Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
My Hero Academia SHOULD be really good, why isn't it?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 авг 2024
- My hero academia SHOULD be a good show, its got everything an anime from 2016 could want! Why does everyone clown on it?
1. Intro - 0:00
2. Should it be really really good - 1:09
3. The Characters - 2:38
3. Bakugo - 3:51
4. Ochaco 5:57
5. The Villains - 8:14
6. The Action - 9:40
7. The Tone - 12:15
8. Plus Ultra is Boring - 16:12
9. Trying to piece together this mess of a video - 18:16
Socials:
not yet
I’m glad this wasn’t just straight trashing the show. It was just explaining legit issues that if fixed would make the show better. A lot of people just mock the show and call it overrated instead of actually critiquing it. I love this show a lot but I still see some of the issues. I mostly love the show for its characters. Even them just hanging out for an entire episode is entertaining to me.😂
I feel like if deku was given
a savior complex with a side of an inferiority complex to mirror
Bakugo’s god complex/gifted kid syndrome
It would be more interesting
That would be very interesting
Deku annoyed me he didn’t have any flaws as a person and all his crying
I will say you are absolutely correct that Deku being mad at someone would be interesting... and thats happened a few times. What is arguably the BEST fight of the show has this as a "turning the tables moment". Deku VS Todoroki. While yes, Deku does end up fighting with a different goal, the core root of all Dekus passion in that fight is that Todoroki wanting to be the best whil NOT giving 100% pisses him off because Deku has to *barely* get by while trying his hardest.
yes deku does get mad there, but i think that barely counts, he was still doing something super righteous and good that helps todoroki. plus that was a self contained moment. i wanna see deku MAD, like MAD MAD. steven universe future type shi
@@kamermoon5691 Yeah, I'm not getting a clearer picture by saying "MAD MAD" unfortunately. He gets to go into a blood rage against Shigiraki in War arc and somewhat against Overhaul.
You mention SU Future, so are you looking for him to have a selfish or personal anger? Because the levels of anger I saw when Steven confronts his dad are equal to Deku chewing out Todoroki imo (but i do agree the series would benefit if Deku was allowed to ponder and dwell on the events of the story more whether he gets angry, regretful, etc.)
@@dradencake3199 what i really want is for deku to be a more complex character, him getting mad is just a means to an ends of that. selfish anger could do that, but so could allowing him to "ponder and dwell on the events of the story more" or some other third thing. i just feel like deku isn't dynamic enough to stay interesting over multiple seasons, though all this is just my opinion
@@kamermoon5691 nah, I agree. The main thing his character was about was his slow burn improvement and that ultimately comes down to personal preference and patience. Of which he hasn't hit the mark for me since after the Gentle fight
@@kamermoon5691 a MAD MAD situation would be when shigaraki almost kills bakugo, where deku then goes 100%. Another time being the ENTIRE VIGILANTE ARC: Deku hated himself because he saw himself as the strongest in his class, and because of that, the people around him gets hurt when he draws out the big bad guys. So to counter this, he refuses to eat and sleep for-- what people suspect-- about 2 weeks to a month so he can take out villains without drawing attention to his classmates. So THEN after the whole vigilante arc, class 1-A tells him that they aren't weak, and that they are capable of fighting, just like him. THIS works.
Not gonna lie, this is the first channel to actually explain was it’s not as good instead of just straight up calling it mid and taking the safe option. I like this video a lot.
I don't like it because it flipped the whole plot on the first episode. Deku us told he can't be a hero without a quirk,so he just goes ans gets one
And then like two episodes later here comes Aizawa, so did he really need a Quirk, or did need to actually put in the work to build himself up instead of being a scrawny nerd?
While I still think My hero academia is good and don't agree with all the takes here this is probably the best qriticue of MHA I have seen. Most people just say they don't like it with minimal arguments or its really degen manga stans that whine about miniscule details being changed. The manga is pretty good but if you want to get trough the anime first it could be a good read after. There is also the spinoff prequel Vigelanties witch is actually where most of the Shirakumo stuff was introduced plus it gives more depth to Midnight so her death hits harder with that. And at least they made sure that the movies are practically canon althoug not necesary for the story to work since most anime movies are just blatant filler. Its still impressive that My hero academia got as big as it has as its the first manga that really blew upp for Horikoshi the last attempts lasted 10-30 ish chapter while MHA is closing in on 420 chapters as of now.
While I don't agree with the takes this video is better than the rest that basically amount to people just raging incoherently about stuff.
I have a question about the tone, One Piece, considered one of if not the best manga of all time is full of both really fun, goofy and wacky moments but also has some of the darkest backstories in manga, so why is it bad for My Hero but other manga can?
it comes down to presentation and pacing. one piece doesn’t have the dramatic and quick shifts in tone that my hero has. it’s difficult to explain in comment form, but it’s almost like one piece has a stronger sense of continuity between the goofy scenes and the dramatic scenes
@@kamermoon5691 Oh I get it. Like so many things in storytelling it's not about what is done but how it is done.
What quick shifts in tone has there been in the later arcs. The only shift in tone I can think of is the Highschool festival arc(the show is called my hero academia) and even then that was essential for eris character and the start of us seeing some of dekus growth with him starting to see the gray areas of villains not just black and white
Because One Piece is paced a lot slower and each flashback normally has a heavy impact on the plot. For example the Robin flashback is in the Enies Lobby arc. An arc which revolves around her.
(Spoilers for EggHead arc)
Or the recent Kuma arc which play a large part in the events in Egghead
Mha is the fastest paced manga I've ever seen
Do yall forget this is a superhero anime? Yes most characters will be nice & kind hearted becus that’s how superheroes are… no Deku won’t have edge to him like a lot of other protagonist these days becus he is a superhero.. even as fiery as Bakugo is he still embodies all accepts of a superhero. Deku has definitely had a lot of growth from first seeing him from him wanting his power to seeing what comes w/ having great power. it’s literally a superhero show lmao
and superhero shows suck ass nowadays. being the same as all the other tripe, especially after implying and setting up your story to break new ground and do so much different and fresh and new, only to back out at the last second over and over and over again, thats even worse.
yea i agree with rubixn here, mha set itself up as something that’s gonna be NEW and DIFFERENT and it ended up being just another superhero show. (i still enjoy it tho)
@@rubixn00b71 in what ways did it set itself up to be different?
@@qerspective4931 I’m not entirely sure but this is new Anime fans if it ain’t edgy or unnecessarily dark for the sake of it it’s not good.
@@Skye2993To a degree, but I also think the MHA fans are struggling to finally admit the new first big shounen battle anime after big 3 wasn’t as new and different as was promised. The new and different there was also more so the new fans trying to argue it’s gonna be way better and way different than Naruto. It’s gonna be the new shounen battle take not all that unlike how JJK/CSM are presented now. Some of the fans were not new. I remember TeamFourStar did videos on the series years back. They weren’t new, but they were about just as annoying as the new fans spouting the same. I saw their takes as just giving ammo to the new fans.
Meanwhile, I kept seeing Deku as New Naruto. Stopped watching in s3. Same with Black Clover. Although, that one did also start looking more FT after a while. Stopped watching that one early, but I think I prefer the Black Clover fanbase over MHA fanbase. At least they didn’t make out their favorite shounen battle pick to be more than it was. Black Clover similarity with other big shounen battle stories actually started to be more flattering. JJK and DS s1s were also more flattering. I’m still watching their s2s.
Vs I was very annoyed by MHA. Not flattered at all. Although, it was mostly due to fans. The series by itself was alright. Just not my preferred shounen battle. I don’t care much for superheroes. Also thought their were too many characters. So many it gave me appreciation of Naruto. Too many characters was something I thought on that one, too. Until I realized I preferred the Naruto cast. Or other big casts in other shounen battle before MHA since this is all I had reference to at the time.
Note: I love Naruto and FT.
question for you. Why does the main character have to have character growth if he/she inspires character growth that wouldn't otherwise happen in others? Goku did this to. Sonic does to. The main character doesn't grow that much mentally but everyone else around them does. I would also argue that deku from what I have seen does have character growth. It might just be a lot more subtle then your use to. I have seen in clips him going from desperately optimistic to a more realistic optimistic to frankly depressed still hoping for the best but beardly holding it together back up to optimistic but hoping it doesn't just crumble around him. If that isn't character development or at least character changing then I don't know what is.
edit: ok kind of have a point over all.
I feel like with the growth thing, Goku and Sonic are far more likeable and charming characters who honestly in some cases have more potent growth and arcs than deku does. Goku during the cell arc coming to terms with his power and place in the world, realizing that by being on earth he is its biggest protector but also its largest magnet for danger. He chooses to give up fighting on earth, his power, and his life for the safety of those who he loves. Sonic usually is more fast and flashy but in Lost World his fast and rash actions are what causes most of the problems and throughout the game. That is his arc. Deku, a. isn't charming; I've seen shy, anxious, school boy protagonist a million times and while he is optimistic and a fighter, these things in my opinion really aren't interesting when he's STILL being a spineless kid multiple seasons in. And b. I don't think 'subtle' is the word that I feel describes his growth, 'barebones' is more what I feel. But I understand where you're coming from, and if you can find interest in how deku grows, that's awesome! I just really don't.
@@kamermoon5691 fair. I haven't watched the show fully so point. thanks for the respectful response back. *thumbs up of approval*
@@dranoradragonqueen1494 I love me a good respectful disagreement on the internet
@@kamermoon5691 more people need to be ok with respectful disagreements in my thoughts.
You bringing up those videos as evidence that the show has fallen off in quality or popularity doesn’t really make sense looking at metrics. Even through the most searched for anime on streaming as categorized by google MHA is in demand more than some of the biggest new titles? Even crazier the sixth season is by far the highest rated in everything?
even though I mostly focus on negative things in the video, I don't think my hero is bad! I point out these videos because it's also a popular opinion to think that MHA sucks and there are valid points there. I think that season 6 was the best season in a while and I'm excited for season 7, but you can't say that MHA couldn't have done better in a lot of places.
At Least you aren't actually trashing on MHA just cause more popular And well known RUclipsrs are. Though it really isn't as bad as many RUclipsrs seem to be trying to make it seem.@@kamermoon5691
@@kamermoon5691facts my hero has one of the easiest and best worlds to get into the only problem is the show feels so corny idk how to explain it but it just feels corny as hell and need new flavor because the first seasons have a great base but after that the show feels stale as hell and has now just became corny🤦.
I personallly do enjoy watching the show still, but I mostly enjoy it to see snippets of my favorite characters, who are very rarely the main focus of any episodes. Hell, my favorite character doesn't even have an actaul character arc.
I feel like moving the protaganist to be someone like Bakugo or Kirishima would've been so much more interesting. Both of them are such fascinating characters who would really benefit from more screen time. (Also since my favorite character is Kaminari, he would get more screen time (: )
Let's start with Bakugo. As mentioned in the video, Bakugo is hot headed, angry and extremely agressive through most of the series, but that's because we're seeing him through Deku's POV. Seeing his view would be something really interesting as we'd actually get to see his thought process. Why did he hate Deku so much? How did he feel when Deku got into UA? What exactly made him have respect for Kirishima? These are all questions that would be so interesting to explore, and almost every arc would still be fascinating from his POV.
Then we have Kirishima. He's a fan favorite character, who I don't think was intended to be as popular as he is. He's my second favorite character and if I could choose one character from MHA to come to life, it would be him. He's not only relatable thanks to his backstory of bullying and dealing with low self confidence, but he has so many sides to his character. We've seen him get angry before, look at Bakugo's kidnapping for example. This guy literally befriended someone who no one else in the class wanted to go near, and he was persitant enough to succeed. Seeing the whole story from his perspective would be interesting since he is someone who has so much room for development. Not only in his quirk (which we have seen) but also in character. Seeing the whole show from Kirishima's POV is something I would absolutely love to see.
Honestly there's so many other characters who would be fascinating to see the story through. Todoroki would also be a great choice but this comment is too long as it is.
Hope you all have a wonderful day (let me know your fav MHA characters below)
I think bakugo is better off being deutorganist and deku did face low confidence until he face bakugo in season 1 and become an inspiring leader for todoriki and ida in season 2 but he did face self worth issues as just a mere vessel for one for all in season 6 just to end disappointingly by class 1a but like, didn't he reject everyone's help, including all might.The vigilante arc is such a disappointment. I still think deku is good but not great, at least he did get proactivity development from gentle criminal about how villains turn out the way they are
@@yuximao-bm8jh Yeah I think this issue hs a lot to do with how the writers wrote Deku. I mean, I wouldn't say kids are the main audience for MHA but since MHA is usually seen as a 'starter anime' for people getting into the medium, I think they're trying to make Deku as 'kid friendly?' As possible without taking away from the story. I think they failed on that count tho?
Im so sick of the pacing of this show and every character pausing for 5 minutes to talk then do 1 move and stop again. How the fuck can Deku not take out toga right away but can fight All for One and Shigaraki, how can bakugo survive being thrown through walls without a strength quirk.?
For your last point, it's a fucking superhero show. You're gonna have to suspend your disbelief. Duh
Legit my favorite channel rn
Bro hit the nail on the head with this one. Cool show, good concept, bunch of potential. Plus ultra is stinky.
I LOVE MY HERO ACADAIMAI
Me Too!
I believe the main problems dont start to show until War arc, The only complaint i have about that arc is it feels feels rushed... Idk if thats just me... The vigilante deku is rushed like
The arc is seven episodes... And 20 manga chapters, for such a great arc its rushed.
Also deku has hid only character development ever in that arc. He loses the things that made him worthy of one for all. His heroism and everything, he learns to also care about himself as the vigilante arc is him pushing others, he learns that he needs friend's and he cant neglect certain aspects of himself.
Also the things he loses of his character in that arc basically just come, back and it feels like forced character development...
Idk if ur a manga reader because of that i wont include alot of stuff.
Hi, as a huge fan of the anime and manga, i do understand where your coming from on many of these points. Though me personally, i think the show is great and i really enjoy it. But when you said the thingy about deku not really having any character arcs, i can agree and disagree. On one hand his personality does not change that much throughout the series. But on the other, he does change quite abit looking at season 1 then season 7. He goes from a slightly immature, weak, crybaby boy who wants to be a hero to a strong, mature, hero who inspires many others. And while his selflessness never really changed (considering how much of a self sacrificing idiot he was during the paranormal liberation war and vigilante arc) i do think he has change throughout the show. Anyways, I was wondering if you could make an updated video since the manga has finished and season 7 of the show is releasing now. I'd like to here your thoughts on the new stuff and the ending.
Never let bro cook ever again 💀
My man if you’re going to disagree, atleast supply a reason. People don’t just believe what you say with no explanation.
And no, a skull emoji doesn’t count for evidence 💀
Nah let bro cook, ima mha glazer but even I agreee with the vid
great video your analysis is some of the best ive seen I would love to see you improve your editing I think you could go far
thank you! glad you enjoyed! but where do you think my editing should improve? I wanna take any opportunity to make my stuff better and if you have an idea of where my editing can go that would be sick
Just wait for season 7....
Just wait till season 5
Just wait till season 6
Now it's just wait till season 7
I'm sorry, I've read the manga and this doesn't get better.
This show fell off after season 4.
Your point is basically saying the first *156~* episodes of the story is mid, but after that it gets good
I never understand comments like this. If someone doesn't like the first six seasons of the show, they're not going to like season 7. Fans like myself will continue to enjoy it, and those who don't will move on to other things
8:11 i need someone to upload the entirety of dabi's dance but just with realistic sounds
I think you showed a fundamental misunderstanding of the series and grossly misinterpreted the show’s problems. Most of your visual aids were horrible, seriously just rewatch them while listening to what you said, and while some of your points were agreeable like the sexism, you either overblow them or misconstrue them entirely.
For someone that says they like analyzing a show, I found your analysis really lackluster.
I don’t find Ikuku boring. What I find interesting about Deku is that he’s a person who is passed on a great responsibility at such a young age that he isn’t sure of how to handle it. That’s actually not that common as far as shounen manga is concerned. Deku’s slow growth is cited as a fault but I think that’s missing the forest for the tree. He does grow, in the sense that things around him evolve. The villains mostly are what Deku could have been had he strayed from his course.
But having people around him evolve doesn't mean he personally grows as a character.
The flashback syndrome is a common thing in shonen battle anime when it comes to long series, we all have to deal with it. My hero was avoiding this problem with it being seasonal, but the studio decided to be unoriginal with the production. 😦
this video and your channel is UNDERRATED like holy shit. wish you the best man
Ay man, first video i saw of yours'. Cool video, i agree with almost everything. You got cool presentation style, jokes, transition edits need work, sure, but theyre still good. Keep up the good work and maybe youll ride the algorithm etc. 👍♥💪
You make some solid points in the video. However.
While the anime definitely has lost some interest. It seems the manga has only grown in popularity. I feel like viewer experience and viewers perspective quality is very subjective of a thing and it still trends everytime an episode or chapter releases. Not to mention sales in circulation have only increased outside of a 30 percent dip last year but that was only due to it selling one less volume than the previous year.
Mha actually has one of the most consistent fanbases in terms of how well the series performs on a metrical scale.
Personally the series is still great for me and while it has has objectively had a change in story direction and quality I do feel like part of the people saying "mha fell off" is a false narritive when you look at how the series is performing overall.
Afterall, this is a series that is closing in on 100 million sales within the foreseeable future and has already passed great series like Yu Yu Hakusho in terms of sales.
Metrics doesn't equal quality but the point is that people are trying to objectify the series current writing quality to fit their narritive that the series lost traction and that one talks about it which is kinda false
For sure! My hero is still something I and a lot of other people actively watch, maybe it's just my side of the internet but I have seen a LOT more people complaining about MHA then liking it/making content for it. Also, not a manga reader! The manga could be the best thing ever and I would have no clue lmao
@@kamermoon5691Horikoshi is the second best mangaka in terms of how he draws and does perspective shots ,You understand how the anime can't exactly replicate Horikoshis art but they at times struggle to even properly draw a character who isn't even moving well .
DEKU DOESN’T HAVE GROWTH! BORING!
I was going to hear you out but after that line, I’m not not watching any more because you clearly have been watching.
I’m not going to say Deku is “the” greatest main character but he is one of the greatest and If season six didn’t convince you of his character growth, the upcoming season 7 will, and he will show the world how great he is
11:57 brooo this is how i feel about them when they say “I WANNA BE A HERO” like bro we’re in season 5 plz say something new 😭
Deku deku you can call me deku green hair green eyes I’m just a lil cinnamon roll ^_^
My biggest gripe with Deku probably comes in the later seasons. I was fine with him being super kind and innocent before, but in the later seasons it doesnt make sense. I thought they were gonna make him more serious and make him walk the line of morality when he went solo, but he never did. It was such a wasted opportunity. Also i think they rushed One for All as a quirk. He went from breaking his bones every punch and only using 5% to going 100% and beating everyone in a season. It felt underwhelming.
for real, i was super excited when i saw the vigilante stuff, i thought they were gonna finally have deku's character go somewhere but nope
Morality wasn't the reason for the vigilante episodes, it was the breaking of the symbol of peace. It was showing that deku and his self sacrificing attitude was bad for everyone and they he didn't have to go it alone.
Also it didn't take a season to go from breaking his bones to a fake 100%, that was throughout the show
"they rushed his quirk"
Bro deku had 5 straight seasons to hone the power of one for all,y'all were the same ppl tryna to give him flack for the leg thing
Walked a new line of morality?
Did you...expect him to join the bad guys or something?
@@chideraumejiaku3895 no, but him continuing to act like the perfect kid and the most innocent one really doesn't feel right in the middle of this situation. And if you don't think they rushed his quirk, that's fine. I was perfectly happy when he got the first power boost. But I think the implementation of the last few were really rushed. I didn't feel like he trained at all in order to get them. It just happened. It's the same problem I have with anime like SAO
@@thefrenchestfrenchman8355 how does he act like the perfect kid?
He's struggling with his own self destructive tendencies,he's tried to kill shigaraki,he's actively failing to keep the promise he made to almight about smiling when saving the day cause he doesn't even look like one of the good guys anymore.
The vigilante arc wasn't supposed to alter dekus ideals, everything from the paranormal liberation war,nagants story and currently shigarakis past are shaping dekus ideals.
He's gonna keep trying to save villains because that's what almight never did and that's why the world is so fucked up now that he's gone.If deku kills shigaraki and the cycle continues then what was the point?
What was the point of them showing us how complacent Almights existence made society?
What was the point of showing us how easily disregarding people for the gifts their born with push them to villainy?
Deku isn't sum perfect protagonist by any means but saying he's innocent and cheerful when he hasn't even smiled once since vigilante ended makes no sense
Meg who let you back in the house?
This vid nice!
Pls read the series
Im saying holy fuck alot of these gripes are due to bones terrorist of an adaptation and later crunching for fucking movies while knowing they got anime season to make. Shame your like the first i seen in here who said read the manga though its nice to see others countered his points at least 😭
I was really hoping you’d go over the writing of the show. It was lightly touched on with the characters but when I think of MHA flaws, I immediately think of how bad the writing is, especially in season 1 like when the teachers were going over that one training area and how it’s called the USJ and all the kids in their heads think “just like universal studios japan” like there’s a lot of moments where the show tries to be quirky, especially since the show is about quirks, but it ends up being a mess of a story and that’s when I think it doesn’t take itself seriously. There’s parts like Ochaco’s motivation in season 2 to be a hero to help her family get money, like that’s really great character development when she fights for herself but ends up as the “I do nothing until it’s for my love” literally immediately after that arc. I hate saying this was my first anime because when there’s moments like the first episode that made me cry when it came to Deku’s mother during that flashback because I think about how cringy the show and the “humor” turned out to be. The only interesting part about this show that’s worth watching imo IS the villains because at least they aren’t written to be absolute morons, for the most part. They actually do something like one car chase in season 3 if I remember correctly, and I thought to myself “oh cool new sand hero character, I wonder how he’ll impact the story of the entire show because his power could be just like Crocodile in One Piece except water doesn’t nullify his power, I’m excited to see how this plays out” and bro just instantly dies to Compress. Bro wasn’t on screen for more than half an episode because the villains actually do something. How is something so interesting like that in a show with awful writing for the main characters? I watch this show and think of how I hate every time one of the main characters speaks a word, then I get to scenes like that and it’s genuinely surprising and awesome, just to go back to cringy teamwork kids doing teamwork things.
Sorry for the long rant LMAO thank u for uploading this cause I’ve been thinking of this show a lot and wondered if it was still worth watching cause I stopped watching a couple episodes after Dabi reveals his identity to Endeavor
Honestly, all of your points are valid and I share the same views!
Honestly, the catastrophe of My Villain Academia in the anime and season five in general is deeply distressing.
I disagree with deku because he does show growth
What you think is good and what others think is good are totally subjective and its hilarious how ppl will shit on MHA but praise others for doing the same shit
Can you make a video similar to this but for demon slayer 🙏
Peak hero academia
Lmao @ 2:52 I completely lost it
i'd thought you would say the manga is better, and also the fanbase is 100x worse than chernobyl
the what??? 11:50
Epitome (pronounced “eh-pit-oh-me”) Yeah, idk why some people pronounce it as “epi-tome”
This is the best explanation I have heard so far and I agree with all of it.
I LOVE mha, and i binged the entire show in two weeks my first watch. I am a new fan, and i totally think deku is one of the weak points. I think the show would be so much better if deku had a negative arc, where he goes thru troubles and spirals (the way FUCKING BAKUGO DOES) and then he can go up AGAIN. Also the villians are so great i feel like the show is worth watching just bc of the villians. And i am activly working on a dabi cosplay. ALSO I TOTALLY AGREE PLUS ULTRA IS DEF BORING
FINALLY! A channel that's actually good!
18:49 Was this sudden stop meant to be there?
For me it's the ass pulls, the lack of emotional stakes and that Hori just refuses to kill any character off that the audience likes. Who cared about Nighteye? He was introduced in the same arc he died, also he was a douchebag most of the time, so yeah. Midnight dying off screen? Who gives a crap? That scale dude that died in the first war arc? Can't even remember his name.
I have literally zero emotional attachment to any of the characters, not anymore at least, because I know nothing will happen to them and for the rare case something bad does happen to them, Hori just pulls something out of his butt to make it not have any lasting impact (Bakugo comes to mind).
The first three seasons were peak, season 4 was a bit on the weaker side (especially because the animation started to drop off) but it was still okay and from season 5 onward there's just nothing really holding my interest. The only saving grace MHA had was that Hori is a once in a generation artist, his art is literally the best art in any running shonen series right now. I hope Hori is doing a horror manga next.
I once saw someone saying in a mocking tone that no one is supposed to die in the "happy go lucky superhero show". But why does MHA try to be so edgy and dark so often? How is "young girl gets tortured for multiple years so criminal organization can harness and abuse her powers" or "boy accidentally kills his whole family which he was mostly abused by" or "dad keeps producing children with a wife that doesn't want to be with him in order to produce the perfect superhero that can succeed him and then punches him and his mom", how is this a "happy go lucky" super hero show? I mean, this is the stuff I wanted the story to keep exploring. It wanted to get darker, then why would it never challenge Deku's mindset and worldview, why would Deku never stop and reflect on himself? That is why will I keep laughing in anyones face who says that the Dark Deku Arc was good character development. Where's the damn development though? Deku was just sad because he was targeted and felt alone because he thought he had to leave everyone. Then it was resolved because power of friendship and then we were back at square one.
I thought I would get more out of MHA when it admitedly got really dark at some places. I thought it would kept going and evolve into this show that throws away the expectations you would have at the beginning. And it kept teasing and teasing with dark stuff, not just with "sunday morning cartoon" dark stuff but with REALLY "this shit happens in real life and is the abyss of humanity" dark stuff.
All Might needed to die. Maybe even Deku's mom needed to die. SOMEBODY needed to die that was close to Deku so he could have FINALLY have some f*ing character development. And I will die on that hill.
Artist should just be that...artists...not writers, leave it to someone else and just do the character designs
Apparently mineta is supposed to be the authors self insert, which is concerning but does make some sense when you look at the story and world. It's a good show, about middle of the road but could be so much better.
When it comes to deku I think OSP sums it up well I'm red's video about pure good protags. Their character isn't the interesting one, it's how other people react to and around them. They are the catalyst for the arcs of those surrounding them and that's what MHA tries and doesn't do well. Also they do eventually develop him but we will have to see where they goes in the next season
Mineta is basically a troll character since the only self insert things are that they are perverts but mostley because he is easy to draw.
it is really good.
2:18 TF WAS THAT
literally never watched an anime in my kife but this video is cool i guess
ONLY 339 LIKES?
first 3 seasons were peak in my opinion but after like the 4th season it felt a little rushed & unreal idk
Thank you for the point because my hero isn’t that good but okay for a starter. The reason are that the writing isn’t that good, sexism, and also the fandom is very much out of hand, now that I’m older I can see the flaws of this show and I totally agree with you and I wish that they did better with the characters because we didn’t get that much improvement with a few side characters and the teachers are so bad. I wish that they did better with show but other then that there is no point in arguing with it because what is done it’s done
I’m glad I finally found a video that actually goes in depth of the problems of MHA and does it correctly. As a fan of the show it’s so refreshing to hear someone’s opinion that doesn’t sound repetitive or lackluster.
yea , can you remember me where he goes depth about the problems ?
@@fan_maty08im saying not to mention some of these problems are better handled in the source material, the manga. Bones fucked up alot in the anime adaptation and that’s undeniable fact you’ll hear from most readers not to mention people missing out on horikoshi’s phenomenal artwork
when I first started watching my hero I had been given the wrong impression that deku was gonna have no powers whatsoever and when I think about it ot just sounds so much more interesting
No it doesn't,he'd fucking die.
It’s the toxic fandom
I actually did really like My Hero. Well, no that's a lie, I read the story to see how the writers handled the idea's they presented in their pilot issue.
It's not breaking any ground, it's Bleach but with a sunshine child Goku instead of irritable preteen Ichigo as the main character.
Except, lacking any sort of genuine substance to bridge the gap between the spectacles of the fight scenes.
But hang on! What about the other Main Characters!
They become floating heads after they get to play a major part in an Arc.
An example:
Mirio stops being relevant after the Yakuza arc, and the Yakuza would have been dealt with before Quirks even came around if you follow the theory that the world of My Hero follows real world events until the Quirks started to show up. Nejire is the only member of the Big Three that I can remember returning after the Culture Festival arc, and even then she's just there so we see some female character in a skintight bodysuit that doesn't require a pov shift from the Main Fight.
And, the stuff that *does* get tossed in that would make a good story arc to add in some world building to the universe he came up with, he just uses it as a throwaway line and never brings it up again, unless it's to give motivations for a new antagonist that'll be killed off or forgotten by writers and fans alike by the end of the issue.
Like, for example, Spinner. The guy faces discrimination for looking like a lizard, and he goes full on death cult for Stain. By the end of the story, he's sort of like the rest of the League, he's only still there because they're his family now, and he's got nothing left but them.
Okay, that sounds like it'd be interesting to have a small filler episode or minor arc exploring the more unfortunate sides of a reality where everybody's super, right?
Nope. Just move on to the next part and forget he ever existed.
Momo Yaoyorozu. Oh boy where do I start..
Okay, Momo's Quirk is arguably one of the most broken powersets in the show. Like, as long as she keeps eating she can create fucking anything. With the exception of living tissue. Does that mean she can create dead tissue? Is her Quirk a Bloodline Power, and one of her parent's has the same ability? Are there more people like her? If there are, then is there a cabal of literal demigods that zap shit into existence maintaining the resources of the world like some weird parody of Thanos?
Secondly, and this is a larger problem I have with their costume design.
You go for a slutty, skintight spandex swimsuit that doesn't cover any of the vital organs, and a bookshelf resting on your spine ready to break it if you take a bad fall...Into a career where people regularly get tossed into and through solid walls, and streets, and other such obstructions typically made of concrete, bricks, and metal. And the high heels...Good god stiletto high heels...Maybe this is why Jirou and Kaminari are my favorite, they're the only ones that seem to get what layered protection is, and even then that's a major stretch, and assuming their clothing is specially made of MacGuffin material, and they have some kind of protective vest under their shirts.
Next up, returning to my earlier point of breaking new ground, the few things that MHA DOES try out seemingly for the first time, the story fumbles it, and/or changes it mind halfway through about what kind of story this is trying to be.
Continuing with this comedy of errors, the overall theming of conforming to society's norms is stupid.
I mean you can't get much more in your face about his views when multiple notable villain characters that actually aren't one dimensional-and not just evil because he needed a new bad guy for the week-have some kind of mental illness (Toga and Shigiraki), are some kind of loose allegory to second class citizens-Burakumin, if you'd like to learn about one part of Japan's history of hating anything that doesn't conform TO THE LETTER-(Spinner), and do not fall in with the child centric heteronormative, strictly gendered ideals of Japanese society (Magne).
Which is why the Internships Arc was wasted potential, it opens up the idea that maybe, just maybe, a government run career field isn't all that high on moral integrity, and then just completely one eighties it by excusing Endeavour's bullshit because 'I'm so sorry for what I did, guys, really! I know I messed up by buying a person to be a slave for breeding purposes, and then abusing her to the point of experiencing a psychotic break. And I know it was wrong to beat my eldest son until he became a sociopathic edgelord, and do the same thing to my youngest son. But I promise I can change despite not having displayed any indication otherwise for upwards of twenty years!'
Hell, the whole needing a super-power to be a superhero thing doesn't even hold water.
The teacher is legit just a dude with some fancy eye beams, some fiber cloth, and a knife, in effect he's fighting at the level of a baseline Human. With perhaps some JSDF or some kind of special operative training but still just a regular guy in a world with people that can sprout wings and jump clear over entire office buildings.
But it doesn't work on someone with a Mutant Quirk, say an extra set of arms to grab him with, or a tortoise shell to tank his hits.
And yet he's still good enough to get into the Hero Class through the Sports Festival transfer route.
Midoriya *absolutely* could have been a Quirkless Hero, if he was willing to put the work in and not have a stupid deus ex machine to fall back on.
And yes, Aizawa got fucked up in the War, but he's in his thirties and managed to last long enough in the Hero field that it takes a conflict organized by a centuries old quote unquote 'Symbol of Evil' before he started to actually take irreversible, potentially career ending injuries. So, either he just didn't face anybody higher up than untrained thugs with Quirks that barely do anything-which in a country with as many people in it as Japan the odds of that happening are potentially astronomical-OR he's just that good at kicking the shit out of people even if they have Mutations he can't suppress that naturally help them in combat.
And hey, you know who else got bodied in the War? Miruko, Hawks, and Endeavour. Three of the highest ranked Heros in the country, regardless of their skillsets they should be able to stand against the Number One at roughly even ground, and he can change the weather of an area with his blows. But again, it took until the main story started before they had major injuries.
In conclusion, MHA sucks because it had such interesting ideas of what a society that Syndrome dreamed of could look like, and like RWBY, it explores none of it, introduces a metric fuck ton of side characters, explores none of those, and then the city blows up.
Yes the Plus Ultra thing with the tone is horrible. A good example of where I think MHA messed up it with the World Heroes Mission, so he just punches the mirror guy a lot and doesn't receive any damage? But didn't Deku just have an arc where he was getting away from punching? Why not show more leg combat? So what if he ended with a kick, which to me seemed like an afterthought. It ruined the previous arc with Deku. Also what Deku was in the hospital 5 minutes ago and now he's oneshotting Muscular? Wait how did he get all these new quirks? Like at least give me 3 episodes wheres he's working at getting he quirks activated and getting used to them. I mean there was like 3-8 episodes of him just learning how to use OFA at 5 percent. There was no show of growth there. They have messed up so many things by either doing the exact thing the previous arc was trying to get away from or just skipping an arc entirely. Like give me a 10 episode training arc where Bakugo, Deku, and Todoroki are training. Deku wakes from his coma to see Bakugo trying to recreate the explosions that allowed him to get to Deku so fast. Todoroki is trying to turn he flames blue and create ice so cold frost comes off it, he unlocks an ability to basically make dry ice. Deku learn how to use his new quirks, then Bakugo learns how to use his quirk in it's awakened form, Todoroki figures out that he can create steam explosions and just use ice a smokescreen. Like there was enough potential to create an entire season of just the power triplets training. I would've been fine with that, but no Deku just is magically super OP. They botched a perfectly good opportunity to make a "filler" season that people would have been happy with.
That movie is not canon, that's why.
@@willfanofmanyii3751is it confirmed that it's not canon, because the first two movies are canon, because there're references to be in the manga and interviews.
@@markanthonyportem3430 Hori wrote the first 2 movies, which is why the manga references them heavily. Hori had no involvement with the third movie, which is why the only reference he made to it was Rody's siblings in the background watching TV.
@@willfanofmanyii3751 thanks. So what about the other 7/6 movies? I heard MHA is getting in total of 10 movies.
@@markanthonyportem3430 That was a rumor made by a wannabe-insider years ago.
I’m not much of a anime guy but I wanted to try this thank you for explaining it
Poor dude. You're getting absolutely roasted. You're very wrong. If you want to be taken seriously as a youtuber, you need better arguments than this.
did u not see deku go crazy against shigaraki and bakugou reactions?
And who said that it was any good in the first place?? That sht NEVER KI11S OFF ANY OF THEIR MAIN CHARACTERS. We don't care about side characters we wan't loss of main ones. That thing with a nerd for a protagonist is worser than fairy tail and one piece of sht.
This show is so good and awesome all the time except when you actually watch the show. Watching the show just feels like underdelivers what it’s expected to be
It’s the stigma I think tbh and the bad wrap it gets bc the fans plus some mid arcs
MHA could've benefited from higher stakes.
it could have easily done that by having some of the teachers and/or class 1A (or maybe even 1B) killed in the USJ arc. Because, come on; it's a big fucking villain assembly. In any other story 70+ powered up villains attacking 20 students plus some pro heroes would've been catastrophic. But no one important died, on both sides...
This arc destroyed all the stakes. In the context of the story, it could not have happen without one student dying. It makes the villains look like barking toy dogs.
In usj they were fighting a handful of low level grunts, Aizawa knocked out three at once on first contact and 1A are the strongest/smartest people in possibly the country, minus ones like mineta who somehow got in. So it does make sense especially when you consider that the villains knew nothing about the kids and put them in places they would thrive. Also they didn't walk out unscathed, both Aizawa and All might almost died and Aizawa remained injured for awhile. People don't need to die for their to be stakes it's just an easy way to do it
@@isdrakon9802 exactly! It wouldn't make sense for the kids or a teacher to die in this event, it would've made more sense if a student died or like another main character died in the first war arc instead of just Ms.Midnight (I think that's her name sorta forgot) and a bunch of randoms, or some injuries to make more of an impact from the story forwards. But about your mineta take I hate when people say that shit no offense. But like, he's like the top 5 or top 3 smartest students in the class, and his quirk is helpful when it comes to restraining an opponent or using it for speed for a bigger attack. He may not be physically strong but his quirk utility and brain helps, it sucks that Horikoshi just delegates him to be a perv, he's genuinely funny and could be useful if utilized more in the story
My hero got the Sakura problem
Why do people always got to throw and compare Sakura, in these kinds of situations? People just can't leave her alone.
MHA really is just Naruto 2.0
naw, thats JJK, mark my fucking words 5 years from now we are going to be tearing into it for almost the exact same reasons we tore into Shippuden.
@@rubixn00b71JJK is Bleach and YYH/HxH by extension. Not Naruto.
I thought the same. From day 1. I couldn’t help being the “this is just Naruto” person.
@@rubixn00b71it’s mid slayer
What the fuck are you even talking about??
i am not listening to 20 minute of yap but i think mha would actually be decent if not for bones studio
Deku takes are fucking awful man