Видео

Nah. Nobody is friends with Hutts. Haha

Agreed. Sol always had his number.

​@@starwarsmusicanalysisHonestly, I have doubts as to whether he was even the apprentice, since I think most Sith apprentices would fight better. He says he has no name, which makes me think he's an acolyte to the actual apprentice.

@yourlocalmathgeek4815 I thought he had some pretty badass moves. He did mow down a bunch of lower tier Jedi. Sol is just on another level. But my theory is that Qimir just heard the name Sith at some point when he was a Jedi apprentice and now he’s using that. And now Plagueis is coming to shut him up before the Jedi are put on higher alert.

​@@starwarsmusicanalysisThat's a compelling theory I haven't thought of yet.

@yourlocalmathgeek4815 I hope we get a chance to find out.

Yeah. I remember when I figured that one out too looking at Creep. And then poof, it was everywhere. Haha. I don’t know yet. They usually only announce it a little over a month or at most two before for whatever reason.

@@starwarsmusicanalysis I've heard it everywhere for a while I just could never find the name for it. Then Rick Beato just kinda casually dropped it in a video and I was like "THAT'S IT!" I don't know what Creep is but yeah that sound is everywhere. Oh ok, thanks :)

@gristleboi3205 Radiohead’s Creep. If you don’t know it, it’s a staple of the early 90s.

@@starwarsmusicanalysis Ohh ok. I'm not much into Radiohead but maybe I'll check it out. Thanks for always being willing to interact, it's cool of you👍

@@starwarsmusicanalysis Bruhhh nvm I know Creep I just never knew it was called that lol

Kinda wonder if it had any inspiration on The Hu.

Didn't even know this song existed before I listened to a Republic Commando Triple Zero audiobook earlier today at work. Very good stuff.

He said it correctly. It’s foreshadowing Vader, who tears through the Jedi. And he’s a politician so he’s going to use extreme hypothetical scenarios to help convey his point. Little does he know that what he described will reality before long. It’s actually a very well crafted and delivered line.

Thank you so much! I’m really excited for season 2 as well. It has such a high bar that season 1 set for it. But I’m super excited to see how they tie everything together. Should be epic!

I always thought he had legs. But man, you say that on the internet and debate there most certainly was. Haha

Thanks!

I don’t think that was the reason. I think there was a designed intention that just never saw fruition.

Me either. My theory was always that he actually played with arms because of the way they were jointed. The leg thing was always a Schrödinger’s cat for me until now.

are you being ironic?

@Darth_Serius that’s how I took it.

@@thestupidnintendokid So we should hate the show because of some legs?

😂 don’t forget to remove your own legs as well in protest. (I don’t actually condone this)

I’m pretty sure he was playing on my own sarcasm and adding to it.

Thank you for watching!

I knew that one but I’m of the understanding that Lego media isn’t actually canon which gives them the freedom to have a little fun.

Oh I missed that one. Just looking at the cover, it seems like they based it off the concept art which isn’t what RotJ even ended up using though. The way Rebo’s limbs are hinged in RotJ always made them arms and not legs. But that’s really weird that they intentionally chose to represent him other than how he was clearly depicted in the movie. So now there’s two different canon depiction of the same character with different anatomy. Haha

It was subtle but I’m waiting for the wave of upheaval to begin. Haha

Yeah. The pacing and world building was beautifully in this show. It told so much without rushing through stories.

🍼🍼🍼

My video and critique have nothing to do with your complaint. A person’s identity has nothing to do with the quality of their work either. And the majority of the fan base aren’t homophobes.

@@starwarsmusicanalysis Im not a homophobe. You may want to look that definition up. I'm just spitting facts. Imagine if a straight man directed the Barbie movie and she blew every other guy she met. That's what happened here, but opposite.

The genders in your example don’t make sense and you still haven’t explained what someone’s sexuality has to do with any of this. I knew what the word meant when I used it.

I know it’s made for the clones which is why it exists but it was based on Mandalorian War Chants. The Order 66 reference is a cool bit that I hadn’t considered before. Thanks for the insight!

I think the most important thing this show does is demonstrate that Star Wars can expand beyond its prototypical stories and character types and still be successful.

Yeah. Williams uses Sanskrit for Duel of the Fates. Survivor uses Mongolian. There are plenty of unused languages out there as well. I don’t know what their goal was.

It’s such an under appreciated gem. I hope the Kiners keep getting pinged for upcoming shows!

I can’t tell if you’re talking about my video or the show. Do you want to specify?

Yo the acolyte kind of is garbage bro ​@@starwarsmusicanalysis

@starwarsmusicanalysis the show dude. Not your channel. Sorry for the confusion. I didn't mean to come at you. Idk a single millennial who will watch that show tho. Js. I feel like It's a slap in the face to people like me who grew up watching star wars. Edited for spelling error

@St1cKnGoJuGgAlO ah gotcha. I watched it and liked it. I don’t feel a need to defend it though and if you hated it, there’s nothing wrong with that. People said the same stuff about the prequels when I was a kid too. Hopefully Skeleton Crew is more well received.

Thanks and I’m really glad you enjoyed it! Feel free to link your video here when you post it.

Yeah I corrected myself on this later. It’s the rebellion theme. But it was heavily introduced first with Kleya which threw me off.

I wouldn’t have picked Obi-Wan as the reference for Disney knowing how to make quality Star Wars, but to each their own. Anyways, the point was that the music of this show actually held up in character, despite wider grievances towards the show.

Fair enough

That’s possible. My theory is that he just started calling himself Sith without anyone guiding him and now Plagueis is coming along to silence him.

That’s “Dido’s Lament” from the opera Dido and Aeneas by Henry Purcell.

@@starwarsmusicanalysis thanks 🙏

Good question. First, it wasn’t actually by Abels so I left it out since I was focusing on him. But since it doesn’t actually go with an image, I left it out as part of specific film scoring. I kind of assumed this would be implied into what I said about the episode 3 singing as well since it’s all in the same vein of not fitting. But I definitely gave it complaint in my breakdown of that episode. It made no sense and wasn’t needed.

It’s possible. He seemed a little surprised though as well at everything that happened.

@@starwarsmusicanalysis Sol was definitely out classing him in the fight. I think that it definitely took qimir off guard.

Maybe that’s it.

What did you think of the music?

@thetjbucy how did the music not fit the scenes? As someone who studies film scoring, I have to tell you that you’re wrong in this regard.

@@starwarsmusicanalysis yeah your right that’s true

Why would it matter if it’s a show? There’s no purpose to a theme if it never comes back again. A good film composer can set the mood and utilize narrative-building themes in tangent with each other. If I don’t look, then we never know.

I can only hear the Vader moment with headphones. If you haven’t already, try it that way once. I compared it to a lot of negative but overall I did still like it. I’m a bit theme obsessed though. Haha. Villain these can go up occasionally. Palpatine starts by going up. But this is a bit of an unusual large upward motion. But Abels always sets it so low that the only place it can go is up and it still feels dark and murky to us.

I hope the same. Abels tried something but I don’t think it worked. It’s not what leitmotifs were designed to do. But yeah, the Williams moments were great whenever they occurred.

​@@starwarsmusicanalysis James Newton Howard uses themes like that too. Instead of representing characters he'll be like "this is the love theme - plays whenever anyone is romantic, no matter who" and "this is the heroic theme - plays when ever anyone triumphs, no matter who" etc.

@RedCaio I just don’t think it gives strength to anything when composers do that. We don’t connect to characters.

I liked it far better than Kenobi. That one was the low point to me.

personally I much prefer the music in Acolyte. Andor didn't have that Star Wars sound imo

I don’t know if Acolyte ever could truly have been a horror since it was intended to be the flagship of a new era. It had to be accessible to large audiences. But I appreciate them leaning that direction with Abels. I’m not sure how much he would have been micromanaged. I never expected him to be great at adapting themes since that’s not the world he lives in. I even questioned originally whether we would get themes. It’s always hard though to determine what was actually the choice of the composer and what they were told to do.

There you have it.

I don’t have to cover anything. I choose to.

Are people really still upset about that? It was a great show. The universe has to feel larger than just Jedi to feel believable.

Great insights. I think the force theme is always used as a way blanket way to demonstrate something being overcome, a barrier being passed. In that way, it certainly fits here as well as we progress.

I wish you were talking about me. Haha

That’s a thought I had as well. I think they made it clear that he’s Vernestra’s former padawan. Even when he says he’s Sith, I had the feeling he’s just calling himself that.

You didn’t like the fights either?

So is your grammar

What did you think of the music?

@@starwarsmusicanalysis Nothing could beat the prequel and original compositions but it held its own.

​@@starwarsmusicanalysis i dont think this guy ever hear kiner music before

Kiners are good. But I do agree with them that even they can’t hit the John Williams level of film scoring.

So not everything else was awful

Your comment is a joke? I didn’t get it.

Osha isn’t a kid and Sol simply doesn’t fight back because he’s overcome with guilt. He evens says “it’s ok” as she kills him. If he had fought her, he would have easily beaten Osha like he did Mae. Not sure how you missed that. But yeah, if you can’t make sense of things that are blatant, I’m sure a lot of things in life would feel incoherent.

😂

I know not everyone enjoyed it, but I really enjoyed these lightsaber battles.

@@starwarsmusicanalysis you can’t please everyone

Certainly can’t. 😂

​@@pharoh32 indeed

Why wouldn’t Jedi also know how to use martial arts in order to be able to battle without having to use their lightsaber? Star Wars was a space fantasy/western/opera/epic while being highly inspired by old Samurai films from the very beginning. Why would aspects of King Fu possibly bother someone?😂

@@starwarsmusicanalysis Why would anything bother anyone in a fantasy story?

I’m just saying. Star Wars has always been mushed together different aesthetics. Seems like a weird beef to suddenly have with the franchise when it’s a foundation of the franchise.

@@starwarsmusicanalysis Star Wars was mushed together in a certain way. It certainly didn't include 70s Hongkong style cablework and scenes where you expect Darth Sexypants to say something like "My tiger claw is superior to you ostrich style!" ...but you are right. Compared to the abysmal state of Disney Star Wars this is far low on the ick list.

What did you think of the music?

@@starwarsmusicanalysis it’s okay, but it doesn’t make up for the bad writing, and woke agenda.

Ok. So the lightsaber fights aren’t the only good part then though?