- Видео 81
- Просмотров 71 556
Meghan the Story Girl
Канада
Добавлен 8 окт 2014
On this channel you'll find me talking about the books I love - mainly classics. I'm also passionate about God and movies!
Lizzy's Adventures in Online Dating - winner of JASNA's 2021 Young Filmmakers' Contest
A modern day Elizabeth Bennet navigates the perils of online dating in this vlog style parody of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice
I'm so excited to say that Lizzy's Adventures in Online Dating won the 2021 Young Filmmakers' Contest which is put on by the Jane Austen Society of North America, Southwest region. It was judged by some amazing filmmakers, authors, and other creatives who I have been a fan of for a long time. I was so honoured that they saw and enjoyed my work. Thank you to JASNA SW for making this happen!
To learn more about the other finalists and the judges visit: jasnasw.com/2021/10/27/6827/?fbclid=IwAR1CyVDvg3eFVxk9LZae6k2sIh1koYCq5p7xkpA0c-VWfxxtGgVL8p9m-hQ...
I'm so excited to say that Lizzy's Adventures in Online Dating won the 2021 Young Filmmakers' Contest which is put on by the Jane Austen Society of North America, Southwest region. It was judged by some amazing filmmakers, authors, and other creatives who I have been a fan of for a long time. I was so honoured that they saw and enjoyed my work. Thank you to JASNA SW for making this happen!
To learn more about the other finalists and the judges visit: jasnasw.com/2021/10/27/6827/?fbclid=IwAR1CyVDvg3eFVxk9LZae6k2sIh1koYCq5p7xkpA0c-VWfxxtGgVL8p9m-hQ...
Просмотров: 855
Видео
Rereading Little House as an Adult
Просмотров 7173 года назад
I finally reread Little House in the Big Woods after not reading it since I was a child. This was a part of the Little House Readathon! Little House Readathon Hosts: LizziefayeLovesBooks ruclips.net/video/nljZkBpzoZ8/видео.html Naomi's Bookshelf ruclips.net/video/zSbzS2hJh0c/видео.html
There's a bedtime story for singles...
Просмотров 5164 года назад
This was an awesome book, guys! Books Mentioned: Alexandra and the Awful, Awkward, No Fun, Truly Bad Dates by Rebekah Manley www.goodreads.com/book/show/50891492-alexandra-and-the-awful-awkward-no-fun-truly-bad-dates
Ranking the Bronte's Novels! (Spoiler-Free)
Просмотров 4,1 тыс.4 года назад
Here I rank the Bronte's novels from my least favourite to favourite. My 'ranking' playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLpQTXKe30xsHeKgX7ijLE8kEt5IIkjdME Channels mentioned Naomi's Bookshelf: ruclips.net/channel/UCO0WAnmT0h5hbmvOBy3RF-A Kate Howe: ruclips.net/channel/UCgcjcyByhekqVpU6cKriX5w
Victober Choose Your Own Adventure Announcement
Просмотров 2614 года назад
The Fate of Jane Moore is the title of our Victorian choose your own adventure. If you want to take part in this head on over to Kate Howe's channel! People to Credit: Kate Howe ruclips.net/channel/UCgcjcyByhekqVpU6cKriX5w Emily “Novelle Novels” ruclips.net/channel/UCKGfL1R_P0xEeEDxNlCoVeg Carolyn “Carolyn Marie Reads” ruclips.net/channel/UCKX6WkAuxHx-BVhyGZqnyIw Mary “Happily Ever Esch” ruclip...
Victober 2020 Reaction + TBR!!!
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.4 года назад
Could I be more thrilled about Victober 2020? The hosts: Kate Howe ruclips.net/video/eidSDkBuwXE/видео.html Katie from Books and Things ruclips.net/video/vD0-QV0kxmE/видео.html Lucy the Reader ruclips.net/video/Q-Gr-idpezw/видео.html Other Channels mentioned: Naomi's Bookshelf ruclips.net/channel/UCO0WAnmT0h5hbmvOBy3RF-A Books for MK's ruclips.net/channel/UC8zVhBDnVGW3htXacn2EaIQ Books Mentione...
A Long Fatal Love Chase SPOILER FREE #louisamay2020
Просмотров 6504 года назад
Here are my SPOILER FREE thoughts on one of Louisa May Alcott's "blood and thunder" stories. Louisa May Alcott playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLpQTXKe30xsHvwB9BbS7ovgmOABFuq6NC My Year of Louisa May announcement video: ruclips.net/video/m4KgkNUqnLs/видео.html Kate Howe's Year of Louisa May announcement video: ruclips.net/video/cDAtNObz03Q/видео.html Read Along Schedule: November: Eden's Outcasts by Jo...
The Anne of Green Gables Book Tag [Original]
Просмотров 1,5 тыс.4 года назад
I created a tag! Let's dive into the wonderful world of Anne of Green Gables! There will be spoilers for the first book in the series, but not the rest. Thank you to Sarah's Story Chronicles (formerly known as Sarah Hanet) for helping me create this tag! Her channel: ruclips.net/user/pamdawkins13 My All Things Anne series: ruclips.net/p/PLpQTXKe30xsEVgUQ4s3OroBg4h3uBn5OV The Questions: 1. Accid...
Channel Name Change and Jane Austen July TBR
Просмотров 8334 года назад
Here I discuss my new channel name as well as what I plan on reading for Jane Austen July! Katie from Books and Things's announcement video: ruclips.net/video/KYi82SaBTjc/видео.html Marissa from Blatantly Bookish's announcement video: ruclips.net/video/IJeokFmt_Ns/видео.html #janeaustenjuly #janeausten
Journey to Jane Austen - The Watson's and Sanditon
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.4 года назад
Here I discuss Jane Austen's novel fragments. Journey to Jane Austen series announcement video: ruclips.net/video/ve_v_Pw_yC8/видео.html My Jane Austen related playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLpQTXKe30xsEQRUMmZgzauJSHCCzizaIH #janeausten #sanditon #thewatsons #prideandprejudice #persuasion #northangerabbey #senseandsensibility #emma #mansfieldpark
Hospital Sketches Spoiler-FREE #louisamay2020
Просмотров 2874 года назад
Here I discuss my second favourite Louisa May Alcott work. Louisa May Alcott playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLpQTXKe30xsHvwB9BbS7ovgmOABFuq6NC My Year of Louisa May announcement video: ruclips.net/video/m4KgkNUqnLs/видео.html Kate Howe's Year of Louisa May announcement video: ruclips.net/video/cDAtNObz03Q/видео.html Read Along Schedule: November: Eden's Outcasts by John Matteson December: Little Women...
Watch Along Annoucement #louisamayalcott
Просмотров 2544 года назад
As part of our Year of Louisa May readalong, Kate Howe and I will be hosting a watch along of the movie The Inheritance (1997) based on Louisa May Alcott's novella. Date: Saturday, June 6th Time: 5:15 pm PST, 8:15 pm EST Louisa May Alcott playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLpQTXKe30xsHvwB9BbS7ovgmOABFuq6NC My Year of Louisa May announcement video: ruclips.net/video/m4KgkNUqnLs/видео.html Read Along Sched...
Journey to Jane Austen - Pride and Prejudice
Просмотров 3594 года назад
Here I discuss Jane Austen's arguably most loved novel. There will be spoilers. Journey to Jane Austen series announcement video: ruclips.net/video/ve_v_Pw_yC8/видео.html My Jane Austen related playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLpQTXKe30xsEQRUMmZgzauJSHCCzizaIH #janeausten #prideandprejudice #persuasion #northangerabbey #senseandsensibility #emma #mansfieldpark
Journey to Jane Austen - Persuasion
Просмотров 8384 года назад
Here I discuss Jane Austen's most romantic novel. Journey to Jane Austen series announcement video: ruclips.net/video/ve_v_Pw_yC8/видео.html My Jane Austen related playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLpQTXKe30xsEQRUMmZgzauJSHCCzizaIH #janeausten #persuasion #prideandprejudice #northangerabbey #senseandsensibility #emma #mansfieldpark
The Shakespeare Tag with Sarah's Story Chronicle
Просмотров 2514 года назад
Original by Libby Stephenson ruclips.net/video/qUcDbvh-ooc/видео.html Sarah's Shakespeare playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLQRbJxO1FUk3TLcZR7v15uVLc5CGP-mGX Naomi's Bookshelf: ruclips.net/channel/UCO0WAnmT0h5hbmvOBy3RF-A The Questions: 1. What was your first exposure to Shakespeare? 2. Which Shakespeare plays (and poems) have you read? 3. Which have you seen (either on stage or on film)? 4. Do you have...
Journey to Jane Austen - Mansfield Park
Просмотров 6374 года назад
Journey to Jane Austen - Mansfield Park
Eight Cousins Spoiler-FREE #louisamay2020
Просмотров 9544 года назад
Eight Cousins Spoiler-FREE #louisamay2020
Journey to Jane Austen - Northanger Abbey and Sense & Sensibility
Просмотров 3454 года назад
Journey to Jane Austen - Northanger Abbey and Sense & Sensibility
Journey to Jane Austen February Wrap Up
Просмотров 3414 года назад
Journey to Jane Austen February Wrap Up
Journey to Jane Austen series announcement and TBR
Просмотров 4924 года назад
Journey to Jane Austen series announcement and TBR
Greta Gerwig's Little Women - My Thoughts
Просмотров 4884 года назад
Greta Gerwig's Little Women - My Thoughts
Book Haul with Sarah's Story Chronicle
Просмотров 4014 года назад
Book Haul with Sarah's Story Chronicle
2017 version is my favorite. Emily Watson as Marmee broke my heart.
She was so good!!
Where did u get the edition of tge professor!?
I believe it was at a used book store!
As an adult I just picked this book up, simply because I've been told it's a very good read., Thank You for your options 😊
The 1985 PBS version will always be special to me, since that is my generation. A true classic. I also met the late Jon Crombie who played Gilbert in 2008.
There was a 1978 TV version with Susan Dey and Eve Plumb. I liked it as a kid.
I wish they would do movies on Little Men for a change. Little Women has been done to death. How about a cinematic version of Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm.
The general public only knows Jane Eyre and Wuthering Heights (partly from popular movies) but kid sister Ann gets the respect she deserves from those who have read all the Bronte novels. Anne's characters to me seem the most believable.
Agreed!
Mine first, mine last, mine even in the grave.
We have watched / Have All of the Anne Series on DVD & Road to Avonlea. Just started watching Emily of new Moon. just curious on where the Avonlea fits into the whole story. because theres Anne of Avonlea & The Book & TV Series Road to Avonlea. which does have Marilla & Rachel Lynd in it. My wife is from PEI & we are going there Again this summer.
That’s awesome that you and your family are so into Anne and the adaptations! The first three books of the series are Anne of Green Gables, Anne of Avonlea and Anne of the Island. Chronicles of Avonlea is a short story collection that was published between books 2 and 3, and is not technically part of the Anne of Green Gables series. While it features Anne and some other Avonlea characters, it kind of stands alone. When you read the stories though, it seems to take place between books 2 and 3. It is also followed up by Further Chronicles of Avonlea which was published several years later. Road to Avonlea is a wonderful TV series created by Kevin Sullivan (as you know of course) which draws from these two short story collections. More than that though, the TV show draws from a different LM Montgomery duology, The Story Girl and its sequel, The Golden Road. These books take place in a different town than Avonlea and do not involve any of the Anne of Green Gables characters. These are the books that Sara, Felix, Felicity, and the rest of the King family come from. Kevin Sullivan brilliantly transplants them to Avonlea, incorporates their stories with the Chronicles stories, and adds plenty of his own creativity. I hope that makes sense, and that you have an amazing time in PEI!
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 we did Thank you. if you haven't do check out Emily of new Moon, channel up lifting faith & Family. it's Fully Filmed in PEI.
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 we did thank you. You do have to check out Emily of new Moon, and do a Review for that one.
I loved the video and how amazing your way of speaking about each book ❤
You were in Narnia? What do you mean??
Just found your channel bc I was looking up Betsy Tacy videos! Do you think you’ll ever make videos again? Love your videos ✨
Yay! So glad you like Betsy Tacy! I likely won't make videos again as I have moved on to different stages in my life, but I appreciate your interest in my channel 😊
Did you ever make it to England to see the Jane Austen places? Are you going to do any more with your channel?
Hi Janine, thanks for the comment! Unfortunately, I STILL have not done my Jane Austen trip. It is certainly not off the table, and I'm hoping to go soon. I will likely not do anymore with my channel as I have moved into some different phases of life, but I appreciate your interest!
I love Anne my favorite Canadian book
Charlotte Brontë is my 7th favorite author and my favorite female author. The only woman to write a book in my top ten books of all time. 7) "Vilette" by Charlotte Brontë 68) "Jane Eyre" by Charlotte Brontë 139) "The Professor” by Charlotte Brontë 163) "Shirley" by Charlotte Brontë 20) "The Tenant of Wildfell Hall" by Anne Brontë 97) "Agnes Grey" by Anne Brontë 173) "Wuthering Heights" by Emily Brontë The 1943 "Jane Eyre" is the best movie version of this story. FAVORITE AUTHORS must have two books in the top 100 books of all time. 1) Leo Tolstoy (Resurrection) 2) Ivan Turgenev (Fathers and Sons) 3) James A. Michener (Chesapeake) 4) Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn (A Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich) 5) Fyodor Dostoevsky (The Idiot) 6) C. S. Lewis (The Magician's Nephew) 7) Charlotte Brontë (Vilette) 8) J. R. R. Tolkien (The Hobbit) 9) Isaac Asimov (Foundation and Empire) 10) Jane Austen (Pride and Prejudice) 11) Mark Twain (The Adventures of Tom Sawyer) 12 Anne Brontë (The Tenant of Wildfell Hall) 13) George Eliot (Silas Marner) 14) Anthony Trollope (He Knew He Was Right) 15) Dr. Burrhus Frederic (B. F.) Skinner (Verbal Behavior) 16) Charles Dickens (Hard Times) 17) Thomas Hardy (Jude the Obscure)
Those are great choices!
Absolutely brilliant video 👍
Reminds me a lot of the Samantha books from American girl
I loved those books!
The Tenant of Wildfell Hall is so underrated as well as Agnes Grey, I only just finished reading them both. Really agree with your comments, however, my favourite is Jane Eyre, and I agree a great one to start with when reading a Bronte book. Great recommendations and comments, it was interesting to hear your views on them. From WA.
Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed Anne's work :)
“Foundered” is a word, it means sank like a ship.
i've now moved on to Tenant and am already enthralled!
It's so good!
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 now finished! she's an incredible author. although i didn't read of any "door slam" in the book -- what was that about?
@@jackjones5920 Great! It was a later literary commentator's figure of speech :)
I found your channel from the 2023 #littlehousereadathon. It was nice to meet you in the discussions and was so fun!
Thanks! I had a great time meeting you there too!
I picked up Agnes Grey today for a casual Sunday afternoon read, at your recommendation, and ended up smashing half the book very quickly! It's great.
That's great! Glad you're enjoying it :)
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 i also have to tell you: i cross-referenced all the Brontë ranking videos on youtube and it turns out Tenant is the most popular of all by a comfortable margin!
@@jackjones5920 Really?? I would have assumed it would have been Jane Eyre or maybe Wuthering Heights. Anne is finally getting her due!
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 yeah you would've thought! Wuthering Heights is 2nd, and Jane Eyre 3rd (Shirley & Agnes Grey equal 4th) i finished Agnes Grey last night. loved it.
I recently read Wuthering Heights and was wondering if i was missing something because I just didn't have the opinion that it is a great novel. I just got very little out of it and it didn't resonate. And i agree, I don't want to read depressing stuff unless there is value in the understanding of it. I will try a re-read in the future and see if anything changes!
Can you please give a listing of all of the Anna Green Gables books and also books that are related Anne that aren’t in the classic eight!!
Besides the classic eight, Chronicles of Avonlea and Further Chronicles of Avonlea contain a little bit of Anne. There's also The Road to Yesterday and The Blythes Are Quoted. I hope you enjoy!
I'm a brazilian fan of anne of green gables and i want to buy an english version to train my reading I'm in doubt between anne of avonlea and anne of the island haha
That's awesome that you're using it to help with your English! So glad you're an Anne fan. Are you wondering which one to read first? I would go with Anne of Avonlea since it comes before Anne of the Island in the series order and in when LM Montgomery wrote it ❤
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 Sooo... I'm currently reading Anne of the island but in portuguese, I'm still not sure which one to buy in english 😅
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 I'm thinking of finish reading them all and choose my favorite to read in english:) For now, my favorite is Anne of Avonlea😊
That's a great idea!
Concerning the restrictions on the Sabbath, I think I can provide a bit of an insight. I am an Orthodox Jew, and also keep the Sabbath. A lot of the forbidden activities in the book, are similar to what a Jewish Sabbath is. I don't know exactly what the restrictions are for Christians, but in Jewish law, there are thirty nine categories of activities that are forbidden to do on the Sabbath, such as lighting and extinguishing fires, cooking, sewing, and so forth. (riding on an animal or vehicle like a cart also is included here.) So yes, in the modern era, we also refrain from turning lights on and off, cook everything beforehand and don't drive in cars. I am assuming, for the purpose of the book, that similar restrictions were adopted in the Christian religion. Sabbath is not necessarily about "relaxation," but as a holy day, and a connection to G-d. It is also joyous. Unlike in the book, our children certainly do play with their toys (unless they are battery operated) sing songs, go for walks and play in the park. Depending on their age and ability, they hopefully do some religious study, but they are certainly not expected to sit still and be quiet all day. I don't know where that custom comes from in the book.
Thank-you! That's very interesting to hear about how Sabbath is within your faith ❤
It’s interesting that you talk about a beautiful ocean setting at the end of Agnes Grey (not a spoiler everyone) because Anne Brontë was really sick and asked to go to the beach to help improve her health, so Charlotte’s best friend Ellen took Anne to the sea and that is where she died.
Wow, that's super interesting to hear how her own dreams and desires for the ocean affected her writing.
I love Mansfield Park
Where you been? I miss your videos,hope you well in life meghan
Aw, thanks! I've been busy with school so haven't been making videos, but I appreciate the message!
So exactly what order should I be reading the Anne of Green Gables books?
Most people automatically read them in chronological order of Anne's life (that's how they're presented in the box sets), but I think the series is actually better in publication order. Since that's the way Montgomery originally planned them to be read, I feel that the momentum and flow is much stronger that way. So the order would be 12357846 😊
oh my birthday is february 29 and exactly i watched this today.,.its just i'm amazed and yes i am going to read the jo's boys right now since my book is finally arrived.. thanks for good feedback
I appreciate the love for Tenant. Anne is so underrated next time her sisters. It's an amazing book. Personally I like wuthering heights better but I like the Gothic creepy element. And I simply adore the twisted relationship as opposed to the traditional "bad boy changing for a good girl" thing of most other novels of this nature. I get why people don't like it but I also think people don't understand that it's not meant to be a romantic book to idolize. The beauty is in Emily's writing and making you react to these characters whether you hate them or love them. She was simply that brilliant of a writer. She went completely against the rules.
I'm glad you love Tenant too! Very true that Emily's writing is brilliant, and that she was bold and audacious in writing what she wanted to write instead of being confined by literary formulae. You're so right that it's good Heathcliff doesn't change for Cathy. In real life abusive people usually stay abusive (unless they have good therapy and a strong desire to change). I think it's actually dangerous and a disservice to the reader to write bad boys (aka abusive jerks) who then reform because of the heroine's magical love. Readers sometimes take this as something to be replicated in their lives. Thankfully, Heathcliff does not reform, and most people don't want to be with a man like that! You can tell I have strong feelings on this 😂
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 I totally get it. That's exactly why I argue against Jane Eyre being feminist and ahead it's time. Mr Rochester was manipulative and emotionally abusive. He strung along an innocent woman to make Jane jealous while he was simultaneously hiding his wife from her. And Jane didn't do anything progressive or feminist....she went back to her abuser after his wife had died so she could be with him properly by society's standards of her time. I argue the point with people that this is not healthy in any way and no matter how brilliant their speeches are to each other, in the end he had done nothing to change his ways or redeem himself. He sat at home until she came running back. And she was even wiling to go back not knowing the wife had died possibly to become his mistress. Put this in a modern day setting and we abhor men who behave in this way. But in a Victorian setting give him a romantic speech and he's the best thing on the planet. Why? I digress. I guess this is why I prefer Heathcliff and Cathy. They are both terrible and pretty much deserve each other and end up hurting each other. You can love them and interpret them as misunderstood or hate them and call them horrible people but they still get what they deserve in the end. Cathy screws herself over marrying a man she doesn't love for money and status and Heathcliff is forced to endure a lifetime without her. If you hate them you can laugh at the karma. If you love them you can be happy they finally get to haunt the moors together for eternity. It works either way. But as these novels go Tenant had the best story to teach a lesson about the nature of abusive relationships and how best to handle it (at least at that time in history) Jane Eyre and Wuthering Heights are great novels to read but not books or characters to model ones life after by any means. Sorry for the long reply. I'm very passionate about this as well lol.
@@bmonster Yes, yes, and yes to everything you said! If you haven't written a book of literary criticism on this topic yet, you totally should. I would definitely read that!
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 That is a great idea!!
Sidney another mr darcy. Austen repeats her characters so much and their status.
This presenter is lik mrs bates
Oof. This hurt, as a huge fan of the 1949 version and someone who did not like the 2019 version at all.
I actually thought it wasn’t that true to the book. Laurie was so different!
Haha, we all have different opinions, that's for sure!
Absolutely! It’s all good!
I love every single book and I can’t pick.
They're all so good!
Did you forget that there’s a 1949 version?! Lol. It’s the best! 😍
Haha, it's not my favourite, but it definitely has it strengths! Here's a video I did about all the different versions😁: ruclips.net/video/47Cuw30S7O4/видео.html
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 oh gosh I love it! Haha. But I did grow up on it.
I'm team Charlotte Brontë lol I enjoyed all of her novels, especially Villette and Jane Eyre. And Wuthering Heights by Emily is my favourite Brontë novel. That's my top three. Wuthering Heights/Villette/Jane Eyre.
Nice!
I love Anne too! And not too much charlotte bronte that much. I love your top 3!!
Hello! Can you please share the link for the replica of original version of Anne of Green Gables book from where I can buy. I would love to buy me one.
For sure :) I got it here: annestore.ca/products/anne-of-green-gables-edition?_pos=1&_sid=c5e66e0c7&_ss=r&variant=39512346165300
Love Mansfield Park too, and really enjoyed this review
Thanks so much!
Ephesians such a unique and interesting choice! Enjoyed the whole video, some of my favorites are in there, too (Little Women, P&P). Peace
Thanks!
Seeing people put both Anne books at the top is just my favorite thing :)
Oh yay, me too!
Nice video.
Hey Mrs Megan, i had bought the collection of Anne of green gables yesterday and reading 1st book. I really liked it!
That's great!
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 yes! Also how is the second book, Anne of avonlea?
I really enjoy the second book even though a lot of people say the first is their favourite 😊
I am currently reading Agnes Grey , and realised how sad it is that Anne Bronte's books are always overshadowed by the other Brontes' . And I was also surprised to see how much I am enjoying Anne's writing and I'm flying through Agnes Grey
So glad you're enjoying it. I agree - Anne is totally underrated!
I have only come across two Anne Brontë poems, but in my esteem they blow out of the water the complete works of poems written by either of her two sisters. I am really trying to get Anne's complete works of poems. 7) "Vilette" by Charlotte Brontë 20) "The Tenant of Wildfell Hall" by Anne Brontë 68) "Jane Eyre" by Charlotte Brontë 97) "Agnes Grey" by Anne Brontë 139) "The Professor” by Charlotte Brontë 163) "Shirley" by Charlotte Brontë 1 73) "Wuthering Heights" by Emily Brontë
Can I borrow your bookssss? :((
I'm a super noob to Victorian literature and the Brontes, but I just finished Wuthering Heights and loved it. I am planning to read at least one more novel by Anne and Charlotte too, but probably I'll read something a little easier in between. I find what little Victorian literature I have read very interesting, but dense and difficult (for me). [Edit: My sister has read Wuthering Heights, Jane Eyre, and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, and she likes Tenant of Wildfell hall the most, so there's that.]
So glad you're getting into Victorian literature! I love that your sister likes Tenant the most. It's just so good!
I totally agree with you on Sanditon and its mini series but you didn't speak about the "complete" book. I would have liked to hear you opinion about it. 😀
I think there's a few completed versions lol Which one do you mean?
@@meghanthestorygirl4581 I only know 1 published version "Sanditon, by Jane Austen and Another Lady". I would like to have you opinion on this completed version, if you know it. I've liked it though in my opinion the 2nd author made the story too short and too simple compaired to what Jane Austen dropped hints of. In my opinion the characters are not developped enough (eg Miss Lamb), secondary charaters plots are not fleshed out enough and finally some potential main themes of the unfinished manuscript are not used as : bankruptcy / unreasonable investments + "sea treatment" and other fashonnable and absurd medicine + habits change, extrantric behaviours and frivolous manners in sea bathing places. I'm not really sure that Jane Austen would have written "this" love story between Charlotte & Sidney because usually her heroine & hero find ways to complete each other, help each other to grow and improve their flaws and I don't find it's the case in the love story of this completed version of the novel. Despite all this, I love the book, I love this version of Sidney Parker, I like the dialogues, I love that the 2nd author really tried to keep on Jane Austen words and humour. It seems I had many things to say ! I wanted to know your opinion and your sentiments about this complete version of Sanditon. 😀
@@MissBennet83 I'll have to read that version of Sanditon! It sounds like I would really appreciate some aspects, but that I might also not find the Charlotte/Sidney storyline entirely satisfactory. You've definitely made me interested though!
Brava! Very well written & acted!!
Thank you!