The main problem with these kind of things is the resistance on getting started.. So if a mac in envolved, you most likely not fill the note because of the friction….
Great review, I think that Apple should include a search functionality; I feel as though the filter option isn’t quite enough. Also, there is no area to recover accidentally deleted journal entries. Of course, it’s a new application that Apple have brought out, so I think that we will see these functionalities in due time. I also want to take a moment to appreciate how Journal looks and feels. It’s very smooth and easy to navigate. The photos are laid out at the top and the text is at the bottom, you can add as many photos as you want and expand the Journal entry to view them all.
@@Praveen-or5ce because I can’t see why they wouldn’t since they have journaling suggestions and the state of mind has to do with your feelings and logging them through the day so I would love to use that information to expand on the context that I added when I logged my mood and feelings
@@Praveen-or5ce so can you and everyone on the beta give apple that feedback for me because I’m sure that I’m not the only one who thinks this is one of the most important journal suggestions for them to add
That would be interesting if Apple could give the option to export it as a book, if you or like what Apple does with Apple Music or Photos, where you get a slideshow or a look at what you’ve been doing throughout the year, if they could give an option for that to be exported into a book if you wanted too
Agree with some other comments, a nice start, but I want multiple journals, I need to keep a journal for work so this digital version would be great, but I don’t want that to get mixed up with a life journal or holiday journal
I was actually looking for a journal app to keep track of my trading attitude/perf. I hope Apple will add a « send to journal » option on screenshot Can’t wait to test it
Great review. I’ve been journaling for a few years now, so if I can’t import my past years from another app I’ll have to give it a pass and that’s why Day One and the rest are not worrying.
I agree. I had high hopes for the app, to the point where I even upgraded to the 17.2 beta so I could install it. But as you say, if I can't import from other apps, it's really no better than a bare-bones text editor.
It seems somewhat under featured. Eg search feature will become necessary in the future. Tagging so can link entries together. Uncovering previous reflections to review to remind self of past events.
I haveit on my iPhone with beta, no multiple journals, no search, no hash tags, no location, no music you were listening to. Hopefully it improves- right now it's add some photos, type some text, can also add a voice entry
I’m now using it in my iPhone, it’s really easy to use and I really like but. But why it doesn’t available in iPad ? I also hope this journal can have the search function.
Why would anyone want to spend time adding stuff to this app when other than looking at it on the screen there is no way to export it?! Lack of export or archive makes it junk! Would you take a load of photos that you could only view on your phone and couldnt get back out?!
I’ve been using Day One for almost a year now and like that I can journal on all my devices, create a photo book of my travels, create templates, etc. Apple will need to add these types of features as well in order for me to stop using Day One. Perhaps down the road it will add new features, but I can’t wait years for Apple to get its act together and be better than Day One.
So you can only add 13 pieces of media.. 12 if you include a location. I wish it allowed to add other locations then one only. Also I’ve noticed that I don’t see a “Headline” like they show in the pics in the App Store. Am I missing something?
I came to see if you could edit the date of the entry cause I accidentally started journaling a week ago (it was a list of notes I dated that turned into a journal log) and I am very happy to see that it’s an option so I can easily copy my notes into the journal app. I do wanna know one very important thing that may be obvious but will obviously need to be there for me to use the new app. Does it have a recently deleted section in case I accidentally delete an entry? I’m sure it should but I’d like to know for sure or bring this to someone’s attention who’s beta testing ios 17.2 to suggest to apple if it is in fact missing. Thanks for the vid.
Might be useful if i could pick any day in the past and see what texts i got and sent and what I did, but im not gonna manually log all that in myself along with my personal thoughts, get a grip
sorry… the video is really clear and your explanation are perfect but… i’m just missing the point: what is the utilty of the app?? 🤔 i mean it’s not a reminder it’s not a diary… mmhh.. i don’t get it… how does it helps me?
The functionality is kinda limited what you can do. It needs to allow us to organize into different categories or folders like Notes. So is not very organized. Like organize into different topics, dates, year, etc.
Is the media independently stored from the library? I don’t do iCloud Photo Library and I’m regularly dumping my camera roll out. I know a lot of machine learning features rely on iCloud Photo Library so I wonder if this app will be of any use for me. I currently pay for Day One and I really like it but I feel like a native app would have more potential
good review andrew. I journal everyday for quite a few years. it is very surprising how frequently I have to search for something or information. I have been anxiously been waiting for this app to be available and it looks great from your initial review. I am curious if you will be able to import a journal from a different app? the Apple journal looks a bit more complex that what I have been using. thank you for your review…keep ‘em coming
I've used Pages as a diary since 2021, and love that Apple have built a journal app in now... but whyyy isn't it on Mac?? I barely ever do diary entries in my phone, I much prefer typing on a proper keyboard. I'm gonna give Journal a go since I love using "the proper thing to do things" but I really hope they port it to Mac soon...
I like the idea of this. I have it installed now with the Beta release, and it says it'll start delivering suggestion prompts depending on what task I'm doing on my phone. Other than opening the Journal app and reviewing the prompts loaded there, I haven't received any while not in the app. Also, maybe it's just me, but it seems like they're missing the boat on incorporating Notes, Freeform, and now Journal into one seamless app with the varying functionality present depending on the use case for a particular task.
I agree with you. Why don’t they put all these 3 apps…Notes, Free Form, and Journal together into one app? Why do we have to switch to different apps? Is just not very functional and also very tedious and redundant when it could be in just one app.
this is the best update on ios17 so far. i love that app so much. it motivates me to write something and it suggests me photos and everything, less work for great memories.
I would love to have the possibility to share entries with others. And these should be able to comment entries. Also workout data could be added such as the track you went on and the exercise summary. Or also some basic weather data for that day.
This seems like a half baked app for Apple. If you journal how are you going to search back and look at your entries? Do you have to scroll the entire time? Can you export your entries? Are they viewable on a Pc? Lots of issues
I would like to see a way to archive all your entries into a playable or printable version, should the app itself be deprecated in the future, otherwise the purpose of a journal becomes a moot point.
It’s cool but I wish it would do more. Apple has so much data they could port into this to make it even easier and fun to use. Of course users would need to consent but if the app would automatically import the pictures I took that day, where I went, music and podcasts I listened to, what workout I did etc. Hopefully that comes in the future, but pretty disappointing in my opinion. Makes you wonder why they even delayed it in the first place when it’s such a basic app.
I’m personally excited about the app because I use all of apples stock apps for simplicity but I do agree with you here in that I don’t understand why Apple delayed this when it looks very basic. Doesn’t make sense to me.
Please let me know how because I’ve used the app and it does not. All it does is suggest a reflection, which pins that reflection to the top that’s it. Then it’s a blank canvas. From there you can add a picture, memo, and location. So no it does not automatically show me the podcasts, or musics I listened to that day, or what type of workout I did. And in regards to location and pictures, you have to manually do it yourself. My statement was I want all that pre populated.
@@LJHeattles check out the original Apple showcase of the journal app. It might come in later betas, but usually in the recommended page there should be one that you can tap that has all the photos you took, what workout you did, what music you listened to, who you were with, where you were, podcasts and so on.
Hello Andrew. Greetings from Germany. As always, just like today, I enjoy your great videos. Entertaining, to the point, and very informative. Thank you very much for all your efforts. I‘m looking forward to the new journaling App.
This looks like a great app! I currently use Day One which I really like. It seems like in this early phase I won’t use it simply because I already get a lot of use out of the tools my current journal has. I need something that is does either differently or in addition to for me to switch. So I’ll keep an eye out for now, but I’ll stick to my current journal app. 👍🏽
Thanks for the review! Like others have commented below, I would love to see a search function but also an 'export as' or 'save/share to' function. Since it's not available on my MacBook Pro and I'd really love to be able to use a keyboard to make entries, I've looked into Day One (which has Search and Export as) but the reviews kinda scare me away 😬
i don't wanna try anything other than Apple's journal. but kinda curious what does the reviews say about Day One (ofcourse I ain't gonna use it, just curious)
It should be downloadable and not come as a stock app like they did with the Apple Music Classical app I have a friend who hates it when they put new apps in the operating system by default
Little guy has glaucoma in his eye. Has required two surgeries so far to correct and has caused some vision loss in the one eye. But he's a trooper and is powering through.
For me, who doesn't like typing so much, it will be stressful to type for a long time on the iPhone. The journal app would have to be compatible with other devices such as the iPad. I am disappointed
no need to be disappointed. If you use Ipad or Mac, you can create new Journal entry/text on your Mac. Then use air drop copy and leave the text in Journal new entry. Thats what I do now when using other apps on Iphone. I just write text on my MAC or iPad and copy to iPhone when ready. do the same in Journal.
Had it for two days now. “Do what you want to do with it “ - which is ‘nothing’. I think I may be too old to understand why this is useful… Do you have to be massively self centred? Is that what people are these days?
That looks like an app that I would prefer to use on my iPad or Mac
I think it will eventually.
OMG, I was saying this should be on a social media app.
@@kimberlymorton4690 😂yes, because social media apps don’t already have enough private information about all of us!
That’s exactly what I was thinking
The main problem with these kind of things is the resistance on getting started.. So if a mac in envolved, you most likely not fill the note because of the friction….
I’ve never journaled before, so I’m interested to try this and see if it helps to organize the way I organize my days.
You mean scheduling wise or diary style? I think this would be interesting
Great review, I think that Apple should include a search functionality; I feel as though the filter option isn’t quite enough. Also, there is no area to recover accidentally deleted journal entries. Of course, it’s a new application that Apple have brought out, so I think that we will see these functionalities in due time.
I also want to take a moment to appreciate how Journal looks and feels. It’s very smooth and easy to navigate. The photos are laid out at the top and the text is at the bottom, you can add as many photos as you want and expand the Journal entry to view them all.
I think they will!
Is this info tied to iCloud storage? I've been adding some video clips and I'm curious about that.
I got a question does this integrate with the state of mind as well? Could you put your state of mind data into your journaling?
Can’t see that option as of now
@@Praveen-or5ce I’m thinking that they are gradually introducing more features and it might be one on the official release
@@Praveen-or5ce because I can’t see why they wouldn’t since they have journaling suggestions and the state of mind has to do with your feelings and logging them through the day so I would love to use that information to expand on the context that I added when I logged my mood and feelings
@@Praveen-or5ce so can you and everyone on the beta give apple that feedback for me because I’m sure that I’m not the only one who thinks this is one of the most important journal suggestions for them to add
Needs to be able to import data from Calendar app as I want to build an autobiography from historical info
Are you what? An emperor?
@@dans7262 idk why this made me laugh so hard
That would be interesting if Apple could give the option to export it as a book, if you or like what Apple does with Apple Music or Photos, where you get a slideshow or a look at what you’ve been doing throughout the year, if they could give an option for that to be exported into a book if you wanted too
What kind of search capabilities are there? Keyword, tag, date? Looks good so far.
What the difference from the notes app
How do you export a journal entry to a contact
I would love to be able to add sound from my Apple Watch to the journal.
Is there a way to take out your data?
is also available for MacBook?
The app is a little too bare bones at the moment, but I’m hoping they pull in some basic formatting features from the Notes app.
Will this app be synced with a Mac?
Agree with some other comments, a nice start, but I want multiple journals, I need to keep a journal for work so this digital version would be great, but I don’t want that to get mixed up with a life journal or holiday journal
I agree! Is not very organized. The functionality is limited. I need to categorize into different folders, organize by year, topics, etc.
I was actually looking for a journal app to keep track of my trading attitude/perf.
I hope Apple will add a « send to journal » option on screenshot
Can’t wait to test it
"I hope Apple will add a « send to journal » option on screenshot" Hear, hear!
What about templates and formatting of text, is Markdown supported? Hwo does it compare to Day One?
Great review. I’ve been journaling for a few years now, so if I can’t import my past years from another app I’ll have to give it a pass and that’s why Day One and the rest are not worrying.
I agree. I had high hopes for the app, to the point where I even upgraded to the 17.2 beta so I could install it. But as you say, if I can't import from other apps, it's really no better than a bare-bones text editor.
@@robynsineadsheppard6480 I'm suer Apple has some grand plan for the App but at the ,moment it's not much better than the notes App.
You can’t search in the entries in that app???
I can see where is the difference with the notes ? Can someone explain to me?
It seems somewhat under featured. Eg search feature will become necessary in the future. Tagging so can link entries together. Uncovering previous reflections to review to remind self of past events.
Can you use hashtags for retrieval afterwards of similar journal entries regarding the same theme?
I haveit on my iPhone with beta, no multiple journals, no search, no hash tags, no location, no music you were listening to.
Hopefully it improves- right now it's add some photos, type some text, can also add a voice entry
Is this similar to the day one app? I’m gonna continue using day one app until Apple matches their features. It looks good so far.
Do you know if will be possible clean the local storage of the Journal, but keep the files on cloud?
I’m disappointed that they didn’t include Search tool in or even Years and Months breaks.
I’m now using it in my iPhone, it’s really easy to use and I really like but. But why it doesn’t available in iPad ? I also hope this journal can have the search function.
How long until it's available to the public and not just beta users?
Likely arriving by the end of the year.
I got it today it just appears
Why would anyone want to spend time adding stuff to this app when other than looking at it on the screen there is no way to export it?! Lack of export or archive makes it junk! Would you take a load of photos that you could only view on your phone and couldnt get back out?!
Is there any way to transfer any previous journaling I’ve done on the notes to the new journals app ?
Did you mess up your screen in the top right corner there already?
No export option, I suppose? 🤔
I’ve been using Day One for almost a year now and like that I can journal on all my devices, create a photo book of my travels, create templates, etc. Apple will need to add these types of features as well in order for me to stop using Day One. Perhaps down the road it will add new features, but I can’t wait years for Apple to get its act together and be better than Day One.
I have iOS 17.1.2 but can’t find it?😅
There is no search!! 😞
Can you export everything into pdf, like for example to make a hard copy in the future.
I wanna use this but on iPhone it would be too cramped. I would prefer on iPadOS so I can use the Magic Keyboard or on my MacBook.
So you can only add 13 pieces of media.. 12 if you include a location. I wish it allowed to add other locations then one only. Also I’ve noticed that I don’t see a “Headline” like they show in the pics in the App Store. Am I missing something?
I came to see if you could edit the date of the entry cause I accidentally started journaling a week ago (it was a list of notes I dated that turned into a journal log) and I am very happy to see that it’s an option so I can easily copy my notes into the journal app.
I do wanna know one very important thing that may be obvious but will obviously need to be there for me to use the new app. Does it have a recently deleted section in case I accidentally delete an entry? I’m sure it should but I’d like to know for sure or bring this to someone’s attention who’s beta testing ios 17.2 to suggest to apple if it is in fact missing. Thanks for the vid.
I don’t believe it does, I couldn’t find it at least.
Might be useful if i could pick any day in the past and see what texts i got and sent and what I did, but im not gonna manually log all that in myself along with my personal thoughts, get a grip
I like to be able to dictate to text as well as record to audio.
I would most likely wait until the Mac version comes out since it’s still too frustrating for me to type on the iPhone keyboard.
It’s not syncing with my devices I have a couple of iPhones and info is not syncing 😢
Do they provide transcription for audio notes?
Not at the moment. It really needs that as it is a pain using the phone to type.
When we add photos I hope it just references the existing photo than storing it as a separate copy.
How did you get 17.2? i've been waiting to dive into this app since they announced it.
sorry… the video is really clear and your explanation are perfect but… i’m just missing the point: what is the utilty of the app?? 🤔
i mean it’s not a reminder
it’s not a diary…
mmhh.. i don’t get it… how does it helps me?
The functionality is kinda limited what you can do. It needs to allow us to organize into different categories or folders like Notes. So is not very organized. Like organize into different topics, dates, year, etc.
Is the media independently stored from the library? I don’t do iCloud Photo Library and I’m regularly dumping my camera roll out. I know a lot of machine learning features rely on iCloud Photo Library so I wonder if this app will be of any use for me. I currently pay for Day One and I really like it but I feel like a native app would have more potential
good review andrew. I journal everyday for quite a few years. it is very surprising how frequently I have to search for something or information. I have been anxiously been waiting for this app to be available and it looks great from your initial review. I am curious if you will be able to import a journal from a different app? the Apple journal looks a bit more complex that what I have been using. thank you for your review…keep ‘em coming
So far, no imports. I was wondering that, too. It’s bare at the moment but hoping for a few more features soon.
I wish I could import to Apple journal from other apps like Journey.
I've used Pages as a diary since 2021, and love that Apple have built a journal app in now... but whyyy isn't it on Mac?? I barely ever do diary entries in my phone, I much prefer typing on a proper keyboard. I'm gonna give Journal a go since I love using "the proper thing to do things" but I really hope they port it to Mac soon...
I like the slight blur at the bottom
The photo, music, workout, location etc. suggestions don’t work for me… anyone else having this issue?
It may take a few days to populate and start creating for you.
Does journal multimedia use iCloud space?
It does. Though the size is minimal I have a few lengthy entries with text, photos etc and the size is 109 KB
Thank you@@calum19_19
I like the idea of this. I have it installed now with the Beta release, and it says it'll start delivering suggestion prompts depending on what task I'm doing on my phone. Other than opening the Journal app and reviewing the prompts loaded there, I haven't received any while not in the app. Also, maybe it's just me, but it seems like they're missing the boat on incorporating Notes, Freeform, and now Journal into one seamless app with the varying functionality present depending on the use case for a particular task.
I agree with you. Why don’t they put all these 3 apps…Notes, Free Form, and Journal together into one app? Why do we have to switch to different apps? Is just not very functional and also very tedious and redundant when it could be in just one app.
It would make more sense to come to iPad first.
I use it all the time every day
It needs a dedicated voice to text option
this is the best update on ios17 so far. i love that app so much. it motivates me to write something and it suggests me photos and everything, less work for great memories.
I would love to have the possibility to share entries with others. And these should be able to comment entries. Also workout data could be added such as the track you went on and the exercise summary. Or also some basic weather data for that day.
This seems like a half baked app for Apple. If you journal how are you going to search back and look at your entries? Do you have to scroll the entire time? Can you export your entries? Are they viewable on a Pc? Lots of issues
I would like to see a way to archive all your entries into a playable or printable version, should the app itself be deprecated in the future, otherwise the purpose of a journal becomes a moot point.
This needs to be on the iPod as well. Why is it not????
A bit out of topic but have you guys seen a change in AirPods Pro 2 volume levels after the 17.1 update?
I was so happy that the feature was going to be a thing. It’s a nice initiative.
good vid, the app looks ok busy but ok = would be great for road trips
It’s cool but I wish it would do more. Apple has so much data they could port into this to make it even easier and fun to use. Of course users would need to consent but if the app would automatically import the pictures I took that day, where I went, music and podcasts I listened to, what workout I did etc. Hopefully that comes in the future, but pretty disappointing in my opinion. Makes you wonder why they even delayed it in the first place when it’s such a basic app.
I’m personally excited about the app because I use all of apples stock apps for simplicity but I do agree with you here in that I don’t understand why Apple delayed this when it looks very basic. Doesn’t make sense to me.
That’s literally what the app does, it suggests all these things from that specific day.
It literally suggests all those things you listed
Please let me know how because I’ve used the app and it does not. All it does is suggest a reflection, which pins that reflection to the top that’s it. Then it’s a blank canvas. From there you can add a picture, memo, and location. So no it does not automatically show me the podcasts, or musics I listened to that day, or what type of workout I did. And in regards to location and pictures, you have to manually do it yourself. My statement was I want all that pre populated.
@@LJHeattles check out the original Apple showcase of the journal app. It might come in later betas, but usually in the recommended page there should be one that you can tap that has all the photos you took, what workout you did, what music you listened to, who you were with, where you were, podcasts and so on.
Hello Andrew. Greetings from Germany. As always, just like today, I enjoy your great videos. Entertaining, to the point, and very informative. Thank you very much for all your efforts. I‘m looking forward to the new journaling App.
Why not add voice dictation and make it easier?
thanks so much for the review
hope gradually it will allow us to
- search
- calendar view (like day one)
Apple has a urinal app?
No search function!
This looks like a great app! I currently use Day One which I really like. It seems like in this early phase I won’t use it simply because I already get a lot of use out of the tools my current journal has. I need something that is does either differently or in addition to for me to switch. So I’ll keep an eye out for now, but I’ll stick to my current journal app. 👍🏽
At least this is free, compared to Day One’s subscription plan
True, but I’m paying for the features which Apple isn’t yet providing. For now, I’m ok with that. You get what you pay for.
now i do really need this app so bad!!!
Life changing for me
hmm. idk if it beats DayOne for me just yet
I use pages because I can search.
It looks really interesting for things that happen to me during my life that were really meaningful to me! Great app!
finally! been waiting for this.
Nice!!
Sounds interesting. I’ll check it out when released.
Thanks for the review! Like others have commented below, I would love to see a search function but also an 'export as' or 'save/share to' function. Since it's not available on my MacBook Pro and I'd really love to be able to use a keyboard to make entries, I've looked into Day One (which has Search and Export as) but the reviews kinda scare me away 😬
i don't wanna try anything other than Apple's journal. but kinda curious what does the reviews say about Day One (ofcourse I ain't gonna use it, just curious)
It should be downloadable and not come as a stock app like they did with the Apple Music Classical app
I have a friend who hates it when they put new apps in the operating system by default
Can you not name an entry?
I hope Apple adds the Journal app to iPad
You can do all that and more on the iPad with Voyage planner (by house of mars)
Wishing you and your little guy all the best!
Until it’s on iPad I will not be using
I was just wondering, what happened with your child’s eye? It got me worried about him/her, if it’s private than its ok.
Little guy has glaucoma in his eye. Has required two surgeries so far to correct and has caused some vision loss in the one eye. But he's a trooper and is powering through.
@@AppleInsider oh thanks for sharing, he is gonna make it through!
I imagine they will develop it quite slowly as not to scare people off it
Apple should have started that app on iPad.
I rather have it in ipad
After seeing this amazing review I’ve deleted this app.
Can't wait this app 😊 Thanks for the review!!
There are better apps but it's free...plus will develop over time.
For me, who doesn't like typing so much, it will be stressful to type for a long time on the iPhone. The journal app would have to be compatible with other devices such as the iPad. I am disappointed
no need to be disappointed. If you use Ipad or Mac, you can create new Journal entry/text on your Mac. Then use air drop copy and leave the text in Journal new entry. Thats what I do now when using other apps on Iphone. I just write text on my MAC or iPad and copy to iPhone when ready. do the same in Journal.
Good review but the app is very underwhelming. EXTREMELY basic functionality. Very disappointing especially considering all of the hype.
Had it for two days now.
“Do what you want to do with it “ - which is ‘nothing’.
I think I may be too old to understand why this is useful…
Do you have to be massively self centred? Is that what people are these days?
First?😊
3rd
Who cares!
@@mikes7070 It’s fun, at least for me.
try decaffeinated coffee. you speak really too fast.