Видео

Oh my god! I absolutely love your analysis. I can't imagine being married to someone who can't move on from their first love. I don't like a people like hae sung.

How did you like “Past Lives”? I enjoyed watching it. It’s a beautiful film thought-provoking film. It kind of reminded me of “Last Night” (2010), which makes me think, should I make a video on “Last Night”? Let me know if you want it!

Timecodes: 00:00 Nora leaves South Korea and says goodbye to her best friend Hesun 00:31 Nora is 24, an aspiring writer and reconnects with Hesun 01:14 Nora wants to meet in person, but Hesun is reluctant 01:40 Truth was, neither of them was ready to take a step towards each other. 02:55 Reviving old relationships. Is it worth to bother? 04:13 For Hesun, Nora is the one who got away, she is his romantic love. 05:09 Is Hesun the villain of the movie? 06:15 Why does Hesun come to see Nora now, when she’s married? 07:33 Nora is not expecting he’s actually come for her. 08:52 Nora puts her husband in a humiliating situation.

This movie is about everything but Justine.

This was a high quality analysis, thank you!

You spent so much time with the details of the human interaction of the movie without mentioning once the real outcome of the movie! The end of the world!! Why?

This is an interesting review focused on the personal motives of the characters as seen from an outsider's perspective. I can see this point of view is just as valid as the ones focused more on the depressive side of the characters.

Patrick really sums it up at the end. “because you let me”. They go to their death like sheep, offering no resistance, knowing their daughter is in danger and has been mutilated in front of their eyes. There is no survival instinct strong enough kicking in to fight like hell for their child, it’s two against two! They are not that physically superior to them. Their submission is pure terror and impairing low self worth. They give up.

I thought the movie was weird in a good way. There was alot i didnt understand but I found it to be an interesting movie.

Thanks for explaining.. i was looking for just the ending but you did an amazing explaining the whole thing. Keep it up

The worst analysis of the movie.

A horror movie, a pschothriller and a drama at the same time, that definitely mirrors us social boundaries, how clinging to good behaviour can show us limits of humanitypf delf esteem of what human race is able to do hidden like devils in disguise.... this story tells us so much about society about cruelty and how far people go to achieve their aims. When I watched It for the first time, I deeply recognize the treasure I have just found. .. the abysses of people's mind, the recklessness and how they can easiöy manipulate and drive others to madness. The movie leaves us breathless, speechlees and deeply hurt behind.... without a final answer.... And thats what makes a good a really really sensitive and peofound movie ..... God's least precious invention? That thought comes up...

Just watched the movie.. it was very frustrating to watch two super-docile and low IQ humans just give in to the serial killers’ deeds.. great analysis tho.. attention to every tiny detail. Would love to talk to you about these kinds of movies (I’m no Patrick lmao). You should totally create a letterboxd or something tbh recommending all the psychological movies like this.

Excellent and on point analysis 👍 I just watched the movie for the first time and thought the leads were such terrible people, I had to go find someone talk about it lol. Totally agree with all your points! I also wanna add that Sarah's character is boring af, she has no personality outside of being beautiful, mysterious and having faith in destiny. It makes sense, it's so John can project more qualities of a perfect woman onto her. John likewise doesnt seem to have any traits outside his obsession with her and being sad, but it comes across as personality because he's played by John Cusack.

I don't know if things were intended as you analize it...but I'm buying many of these... It's everything about what Jongsu doesn't say, that makes this film really interesting. I didn't felt that much about Emi...but it could be what you interpreted. Indeed, the scene when they say goodbye and Ben rides Emi it's one of the most intense in the film (well, it's all pretty intense to be honest) I remember myself watching it in the theater and ragin so much inside. I saw Ben as predator taking everything from them...just that they can't act, they could have probably, that's the tragedy, as it is for many of us in our own lifes.

I appreciate this video but the background music and voice is weird

Justine indicates she's clairvoyant. She tries hard to put on a happy face at a wedding that has no significance in light of the upcoming death of everything. The folks at the wedding are rich and privileged, who laugh at the news the world's about to end. They believe Claire's husband. That's how I saw the movie.

Excellent interpretation. You are so articulate.

I dont understand why the husband left her 🤔 Just becuz she stood up for herself with the FIL? Why would he be so quick to leave becuz of that? His dad was being a dick! Why did she HAVE to work on her wedding night? I don't get it. Did he see her practically rape that dude? Also, why didn't they free all the horses so they could be free and not in cages? This movie was so bizarre.

This analysis was easily the most bizarre I've ever heard. Kudos! You told us all a lot more about YOU than you did the movie.

what's tragic is that they have such a genuine bond, but that doesn't guarantee us anything... I think their roles in the relationship are both bad for their growth, and yesss they are not in equal footing and it's like a matter of chicken or the egg... something external has had to happen for them to move their footing, but it results to them not being together anymore.... heartbreak!

I feel those who defend Justine are just feeding their victimhood. Yea, shes depressed its terrible, but it doesn’t justifying hurting everyone else around you

why video always stop. idt

Thank you for sharing your opinion, you thoroughly analyzed. Personally, I think it is appropriate for both of them to separate and continue their own love path. btw, I laugh when you say that Celeste is Jesse's mom, and he's her lazy teenager love it!😂😂😂

Good comparison to social media, but you didn't look at the other side too. Just as there are voyeurs on one side, there are exhibitionists on the other and all four of them fitted into the latter category too. There are people who cared too much about the lives of their "friends" in social media, but at the same time there are those with an obsession to keep others informed of almost every minute of their lives as if they would care (in most cases they don't). It is unhealthy for both cases.

im sorry but it's the husband the one that gets mad about ruining the tie. She acts like, upsie no big deal right? and he is like: buuu i i don't have another tie that matches this shirt, look what you have done. The movie is more about a toxic relationship. Toxic relationships don't have to be over the top, like she tells him: i made something unespected today, i choose the curtains, and he answer: are you sure that they are the right colour, like, she can't even choose curtains... she is not being treated like a human being with needs and free will

If he has issues that people leave I understand why he entrapped her but then why want to kill later and move on to another girl

I dont understand why he wants to kill her at the end if he has issues that people leave then when he got her trapped why he wants to kill her and find some other girl

Timecodes💖 00:00 Intro 00:41 So-re’s real life is far from perfect. 01:51 Murderer or unlucky girl? A point of view matters. 04:00 So-Re’s heart was vacant. 05:32 Pak He Djun’s life: convenient marriage, still a vacant heart. 08:47 So-Re escaping reality; her favourite tool. 10:13 So-re’s goal for Pak He Djun 10:54 Sad ending is better than a happy end. 12:25 What we really saw on the screen. 13:05 So-re 14:06 Pak He-Djun 16:07 Both characters are very similar 16:27 Questions to ask yourself

Andy is so nice why would anyone wanna leave 😢

this analysis is: depressed people cause constant problems to those arround them. done 🙏🏻 why care for justine or try to understand her right?

Sizin anlatımınız çok akıcı ve yorumlarınız zekice ve mantıklı. Siz Bjorn hakkında konuşurken ben o adamın, benim erkek versiyorum olduğunu fark ettim. Sınırlarım yok tıpkı Bjorn gibi. Nazik ve kırılganım, nazik insanlara kolayca inanıyorum. Beni uyandırdınız. Size teşekkür ederim. Kişisel sınırlar hakkında daha çok şey öğrenmem gerektiğini sizin sayenizde anladım.

If your heart is not in it, something bad can happen to you. so very true.

I feel like you didn't watch the second half of the movie, at all. This take is so far off the mark. I suggest you rewatch the scene of Claire trying to bathe Justine and then think about your assessment again and how easily you dismiss people caring for their family. Also, as someone who went through a significant depressive bout and was similarly cared for in the home of my sibling and his wife and young son, I can assure you that loved ones not giving up their family members literally saves lives. Every day.

Pls keep making videos

I hope this channel gets more recognition. Such great content with meticulous analysis does it for a nerd like me.

Congratulations, I’ve really enjoyed

uh, depression?

Great acting in this film, well done!

So spot on about Christian.

Whether anyone agrees with you or not, I certainly saw both sisters in a different light after watching your review and listening to your take about the film. Well done!

This video is filled with so much good advice. Thank you for making this beautiful video essay 🙏

Amazing video, defiantly opened my eyes to s few things I missed throughout the film. Please continue to upload more analysis

This movie is more of a character study than a straight horror movie. I appreciate your analysis.

People like Justine "enjoy their lifestyle"? Are you actually serious here? When children don't get their needs met when growing up, that pain comes out in adulthood. It's not as easy as just "growing up", snapping your fingers and becoming the perfect wife and mother. Furthermore the male apologist angle of this video is extremely frustrating and kind of grotesque. Claire's husband is quite literally the biggest coward in this entire film. Plus speeding up the video to make their voices sound infantile is a really nice touch to your terrible take on the characters and the film as a whole. I don't think anyone is claiming that Justine's behavior is ok or justified: it just is because she is severely depressed. It's not up to you to fix her. Your misunderstanding of depression is quite obvious as is your lack of empathy. My eyes have rolled so hard into the back of my head that I can't see.

I don't think the film is asking the audience their opinions on what the characters "should have done". Especially not in the context of pleasing their husbands. What a weird take.

It makes me angry that some people think depression is an excuse for awful behaviour … it’s not . I have severe depression and anxiety , but would never beat my horse to the ground , have sex with a stranger on my wedding day or enjoy all the attention my obnoxious behaviour is creating . I believe Justine did enjoy the attention while I would do anything just to disappear from sight ‼️. That apart I did enjoy the film , both female leads were excellent ably supported by Kiefer Sutherland as the narcissistic John . The scene where Justine can not lift her leg to climb into her bath was one of the most accurate depictions of severe depression I’ve ever seen on film . If you have been unfortunate to have been there you will know ‼️

This movie is just stupid I dont like it and just leave 🤷‍♀️

Seeing Justine as a manipulator... There's gotta be some award for missing the point of a movie by several solar systems... 😁it's kind of spectacular, to be fair. (And no, I'm not talking from an arrogant "sovereignty of interpretation" viewpoint. This movie is NOT a Lynch movie. It's pretty on the nose, and almost everybody gets it. Lars von Trier has talked about its meaning extensively.)

Stayed up late watching it last night. I must say this was a great breakdown. I like really like your take on it.