Wow. This video just brought a huge smile to my face. It's so awesome to see how far you've come since your early videos, MGM. Congrats on a fantastic video! I loved every time a new clone popped in.
OH MY Goodness!! THAT would be an AWESOME collaboration! #Canada 's most incredible online export ***** making a music video with ***** I'd buy in to that! Come on guys, it would be AWESOME!!! (and potentially so wonderfully multi-lingual!) ***** *****
How are you still on youtube and not working for some huge production company making millions? Always amazing to see what you come up with, and I'm glad you still spend so much time entertaining us fans. Just surprising that you havent disappeared into the credits of amazing productions.
This video reminded me to one of your old video: "One band man", it's super impressive to see your grow on RUclips! One day you were at freddy's filming that video using basic camera setup / video editing tricks and the next day you are make huge editing effects with a 4k camera and crane-camera!! You sir: Are very inspirational for a lot of us youtubers! Thanks for your hard work!!
Oh yeah! That was a fun video. Gosh... you reminded me of my second video ever. Probably unlisted now, called "Playing with Myself". That was one of my worst videos.
I remember watching Joe Penna since over a decade ago but in the last few years I haven’t really seen anything, and for the last few months i’ve been killing myself tryna remember his channel name and today I have finally found my way back to this masterpiece
The fact that you recorded a clone for each seat in the auditorium blows my mind. Re-watched it like 10 times just to make sure. :) Amazing once again, Joe!
It still amazes me how passionate you are uploading consistent great content. I could only imagine how long you take on each video so good work once again!!
The real question isn't "how in the world did he do that?", it's more like "why am I only just now discovering you?" Epic entertainment right here. #kitkatconducting
i stopped watching for a year, i regret my decision, as i look at the videos that ive missed you are amazing, and i wish everlasting success to your channel
This is absolutely amazing. I knew I should have gotten your autograph at the vidcon pre party this year. Its all good, I got a picture at last years vidcon. You are a LEGEND.
+Devin De Anda It's motion control. The camera is on a computer-controlled crane that does the same move exactly the same way over and over again, so they can layer different takes on top of each other seamlessly.
uhhhhh.... i have never seen a video in such a high quality before... 720pHD, 1080pHD, 1440pHD, 2160p4K... so awesome, such editing, such skills, so cool. awesome video too :)
I had commented on your last video to do something related to actual instruments and you did not let me down!:) I really enjoyed watching your very talented clones;) Keep up the good work!
I've always dreamt as a kid of somehow programming a camera crane to move along the same path multiple times do this sorta thing, so cool seeing it action, awesome work dude, inspirational stuff!
Great idea, awesome music and amazing editing with After Effects and this video doesn't have over a million plus views yet? Wow! RUclips isn't about talent and it's a "Mystery Man" but I and others appreciate your videos and the time it takes to make them, keep up the good work!
Looking forward to seeing how this video was made! I really like editing, and this thing looks really technical, and I WANT to know how it was made, because it's so good and exciting! Great job, Joe! Fantastic! :)
At my high school, they played this over the PA system right before classes started. If you didn't get in the door before the song ended, you were marked late. Worked pretty damn well.
Amazing as always! Great video, love the effort and the music! Really enjoy watching stuff that I know have taken a long time to do, I appreciate it more :) The subtitles worked great.
Joe! When playing the cello, you should try to keep your bow parallel to the bridge! Seriously, absolutely amazing video, the editing is getting overwhelmingly good.
Wow! Ever since that aviici video you did with motion control it's become quite an awesome feature on this Channel, and it's great to have top quality visuals to accompany top quality sound!! :3
This is spectacular! I can't even imagine how hard it was to film/edit that. Very entertaining, you rock! I've tried to work with a bunch of clones before and they don't cooperate very well... Epic Clone Chess Battle
This video is amazingly well done, and I only noticed this the 2nd time I watched it: The sound of the contrabass is that of a bowed one, but in the video it is plucked. Guess that's the image most people have of the instrument due to its use outside classical music, so I bet it won't be noticed :)
geez, been watching your vids for quite some time now. You are really talented! (btw, you and a couple of other talented muscians inspired me to pick up the guitar and learn to play)
Wow. This video just brought a huge smile to my face. It's so awesome to see how far you've come since your early videos, MGM. Congrats on a fantastic video! I loved every time a new clone popped in.
Umm, it might be too early to call, but I think you've officially won the greatest clone video on RUclips ever. Just freaking amazing!
oh th-top it
Yes. Agree completely.
Awesome! It was great how the instruments that the camera was closest to were louder than the others
Good catch ;)
Amazing!
like you!
OH MY Goodness!! THAT would be an AWESOME collaboration! #Canada 's most incredible online export ***** making a music video with ***** I'd buy in to that! Come on guys, it would be AWESOME!!! (and potentially so wonderfully multi-lingual!)
***** *****
gunnarolla hey Andrew!
Congrats to Ryan Thomas, Ruth Moir, and Sasha Hettich for winning the LG G3 phones!!
I'll be emailing you guys :D
You should do this with the star wars cantina song, purely for my satisfaction.
Good work MGM
Star Wars' main theme song could be great too.. :D
*****
What! You have clones!?!
give up bro, you rip
Quando e onde vc vai estar em Sao Paulo?? O.O (where and when your going to Sao Paulo?)
You are the magician of RUclips Joe.
Absolutely stunning. And plenty of humor to spice it up.
Joe.. Demais o vídeo cara.. Fico imaginando o trabalho que deu pra filmar e produzir um vídeo como esse..
How are you still on youtube and not working for some huge production company making millions? Always amazing to see what you come up with, and I'm glad you still spend so much time entertaining us fans. Just surprising that you havent disappeared into the credits of amazing productions.
This video reminded me to one of your old video: "One band man", it's super impressive to see your grow on RUclips! One day you were at freddy's filming that video using basic camera setup / video editing tricks and the next day you are make huge editing effects with a 4k camera and crane-camera!! You sir: Are very inspirational for a lot of us youtubers! Thanks for your hard work!!
Oh yeah! That was a fun video.
Gosh... you reminded me of my second video ever. Probably unlisted now, called "Playing with Myself". That was one of my worst videos.
*****
are we talking about the same playing with myself right... if you know what i mean
***** I found the secret annotation for that video back then. I watched it! MWAHWHAHWA!! :D
I think Joe did the best job in the orchestra, to be honest. Sorry to offend everyone else.
Don't make the other Joes upset!
***** Sorry, Joe. It's not personal, but Joe has more talent than the rest.
The one thing that's always stood out for me about MGM's videos is how much effort is put into them. Amazing.
I remember watching Joe Penna since over a decade ago but in the last few years I haven’t really seen anything, and for the last few months i’ve been killing myself tryna remember his channel name and today I have finally found my way back to this masterpiece
The amount of effort put into this is awesome!
My friend is so talented.
SupDaily06 Yup! ^_^
The fact that you recorded a clone for each seat in the auditorium blows my mind. Re-watched it like 10 times just to make sure. :) Amazing once again, Joe!
It still amazes me how passionate you are uploading consistent great content. I could only imagine how long you take on each video so good work once again!!
The real question isn't "how in the world did he do that?", it's more like "why am I only just now discovering you?" Epic entertainment right here. #kitkatconducting
wow caleb here commenting on this video. awesome
i stopped watching for a year, i regret my decision, as i look at the videos that ive missed
you are amazing, and i wish everlasting success to your channel
This is absolutely amazing. I knew I should have gotten your autograph at the vidcon pre party this year. Its all good, I got a picture at last years vidcon. You are a LEGEND.
After All these Years, Joe's work is still awesome
And the most awesome youtuber goes to MGM. You make the best videos.
AWE AWE AWE AWE.
:D :D :D :D
***** 7-1 hahahahah
THE ROTOSCOPING!!!! How many man-hours did it take!?!?!
"Green screen"
Yeah, keying things out can help, but the BTS and just a general knowledge of video FX should tell you it wasn't 100% "Green screen!"
+Devin De Anda
It's motion control. The camera is on a computer-controlled crane that does the same move exactly the same way over and over again, so they can layer different takes on top of each other seamlessly.
+Jesse Haycraft Yes, since posting my year old comment, I have been enlightened in the ways of film-making... Thanks!
1:40 The chairs in the reflection were EMPTY! O_o
It's a conspiracy! haha
shhhhh
Too funny !!!!!
No, no, no theire vampires duh
***** He meant the shadows of the MysteryGuitarMen, or lack thereof.
Joe, that was amazing. The best video I've watched from some monthe. You can be really proud, good job.
Thanks! :D It's definitely the most expensive video we've ever made.
Ahah, obviously
Haven't looked at this channel in over a year. This is REALLY good!
This is so seamless, you can even see the shadows of two Joes get darker when the overlap
Every video I see of yours I'm left thinking "he must have spent FOREVER working on this". Great work again, this video was incredible.
MysteryGuitarMan is back! and more of them!
uhhhhh.... i have never seen a video in such a high quality before... 720pHD, 1080pHD, 1440pHD, 2160p4K... so awesome, such editing, such skills, so cool. awesome video too :)
Damn! How creative is that dude?
Mystery Orchestra! You are a genius MGM :-) Keep up the good work.
Esse vídeo merece milhões de Views, imagino o trabalho que deu pra fazer!
This is hands down the most talented man on earth, right here. Thx mgm for making my day!
I hardly believe that all the instrumentalists are one person.
The editing is super smooth.
Great job.
Amazing!!! I have no idea how this was edited. And great to see the flute in one of your amazing videos!
sweet mother of clones this looks like soooo much work! I can't tell you how much I appreciate everyone's hard work on these videos! love it Joe :)
I had commented on your last video to do something related to actual instruments and you did not let me down!:) I really enjoyed watching your very talented clones;) Keep up the good work!
To be honest u r my no.1 enjoyment for the past 6 years .. its been soo long .. but i never get bored :D
Se antes eu achava o máximo quando vc usava legendas em PT-Br, imagina vídeos totalmente em português.
Fantástico
I have been subscribed to your channel for more than 2 or 3 years now, and I just wanted to say I LOVE your work!! great job (Y)
Wow!
If this video doesn't make million views I'm ready to eat my hat (which is a top hat, so this is serious stuff)
I totally agree with you!
faireset! I havent seen you since this awesome pink panther video many years ago :D
You best get munching 11 Mounths and only 300,000+ views
It only has 357k, even after 2 years :(
Eat that hat
the multiple instruments is not new but the amazing thing was how well the camera movement was executed
A classic among classics. Such a good choice. I would like to see more classical music songs done for your videos.
This was absolutely amazing,i imagine it took ages to make! Your such an inspiration man! Amazing.
Man this was fantastic! Just like your old videos but even better :D Keep up the amazing work Joe!
That was awesome! Incredible special effects in there!
Joe, you seriously deserve alot more views :) Incredible job, and the efforts that you put in every one of films are huge! Keep on clonin ;)
mysteryguitarman has a tendency to pull great videos out of his ass
great work
Os vídeos do Joe mereciam mais views :/ Esse de tão bom no lançamento fiz questão de compartilhar. Qse nunca faço isso, acho q foi a unica vez ate.
"Coconuts clapping together" gotta love whoever made those subtitles
Oh my god... this video is just incredible... you must haver worked soooo hard and it must have take so much time to put together
I don't know why, but the dancing shadow made me so happy. XD
I've always dreamt as a kid of somehow programming a camera crane to move along the same path multiple times do this sorta thing, so cool seeing it action, awesome work dude, inspirational stuff!
you ALWAYS the one that really deserved millions of views and likes joe!
man, this video was great, everything looked seamless! awesome job
Great idea, awesome music and amazing editing with After Effects and this video doesn't have over a million plus views yet? Wow! RUclips isn't about talent and it's a "Mystery Man" but I and others appreciate your videos and the time it takes to make them, keep up the good work!
Looking forward to seeing how this video was made! I really like editing, and this thing looks really technical, and I WANT to know how it was made, because it's so good and exciting! Great job, Joe! Fantastic! :)
What is MysteryGuitarMan? This video is a perfect example of what he is/does/do.
amazing puppetry and CG -- all the Joe Penna's look real!
At my high school, they played this over the PA system right before classes started. If you didn't get in the door before the song ended, you were marked late. Worked pretty damn well.
Totally loved this video! Amazing what you do with those effects!
Amazing as always! Great video, love the effort and the music! Really enjoy watching stuff that I know have taken a long time to do, I appreciate it more :)
The subtitles worked great.
Adoro quando o youtube me recomenda seus vídeos! Acompanho desde o comecinho
Wow I love how you make all these videos they brighten my day!
Oooooo! So talented! I wish I was a music teacher already, and not just a college student, so I could show this to my kids!
Joe! When playing the cello, you should try to keep your bow parallel to the bridge! Seriously, absolutely amazing video, the editing is getting overwhelmingly good.
We watched this in our band class when I mentioned it and they were all amazed
That just blew my mind!
This is so amazing it deserves more views!
Would love to see a BTS OF THIS VIDEO very well done .
This is so awesome, hear that sound follow too ! Gonna have to repeat until the making of is out :)
Wow! It's amazing to see how much you have grown! You are truly in inspiration! I hope to see many more videos! :D!
I think this is your best video yet
I can't believe you play so many instruments and so well!
Wow! Ever since that aviici video you did with motion control it's become quite an awesome feature on this Channel, and it's great to have top quality visuals to accompany top quality sound!! :3
"Iberê Thenório, parece nome de uma cidade da Zona Leste de São Paulo"
"Iberê Thenório, parece nome de personagem de Game of Thrones"
hahaha
I have been watching this over cause it's amazing
Hey Joe,
Most under appreciated music in the world: Portuguese composer Bom Tempo, his Symphony No. 2
Man.... HOW DO YOU DO IT? You started my day with a smile on my face. Thank you and I appreciate the time and effort you put into this video. :)
This is spectacular! I can't even imagine how hard it was to film/edit that. Very entertaining, you rock! I've tried to work with a bunch of clones before and they don't cooperate very well... Epic Clone Chess Battle
I feel so happy to say that we played this song in band, and it was as fast as he was going too, it was hard though, but cool
This video is amazingly well done, and I only noticed this the 2nd time I watched it: The sound of the contrabass is that of a bowed one, but in the video it is plucked. Guess that's the image most people have of the instrument due to its use outside classical music, so I bet it won't be noticed :)
This deserves so many more veiws. it will get there
Ate que fim um video em português kkkkk
Deveria fazer assim iria alcançar mais brasileiros
Esse é sem duvida o mais trabalhoso de todos
so much work put into this but so little views it just makes me sad...
you're awesome!
ooh that was cool
MysteryGuitarMan is a God when it comes to clone editing. Who agrees?
This is so awesome! Sometimes I wonder how you this. I figure it out but then I have a headache
This kind of stuff is the reason I'm subscribed
A-mazing
Even thought I actually espected the last effect (Mystery Guitar Man Teather crowd) it was really well done!
geez, been watching your vids for quite some time now. You are really talented! (btw, you and a couple of other talented muscians inspired me to pick up the guitar and learn to play)
wow, amazing, I love this video, MysteryGuitarMan you're the best
I think you just inspired me to get back into playing my clarinet...
What the fuck... MGM HOW ARE YOU NOT THE MOST SUBSCRIBED? Such talent, in SO many ways! Why can't people appreciate it more!
Im so mind blown on how you did this.
Wow i miss these kind of videos
This video should have more than 200 thousand views
I haven't watched you in a year . And "oh Howve I missed you !"