@Alici_Evans It's cliche mostly and the way it's used in the movie is so funny. She's singing about not going in silence and all that and instantly gets imprisoned.
Naomi actually said in an interview that she sang speechless live when they filmed it and that’s so impressive considering speechless is such a hard song
Imo one of the best remakes is the 90’s version of 101 Dalmations. Then again, that one’s not a part of this trend of remakes so are we counting it? I agree tho Cinderella and Aladdin are also two of the best
in all her videos she hypes up women and never really has good stuff to say about guys, she loves insults thrown at guys but at girls isnt funny, shes a sjw, fat part makes sense
They could have done so much more with beauty and the beast but they removed many things and bad cast for beauty and the beast ( no hate to the actors)
This is definitely the best of the *musical* live action adaptations, Mena is an excellent Aladdin (Hollywood please cast him in things!!). Naomi is *so* perfect as Jasmine, and Speechless is an utterly phenomenal song. the best animated to live action overall is Cinderella (2015), but this is a very close second.
I wish Hannah would react to Cinderella (2015) even though it's not a musical. Sometimes I think about how it would've been if it were because it's my favorite Disney live action movie, how the classic songs would have sounded and in which parts of the story they would have added original songs.
I'd say The Jungle Book (2016) or Cinderella was the best of the live action adaptations, though Jungle Book is so different from the animated version as to be a different story altogether, which is part of why it works.
I feel like hannah should watch into the woods next. It might not be the most amazing movie but there is SOO MUCH material for her to react to!! (please like this so she sees. I honestly just really want her to watch it 😫😫😫)
As a former Disney entertainment cast member who spent a lot of time with Jasmine, this was so exciting for me to see! I agree with your notes. One thing I will say, is I didn’t mind Will Smith bringing some rap elements to the Genie. He was very humble in acknowledging that Robin Williams “didn’t leave a lot of room for improvement” in the role, and it almost kept Will from taking it. I believe he said what helped him was taking a step back to see what he could bring to the Genie. Robin Williams was obviously an incredible impressionist and they brought that to the cartoon Genie. Instead of Will copying that aspect of the role, he leaned into his Fresh Prince persona and brought that to Genie. When I look at it from that perspective, I can appreciate it more and see how each actor brought their own “signature” to this iconic role. Overall, agreed with everything else you said! (Also I think Will was CGI’d in Genie rather than painted blue and enlarged, so your “uncanny valley” comment is spot on!) thank you for reviewing this! It made me smile 💙
Do you know why they changed one of the lines in "Prince Ali" from "heard your princess was a sight lovely to see" to "Heard your princess was hot, where is she"? I saw the movie in the theaters - and it straight away bugged me, concidering they changed some other texts to be inclusive this just made the movie shallow to me :( concidering this was my favourite movie growing up it put me off quite a lot!
@@helene1288 My best guess is they decided to bring the more casual "Fresh Prince" approach to the Genie this time around. I do know they changed the lyric from "Brush up your Sunday salaam" to "Friday salaam" since it's the Muslim Holy Day. That change made sense to me from a cultural perspective! But you're right, this one wasn't necessary. I hope you still were able to enjoy the visuals- I thought they did a great job bringing vibrant colors and outfits to what could have been a very bland "desert" palette.
What I did like about this version of Aladdin is that it was just enough different from the cartoon version that it could stand alone. I like when Disney makes the live action movies to stand on their own instead of try to match exactly like the original. I loved cruella the live action of 101 dalmatians :) that doesn't have a ton of music but it is a good one. Another great reaction Hannah keep it up :)
same, never watched Cinderella since they've redone her so much that I'm tired of it. Lion King was basically nothing different. Beauty and the Beast and Aladdin both changed things to address plotholes or mysteries. Those are the only remakes I've seen.
Thats the literal definition of a remake. To take something and turn it into something new/different. it's still similar to the source material/original, but not the same. I wish people understood this. Instead they complain "it's unneccessary" or "it's not the same". Another reason to make the remakes is to keep the beloved cartoons in the light for younger generations who are growing up with "cocomelon" instead of disney channel. Personally, I enjoyed all the remakes so far. Sure they have a few issues here and there, but overall, they're not that bad.
@@MattZRJSRoxy Cinderella is the same as cartoon storywise, they also added a little bit, but not much.. but it looks stunning. Definitly a beautiful movie. Mulan however.. is a general bad movie. They made some things the same.. but they left out most of the movie and added so much other trashy storylines that if you gave the movie anothe name, you wouldnt even recognize it was mulan.
As a gay guy myself, I've loved seeing how much gayer your videos have been getting as you're more openly comfortable and open with your own queerness! It's genuinely inspiring.
Naomi Scott is absolutely stunning. This is probably my favorite live action Disney re-make. Her 'Speechless' and Will Smith's 'Prince Ali' were so freaking good.
A lot of people said they hated the versions of "Speechless" as it gave Jasmine more of a feminist role, I thought it only added to her charcater. The growl in "Speechless" is just awesome, I can't ever get it right when I try to sing that song. I LOVED Will Smith as the Geini, I think he did a great job in singing and everythign. There was/is some behind the scenes videos of the trio working on some fo the songs and they all looked like they were having a blast! I think you need to do Phantom of The Opera next, maybe with Sierra Boggess, or even Sweeny Todd with Angela Lansbury!
@Day i think its more telling, empowered women are always gonna be ignored and overlooked, that's exactly how it happens IRL, but we speak out, and say how we feel and that's really all we can do.
@@Miyanoai14 Honestly... I disagree with this. Yes, her attempts don't entirely succeed and she still ends up imprisoned, BUT her words get through to the guard and it forces Jafar to use his second wish. So her actions DID play a part in the story, hindering Jafar's attempts to take over the kingdom and forcing him to go one step forward instead of winning so easily. Sometimes small victories are worth it. She was in a hopeless situation and spoke out anyway. That's what Speechless is about.
@@cjf92 She was definitely always a very out-spoken princess and one of the best Disney princesses. But wanting to marry for love and wanting to be sultan are very different things (which relates to her role in the plot more than just the song itself; the song is just a way to express her feelings--and let us hear Naomi's amazing voice).
The term “diamond in the rough” means so much more to me. Aladdin is poor, yes. But he has the personality of a diamond. He is a great human being that never loses his compassion given his “rough” circumstance. Even with the power of the genie, he maintains his soul even though there are a few bumps in the road of him losing himself. He always reverts back to that strong, willful, and determined personality. I completely love the saying!
It's also literally *how* you create diamonds. In addition to the carbon, intense heat and pressure come together under the surface of the earth's mantle to create natural diamonds. It's rough circumstances that create diamonds - and along comes Aladdin.
its been a year so its probably too late to say this, but in an interview will smith actually said he didnt wanna take the genie role originally bc he felt that robin williams smashed it and he didn't want to top it out of respect, but then he had a moment where he felt it would be fun to put his own spin on the character, and i think he did a really good job!
Will Smith said that was very stressful to be the Genie bc Robin did an amazing job, but he did NOT tried to be like him, because he didn't wanted to mess with Robin. Will did his best to make his version of the character, that's why there's the rap moments, and they make sense cause tecnically Genie somehow knows about the past and the future and he would know about hip hop and future things that people didn't know.
The “meh” feeling always happens when you translate animation to live action, in my opinion. With animation, you can add change and warp the backgrounds and characters to match the action. But with live action you have limits, making it feel lack luster.
I love the little harmony they throw in on "feeling" (18:15) it's only a small difference from the original version but it fits in so nicely, also their voices sound so good together
I love the live action Aladdin, from the vocals to the choreography - it's all just beautifully done. Also that scene where the genie controls Aladdin while dancing, I think Mena Massoud does such a fantastic job here. I also love that they adapted the ending so Jasmine can change the law to choose who she marries. Naomi Scott singing Speechless gives me chills every time.
Oh my god my dad would not stop singing speechless when this movie came out, like he would even tell my mom whenever we were going out that she looked so good it left him “SPEEECHLEEEEEES” 😭
I liked Aladdin a lot. I felt like it was done well. The actors obviously can sing well. I never felt like the live action was meant to replace the classics. I love the Aladdin classic as well. I felt like they were meant to draw in a brand new generation to the older Disney classics. And the live action versions usually impress me…keeping that in mind.
@@Sthuthukile I agree. I think as a remake of the original Disney movie it sucked, they took tons of liberties with their original story that it didn’t feel like the same movie; however, on its own, I feel like the movie was fine
This is hands down the best live action Disney movie from this current era. Will Smith was the right choice for genie because just like with Robin Williams if he can't sing on par with the others he has charisma to back him up. Also having him walk around and be human helped with the uncanny valley of the CGI (work smarter not harder). I also loved the set design and costumes like you did. Showcasing so much culture. Culture is fun. And yes Naomi Scott is a gem
Naomi Scott sang with veins to portray jasmines emotions in that moment , she was also singing it completely live which was hard so I think that she could easily sing this no strain it was due to her acting and portraying jasmine that she did that
Also, I think it's very very worthwhile to mention that the second time Naomi Scott Sings Speechless she actually sings it live on set, and that's the recording they use, which is why it sounds so authentic and beautiful and unedited. Which I think is so amazing and one of the reasons why its my favourite song of any of the recent Disney Live action movies
this is one of my guilty pleasure movies. I understand the frustration of disney just making live-action movies and being unoriginal, but this one's different for me. I am absolutely obsessed. And i LOVE speechless
i do have to say Naomi Scott who plays Jasmine did an amazing job and it shocked me when I saw her in this movie... gives me memories of Lemonade Mouth which she also sings amazing in. I also loved the video Hanna and you're channel. ♥
Can we take a second to just applaud Naomi for doing speechless in literally one take while it was live. Naomi had talked about how that song was only rehearsed the studio prior to the day of the shoot and she got so overwhelmed while singing it that emotion you see is her actually crying. I do agree that’s such a hard song to sing, and because of that I have so much respect for Naomi Scott as a singer above all because bravo to her.
You should take a look at a song they deleted (it was filmed), it's called desert moon, sung by Aladdin and Jasmine. It should have been when Aladdin was going to the cave of wonder while Jasmine was waiting for him, and it's the song both their mothers used to sing to them when they were children (they bonded over it at Aladdin's home)
i genuinely think this is the best live action adaptation disney has put out since they started doing them with beauty and the beast - it has it''s flaws, but i like that they added a lot to jasmine's character. she seems a lot more fleshed out with her ambitions and such than her animated counterpart, though it's been a long time since i've seen the animated aladdin.
I actually enjoyed how Genie ended up coming back around at the end with his own family. It threw me off in the beginning, but it made more sense that he was telling that story because he was a part of it. It was cute!
5:45 the “one jump” moment is weird because they sped up the scene to match the vocals that was either added later or laid the isolated vocals back over the sped up scene. The song was probably faster paced than the original movement of the actors.
I am usually not a big live action Disney movie, but when I watched this for the first time. It was my favorite Disney live action movie. I loved there voices I loved everything about this movie.
I’ll say it right here and now: Aladdin is the ONLY live action Disney movie that actually satisfies me. The casting was perfect, the music was perfect, the cgi was near perfect! Everything was amazing!
something i rlly love about musicals is the ensemble and the dance numbers and we don't get that a lot in the older disney movies so i was so happy to see it in this one because the songs are the perfect material
I’ve been to the musical in theater a few days ago and it was literally amazing the songs, dances, acting, decors and of course the cast. It was so so good that I can’t describe it with words and would want to go there again but it stops at the end of the week. I’m so sad but glad that I was allowed to see this masterpiece in real life
21:33 I don’t know if anyone already said this but Naomi actually sang this live as they were shooting the movie. The director was a person that was really good about live singing and Naomi wanted to try to sing live and so she did. It made the Final Cut as we have all just seen
If you haven’t seen Twisted (musical by Starkid) I highly recommend it! It’s so good! It’s like if Wicked and Aladdin had a baby. The music is wonderful, and the storyline in amazing!
Oh yes totally! I absolutly love dilan as jafar in twisted. And when she said he had a soft spots for vilain i immediatly thought of the vilains song in twisted. She needs to react to that musical! And the harry potter ones as well!
fun fact: Naomi actually sang (the second) Speechless live as they were recording. There is very very little playback during the song, they were actually recording her singing live. In an interview she said it was really hard because everyone on set had to be completely quiet.
You made so many good points! Aladdin and Jasmine had amazing chemistry (and sounded great apart and together), the movie was gorgeous, and Will Smith definitely worked best as the genie when he wasn't trying to emulate Robin Williams' performance. He's more than good enough in his own right that the parts where comparisons were easier to draw detracted from the character as a whole.
so happy that you are reacting to this. Abu was voiced by the same voice actor; Frank Welker who also reprises his voice roles of Rajah the tiger and the Cave Guardian. Of course Jasmine is a babe since Naomi Scott is such a babe. Yup correct regarding Abu stealing the lamp back. Agreed, Mena definitely sounds like the singing voice that stood in for the Full House star with Aladdin's singing lines. Naomi is so perfect with her performances here. Correct regarding the Genie, he never lost his powers back then, he just wasn't tied down to a prison. The intro was meant to be homage to the intro in the original where a peddler shows the lamp to the audience as a 4th wall break and starts to explain the story. This was never confirmed back then in-movie but the Directors had later confirmed that it was meant to be a disguised Genie hence why Robin did that voice too BUT didn't do the peddler's singing voice.
i remember seeing this movie without any expectations, because Disney barely advertised it. So of course me and my friends were pleasantly surprised at how much we enjoyed this movie! the cast is great and so are all the musical numbers, honestly its just such a fun movie night
You should react to the StarKid musical Twisted: The Untold Story of a Royal Vizier. Basically they gave Ja'far the Wicked treatment. It's so good. Very funny, lots of meta jokes, amazing singing, and also kind of emotional
YES! I mean Hannah mentions Darren Criss in her Glee videos, so is not such a leap to watch some Starkid stuff. The next logical step, really. She should go full circle and react to Twisted, it's the best Starkid musical there is. It would be totally awesome.
The way you make me feel when you react to these makes my heart flutter. I cried during speechless it was too powerful. Love you please keep doing these
Undoubtedly, Aladdin is the most visually impressive live-action movie Disney has ever made ('cause the Lion King was so realistic that it makes me uncomfortable). Perfect cast and music performances. Stunning!
I agree with you Hannah. The colors are amazing. The ensembles are amazing. I just love Jasmines dresses so much. I just want to watch this movie again and again just to see these beautiful dresses and colors
Raise your hand if you think Cinderella was the best Disney live action remake (On a separate note, Hannah, you look so lovely today. Your sweater is so cute!)
Cinderella is definitely one of the better ones. Aladdin was my favorite out of all of them but Cinderella is definitely a close second. Her dress was gorgeous.
Cinderella is my favorite (so wholesome and sincere), but I think Jungle Book might be the best. Cinderella, Jungle Book, and Aladdin are top three. So excited for Little Mermaid and Peter Pan.
Aladdin is hands down my favorite Disney movie and Jasmine so my favorite princess. This is my favorite live action remake so far that Disney has done.
I say this a lot with Disney movies but I love this movie. I remember seeing this in theaters when it came out the first day. Everyone in this and the people who made this movie possible are so so flipping amazingly talented. Also yes I would love to see you react to more Disney live action movies! Love the videos! You do an amazing job!
Can I just say how proud I am to consider myself Hannah’s student? I started watching these videos a couple of years ago and I don’t remember where I first saw her talk about tension in the neck/throat and i distinctly remember thinking back to Naomi singing speechless because I’d always thought that the tension was just a sign that the singer is putting a lot of power and emotion into it and it was Hannah who made me understand it. And as soon as I saw that she reacted to this movie I had to come back and hear what she had to say and AAAAHHHH I’m sorry for the rant lol but I just feel blessed to have been taught by Hannah 😭❤️
16:40 I watched this movie in theaters after it came out and the ENTIRE THEATER got second hand embarrassment from that scene. It was so embarrassing you could hear people groan from the embarrassment. 😂
Mena Massoud Is awesome. Now he Is playing Ezra Bridger in the Mandalorian. You know? Ezra Bridger when he was 17 in Star Wars Rebels season three was very handsome with haircut and those dark Blue eyes like Deep Sea. Rebels season three was my favorite because It was perfect for the fangirls especially the teen girls that they were obessed Ezra with haircut.
i watched this movie with my dad and my twin sister on theaters on my 14th birthday, before the pandemic we'd always watch a movie together (my dad moved to a different city because of his job and so i haven't spent that much time with him lately), it brings me back good memories!!
When you talked about that Aladdín versión where Aladdin is the villain made me think about Starkid's Twisted: the untold story of a royal visir. Have you seen it? It's honestly the best thing ever lol awesome songs sung by super talented actors, hilarious comedy, a Ja'far backstory and character arc very Wicked inspired, you should totally check it out if you haven't!
It’s so impressive that Naomi was moving, acting, 𝓪𝓷𝓭 add emotion while singing speechless. It’s a very good but hard song to sing! And yet she sang it perfectly❤️❤️❤️😍
I loved this live action. I thought the main three (Mena, Naomi and Will) were so well cast. Movie was colorful and fun. I do love Hannah’s reaction! Please cheetah girls. Way overdueeeee
this was one of the live action adaptations i genuinely liked and enjoyed bc they had the flavor of the original but added their own twist especially in the music! everything was fresh and i think the budget on this was wooow. look at the outfits and all the colors and CGI! the casting was great i guess lol but especially mena as aladdin and naomi as jasmine, they were perfect! i was obsessed with mena for a whole year when this came out lmao. i love that you liked it too!
Hey Hannah. Actually Naomi Scott sang “Speechless” on set instead of using the recorded version of the song. That’s why her neck was so tense and you can also hear her running out of breath. This was something they discussed in an interview with the cast after the movie premiere
Here in Brazil,who dubbed the voice of Alladin was a great voice actor called Daniel Garcia. The amazing thing about this is that Daniel Garcia also goes by the stage name Gloria Groove. one of the greatest drag artists in Brazil. Please Hannah, if one day you can, get to know Gloria Groove's work, you will love it!!!
If we’re talking about the Brazilian dub, I wanna give a shout out to the voice actress who dubs Jasmine, Lara Suleiman! She does a GREAT job, and her rendition of Speechless is absolutely beautiful! She also dubs Luisa in Encanto, and her voice is just so amazing and versatile! (On an unrelated note, she was also the understudy of Wednesday Addams in the last production of the Addams Family musical in São Paulo, and she killed it)
This is the difference in getting a lead actress who can SING and one who is just sort of okay. I know they didn't help Emma Watson out at all by surrounding her with Broadway caliber singers and the auto-tuning, etc, but she never could've performed like Naomi Scott. Aladdin is my favorite of the Disney live actions, partly because of that, and also because it's not word-for-word the same as the animated one. It's just different enough, they tweaked just enough things, and I think it works SO well!
Most of Speechless was not pre-recorded. I don't know the reason for that, but it may be why you see the tension she's holding - she is singing the song in that moment.
The end credit dance number, made me realize we could’ve had a Bollywood style version of the movie. They did so much for the ensemble for numbers like “Prince Ali” but cut up the footage to not show anything for very long and showed too much of just Aladdin smiling nervously
you should also watch the song taken out of Aladdin due to the movie being too long!! Its called Desert Moon. Alan Menken even did a intro for that song. Its so sweet
I believe they started the live action with an epilogue was because in the animated movie, the story began with a travelling merchant (also voiced by the amazing Robin W.) who told the story of the lamp. And the movie was supposed to end with the reveal that the merchant was the genie all along but was cut due to time constraints. They kept the idea, considering that the live action genie also became a travelling merchant in the end. If I'm not wrong, the merchant that started story in the animation made a final appearance on Aladdin and the King of Thieves when Aladdin and Jasmine had one last carpet ride around Aggrabah after their wedding.
Watching your videos always brings a smile to my face. I love watching you react to things and laughing with you. Please never stop bringing joy to us. ❤️
HANNAH!!! Thanks for the Sideways shoutout!!! He’s my favorite RUclipsr (besides you of course!) and I really appreciate you spreading his channel… he really deserves it
I really loved this movie! I’m like you and really loved the nostalgia, but I’m also so happy Jasmine got more depth to her part in this movie… and Speechless is on every playlist I have right now! I absolutely love the power it has to it! Thanks for (finally, lol!) doing Aladdin! I love how real your reactions are and your genuine excited ent with this movie! I have friends who say they hated this movie, but loved Lion King. I wasn’t a fan of LK, but absolutely LOVE this remake! Anyway, thanks for being you! ❤
I've seen a couple of comments about this, so Naomi Scott sings the first part of the second Speechless live and it goes to the studio version the moment she turns around on the first "I won't be silenced". Absolutely love the live part!!!
Naomi Scott sang part of the second speechless live on the set which made it all the more impressive
She sounds so good, but the song is so bad and is hilarious in the movie.
@@neutralman9124 What do you not like about the song?
@Alici_Evans It's cliche mostly and the way it's used in the movie is so funny. She's singing about not going in silence and all that and instantly gets imprisoned.
@@neutralman9124 its the message of the song lmaoooo
@@neutralman9124it’s abt not being silenced by men or anyone😭
Naomi actually said in an interview that she sang speechless live when they filmed it and that’s so impressive considering speechless is such a hard song
1,2k likes and no comments? Let me fix that❤😊
@@Anna-xg2nw same
usually live actions feel a bit unecessary but this aladdin just feels like it adds a lot. it’s just exciting and fun
Honestly this and the 2015 Cinderella were the only live action remakes I really enjoyed.
@@Bookshelved_ Right! Oh I LOVE Cinderella. It just has so much glee in it. Lily James did a wonderful job!
not with that ending, hate it they change the ending it pointless
Imo one of the best remakes is the 90’s version of 101 Dalmations. Then again, that one’s not a part of this trend of remakes so are we counting it? I agree tho Cinderella and Aladdin are also two of the best
@@Bookshelved_ And the jungle book
i love how hannah’s favorite parts were Jasmine, Jasmine’s dresses, Jasmine’s voice, and Jasmine’s acting 😂
girl me too
I agree wholeheartily
in all her videos she hypes up women and never really has good stuff to say about guys, she loves insults thrown at guys but at girls isnt funny, shes a sjw, fat part makes sense
Sigma🤫🧏♀️
Fun Fact: So Hannah, in Speechless, Naomi Scott recorded this scene in one take and it's live, so we're hearing the "raw" voice in the scene.
love you
Just the beginning is live. The rest is in a studio
This is not true. Only the beginning.
I actually think Aladdin is probably one of the best live-action adaptations Disney has done so far 😍
Jungle Book and Aladdin were all they should have done.
I think Aladdin is one of the only five action movies they did properly because the rest of them are pretty bad
it's enjoyable for sure
@Lina elhabashy yeah I 100% agree...like Aladdin and The jungle book live action was my 2 absolute favorite ❤❤❤❤❤
They could have done so much more with beauty and the beast but they removed many things and bad cast for beauty and the beast ( no hate to the actors)
Naomi Scott and Mena Massoud did a great job, oh my gosh. Their chemistry and voices really tie the movie together.
lol ok
Truth
Fax
I love how much Naomi’s voice has grown since her Lemonade Mouth days.
Oh my GOSH I didn't even recognize her!
This is definitely the best of the *musical* live action adaptations, Mena is an excellent Aladdin (Hollywood please cast him in things!!). Naomi is *so* perfect as Jasmine, and Speechless is an utterly phenomenal song. the best animated to live action overall is Cinderella (2015), but this is a very close second.
He's in the Netflix movie "The Royal Treatment" from 2022, where he plays a prince as well🥰
I totally agree! Cinderella was beautiful and amazing and this was a close second for sure. 😊
I wish Hannah would react to Cinderella (2015) even though it's not a musical. Sometimes I think about how it would've been if it were because it's my favorite Disney live action movie, how the classic songs would have sounded and in which parts of the story they would have added original songs.
TOTALLY AGREE!!!❤
I'd say The Jungle Book (2016) or Cinderella was the best of the live action adaptations, though Jungle Book is so different from the animated version as to be a different story altogether, which is part of why it works.
fun fact: when jazmine was singing speechless she actually didn’t record that before that was her live voice in that moment with no auto tune
I feel like hannah should watch into the woods next. It might not be the most amazing movie but there is SOO MUCH material for her to react to!! (please like this so she sees. I honestly just really want her to watch it 😫😫😫)
I agree!!!
Half of them can't sing though, IMOP. Talk about a LONG moive though...
Oh my god I need her reactions to Agony. Thats all i need in my life now 😂😂
Omg I love Into the Woods💕✨
Yesss boosting!!
As a former Disney entertainment cast member who spent a lot of time with Jasmine, this was so exciting for me to see! I agree with your notes. One thing I will say, is I didn’t mind Will Smith bringing some rap elements to the Genie. He was very humble in acknowledging that Robin Williams “didn’t leave a lot of room for improvement” in the role, and it almost kept Will from taking it. I believe he said what helped him was taking a step back to see what he could bring to the Genie. Robin Williams was obviously an incredible impressionist and they brought that to the cartoon Genie. Instead of Will copying that aspect of the role, he leaned into his Fresh Prince persona and brought that to Genie. When I look at it from that perspective, I can appreciate it more and see how each actor brought their own “signature” to this iconic role. Overall, agreed with everything else you said! (Also I think Will was CGI’d in Genie rather than painted blue and enlarged, so your “uncanny valley” comment is spot on!) thank you for reviewing this! It made me smile 💙
Do you know why they changed one of the lines in "Prince Ali" from "heard your princess was a sight lovely to see" to "Heard your princess was hot, where is she"? I saw the movie in the theaters - and it straight away bugged me, concidering they changed some other texts to be inclusive this just made the movie shallow to me :( concidering this was my favourite movie growing up it put me off quite a lot!
@@helene1288 My best guess is they decided to bring the more casual "Fresh Prince" approach to the Genie this time around. I do know they changed the lyric from "Brush up your Sunday salaam" to "Friday salaam" since it's the Muslim Holy Day. That change made sense to me from a cultural perspective! But you're right, this one wasn't necessary. I hope you still were able to enjoy the visuals- I thought they did a great job bringing vibrant colors and outfits to what could have been a very bland "desert" palette.
I luv what was done with Genie and to my understanding will did not want to do this bc he is not a singer… but I think he did an amazing job!!!
What I did like about this version of Aladdin is that it was just enough different from the cartoon version that it could stand alone. I like when Disney makes the live action movies to stand on their own instead of try to match exactly like the original. I loved cruella the live action of 101 dalmatians :) that doesn't have a ton of music but it is a good one. Another great reaction Hannah keep it up :)
same, never watched Cinderella since they've redone her so much that I'm tired of it. Lion King was basically nothing different. Beauty and the Beast and Aladdin both changed things to address plotholes or mysteries. Those are the only remakes I've seen.
Thats the literal definition of a remake. To take something and turn it into something new/different. it's still similar to the source material/original, but not the same. I wish people understood this. Instead they complain "it's unneccessary" or "it's not the same". Another reason to make the remakes is to keep the beloved cartoons in the light for younger generations who are growing up with "cocomelon" instead of disney channel.
Personally, I enjoyed all the remakes so far. Sure they have a few issues here and there, but overall, they're not that bad.
@@MattZRJSRoxy Cinderella is the same as cartoon storywise, they also added a little bit, but not much.. but it looks stunning. Definitly a beautiful movie. Mulan however.. is a general bad movie. They made some things the same.. but they left out most of the movie and added so much other trashy storylines that if you gave the movie anothe name, you wouldnt even recognize it was mulan.
yesssss this is why I love maleficent so much
@@dolcebelcanto3626 I love maleficent too, such a good movie
The live action Aladdin is honestly my favorite Disney live action. Granted, I haven't seen many of the others, but this worked so well in my opinion!
Also want to add, you started watching The Cheetah Girls awhile back, so maybe you could do 2 and 3?
You should see the live action Cinderella. It’s my favourite live action film
You should also check out the Jungle Book
As a gay guy myself, I've loved seeing how much gayer your videos have been getting as you're more openly comfortable and open with your own queerness! It's genuinely inspiring.
???
@@jeremyrdlamaxima7052ym “???”😭he said what he said
@@jeremyrdlamaxima7052 Hannah is bi, that’s why haha
Spill bro
@@Shae29 really??? omg true icon
Naomi Scott is absolutely stunning. This is probably my favorite live action Disney re-make. Her 'Speechless' and Will Smith's 'Prince Ali' were so freaking good.
A lot of people said they hated the versions of "Speechless" as it gave Jasmine more of a feminist role, I thought it only added to her charcater. The growl in "Speechless" is just awesome, I can't ever get it right when I try to sing that song. I LOVED Will Smith as the Geini, I think he did a great job in singing and everythign. There was/is some behind the scenes videos of the trio working on some fo the songs and they all looked like they were having a blast! I think you need to do Phantom of The Opera next, maybe with Sierra Boggess, or even Sweeny Todd with Angela Lansbury!
@Day Always found that hilariously ironic tbh. "won't be silence" she sings as she's captured immediately.
@Day i think its more telling, empowered women are always gonna be ignored and overlooked, that's exactly how it happens IRL, but we speak out, and say how we feel and that's really all we can do.
@@Miyanoai14 Honestly... I disagree with this. Yes, her attempts don't entirely succeed and she still ends up imprisoned, BUT her words get through to the guard and it forces Jafar to use his second wish. So her actions DID play a part in the story, hindering Jafar's attempts to take over the kingdom and forcing him to go one step forward instead of winning so easily.
Sometimes small victories are worth it. She was in a hopeless situation and spoke out anyway. That's what Speechless is about.
Jasmine was always a feminist
@@cjf92 She was definitely always a very out-spoken princess and one of the best Disney princesses. But wanting to marry for love and wanting to be sultan are very different things (which relates to her role in the plot more than just the song itself; the song is just a way to express her feelings--and let us hear Naomi's amazing voice).
the reason you can see so much tension in naomi’s neck during speechless is because she actually sang most of that song live. very impressive.
The term “diamond in the rough” means so much more to me. Aladdin is poor, yes. But he has the personality of a diamond. He is a great human being that never loses his compassion given his “rough” circumstance. Even with the power of the genie, he maintains his soul even though there are a few bumps in the road of him losing himself. He always reverts back to that strong, willful, and determined personality. I completely love the saying!
It's also literally *how* you create diamonds. In addition to the carbon, intense heat and pressure come together under the surface of the earth's mantle to create natural diamonds. It's rough circumstances that create diamonds - and along comes Aladdin.
its been a year so its probably too late to say this, but in an interview will smith actually said he didnt wanna take the genie role originally bc he felt that robin williams smashed it and he didn't want to top it out of respect, but then he had a moment where he felt it would be fun to put his own spin on the character, and i think he did a really good job!
the best parts of his songs were when he was being Will Genie and not trying to be Robin Williams Genie fr
Will Smith said that was very stressful to be the Genie bc Robin did an amazing job, but he did NOT tried to be like him, because he didn't wanted to mess with Robin. Will did his best to make his version of the character, that's why there's the rap moments, and they make sense cause tecnically Genie somehow knows about the past and the future and he would know about hip hop and future things that people didn't know.
YESSSSS!
No I completely agree I hate how she said that because he defo wasn't trying to be him
The “meh” feeling always happens when you translate animation to live action, in my opinion. With animation, you can add change and warp the backgrounds and characters to match the action. But with live action you have limits, making it feel lack luster.
I love the little harmony they throw in on "feeling" (18:15) it's only a small difference from the original version but it fits in so nicely, also their voices sound so good together
I love the live action Aladdin, from the vocals to the choreography - it's all just beautifully done. Also that scene where the genie controls Aladdin while dancing, I think Mena Massoud does such a fantastic job here. I also love that they adapted the ending so Jasmine can change the law to choose who she marries. Naomi Scott singing Speechless gives me chills every time.
I think that is not Mena Massoud who is dancing😢
Oh my god my dad would not stop singing speechless when this movie came out, like he would even tell my mom whenever we were going out that she looked so good it left him “SPEEECHLEEEEEES” 😭
That's so cute!
This is adorable
goals
I thought the rap part of Friend like Me was what made Will's different from Robin's and I loved it! By far, my favorite live action remake
I liked Aladdin a lot. I felt like it was done well. The actors obviously can sing well. I never felt like the live action was meant to replace the classics. I love the Aladdin classic as well. I felt like they were meant to draw in a brand new generation to the older Disney classics. And the live action versions usually impress me…keeping that in mind.
Breaking my silence : I actually enjoyed the live action Mulan
@@Sthuthukile I agree. I think as a remake of the original Disney movie it sucked, they took tons of liberties with their original story that it didn’t feel like the same movie; however, on its own, I feel like the movie was fine
@@Sthuthukile I loved Live action Mulan too
This is hands down the best live action Disney movie from this current era. Will Smith was the right choice for genie because just like with Robin Williams if he can't sing on par with the others he has charisma to back him up. Also having him walk around and be human helped with the uncanny valley of the CGI (work smarter not harder). I also loved the set design and costumes like you did. Showcasing so much culture. Culture is fun.
And yes Naomi Scott is a gem
Just because it’s the best live action movie doesn’t mean it’s a good movie on its own, but this one is the rest of the ones aren’t
Naomi Scott sang with veins to portray jasmines emotions in that moment , she was also singing it completely live which was hard so I think that she could easily sing this no strain it was due to her acting and portraying jasmine that she did that
Also, I think it's very very worthwhile to mention that the second time Naomi Scott Sings Speechless she actually sings it live on set, and that's the recording they use, which is why it sounds so authentic and beautiful and unedited. Which I think is so amazing and one of the reasons why its my favourite song of any of the recent Disney Live action movies
this is one of my guilty pleasure movies. I understand the frustration of disney just making live-action movies and being unoriginal, but this one's different for me. I am absolutely obsessed. And i LOVE speechless
Ditto!
I accidentally turned the subtitles on and when Jafar said "I wish to be Sultan of Agrabah" the subtitles said "I wish to be southern Nevada" 😂
i do have to say Naomi Scott who plays Jasmine did an amazing job and it shocked me when I saw her in this movie... gives me memories of Lemonade Mouth which she also sings amazing in. I also loved the video Hanna and you're channel. ♥
I love Lemonade Mouth so much
She's so gone! :)
Can we take a second to just applaud Naomi for doing speechless in literally one take while it was live. Naomi had talked about how that song was only rehearsed the studio prior to the day of the shoot and she got so overwhelmed while singing it that emotion you see is her actually crying. I do agree that’s such a hard song to sing, and because of that I have so much respect for Naomi Scott as a singer above all because bravo to her.
Can we take a moment to appreciate👏how 👏awesome👏the 👏ensemble 👏were!! They did so good and really added to the songs as a whole, such as Prince Ali
You should take a look at a song they deleted (it was filmed), it's called desert moon, sung by Aladdin and Jasmine. It should have been when Aladdin was going to the cave of wonder while Jasmine was waiting for him, and it's the song both their mothers used to sing to them when they were children (they bonded over it at Aladdin's home)
aladdin is the ONLY disney live action that’s actually kinda good. also, it’s so wholesome watching your reactions to movies
Um hello, Cinderella 2015? In terms of cinematography anyway
Definitely agree with Cinderella! In terms of storytelling and character development too, just such a good movie
also the jungle book
Maleficent can’t be beat but Aladdin is good too
let’s be fr. beauty and the beast is the best. aladdin is a close second
i genuinely think this is the best live action adaptation disney has put out since they started doing them with beauty and the beast - it has it''s flaws, but i like that they added a lot to jasmine's character. she seems a lot more fleshed out with her ambitions and such than her animated counterpart, though it's been a long time since i've seen the animated aladdin.
I actually enjoyed how Genie ended up coming back around at the end with his own family. It threw me off in the beginning, but it made more sense that he was telling that story because he was a part of it. It was cute!
I'm glad you actually liked this one! This is probably my second favorite live action, Cinderella being my first.
The version of Naomi singing Speechless in the studio is so good
5:45 the “one jump” moment is weird because they sped up the scene to match the vocals that was either added later or laid the isolated vocals back over the sped up scene. The song was probably faster paced than the original movement of the actors.
I am usually not a big live action Disney movie, but when I watched this for the first time. It was my favorite Disney live action movie. I loved there voices I loved everything about this movie.
I had to watch it just because Naomi was in it.
I’ll say it right here and now: Aladdin is the ONLY live action Disney movie that actually satisfies me. The casting was perfect, the music was perfect, the cgi was near perfect! Everything was amazing!
something i rlly love about musicals is the ensemble and the dance numbers and we don't get that a lot in the older disney movies so i was so happy to see it in this one because the songs are the perfect material
13:35 it’s because he didn’t wanna be the same fact same as like robin william was so he wanted to make the genie kinda himself too
A Whole New World was the biggest nostalgia punch in the feels out of all of the remakes. Especially since the singing by the two were amazing.
I’ve been to the musical in theater a few days ago and it was literally amazing the songs, dances, acting, decors and of course the cast. It was so so good that I can’t describe it with words and would want to go there again but it stops at the end of the week. I’m so sad but glad that I was allowed to see this masterpiece in real life
I love watching Hannah’s honest reactions! We gotta start a Mamma Mia 1 and 2 reaction next!
21:33 I don’t know if anyone already said this but Naomi actually sang this live as they were shooting the movie. The director was a person that was really good about live singing and Naomi wanted to try to sing live and so she did. It made the Final Cut as we have all just seen
If you haven’t seen Twisted (musical by Starkid) I highly recommend it! It’s so good!
It’s like if Wicked and Aladdin had a baby. The music is wonderful, and the storyline in amazing!
"if Wicked and Aladdin had a baby" might be the greatest description of Twisted i've ever heard xD
Finally someone said it! Twisted is honestly one of the best musicals ever. And I’m a fan of a ton of musicals, theatre and filmed.
Oh yes totally! I absolutly love dilan as jafar in twisted. And when she said he had a soft spots for vilain i immediatly thought of the vilains song in twisted. She needs to react to that musical! And the harry potter ones as well!
fun fact: Naomi actually sang (the second) Speechless live as they were recording. There is very very little playback during the song, they were actually recording her singing live. In an interview she said it was really hard because everyone on set had to be completely quiet.
will smith actually came to set the day they were filming speechless because Naomi sang it live and he cried because she was so good
I think after Cinderella, Aladdin's live action is my favorite. I enjoyed it so much.
You made so many good points! Aladdin and Jasmine had amazing chemistry (and sounded great apart and together), the movie was gorgeous, and Will Smith definitely worked best as the genie when he wasn't trying to emulate Robin Williams' performance. He's more than good enough in his own right that the parts where comparisons were easier to draw detracted from the character as a whole.
The person who plays Jafar is a Dutch actor, I’m also Dutch and very proud of him, playing in this movie. Of course other movies too.
so happy that you are reacting to this. Abu was voiced by the same voice actor; Frank Welker who also reprises his voice roles of Rajah the tiger and the Cave Guardian. Of course Jasmine is a babe since Naomi Scott is such a babe.
Yup correct regarding Abu stealing the lamp back.
Agreed, Mena definitely sounds like the singing voice that stood in for the Full House star with Aladdin's singing lines.
Naomi is so perfect with her performances here.
Correct regarding the Genie, he never lost his powers back then, he just wasn't tied down to a prison.
The intro was meant to be homage to the intro in the original where a peddler shows the lamp to the audience as a 4th wall break and starts to explain the story. This was never confirmed back then in-movie but the Directors had later confirmed that it was meant to be a disguised Genie hence why Robin did that voice too BUT didn't do the peddler's singing voice.
i remember seeing this movie without any expectations, because Disney barely advertised it. So of course me and my friends were pleasantly surprised at how much we enjoyed this movie! the cast is great and so are all the musical numbers, honestly its just such a fun movie night
I'm obsessed with the live-action Aladdin. It's my favorite of the remakes by a long shot.
I also got chills during a whole new world, even during these little clips you showed! It’s just all so magical.
You should react to the StarKid musical Twisted: The Untold Story of a Royal Vizier. Basically they gave Ja'far the Wicked treatment. It's so good. Very funny, lots of meta jokes, amazing singing, and also kind of emotional
Yessss that's what I said! It's free on starkids RUclips channel!!
YES! I mean Hannah mentions Darren Criss in her Glee videos, so is not such a leap to watch some Starkid stuff. The next logical step, really. She should go full circle and react to Twisted, it's the best Starkid musical there is. It would be totally awesome.
Please do it, Hannah!!!
I came in the comments to say this as soon as she started talking about Jafar! It's very well done, I love a good StarKid musical!
The way you make me feel when you react to these makes my heart flutter. I cried during speechless it was too powerful. Love you please keep doing these
Undoubtedly, Aladdin is the most visually impressive live-action movie Disney has ever made ('cause the Lion King was so realistic that it makes me uncomfortable). Perfect cast and music performances. Stunning!
I agree with you Hannah. The colors are amazing. The ensembles are amazing. I just love Jasmines dresses so much. I just want to watch this movie again and again just to see these beautiful dresses and colors
Raise your hand if you think Cinderella was the best Disney live action remake
(On a separate note, Hannah, you look so lovely today. Your sweater is so cute!)
Yes!! It is a beautiful movie. It gives you a ‘free’ and warm feeling in some way. Lily James did amazing!
It is great, but I enjoyed The Jungle Book too.
Cinderella is definitely one of the better ones. Aladdin was my favorite out of all of them but Cinderella is definitely a close second. Her dress was gorgeous.
Cinderella is my favorite (so wholesome and sincere), but I think Jungle Book might be the best. Cinderella, Jungle Book, and Aladdin are top three. So excited for Little Mermaid and Peter Pan.
I think 101 Dalmatian’s was good too
Aladdin is hands down my favorite Disney movie and Jasmine so my favorite princess. This is my favorite live action remake so far that Disney has done.
I say this a lot with Disney movies but I love this movie. I remember seeing this in theaters when it came out the first day. Everyone in this and the people who made this movie possible are so so flipping amazingly talented. Also yes I would love to see you react to more Disney live action movies! Love the videos! You do an amazing job!
Aladdin is by far my favorite live action movie Disney has done!! It’s is incredible!!!
Can I just say how proud I am to consider myself Hannah’s student? I started watching these videos a couple of years ago and I don’t remember where I first saw her talk about tension in the neck/throat and i distinctly remember thinking back to Naomi singing speechless because I’d always thought that the tension was just a sign that the singer is putting a lot of power and emotion into it and it was Hannah who made me understand it. And as soon as I saw that she reacted to this movie I had to come back and hear what she had to say and AAAAHHHH I’m sorry for the rant lol but I just feel blessed to have been taught by Hannah 😭❤️
She actually sang speechless live which is insane
I don’t really know much about singing but I think her straining her voice adds emotion to the song
The way I IMMEDIATELY knees what book you were talking about 😂 we should go touch some grass 😂😂
This is actually one of my favorite live-action Disney movies. Cinderella takes the top slot but I really loved Maleficent and it's sequel too.
16:40 I watched this movie in theaters after it came out and the ENTIRE THEATER got second hand embarrassment from that scene. It was so embarrassing you could hear people groan from the embarrassment. 😂
I think you should definitely, if you haven't already, watch Twisted by starkids! It's my favorite rendition of Aladdin! And the voices are amazing!!!
Mena Massoud Is awesome. Now he Is playing Ezra Bridger in the Mandalorian. You know? Ezra Bridger when he was 17 in Star Wars Rebels season three was very handsome with haircut and those dark Blue eyes like Deep Sea. Rebels season three was my favorite because It was perfect for the fangirls especially the teen girls that they were obessed Ezra with haircut.
i watched this movie with my dad and my twin sister on theaters on my 14th birthday, before the pandemic we'd always watch a movie together (my dad moved to a different city because of his job and so i haven't spent that much time with him lately), it brings me back good memories!!
There’s a song/scene in the movie that got cut off called “Desert Moon”, and their harmonies are AMAZING!
When you talked about that Aladdín versión where Aladdin is the villain made me think about Starkid's Twisted: the untold story of a royal visir. Have you seen it? It's honestly the best thing ever lol awesome songs sung by super talented actors, hilarious comedy, a Ja'far backstory and character arc very Wicked inspired, you should totally check it out if you haven't!
Yessss same. Its free on starkids RUclips channel. She should so react it. Dylan's voice is God tier
It’s so impressive that Naomi was moving, acting, 𝓪𝓷𝓭 add emotion while singing speechless. It’s a very good but hard song to sing! And yet she sang it perfectly❤️❤️❤️😍
I loved this live action. I thought the main three (Mena, Naomi and Will) were so well cast. Movie was colorful and fun.
I do love Hannah’s reaction!
Please cheetah girls. Way overdueeeee
SAME! IDK WHY BUT I ALSO LOVE THE LION KING 2019
When Naomi Scott sang “Speechless” she was singing it live while filming. One of the interviews they did when the movie came out mentions it.
this was one of the live action adaptations i genuinely liked and enjoyed bc they had the flavor of the original but added their own twist especially in the music! everything was fresh and i think the budget on this was wooow. look at the outfits and all the colors and CGI! the casting was great i guess lol but especially mena as aladdin and naomi as jasmine, they were perfect! i was obsessed with mena for a whole year when this came out lmao. i love that you liked it too!
Hey Hannah. Actually Naomi Scott sang “Speechless” on set instead of using the recorded version of the song. That’s why her neck was so tense and you can also hear her running out of breath. This was something they discussed in an interview with the cast after the movie premiere
We are just moving through the live action Disney films! I have not seen this one, so I'm watching it for the first time with Ms. Hannah!
I feel like theres this shadow tint yall put on when we watch these movies when it recently comes out bc these songs SLAPS
Here in Brazil,who dubbed the voice of Alladin was a great voice actor called Daniel Garcia. The amazing thing about this is that Daniel Garcia also goes by the stage name Gloria Groove. one of the greatest drag artists in Brazil. Please Hannah, if one day you can, get to know Gloria Groove's work, you will love it!!!
If we’re talking about the Brazilian dub, I wanna give a shout out to the voice actress who dubs Jasmine, Lara Suleiman! She does a GREAT job, and her rendition of Speechless is absolutely beautiful! She also dubs Luisa in Encanto, and her voice is just so amazing and versatile! (On an unrelated note, she was also the understudy of Wednesday Addams in the last production of the Addams Family musical in São Paulo, and she killed it)
This is the difference in getting a lead actress who can SING and one who is just sort of okay. I know they didn't help Emma Watson out at all by surrounding her with Broadway caliber singers and the auto-tuning, etc, but she never could've performed like Naomi Scott. Aladdin is my favorite of the Disney live actions, partly because of that, and also because it's not word-for-word the same as the animated one. It's just different enough, they tweaked just enough things, and I think it works SO well!
In my opinion Aladdin was by far the best Disney live action, and no live action will ever be able to top it. It was just perfectly cast
Most of Speechless was not pre-recorded. I don't know the reason for that, but it may be why you see the tension she's holding - she is singing the song in that moment.
The end credit dance number, made me realize we could’ve had a Bollywood style version of the movie. They did so much for the ensemble for numbers like “Prince Ali” but cut up the footage to not show anything for very long and showed too much of just Aladdin smiling nervously
Mena and Naomi had such great chemistry throughout the entire movie. Their voices together were phenomenal
you should also watch the song taken out of Aladdin due to the movie being too long!! Its called Desert Moon. Alan Menken even did a intro for that song. Its so sweet
I believe they started the live action with an epilogue was because in the animated movie, the story began with a travelling merchant (also voiced by the amazing Robin W.) who told the story of the lamp. And the movie was supposed to end with the reveal that the merchant was the genie all along but was cut due to time constraints. They kept the idea, considering that the live action genie also became a travelling merchant in the end. If I'm not wrong, the merchant that started story in the animation made a final appearance on Aladdin and the King of Thieves when Aladdin and Jasmine had one last carpet ride around Aggrabah after their wedding.
Half of this video was Hannah full on gawking over Jasmine’s outfits and honestly WE ARE HERE FOR IT HAHAHA-
Watching your videos always brings a smile to my face. I love watching you react to things and laughing with you. Please never stop bringing joy to us. ❤️
You really should react to the extra song, Desert Moon, it's sooooo beautiful. Another duet from Jasmine and Alladin.
HANNAH!!! Thanks for the Sideways shoutout!!! He’s my favorite RUclipsr (besides you of course!) and I really appreciate you spreading his channel… he really deserves it
I really loved this movie! I’m like you and really loved the nostalgia, but I’m also so happy Jasmine got more depth to her part in this movie… and Speechless is on every playlist I have right now! I absolutely love the power it has to it! Thanks for (finally, lol!) doing Aladdin! I love how real your reactions are and your genuine excited ent with this movie! I have friends who say they hated this movie, but loved Lion King. I wasn’t a fan of LK, but absolutely LOVE this remake! Anyway, thanks for being you! ❤
I've seen a couple of comments about this, so Naomi Scott sings the first part of the second Speechless live and it goes to the studio version the moment she turns around on the first "I won't be silenced". Absolutely love the live part!!!