Chill dude. You can watch what you want. But grown ups organizing a film festival have the Freedom to choose what they want to show. And other grown ups have the Freedom to inform the festivals of what they believe is going on with this film. Freedom of speech ≠ All film festivals have to showcase all controversial films.
This is not about what you should or shouldn't see. You can see what ever you want. It was stated that this is documentary moview. This is not true. Anastasia Trofimova in her interview said that “I was not really allowed, but not really forbidden, to be in the rear. I stuck around and people slowly got used to me. They found me amusing and weird. This girl from Moscow who wanted to film them.” It is lie. It looks like russian army is a band of idiots. Who know reality know that to be able to be with russian soldiers on occupied territory you must received approve from military and FSB boses. And you must report about all you activites. It is fair to know if it is a real documentary movie or movie recordbed by FSB control. So as Ukrainian I would like to hear true from TIFF or any other ogranization - we show the FSB-movie about russian solider because it is another point of view. That is it. Instead I've read that this is a documentary movie and it is according to the "Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms for all Canadians including Canadian artists". Do you understand that "the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms for all Canadians including Canadian artists" doesn't work on occupied Ukraine territory when you make a video about russian soldiers during 7 monthes?
@@VolodymyrMy At Last A Good Comment To Say The Least But Its Moreoff The People Getting Feed Up By The Amount Hohlering Around The Conflict That Was Given To Your Side Of Nation I Think The Contrarainism Is Here Because Of That And Mostly The Racial Slur And The Aloof Internet Warriors That Had A Self Gratifying Job Since 2022
Remember this is not only a physical war but a war of censorship and propaganda and I would like to see the documentarty. I want to decide not someone else for me.
This film was made by someone who has previously made 11 documentaries for Russia Today (RT), the state controlled media organization in Russia. The filmmaker likely broke the law entering Ukraine illegally, without contacting Ukrainian authorities. The goal of this film is to try to get Western audiences to empathize with occupying soldiers. Imagine a film called "Germans at War" released during WW2 to try to get an American or Canadian audience to sympathize with the invading German soldiers, created by someone who previously had made 11 films for the propaganda ministry of Germany. It's unethical for TIFF to be screening this film.
Зашибись, это когда немцы в Америку и Канаду вторгались! Страдалицы вы наши! В СССР 27 миллионов полегло, меньше миллиона французов, ещё меньше англичан.
@@АврилЛавин-й1сскажи спасибо святому командованию мясников из твоей страны. Немцы были нападающей стороной и меньше потеряли пока «святая россия» в мясных штурмах уничтожала население всех соседних республик
Just imagine how many ukranian artists and officials worked together with Russia before. Just imagine ukrainians officials are still receiveng russian money for gas transit. lmao
It's not that you're banned from watching this movie. It's that Russia is a dictatorship, and this movie shows Russian narratives. So it's just Kremlin propaganda filmed with Canadian government money. The truth is that Russia attacked Ukraine, destroyed its cities and villages, raped women and children, and cuts off Ukrainian people heads. But you won't see any of that in the movie, of course. The Russians are good there, usual men.
Rus troll, ofcourse you can watch this rus propaganda, but it shouldn't be promoted at International Film Festivals, because it works to promote Russia's predatory
To all the seething liberals in the comments why don't you go and enlist in Ukraine's army ? If you love Ukraine so much join them, they take anyone now a days.
okay Jimmy. Because people who stand for something / a country need to go enlist in it's army to be supportive... your last two brain cells working over time i see
@@SashAlex-xk2mn So you are saying youre a coward? Whats the point of standing for something if you are not willing to sacrifice anything? Your "standing" has no influence whatsoever on the frontlines. Who gives a shit who people in the west support lol
@@SashAlex-xk2mn I don't see how a documentary which shows a lot of russian soldiers having very mixed feelings about the war and fight they are in is a bad thing...
By ignoring the Russian perspective, we may never fully understand the problem. In Canada, we often hear about Ukraine's viewpoint, but we should also listen to Russia in order to make fair judgments and comprehend the true issues at hand.
You want to fully understand it? Here you are. The "problem" is that the absolute majority of the population of Russia and many, many Russians in other countries take it for granted that the countries that once were part of the USSR must one way or another remain a zone of Russian influence. (Putin masterfully uses this trait of soul, core idea of his people.) If they do not want it willingly, if neither soft power, nor blackmail, threats, corruption help, then there is nothing else left but using military force. A lot of Russians, including the director of the film, from those against the war, strongly believe that some kind of diplomacy should resolve this "conflict" how they use to call this act of agression. Diplomatic talks with those obsessed with imperial delusions... Enough of them. (I am not Ukrainian)
@@asnatevasiljeva9220 actually they should have russian influence because russian and ukrainian people are the same race with the same historical religion. and also, loving your neighbor is a commandment of moral people. what do you think your going to get from "befriending" the west? degeneracy and thieving.
Вы хотите узнать правду о русских?!? Приезжайте в Харьков, Покровск, Мартинку, Запорожье, Херсон, Краматорск, Сумы и посмотрите их любофф к другим своими глазами
So, from what I've gathered in the comments section any country fighting a war of aggression is run by hitler, yet it's okay to make documentaries that humanize say, israelis for example, a country that is committing an actual genocide on top of a war of aggression. i guess 90% of the documentaries made regarding western troops in iraq were also made by people who love hitler? or is that different too?? just trying to understand the logic being displayed here.
The logic is why would a film be made to show the attacker's point of view, using Canadian tax dollars? Ukraine was invaded by russia and the russian soldiers are committing war crimes and indiscriminately killing, raping and torturing civilians. The russians have been documented raping a seven year-old girl before killing her, raped Ukrainian women have had their vaginas filled with window sealer so they wouldn't be able to have children, Ukrainian POWs have been castrated, beheaded and shot after surrendering. Now do you see the logic why Ukrainians are against this film?
Well if you look at Dimitri Utkin founder of the Wagner group and main initiator of this war in 2014 you might get the Hitler comparison, there's also the whole killing political opposition and being elected by an impossible margin for like basically 20 years and changing the constitution to allow him to rule even longer. Just look at the stated reasons for invading, he's defending ethnic Russians and reclaiming historic land, that is exactly what Hitler claimed when he invaded Poland with the soviets. As for Israel they did not start this current battle hamas did. Maybe you're OK with letting terrorists rape and murder but, I have very little sympathy for a people who can elect and approve of Hamas. If you think Israel is committing genocide you have no idea what genocide means. They are not targeting civilians it just so happens that hamas embeds themselves into the various refugee camps and hospitals becuase when they get bombed idiots will side with them. That was their entire plan since Oct. 7 they knew they could never win an actual war with Israel so they are trying to win a propoganda war by getting as many innocent people killed as possible. One of the hamas leaders litterally Tha ked God when multiple members of his family were killed in Gaza of course he was sitting in the safety of a mansion in Qatar while making that statement. Hamas must be defeated along with anyone who supports them any thing less is just kicking the can down the road for later.
Logic is simple. If war is going on you need high morale, motivated society and high public support of war. So you need a clear image of enemy. Such film humanizes enemy, that means that this bolsters anti-war sentiment, and people stop supporting war or war aid. In turn this way you get disadvantage and can just lose.
My respect to TIFF for showing movies that go against mainstream views! After massive backlash from Ukrainian community I now want to see this movie for myself. Anastasia is a very courageous girl!
against mainstream views？？？напуй лізти в чужу країну та нищити її, вбивати та гвалтувати населення. Показана правда? Так показана правда, про вас мocкoлoтy, про вас нелюдів, котрі забеpають життя безневинних людей, моїх співвітчизників. Захотілося документадочку глянути? Та приїзди до мене до дому, побачиш справжню документалочку і скажеш чи сподобалось дивитися? А і не тільки дивитися будеш учасницею усіх подій, якщо твої ракети тобі дозволять довше прожити.
you better watch a movie about Mariupol. When I was leaving the Muscovite occupation of my city of Melitopol, Anastasia and "Z" shot at me and my family
Please don't comment unless you actually saw the film, just as you shouldn't comment if you haven read a book, watched a play, saw a painting, etc. Just don’t. It's wrong. And weird. I'm just puzzled by the number of comments here. I don’t understand what they're based on if people writing them haven't seen the film in question, just the trailer above. It's ludicrous. Apparently, the film was taken off the program because of threats to viewers at the Toronto festival if the film were to be shown, are you real? I wouldn't have known about the movie otherwise, so I was curious why and googled it. I want to see it now and what all fuss is about!
@meemuboi True. We all live in our own information bubbles and don't even realize it. Social media algorithms show us news and information based on our previous watch history, location, and other factors. One time I taught a course in college called "Digital Media," and we did an experiment in class. I asked everyone to Google the same exact phrase, and while the majority of students got similar or the same top results, some students got complete outliers, almost opposite results. It was eye-opening. So, we should all try to step out outside our bubbles and actively seek the information and opinions that are different from our own, which we often consider to be "the truth."
Ukrainians should choose for themselves. Countries of the former Soviets bloc that have CHOSEN TO join NATO are thanking heaven they had considering Russia's current push to reclaim their lost empire.
@@Scriptadiaboly It's a very weird type of propaganda that starts with the soldiers saying: "We're being sent in like blind kittens." Say it as it is - you're afraid that people might start seeing Russian soldiers as people, despite all your efforts to portray them as monsters.
@@РФ-БОМБИТ-КУРСК-не-молчите ,.ne bredi zidva srana , NIKTO I NE VTORGALSE NA KURSKU OBLAST , kak i na ukrainu !!!! VSE ETO VASI TELEVIZIONI FEIKI I OBMANUHI , KAK I NA ISRAELU I SIRII !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Eto vse zidovi lepet feik na obman i obratno . NIKAKOVE NATURALNE VOINE I PROTIVOSTOJANIA MEZD UKRAINSKIM I RUSKIM N E T , i nikagda ne bilo na terenu . ZIDOVSKA NEUROSETNA MATRUSCHKA RABOTAET POLNIM PAROM KAK BI RAZVEZALA SAMU NASTOISCHU VOINU-GRAZDANKU , no u ih i poslke deset polnih let NIHERA NICEVO NE POLUCAETSE !!!!!!!!!! , dumaite pacemu eto tak .
Seems to be a trend in Canada lately. Justin Castro banned all news on Facebook through a monetary guise. ( truth is people were taking a dump on him for his shitty policies and it rubbed him the wrong way ) Same with Montreal's mayoress whos anti-car tactics have made her very unpopular online, hence no more commenting on her page. She also doesent want you to reference her by name "Valerie plante" its o.k. we have renamed her valerie "plate" which translates to Valerie "boring". The sad thing if you go far enough to the right or left on the political spectrum, you wind up in the same shitty censored political jail.
They're just crazy. What truth? That any war brings grief, blood, and dirt. Isn't that the truth? This movie isn't about blaming individuals or separate peoples/countries. It's about showing the situation from the inside. They're trying to depict the consequences of war... the behavior of most people and soldiers. Most of them, of course, are simply misguided (after all, going to war is always a foolish idea, especially when the children of elites are not involved). But still, it's interesting to understand what drives them and what their opinions are.
Hi, man. I live in Russia. In our country, people are imprisoned for their opinions for 8-10 years in a maximum security prison colony. Tell me, how in Israel or the US, people are imprisoned for such terms for their opinions?)
@@chuvak_s_troi Я интересовался. Меня пару раз набутылили и усё. Коллективную ответственность не отрицаю, но это уже культурные особенности. Русские всегда были терпилами, поэтому такой народ легко разделить и властвовать над ним.
Интересная реакция. Люди, по сути, поделились на 2 лагеря: Те, кто горячо желает запретить показ этого фильма и люди, которые хотят самостоятельно принять решение о его просмотре или отказаться от просмотра. Это ведь касается не только этого фильма. В нынешнем мире абсолютно вся информация подвергается цензуре. Те, кто это делает, держат людей за безмозглое стадо, которому нужно объяснять что правильно, а что нет. И мы зовёмся потомками своих предков... Стыд и позор.
Я могу сказать 100% это нужно запрещать, я был на показе, в фильме не показали вагнеровцев, загран отряды, штурмовиков, не показали как проходит обучение с 1 м патроном, даже боллее того в фильме есть парень который сьездил на войну в топовой экипировке, а потом вернулся домой как ни в чем не бывало, как будто просто в командировке был заработал денежища и вернулся довольный. Фильм пропаганда
I want to see this film. Based on the trailer this doc shows the Russian soldiers as human. And they are. Just like the German soldiers of WW II were human. This doc doesn't seem to be about justifying the invasion or glorifying the Russian soldiers. But if it is I, at least, am intelligent enough to see through that. And yes a scared Russian conscript who has no idea WTF he's doing in the Ukraine can be a victim. And also a criminal.
@@ruderuderu я вру?! Окей, давай пруфы) Сколько судебных дел было по поводу отказа? Сколько людей в бусик упаковали? Сколько людей посадили и на сколько лет? Покажи где митинги были и сколько там приняли участия? Ну кто там из нас врёт)?
I am from Ukraine. This film is about people, who was told to kill us, and so they do everyday. If you want to know our story, watch "20 days in Mariupol", "The Hardest Hour / Dovha Doba" and many other films.
Ukraine is not a real country. You have no culture and are merely used by the West to weaken Russia. "Ukraine" has been the most corrupt nation on Earth. Nothing more than a money laundering tool
War is terrible for everyone. Governments both force people to go. No one needs war, and its only death and destruction. Ukrainians and Russians should both sign a peace, unfortunately, they will keep sending men to their death like the First World War. Russian soldiers and Ukrainian soldiers, all the soldiers, are victims in the trenches.
I am NOT pro-Russia. But I do want to take a moment to play devil’s advocate: The filmographer did at least leave RT, and left Russia. And she at least got the perspectives of soldiers saying they don’t know if what they’re doing is “right” or not. That is interesting - and not overtly biased - to me and I wish they didn’t cancel this film at the Toronto film festival.
she joined RT around or after 2014 - after the annexation of Crimea, when some journalists like Abby Martin, who worked for RT before 2014, decided to cut ties with this establishment, specifically over disinformation spread by RT. Interesting choice for a person, who had an opportunity to work in Canada.
@@olq5689 Has nothing to do with elephants, so its completely irrelephant. The real question is was the documentary cut & put together in Canada after the fact In which case she could say whatever she wanted, and the Kremlin would have little influence.
If you believe her telling that Russia only wants peace, then watch video "Russian artillery pounds Grozny, Chechnya". Before Ukraine there were Russia's wars with Moldova, Chechnya, Georgia, Syria...
Как режиссер могла снимать фильм без ведома власти, там, где мышь не проскочит? Там за такую деятельность по сути, после выхода фильма должны были наказать всех участников этого фильма. Но такого по сути быть не может! Армия это прежде всего дисциплина!!! Это же не ополченцы. А тут неизвестная мадам приезжает, Привет вам, я из Канады!!! Хочу вас снимать! И все такие! О! Круто! Мы будем знаменитыми! Да, они бы такое не допустили, потому что любой солдат знает, что ему за такое потом по шапке надают! Без согласования в ГОСУДАРСТВЕННОЙ АРМИИ это просто НЕВОЗМОЖНО!
Угараешь? На фронте бардак так или иначе, при должной сноровке по факту езди кто хочешь и снимай что хочешь, если командиры/военные на местах пизды не выпишут конечно
Именно об этом я в первую очередь подумала. Просто смешно это "в тайне от министерства обороны". Ещё бы Путина туда вставила и написала, что он не в курсе.
She's a smart woman who makes her choice - driven by her own ambitions. She knew perfectly well that RT (including RT Documentary) is a weapon of Russian propaganda while she was working for them before that war. But she made her choice anyway - driven by her own ambitions. I know women who work for RT. They all have one thing in common: they can be meditation teachers, motivational speakers, pacifists... but in the end, it's all about their own ambitions - not the truth. I don't think Anastasia has changed since her days at RT. This film is also about her own ambitions - not the truth. Well, she is fulfilling them, cause this propaganda film is being show in Toronto after having been shown in Venice.
I don't give a shit who Trofimova worked for. Even better, everyone at once. She made a unique, awesome documentary film, it required amazing, inhuman courage from her not only to sit under bombs with cameras, but also to demolish this avalanche of shit. She is a real artist, a real passionate professional to the point of madness. I hope she doesn't give a shit about you all, Putin, Dustin Trudeau and others. She longed to create something outstanding in her life's work and she created it despite everything. I express my true, endless admiration.
Лени Рифеншталь тоже было плевать на всех когда она снимала свои пропагандистские шедевры. Уверен, если бы её попросили снимать работу немецких айнзацкоманд в Восточной Европе, то она бы сняла потрясающий документальный фильм про геноцид местного населения. Зато потом были несколько процедур денацификации и курс лечения в психиатрической клинике. Кстати в рецензии на мемуары Лени изданные в 1987 г. было написано «Ей до сих пор удалось остаться в неведении о том, о чём она не хотела знать»
Were she to fund it herself or by RT things would be okay. Of course you can make anything you want. Your expression is yours but this was illegally funded by Canadian tax payers. This is a spit in the face of free expression. It's clear and obvious propaganda meant for western eyes.
@@Com-bc6jl This is the problem of Canadian taxpayers, if it is a problem at all. Trofimova is a good girl. She found the money, she found the opportunity, she found the strength and courage in herself, and she used her talent to do her job in the best possible way. For this she deserves honor and glory. Among Canadian taxpayers there are all sorts of people, and there are plenty of fools, too. She is not easy to please, and there is no need.
@@Com-bc6jl While you and I were chewing pasta and selling insurance, or whatever you sell, Trofimova spent months under bombs filming a movie for me and people like me. I'm glad that people like Trofimova still exist.
@evgenynikhaev5104 Using sympathy as a tool to soften the blow of failure in their war for domination is pathetic and vile at the same time. What slime steals tax payer money to push clear propaganda back at them. This is a spit in the face to our way of life. Freedom of expression dragged through the mud, digested and vomited by people that do not care for such things. She's a thieve and a worm. Yea go watch it. Watch the worming and listen to pig squeals.
The girl at the end of the video said: It's easy to start a war, but to end it, you try to do it, it's very hard Russian Russian soldiers, I always admire the way they fight for their country, because the whole Russian people promised their grandfathers no time to give up, so they will always succeed.
For all those on their "freedom of expression" high horse - i hear you. The view must be very nice from there. Nicer than in a bomb shelter or at a funeral of your loved ones killed by Trofimova's "ordinary guys with a sense of humor". Clearly, we are a society not easily offended by a "different point of view". Unlike Germany where Nazi salute is banned. Such censorship! But by all means, watch what you like. I only hope you consider watching "20 Days in Mariupol" as your double feature.
Слава Богу, что нашёлся хоть один человек, сумевший показать, что российские солдаты тоже в первую очередь нормальные люди, со своими страхами, чаяниями и надеждами. Спасибо Анастасии за это! Почитал комментрарии украинцев... Люди, мне стыдно за вас. В вас не осталось ничего человеческого! Только ненависть ко всему российскому. Мне вас искренне жаль.
@@svpiter78 Ответьте себе на вопрос: что русские солдатьі забьіли в суверенной стране? Вьі искренне не понимаете за 2 года войньі за что вас ненавидят? Отрицание раельности - єто так характеризует россиян
@@natalieivanova3011 у меня родственники со стороны жены (двоюродный брат и тётка) проживают в Полтавской области, так что я в курсе происходящего. А жена моя - гражданка Украины. Так что меня пугать не надо
Yea most of russian army is contract soldiers, conscripts are a tiny minority. Even conscripts will only go to jail if they refuse, it's not like north korea or anything where they k*ll all your family for disobeying. So really, 100% of russian army are volunteers.
@@abodabalo Easy to say from a safe sofa at home. I doubt war crimes come as a calculated strategic decision. The videos I see on this channel just show pure panic on all sides and an extreme level of stress. Calculating that those soldiers did never belong to the more intelligent men of their peers, I think war crimes come out of a total panic, extreme anger over fallen comrades and death scare. It is a traumatic experience for all involved, which leads to a complete rund down of critical thinking skills and intelligence in itself. I dare to ask, it is worth it for any of them? And those who were drafted definitely had no choice to decline.
some of russian soldiers are taken there by force, cause if they resist they would be sent to jail. contracted soldiers, which were the majority of the fighters cannot leave the war anymore. it is russian law. some of soldiers struggling to leave home from the war are sent by their officers to kind of underground jails ("podval") on the occupied territory, till they change their mind. you could read such a media like Meduza and Novaya Gazeta there you can get more information what is happening. these medias are already forbidden in russia
Die Soldaten, die eingezogen wurden haben in der tat eine Entscheidungsgewalt, 4 Jahre Knast (auch wenn das russische Gefängnis ziemlich hart ist) ist moralisch besser als ein Land zu überfallen, dessen Zivilbevölkerung zu bombardieren und alles was "befreit wird" in Schutt und Asche zu legen. Außerdem ist es auch besser für die Gesundheit, wenn man sich die Statistiken anschaut wie viele unbeschadet von der Front kommen. Ich denke nicht das die ständige Bombardierung ziviler Ziele in ukrainischen Stäten aus Angst und Frust passiert, es ist ein Mittel um die Bevölkerung zu terrorisieren und Kriegsmüde zu machen.
«Wo got into a fight in Ukraine, but I don't I'm right» Why do 100% of the hate comments miss these words from the movie? Although I understand, the position “there are only orcs there” is much more pleasant. It is very easy to live in a black and white world, although in fact there are hundreds of other shades in the world
@@901blitz you are not the one of these ignorant persons, right? So, what do you find good in agressive war against peaceful brotherhood neighbour country?
Война это грязно и холодно Война это когда уже на все тебе по барабану За 3 года войны понял одну простую истину - стравливали и вооружали людей НЕдолюди, которые в закулисье жмут друг другу руки Но стадо дальше блеет про какую то славу странам, которые кидают их на мясо. Мы заслуживаем то что сейчас происходит
humanity should always be considered superior to nationality, I totally understand and support a film festival selected this film for screening, because that's the reason why we need a film festival: let the different voice to be heard so that the point of view might be shaked. It might be difficult to create a world of equality in reality, but in the world of film, we should strive to treat all beings as equals.
When filmmakers make documentaries from the Russian side, they are propagandistic. When others make documentaries from the Ukrainian side, they are heroes.
I never heard of this film until i saw that it was cancelled at TIFF. Now i want to watch it. Censorship does the opposite of its intentions always. Blessings to my Orthodox brothers, both Ukrainians and Russians ☦️
It's not that you're banned from watching this movie. It's that Russia is a dictatorship, and this movie shows Russian narratives. So it's just Kremlin propaganda filmed with Canadian government money. The truth is that Russia attacked Ukraine, destroyed its cities and villages, raped women and children, and cuts off Ukrainian people heads. But you won't see any of that in the movie, of course. The Russians are good there, usual men.
@@SashAlex-xk2mn If you can't sympothize with people who are tricked into going to war with propaganda, then you must not be American. Americans citizens have been tricked into going to war for "Freedom" since 1955... Not 1 single time has American freedom been threatened.
@@agentbuckwheat tricked? lol hwat, were they tricked in russian empire, ussr too? These are men from country on the border, country where half of those idiots have relatives from Ukraine. They are not tricked, they do not care. Grow up
В Токмаке (Запорожская область) российские солдаты застрелили на улице местного жителя, у которого в руках бал телефон. Солдатам показалось, что он снимает на камеру место расположения военных. Человек ничего не снимал, погорячились русские солдатики, ошибочка вышла. А Трофимова рассказывает сказочку о том, что она несколько месяцев без разрешения российских властей вела съёмки в расположении действующих российских войск.
Like i read in some review: "We see how the Russians die, but not how they kill". If they want to show the entire story, maybe they should include the truth about them being occupiers and killers, and also humans. Because yes, all killers are also humans but for some reason this film doesn't show it
I'm an anti-war Russian and I can't believe my eyes 😢 It would be appropriate as a news story (to inform people about conditions and moral of the ennemy), but not as a documentary at a festival.
Finally someone asking the real question! Looks like a great film. Seems like a lot of russian soldiers have doubts about the war. Bringing this to light will only help the war end.
@@agentbuckwheat ты дурак если так думаешь. У нас сомнения только в братоубийственной войне, но в с самой войне сомнений нет. Она не избежна. Америка и Европа привели к этому.
It's not that you're banned from watching this movie. It's that Russia is a dictatorship, and this movie shows Russian narratives. So it's just Kremlin propaganda filmed with Canadian government money. The truth is that Russia attacked Ukraine, destroyed its cities and villages, raped women and children, and cuts off Ukrainian people heads. But you won't see any of that in the movie, of course. The Russians are good there, usual men.
Why? Are you afraid that someone can't make up their own mind? Do you have such contempt for your fellow people that you wish to smother them in censorship? What a weak sentiment... All that this shows is the humanity and horror of war. That is a story that is good to tell, so that we understand how important peace is.
@@nicky640 Well, let’s start by saying that they are not my fellow people. Fortunately, the murderers and I are not of the same blood. And what does censorship have to do with it? She spoke out in defense of the aggressor, it is her right, but our right is to ask the international community not to broadcast this on platforms like international festivals when these "unfortunate murderers" bomb Ukraine every day and night. When they destroy life itself in a free country that was not lucky enough to be a neighbor of maniacs. This film is not against war, it calls for the justification of murderers. And this is not a condemnation of war at all. This is not an anti-war film, no matter how you turn it. Asking for sympathy for the rapist, and not for the victim, is not quite the same as asking for justice, is it?
@@LaJons I had written a well-meant reply but it's completely deleted. That's what all this censorship does: stop dialogue. I suppose you're happy that I can't have a real conversation with you, since you support censorship too. If you don't, then you should also rethink your stance.
Watching this movie after hearing the news about a Ukranian child who had her head blown off by Russian missiles hits different. Russia can be many things but it will NEVER be the victim of this situation.
As in, it would never have children killed by foreign force or by missiles? I'm pretty sure 1st child (4-years-old) was killed by Ukrainian's missile way back on December 30th 2023, in Belgorod. Or did you only meant it in terms of Agressor and Victim? Yeah, those roles couldn't be swept no matter how many more civilians would be killed or displaced, now on both sides and by both sides. Russia (my country) as an agressor, obviously. I'm kinda curious to actually watch the film that every side critique, but very few saw. From the reviews it seems, that edges were smoothed (intentionally or not idk) on the different issue that many abroad have no clue about: mobilization and sending massive amount of prisoners on the frontlines. On the other hand, I'm glad that main hero is Ukrainian (I'm not talking about Ukrainians born in Russia, obviously), cause dear lord there are a ton of them here right now (regions on the border). Every time I see their cars with states numbers of LNR or DNR, I wonder, why would I willingly (I'm not talking about those who were forced to "evacuate" from let's say Mariupol) move to live in the country that annexed or occupied part of my country of origin. And why so many of them such ardent Fuhrer lovers when they weren't under Kremlin propaganda for majority of their lives. It's so bizarre.
Городской бой общевойсковой армии - это не терроризм, а - городской бой общевойсковой армии. Kомбатантам и не комбатантам может оторвать голову или руку снарядом. Это война, blead. Легальный способ избежать жертв - мэрия объявляет город открытым, обороняющий город гарнизон складывает оружие. Вот - серьезный разговор. А плач за мертвую девочку - это разговоры в пользу бедных, эмоциональная демагогия на фоне военных действий.
@@Juraweg1987 в каком-то смысле верно, но это скорее относится к ситуации, когда войска физически находятся в городе или рядом с ним. А в ситуации обстрелов и налетов дронов как быть? Половина городов Украины и города 2х областей России должны быть эвакуированы по этой логике. Но это же ведь нереально. Большой парадокс этой войны, помимо целости газовой инфраструктуры (а значит обе стороны умеют бить прицельно, когда захотят), это относительно, пока (и проверенных на данный момент), низкое число смертей среди мирного населения. Безумия происходящего это не отменяет. Да и родственников эти цифры не утешут.
I haven't seen the film, so there's little I can say about what it really shows. But I've read it's about the war seen from the perspective of soldiers who are unaware of being manipulated by their leaders. Which is basically what happened in every war in history, and still happens. There are no winners or heroes in wars. Everyone is a victim of evil, superior plans in the end. But once again, I haven't seen this movie.
Комментарии насыщены носителями "Единственной правды", "американскими освободителями". Автор молодец, надеюсь эта документальная работа покажет истинное лицо войны от которой безуспешно нас пытались уберечь наши деды и отцы, потому что именно благодаря американской политике вмешательства во внутренние дела других государств исключительно в целях своей выгоды сегодня наши братья убивают друг друга без особой на то исключительной причины.
If this shakes your support for ukraine then youre a fickle supporter. This looks brilliant. Im not at war with the russian people and i wanna know just wtf they think theybare fighting for cause i cant understand it. Ill deffo be watching
Then watch Intercepted for an example of russian mindset in this context?🤷♀️ Why would you want to watch a movie from the confirmed russian propagandist to find out what russians think or say about this war?
Two quotes from a film's director: 1) "I saw no signs of war crimes during my time near the front with russian soldiers". 2) [The highest russian brigade commander] ordered that I be given a military uniform - "so that my own people don't accidently shoot me". This is a fasc slop for people with temperature IQ.
To be fair, we don't want the Ukrainian military to accidentally confuse her for an actual journalist. I think all Russian propagandists should be issued military uniforms. It shoes their true allegiance.
I have bene wondering for a while whether there will even be someone brave enough to present us with the less “popular” side’s account of the war. Thank you for making this happen. There is nothing that can justify the atrocities happening in Ukraine right now but the only way to overcome the big issue is to change the mindset or ordinary Russians on the war. And you can't do that without giving them a chance to speak.
It's 1943, a German journalist travels to occupied France to show how "unwilling" SS soldiers are truly suffering, not the civilians, to the British and American audiences. The movie is titled "Germans at War"
You have newer been our brothers, and you will never be. Every tear of Ukrainian children’s and women’s on your hands. We will never forgive you, remember that.
I'm grateful that our Canadian tax dollars support films like this, which tell the story of humanity. By cancelling this film, however, TIFF’s current leadership has seriously undermined their integrity and professionalism. If you're unable to uphold the values of freedom of expression, then the least you can do is to step down. Shame on you!
Выложите его на ютубе, большую аудиторию захватите! И ненадо будет с этими дебильными запретами сталкиватся!! Док.фильм и так противятся. А почему??? Наверное боятся что правду там увидеть можно!!! Удачи. Я жил на донбассе до 1997, теперь в германии, но много родствеников еще по всей украине!
After having spent last week under heavy missile strikes with no electricity and internet for hours, having my hometown heavily damaged by “russians at war”, I’m furious that you let them take the center stage and speak for themselves
Бедолага, это для фильма взяли пару человек, которые чего-то там не знают и не понимают. Большая часть все понимает и знает, что русские на стороне правды и справедливости. Вы просто сдохнете, а мы попадем в рай
The guy in the film: " In the fight, I need to feel that I am right. Here I am not right" Proceeds to kill civilians and destroy the neighboring nation. Every Russian soldier in a nutshell.
![[DRAGON BALL LEGENDS REVEALS ＆ STUFF] LEGENDS FESTIVAL 2024 Special Edition Part 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mV5bGIswTtQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I love it when an angry mob decides for me what I should or shouldn’t see, instead of me being able to see it and make up my own mind. This is the way
This Is Not A Model Citizen
A Model Citzen Must Follow Its Betters
Chill dude. You can watch what you want.
But grown ups organizing a film festival have the Freedom to choose what they want to show. And other grown ups have the Freedom to inform the festivals of what they believe is going on with this film.
Freedom of speech ≠ All film festivals have to showcase all controversial films.
yes also the "moral authority" ukrainians were threatening TIFF allegedly. what a honorable bunch !
This is not about what you should or shouldn't see. You can see what ever you want. It was stated that this is documentary moview. This is not true.
Anastasia Trofimova in her interview said that “I was not really allowed, but not really forbidden, to be in the rear. I stuck around and people slowly got used to me. They found me amusing and weird. This girl from Moscow who wanted to film them.”
It is lie. It looks like russian army is a band of idiots. Who know reality know that to be able to be with russian soldiers on occupied territory you must received approve from military and FSB boses. And you must report about all you activites.
It is fair to know if it is a real documentary movie or movie recordbed by FSB control.
So as Ukrainian I would like to hear true from TIFF or any other ogranization - we show the FSB-movie about russian solider because it is another point of view. That is it.
Instead I've read that this is a documentary movie and it is according to the "Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms for all Canadians including Canadian artists".
Do you understand that "the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms for all Canadians including Canadian artists" doesn't work on occupied Ukraine territory when you make a video about russian soldiers during 7 monthes?
@@VolodymyrMy At Last A Good Comment To Say The Least
But Its Moreoff The People Getting Feed Up By The Amount Hohlering Around The Conflict That Was Given To Your Side Of Nation
I Think The Contrarainism Is Here Because Of That And Mostly The Racial Slur And The Aloof Internet Warriors That Had A Self Gratifying Job Since 2022
The more they are pushing against this movie , the more I am motivated and inspired to watch it . And I will find the way ❤
Yeah I don't like how people in the comments are behaving like wild animals. Its a documentary, not a pro russia propaganda film.
Remember this is not only a physical war but a war of censorship and propaganda and I would like to see the documentarty. I want to decide not someone else for me.
@@joeproton2469 🖐️💯👍❤️🤗👍👍💯💯👍👍💯🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️
@agentbuckwheat this movie made by RT (russia today) which spreads precisely Russian propaganda and recognized as Rus intelligence
@larisamarks4236 another russian BOT from RT farms
This film was made by someone who has previously made 11 documentaries for Russia Today (RT), the state controlled media organization in Russia. The filmmaker likely broke the law entering Ukraine illegally, without contacting Ukrainian authorities. The goal of this film is to try to get Western audiences to empathize with occupying soldiers.
Imagine a film called "Germans at War" released during WW2 to try to get an American or Canadian audience to sympathize with the invading German soldiers, created by someone who previously had made 11 films for the propaganda ministry of Germany.
It's unethical for TIFF to be screening this film.
ZZZZZ ГОЙДА ГОООООООООЛ ZZZZZVVVVVZZZZZ СЛАВА РОССИИ!!!!
Зашибись, это когда немцы в Америку и Канаду вторгались! Страдалицы вы наши! В СССР 27 миллионов полегло, меньше миллиона французов, ещё меньше англичан.
@@АврилЛавин-й1сскажи спасибо святому командованию мясников из твоей страны. Немцы были нападающей стороной и меньше потеряли пока «святая россия» в мясных штурмах уничтожала население всех соседних республик
Just imagine how many ukranian artists and officials worked together with Russia before. Just imagine ukrainians officials are still receiveng russian money for gas transit. lmao
Japaneese at war?
The censorship makes me want to watch this even more.
@@someguy7897 exactly.
It's not that you're banned from watching this movie. It's that Russia is a dictatorship, and this movie shows Russian narratives. So it's just Kremlin propaganda filmed with Canadian government money. The truth is that Russia attacked Ukraine, destroyed its cities and villages, raped women and children, and cuts off Ukrainian people heads. But you won't see any of that in the movie, of course. The Russians are good there, usual men.
You can always visit Russia and see all with your own eyes, propaganda lover
Rus troll, ofcourse you can watch this rus propaganda, but it shouldn't be promoted at International Film Festivals, because it works to promote Russia's predatory
Its terrific, if you are a natsee :)
OK now I wanna watch this, given how hard all these ppl are trying to censor it.
I would probably pay attention to this documentary, Thank you TTIF
how many of those "innocent" soldiers carved up really innocent men and women like dogs when they invaded Ukraine?
You will not see anything new. The usual ''poor Russians are having it hard while invading their neighbors'' narrative.
@@danielj1642clown
These ppl 🤡 first watch some goebbels propaganda movies, to be prepared
Say no to censorship. Freedom of expression.
Say no to propaganda.
Do you like to see nazi films?
yep. yuck fou! this is my expression! no censorship 😂
@@misterenic ofcourse
@@spkz0rwho gets to decide what is deemed “propaganda”?
To all the seething liberals in the comments why don't you go and enlist in Ukraine's army ? If you love Ukraine so much join them, they take anyone now a days.
okay Jimmy. Because people who stand for something / a country need to go enlist in it's army to be supportive... your last two brain cells working over time i see
@@SashAlex-xk2mn So you are saying youre a coward? Whats the point of standing for something if you are not willing to sacrifice anything? Your "standing" has no influence whatsoever on the frontlines. Who gives a shit who people in the west support lol
Ukraine doesn't want untrained Americans who don't speak Ukranian. They do want American money and gear though.
@@SashAlex-xk2mn I don't see how a documentary which shows a lot of russian soldiers having very mixed feelings about the war and fight they are in is a bad thing...
There is nothing wrong with someone documenting the war. People are so crazy man.
By ignoring the Russian perspective, we may never fully understand the problem. In Canada, we often hear about Ukraine's viewpoint, but we should also listen to Russia in order to make fair judgments and comprehend the true issues at hand.
In Russia they want you to die.
Enjoy the truth.
You want to fully understand it? Here you are. The "problem" is that the absolute majority of the population of Russia and many, many Russians in other countries take it for granted that the countries that once were part of the USSR must one way or another remain a zone of Russian influence. (Putin masterfully uses this trait of soul, core idea of his people.) If they do not want it willingly, if neither soft power, nor blackmail, threats, corruption help, then there is nothing else left but using military force. A lot of Russians, including the director of the film, from those against the war, strongly believe that some kind of diplomacy should resolve this "conflict" how they use to call this act of agression. Diplomatic talks with those obsessed with imperial delusions... Enough of them.
(I am not Ukrainian)
Never mind what the Russian army has done in Ukraine. Just search for 'Russian artillery pounds Grozny, Chechnya'.
First you wish comprehesion, than you want peace, at last you lose some valuable land, resources and political weight!
@@asnatevasiljeva9220 actually they should have russian influence because russian and ukrainian people are the same race with the same historical religion. and also, loving your neighbor is a commandment of moral people. what do you think your going to get from "befriending" the west? degeneracy and thieving.
Вы хотите узнать правду о русских?!? Приезжайте в Харьков, Покровск, Мартинку, Запорожье, Херсон, Краматорск, Сумы и посмотрите их любофф к другим своими глазами
ZZZZZ ГОЙДА ГОООООООООЛ ZZZZZVVVVVZZZZZ СЛАВА РОССИИ!!!!
Кто Чонгар разминировал???????
@@Алёнаткач-е2ъ Змей горьіньіч.
Кто строил?
@@чезвалсларк-з6д Don't you feel stupid writing this?
So, from what I've gathered in the comments section any country fighting a war of aggression is run by hitler, yet it's okay to make documentaries that humanize say, israelis for example, a country that is committing an actual genocide on top of a war of aggression. i guess 90% of the documentaries made regarding western troops in iraq were also made by people who love hitler? or is that different too?? just trying to understand the logic being displayed here.
The logic is why would a film be made to show the attacker's point of view, using Canadian tax dollars? Ukraine was invaded by russia and the russian soldiers are committing war crimes and indiscriminately killing, raping and torturing civilians. The russians have been documented raping a seven year-old girl before killing her, raped Ukrainian women have had their vaginas filled with window sealer so they wouldn't be able to have children, Ukrainian POWs have been castrated, beheaded and shot after surrendering. Now do you see the logic why Ukrainians are against this film?
Ummm, isreal was attacked and 1200 people killed in an afternoon. They have every right to go after Palestine.
Well if you look at Dimitri Utkin founder of the Wagner group and main initiator of this war in 2014 you might get the Hitler comparison, there's also the whole killing political opposition and being elected by an impossible margin for like basically 20 years and changing the constitution to allow him to rule even longer.
Just look at the stated reasons for invading, he's defending ethnic Russians and reclaiming historic land, that is exactly what Hitler claimed when he invaded Poland with the soviets.
As for Israel they did not start this current battle hamas did. Maybe you're OK with letting terrorists rape and murder but, I have very little sympathy for a people who can elect and approve of Hamas. If you think Israel is committing genocide you have no idea what genocide means. They are not targeting civilians it just so happens that hamas embeds themselves into the various refugee camps and hospitals becuase when they get bombed idiots will side with them. That was their entire plan since Oct. 7 they knew they could never win an actual war with Israel so they are trying to win a propoganda war by getting as many innocent people killed as possible. One of the hamas leaders litterally Tha ked God when multiple members of his family were killed in Gaza of course he was sitting in the safety of a mansion in Qatar while making that statement. Hamas must be defeated along with anyone who supports them any thing less is just kicking the can down the road for later.
У этих лицемеров нет логики
Logic is simple. If war is going on you need high morale, motivated society and high public support of war. So you need a clear image of enemy. Such film humanizes enemy, that means that this bolsters anti-war sentiment, and people stop supporting war or war aid. In turn this way you get disadvantage and can just lose.
How can I watch this? I'd love to see other perspectives.
in the hell
russian bot ahh comment
u mad? don't make victims from the invaders
@@ivanarchivdaldoguzman7059ukrainan bot responding
@@jakubniechoda6758 all of them are victims of war. You shall just realise it.
Interesting how comments section got flooded by oddly similarly-minded individuals.
NAFOs
WHERE CAN I WATCH THIS?! I WANT TO SEE IT FROM THE OTHER SIDE!!!
Any Russian telegram channel
@@Игорьсуздальский который из?
@@user05878 крупнокалиберный переполох
@@Игорьсуздальскийтам нет
I need with English aubs@@Игорьсуздальский
My respect to TIFF for showing movies that go against mainstream views! After massive backlash from Ukrainian community I now want to see this movie for myself. Anastasia is a very courageous girl!
Respect for publishing a foreign powers propaganda piece?
You are actually stupid.
against mainstream views？？？напуй лізти в чужу країну та нищити її, вбивати та гвалтувати населення. Показана правда? Так показана правда, про вас мocкoлoтy, про вас нелюдів, котрі забеpають життя безневинних людей, моїх співвітчизників. Захотілося документадочку глянути? Та приїзди до мене до дому, побачиш справжню документалочку і скажеш чи сподобалось дивитися? А і не тільки дивитися будеш учасницею усіх подій, якщо твої ракети тобі дозволять довше прожити.
Do you also watch RT?
Illiona - be edgy - check out the Russian movie "Grus 200" by Balabanov. In English it's Cargo 200.Its free on RUclips. Thank me later.
you better watch a movie about Mariupol. When I was leaving the Muscovite occupation of my city of Melitopol, Anastasia and "Z" shot at me and my family
I am going to watch this tomorrow. Fact that so many tools wanted to censorship this motivated me to go and see it even more.
Please don't comment unless you actually saw the film, just as you shouldn't comment if you haven read a book, watched a play, saw a painting, etc. Just don’t. It's wrong.
And weird. I'm just puzzled by the number of comments here. I don’t understand what they're based on if people writing them haven't seen the film in question, just the trailer above. It's ludicrous.
Apparently, the film was taken off the program because of threats to viewers at the Toronto festival if the film were to be shown, are you real? I wouldn't have known about the movie otherwise, so I was curious why and googled it. I want to see it now and what all fuss is about!
People calling this film propaganda don't realise they watch propaganda from their own side ALL the time...
@meemuboi True. We all live in our own information bubbles and don't even realize it. Social media algorithms show us news and information based on our previous watch history, location, and other factors. One time I taught a course in college called "Digital Media," and we did an experiment in class. I asked everyone to Google the same exact phrase, and while the majority of students got similar or the same top results, some students got complete outliers, almost opposite results. It was eye-opening. So, we should all try to step out outside our bubbles and actively seek the information and opinions that are different from our own, which we often consider to be "the truth."
Putin for the last 22 years: “Niet means niet. No NATO in Ukraine.”
Ukrainians should choose for themselves.
Countries of the former Soviets bloc that have CHOSEN TO join NATO are thanking heaven they had considering Russia's current push to reclaim their lost empire.
Putin can jump but he is not the boss over other country's
honestly this is interesting, i like to see both side view of the war, i dont get all the censorship.
Irrespective of your opinion, this needs to be available for everyone to watch.
Why russian propaganda should be available for everyone to watch?
@@Scriptadiaboly Who is to say what is and isn't propaganda?! These are soldier not actor.
@@Scriptadiaboly It's a very weird type of propaganda that starts with the soldiers saying: "We're being sent in like blind kittens." Say it as it is - you're afraid that people might start seeing Russian soldiers as people, despite all your efforts to portray them as monsters.
To understand history, you must hear both sides. Its a shame this film got banned. where can i watch this?
Are you interested in knowing the history of the third reich? why did it invade europe?
@@РФ-БОМБИТ-КУРСК-не-молчите
,.ne bredi zidva srana , NIKTO I NE VTORGALSE NA KURSKU OBLAST ,
kak i na ukrainu !!!!
VSE ETO VASI TELEVIZIONI FEIKI I OBMANUHI , KAK I NA ISRAELU I SIRII !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Eto vse zidovi lepet feik na obman i obratno .
NIKAKOVE NATURALNE VOINE I PROTIVOSTOJANIA MEZD UKRAINSKIM I RUSKIM N E T , i nikagda ne bilo na terenu .
ZIDOVSKA NEUROSETNA MATRUSCHKA RABOTAET POLNIM PAROM KAK BI RAZVEZALA SAMU NASTOISCHU VOINU-GRAZDANKU ,
no u ih i poslke deset polnih let NIHERA NICEVO NE POLUCAETSE !!!!!!!!!!
, dumaite pacemu eto tak .
So, audience not adult enough to make their own decisions. Censorship and threats are the way?
Seems to be a trend in Canada lately. Justin Castro banned all news on Facebook through a monetary guise. ( truth is people were taking a dump on him for his shitty policies and it rubbed him the wrong way ) Same with Montreal's mayoress whos anti-car tactics have made her very unpopular online, hence no more commenting on her page. She also doesent want you to reference her by name "Valerie plante" its o.k. we have renamed her valerie "plate" which translates to Valerie "boring". The sad thing if you go far enough to the right or left on the political spectrum, you wind up in the same shitty censored political jail.
Censorship and threats are the russian way
@@Jb11245 except the opposite is true.
сучасна аудіторія досить тупа, то так. А скажіть, чому нема на фестивалях фільмів про канібалізм чи наругу над дітьми? Ми ж за свободу?
@@chuvak_s_troiпродолжай продавать свою страну западу мололец поросёнок.🤣
Тот кто призывает запретить этот фильм, боится правды, потому что знает, что не прав.
They're just crazy. What truth? That any war brings grief, blood, and dirt. Isn't that the truth? This movie isn't about blaming individuals or separate peoples/countries. It's about showing the situation from the inside. They're trying to depict the consequences of war... the behavior of most people and soldiers. Most of them, of course, are simply misguided (after all, going to war is always a foolish idea, especially when the children of elites are not involved). But still, it's interesting to understand what drives them and what their opinions are.
Правда в том, что русские - бедненькие захватчики, как же они устали. Наверное трудно бомбить людей :(
@@alexandervodopyan4056бедные поросята терпят ужасную войную эх жаль.
А где можно посмотреть?
Didnt care about this but I will watch it now because people are trying to censor it. They cancelled it at ZurichFilmFestival.
Дивіться, але ж зрозумійте- рашизм- то калька з націонал-соціалізму. Ну як, як Німеччина може офіційно крутити таке ? Не може.
Hi, man. I live in Russia. In our country, people are imprisoned for their opinions for 8-10 years in a maximum security prison colony.
Tell me, how in Israel or the US, people are imprisoned for such terms for their opinions?)
@@anti-commie співчуваю. Але ж. Ви самі довели до цього своїм " я политикой не интересуюсь".
@@chuvak_s_troi Я интересовался.
Меня пару раз набутылили и усё.
Коллективную ответственность не отрицаю, но это уже культурные особенности. Русские всегда были терпилами, поэтому такой народ легко разделить и властвовать над ним.
@@anti-commie я бы спорил. Но ты прав, увы.
Интересная реакция. Люди, по сути, поделились на 2 лагеря: Те, кто горячо желает запретить показ этого фильма и люди, которые хотят самостоятельно принять решение о его просмотре или отказаться от просмотра.
Это ведь касается не только этого фильма. В нынешнем мире абсолютно вся информация подвергается цензуре. Те, кто это делает, держат людей за безмозглое стадо, которому нужно объяснять что правильно, а что нет. И мы зовёмся потомками своих предков... Стыд и позор.
Я могу сказать 100% это нужно запрещать, я был на показе, в фильме не показали вагнеровцев, загран отряды, штурмовиков, не показали как проходит обучение с 1 м патроном, даже боллее того в фильме есть парень который сьездил на войну в топовой экипировке, а потом вернулся домой как ни в чем не бывало, как будто просто в командировке был заработал денежища и вернулся довольный. Фильм пропаганда
War hurts everyone, especially those who don't want to fight in it, and are forced to be men in high places
I want to see this film. Based on the trailer this doc shows the Russian soldiers as human. And they are. Just like the German soldiers of WW II were human. This doc doesn't seem to be about justifying the invasion or glorifying the Russian soldiers. But if it is I, at least, am intelligent enough to see through that. And yes a scared Russian conscript who has no idea WTF he's doing in the Ukraine can be a victim. And also a criminal.
Если ты не в курсе, в армии РФ принимают участие в СВО только контрактники
Не сравнивай нас с фашистами! Мы добрые и мирные люди! Узнай из за чего эта война! Сатанистам выгодно славян убивает славяна! В этом суть!
@CaptC4t so why those "scarred" people choose to receive military contract and money from government? They totally could reject this awesome proposal
@@dmitriyandreevich8804 ну чего ты врёшь. Мобилизация еще была, она прошла с таким сопротивлением о общества, что власти не рискуют иее повторять
@@ruderuderu я вру?!
Окей, давай пруфы)
Сколько судебных дел было по поводу отказа? Сколько людей в бусик упаковали? Сколько людей посадили и на сколько лет? Покажи где митинги были и сколько там приняли участия?
Ну кто там из нас врёт)?
I am from Ukraine.
This film is about people, who was told to kill us, and so they do everyday.
If you want to know our story, watch "20 days in Mariupol", "The Hardest Hour / Dovha Doba" and many other films.
Ukraine is not a real country. You have no culture and are merely used by the West to weaken Russia. "Ukraine" has been the most corrupt nation on Earth. Nothing more than a money laundering tool
Because we have to watch the perspective from different sides and come to conclusion by ourselves instead of blindless catering to one side?
War is terrible for everyone. Governments both force people to go. No one needs war, and its only death and destruction. Ukrainians and Russians should both sign a peace, unfortunately, they will keep sending men to their death like the First World War. Russian soldiers and Ukrainian soldiers, all the soldiers, are victims in the trenches.
Yeah, sure, we must watch this only Ukrainian films, and ban/ignore others 🤣. 1984 by Orwell
They are coming for you!!!
Так а где можно посмотреть этот фильм?
Или когда он выйдет в общий доступ?
I am NOT pro-Russia. But I do want to take a moment to play devil’s advocate: The filmographer did at least leave RT, and left Russia. And she at least got the perspectives of soldiers saying they don’t know if what they’re doing is “right” or not.
That is interesting - and not overtly biased - to me and I wish they didn’t cancel this film at the Toronto film festival.
(She left her job at RT in 2020)
She was allowed to stay with Russian troops for several months! For sure with the permission of the Russian authorities!
she joined RT around or after 2014 - after the annexation of Crimea, when some journalists like Abby Martin, who worked for RT before 2014, decided to cut ties with this establishment, specifically over disinformation spread by RT. Interesting choice for a person, who had an opportunity to work in Canada.
@@olq5689 Has nothing to do with elephants, so its completely irrelephant. The real question is was the documentary cut & put together in Canada after the fact In which case she could say whatever she wanted, and the Kremlin would have little influence.
If you believe her telling that Russia only wants peace, then watch video "Russian artillery pounds Grozny, Chechnya". Before Ukraine there were Russia's wars with Moldova, Chechnya, Georgia, Syria...
Как режиссер могла снимать фильм без ведома власти, там, где мышь не проскочит? Там за такую деятельность по сути, после выхода фильма должны были наказать всех участников этого фильма. Но такого по сути быть не может! Армия это прежде всего дисциплина!!! Это же не ополченцы. А тут неизвестная мадам приезжает, Привет вам, я из Канады!!! Хочу вас снимать! И все такие! О! Круто! Мы будем знаменитыми! Да, они бы такое не допустили, потому что любой солдат знает, что ему за такое потом по шапке надают! Без согласования в ГОСУДАРСТВЕННОЙ АРМИИ это просто НЕВОЗМОЖНО!
Угараешь? На фронте бардак так или иначе, при должной сноровке по факту езди кто хочешь и снимай что хочешь, если командиры/военные на местах пизды не выпишут конечно
Именно об этом я в первую очередь подумала. Просто смешно это "в тайне от министерства обороны". Ещё бы Путина туда вставила и написала, что он не в курсе.
@@bebro4kaты клоун, попробуй где-нибудь приблизиться к военным незаметно, войти в часть или другое расположение
She's a smart woman who makes her choice - driven by her own ambitions. She knew perfectly well that RT (including RT Documentary) is a weapon of Russian propaganda while she was working for them before that war. But she made her choice anyway - driven by her own ambitions. I know women who work for RT. They all have one thing in common: they can be meditation teachers, motivational speakers, pacifists... but in the end, it's all about their own ambitions - not the truth. I don't think Anastasia has changed since her days at RT. This film is also about her own ambitions - not the truth. Well, she is fulfilling them, cause this propaganda film is being show in Toronto after having been shown in Venice.
Where can I stream this movie?
I don't give a shit who Trofimova worked for. Even better, everyone at once. She made a unique, awesome documentary film, it required amazing, inhuman courage from her not only to sit under bombs with cameras, but also to demolish this avalanche of shit.
She is a real artist, a real passionate professional to the point of madness. I hope she doesn't give a shit about you all, Putin, Dustin Trudeau and others.
She longed to create something outstanding in her life's work and she created it despite everything.
I express my true, endless admiration.
Лени Рифеншталь тоже было плевать на всех когда она снимала свои пропагандистские шедевры. Уверен, если бы её попросили снимать работу немецких айнзацкоманд в Восточной Европе, то она бы сняла потрясающий документальный фильм про геноцид местного населения.
Зато потом были несколько процедур денацификации и курс лечения в психиатрической клинике.
Кстати в рецензии на мемуары Лени изданные в 1987 г. было написано «Ей до сих пор удалось остаться в неведении о том, о чём она не хотела знать»
Were she to fund it herself or by RT things would be okay. Of course you can make anything you want. Your expression is yours but this was illegally funded by Canadian tax payers. This is a spit in the face of free expression. It's clear and obvious propaganda meant for western eyes.
@@Com-bc6jl
This is the problem of Canadian taxpayers, if it is a problem at all.
Trofimova is a good girl. She found the money, she found the opportunity, she found the strength and courage in herself, and she used her talent to do her job in the best possible way.
For this she deserves honor and glory.
Among Canadian taxpayers there are all sorts of people, and there are plenty of fools, too. She is not easy to please, and there is no need.
@@Com-bc6jl
While you and I were chewing pasta and selling insurance, or whatever you sell, Trofimova spent months under bombs filming a movie for me and people like me. I'm glad that people like Trofimova still exist.
@evgenynikhaev5104 Using sympathy as a tool to soften the blow of failure in their war for domination is pathetic and vile at the same time. What slime steals tax payer money to push clear propaganda back at them. This is a spit in the face to our way of life. Freedom of expression dragged through the mud, digested and vomited by people that do not care for such things. She's a thieve and a worm. Yea go watch it. Watch the worming and listen to pig squeals.
It's been 10 years since the war in Donbass, remember that.
The girl at the end of the video said: It's easy to start a war, but to end it, you try to do it, it's very hard
Russian Russian soldiers, I always admire the way they fight for their country, because the whole Russian people promised their grandfathers no time to give up, so they will always succeed.
For all those on their "freedom of expression" high horse - i hear you. The view must be very nice from there. Nicer than in a bomb shelter or at a funeral of your loved ones killed by Trofimova's "ordinary guys with a sense of humor". Clearly, we are a society not easily offended by a "different point of view". Unlike Germany where Nazi salute is banned. Such censorship! But by all means, watch what you like. I only hope you consider watching "20 Days in Mariupol" as your double feature.
💯
Wo oder wann ist dieser Film zu bekommen? ?Viele möchten das wissen...
Слава Богу, что нашёлся хоть один человек, сумевший показать, что российские солдаты тоже в первую очередь нормальные люди, со своими страхами, чаяниями и надеждами. Спасибо Анастасии за это! Почитал комментрарии украинцев... Люди, мне стыдно за вас. В вас не осталось ничего человеческого! Только ненависть ко всему российскому. Мне вас искренне жаль.
їбать ви там попаяні
@@svpiter78 Ответьте себе на вопрос: что русские солдатьі забьіли в суверенной стране? Вьі искренне не понимаете за 2 года войньі за что вас ненавидят? Отрицание раельности - єто так характеризует россиян
А мне вас жаль...хотя нет- абсолютно не жаль!!! Вы не человек, вы особь!!!!!!!!
А ты лучше приедь в любой разбитый город в Украине, а потом высказывайся
@@natalieivanova3011 у меня родственники со стороны жены (двоюродный брат и тётка) проживают в Полтавской области, так что я в курсе происходящего. А жена моя - гражданка Украины. Так что меня пугать не надо
They banned the screening of this film from The Toronto International Film Festival because they were getting terroristic threats from Ukrainians.
They weren't getting terroristic threats. It wasn't cancelled by police, but the organizers of the festival being a bit scared by pacific protesters
And it makes perfect sense. Ukrainians It's to be expected!
@@julietavargascarcamo4411🤣🤣🤣 don’t watch fake news
What a BS
@@depre__ed just read the Toronto police statement if you can
이 영화는 어디서 보나요?
Do the Russian soldiers have a choice not to go? Or to leave after they see the reality on the ground?
Yea most of russian army is contract soldiers, conscripts are a tiny minority. Even conscripts will only go to jail if they refuse, it's not like north korea or anything where they k*ll all your family for disobeying. So really, 100% of russian army are volunteers.
They have a choice not to go, they went for money. Once there they have a choice not to commit war crimes.
@@abodabalo Easy to say from a safe sofa at home. I doubt war crimes come as a calculated strategic decision. The videos I see on this channel just show pure panic on all sides and an extreme level of stress. Calculating that those soldiers did never belong to the more intelligent men of their peers, I think war crimes come out of a total panic, extreme anger over fallen comrades and death scare. It is a traumatic experience for all involved, which leads to a complete rund down of critical thinking skills and intelligence in itself.
I dare to ask, it is worth it for any of them? And those who were drafted definitely had no choice to decline.
some of russian soldiers are taken there by force, cause if they resist they would be sent to jail. contracted soldiers, which were the majority of the fighters cannot leave the war anymore. it is russian law. some of soldiers struggling to leave home from the war are sent by their officers to kind of underground jails ("podval") on the occupied territory, till they change their mind. you could read such a media like Meduza and Novaya Gazeta there you can get more information what is happening. these medias are already forbidden in russia
Die Soldaten, die eingezogen wurden haben in der tat eine Entscheidungsgewalt, 4 Jahre Knast (auch wenn das russische Gefängnis ziemlich hart ist) ist moralisch besser als ein Land zu überfallen, dessen Zivilbevölkerung zu bombardieren und alles was "befreit wird" in Schutt und Asche zu legen. Außerdem ist es auch besser für die Gesundheit, wenn man sich die Statistiken anschaut wie viele unbeschadet von der Front kommen. Ich denke nicht das die ständige Bombardierung ziviler Ziele in ukrainischen Stäten aus Angst und Frust passiert, es ist ein Mittel um die Bevölkerung zu terrorisieren und Kriegsmüde zu machen.
People from twitter are very angry about this, meaning that its definetly something good
Yes
Where can I see a full movie?
Где я могу посмотреть целиком?
We the public should be able to watch it; blocking it from film festivals is a pure infringement on our liberty to get all sides of the story
There is no side in this film .
Besides everybody can imagine what war looks like . Our parents dealt with it . Should we hide the truth ???
«Wo got into a fight in Ukraine, but I don't I'm right»
Why do 100% of the hate comments miss these words from the movie?
Although I understand, the position “there are only orcs there” is much more pleasant. It is very easy to live in a black and white world, although in fact there are hundreds of other shades in the world
Because it's a portion of lie mixed in trurth.
Good morning, pal, modern propaganda by fascist regimes has became sophisticated several times.
What shade of the color do you want to paint the invasion, murders and violence, though?
This is what happens when people watch decades of Marvel movies with little beyond good and bad.
@@901blitz you are not the one of these ignorant persons, right? So, what do you find good in agressive war against peaceful brotherhood neighbour country?
@@e99plantpeaceful? Brotherhood? Lol, you can't be serious😂
Война это грязно и холодно
Война это когда уже на все тебе по барабану
За 3 года войны понял одну простую истину - стравливали и вооружали людей НЕдолюди, которые в закулисье жмут друг другу руки
Но стадо дальше блеет про какую то славу странам, которые кидают их на мясо.
Мы заслуживаем то что сейчас происходит
where can i see this movie?
Now it’s a must see documentary- TIFF, please schedule showings
humanity should always be considered superior to nationality, I totally understand and support a film festival selected this film for screening, because that's the reason why we need a film festival: let the different voice to be heard so that the point of view might be shaked. It might be difficult to create a world of equality in reality, but in the world of film, we should strive to treat all beings as equals.
On a du mal a croire qu elle ait pu tourner sans autorisation officielle
When filmmakers make documentaries from the Russian side, they are propagandistic. When others make documentaries from the Ukrainian side, they are heroes.
Because Ukrainians are hero's.
@@Com-bc6jlLol, no
@adevarulgolgolut1NATO
@@bearclooneywatches4186 silence vatnik, nato isnt even in ukraine
@@Com-bc6jl🤣🤣🤣 Ответ убил.
I never heard of this film until i saw that it was cancelled at TIFF. Now i want to watch it.
Censorship does the opposite of its intentions always.
Blessings to my Orthodox brothers, both Ukrainians and Russians ☦️
It's not that you're banned from watching this movie. It's that Russia is a dictatorship, and this movie shows Russian narratives. So it's just Kremlin propaganda filmed with Canadian government money. The truth is that Russia attacked Ukraine, destroyed its cities and villages, raped women and children, and cuts off Ukrainian people heads. But you won't see any of that in the movie, of course. The Russians are good there, usual men.
base, censorship is the best advertisement
Why did this film receive $340,000 from the Canada Media Fund, which is funded by the Government of Canada?
Классный фильм! Удивительно, что правда прорввпетмя сквозь завесы лжи и русофобии , Браво автор !!
и где вы его видели? Это трейлер фильма, но вы уже сделали выводы, что фильм классный, как это у вас получилось?
I will see this film.
Can I know where to watch after they release this documentary
Patriots better put it on torrents sites or just provide the magnet link
Following this comment
@@marshallmcluhan33 I believe it will be made available on the web soon!
Bravo! Thisis called freedom of speech! There are always two sides to a conflict.
ummm no we dont need to see the side of the rapist and murders
@@SashAlex-xk2mnso you shouldn’t watch ukrainian sources 😅
@@SashAlex-xk2mn If you can't sympothize with people who are tricked into going to war with propaganda, then you must not be American. Americans citizens have been tricked into going to war for "Freedom" since 1955... Not 1 single time has American freedom been threatened.
@@agentbuckwheat tricked? lol hwat, were they tricked in russian empire, ussr too?
These are men from country on the border, country where half of those idiots have relatives from Ukraine. They are not tricked, they do not care.
Grow up
the west have today stopped it from showing us.
where is possibile to watch it?
В Токмаке (Запорожская область) российские солдаты застрелили на улице местного жителя, у которого в руках бал телефон. Солдатам показалось, что он снимает на камеру место расположения военных. Человек ничего не снимал, погорячились русские солдатики, ошибочка вышла.
А Трофимова рассказывает сказочку о том, что она несколько месяцев без разрешения российских властей вела съёмки в расположении действующих российских войск.
Why did Ukrainians stop writing about old women raped by Russian soldiers and children eaten?
А по ошибки ли убили солдаты Украины беременную женщину в Курске на глазах мужа и сына ?
@@haheha667 для тебя с мордора - это какой-то конфликт, да? Для остального мира - это преступная война, развязанная расеей
@@МарияДьяченко-щ9ю ну как, посочувствовали что такое война на своей территории? Не нужно было нападать на соседнюю страну.
@@elenakotlyar5038 Трофимова рассказывает то , что видела, а вы рассказываете чужие пересказы, это не документалистика, а фольклор
Is there a place to watch this after the festival, I would love to watch it.
Thanks for the film, can't wait to see the whole movie. Haters gonna hate 😊
Where can I watch this movie? Can I stream it somewhere?
Impossible.
I've looked everywhere.
i read that it will be available online next spring
How have people claimed to watch it already?@@lonewolfandcub668
The film is explicitly anti-war. It chronicles the stories of soldiers. They happen to be Russian and humanizing the enemy is undesirable.
It not anti war. This film has goal to whitewash russian war crimes
Like i read in some review: "We see how the Russians die, but not how they kill". If they want to show the entire story, maybe they should include the truth about them being occupiers and killers, and also humans. Because yes, all killers are also humans but for some reason this film doesn't show it
It's not anti war it's anti reality.
Full support for this piece of art! FREE THE ARTS FROM POLITICS!
I'm an anti-war Russian and I can't believe my eyes 😢 It would be appropriate as a news story (to inform people about conditions and moral of the ennemy), but not as a documentary at a festival.
Why not?
Why did this film receive $340,000 from the Canada Media Fund, which is funded by the Government of Canada?
@@magicbullet9945because it's a whitewashed film sympathizing with the invading forces while they demolish civilian city centers
Начал тараспереход?
ПНХ
Why are you fighting. What are you fighting.
Watch the film. It has answers
They are fighting a hostile NATO expansion into Ukraine
Как посмотреть этот фильм?
where can I watch this?
Finally someone asking the real question! Looks like a great film. Seems like a lot of russian soldiers have doubts about the war. Bringing this to light will only help the war end.
@@agentbuckwheat ты дурак если так думаешь. У нас сомнения только в братоубийственной войне, но в с самой войне сомнений нет. Она не избежна. Америка и Европа привели к этому.
@@agentbuckwheatпоэтому они идут добровольно, а в стране 404ua людей пакует тцк
LOL
It's not that you're banned from watching this movie. It's that Russia is a dictatorship, and this movie shows Russian narratives. So it's just Kremlin propaganda filmed with Canadian government money. The truth is that Russia attacked Ukraine, destroyed its cities and villages, raped women and children, and cuts off Ukrainian people heads. But you won't see any of that in the movie, of course. The Russians are good there, usual men.
In Pokrovsk
С другой стороны, есть же фильмы про американцев во Вьетнаме
и вьетнамцы что то не выступали с протестами в США...
@@СергейКрасиков-р2щ haahahah how is it to be renamed 2 times within the span of 30 years.
Where can we watch this now that that it wont be played?
Вот это горение в комментах
Скорее взрыв, скорее всего правдивый фильм, раз у хохлов подгорело, надо посмотреть!
The most anti-war stuff that I've seen last months. Strong All quiet on the western front vibe
I wonder, is any petition against this film started yet? I would sign with pleasure!
Why? Are you afraid that someone can't make up their own mind? Do you have such contempt for your fellow people that you wish to smother them in censorship?
What a weak sentiment...
All that this shows is the humanity and horror of war. That is a story that is good to tell, so that we understand how important peace is.
@@nicky640 Useless, democracy for them somehow includes censorship, people like lajons wouldnt get it simply
@@nicky640 Well, let’s start by saying that they are not my fellow people. Fortunately, the murderers and I are not of the same blood. And what does censorship have to do with it? She spoke out in defense of the aggressor, it is her right, but our right is to ask the international community not to broadcast this on platforms like international festivals when these "unfortunate murderers" bomb Ukraine every day and night. When they destroy life itself in a free country that was not lucky enough to be a neighbor of maniacs. This film is not against war, it calls for the justification of murderers. And this is not a condemnation of war at all. This is not an anti-war film, no matter how you turn it. Asking for sympathy for the rapist, and not for the victim, is not quite the same as asking for justice, is it?
@@LaJons
I had written a well-meant reply but it's completely deleted.
That's what all this censorship does: stop dialogue. I suppose you're happy that I can't have a real conversation with you, since you support censorship too.
If you don't, then you should also rethink your stance.
@@nicky640 If you need to watch a narrative from one side to understand why peace is important... then you're just a one-sided shill to begin with.
Watching this movie after hearing the news about a Ukranian child who had her head blown off by Russian missiles hits different. Russia can be many things but it will NEVER be the victim of this situation.
As in, it would never have children killed by foreign force or by missiles? I'm pretty sure 1st child (4-years-old) was killed by Ukrainian's missile way back on December 30th 2023, in Belgorod. Or did you only meant it in terms of Agressor and Victim? Yeah, those roles couldn't be swept no matter how many more civilians would be killed or displaced, now on both sides and by both sides. Russia (my country) as an agressor, obviously.
I'm kinda curious to actually watch the film that every side critique, but very few saw. From the reviews it seems, that edges were smoothed (intentionally or not idk) on the different issue that many abroad have no clue about: mobilization and sending massive amount of prisoners on the frontlines.
On the other hand, I'm glad that main hero is Ukrainian (I'm not talking about Ukrainians born in Russia, obviously), cause dear lord there are a ton of them here right now (regions on the border). Every time I see their cars with states numbers of LNR or DNR, I wonder, why would I willingly (I'm not talking about those who were forced to "evacuate" from let's say Mariupol) move to live in the country that annexed or occupied part of my country of origin. And why so many of them such ardent Fuhrer lovers when they weren't under Kremlin propaganda for majority of their lives. It's so bizarre.
Городской бой общевойсковой армии - это не терроризм, а - городской бой общевойсковой армии. Kомбатантам и не комбатантам может оторвать голову или руку снарядом. Это война, blead. Легальный способ избежать жертв - мэрия объявляет город открытым, обороняющий город гарнизон складывает оружие. Вот - серьезный разговор. А плач за мертвую девочку - это разговоры в пользу бедных, эмоциональная демагогия на фоне военных действий.
@@Juraweg1987 в каком-то смысле верно, но это скорее относится к ситуации, когда войска физически находятся в городе или рядом с ним. А в ситуации обстрелов и налетов дронов как быть? Половина городов Украины и города 2х областей России должны быть эвакуированы по этой логике. Но это же ведь нереально.
Большой парадокс этой войны, помимо целости газовой инфраструктуры (а значит обе стороны умеют бить прицельно, когда захотят), это относительно, пока (и проверенных на данный момент), низкое число смертей среди мирного населения.
Безумия происходящего это не отменяет. Да и родственников эти цифры не утешут.
А укры сколько детей на Донбассе убили???
Мммм????!!
Вы животные себя ещё жертвами считаете
change ur media sources sometimes if u don't want to become brainwashed NATO-lover
I haven't seen the film, so there's little I can say about what it really shows. But I've read it's about the war seen from the perspective of soldiers who are unaware of being manipulated by their leaders. Which is basically what happened in every war in history, and still happens. There are no winners or heroes in wars. Everyone is a victim of evil, superior plans in the end.
But once again, I haven't seen this movie.
Комментарии насыщены носителями "Единственной правды", "американскими освободителями". Автор молодец, надеюсь эта документальная работа покажет истинное лицо войны от которой безуспешно нас пытались уберечь наши деды и отцы, потому что именно благодаря американской политике вмешательства во внутренние дела других государств исключительно в целях своей выгоды сегодня наши братья убивают друг друга без особой на то исключительной причины.
Internal affairs... LOL
If this shakes your support for ukraine then youre a fickle supporter. This looks brilliant. Im not at war with the russian people and i wanna know just wtf they think theybare fighting for cause i cant understand it. Ill deffo be watching
Watch the events of 2014 and pay special attention to the Maidan.
Вы по российскому фильму от пропагандистки RT решили что то понять?)
Then watch Intercepted for an example of russian mindset in this context?🤷♀️
Why would you want to watch a movie from the confirmed russian propagandist to find out what russians think or say about this war?
Humanity exists on both sides. No one is going to come away from this undamaged. It is a tragedy we will feel for decades to come.
All I want to know is where can I watch this?
Can't wait to see it
where? post a torrent link
A person can rise through the efforts of his own mind or draw himself down in the same manner. Because each person is his own friend or enemy.
Two quotes from a film's director: 1) "I saw no signs of war crimes during my time near the front with russian soldiers". 2) [The highest russian brigade commander] ordered that I be given a military uniform - "so that my own people don't accidently shoot me".
This is a fasc slop for people with temperature IQ.
Whether she realizes it or not she became a tool to spread propaganda.
To be fair, we don't want the Ukrainian military to accidentally confuse her for an actual journalist. I think all Russian propagandists should be issued military uniforms. It shoes their true allegiance.
а вы не слышали когда всу своих же подстреливали потому что не разобрались?
🇷🇺🇷🇺☦️❤️🇷🇺🇷🇺
Wo kann ich diesen Film in voller Länge sehen?
Лучше не стоит
Jetzt erst recht 😂@@grendleniafly5428
Where can I watch this movie?
You are russian, i can tell by your name.
Please upload the full film
I have bene wondering for a while whether there will even be someone brave enough to present us with the less “popular” side’s account of the war. Thank you for making this happen. There is nothing that can justify the atrocities happening in Ukraine right now but the only way to overcome the big issue is to change the mindset or ordinary Russians on the war. And you can't do that without giving them a chance to speak.
It's 1943, a German journalist travels to occupied France to show how "unwilling" SS soldiers are truly suffering, not the civilians, to the British and American audiences.
The movie is titled "Germans at War"
Give her a Leni Riefenstahl award
You have newer been our brothers, and you will never be. Every tear of Ukrainian children’s and women’s on your hands. We will never forgive you, remember that.
I'm grateful that our Canadian tax dollars support films like this, which tell the story of humanity. By cancelling this film, however, TIFF’s current leadership has seriously undermined their integrity and professionalism. If you're unable to uphold the values of freedom of expression, then the least you can do is to step down. Shame on you!
There were two vultures... Some kills, some watches
ZZZZZ ГОЙДА ГОООООООООЛ ZZZZZVVVVVZZZZZ СЛАВА РОССИИ!!!!
Выложите его на ютубе, большую аудиторию захватите! И ненадо будет с этими дебильными запретами сталкиватся!! Док.фильм и так противятся. А почему??? Наверное боятся что правду там увидеть можно!!! Удачи. Я жил на донбассе до 1997, теперь в германии, но много родствеников еще по всей украине!
Правда в том что русские разбили пол Украины, в 2014 урвали Крым, а вами, дураками, прикрылись.
If independence is good for Ukraine, it'll be great for Dixie.
Normal Russians are at home, not at war
ZZZZZ ГОЙДА ГОООООООООЛ ZZZZZVVVVVZZZZZ СЛАВА РОССИИ!!!!
Normal russians fled russia to avoid this war too .
@@чезвалсларк-з6дyou know we barely care about what you claim?
@@lf6756 100%
@@lf6756 Well, not all people fled Russia because they are against the war, many of them just didn't want to be sent to Ukraine and get killed.
After having spent last week under heavy missile strikes with no electricity and internet for hours, having my hometown heavily damaged by “russians at war”, I’m furious that you let them take the center stage and speak for themselves
Womp womp
What if this film helped to end the conflict? Would you be glad or still upset?
Dont forget Donbas sinces 2014 what ukraine did to those poor Russian speaking people. just saying.
А сколько так живёт Донецк???????
Не скули укроп
@@menya00045 you are a lier
Can it be downloaded somewhere? Thank you in advance
poor Russians, as always they know nothing and are guilty of nothing.
They just need to be understood and forgiven
Good comment. Tiff and TVO and others are vatniks.
Poor you?
Бедолага, это для фильма взяли пару человек, которые чего-то там не знают и не понимают. Большая часть все понимает и знает, что русские на стороне правды и справедливости. Вы просто сдохнете, а мы попадем в рай
@@Basikmusic хаахах нацист!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! а точнее рашист!
@@РФ-БОМБИТ-КУРСК-не-молчите терпи
The guy in the film: " In the fight, I need to feel that I am right. Here I am not right"
Proceeds to kill civilians and destroy the neighboring nation.
Every Russian soldier in a nutshell.
Why did Ukrainians stop writing about old women raped by Russian soldiers and children eaten?
Just like before Ukraine, the Russian soldiers were doing the same in Chechnya and Syria.
@@OKEAHKPACA-pd1gl ложь