are a new diver I would recomend to start with a cheap puck size computer, then if you continue to dive, start saving more money and buy a Perdix.
why not save a few hundred and go straight for the perdix?
@@djknauss1 yes if you know that diving is something you really want but for a beginner with a limited budget it might be a good priority to get in the water as often as possible before spending 8-900 euro on a fancy perdix. By the way I LOVE my perdix;)
Get the peregrine then if you ever do want to move to the Teric or Perdix you’ll have a superb backup.
First thing I did on my DC, turn off the audio and for specific reasons.
1) with the hood on I can't hear it, no I'm not deaf or anything
2) saves battery?
3) it forces me to check it, and when I'm near max depth I tend to check it even more. You know safety and stuff.
This is tough for me. I love the screen of the peregrine. I guess AI is just a fancy addition I really don't need. Especially since I'll have to use an SPG anyway. I love that the peregrine vibrates. But they don't have compass'. Also I worry about the size being too large for me. I have a Geo 2.0 and I love that it's my watch.. decisions decisions...
50% of diver fatalities are due to running out of air. IMO AI should be standard.
I like the Aqua because it is smaller.
OOOPS - US CONSUMER PRODUCT SAFETY COMMISSION HAS RELEASED THIS STATEMENT- “Aqualung Recalls i330R SCUBA Diving Computers Due to Injury and Drowning Hazards”
Has this been resolved ?
@@julianwg92 BUY SHEARWATER
Do not buy the i330R at the moment. They have issued a recall on all their i330R's because of a faulty internal seals. Mine has gone back because it died and now the demo unit that I was borrowing whilst they were fixing it has died too. This recall is also taking a loooong time because of the global component shortage that is happening right now.
The newer serial numbers are unaffected by this O-ring recall..
I know Brexit has confused some things but in the UK we still work in pounds Sterling not Dollars
Yeah, nothing to do with Brexit. The GBP RRP fluctuates with the exchange rate every month, so it's easier to compare the USD
No AI is IMO a deal breaker in that price range. Especially for the peregrine.
AI is going to cost 4x this price range
The majority of recreational divers (the primary market of both these products) dont use AI (some do, but most dont)...
First view
beaucoup trop de blabla ! !