The Propsmith
The Propsmith
  • Видео 31
  • Просмотров 236 823
The Propsmith Guide to Prop Collecting
This is a compilation of the entire Prop Collecting Primer Series, so you have all the ame information gathered into one video... FOR YOUR CONVENIENCE! I'm so nice!
Просмотров: 65

Видео

Supernatural First Blade by DarkMatter Props
Просмотров 3232 месяца назад
If you have to rid yourself of a pesky Knight of Hell, look no further than the legendary First Blade, guaranteed to gank any denizen of Hell, no matter how tough. In this video, I'm reviewing a truly excellent replica of this prop, made by DarkMatter Props. You can find their Etsy shop here: www.etsy.com/shop/DarkMatterProps
Review: Rubbertoe Laser Screwdriver Replica
Просмотров 2452 месяца назад
An in-depth look at the Master's Laser Screwdriver replica by Rubbertoe Replicas! PLUS: An upgrade to make it even better!
Prop Collecting Primer (Part 4): Where to Buy Props
Просмотров 773 месяца назад
The video answers probably the most important question about collecting props: WHERE DO YOU GET THEM?? I go in-depth on the various places you can get props and let you know about the business practices of those various sites in order to help ensure you're getting an authentic prop. I also briefly go over where you can get replicas. 00:00 - Introduction 01:27 - Auction Sites 03:19 - Studio Auct...
Review: Doctor Who Psychic Paper by Little Shop Props
Просмотров 2813 месяца назад
If you're a Doctor Who fan, then you're familiar with the Psychic Paper, the handy "slightly psychic" accessory that helps the Doctor get into places he isn't authorized to be in, strictly speaking. In this video, I'll be reviewing the only fully-accurate replica of this available, from Little Shop Props. 00:00 - Intro 01:47 - RTD Talks Psychic Paper 02:50 - History of the Prop 03:15 - Original...
Prop Collecting Primer (Part 3): Terminology
Просмотров 463 месяца назад
There are lots of terms and jargon in the prop collecting community, and I'm here to help you sort it out! You'll be talking like a prop collecting pro in no time!
Prop Collecting Primer (Part 2): Types of Props
Просмотров 403 месяца назад
For the second video in the Prop Collecting Primer series, I'm going over the various types of props you may experience in your collecting journey. It's much more involved than you may think at first, but I'm gonna help you through it!
Prop Collecting Primer (Part 1): Introduction
Просмотров 654 месяца назад
In this first part of the Prop Collecting Primer series, it’s just a real quick introduction to the hobby: What a prop is, and why people collect them. A great starting point for anyone just getting into the hobby, with much more information coming your way over the next few weeks! Be sure to subscribe and have a look at some of my other videos: I've got reviews, tutorials and much more!
Can TOYS be Prop Replicas??
Просмотров 2164 месяца назад
Lovers of props and prop replicas have to get their fix in any way they can... But should you consider a TOY to be a valid prop replica?? I'm going to dive deep into that question and give you an answer that hopefully not too many people argue about!
Build Diary: Westworld Maze Replica
Просмотров 1544 месяца назад
If you're a fan of Westworld, then you're familiar with THE MAZE, the central conceit of the first season, which was personified in a children's game called PIGS IN CLOVER. This is the ONLY completely accurate replica ever made of the Pigs In Clover Maze as far as I can tell... and this is how I made it! The excellent Westworld theme cover is by Tillian: tillian.band (used with their gracious p...
Build Diary: Hourman's Hourglass (from DC's Stargirl)
Просмотров 804 месяца назад
This is my build process recreating a screen-accurate replica of Hourman's Hourglass from SOLID BRASS. You can find the glass hourglass here: www.hayshopus.com/hay-time-hourglass-3-minutes/ - NOW HAS YELLOW SAND! This was not an option when I made mine! And the correct chain can be found here: a.co/d/5jMKH4z Please be sure to leave a comment and subscribe to see more videos!
Captain America Shield Glowup
Просмотров 795 месяцев назад
See how I turned a relatively inexpensive metal Captain America Shield from China into a spectacular screen-accurate replica!
11th Doctor Sonic REMATCH: CT vs Rubbertoe
Просмотров 6 тыс.2 года назад
With an updated Rubbertoe Replica's V2 out on the market, it's time to see how it stacks up vs the winner of the previous Sonic Showdown, the Celestial Toystore.
Mr. Kite Letterpress Promo Video
Просмотров 3384 года назад
A look at the process of creating my Ultimate Edition Mr. Kite Letterpress poster, available at mrkite.thepropsmith.com
History and Evolution of the Mr. Kite Poster
Просмотров 2 тыс.4 года назад
This is a look at the history of John Lennon's Mr. Kite Poster and its many replicas, culminating in the ultimate replica by yours truly, a Limited Edition Letterpress print available at mrkite.thepropsmith.com
The Ultimate Mr. Kite Poster Replica!
Просмотров 8005 лет назад
The Ultimate Mr. Kite Poster Replica!
The Maze (Westworld)
Просмотров 2587 лет назад
The Maze (Westworld)
How To Make a Two-Face Coin
Просмотров 24 тыс.8 лет назад
How To Make a Two-Face Coin
Character Options Doctor Who 11th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Review
Просмотров 4,4 тыс.8 лет назад
Character Options Doctor Who 11th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Review
Celestial Toystore Doctor Who 11th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Review
Просмотров 20 тыс.8 лет назад
Celestial Toystore Doctor Who 11th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Review
Rubbertoe Replicas Doctor Who 11th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Review
Просмотров 7 тыс.8 лет назад
Rubbertoe Replicas Doctor Who 11th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Review
Ultimate 11th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Showdown
Просмотров 63 тыс.8 лет назад
Ultimate 11th Doctor Sonic Screwdriver Showdown
The Wand Company 11th Doctor Extending Sonic Screwdriver Review
Просмотров 12 тыс.8 лет назад
The Wand Company 11th Doctor Extending Sonic Screwdriver Review
The Devil's Vinyl replica
Просмотров 3,8 тыс.10 лет назад
The Devil's Vinyl replica
Mr. Kite Poster: Mine vs. Kiteprint
Просмотров 6 тыс.10 лет назад
Mr. Kite Poster: Mine vs. Kiteprint
Celestial Toystore Ultimate Edition Chameleon Arch Pocket Watch review.
Просмотров 7 тыс.11 лет назад
Celestial Toystore Ultimate Edition Chameleon Arch Pocket Watch review.
Ultimate Warehouse 13 Farnsworth Communicator Replica
Просмотров 12 тыс.11 лет назад
Ultimate Warehouse 13 Farnsworth Communicator Replica
Celestial Toystore Ultimate Edition Doctor Who Sonic Screwdriver
Просмотров 41 тыс.12 лет назад
Celestial Toystore Ultimate Edition Doctor Who Sonic Screwdriver
Custom Warehouse 13 Farnsworth
Просмотров 10 тыс.12 лет назад
Custom Warehouse 13 Farnsworth
Celestial Toystore Sonic Screwdriver (Tennant ver.)
Просмотров 15 тыс.14 лет назад
Celestial Toystore Sonic Screwdriver (Tennant ver.)

Комментарии

  • @herrjohnssen
    @herrjohnssen 11 дней назад

    Now do the video again but with the Nawya sonic

  • @alinds1
    @alinds1 29 дней назад

    I've been itching to get deeper into prop recreation and THE MAZE is at the top of my list. I came looking for inspiration, and here you are! I'm most definitely interested in your project files if you still plan on making them available. Fantastic work. Subscribed!

  • @mystic48209
    @mystic48209 Месяц назад

    What was the movement? Auto? Handwind? Seagull?

  • @maxhebus
    @maxhebus 2 месяца назад

    What color have you used to paint the aluminum box?

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Месяц назад

      I believe it was called "Leather Brown" or something like that. It was a very long time ago, though, and I don't know that I'd use the same paint now.

  • @tyronepowers76
    @tyronepowers76 2 месяца назад

    Nice overview of the first blade Do i detect a demon knife, angel blade and maybe even, the colt with bullets and case!!

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 2 месяца назад

      @@tyronepowers76 Your powers of detection are strong.

  • @YungGaze
    @YungGaze 2 месяца назад

    Yo, you got the link to it LMAO?

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 2 месяца назад

      @@YungGaze It hasn’t been available for many years. You’ll need to find it on eBay.

  • @Dac1915
    @Dac1915 2 месяца назад

    I have 37th laser. However, the removal is also the same, and as seen in other RUclipsrs' reviews, the upper emitter part still has problems with the light not working, and it's a prop like a random box where the emitter doesn't come out well until the end.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 2 месяца назад

      @@Dac1915 Strange, I haven’t encountered these issues, and I’ve had this guy for some time. I wonder if that’s one of those cases where earlier batches had issues that got worked out in later batches? Thanks for the info, and thanks for watching!

  • @jamesmatthews6477
    @jamesmatthews6477 2 месяца назад

    A great review, detailed and informative! 👏👍 It’s a gorgeous piece! Thanks, James

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 2 месяца назад

      @@jamesmatthews6477 Yeah, I’m very happy with it!

  • @boredbum2009
    @boredbum2009 3 месяца назад

    If been having issue with my CT with the flickability have you had this issue as well I reached out and they replied fixed it for a little bit. Could you maybe do a break down video of how to solve this? Thanks! I love my CT I just wanna get that flick back!

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 2 месяца назад

      @@boredbum2009 I would absolutely make a video specifically on this issue just to help you with your issue if I could. Unfortunately, I have sold off my CT so no longer have it to shoot.

  • @robopam
    @robopam 3 месяца назад

    That has been my phones ringtone ever since the first season and it still is to this day.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 2 месяца назад

      @@robopam It was also my ringtone for YEARS… now, I don’t actually know what my ringtone is, because I haven’t had my ringer on in many years. If my phone rang out loud, I’d freak out and not know what was happening.

  • @omarmalik4939
    @omarmalik4939 3 месяца назад

    Awesome video - I subscribed right away!

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 3 месяца назад

      Amazing! Thanks for watching and for the sub!

  • @jamesmatthews6477
    @jamesmatthews6477 3 месяца назад

    Another super interesting video, thank you! 👍👍

  • @null_verdict
    @null_verdict 3 месяца назад

    Good review, and thank you for avidly supporting the propmakers who poured their time, money, energy, and love into their craft! I bought LSP's old version via Rubbertoe Replicas when it first became available. This has always been one of my favorite props, on the show and I spent very many hours and days of my own starting years ago, trying to make a screen accurate version, so I immediately ordered it when I saw it on the website back then. (The specific wallet I got seemed to have a few inaccurate issues, but it's still the closest I've ever seen / had to screen accuracy.) 0:33 I think you meant Peter Capaldi (Twelfth Doctor) as he was the one who used the Paul Smith wallet for a short time until he switched back to the original style wallet 2:53 I remember seeing your old review of another psychic paper-inspired recreation where it referenced the original prop as a "passport wallet" and it always bothered me, so I'm glad the screen-used prop's origins are being made known to more people

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 3 месяца назад

      I have actually had this since before they started selling through Rubbertoe, I just wasn't really active on this channel... so now I'm going back and reviewing stuff I should have done long ago. And, yeah, I did mean Capaldi, I just mis-remembered when that change happened. I was literally thinking it was during Smith, probably because there were so many other changes at that time. The old review was a written one of a Psychic Paper from DarthMule on the RPF... and it's still quite a lovely piece and great for what we knew at the time, but this one frankly blows it out of the water, in essentially every conceivable metric. Thanks for watching, I have more Doctor Who stuff coming up soon, but I'm trying to avoid making it a Doctor Who channel, so I'm trying to spread them out a bit. The last thing I want is anyone making a VoteSaxon comparison 0_0

  • @jamesmatthews6477
    @jamesmatthews6477 3 месяца назад

    Again, interesting to understand all the different types. James

  • @jamesmatthews6477
    @jamesmatthews6477 3 месяца назад

    Looking forward to getting some this information from you! James

  • @jamesmatthews6477
    @jamesmatthews6477 3 месяца назад

    Really interesting, thanks for explaining all this! James

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 3 месяца назад

      Thanks for watching! If there are any questions you’d like addressed in a future video, please let me know.

  • @richardsmith3079
    @richardsmith3079 3 месяца назад

    SAD 👎😩

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 3 месяца назад

      @@richardsmith3079 What’s sad? Care to elaborate?

    • @richardsmith3079
      @richardsmith3079 3 месяца назад

      @@PropsmithReplicas getting excited about a wallet 🤣

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 3 месяца назад

      @@richardsmith3079I’m sure you get nerdy about things that I don’t see the appeal of. We all find bits of joy in different places, and it’s totally okay that you don’t dig what I dig. Anyway, thanks for watching! Hope you have a great weekend.

    • @richardsmith3079
      @richardsmith3079 3 месяца назад

      @@PropsmithReplicas True fair play and you 🙏

  • @minakochan29
    @minakochan29 3 месяца назад

    I do not see why would I buy it, instead of just making it myself. Cutting old driving licence holder is not complicated. I have seen this prop's price, it is very expensive for what it is! Completely not worth it.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 3 месяца назад

      I suppose that's on me for not mentioning: The actual Driving License holder is IMPOSSIBLE to find. If you could get your hands on one... yeah, it'd be a real easy conversion. But I've been trying to find one for over 10 years to no avail. In fact, I literally can't even find a PHOTO of one on the internet. Literally the only photos I can find are the ones in the video... and those were taken by James at Little Shop Props of the one they were able to source. So, given their rarity, if you DID find one, it would likely cost FAR more than this replica. Could you grab some relatively close wallet and make a rough approximation of the prop? Absolutely. But if you want a PERFECT replica, this is the option you've got. There is no other. But I always encourage people to make their own props! Take a swing at it, I'd love to see what you come up with! And thanks for watching!

  • @AndrewSink
    @AndrewSink 3 месяца назад

    Nice work! I'm always amazed at the amount of detail put into screen-used props, replicas, and everything else. Thanks for breaking this down!

  • @akseldegard4329
    @akseldegard4329 3 месяца назад

    Creepy but cool I I here it like actually here it

  • @starwhite9655
    @starwhite9655 3 месяца назад

    Dunno if you’ll see this but great video dude, I have one of the Rubbertoe V2’s and it’s my favourite prop replica of all time, Nick has really improved when it comes to replicating these sonics, and I’m glad I own one, only reason I didn’t get the first edition was because of how lacklustre the flicking seemed to be and because of how fragile it was in comparison to the CT.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 3 месяца назад

      Yeah, Nick’s doing top-notch work and he’s a good bloke on top of it!

  • @claydumaw
    @claydumaw 4 месяца назад

    Great video.

  • @AndrewSink
    @AndrewSink 4 месяца назад

    Dude, this is so good. Nice work!

  • @AndrewSink
    @AndrewSink 4 месяца назад

    He’s back!

  • @DeadGodFound2rd
    @DeadGodFound2rd 4 месяца назад

    you back?????????????

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 4 месяца назад

      Oh yeah! I’ll be posting every week without fail… I’ve got a lot going on that I’m really excited about. Hope you’ll be along for the ride!

    • @DeadGodFound2rd
      @DeadGodFound2rd 4 месяца назад

      @@PropsmithReplicas sweet, keep up the good work man

  • @ParametricAlex
    @ParametricAlex 4 месяца назад

    Immaculate execution, especially relatively speaking. I’m curious to the value this might be appraised. What sorts of other props have you ever considered making, if time and money were never a consideration, for example, what might you like to have in your collection you haven’t already made?

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 4 месяца назад

      I've got quite an extensive list of things I plan on getting to... top of the list is the Colt from Supernatural (full steel!), also want to do the TVA TemPed from Loki, The VFD Spyglass from A Series of Unfortunate Events, and a couple fun items from WareHouse 13, and honestly just an endless list. Not sure what order I'll get to things, but I'll have full build videos for each (more detailed than this one)! And thanks for the kind words!

  • @garethroberts2099
    @garethroberts2099 4 месяца назад

    Still love your poster to this day. framed and always in prime position.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 4 месяца назад

      SO glad you're enjoying it! It was really a years-long labor of love.

  • @johngdoty
    @johngdoty 8 месяцев назад

    Brilliant work. I'm rewatching the series and I would so love one of those!

  • @dylanringproductions160
    @dylanringproductions160 9 месяцев назад

    Great video

  • @Unclerad7777
    @Unclerad7777 9 месяцев назад

    Do you know who owns the original poster? I couldn’t find anything online.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 9 месяцев назад

      Yoko owns it. I imagine it’ll eventually pass on to Sean.

    • @Unclerad7777
      @Unclerad7777 9 месяцев назад

      Thanks!

  • @Unclerad7777
    @Unclerad7777 9 месяцев назад

    Yours is better, John told me so.

  • @momsberettas9576
    @momsberettas9576 11 месяцев назад

    Why not factor in price?

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 11 месяцев назад

      I think CT still wins the price battle, as in the original video and I really just wanted to focus on what the major shortcomings were of the original Rubbertoe to see how the new one stacks up.

  • @philipsmith1134
    @philipsmith1134 11 месяцев назад

    I purchased a CT in October off the CT site. It arrived three weeks ago (I got sonic 362). Now, I can’t speak for the quality of the original ones compared to the newer ones, but in all honesty I think my sonic came out great. When polished it looks sleek, and everything seems in order. The flick is phenomenal and there’s no funky pieces or anything of the sort. I’m glad I got it. I understand some have complained about a decrease in quality, so for all I know I just got lucky. Furthermore, when emailing CT about anything, I always made sure I was very cordial and understanding. He replied fast with short responses but seemed friendly nonetheless. The only complaint I have, and this is a small one, is that the red emitter included as a bonus wasn’t filed/sanded/shaved down fully, so when screwed on and extended, two of the claws sometimes get caught on the bottom resin. Sorry for the long comment, I just wanted to provide a bit of info to anyone curious and was thinking of getting a CT. Again, it’s possible I just got lucky.

    • @nextofkin2321
      @nextofkin2321 10 месяцев назад

      What is his email? Thinking of buying a ct aswell, glad yours was made well and sturdy

  • @PKSeven
    @PKSeven 11 месяцев назад

    Ah, fancy seeing you here! (One of the old group.) Nice comparison.

  • @ciarangrey7576
    @ciarangrey7576 Год назад

    on one of your previous videos you insulted people for wanting to de-construct their sonics, but you do it yourself?

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Год назад

      I have no recollection of that. Can you point me to the comment you refer to?

  • @jonathanclyde2579
    @jonathanclyde2579 Год назад

    calling people "cheap bastards" for not being able to spend $100+ on a sonic in insane, not to mention the fact that this is designed to be a toy for kids, not a replica

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Год назад

      I felt like that was pretty clearly a tongue-in-cheek joke and not meant seriously. I am aware that it’s a toy and said so in the video, but noted that I was reviewing it in terms of being an option to use as a prop replica. Honestly, I didn’t want to have to do that, but I knew people would come at me if I didn’t include it. I treated it with the same level of criticism that I would give any prop replica, not allowing for its intended use as a toy. And, given the fact that you can’t find one of these under $100 anymore, I think that was the right move. Clearly, it’s being bought by more than just children. But thanks for watching to the end! I’ll have a lot more content coming soon, so be on the lookout!

  • @jnielson1121
    @jnielson1121 Год назад

    Love these videos! ...would you consider doing a review of the Rubbertoe classic sonics?

  • @alejandroahumada30
    @alejandroahumada30 Год назад

    How can I buy a copy.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Год назад

      It’s available on Etsy: www.etsy.com/listing/756193492/

  • @npe1
    @npe1 Год назад

    The poster advertised a fair/circus held at Town Meadows, Rochdale in Lancashire. Rochdale is my home town and is about 12 miles from the city centre of Manchester. Town Meadows no longer exists, it is largely covered by Rochdale Police Station and the War Memorial Gardens.

  • @Ash_Vulpine
    @Ash_Vulpine Год назад

    recently started getting into the whole replica/cosplay scene and was wondering if you knew how often rubbertoe does runs of their 11th sonic? I know CT is done making new ones and is just selling leftover stock now (which i've heard has severely dropped in quality), so I was trying to see how often rubbertoe does runs of past props.

    • @aidyn_ws
      @aidyn_ws Год назад

      Rubbertoe JUST put another batch on sale a couple months back, but to my knowledge all units have been purchased and he said on his Instagram that this will be the final run, of the model he’s replicating at least. I actually happened to be one of the people who managed to purchase the replica in time. So unfortunately, you might be out of luck when it comes to Rubbertoe. There are some 11th Doctor Universal Remotes being sold online which are said to be surprisingly SUPER good replicas even if it wasn’t intended to be one, though be weary that they’re fairly expensive, and sadly don’t flick open. If you’re left with absolutely NO choice, and wouldn’t dare resorting to the ugly Character Options toy unless you’re on a strict budget, Celestial Toystore sonic screwdrivers still make the cut even if they aren’t as illustrious as they once were. I purchased and received one earlier this year, and while it definitely had some issues I was still happy with it. It was still fun to “sonic” things and flick it open. But with that said, PLEASE handle it with care. Mine recently broke during transit on an airplane ride since I didn’t secure it properly enough I guess, and further more when I tried inspecting the issue. So be sure to handle it with ample care. Unless Rubbertoe decides to do another run of his screwdrivers, CT is likely the only option if you want something legit. You might have to sacrifice a marginal amount of quality but keep your expectations tempered and you should be content with the final product.

  • @KYPT0KNIGHT
    @KYPT0KNIGHT Год назад

    I bought a 10th doctor screwdriver from CT... the end kind of broke with the slider... he had me ship it to him and list it as a 25 dollar toy flashlight. I sent it off... it vanished during shipping... he told me it happens sometimes and not to worry about it, never made it to destination, he stopped responding to me, and I'm pretty sure i paid close to 300 for it. So... I ended up with nothing.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Год назад

      That’s tragic. I’m so sorry you’ve had to deal with that. The issue with his being based in China to avoid copyright claims also means he’s pretty untouchable from this perspective. The only advice I can offer is, if you paid with a credit card, try to do a chargeback. Unfortunately, if you paid with debit, that’s probably not possible. And, in the future, don’t listen to people who tell you to ship things with a low declared value. What they’re doing is asking you to risk the loss of your item so that they can avoid paying much of an import fee. And I can tell you for certain: CT is fucking LOADED. He can afford the import duty in order to fix his own faulty product.

    • @KYPT0KNIGHT
      @KYPT0KNIGHT Год назад

      @@PropsmithReplicas it was a long time ago

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Год назад

      @@KYPT0KNIGHT Shame.

  • @philipsmith1134
    @philipsmith1134 Год назад

    I ordered a CT sonic one week ago. I’ve heard differing opinions on the recent productions, with some saying they’ve lessened in quality and others saying they’re just as good. Regardless, I’m excited to see how it holds up when it ships (which could take awhile given the the shipping from China to eastern US)

    • @mijju7604
      @mijju7604 Год назад

      Could you tell me how good it's quality is?

    • @nextofkin2321
      @nextofkin2321 10 месяцев назад

      You got it yet?

    • @philipsmith1134
      @philipsmith1134 10 месяцев назад

      @@nextofkin2321 hi, I got it back in the middle/beginning of February. So far it’s good. It looks amazing when polished, and the flick on the sonic I got is pretty good. Sometimes it gets a little tight and finicky but I think the Cape Cod polish I use lubricates it to flick better. The only complaint I have is that the red emitter that came with it isn’t fully sanded down on the bottom, so it screws on a little wonky but it still works I suppose.

  • @Kowalski_props
    @Kowalski_props Год назад

    You people really to cut this guy some slack here, a reason for the CO being there could be because Character Options make the sonics so when kids play with them and feel like the doctor so in that respect it is a replica and same goes for TWC one it’s just slightly more snazzy so all of you should just chill with all these complaints

  • @SimonSedivak
    @SimonSedivak Год назад

    just a small correction - the pommel and collar ARE actually screen accurate, but to the later version of the sonic that has been used by 12th Doctor. Nick actually revamped and upgraded his initial design for series 8-9 - mostly to make it stronger and less finicky. You can see the 1st gen and 2gen prop pictures side by side on his website where he talks about the history of the prop. So to sum it up, the v2 is kinda the best of both words - the stronger design from later seasons plus the button from the gen 1. I personally prefer the look of the collar from the gen1 but Nick probably had his reason to update the design for the prop to be more sturdier.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas 11 месяцев назад

      Hey! Sorry I somehow missed the notification for this comment when it posted, or I’d have responded sooner. Before doing this review, I spoke to Nick and he told me that this version was based on the original four filming props, so that’s the metric I used for this breakdown. But taking the later revisions into account actually makes this even more confusing… because apparently this has a hinged pommel, as used by 11, but with the dimensions of the hinge-less pommel of the 12? I think the scores would remain unchanged, honestly. But thanks so much for the extra context and please don’t hesitate to let me know if I make any factual errors in the future!

  • @yournutt
    @yournutt Год назад

    I have to admit, this review really rubs me the wrong way. Beyond the fact that you're including a toy in a replica comparison video, the rating system is inconsistent (ties aren't allowed but you'll skip numbers and also assign 0 points?), you miss out on the accuracy of various features and functions (the CO sounds are other sound effects the sonic makes in the show), and your "objective" point assignment system is really just a personal ranking based on factors you find important. I'm not even sure why you included the WC model, since that one is intended to be a functional thing and so will necessarily take liberties with accuracy. I think if you're going to include things that aren't pure replicas, you should probably not try to rank them as replicas, and instead talk about how they might appeal to other audiences. If you're going to talk about how you aren't a toy reviewer, you shouldn't review toys.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Год назад

      I don't know what to tell you, bud. I included the CO because not doing so would have resulted in a hundred people asking why I didn't include it. The point was to review all the replicas of this prop that were available at the time, and I did so in the most consistent and objective way I could, leaving aside my personal thoughts. I don't think the ratings would have come out any differently in terms of ranking if I had done some of the things you suggested... like, the CO's extra sounds weren't going to put it up over the Rubbertoe in a million years. And making a review for different audiences ins't what I do. It's not a Doctor Who channel, it's a prop channel. That said, I have full, individual reviews of each of these four that judge them on their own merits, rather than against one-another. I think the video is fair, and I think I communicated pretty well at the top what to expect. Sorry to have not met your expectations.

  • @maniraptavia4008
    @maniraptavia4008 Год назад

    Did you ever get around to the 10th Doctor's sonic in the end? I saw that you were originally planning to.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Год назад

      No, I couldn’t get my hands on an MFX and now there are SO MANY varieties of the 9/10 available that the video would be 2 hours long and probably obsolete the moment it came out.

  • @That_nerd_collection
    @That_nerd_collection Год назад

    Though I agree the first RR was built poorly, based on the photos of the film used props, the first RR would be the more screen accurate because it has them flaws like the gaps. I have a RR version 2 which is far better quality

  • @seansolo5318
    @seansolo5318 Год назад

    what edition number do you have

  • @LiveHedgehog
    @LiveHedgehog Год назад

    I wonder how difficult (if possible at all) it would be to essentially take the accurate bits from both Sonics to create the ultimate replica. i.e. the top of the Rubbertoe, the angled collar of the CT, the Rubbertoe leather and white handles, and the CT pommel. Probably not worth potentially damaging two rare items.

    • @PropsmithReplicas
      @PropsmithReplicas Год назад

      The only parts you’d be able to swap between the two would really be the black leather section and the white handle. The pommel, in particular, is made completely differently on the two. The CT is male, with the body of the sonic as the female, and it’s opposite on the Rubbertoe. For me, I’d be happiest with the Rubbertoe for most of the sonic, replacing only the pommel with the CT.

  • @bobpourri9647
    @bobpourri9647 Год назад

    11:35 the poster. Great job at reproduction! I have seen some really bad, inaccurate versions.