The motivation for this video came from the many times I get asked by my patients this question about Basmati Rice vs Brown Rice, which made me realised that many people do not realise that Basmati Rice can be White Rice, Red Rice, Brown Rice, whilst at the same time, Brown Rice can come from Basmati Rice, Jasmine Rice, other types of rice. If you have found this video, I am delighted that my effort in making this video has not gone to waste, but if I have failed to achieve the goal of clearing this up this confusion or worse, even added to the confusion, then my bad! I shall reflect on how I could have done this video better and improve myself for future videos. Ever since I posted this video a few months ago, it has received many comments from viewers, some positive and also many negative and even angry comments. I want to thank everyone who made the effort to leave comments, regardless of whether they were positive or negative. I shall take encouragement from the positive encouraging comments but at the same time, even though I may not have or be replying to all comments, I will also not ignore or disregard the negative comments/feedback but to take such negative feedback seriously and learn from them, then use them as motivation for me to try harder to improve and make better videos moving forward. THANK YOU ALL! Thanks all for dropping by my channel. Best Regards Doc
@The Habits Doctor, thank you for this informative video! I'm embarrassed to admit my ignorance in that I thought Jasmine and Basmati rice were only white, AND grew that way, oh dear!🙄
@Renee CA Hey Renee, it is a very common misconception! that was why I made this video, hoping to help people, who are trying to make better food choices, understand the different types of rice better. But looking at the many negative and even angry comments below, I might have made some people even more confused by my video! Sigh. I shall learn from this and endeavour to make better and clearer videos in the future. Thanks so much for dropping by my channel and making the effort to drop me a comment, thanks! really much appreciated, best regards, Doc
Interesting and nicely presented, not too long. I think we are now clear you can't make comparisons between different rice cultivars without specifying how the rice has been processed, but we're still not clear what rice to go for if you're T2, as I am. For the record, I tend to buy brown basmati. Is this a wise decision? I also hear parboiled white is a bit better than plain white rice too.
yeah, I hardly find red basmati rice anywhere. It is very uncommon and not easy to find. I got my red basmati rice from a supermarket in Singapore www.fairprice.com.sg/product/acenuwara-red-basmathi-rice-13078502 It is a red basmati rice from Sri Lanka
I am from Pakistan and have seen lots of white and brown basmati rice but haven't heard of red Basmati rice though 😜. There's also dozens if not hundreds of subcategories of the basmati rice
Thanks for clarifying the difference between the colours of Basmati Rice. I thought it was healthier than other types of rice but now it’s clear that it is the Brown and Red Basmati rice that are healthier than the popular white one.
@@beaerconwald6745 Not true, the fiber(red,brown cover) has been removed from white Basmati rice. Therefore, white Basmati has a HIGHER glycemic index but red or brown (fiber not removed) have a LOWER glycemic index.
@@daw7773Thank you for your input but a dietician in Germany told me that white basmati rice has lower GI than other white rice. That was what I was trying to say.
@@beaerconwald6745 Yes , I was not comparing other white rices. I was comparing white basmati rice to red and brown basmati rice which has a lower glycemic index than white basmati rice because it’s fiber shell has not been removed. Similarly brown rice (fiber shell intact) has a much lower glycemic index than white rice(fiber shell removed).
In India, traditionally the best rice is supposed to be parboiled brown Basmathi rice. And it has a GI of something like 30s which is excellent for any rice. Please doctor, if you can gather data on it, do a video after your investigation. Thanks.
Again stupid assumptions that have not be looked into full. I'm actually shocked how stupid most people are. Even though the internet has been around for min 20 years in developing countries. Not going to explain as all of you lazy people need to start looking up info you self. parbroild rice is half way between white rice and brown rice, its still consider white rice. Its been half polished to take off the tough outer bran. Brown rice is better than any type of white rice
Hi Dr Chan I was hoping you'd explain which one is healthier to eat, to digest , the brown and red against the white polished rice and good over all better.thanks
*Alternative to **_white rice (73)_** Glycemic Index = 100 (glucose/simple sugar)(boiled)* Brown rice = 50 to 55 Whole grain basmati rice = 50 to 52 Steamed brown rice = 50 Red rice = 55 Black rice = 42 to 45 Wild rice = 45 The glycemic index is a value assigned to foods based on how slowly or how quickly those foods cause increases in blood glucose levels. *The lower the NUMBER the better.* Therefore, Basmati rice is much lower in sugar than plain white rice.
@@BC-cd3pz U'r welcome. I've kept my glucose sugar just below or at pre-diabetes levels. Average A1C = (L) 5.6 to (H) 6.1. And I was able to do that via my PCP (doctor), my endocrinologist & nutritionist, plus tons of great info like this YT channel. In this day and age of internet info, people can easily control & maintain their glucose levels. 👍
Thanks for clearing that up...refined white rice is higher on the glycemic scale for diabetics ,at least thatz what I got from your vid...thanks ..brown rice has the most nutrients still intact..
I had went to Nepal from Tibet a decade more ago! I had no appetite for food in Tibet although feeling hungry. Almost 20 days! But when I reached Nepal through winding slopes. My first meal with Brasmathi rice was so inviting that i gained appetite instantly! It was so herbal enriched with the rice and when i am back to Malaysia i could not find any eateries that can match the flavours i had in Nepal! Simply splendid!
Dr Chan, I'm 56 yrs old, a GP in UK, of Indian origin and lived in one of the major Basmati rice producing states for 23 years. I was ignorant of the this knowlege till I saw your video. I cannot thank you enough. Would you mind if I showed this to the large population of Bangladeshi and Pakistani patients we have in our practice? We are a practice with the largest percentage of above ethinicity patients in our surgery and the majority of our patients are from Bangladeshi surgery. Once again thank you for your highly educating video. BTW I am type 2 diabetic, medicine controlled and am looking to wrestle my diabetes by improving my diet.
I was borderline Diabetic and simply losing some weight really helped me reverse this and HbA1C now normal. Stick to wholegrain and complex carbs including fruits and vegetables especially legumes with lots of fibre and it's all good.
If you drink 1 tbsp apple cider vinegar in a glass of water before eating the rice, the GI will be "lowered" since the ACV will cause a slower releasing of the starches. Or so I've been told, and it feels like it works! (for me) And of course, if the meal contains (healthy) fat, the total GI for the meal will be lowered.
Hi hi, thanks so much for making the effort to leave a comment. It's still a steep learning process for me, I shall continue to try harder to improve and make better videos. Best regards.
I am 52. I have been in this earth for 18980 days. I eat white basmati all the time and I had no idea. Thank you soo much for educating us. I will now eat red or brown basmati. Life changing. Thank you :-)
You described about differences of different color rice, but you didn’t say which rice is good for health. Also can you explain about parboiled rice and if it’s good for health. Thank you!
@@Lucky73678 My endocrinologist said to me that all Wheats is bad So me as a diabetic is going crazy over here because sometimes I would like to have rice🙄
After this over 4 min talk the Dr should say this in half a minute. There are white basmati rice , brown basmati rice and Red basmati. The white comes from any of the other basmati rice but has removed shell which has less nutrient so should be said why the shell need to be removed, waste of time waiting on this important information over 4 min? and never was said.☹️
I have been eating imported from India Basmati white rice for years, and white Jasmine rice imported from Thailand from any years. I like both styles. I did not realize that bot Basmati and Jasmine have red and brown rices as well. Thanks you for this information.
Ok. Clarification, I am not a diabetic, but have insulin issues. I normally do not eat rice due to the glycemic nature. So yesterday, I indulged. I keep a mix of brown, red, white, wild rice blend and quinoa I use one e in a while with lentils. I am unsure as the variety. I had a 1/2 cup of lentils with rice mixture and 1/2 cup of homemade fresh ground pork. This would make the rice mixture a 1/4 of the bulk of the food. My blood glucose did not seem to spike much. It was a normal low carb bump. I am going to test this some more, but if my body does not react to whole grain rice that bad, I may use it more. I will look to make sure the other rice varieties I buy are the whole grain basmati next time. I really have no idea what this was. I normally substitute cauliflower as my rice for most meals and keep very little rice on hand.
I think the Ponni rice from India has the lowest GI of 38 according to report. I did a comparison between organic Basmati rice and Ponni rice and the result was a lower blood sugar reading with the Ponni but cannot be conclusive because this was not tested based on HBA1C but random fasting.
Doctor while clarifying the doubt in this video on basmati rice Red/ brown/ white - please recommend as a doctor what type of rice is better to consume for prediabetic or diabetic people. Us boiled rice a better option totally?
Oops my bad! Sorry if I had confused you more. 😅😅 I shall learn from this and try to do better for my future videos. Thanks for your feedback! Best Regards, Doc
From what I understand, Southeast Asia rice need to grow in fields flooded with water; therefore, the rice absorbs the chemistry in that water. Unfortunately, nowadays, water in these areas is very polluted and studies show that this rice has higher level of arsenic than the rice grow on the mountain sides or inland like Basmati rice. What do the doctor think? Does this theory sound far fetched or have some merit?
Of all the comments I found yours to be the most valid ones. I buy Double Good basmati from Dehradun in Indian Himalayas, they taste the best. Punjab basmati which is famous the world over is too inferior in taste compared to the Doube good dehradun basmati rice. Thanks
Thank you! This helps clear the confusion. Now we have a starting point to compare GI index. Here in the U.S. so many of us think Basmati is "one thing" unto itself. I am type 2 and I like Basmati very much.. now I can search for the best option. you state clearly that you might compare GI in another video, so ignore the complainers who want it all handed to them on a silver platter. (They probably want you to prepare dinner for them, too)....
Hi Philip, your comment cracked me up :-) I had taken a break from making videos for my channel, it's been more than 3 months since my last video, mainly because I was discouraged and I was beginning to wonder if all the heart, hard work spent planning and making the videos was making any difference or benefitting anyone. Reading your comment has encouraged me, maybe I should make a 'comeback' :-). Thank you Philip. Blessings, Dr Chan.
@@TheHabitsDoctor I haven't watched any of your other videos, (yet) but this was straight forward, clear and informative. Next time I shop for Basmati I will make different choices. One small step at a time can make important changes in the long run. Thanks again for helping me to understand and make a simple but effective change. It DOES make a difference!. Philip
Hello… how true that even despite brown rice is more nutritious than white rice, brown rice has more arsenic than white? Please clarify. Thank you doctor.
I’ve literally heard by so many people that the best most healthiest rice out there available is called parboiled rice. I have no idea what that is but everyone keeps telling me it’s the best rice. Very Low arsenic, low glycemic index, highly nutritious. Brown rice I’ve learned has an extremely high levels of arsenic. I did not know that.
Still kinda confused Are there any healthier organic brands of white and yellow rice? I know basmati rice is still white rice but is it healthy. I been eating more brown and black rice cuz I know its healthier. I still wanna eat white and yellow rice just healthier brand
What is your take on basmati rice specifically sold as Low GI Basmati Rice? It's generally the polished but I've noticed a difference in flavor and texture, likely with it being aged longer. Is it just marketing or is it actually low GI despite being polished rice?
Thanks for dropping by my channel and making the effort to leave a comment. Much appreciated. I hope I have cleared up the confusion and not added to it! 😅
Cleaning the confusion, but still left confused! from the comment I thought I was the only one left more confused than I came in. I was look for my in-depth as to which one is healthier. He didn't address this at all.
Make video, if someone asks... you show them this video, you save 4 minutes 26 seconds of your life per patient or person. lol... Love this video, no ads or sponsors mid video.
Dr Chen Is it possible to specify the G. I. in the different rice. Which I believe is the main concern. Would you agree that what you eat in the most natural form is best. I also have another question. My wife has created a mixture of natural ginger, (graded) honey,lemon rind/ juice. In hot water as a tea. I have been drinking this. I am wondering what affect or health benefits are received.
The ridiculous confusion is some called the unpolished or whole grain rice to brown rice even if the color is not brown. The reason I landed on this video is because I saw an ad about two doctors men and women showing "brown rice" vs white rice which one causes diabetic. Try to use general terms wholegrains rice or unpolished rice instead of brown rice.
I have read that one may reduce arsenic content of rice buy cooking it in a large volume of water and pouring off the water when cooked rather than using a rice cooker. That makes sense. How about cooking the rice in a large volume of water, then pouring off the water before it is fully cooked, then finishing the cooking in a rice cooker to achieve the drier rice result? It seems to me that would be the better method.
Dr Chan would be more helpful if his discussions would treat the arsenic question with regard to basmati brown or red rice, the whole grain rice varieties. I want to know if the brown basmati rice I bought from India is significantly lower in arsenic than other brown rice. How does it compare in this respect with California grown brown basmati rice or with California grown brown rice? I am now relying on an old Consumer Reports statement that Indian rice is low in arsenic. Would I do just as well to buy Californina brown rice?
Hi Dr Chan, thanks for this video. Appreciate your help to compare GI of Basmati White vs Jasmine white, Basmati Brown vs Jasmine brown & Basmati Red vs Jasmine Red rice . Thanks
00:05 Dr. Chan clears up confusion between Basmati and Brown rice 00:40 Choosing between Basmati Rice and Brown Rice for Diabetes 01:14 Basmati rice is a specific variety of rice with no indication of color or whole grain status 01:49 Different colors of Basmati rice indicate whole grain presence. 02:25 Basmati rice and brown rice are both whole grain rice with different outer layers 02:57 White Basmati rice is a refined grain, not whole grain. 03:33 Clarifying the confusion between Basmati rice and Brown rice 04:07 Comparison between Basmati rice and Brown Jasmine rice
So true I use to work at a rice factory, begin with the padi when that shell off that's call cargo (that's how it export to other countries) the cargo polish that's brown rice then it polish again that's the light brown rice then it polish again that's white rice. whole grain white rice,semi whole grain and broken white rice and that's has 2 types broken 1 and broken 2
Thanks dr. For information and i am a farmer in India, we have a red rice which are nutritious, aromatic and delicious they are not available on store,only locally grown any one can try
My confusion about basmati rice or white rice and brown rice before I watch this video is 70% but after i watched the video my confusion is completely 100% 😀
Oops my bad! Sorry if I had confused you more. 😅😅 I shall learn from this and try to do better for my future videos. Thanks for your feedback! Best Regards, Doc
Brown basmati rice from India has much less arsenic than just brown rice from the U.S. Also freezing the rice after cooking and reheating lowers the GI.
Is Brown rice high in arsenic content ? Or is it just propaganda to increase sales of Quinoa ? Do we have to soak brown rice overnight to get rid of arsenic? Plz advise. Thks
People with T2D are more interested in the blood glucose responses in the following cases: 1) brown vs white rice of the same type, 2) brown vs brown of different type and 3) white vs white of different type. Ultimately, people want to have the knowledge to make their own decision. Thanks!
If you are insulin resistant, you should not be eating rice at all. It makes no difference if you eat white rice, brown rice, or Korean mixed rice. The spike is nearly identical. If you don't believe it, do a glucose test for each one and compare the results. The only reason you would eat brown rice is for a little bit more fiber and nutrients. With 45 grams of carbs in one cup of rice, that's a lot of starch that will turn into sugar. Unfortunately, there is no close substitute for rice. Quinoa has similar texture to rice, but it too is high in carbohydrates. If you don't want to give up rice altogether, your best alternative is to cut the portion in half or more. Increase the amount of vegetables, meat, and healthy fat in your diet to fill you up.
Excellent teaching video, Dr. Chan, sir. I find that as an American, living in a suburban areà, my problem is twofold in nature: the first being, my ignorance of the differing varieties within both Basmati and Jasmine rice; and, secondly, lack of availability. Perhaps with the new knowledge I have gained, I will explore online ordering. Would love your opinion on black rice, too. Much respect and gratitude.
Thanks for dropping by my channel and making the effort to leave a comment. Much appreciated. I hope I have cleared up the confusion and not added to it! 😅😅
The motivation for this video came from the many times I get asked by my patients this question about Basmati Rice vs Brown Rice, which made me realised that many people do not realise that Basmati Rice can be White Rice, Red Rice, Brown Rice, whilst at the same time, Brown Rice can come from Basmati Rice, Jasmine Rice, other types of rice. If you have found this video, I am delighted that my effort in making this video has not gone to waste, but if I have failed to achieve the goal of clearing this up this confusion or worse, even added to the confusion, then my bad! I shall reflect on how I could have done this video better and improve myself for future videos.
Ever since I posted this video a few months ago, it has received many comments from viewers, some positive and also many negative and even angry comments. I want to thank everyone who made the effort to leave comments, regardless of whether they were positive or negative. I shall take encouragement from the positive encouraging comments but at the same time, even though I may not have or be replying to all comments, I will also not ignore or disregard the negative comments/feedback but to take such negative feedback seriously and learn from them, then use them as motivation for me to try harder to improve and make better videos moving forward. THANK YOU ALL!
Thanks all for dropping by my channel.
Best Regards
Doc
@The Habits Doctor, thank you for this informative video! I'm embarrassed to admit my ignorance in that I thought Jasmine and Basmati rice were only white, AND grew that way, oh dear!🙄
@Renee CA Hey Renee, it is a very common misconception! that was why I made this video, hoping to help people, who are trying to make better food choices, understand the different types of rice better. But looking at the many negative and even angry comments below, I might have made some people even more confused by my video! Sigh. I shall learn from this and endeavour to make better and clearer videos in the future. Thanks so much for dropping by my channel and making the effort to drop me a comment, thanks! really much appreciated, best regards, Doc
Interesting and nicely presented, not too long. I think we are now clear you can't make comparisons between different rice cultivars without specifying how the rice has been processed, but we're still not clear what rice to go for if you're T2, as I am. For the record, I tend to buy brown basmati. Is this a wise decision? I also hear parboiled white is a bit better than plain white rice too.
Hello dear yin thank The Habits Doctor
Ssssssssss
Doc your volume is too low. Turn it up a bit.
Thank you so very much Dr. Chan watching from Kano State Nigeria west Africa ❤
This is my answer. I've looked up an answer to this question about a year ago without finding it. Thank you! God bless you.
wow I am from India but even I was unaware Basmati came in Brown and Red variety
yeah, I hardly find red basmati rice anywhere. It is very uncommon and not easy to find. I got my red basmati rice from a supermarket in Singapore www.fairprice.com.sg/product/acenuwara-red-basmathi-rice-13078502
It is a red basmati rice from Sri Lanka
😂
We get brown basmati rice in certain supermarkets in the US.. Amazon has everything..😊
@@TheHabitsDoctor l
I am from Pakistan and have seen lots of white and brown basmati rice but haven't heard of red Basmati rice though 😜.
There's also dozens if not hundreds of subcategories of the basmati rice
Thanks for clarifying the difference between the colours of Basmati Rice. I thought it was healthier than other types of rice but now it’s clear that it is the Brown and Red Basmati rice that are healthier than the popular white one.
Actually, White basmati rice has lower GI than other white rice varieties.
@@beaerconwald6745
Not true, the fiber(red,brown cover) has been removed from white Basmati rice. Therefore, white Basmati has a HIGHER glycemic index but red or brown (fiber not removed) have a LOWER glycemic index.
@@daw7773Thank you for your input but a dietician in Germany told me that white basmati rice has lower GI than other white rice. That was what I was trying to say.
@@beaerconwald6745 Yes , I was not comparing other white rices. I was comparing white basmati rice to red and brown basmati rice which has a lower glycemic index than white basmati rice because it’s fiber shell has not been removed. Similarly brown rice (fiber shell intact) has a much lower glycemic index than white rice(fiber shell removed).
In India, traditionally the best rice is supposed to be parboiled brown Basmathi rice. And it has a GI of something like 30s which is excellent for any rice. Please doctor, if you can gather data on it, do a video after your investigation. Thanks.
Yess for some crazy reason when i eat it i doesn't spike my blood sugar
parboiled just means it is already cooked
Again stupid assumptions that have not be looked into full.
I'm actually shocked how stupid most people are. Even though the internet has been around for min 20 years in developing countries.
Not going to explain as all of you lazy people need to start looking up info you self.
parbroild rice is half way between white rice and brown rice, its still consider white rice. Its been half polished to take off the tough outer bran.
Brown rice is better than any type of white rice
Hi Dr Chan I was hoping you'd explain which one is healthier to eat, to digest , the brown and red against the white polished rice and good over all better.thanks
Wholegrain. White is processed, a bit like wholegrain bread/flour versus white.
this is very confusing. you should answer if the rice is good or not in a diabetic person
agreed! as far as I know being diabetes myself... all rice types are carbohydrates n will spike glucose in blood!
*Alternative to **_white rice (73)_** Glycemic Index = 100 (glucose/simple sugar)(boiled)*
Brown rice = 50 to 55
Whole grain basmati rice = 50 to 52
Steamed brown rice = 50
Red rice = 55
Black rice = 42 to 45
Wild rice = 45
The glycemic index is a value assigned to foods based on how slowly or how quickly those foods cause increases in blood glucose levels. *The lower the NUMBER the better.* Therefore, Basmati rice is much lower in sugar than plain white rice.
@@SooperFlye Thanks for the great information
@@BC-cd3pz U'r welcome. I've kept my glucose sugar just below or at pre-diabetes levels. Average A1C = (L) 5.6 to (H) 6.1. And I was able to do that via my PCP (doctor), my endocrinologist & nutritionist, plus tons of great info like this YT channel. In this day and age of internet info, people can easily control & maintain their glucose levels. 👍
@@SooperFlye 👍
Thanks for clearing that up...refined white rice is higher on the glycemic scale for diabetics ,at least thatz what I got from your vid...thanks ..brown rice has the most nutrients still intact..
I had went to Nepal from Tibet a decade more ago! I had no appetite for food in Tibet although feeling hungry. Almost 20 days! But when I reached Nepal through winding slopes. My first meal with Brasmathi rice was so inviting that i gained appetite instantly! It was so herbal enriched with the rice and when i am back to Malaysia i could not find any eateries that can match the flavours i had in Nepal! Simply splendid!
Dr Chan, I'm 56 yrs old, a GP in UK, of Indian origin and lived in one of the major Basmati rice producing states for 23 years. I was ignorant of the this knowlege till I saw your video. I cannot thank you enough. Would you mind if I showed this to the large population of Bangladeshi and Pakistani patients we have in our practice? We are a practice with the largest percentage of above ethinicity patients in our surgery and the majority of our patients are from Bangladeshi surgery.
Once again thank you for your highly educating video. BTW I am type 2 diabetic, medicine controlled and am looking to wrestle my diabetes by improving my diet.
Glad you found it useful! Cheers
I was borderline Diabetic and simply losing some weight really helped me reverse this and HbA1C now normal.
Stick to wholegrain and complex carbs including fruits and vegetables especially legumes with lots of fibre and it's all good.
I have checked kachi Tilda Basmati Rice. Washed many (8 to 10) times before cooking. Cooked cooled and reheated does not spike blood sugar level.
If you drink 1 tbsp apple cider vinegar in a glass of water before eating the rice, the GI will be "lowered" since the ACV will cause a slower releasing of the starches. Or so I've been told, and it feels like it works! (for me)
And of course, if the meal contains (healthy) fat, the total GI for the meal will be lowered.
Thank you, Dr. Chan, for the clarity in explaining the confusion in Basmati rice.
Hi hi, thanks so much for making the effort to leave a comment. It's still a steep learning process for me, I shall continue to try harder to improve and make better videos. Best regards.
Thank you for clearing this up Dr. Chan!
I am 52. I have been in this earth for 18980 days. I eat white basmati all the time and I had no idea. Thank you soo much for educating us. I will now eat red or brown basmati. Life changing. Thank you :-)
So, which one is healthier?
Great video! If only you answered the initial question that your patients had!
You described about differences of different color rice, but you didn’t say which rice is good for health. Also can you explain about parboiled rice and if it’s good for health. Thank you!
Parboiled is just semi cooked rice. It's only for convenience. No other difference than it cooking faster.
None. All bad.
All wheat is bad.
Eat millets and more veg
@@Lucky73678 My endocrinologist said to me that all Wheats is bad So me as a diabetic is going crazy over here because sometimes I would like to have rice🙄
All rice are not good! Best is to not eat any at all!
Just have brown rice because it's not processed at all although eat as little as you can cuz carbs is not very good for you.
After this over 4 min talk the Dr should say this in half a minute. There are white basmati rice , brown basmati rice and Red basmati. The white comes from any of the other basmati rice but has removed shell which has less nutrient so should be said why the shell need to be removed, waste of time waiting on this important information over 4 min? and never was said.☹️
Thank you for saving my time
What did you expect off youtube. Do you really think a legit doctor has the time to make 7 videos a week. These people do anything for views
This dr is china or philipino..kkk..basmati rice Basmati rice..he also basmati rice..kkk
I was just about to post this. What a useless yapped this guy is.
I have been eating imported from India Basmati white rice for years, and white Jasmine rice imported from Thailand from any years. I like both styles. I did not realize that bot Basmati and Jasmine have red and brown rices as well. Thanks you for this information.
Ok. Clarification, I am not a diabetic, but have insulin issues. I normally do not eat rice due to the glycemic nature. So yesterday, I indulged. I keep a mix of brown, red, white, wild rice blend and quinoa I use one e in a while with lentils. I am unsure as the variety. I had a 1/2 cup of lentils with rice mixture and 1/2 cup of homemade fresh ground pork. This would make the rice mixture a 1/4 of the bulk of the food. My blood glucose did not seem to spike much. It was a normal low carb bump. I am going to test this some more, but if my body does not react to whole grain rice that bad, I may use it more. I will look to make sure the other rice varieties I buy are the whole grain basmati next time. I really have no idea what this was. I normally substitute cauliflower as my rice for most meals and keep very little rice on hand.
Basmati rice is long grain rice
It is famous for its smell or excellent odour when cooked. Dehradun basmati rice from India is best quality variety .
I like Tilda. :)
I think the Ponni rice from India has the lowest GI of 38 according to report.
I did a comparison between organic Basmati rice and Ponni rice and the result was a lower blood sugar reading with the Ponni but cannot be conclusive because this was not tested based on HBA1C but random fasting.
Doctor while clarifying the doubt in this video on basmati rice Red/ brown/ white - please recommend as a doctor what type of rice is better to consume for prediabetic or diabetic people. Us boiled rice a better option totally?
So which one is better Basmati rice or jasmine rice????🙄
Thank you again for keeping the confusion alive!
Oops my bad! Sorry if I had confused you more. 😅😅 I shall learn from this and try to do better for my future videos. Thanks for your feedback! Best Regards, Doc
It was very clear to me. Sorry u had a problem.
Hi Dr...still no clarity as to which rice is better.
@@TheHabitsDoctor What bullshit. You explained it in detail. If someone didn't understand it, they are overdue for a reading comprehension course.
@@saraswathis7433 Always the least processed food is best.
Helpful video about rice, and your English is so so good. Thank you God bless
Dr Chan , thankyou for explaining to me about arsenic in rice. I look forward to your explaining it further.
Hey Kathy, I just made and uploaded a new video on Arsenic in Rice - ruclips.net/video/dPsBBl-bkgc/видео.html
hope you'll find it useful. Cheers Doc
From what I understand, Southeast Asia rice need to grow in fields flooded with water; therefore, the rice absorbs the chemistry in that water. Unfortunately, nowadays, water in these areas is very polluted and studies show that this rice has higher level of arsenic than the rice grow on the mountain sides or inland like Basmati rice. What do the doctor think? Does this theory sound far fetched or have some merit?
Of all the comments I found yours to be the most valid ones. I buy Double Good basmati from Dehradun in Indian Himalayas, they taste the best. Punjab basmati which is famous the world over is too inferior in taste compared to the Doube good dehradun basmati rice. Thanks
Makes sense ,thanks
But we don't know which one is better in terms of nutritional value...and diabetes, which one is better?
It would be nice to know what other suggestions the Doctor has to maintain Health
Thankyou Dr Chan. Very informative.
Thanks for explaining the difference between brown, red, and white basmati rice.
Glad you found it useful. Blessings, Dr Chan
Good explanation, but what about black rice?
Which one is healthier?
Which Rice is better for us? Brown rice or refined rice
Brown
Thank you! This helps clear the confusion. Now we have a starting point to compare GI index. Here in the U.S. so many of us think Basmati is "one thing" unto itself. I am type 2 and I like Basmati very much.. now I can search for the best option. you state clearly that you might compare GI in another video, so ignore the complainers who want it all handed to them on a silver platter. (They probably want you to prepare dinner for them, too)....
Hi Philip, your comment cracked me up :-)
I had taken a break from making videos for my channel, it's been more than 3 months since my last video, mainly because I was discouraged and I was beginning to wonder if all the heart, hard work spent planning and making the videos was making any difference or benefitting anyone. Reading your comment has encouraged me, maybe I should make a 'comeback' :-). Thank you Philip. Blessings, Dr Chan.
@@TheHabitsDoctor I haven't watched any of your other videos, (yet) but this was straight forward, clear and informative. Next time I shop for Basmati I will make different choices. One small step at a time can make important changes in the long run. Thanks again for helping me to understand and make a simple but effective change. It DOES make a difference!. Philip
Hello… how true that even despite brown rice is more nutritious than white rice, brown rice has more arsenic than white? Please clarify. Thank you doctor.
I’ve literally heard by so many people that the best most healthiest rice out there available is called parboiled rice. I have no idea what that is but everyone keeps telling me it’s the best rice. Very Low arsenic, low glycemic index, highly nutritious. Brown rice I’ve learned has an extremely high levels of arsenic. I did not know that.
So which rice is best for health?
So which is good for health
Still kinda confused
Are there any healthier organic brands of white and yellow rice? I know basmati rice is still white rice but is it healthy. I been eating more brown and black rice cuz I know its healthier. I still wanna eat white and yellow rice just healthier brand
Didn't answer the question. Which one is better?
Yes, i also waiting for the answer
Why not straight to the point
.... Which one is good for diabetic???
I noticed these video makers never bother to check for viewers' questions and answer them!
@@Wntr446 they are only quick to thank those who praise them blindly but can't answer queries, 😫😫
Never answer which rice??
What is your take on basmati rice specifically sold as Low GI Basmati Rice? It's generally the polished but I've noticed a difference in flavor and texture, likely with it being aged longer. Is it just marketing or is it actually low GI despite being polished rice?
I take it that both brown and red rice are better for diabetics than white rice.
What about between red and brown rice, which is better for diabetics?
I didn't get it which rice is healthier for blood sugar people?
Doc, to start with...is Brown rice a good idea? Why?
THANK YOU DOC FOR CLEARING THE CONFUSION.
Thanks for dropping by my channel and making the effort to leave a comment. Much appreciated. I hope I have cleared up the confusion and not added to it! 😅
👍😂
Which one is better for diabetics?
You didn't touch th main issue
So can someone tell me which rice is good for pre diabetic is brown rice good?
It is not clear I think. Finally what is to be taken doctorji
Cleaning the confusion, but still left confused! from the comment I thought I was the only one left more confused than I came in. I was look for my in-depth as to which one is healthier. He didn't address this at all.
When you buy ur rice. Look at the label and compare which is higher in carbs..simple.
Is brown or red basmati rice healthier?
hello dr chan, very good explaination. i'm from malaysia, welcome to terengganu..
Thank you! 😃
Thank you so much Dr Chan, you talk utter sense. I’ve always known that brown rice is much better for you. Please stay safe and well too xxx Mags
You brought the question which one is better but in the end no answer was given.. Where in Singapore you were studying again? NUS?
Make video, if someone asks... you show them this video, you save 4 minutes 26 seconds of your life per patient or person. lol... Love this video, no ads or sponsors mid video.
But the Dr did not address the question his patients ask.. Which is better?
They are the same rice.
So which rice is good for diabetic?
Did not answer really the topic
What Rice Is good for MTHFR disorder?
Dr Chen
Is it possible to specify the G. I. in the different rice. Which I believe is the main concern. Would you agree that what you eat in the most natural form is best.
I also have another question.
My wife has created a mixture of natural ginger, (graded) honey,lemon rind/ juice.
In hot water as a tea. I have been drinking this. I am wondering what affect or health benefits are received.
The ridiculous confusion is some called the unpolished or whole grain rice to brown rice even if the color is not brown. The reason I landed on this video is because I saw an ad about two doctors men and women showing "brown rice" vs white rice which one causes diabetic. Try to use general terms wholegrains rice or unpolished rice instead of brown rice.
thank you Dr Chan, this was exactly what I wanted to know.
So, you didn't clear up anything for me.
Horribly answered and did not cover the main problem.. is brown rice better than refined rice??
I have read that one may reduce arsenic content of rice buy cooking it in a large volume of water and pouring off the water when cooked rather than using a rice cooker. That makes sense. How about cooking the rice in a large volume of water, then pouring off the water before it is fully cooked, then finishing the cooking in a rice cooker to achieve the drier rice result? It seems to me that would be the better method.
Dr Chan would be more helpful if his discussions would treat the arsenic question with regard to basmati brown or red rice, the whole grain rice varieties. I want to know if the brown basmati rice I bought from India is significantly lower in arsenic than other brown rice. How does it compare in this respect with California grown brown basmati rice or with California grown brown rice? I am now relying on an old Consumer Reports statement that Indian rice is low in arsenic. Would I do just as well to buy Californina brown rice?
What best to buy in store?
Thank you, Dr. Chan.
You're most welcome!
I take pumpkin seeds on a daily basis because I have mild BPH. Now I have no problem with urination.
You didn’t clear anything. Which one is the best.
Happy to discover your channel.
Glad you found it useful. Blessings, Dr Chan
Hi Dr Chan, thanks for this video. Appreciate your help to compare GI of Basmati White vs Jasmine white, Basmati Brown vs Jasmine brown & Basmati Red vs Jasmine Red rice . Thanks
00:05 Dr. Chan clears up confusion between Basmati and Brown rice
00:40 Choosing between Basmati Rice and Brown Rice for Diabetes
01:14 Basmati rice is a specific variety of rice with no indication of color or whole grain status
01:49 Different colors of Basmati rice indicate whole grain presence.
02:25 Basmati rice and brown rice are both whole grain rice with different outer layers
02:57 White Basmati rice is a refined grain, not whole grain.
03:33 Clarifying the confusion between Basmati rice and Brown rice
04:07 Comparison between Basmati rice and Brown Jasmine rice
Hi Dr Chan. Thank you so much for your sharing
Simple and clear - excellent!
Glad you found it useful, Blessings, Dr Chan
Very informative Dr Chan!!! 😊👏
Thank you Dr Chan so good to know the comparisons. Very interesting topic ⚘
You didn’t clear up anything about the nutritional values or glycemic index.
Very informative. Thank you Dr. Chan.
Glad you found it useful. Thanks for dropping by my channel and leaving a comment. Cheers, Doc
So true I use to work at a rice factory, begin with the padi when that shell off that's call cargo (that's how it export to other countries) the cargo polish that's brown rice then it polish again that's the light brown rice then it polish again that's white rice. whole grain white rice,semi whole grain and broken white rice and that's has 2 types broken 1 and broken 2
Didn’t understand so which rice is good
Thanks dr. For information and i am a farmer in India, we have a red rice which are nutritious, aromatic and delicious they are not available on store,only locally grown any one can try
How's Jyoti brown basmati rice on arsenic ?
Yes very confusing. Which rice is good for diabetic?
My confusion about basmati rice or white rice and brown rice before I watch this video is 70% but after i watched the video my confusion is completely 100% 😀
🙈😂😂😂
Oops my bad! Sorry if I had confused you more. 😅😅 I shall learn from this and try to do better for my future videos. Thanks for your feedback! Best Regards, Doc
Brown basmati rice from India has much less arsenic than just brown rice from the U.S. Also freezing the rice after cooking and reheating lowers the GI.
Thanks Dr. Chan🇺🇸
Thank you for dropping by my channel and making the effort to drop me a comment, thanks! Greetings from Singapore! Best Regards Doc
Is Brown rice high in arsenic content ? Or is it just propaganda to increase sales of Quinoa ? Do we have to soak brown rice overnight to get rid of arsenic? Plz advise. Thks
I just made and uploaded a new video on Arsenic in Rice - ruclips.net/video/dPsBBl-bkgc/видео.html
hope you'll find it useful. Cheers Doc
hi doctor if compare to a bowl of ordinary white rice with a bowl of white basmathi rice....which one is good...doctor...plz rpy me
People with T2D are more interested in the blood glucose responses in the following cases: 1) brown vs white rice of the same type, 2) brown vs brown of different type and 3) white vs white of different type. Ultimately, people want to have the knowledge to make their own decision. Thanks!
If you are insulin resistant, you should not be eating rice at all. It makes no difference if you eat white rice, brown rice, or Korean mixed rice. The spike is nearly identical. If you don't believe it, do a glucose test for each one and compare the results. The only reason you would eat brown rice is for a little bit more fiber and nutrients. With 45 grams of carbs in one cup of rice, that's a lot of starch that will turn into sugar. Unfortunately, there is no close substitute for rice. Quinoa has similar texture to rice, but it too is high in carbohydrates. If you don't want to give up rice altogether, your best alternative is to cut the portion in half or more. Increase the amount of vegetables, meat, and healthy fat in your diet to fill you up.
@@onespeedlite I try all vegetables on my plates add rice doesn't matter brown, white, or any kind of rice I just eat 1 tablespoon of
rice,,,,
Just tell us which is better to eat . Basmati. Brown or white rice.
Thanks for clarifying
What’s most healthy rice
I use brown basmati rice , I don’t know if they are more nutritious than White basmati rice
Excellent teaching video, Dr. Chan, sir. I find that as an American, living in a suburban areà, my problem is twofold in nature: the first being, my ignorance of the differing varieties within both Basmati and Jasmine rice; and, secondly, lack of availability. Perhaps with the new knowledge I have gained, I will explore online ordering. Would love your opinion on black rice, too. Much respect and gratitude.
I am looking forward to watching and learning! Thanks for clearing up the confusion!!
Thanks for dropping by my channel and making the effort to leave a comment. Much appreciated. I hope I have cleared up the confusion and not added to it! 😅😅
everything I have found in my research does NOT include portion size...very important info
Thank you.
Samuel from Brazil.
Hi Doc. Matta rice is different in brown rice?