MOHAMMED HIJAB - PHILOSOPHY OR QURAN?! | SHAMSI
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 окт 2021
- Islam, Sunnah, way of the Salaf
➜ www.salaf.com
TERRORISM IS NEVER ISLAMIC
➜ www.islamagainstextremism.com
Listen to Quran with English Translation Online
➜ www.giveaquraan.org/quraan-audio
Subscribe to this channel for more content like this, and please give this video a thumbs-up and share it across all social media platforms.
Abu Hurraira narrated that The Prophet ﷺ said:
❝Whoever invites to guidance will be rewarded like those who follow him in guidance are rewarded, and that will not decrease the reward of those who have followed him❞.
[Collected by Imām Muslim]
To get in touch with a Muslim community or attend gatherings of knowledge that are local to you, email us and we will direct you in-shā Allah. We also welcome questions from non-Muslims who want to understand Islām.
Email: admin@dusunnah.com
SUPPORT MASJID DAARUSSUNNAH
➜ www.paypal.me/dusunnah
#speakerscorner #dawah #Islam
Mohammed Hijab Philosophy in dawah▶ruclips.net/video/T-o0dAEA1ao/видео.html
My ALLAH bless you ameen 🌺
#GoldenWorldSami
@@urduking835 ameen
@@urduking835 zq
The best book for establishing Allahs existence , legislations and wisdoms is the Quran !
No doubt
I cannot find this book, not even as a title on google
is that definitely the name?
@@mohamedorayith4626 يقول القرآن الكريم هو الكتاب
Philosophy is how a lot of people went astray, May Allah protect us all
Yes.... Like a bid'ah
They went away by thinking logically?
The best way of da'wah is the da'wah of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ . Qur'ān and Sunnah, thats it, walhamdulillah.
True but how are we gonna guide the Atheist when they don't even believe in god? I feel like this is where philosophy comes in handy.
And also I am not doubting the Quran and Sunnah.infact I believe that Allah is the only God and Prophet Muhammad S.A.W is the messenger of god
Anybody that claims that the Quran isn't independent enough as evidence againts the atheist needs to take a deep look at themselves and review their emaan.
Well you need a brain to understand the Quran
You cannot understand Quran without checking it against reality. We are instructed not to believe blindly, but believe by logic, reasoning and evidence. We need to stop limiting Quran to our own limited world views. It's much larger than that!
Quran itself is detailed about everything and explains everything but people will tell you it’s not enough we need things outside of it look at the arrogance of people who in a way think their reason and logic and explanation is better then Quran and prophet and his companions and early generations understood and acted upon it
Shamsi once said philosophy makes you majnoon... and hes right
@@southernrealist5789 Thanks
Imām Ash-Shāfi’i (رحمه الله) stated: “My judgment upon the people of rhetoric (Ahlul-Kalām) is that they should be beaten with palm branches, placed on the back of a camel and paraded among the people and it be announced: ‘This is the punishment for the one who abandons the Book and Sunnah and takes to Kalām (theological rhetoric).” (Al-Baghawi reported it in Sharhus-Sunnah, 1/218)
He only criticized the Kalam of the philosophy, he didn’t criticize the kalam
Of Ahlu Sunnah.
@@ajeey914 what was the kalam of the people of Sunnah?
@@iimiboy There is no 'Kalam' of Ahl Sunnah. It is only Quran and Sunnah we follow. This guy does not seem to understand that.
This was reffering to the mu'tazila
@@lallalamalalala5142 No, Asharis, Maturidis..etc, all that use Kalaam are included.
I see some brothers try to use philosophy, and it just make the other person gets lost in the argument.
Most people don't use philosophy or even understand it. Most people deal with simple arguments, cuz finding God wasn't made difficult in the first place.
facts ... 90% of ppl have nothing to do with it.
@@outofservice5438 99.99%*
When you use philosophy which is not inline with Quran and Sunnah people usually try to use it against you
Well said Shamsi I agree with you 1000 percent
One thing id like to advice br Hijab, is that those who come into islam or those who leave due to their misguidance is down to ALLAH, you can’t nor will you be able to save these people, its only ALLAH who can, had ALLAH willed he could make everyone Muslims, your Dua is more powerful than your arguments from kalam, not every atheist is intellectual majority are definitely not, they have their own personal problem with ALLAH, argument from kalam isn’t going to change someones hatred toward ALLAH only Dua can and ALLAH may soften their hearts
I used to be a fanboy of Mohammed Hijab and Ali Dawah,but alhamdulillah because I discovered Shamsi who is based upon the Qur'an and the Sunnah of Nabi Muhammad(s.a.w)
may Allaah bless u
How people are fans of these two is baffling but glad your eyes have been opened alhamdulillah
@@iimiboy dopamine is
the reason.
@@TheMedicalLad how is it dopamine akhie? Asking this in a great way
@@TheMedicalLad did you categorize those two muslims with the same category as substances such as nicotine, narcotics and alcohol which induce and are known to induce above mentioned dopamine rush.?
To be honest, everytime I watch Hijab using philosophy, I just don't get it. I be feeling like his complicating an easy clear point. May Allah guide us to the truth.
Exactly bro, and this religion is simple.
Hijab is good at speaking a lot of words and using big words without any meaning, if he just stick to basic logic and intellect derived from the quran he would do much better
If you dont get it the problem is with you not him !!! Its very clear when I hear his speech
@AK Milli Bro did the scholars of the past have degrees? Shaykh fawzan said it best. "A degree means nothing." Even from Medina University. Learn the history of Islam, and the scholars of Ahl Sunnah.
@@MrCriterion Stop lying to yourself, and stop over complicating our beautiful religion to please some atheist fam
Philosophy looks and sounds big and wide. But when one looks at it from up close, one can see just a big empty hole in it. Nothing is truly connected in it, its connections are imaginary (just subjective: guesses, assumptions and conjectures). It has no any weight (it's like an empty ball). The smallest argument from the Qur'an or Sunnah has more weight than all philosophical arguments in existence. ..................Using the arguments from the Qur'an and Sunnah, like: first cause argument, dependency argument, itc, then calling it "philosophical arguments" and inventing phrases like "islamic philosophy" is misrepresentation of rational reasoning arguments from the Qur'an and sunnah. That is like steeling from Qur'an and belittling it while in the same time putting philosophy on a pedestal (above the Qur'an). Proper use of our intelligence, insight and ability to reason on facts (analogy), is not a philosophy. It's simply proper use of the gifts that Allah s.v.a has given us. As we can use the gifts in a right way, we can also use it in a wrong way (like anything else). Not all rhetorical and rational reasoning arguments are philosophy. Only those arguments that use: guesses, assumptions, conjectures , are philosophical. In the Qur'an, there are also some rhetorical and reasoning arguments, but the Qur'an is certainly not philosophy, there are no guesses, assumptions or conjectures in it, it's a revelation from Allah s.v.a.
Safete ti ne razumiješ šta je filozofija uopšte, ako je reduciraš na "asumpcije" i "konjekture", to je alatka Bogomdana preko razuma, mora da se educiraš od ovih pustinjskih arapa tamo, Muhamed saws. je imao filozofske stavke u svojim hadisima, što je potpuno normalno, svako ko razmišlja i producira misli je filozof po definiciji. Izvini al ne razumiješ uopšte u čemu je štos sa filozofijom.
You right prophet Muhammad saw did use Quran he didn’t use philosophy may Allah tabarkallah bless u shamsi
Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam not SAW!
@Sabir Who are you to say who is misguided? Maybe you just never understood what he said. Listen to mh latest vid.
@@spreadtheword2066 He is misguided though. So can you explain how you understood it and cite examples from the Qur'an and Sunnah and scholar of the past.
Ameen
May Allah guide us all, ameen.
جزاكم الله خيرا
May Allah keep us firm upon Islam and the Sunnah. Aameen.
Straight to the point mashallah
الحمد الله for islam
We are not in need of any kind of philosophy or science 😌
JazaakAllahu Khyran..SHAMSI for exposing those who call to deviation and misguidance ..
نحبك في الله اخ شمسي محبك من السعوديه حفظك الله ورعاك
بارك الله فيك أخي الحليب.
Hijab is much influenced by the philosophies 😇😇😇🤥 ... the Qur'an & sunnah are the best on this earth... May Allah subhnahu wa ta'aalaa give guidance to all of us.. amen. BarokAllahu fiikum Shamsi...
جزاكم الله خير.
Yes, That video had to be addressed. I couldn’t believe if he was actually being serious. Some Muslims may Allah guide them, give the impression now, that Greek Philosophy should be regarded as a criterion to establish truth from falsehood. This tool is bankrupt. It’s a tool that can lead a person to potentially deny his own existence, tells you a lot about it. Quran and the Sunnah is the best tool for one’s Amnesty, Confidence, Guidance and Assurity in this life and in the next. If you’re using Philosophy to achieve the Quran and Sunnah, then that tells you, Quran and Sunnah are not sufficient to establish the truth. والعياذ بالله
Well written.Baaarakallah fiyk.
Shamsi is a real one. A real Qari, may Allah keep him blessed and keep on blessing us with worthy knowledge. Ameen
Isn’t a qari someone who recites Quran?
@@longegg-wind9577 It can also mean a student
@@botbeamer in Algerian dialect
@@botbeamer nah im Algerian and i can tell you that the Algerian people use the word Qari to refer to someone educated or learned and they use it in some parts of Algeria
In Arabic it should be مثقف or عالم
@@user-fr3rg9xz4d the brother meant like we say in algeria واحد "قاري" , which means someone who studied
Alhamdulillah for the clarification.
Today I listened to him speaking about it and I was a bit doubtful about what he said but I wants exactly against it. Thank Allah I watched this video and I am aware of what I wants so aware of!
To the people who are trying to “stand up” for MH: he clearly fell into error regarding the fact that philosophy can be used in Dawah as this is in opposition to what the salaf us saalih were upon. Shamsi is merely clarifying the erroneous stance MH has chosen to adopt, as an advice to MH and a portion of his followers who seem to agree with everything that comes out of his mouth, in addition to warning the people against such a stance.
The Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم stated:
من رأى منكم منكرًا فليغيره بيده ، فإن لم يستطع فبلسانه، فإن لم يستطع فبقلبه وذلك أضعف الإيمان" (رواه مسلم)
Whoever amongst you sees an evil, he must change it with his hand; if he is unable to do so, then with his tongue; and if he is unable to do so, then with his heart; and that is the weakest form of Faith".
[Muslim].
How can you proof to the atheist about existence? U gonna use circular reasoning?
@@A1.4U So Qur'anic arguments against atheist are weak?
May Allah guide you.
Allah didn't just send a book which doesn't have any arguments.
@@A1.4U so basically Allah and His messenger صلى الله عليه و سلم cant give dawah and they need philosophy? Thats basically what you are saying. Fear Allah
Barakallaahu feekum oh my brothers who are here to defend the Haqq!
@@A1.4U The Quran and the Sunnah contain clear cut argument for anyone. The Atheists are just in denial even if you show them that there has to exists a Creator. When i do this, they say:
*But this does not prove that this 'thing' is intelligent or powerful, this does not prove God* .
I mean, this is ridiculous. They rather believe that the creation of everything is random rather than being actually created and designed. A person will never say that a Smartphone is not designed, but when it comes to the *one that made the phone and even the Universe, to that they say IT IS RANDOM* .
So they fail in common sense. They fail to use their intellect. This is all in the Quran.
بارك الله فيكم اخي شمسي
جزاك الله خيرا
*_Tariq reported: Abdullah ibn Mas’ud, may Allah be pleased with him, said, “Verily, the best speech is the book of Allah, and the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammed, peace and blessings be upon him.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 5747_*
Yeah MH doesn’t disagree with this you clown.. have some honour.
اللهم بارك اخي كلامك مفهوم و واضح
May Allah reward you brother Shamsi
They were unable to memorize and understand hadiths , so they preferred and led astray by opinion and philosophy
JazakAllahu Khayran
Subhanallah it is so so clear Alhamdulillah the confusion they have it’s frustrating, the contradictions jump out like pow!
It's sad to see those justiifcations Brother Hijab used in his video. And it's also interesting to see someone as intelligent as he is, cannot see the great flaws in those justifications and their implications as Brother Shamsi pointed out. اللهم اصلح احوالنا وثبت قلوبنا على دينك
Hijab might resort to insults because of this video. May Allah guide us.
its better to be upset here in dunya while we have time to mae taubah. not upset in the hereafter.
Assalam wa aleykoum, where can I buy abayas like Shamsi's macha ALLAH? Jazaka LAHOU kheir.
I'm not English speaker and i think my English is not bad , but when i listen to brother Mohamed Hijab and some of other Brothers from speakers corner , i really get so confused
they use deep philosophical logic that make easy things very confusing , i benefit from some of their words , but majority of there their are confusing , and i can see people speaking with them getting confused about very simple things , and that what i like about Brother Shamsi he use simple words and Examples that anyone can understand , i think philosophy when you speak with it more you complicate simple meanings , i really hope all of our brothers to speak away from it and use Quran and sunna and simple speech
Allah Always use simple example for people to understand .
Allah to speak about his power
Quran 88 17 to 19
Will they not regard the camels, how they are created? And at the sky, how it is raised aloft? And at the mountains, how firmly they are reared? .
very simple yet very powerful any one can understand it , even if he doesn't fully understand the language .
and i see brother over complicate things just to say the same words.
may Allah guide us All
Spot on Shamsi🙌 barak Allahu feek
Ilm al-kalam was the reason for entering batil beliefs among Muslims.
Shamsi May Allah increase you in knowledge
May ALLAH preserve akhi shamsi in dawatus Salafiya.
mh: we dont need red pill we have quran
also mh: we need philosophy quran is not enough
jazakallah khair shamsudeen
برك الله فيكم
the truth has light upon it
نريد ترجمة و جزاكم الله خيرا. اخ شمسي حفظك الله
الفيديو رد على محمد حجاب هداه الله، عن فيديو قام بنشره في قناته، يتحدث فيه على اننا نستخدم الفلسفة لإثبات الإسلام، لكي لا نقع في مغالطة "الأستدلال الدائري". وشمسي يرد عليه على أننا يجب علينا أستخدام القرآن والسنة للدعوة، لأنها أفضل أداه للدعوة بلا شك. لا الفلسفة. أما إدعاء محمد حجاب بأننا سنقع في "استدلال دائري" ، فأقول نِعم الأستدلال الدائري الذي تَبِعه الرسول والصحابة والسلف للدعوة. ولا عزاء لأداة الإغريق تلك. هذا هو الفيديو بأختصار، وفقكم الله.
@@saoud_alahbabi حفظهم الله هذا محمد حجاب اخواني متحزب . و لكن ترفقون المقطع بالترجمة . و جزاك الله خيرا
@@user-lr2es3xm1f
ياليت والله أخي الكريم العاملين فالقناة يرفقون الترجمة العربية لغير متحدثين اللغة الإنجليزية. ولكن أنت تعلم أن هذا يتطلب وقت وتخصيص وقد يتأخر رفع الفيديو. فإن شاء الله يتم فعل هذا مستقبلاً. أو يتم فتح قناة أخرى تترجم الفيديوهات. نسأل الله لهم التوفيق.
@@saoud_alahbabi ان شاء الله تتيسر
Can anyone post the link of the video brother Shamshi mentioned why Islam is truth
DUS Dawah - Islam is the Truth
ruclips.net/video/E6CX-72zRRE/видео.html
الله يبارك فيك كلامك ١٠٠%
Love you Shamsi from the Gambia
Salem 3aleykoum khouya shemsi, stp,aide moi ,j'ai vraiment besoin de toi stp stp. Comment te joindre ? Je n'ai pas de face Book ni autres ..stp
a big problem i see in a lot of "dawah" channels is that they forget that guidance ONLY comes from Allah. our job is to convey and explain the message and make dua for their guidance. now what happens is people utilize things like kalam to explain things but they get pushed into a corner easily using that same logic. this is what happens when you innovate. may Allah guide us all.
Nice shering 🌺
My ALLAH bless you ameen 🌺
#GoldenWorldSami
Can you make a video about the issue of sabaya السبي ,
Salem aleykoum .SVP, comment je peux contacter rapidement Shamsi? Urgent !! SVP
May Allah give him, Ameen
ارجو الترجمة بالعربية. جزاك الله خير
Brother Shamsi please make a video about a common misconception in the Muslim society, we hear khateebs in our mosques nearby saying that Quran is Allah's creation, but the that isn't correct, it is a matter of aqidah, and sifat. Please clarify so that people can know.
1. Someone's speech is their attribute.
2. Allah's speech is his attribute.
3. None of his attributes are created.
4. Quran is Allah's speech.
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
Which Book should I read for making dawah ?
Al usool athalaatha & Kitaab Al Tawheed
@@disneysports
Naam nawaqid, qwa3idu, ...
Kutub a sitta, but that's memorisation
Me I'm talking about a Book from a scholar to read. To explain how to speak to atheist, Christian,...
ٱلْيَوْمَ أَكْمَلْتُ لَكُمْ دِينَكُمْ﴾
ولهذا كان الكتاب والسنة كافيين كل الكفاية في أحكام الدين؛ أصوله وفروعه، فكل متكلف يزعم أنه لا بد للناس في معرفة عقائدهم وأحكامهم إلى علوم غير علوم الكتاب والسنة؛ من علم الكلام وغيره، فهو جاهل، مبطل في دعواه، قد زعم أن الدين لا يكمل إلا بما قاله، ودعا إليه، وهذا من أعظم الظلم والتجهيل لله ولرسوله. [السعدي:٢٢٠]
ماشاء الله أخي في أي كتاب ذكر هذا الكلام؟ جزاكم الله خيرا
تفسير ابن سعدي سورة الماءدة اية ٣
@@DUSDawah وإياكم
بارك الله بكم
جزاك الله خيرا أخي
I just have a question cause im a bit confused: is it also considered philosophy when Allah said do they come from nothing or have they created themselves (Surah Tur 52:35) or is it just a Quranic argument and not to be classified as philosophy. Thanks for the explanation
There is a difference between logical reasoning and arguments, and philosophical arguments.
Masha Allah
Wallahi Everytime there is a debate, Q&A, speeches, ... And the Muslim guys answer with his opinion and gives lengthy explanation
While there is clear aayat and ahadeith about all of those Matters; either directly or clearly related and connected.
barakAllahu feek akhi. much needed lesson to teach the muslims and to protect them from this baatil kalam.
Allahu akbar! just a quick question shamsi is the reward of listening to quran as much as reading it?
نعم لك أجر على سمتع القرآن
Sheikh bin baaz said that the one who listens gets the same reward as reading, but Allah knows best as the one who reads is exerting more effort to read whilst listening is easier. But for sure you'll be rewarded with the right intention
“The people of desires according to Mālik and all of our companions are Ahlul-Kalām (the people of theological rhetoric). So every mutakallim (one who resorts to theological rhetoric) is from the people of desires and Bid’ah whether he is an Ash’ari or other than an Ash’ari. His witness is never accepted in Islam. He is to be abandoned and disciplined for his innovation. And if he continues upon innovation, his repentance is sought [by those in authority].” (Jāmi’ Bayān Al-‘Ilm wa Fadlihi, 2/96)
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله
حياك الله أخي شمسي
ممكن طلب بارك الله فيك
أريد حسابك الخاص على اليوتوب او الفيسبوك
I feel like Mohammed hijab and others wants to impress the Western with their philosophy. So he always uses big words and complicated arguments .. That's good sometimes... But when you are talking to a lay man it's better to just use simple arguments.. No need to make it complicated. May Allah guide him and all of us
Yeah and just watch his video with Jordan Paterson , the man was asking hijab simple questions, yet hijab using a lot of terminologies and names of western philosophers
Honestly I love the brothers and Hijab is good in debates (when he doesn’t go into philosophy). But when I first heard them speak about these kalam arguments, none of it made sense to me, I was so confused, I was wondering if there was something wrong with me, I was like I don’t get how do they get to the conclusion (not because I rejected the conclusion, but bc I didn’t get the steps), like some of them would speak about how when something is made of parts and then the characteristics of of the subparts bs the characteristics of the whole, and so on and so forth. And it just didn’t really make sense as to why exactly people are subscribing to these laws of philosophy.
May Allāh guide Mohammed Hijab
9:49 💯 jazakALlah khayr
I’m left with nothing but to say ALLAHUAKBAR
Brother Shamsi, can I have your email address please as I want to ask you questions and get your advice iA. I am having this fear of death and that I am going to die and at times struggle to cope. I am trying my best alhamdullilah, would love to hear any advice you have iA.
I have the same problem 😆😆
May Allah bless you bro Shamsi..
May Allah increase ur knowledge
I love u bro for the sake of Allah .
As ur representing Quran and Sunnah
Ur defending Companions of Beloved Prophet(peace and blessings of Allah be upon them).
oyalaikumussalam oyarahmatullahi oyabarkatuh, jajakAllah khairan, loooooooovvvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeee you brother.
الله يوفقك يا شمسي
الصوفية والاشاعرة والماترودية ثم
النصارى والملحدين وغيرهم يلجأون إلى الفلسفه وتعقيد الامور
اما ديننا سهل والحمد لله سبحانه وتعالى
نسأل الله تعالى لاخواننا واصحابهم من الدعاة الاخرين ان يسددهم إلى الحق وتكون دعوتهم بسيطة وواضحة و سهلة لكل صادق عاقل امين يبحث عن الحق
ام السلفية السعودية اكرمكم الله
فا هي سهلة المنال من الدهماء و الحمقاء الذين لا عقل لهم … دين مبني على الرواية
الذين ضل سعيهم في الحياة الدنية و يحسبون انهم يحسنون صنعى
ولكن كيف سترد على هؤلاء الذين ذكرتهم؟ لا يمكنك إلا استخدام طرقهم حتى تقنعهم بالحجة، مثل ما فعل ابن تيمية رحمه الله
وصدقني هؤلاء ليسوا أناس عاديين ولا يفهمون ما يفهمه الإنسان العامي، بسبب تعمقهم في الفلسفة هناك مشكلة لديهم في المسلمات العقلية والبديهيات
@@amroabdalwahed5315
اولو النهى قلة قليلة
اولو الالباب قلة قليلة
اولو الفهم قلة قليلة من اولو الالباب
العلوم التي يدخل فيها التفكر و المنطق ليست للعامة
بل هي للخواص
امة هبلها السلفية
@@amroabdalwahed5315 اتمسك بالسنة وليس بالفلسفة الأحاديث النبوية الصحيحة تسعقهم
فمثلا حديث البخاري ان لله يدين وكلما يد الله يمنى
فهل رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم كان يتبع شيخ الإسلام او مخمد بن عبدالوهاب
ولماذا قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم مثل هذا الحديث الصحيح ورد عليهم قبل ١٤٠٠ سنة
طبعا يد الله تعالى لا يستطيع العقل البشري ان يصغها أويجسمها أو يمثلها ولله المثل الأعلى فيد القط لا تشبه يد الفيل
هم يقولون ان اليد معناها القوة والرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم يقول ان اليد معناها يد فمن نتبع الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم ام نتبعهم
كل شيء واضح ويسير وفلسفتهم مخالفة لهدي النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم ولسنا بحاجة إليها والحمد لله رب العالمين
ممكن نتعلم الفلسفه فقط لكي نفندها بالقرآن الكريم والسنة النبوية الصحيحة
جزاك الله خير الدنيا والاخره
Philosophy = Donkey suicied
نريد ترجمة بالعربية لفيديوهاتك أخي شمسي
Salaama aleikum akhi Shamsi, akhi correct me if I am wrong, but I am sure I have seen you and Br. Anwar debate with athiests and utter statements of the athiestic movements to debunk the athiest.
Is this permissable and are the people of athiesm/scientists philosophers or have i misunderstood this completely.
Barakallah feek Shamsi akhi
هل يوجد ترجمة للمقطع
jazakallahu khairun
Allahu Akbar
If someone is an atheist. And he is not convinced by the beautiful strong arguments in the Qur'an because he is stubborn or is not enlightened enough. Then the da'ee uses a kalam argument with arguments that does not go against the aqidah of salaf (Like the infinite regress argument) and is able to convince the atheist and the atheist reverts; is the da'ee sinful?
The fundamental principle you have to understand is this: whoever Allah guides, none can misguide, and whoever Allah allows to be misguided, no one can guide him.
Allah alone is the one who guides. What is upon the muslim is to convey the message (with wisdom and good manners). If you stick to this principle you’ll never have any problems InshaAllah
The problem many Daee’s are falling into is that they’re so obsessed with trying to convince an individual and result in going beyond the boundaries of Islam, often resulting in them innovating or May Allah protect us, making Kufri statements. This may be harsh, but the reality is that the hellfire was created for a reason … it wasn’t created in vein or as a joke … some people will never accept Islam no matter what you tell them.
Our job is to convey … Allah is the one who guides … if one is stubborn, move on akhi. If that person is dear to you, make dua for them and perhaps Allah softens their heart.
As for the infinite regress argument etc … akhi it does go against the Aqidah of the salaf (simply put, Allah is capable and competent of all things والله على كل شيئ قدير). In order to understand this topic in details, I invite you to read در تعارض العقل والنقل by Sheikh-ul-Islam Ibn Tayymiyyah … but in order to understand this book you have to be grounded upon the aqeedah of Ahlus Sunnah and should take this book and it’s prerequisites from the scholars of Ahlus Sunnah.
Firstly, may Allah guide Mohammed Hijab and correct his affairs, Ameen. I agree with the brother Shamsi because we should never deviate from the Sunnah of the Prophetصلى الله عليه وسلم. It is attached to the Shahadah which means: There is no one that should be followed after the Book of Allah except Muhammadصلى الله عليه وسلم.
Philosophy promotes the overly use of logic and shouldn't be followed or taught by a Muslim. Ali ibn Abi Mutalibرضي الله عنه said similarly:" If our religion was based on logic then we would have to wipe the bottom of the Kuffs instead of the top." Proof of the Sunnah being over the logic of men. The only thing that explains the Qur'an is the Sunnah. Shaykh Ibn al-Qayyam mentioned: "One of the forms of abandoning the Qur'an is to exchange its proofs for logic. May Allah pardon the Ummah of Muhammadصلى الله عليه وسلمon the Day of Judgement, Ameen.
This is 💯 💯 💯
And it (the Qur'an) is not the word of the outcast Shaitan (Satan).(QS At Takwir: 25)
Such are the Signs of Allah, which We rehearse to thee in Truth; then in what exposition will they believe after (rejecting) Allah and His Signs?.(QS Al Jatsiyah: 6)
We have not instructed the (Prophet) in Poetry, nor is it meet for him: this is no less than a Message and a Qur'an making things clear.(QS YaaSiin: 69)
ali need dawah wellahi
Can anyone tell me if Mohammad zHijab has a degree in Philosophy.? To the best of my knowledge he has not.
Funny thing is I have never seen someone taking their Shahada from Mohammed Hijabs dawah
Because hijab only a debater with lots of philosophy talks with no guidence from Quran and Sunnah
It is Allah who guides...
SubhanAllah so true
There is actually a video where a man took Shahada with Hijab
Even if people do it’s not a proof for him to be upon the truth the proof is Quran and Sunnah and the way of companions
I love u brother and brother m hijab... hopefully both of u can settle down and be frens... i make Dua for both of u... its ok to disagree on certain issues...
الله يحفظك
30 dislike 👎 30 misguided people who support hijab not for the truth but for hate of Islam and the sunnah anyone who hate what our Nobel brother shamsi said is a clear proof to the Quran and the sunnah and using philosophy is not Islam no prophet no messengers no sahabah no salaf us salih great imam no scholars believe or use philosophy. Or believe that can be a tool to call to Islam MH is clearly not following Islam
رعاكم الله برعايته
Also it makes no sense logically to go the philosophy to prove the Quran. Everyone knows the statement ‘the proof is upon he claimant’. Therefore logically, the Quran has to prove itself that it is the Book of Allah which Alhamdulillah, Allah done in the best, clearest, most rational, most miraculous and tangible way
و الحمد لله رب العالمين
Salam Aleykum. It is playing the game of the disbelievers, to accept arguying on a subjective level, where only more confusion will be possible, what will allow them to defend their positions and to avoid a truth-finding of any kind... This "sanitary-crisis" is build on the same way (false objective premisse which is the base for all subjective measures and decisions...), and is a perfect example and a prove more, that we must stay on an objective level.
well said
I'm confused, did shamsi really say that hijab has said statements of kufr?
Yeah?
Yeah. To clarify, that which is necessary from Muhammed Hijab's claim about philosophy in da'wah is that the philosophy he has in da'wah (which he said is a vantage point outside of the Quran) is needed to call to Islam. Also, he said that using the Quran to call to it is circular reasoning. This is a major error as it necessitates that the prophet used a futile method (the Quran) to call to Islam, and that the method of Muhammed hijab is better
❤
رحم الله امرئ عرف قدر نفسه فالزمها حدها
i already said that before, mohammad uses too much philosphy and not koran
How are u gonna answer their question if u don’t read their questions and ideas?
Exactly
What is this in reference to?