This reminds me of an episode I had with my elderly mother’s doctor during an office visit. My mother was having a lot of pain for which she was Rx’ed Darvocet 65 mg every 6 hours. When I told the doctor that I didn’t think she was receiving adequate pain control, I felt that the doctor was hinting that maybe my mother was not receiving her pain medicine as ordered. I assured the doctor that she was given the pain med every 6 hours as ordered. Blood and urine samples were collected. The doctor asked how many people had access to my mother’s medications. I told the doctor that I, alone, administered my mother’s meds to her. The pain med was eventually changed to something stronger, but not before my mother had to suffer a while longer and I had to beg that she be given some relief.
She was known to be very aggressive at her DCF office. The highest rate of removing children from families in the state of FL. As Director ahe held a lot of power.
Sorry, this woman made the right call. Especially outing that ridiculous Dr K who got Maya on a path of high doses of Ketamine and made a lot of $ doing it. That child had enough meds in her system that were outreaching and dangerous. And what was another huge red flag in Mayas med history? In 2015 within a 6 week period she's hospitalized for Asthma 10x. That's crazy. Something was so wrong here and it wasn't CRPS. Nobody wants to believe that this angelic looking girl and this "heroic mom" had severe intertwined psychological issues that were at the base of all of this. So far the only liars are Jack and Maya. Maya saying she doesn't go anywhere with her BF. Photo of her in Tribeca? She can't move her feet. Caught moving her feet when no one is looking. Says she's so modest. Photos say something else. Jack says SS wore a lab coat. No. Didn't introduce herself. She did. Makes a snippy remark she has a cigarette voice. She doesn't smoke and that vocal cord issue is not a cigarette voice. Ok Jack is dumb..but still he was trying to be gotcha. Obviously his chat with the detective revealed he knew something was off with Beata and didn't support her
OMG!! You do think you know more!!! You think your opinion could NOT be wrong and you are the best of the best. Dr Smith needs to come down off her high horse.
Who does this lady think she is. Smirking all through her questioning. She has now resigned but she has taken other kids away from their families and ruined their lives. The documentary shows at the end other families who discuss how she took their kids away for no reason. She also had been done for abuse in past. Horrible person who sitting there lying.
Look further into her she literally benifits financially from removing children and since the county started outsourcing to that sunshine company that this dr is or was the head of at the time children were being removed 2.5 times higher than ever before and highest in the state she had financial reasons to remove children & this should never have happened the reason for such high removals from parents for profit should never happen again DCF had already investigated myas case and refused to go further and remove Mya because there investigation concluded that Mya had this condition and was not being medically abused it was only when this company that dr sally smith runs came into the picture did this removal happen
I believe this woman loves to hear herself talk. She enjoys controlling others especially children. The fact she didn’t feel leaving someone to defecate and urinate in their bed was abuse for lack of care is disgusting. In a nursing home setting that’s considered elder abuse. That is blatant child abuse because they did it on purpose in order to “test” her to see if she’d get up in her own. How awful for a ten year old child to be forced into that situation.
So, according to you, this evil woman has been for over 14 years controlling children by, for example, separating them from abusive "caretakers", perhaps from those "dads", "moms" and "uncles" who beat those kids, sexually exploited them, and - some of them, yes, like Beata - used them to feed their grandiosity and sense of uniqueness in medical settings? This woman has probably saved a lot of kids from a life-long physical and psychological damage, maybe saved lives of some of those kids. No, she does not look nice and cuddly, and perhaps reacts to the plaintiff's lawyer's "below the belt" jabs in a snarky way, but how would you look if you had to deal with child abusers for over a decade?
@@Nannygoat-h8o But that was a hypothetical Q. Geez listen to the actual testimony. Anderson was pissed because he thought she ordered it and she knew nothing about it. Next best thing..ask her if that's child abuse... Stupid question because he didn't like her answer.
Omg right?? I literally just commented the same thing.Her face says it all. She calls the shots. This woman is on a power trip and nobody can argue with her.
Surely you mean saved? Can you imagine what it's like to separate a battered child from his raging alcoholic dad, or take a girl away from from her narcissistic mom who uses her for self-aggrandizing? Helping these kids may indeed not be what they want, just like going to a dentist is not what a child wants. But these doctors save lives. They are not monsters!
@@SK_TorONshe is not a mother. But she save her😂😂😂. From what she save? So point is Don t treat your sick kid, you have just Syndrome. Don t belive doctors.
Breaks my heart how a parent can go to doctors who are experts in their field and is guided by them. See their treatments as relieving their daughters pain albeit short lived relief without continuing medication, as I think that most illnesses require ongoing medications. The to take their child to another hospital to be then believed to be causing medical harm because they themself is mental. Surely those doctors at JH CH should have gone after the doctors who readily prescribed the medications and diagnosis they found so harmful. The parents only wanted their daughter free of pain and listened to. The Waring medical people should have battled in court and not blame the parents. Because of ongoing battles between medical institutions regarding what constitutes an illness that no one truly understands can lead to the destruction a family forever. Plus there will always be exceptions to every illness/ syndrome . The notion of the God Complex Theory is the major theme running throughout here. All children need to be safe and I feel that here this family was in caught between the battle already being fought between competing medical theories of what constitutes Regional pain disorder syndrome and the treatments of it .
Just because these parents found an option and went to Mexico to get their daughter treatment does not make them bad parents they were willing to do whatever they had to do to give their child some relief and just because these ass hats don’t know nothing about CRPS does not mean that Maya, her mother and father were lying about her condition. And the last time I checked, there’s side effects to every medication that is FDA approved that they use even in the hospital setting and as far as procedures go, you risk having a procedures done all the time I just had a major facial reconstructive surgery due to an accident that has caused me to have CRPSand the risks were huge but I did it anyways so for people that say her parents were wrong, you guys never been there
@@tammyirwin703 this is my view too. I hope there will one day soon be a safe treatment to treat the pain in a more effective way. No one should ever believe they have the right to deny the pain of another. I should think that instead of competing on selling their personal beliefs of how to best treat it they should all get their heads together and work on a safe treatment .
@@tammyirwin703I think it is even fair to say that parents would go to the other side of the world if they needed to in order to help their children. Mexico has a bad rep because of all the Brazilian butt implants and plastic surgery botches but they also have excellent doctors and I would have brought my child there without hesitation had my child suffered with no relief!
This woman Sally Smith is the person who destroyed this family. No wonder her voice starts breaking up when she starts lying and denying. Also I think she comes across mentally a bit off from the looks of it. 👀
The woman attorney for the defense really brought up how the court needs to ask the plaintiffs attorneys to stop laughing yet every time the PA are doing their job she laughs and you can hear her audible scoffs.
I’m in utter amazement that this hasn’t already been a mistrial based on the conduct of the plaintiffs attorneys Mr. Anderson﹠Whitney. When Maya spoke about hospital staff, “They acted like children, ugh” and scoffed disgusted by it-this is how her attorneys act. Regardless there are so many inconsistencies in Mayas testimony alone, the jury believes none of it.
@@nancywhite4776it’s NOT a threat! He HAS to say it in the record so if they lose he has all the reasons to use as a possible case in a lawsuit to appeal. If he does the whole case and never says he’s thinking of a mistrial… then he has no case to appeal…. Because the appellate judge would say, “at no point during the trial did you ever ask for a mistrial… So clearly it was a fair trial.” It’s all a game of chess and you have to think ahead. Both plaintiffs and defense have been playing a hard game.
That is an awful thing to say, she was a mother who has tons of experience and tried to advocate for her daughter. That in my opinion is the epitome of a Mother’s Love.
On another platform owned by Meta there’s a large gathering of folks with a common goal of stopping this featured defendant from all future activities. Please locate us and help.
Yes! It took us a minute to realize what you were saying. The RUclips screening words are difficult not to get snagged in. We found what you are talking about and joined and helped.
In the case of Kowalski vs. Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital I believe that the family is deserved the win of the sum of $220 million dollar lawsuit against the hospital. They are fully responsible for the death by suicide of Beata Kowalski who is Maya’s biological mother. It would seem to me that Dr. Sally Smith should be revoked of any and all medical licenses and terminated immediately. Secondly, I ask that you incarcerate this person until she stands trial for endangering Maya Kowalski and performing malpractice and having malicious attempted of taking her parents rights away.
@@MyMomo17All should keep in mind that Beata started taking Ambien for sleep. This drug is associated with an increased risk of suicidal tendencies. It is published in PubMed.
Yes, she was called the first time on the 8th, and Child Welfare closed case on 10th,, because there was in fact history of CRPS. So, the second time she resubmitted on the 13th it was with Munchausen’s by Proxy, against Maya’s Dr’s advice.
I’m catching up but Sally Smith lied on the stand, her facial expressions are sickening. She should not ever be in charge of another human being!! Justice for MAYA 💟 hope she gets all the money and never has to work or worry about this ever again. Her mom is her guardian angel now and it’s heart wrenching what they went through
@@MyMomo17I would like to believe that, however, from all the evidence that has come out regarding child trafficking, Pinellas County is notorious for such.
@@MyMomo17 Thank you stating that! I totally agree. These doctors have done a lot of good in their lives, and they are being described by many in these comments like a bunch of sadists. This law suit has become a sequence of snarky huffs and puffs from the plaintiff attorneys while the defense presents one cold fact after another!
Yess very COLD facts... I do not see any emphaty from them at all. Some might say it helps them do a better job.. I do not believe that , they are just cold and love money's and most of all reputation is #1
Quick question . . . if Dr. Sally Smith gives a lot of testimony in cases why did "Siri" send her to City Hall????? As someone with CRPS, this is heartbreaking. Just admit, Dr. Sally Smith, that you, the agency or whoever diagnosed Maunchhausen by Proxy and treated Maya as a prisoner - just admit you were wrong!!!!
The family already settled with The Organization Dr.Smith worked for for 2.5 million The Mom probably did abuse Maya medical abuse is when a parent puts their child through unnecessary medical trauma like putting them in a medically induced coma with enough Ketamine to knock out 100 kids for surgery. Maya could have died every time the parents should Sue Kirkpatrick.
No way would I have left my daughter in that hospital no matter what they told me they would do. It’s so awful to think that Beata was guilty until proven innocent. No family should leave their children with these so called professionals.
Unfortunately you would have been arrested there is also a famous case in Texas who went through something similar with a hospital and the wife had a small baby CPS came in and removed the baby while he was latched on and feeding! It was all caught on tape and it’s just heartbreaking and like this family there was no abuse just a system way to willing to take children from good parents… the Bright family in Houston tx there is even a podcast on the case called Do no harm
If I were one of the Judges she gave her ‘reports’ to I would be infuriated, she tricked them into action they might have not otherwise taken based on her picking a choosing information that suited her. Hope some sort of universal karma comes her way.
Yeah, imagine not giving her ketamine to the point of a coma. Imagine getting her off of 29 medications many of which were narcotics. Imagine figuring out the mother had major issues and they saved her life.
@rlfrohs6123 imagine accusing her mother of abuse & causing her suicide whilst billing for a diagnosis of CRPS imagine 3 specialists administering drugs to the girl & NOT her mother imagine being a child & not allowed to see your family imagine the case has already been proved sincethat she did have CRPS & her mother did not abuse her ? How can you blame the mother for what the specialists prescribed ? imagine that still today ketamine is used for CRPS
I wonder if a Jury question will be if she ever ordered a gait belt. Lol lots of gait belt questions. It's not even practical because they are for helping people walk and transfer but it's not useful if the patient is 4 feet tall. and 60 pounds.
Good grief! Dr Sally Smith appears to have more twists, turns and swerves than a slinky on a staircase! A lady with delusional ideas above her station, it seems to me!
According to her she learned in the trenches and ended up acquiring a high standard of expertise. She loves to blow her own trumpet, she has a lot of knowledge about child abuse according to her, shame she used it to the opposite effect.
How is Sally Smith allowed to bring her entire paper file to the stand and then allowed to sit and read from her own files. While they are at sidebar, she is taking the chance to read up on her notes and get her story straight V's telling the truth through her memory.
🤔 🤔 Umm just like other people have done on the Plaintiffs side! Sounds fair To me! Especially the man who was summoned back over the weekend, and stated that he was only there because he cares! Although Attorney Hunter called BS and busted him on a few occasions; for instance, he was making a statement about the hospital’s policies and training as it pertains to the Doctors;(Non of which he had viewed, and he but didn’t want to give a direct answer) an with the other situation, but he finally admitted that he hadn’t seen them. Secondly, he finally stated that his financial gain was based on Pro-bono.
Because they're using the notes as evidence. You can't honestly expect people to remember these things over time. Especially details. Even so, she is being torn apart. She has no credibility as soon as the plaintiff Attorney started. The jury will feel the same way we feel for the most part. She is a snake.
As a CRPS sufferer this woman, if you can call her that, has sent me into a massive flare with her every breath! Still causing pain wherever she goes! She should never ever be allowed to be near a child or in any "care: role ever again!
@joystoys99 great advice thanks! 👍 Do you have it too? Sounds like you know what your talking about! P.S. I stopped watching before the original comment so well done for great advise 😁
What is going on in Florida . IMO every case involving medical abuse diseases similar or like cprs involving Smith Should have a harder look at Smith ruined lives parents in prison . And bedy a known child abuser tried suffocating A 10yr old and then gets hired as social worker WAIT FOR IT stationed at All Children’s Hospital I’m laughing and crying My heart goes out to Maya Kyle and Jack your patients and devotion to the kids is why Beata and Maya,Kyle received J U S. T I C E
This whole trial is disgusting. The Hospital should be ashamed of itself of All the lives they have destroyed. Letting CPS dictate atvtheir hospital..with their track record. Just sickening. You ever want to see something..look up Kidjacked..real stories of corrupt Drs..lawyers hospitals and CPS. This evil needs to come down!!!
A Court of law ordered them to shelter her at the Hospital. What do you say about a child who comes in with many fractured bones over a year. Is the Hospital right to call CPS. If they don't report suspected abuse it's a felony.
If anybody reads this can somebody please explain to me what's going on please.... Because I was in DYFS when I was a kid I was in foster homes and everything... I know how some of those fake foster parents get down... Thank God I was never sexually abused or anything like that... I had some that would make me do some messed up stuff as far as punishment goes.. for example.... One lady named Miss Williams (from E.O.,NJ) Used to make me stand in the corner holding books in my hand for at least an hour and if I let my arms drop she wouldn't let me eat that night... the crazy thing is that her husband (MACK) (WITH HIS FAT B*TCH ASS WOULD MAKE ME STAND ON ONE LEG WHILE DOING IT 😏 NEEDLESS TO SAY IT ONLY TURNED ME INTO A STR8 BEAST WHEN I GOT OLDER 😏😏😏 AND BY THE GRACE OF ALLAH, I WAS OUT OF THEIR HOUSE WITHIN 3 MONTHS.... I WAS BEING PUNISHED BECAUSE I WOULDN'T CALL HER MOMMY OR MOM..... YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND MY BIOLOGICAL MOTHER DIED AND I WAS 8 YEARS OLD I WAS LIVING WITH THEM WHEN I WAS 9 YRS OLD.... SHE HAD ME AND MY LITTLE BROTHER.... SHE WAS MAD BECAUSE I TOLD MY BROTHER SHE'S NOT A REAL MOTHER STOP CALLING HER MOMMY MOMMY IS DEAD... AND SHE JUST DIDN'T TREAT US GOOD ANYWAY.... WHAT IS ALL OKAY.... WHAT DOESN'T KILL YOU CAN ONLY MAKE YOU STRONGER RIGHT???😏😏💯💯💯💪🏽💪🏽💪🏽 AND THAT'S ONLY ONE TEMPERARY FOSTER HOME I HAD TO GO THROUGH 😏
CPS needs to be completely dismantled and rebuilt. They take kids away from wonderful parents, and they force reunification with meth addicted, abusive parents. How many children have to die before something is done?
Procedures have high probability of complications/death all the time. Brain surgery, spinal surgery, open heart surgery, organ transplants, neurosurgery, etc. Probability of mortality isn’t as big as what you’re making it out to be.
If I would of had the option of the ket coma, I would have gone immediately. I still believe that it is very difficult for others to understand RSD or CRPS.
Wow cautions for any treatment even medications come with cautions and even death! Incredible right?(sarcasm) people have died from tylonal idk get educated not googled, that’s all. Blessings
Props,,or trying to look important, or trying to subliminally make jurors think she took lots of notes, even though they will know by previous witnesses that logging was anything but impressive.
I Pray for The Kowalski Family. May Beata (a Great Human Being and Most a Concerned Mother. May She Rest In Eternal Peace.🙏🙏🙏, as well deserved. Maya, keep fighting to do the best you can, that was all Your Dear Mom aimed for You and Kyle.!!!
Exactly. The thing is she was telling on herself. She was allowing the jury to know that they would contact her first to make sure there is enough evidence to make it stick as abuse.
Except Beata was cleared of MbP during the dependency hearing. One of the major criteria for MbP is that the child gets better upon removal of the parent. Maya didn’t get better. She was still in pain and still unable to walk when she left the hospital.
@hostronic Exactly! I think they just didn't like her because she has a medical background and had done more research on CRPS than any of them had. She was a passionate advocate for her doctor, and she came off as harsh, rude, and controlling, and they did not like that. They decided to make her pay, but all they did was hurt Maya more.....and destroy an entire family. It's disgusting.
No, SS was operating beyond what should’ve been her purview. The hospital was not being overseen properly. Check out Dr. Corcoran’s 2nd testimony at the end of the trial. I think he was the last witness before the jury began deliberating. Remember how CB (and possibly SS) kept talking about talking with risk management? Unlike all the other JH hospitals, JHACH’s Risk Management had no oversight from the main hospital department. They didn’t inform the main risk management team about any of the difficult cases that could be liabilities. HUGE problem. Jack and Beata’s complaints/grievances were supposed to be responded to (with input from Corporate Risk Mgmt within 10 days. JHACH didn’t respond to them at all! THIS is one of the reasons JCACH was under Immediate Jeopardy. Some here may say, but that was only for the heart surgery program, Why then did JHACH overhaul their operations for the whole JHACH, having found serious problems throughout the hospital. The first complaints from nurses and/or doctors in 2015, but were not addressed. Myers stay was in the range of time that was being addressed. If it’s not broke, don’t fix it. But if it IS broke, absolutely fix it, even if the state and federal accreditation boards don’t spot it. Eight senior executives resigned or were fired as result of this. Maya Kowalski was the canary in the coal mine for this.
I have to say I have watched trials and this trial is as shady as can be..yesterday defense i kid you not whined at the judge to get her way..its clear an has been since the get go of this trial defense is clearly running this courtroom...Today defense is talking about what the plaintiff wants to keep out of this trial thats comical being as from the start we have been getting half the facts an have the truth. This Smith I wont say doctor because she doesnt deserve that tital thought it was funny that a child used the restroom on herself and then had to lay in it for who knows how long from what we have heard. I wouldnt go to this hospital with my children and if i came across these people that have "resigned" anywhere else I wouldnt walk away with my child I would run..these people associated with this place are corrupt and evil..First the people working at this hospital and yes I say that because defense keeps saying they had nothing to do with it but today Smith herself said she was a "member of the medical staff team" if shes not a member from this hospital then where?? They claim Maya was making up the pain an her mother was the cause..because she was taking her to doctors trying to find out first what was going on then later did but NO even with experts which clearly Smith is not it didnt matter..then after the mother commits succide then they have it in her files she has CRPS..lets just say Maya didnt have this..how this child was done an treated while in their care the hospital is unreal in itself..Smith in her depo said she had known Bedy and worked with her before.. I would really love to know how many other famiies an kids have been done this way but I have a feeling we never will sadly.
Exactly Attorney Hunter! Why is the Judge inserting his opinion on what prescriptions can come into the trial as evidence?? Isn’t it up the the JURY to decide on the evidence????
If I’m reading your comment right- It is up to the judge to decide what evidence is admissible. If the jury were to get to decide, they would see materials that they are not supposed to, it could potentially cause a bias or mislead, and then a fair trial is out the window. Also, the jury doesn’t have the legal knowledge or authority to decide what is admissible as evidence like the judge does. - Deciding which medications (which all have certain administration indications and Rx dates) are relevant to the trial could be argued by the lawyers and then decided on by the judge.
Amazing what a total personality change this Sally Smith underwent from her deposition to now putting on a good show for the jury. This woman is two faced and I don’t trust a word that comes from her mouth.
Why don’t you just accept Kelly’s interview to tell her. That way not necessarily everyone will see that. And really appreciate what did you do to this matter. This is not my information in your place except picture. If I receive what I have, then I will do my part, otherwise I don’t have ability to donate.
Wow, how comes all illness alway on Saturday, then patients need suffering 4 days plus your investigation, when is patient need suffering to? Anyway as long as you earn that money , nothing is important.
Have you read those emails that Beata wrote to herself as if in Maya's voice?!!! Sorry, but that IS crazy. Beata did have a serious mental disorder; probably a Narcissistic Personality. I am not mocking her: just pointing out that of course she engaged in a Munchhausen by Proxy. Perhaps unconsciously, probably her emotional needs and unprocessed trauma demanded her to do that. But it WAS a case of a MbP. And the standard procedure in such cases is to separate the child and the parent, at least temporarily. Then to offer a psychotherapy to the family. Which the court order and the Child Protection Team did. I am really sorry for Maya... Her mom defined Maya's identity by her (Beata's) mental disorder, and Maya will need a lot of therapy, not this frivolous law suit which will only make her mental healing more difficult.
You should really read the DSM-5 guidelines for Factitious Disorder Imposed on Another (MbP). It doesn’t line up and Sally Smith admitted in proffer to only considering evidence that corroborated her suspicion of MbP in her report to the dependency court. She did NOT include any evidence that refuted her claim because she said it’s “not her job” to do so. Yet the DSM-5 clearly states that when evaluating someone for MbP ALL evidence must be considered, including refuting evidence. She broke the DSM guidelines.
@@hostronic OK, granted: you may be correct, and Beata may not have had an MbP, strictly technically speaking. My main point was that SHE was, if not 100%, then 99% responsible for what went on with Maya. She used Maya as a prop in her fantasies of a one-in-a-history-of-the-World girl with a heroic "mommy" by her side. Just read those emails!
Tell me why the doctor was takint the girl off the meds then, prior to being told to? 🙄 i didnt know it was the doctors recommendation to wean off the meds to test the child. If that is the case, why did the doctor decide to place the child on the drugs to begin with? Obviously it took someone to place something in the doctor ear. Im probably missing something. I mean i understand doctors test drugs out on patients, but it is usually one at a time to see what is helping. How did she manage getting on multiple drugs without any improvement, then decided we're going to take her off all them.
The Attorney for the family plays dirty! He has wasted more time badgering witnesses asking the same question 10 different ways hoping to get a different response. Then he mutters something ignorant under his breath!
I agree with you. This Mr. Anderson is often wrong but never uncertain... I do hope the defense wins. Honestly, I would be impressed if the father decided to spare further damage to his children and withdrew the law suit. I know if won't happen, but I feel that healing their psychological trauma would be better for his children then a 200 million...
@@TheUniqueme1Hi, I'm glad I wasn't the only person who found him obnoxious! And you're right Dr. Sally wasn't having it! It's funny bc I usually watch after they adjourn for the day & the Defense Attorney brought it up to the Judge & said others sitting @ their table make faces too knowing the Jurors are beside them & can hear & see them. So they must read the comments! I watched a video that the Jury won't see & it's Maya dancing exactly like the girl in the video twisting her body & playing with her hair like she was 18 & on stage! This was a couple of weeks after getting out of the hospital after one of her administrations. I was shocked that she had it posted! I deal with severe chronic pain & have had surgeries throughout my life to which I had to learn to walk again when I was young. Theirs so much I see that I don't believe & I've also worked in a hospital. I hope when this trial is over someone can access all the videos, pictures & documents as people will be surprised @ the real truth. The only statement I believe from Maya is the one she told the Nurse that her life is a lie. She's not this poor angel that was abused by everyone @ the hospital theirs so much more to it! Take Care! Ontario, 🇨🇦 P.S. If you watch every courtroom proceeding to the end after the Jury leaves you'll learn a lot more although the evidence won't be shown to the Jury. 🐾
I’m completely oblivious to what’s happening in this trial. I don’t have Netflix. So, I just a while ago. Woke up and this was on. I noticed by the comments. There are people for both sides in here. I know too, I’m probably in here by myself. But, if anyone reads this ? If you could clue me in at all. I’d appreciate it.
Maya has a rare pain condition where she was taking doses of ketamine to treat it, prescribed by a doctor. She was getting better. Then she relapsed and needed emergency care. Father took her to JH and they told the staff about her condition and the ketamine. The mother came in later telling them to give Maya ketamine so she can stop hurting. The staff felt she was being controlling and suspected munchausen by proxy or medical child abuse. The staff thought Maya was making it up and the mother was making her sick on purpose. There was a court order where the mother could no longer see Maya and the mother could only talk to her by phone only, supervised. After 3 months or so, the mother could not bare not seeing her daughter and being wrongly accused by the court and hospital, and committed suicide. More details but that is the gist. The hospital also said Maya was making it up, but was billing their insurance for the disease they thought she was making up. Dr Sally Smith was one of the top people in the abuse investigation.
I know this has nothing to do with the medical part but I haven’t seen the whole documentary I saw up until the father was speaking to the cop and I feel put the mother under the bus.
Do you see these problems? Her knowledge over 19 years, no upgrade skill or knowledge, in eastern countries,Doctors or nurse always need go to class or offer your research paper submit to conferences team. Here no these updates, only limited experience.
So many comments here, trashing Dr. Sally Smith. How about we focus on those emails? Those are just… effin’ bizarre. Who composes emails written in the tone of their child and sends them to themselves? That’s unsettling.
Maya went into the hospital with CRPS, was charged for CRPS protocol treatments, and left hospital with CRPS diagnosis. They did not save her life, they were trying to disprove the CRPS diagnosis, and Dr. Smith was at the forefront of keeping this family separated. Hospital staff submitted an abuse report, and child welfare officials closed it the same day after confirming Maya’s CRPS with her specialist. It was only after Dr. Smith filed a second report, against Maya’s Pediatrician’s advice, that she used Munchausens by proxy to get a separation order.
@@dianealarcon8304 Taking ur child to be put in a ketamine coma which gives a 50% chance of death when the child is not even dying of cancer or any other fatal disease says it all. Oh and then to write a blog as if u r the child but ur really the mother. Come on, this isn’t rocket science. The mother was mentally ill. I’m sure she would have killed her child if not for the hospital. As a matter of fact, she asked for hospice to have lethal doses of drugs. Super dysfunctional family and sad the mother put her family through misery and then hung herself.
That’s not what the jury found. JHACH falsely imprisoned, her, battered her, subjected her and her family member to intentional emotional distress that led directly to Beata’s death by suicide, was liable of the wrongful death wrongful death of Beata, was liable for fraudulent billing, and two other issues. And the family settled with SS and CB. And terrible news from both of their pasts became public knowledge. So, no.
There is also a famous case in Texas who went through something similar with a hospital and the wife had a small baby CPS came in and removed the baby while he was latched on and feeding! It was all caught on tape and it's just heartbreaking and like this family there was no abuse just a system way to willing to take children from good parents... the Bright family in Houston tx there is even a podcast on the case called Do no harm
This reminds me of an episode I had with my elderly mother’s doctor during an office visit. My mother was having a lot of pain for which she was Rx’ed Darvocet 65 mg every 6 hours. When I told the doctor that I didn’t think she was receiving adequate pain control, I felt that the doctor was hinting that maybe my mother was not receiving her pain medicine as ordered. I assured the doctor that she was given the pain med every 6 hours as ordered. Blood and urine samples were collected. The doctor asked how many people had access to my mother’s medications. I told the doctor that I, alone, administered my mother’s meds to her. The pain med was eventually changed to something stronger, but not before my mother had to suffer a while longer and I had to beg that she be given some relief.
That’s unbelievable! They had no reason to believe that. Like God forbid the meds aren’t strong enough 🙄
Wondering how many families she destroyed
She was known to be very aggressive at her DCF office. The highest rate of removing children from families in the state of FL. As Director ahe held a lot of power.
@@dianealarcon8304I'd like to meet her. She probably needs to be prosecuted but it would serve better as street justice ⚖️
Omg people please run with your children from this “doctor”
this goes to show… credentials don’t mean SHI*
Sally needs to loose her license and all jobs related with kids.
She’s such an arrogant and bad liar I can’t
You need to “loose” your license to post on RUclips.
Sorry, this woman made the right call. Especially outing that ridiculous Dr K who got Maya on a path of high doses of Ketamine and made a lot of $ doing it.
That child had enough meds in her system that were outreaching and dangerous.
And what was another huge red flag in Mayas med history?
In 2015 within a 6 week period she's hospitalized for Asthma 10x.
That's crazy.
Something was so wrong here and it wasn't CRPS.
Nobody wants to believe that this angelic looking girl and this "heroic mom" had severe intertwined psychological issues that were at the base of all of this.
So far the only liars are Jack and Maya.
Maya saying she doesn't go anywhere with her BF. Photo of her in Tribeca? She can't move her feet. Caught moving her feet when no one is looking.
Says she's so modest. Photos say something else.
Jack says SS wore a lab coat. No.
Didn't introduce herself. She did.
Makes a snippy remark she has a cigarette voice.
She doesn't smoke and that vocal cord issue is not a cigarette voice.
Ok Jack is dumb..but still he was trying to be gotcha.
Obviously his chat with the detective revealed he knew something was off with Beata and didn't support her
@@blindlemon9 English isn’t my first language
This woman should to loose her licence and never work as doc again.
OMG!! You do think you know more!!! You think your opinion could NOT be wrong and you are the best of the best. Dr Smith needs to come down off her high horse.
Who does this lady think she is. Smirking all through her questioning. She has now resigned but she has taken other kids away from their families and ruined their lives. The documentary shows at the end other families who discuss how she took their kids away for no reason. She also had been done for abuse in past. Horrible person who sitting there lying.
Look further into her she literally benifits financially from removing children and since the county started outsourcing to that sunshine company that this dr is or was the head of at the time children were being removed 2.5 times higher than ever before and highest in the state she had financial reasons to remove children & this should never have happened the reason for such high removals from parents for profit should never happen again DCF had already investigated myas case and refused to go further and remove Mya because there investigation concluded that Mya had this condition and was not being medically abused it was only when this company that dr sally smith runs came into the picture did this removal happen
I believe this woman loves to hear herself talk. She enjoys controlling others especially children. The fact she didn’t feel leaving someone to defecate and urinate in their bed was abuse for lack of care is disgusting. In a nursing home setting that’s considered elder abuse. That is blatant child abuse because they did it on purpose in order to “test” her to see if she’d get up in her own. How awful for a ten year old child to be forced into that situation.
She didn't say that. She said she didn't order the commode to be placed that way nor had she heard about it.
So, according to you, this evil woman has been for over 14 years controlling children by, for example, separating them from abusive "caretakers", perhaps from those "dads", "moms" and "uncles" who beat those kids, sexually exploited them, and - some of them, yes, like Beata - used them to feed their grandiosity and sense of uniqueness in medical settings? This woman has probably saved a lot of kids from a life-long physical and psychological damage, maybe saved lives of some of those kids. No, she does not look nice and cuddly, and perhaps reacts to the plaintiff's lawyer's "below the belt" jabs in a snarky way, but how would you look if you had to deal with child abusers for over a decade?
She SAID she thought it was a stretch to call it child abuse when no one would come to this aid child to use the bathroom
@@Nannygoat-h8o But that was a hypothetical Q. Geez listen to the actual testimony.
Anderson was pissed because he thought she ordered it and she knew nothing about it.
Next best thing..ask her if that's child abuse...
Stupid question because he didn't like her answer.
Agree! She should not be in the health field anymore. All patients should be warned about her.
Her shock and aggravation at the first objection is palpable. How dare anyone tell her no!?!?
This woman was given way to much power.
Omg right?? I literally just commented the same thing.Her face says it all. She calls the shots. This woman is on a power trip and nobody can argue with her.
Exactly. Not just the first one. Each one she has that look of filth
Mrs. Smith seems to be nervous and nicer today! Not so defensive and evil like the last time. Probably she's sensing what's coming next.
Just wait. It leaks back out in cross.
I’m sure she was well prepped and threatened by the Defense lawyers 😂😂😂😂😂
she knows she has been the target. What would you do in same situation?
That means she is two faced and not to be trusted. Putting on a good show for the jury 🙄
@@chrismarchetti-olson6632 yeah the defense team are super scary.
Family deserves and IS going to receive Justice--
how many appeals before they see a dime?
She is a miss know it all ,she is making me annoyed I can only imagine how this 10 year old went through . 😡😡😡
We already know that it was more families wrongly accused by her. You can google it. So sad...
Seems to me she had a quota to fill for hospital funding I bet.
Can you imagine SS providing her brand of child abuse masterclasses to interns as part of their medical education??
I wouldn’t want Smith or Bedy taking care of me or my family 😠
12 yrs imagine how many families she ripped apart
Surely you mean saved? Can you imagine what it's like to separate a battered child from his raging alcoholic dad, or take a girl away from from her narcissistic mom who uses her for self-aggrandizing? Helping these kids may indeed not be what they want, just like going to a dentist is not what a child wants. But these doctors save lives. They are not monsters!
@@SK_TorONshe is not a mother. But she save her😂😂😂. From what she save? So point is Don t treat your sick kid, you have just Syndrome. Don t belive doctors.
Breaks my heart how a parent can go to doctors who are experts in their field and is guided by them. See their treatments as relieving their daughters pain albeit short lived relief without continuing medication, as I think that most illnesses require ongoing medications. The to take their child to another hospital to be then believed to be causing medical harm because they themself is mental. Surely those doctors at JH CH should have gone after the doctors who readily prescribed the medications and diagnosis they found so harmful. The parents only wanted their daughter free of pain and listened to.
The Waring medical people should have battled in court and not blame the parents.
Because of ongoing battles between medical institutions regarding what constitutes an illness that no one truly understands can lead to the destruction a family forever.
Plus there will always be exceptions to every illness/ syndrome .
The notion of the God Complex Theory is the major theme running throughout here.
All children need to be safe and I feel that here this family was in caught between the battle already being fought between competing medical theories of what constitutes Regional pain disorder syndrome and the treatments of it .
Just because these parents found an option and went to Mexico to get their daughter treatment does not make them bad parents they were willing to do whatever they had to do to give their child some relief and just because these ass hats don’t know nothing about CRPS does not mean that Maya, her mother and father were lying about her condition. And the last time I checked, there’s side effects to every medication that is FDA approved that they use even in the hospital setting and as far as procedures go, you risk having a procedures done all the time I just had a major facial reconstructive surgery due to an accident that has caused me to have CRPSand the risks were huge but I did it anyways so for people that say her parents were wrong, you guys never been there
@@tammyirwin703 this is my view too.
I hope there will one day soon be a safe treatment to treat the pain in a more effective way. No one should ever believe they have the right to deny the pain of another.
I should think that instead of competing on selling their personal beliefs of how to best treat it they should all get their heads together and work on a safe treatment .
@@tammyirwin703I think it is even fair to say that parents would go to the other side of the world if they needed to in order to help their children. Mexico has a bad rep because of all the Brazilian butt implants and plastic surgery botches but they also have excellent doctors and I would have brought my child there without hesitation had my child suffered with no relief!
This woman Sally Smith is the person who destroyed this family. No wonder her voice starts breaking up when she starts lying and denying. Also I think she comes across mentally a bit off from the looks of it. 👀
The woman attorney for the defense really brought up how the court needs to ask the plaintiffs attorneys to stop laughing yet every time the PA are doing their job she laughs and you can hear her audible scoffs.
I see the smirks from defense attorneys!
The judge let Anderson get away with a lot of sarcasm and rudeness towards experts.
Unusual in civil litigation.
Don’t you think the plaintiff has threatened mistrial enough times that he is cautious?
I’m in utter amazement that this hasn’t already been a mistrial based on the conduct of the plaintiffs attorneys Mr. Anderson﹠Whitney. When Maya spoke about hospital staff, “They acted like children, ugh” and scoffed disgusted by it-this is how her attorneys act. Regardless there are so many inconsistencies in Mayas testimony alone, the jury believes none of it.
@@nancywhite4776it’s NOT a threat! He HAS to say it in the record so if they lose he has all the reasons to use as a possible case in a lawsuit to appeal. If he does the whole case and never says he’s thinking of a mistrial… then he has no case to appeal…. Because the appellate judge would say, “at no point during the trial did you ever ask for a mistrial… So clearly it was a fair trial.”
It’s all a game of chess and you have to think ahead. Both plaintiffs and defense have been playing a hard game.
How difficult it must be for Mr. Kowalski to look at this women.... she's destroyed their family. No price is big enough to heal this family.
No-one can make anyone to commit suicide. Beata killed herself leaving two children behind. Some mother's love!
@@SK_TorONThe law says differently.
That is an awful thing to say, she was a mother who has tons of experience and tried to advocate for her daughter. That in my opinion is the epitome of a Mother’s Love.
I think SS’s vocal fry adds to her “cigarette voice.”
On another platform owned by Meta there’s a large gathering of folks with a common goal of stopping this featured defendant from all future activities. Please locate us and help.
Yes! It took us a minute to realize what you were saying. The RUclips screening words are difficult not to get snagged in. We found what you are talking about and joined and helped.
This evil woman distorted a family even with the suicidal of the mother . 😡😡😡😡😡😡
Ok! Who else read the email Beata wrote to Beata? How can live court streems show every piece of evidence before or never for the jury…I’m scared
That email is really weird
WARNING--- Sally Smith is self tought???!!!! She sure sounds so nervous, wonder why? LOL
In the case of Kowalski vs. Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital I believe that the family is deserved the win of the sum of $220 million dollar lawsuit against the hospital. They are fully responsible for the death by suicide of Beata Kowalski who is Maya’s biological mother.
It would seem to me that Dr. Sally Smith should be revoked of any and all medical licenses and terminated immediately. Secondly, I ask that you incarcerate this person until she stands trial for endangering Maya Kowalski and performing malpractice and having malicious attempted of taking her parents rights away.
The Mom made a choice to commit suicide. Her husband asked her to move out he said.
@@MyMomo17 because she was being a mom and refused to accept she couldn’t speak to her own child.
@@MyMomo17All should keep in mind that Beata started taking Ambien for sleep. This drug is associated with an increased risk of suicidal tendencies. It is published in PubMed.
Justice for Maya and her family……. Kim🇬🇧
1:53:37 man! She’s been WAITING for that question! 😂 so obvious!
No, she was looking through that binder while y’all were talking!
Yes, she was called the first time on the 8th, and Child Welfare closed case on 10th,, because there was in fact history of CRPS.
So, the second time she resubmitted on the 13th it was with Munchausen’s by Proxy, against Maya’s Dr’s advice.
I’m catching up but Sally Smith lied on the stand, her facial expressions are sickening. She should not ever be in charge of another human being!! Justice for MAYA 💟 hope she gets all the money and never has to work or worry about this ever again. Her mom is her guardian angel now and it’s heart wrenching what they went through
😅, she shouldn't be a doctor because of her face expressions??😂😂
Pretty sure she save many children from abusive parents during her career the people who go by the Documentary seem a bit like fanatic's.
@@MyMomo17I would like to believe that, however, from all the evidence that has come out regarding child trafficking, Pinellas County is notorious for such.
@@MyMomo17 Thank you stating that! I totally agree. These doctors have done a lot of good in their lives, and they are being described by many in these comments like a bunch of sadists. This law suit has become a sequence of snarky huffs and puffs from the plaintiff attorneys while the defense presents one cold fact after another!
Yess very COLD facts... I do not see any emphaty from them at all. Some might say it helps them do a better job.. I do not believe that , they are just cold and love money's and most of all reputation is #1
Why is this monster not in prison?
Quick question . . . if Dr. Sally Smith gives a lot of testimony in cases why did "Siri" send her to City Hall????? As someone with CRPS, this is heartbreaking. Just admit, Dr. Sally Smith, that you, the agency or whoever diagnosed Maunchhausen by Proxy and treated Maya as a prisoner - just admit you were wrong!!!!
It strikes me that she might not easily ever admit she’s wrong about anything. She’s very frightening.
She must be a joy to work with and or live with
@@irishnunnasaid no one ever 😂😂😂😂😂. I hope the hospital, in turn, sues HER after they pay the $200 mil 😂
The family already settled with The Organization Dr.Smith worked for for 2.5 million The Mom probably did abuse Maya medical abuse is when a parent puts their child through unnecessary medical trauma like putting them in a medically induced coma with enough Ketamine to knock out 100 kids for surgery. Maya could have died every time the parents should Sue Kirkpatrick.
Except for the fact that she’s not wrong.
Because there is NO defending this CRIMINAL
I don’t care who did what I think the real victim was Maya she was only a kid
Here we go with the evil Sally Smith MD
MD…. In this case sally smith mentally disturbed
I hope the jury saw through your soul and you get judged according . Karma is a #####
Justice for maya ❤
No way would I have left my daughter in that hospital no matter what they told me they would do. It’s so awful to think that Beata was guilty until proven innocent. No family should leave their children with these so called professionals.
Unfortunately you would have been arrested there is also a famous case in Texas who went through something similar with a hospital and the wife had a small baby CPS came in and removed the baby while he was latched on and feeding! It was all caught on tape and it’s just heartbreaking and like this family there was no abuse just a system way to willing to take children from good parents… the Bright family in Houston tx there is even a podcast on the case called Do no harm
If I were one of the Judges she gave her ‘reports’ to I would be infuriated, she tricked them into action they might have not otherwise taken based on her picking a choosing information that suited her. Hope some sort of universal karma comes her way.
look at Mayas face in those photos shes so distressed, its sickening what they did to that little girl
Look at Maya's face in so many other photos lol and she has full makeup on, laughing, having fun.
I know..the disease comes and goes. Lol
@LIGal398 relevance ?
Yeah, imagine not giving her ketamine to the point of a coma. Imagine getting her off of 29 medications many of which were narcotics. Imagine figuring out the mother had major issues and they saved her life.
@rlfrohs6123 imagine accusing her mother of abuse & causing her suicide whilst billing for a diagnosis of CRPS imagine 3 specialists administering drugs to the girl & NOT her mother imagine being a child & not allowed to see your family imagine the case has already been proved sincethat she did have CRPS & her mother did not abuse her ? How can you blame the mother for what the specialists prescribed ? imagine that still today ketamine is used for CRPS
@@rlfrohs6123 Agree with 💯
So many hats with this expert, even already out from last July, what is your purpose? To get some benefit to device with your legal teams?
This one is a real nut job Dr Susie Smith I hold her personally responsible for this whole debacle and death of Mayas mother
I wonder if a Jury question will be if she ever ordered a gait belt. Lol lots of gait belt questions. It's not even practical because they are for helping people walk and transfer but it's not useful if the patient is 4 feet tall. and 60 pounds.
Sally Smith needs to lose her license.
Her voice is shaky and she’s out of breath. Makes you nervous when you have to remember your own lies!!!
Good grief! Dr Sally Smith appears to have more twists, turns and swerves than a slinky on a staircase!
A lady with delusional ideas above her station, it seems to me!
According to her she learned in the trenches and ended up acquiring a high standard of expertise. She loves to blow her own trumpet, she has a lot of knowledge about child abuse according to her, shame she used it to the opposite effect.
How is Sally Smith allowed to bring her entire paper file to the stand and then allowed to sit and read from her own files. While they are at sidebar, she is taking the chance to read up on her notes and get her story straight V's telling the truth through her memory.
🤔 🤔 Umm just like other people have done on the Plaintiffs side! Sounds fair
To me! Especially the man who was summoned back over the weekend, and stated that he was only there because he cares! Although Attorney Hunter called BS and busted him on a few occasions; for instance, he was making a statement about the hospital’s policies and training as it pertains to the Doctors;(Non of which he had viewed, and he but didn’t want to give a direct answer) an with the other situation, but he finally admitted that he hadn’t seen them. Secondly, he finally stated that his financial gain was based on Pro-bono.
Because they're using the notes as evidence. You can't honestly expect people to remember these things over time. Especially details. Even so, she is being torn apart. She has no credibility as soon as the plaintiff Attorney started. The jury will feel the same way we feel for the most part. She is a snake.
As a CRPS sufferer this woman, if you can call her that, has sent me into a massive flare with her every breath! Still causing pain wherever she goes! She should never ever be allowed to be near a child or in any "care: role ever again!
Are you off your meds again?
Maybe following your Dr. Orders to not do stressful things that might cause a flare up would help a person not have massive flares. Stop watching it.
@joystoys99 great advice thanks! 👍 Do you have it too? Sounds like you know what your talking about! P.S. I stopped watching before the original comment so well done for great advise 😁
@@CRPS-AND-ME certainly have become experts after 22 days of testimony.
@@JoAnnToledo I would prefer not to have my first hand knowledge so if anyone wants first hand experience please take mine.
What is going on in Florida . IMO every case involving medical abuse diseases similar or like cprs involving Smith
Should have a harder look at Smith ruined lives parents in prison . And bedy a known child abuser tried suffocating
A 10yr old and then gets hired as social worker WAIT FOR IT stationed at All Children’s Hospital I’m laughing and crying
My heart goes out to Maya Kyle and Jack your patients and devotion to the kids is why Beata and Maya,Kyle received
J U S. T I C E
So Dr Smith did have privileges , interesting 🤔
I don’t have Netflix. It’s a shame there ain’t no information to go along with this video.
Everyone think this way, so don’t need individual responsible.
Do you think Dr Sally Smith is ever wrong
She certainly thinks she's always correct 😂
Can we all please remove dr, md or any of these attachments to this … can’t even or want to call her a person.
Poor Dad he looks so tired he’s done 😳
He’s not done yet - and he’s a powerful witness.
She looks so 👿 evil!!
This whole trial is disgusting. The Hospital should be ashamed of itself of All the lives they have destroyed. Letting CPS dictate atvtheir hospital..with their track record. Just sickening. You ever want to see something..look up Kidjacked..real stories of corrupt Drs..lawyers hospitals and CPS. This evil needs to come down!!!
A Court of law ordered them to shelter her at the Hospital. What do you say about a child who comes in with many fractured bones over a year. Is the Hospital right to call CPS. If they don't report suspected abuse it's a felony.
If anybody reads this can somebody please explain to me what's going on please.... Because I was in DYFS when I was a kid I was in foster homes and everything... I know how some of those fake foster parents get down... Thank God I was never sexually abused or anything like that... I had some that would make me do some messed up stuff as far as punishment goes.. for example.... One lady named Miss Williams (from E.O.,NJ)
Used to make me stand in the corner holding books in my hand for at least an hour and if I let my arms drop she wouldn't let me eat that night... the crazy thing is that her husband (MACK) (WITH HIS FAT B*TCH ASS WOULD MAKE ME STAND ON ONE LEG WHILE DOING IT 😏 NEEDLESS TO SAY IT ONLY TURNED ME INTO A STR8 BEAST WHEN I GOT OLDER 😏😏😏 AND BY THE GRACE OF ALLAH, I WAS OUT OF THEIR HOUSE WITHIN 3 MONTHS.... I WAS BEING PUNISHED BECAUSE I WOULDN'T CALL HER MOMMY OR MOM..... YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND MY BIOLOGICAL MOTHER DIED AND I WAS 8 YEARS OLD I WAS LIVING WITH THEM WHEN I WAS 9 YRS OLD.... SHE HAD ME AND MY LITTLE BROTHER.... SHE WAS MAD BECAUSE I TOLD MY BROTHER SHE'S NOT A REAL MOTHER STOP CALLING HER MOMMY MOMMY IS DEAD... AND SHE JUST DIDN'T TREAT US GOOD ANYWAY.... WHAT IS ALL OKAY.... WHAT DOESN'T KILL YOU CAN ONLY MAKE YOU STRONGER RIGHT???😏😏💯💯💯💪🏽💪🏽💪🏽
AND THAT'S ONLY ONE TEMPERARY FOSTER HOME I HAD TO GO THROUGH 😏
CPS needs to be completely dismantled and rebuilt. They take kids away from wonderful parents, and they force reunification with meth addicted, abusive parents. How many children have to die before something is done?
Liars lies lies Sally smith I see you
Maya is clearly a victim here. Her mom signed a consent for a procedure that had a 50% chance of DEATH.
Procedures have high probability of complications/death all the time. Brain surgery, spinal surgery, open heart surgery, organ transplants, neurosurgery, etc. Probability of mortality isn’t as big as what you’re making it out to be.
If I would of had the option of the ket coma, I would have gone immediately. I still believe that it is very difficult for others to understand RSD or CRPS.
@@hope4all366Exactly, people who don't live in constant pain just can't even begin to understand what it is like.
Wow cautions for any treatment even medications come with cautions and even death! Incredible right?(sarcasm) people have died from tylonal idk get educated not googled, that’s all. Blessings
Haha the judge called her stack of binders a prop lol
Smith you weren’t the expert in child abuse…… you were an expert at abusing this child!
That's the perfect statement for ss!!
What is the point of the stack of binders that she brought in with her?
Props,,or trying to look important, or trying to subliminally make jurors think she took lots of notes, even though they will know by previous witnesses that logging was anything but impressive.
I Pray for The Kowalski Family.
May Beata (a Great Human Being and Most a Concerned Mother. May She Rest In Eternal Peace.🙏🙏🙏, as well deserved.
Maya, keep fighting to do the best you can, that was all Your Dear Mom aimed for You and Kyle.!!!
I am glad they won for all they have been though
I'm a child advocate at CAC. You make a report if there is any suspicions. You wouldn't need to consult a dr first.
Exactly. The thing is she was telling on herself. She was allowing the jury to know that they would contact her first to make sure there is enough evidence to make it stick as abuse.
“I really didn’t want to kill those trees”….. but let me put away these 1.2 million pieces of papers I brought in my binders….🤔😒
Also gotta love her “no.” (Oh snap evidence let me now ummmm wave my wand at the jury) this lady needs to face charges. She’s disgusting.
Plaintiff lawyer questions are ridiculous. MPB is no joke. These people were trying to protect Maya in my opinion.
Except Beata was cleared of MbP during the dependency hearing. One of the major criteria for MbP is that the child gets better upon removal of the parent. Maya didn’t get better. She was still in pain and still unable to walk when she left the hospital.
@hostronic Exactly! I think they just didn't like her because she has a medical background and had done more research on CRPS than any of them had. She was a passionate advocate for her doctor, and she came off as harsh, rude, and controlling, and they did not like that. They decided to make her pay, but all they did was hurt Maya more.....and destroy an entire family. It's disgusting.
No, SS was operating beyond what should’ve been her purview. The hospital was not being overseen properly. Check out Dr. Corcoran’s 2nd testimony at the end of the trial. I think he was the last witness before the jury began deliberating.
Remember how CB (and possibly SS) kept talking about talking with risk management? Unlike all the other JH hospitals, JHACH’s Risk Management had no oversight from the main hospital department. They didn’t inform the main risk management team about any of the difficult cases that could be liabilities. HUGE problem. Jack and Beata’s complaints/grievances were supposed to be responded to (with input from Corporate Risk Mgmt within 10 days. JHACH didn’t respond to them at all! THIS is one of the reasons JCACH was under Immediate Jeopardy. Some here may say, but that was only for the heart surgery program, Why then did JHACH overhaul their operations for the whole JHACH, having found serious problems throughout the hospital. The first complaints from nurses and/or doctors in 2015, but were not addressed. Myers stay was in the range of time that was being addressed. If it’s not broke, don’t fix it. But if it IS broke, absolutely fix it, even if the state and federal accreditation boards don’t spot it. Eight senior executives resigned or were fired as result of this. Maya Kowalski was the canary in the coal mine for this.
She was a liability to the hospital and that cps board
Yeah, the judge is going to cover up the back loophole that takes that evidence in before and after, and both of them agreed on it
Look at her creepy smile when the defense ask her questions 🤥
I have to say I have watched trials and this trial is as shady as can be..yesterday defense i kid you not whined at the judge to get her way..its clear an has been since the get go of this trial defense is clearly running this courtroom...Today defense is talking about what the plaintiff wants to keep out of this trial thats comical being as from the start we have been getting half the facts an have the truth. This Smith I wont say doctor because she doesnt deserve that tital thought it was funny that a child used the restroom on herself and then had to lay in it for who knows how long from what we have heard. I wouldnt go to this hospital with my children and if i came across these people that have "resigned" anywhere else I wouldnt walk away with my child I would run..these people associated with this place are corrupt and evil..First the people working at this hospital and yes I say that because defense keeps saying they had nothing to do with it but today Smith herself said she was a "member of the medical staff team" if shes not a member from this hospital then where?? They claim Maya was making up the pain an her mother was the cause..because she was taking her to doctors trying to find out first what was going on then later did but NO even with experts which clearly Smith is not it didnt matter..then after the mother commits succide then they have it in her files she has CRPS..lets just say Maya didnt have this..how this child was done an treated while in their care the hospital is unreal in itself..Smith in her depo said she had known Bedy and worked with her before.. I would really love to know how many other famiies an kids have been done this way but I have a feeling we never will sadly.
Have you really think what she said?
I am on the re-watch crew and Dr. Sally Smith is a nervous Nelly on the stand. Not as smug as she is in depo
Looks like she softened her 11s a bit, since the depo, hair down, floral shirt. I’m sure she was advised by someone, indirectly, from the D-team.
Exactly Attorney Hunter! Why is the Judge inserting his opinion on what prescriptions can come into the trial as evidence?? Isn’t it up the the JURY to decide on the evidence????
If I’m reading your comment right- It is up to the judge to decide what evidence is admissible. If the jury were to get to decide, they would see materials that they are not supposed to, it could potentially cause a bias or mislead, and then a fair trial is out the window. Also, the jury doesn’t have the legal knowledge or authority to decide what is admissible as evidence like the judge does.
- Deciding which medications (which all have certain administration indications and Rx dates) are relevant to the trial could be argued by the lawyers and then decided on by the judge.
this woman thinks she knows everything
Oh wow IT smiles 😂
Amazing what a total personality change this Sally Smith underwent from her deposition to now putting on a good show for the jury. This woman is two faced and I don’t trust a word that comes from her mouth.
Why don’t you just accept Kelly’s interview to tell her. That way not necessarily everyone will see that. And really appreciate what did you do to this matter. This is not my information in your place except picture. If I receive what I have, then I will do my part, otherwise I don’t have ability to donate.
So defense lady lawyers think this email from BK is funny? Rude
It's strange to watch this knowing the outcome of the previous proceedings against Suncoast/Smith..
1:00:42 😂 WHY does she have to look Soooooo Shocked when Mayas team says anything! Omg chill out lady! 👀
How can you write report depend on imagination? So powerful also use your lawyer teams.
Wow, how comes all illness alway on Saturday, then patients need suffering 4 days plus your investigation, when is patient need suffering to? Anyway as long as you earn that money , nothing is important.
See, who dare to trust medical system? If you meet such huge figure.
no objection to carrying on this process! Well, that’s all about due process
Have you read those emails that Beata wrote to herself as if in Maya's voice?!!! Sorry, but that IS crazy. Beata did have a serious mental disorder; probably a Narcissistic Personality. I am not mocking her: just pointing out that of course she engaged in a Munchhausen by Proxy. Perhaps unconsciously, probably her emotional needs and unprocessed trauma demanded her to do that. But it WAS a case of a MbP. And the standard procedure in such cases is to separate the child and the parent, at least temporarily. Then to offer a psychotherapy to the family. Which the court order and the Child Protection Team did. I am really sorry for Maya... Her mom defined Maya's identity by her (Beata's) mental disorder, and Maya will need a lot of therapy, not this frivolous law suit which will only make her mental healing more difficult.
You should really read the DSM-5 guidelines for Factitious Disorder Imposed on Another (MbP). It doesn’t line up and Sally Smith admitted in proffer to only considering evidence that corroborated her suspicion of MbP in her report to the dependency court. She did NOT include any evidence that refuted her claim because she said it’s “not her job” to do so. Yet the DSM-5 clearly states that when evaluating someone for MbP ALL evidence must be considered, including refuting evidence. She broke the DSM guidelines.
It has already been determined and proven that Beata did not have MSP.
@@hostronic OK, granted: you may be correct, and Beata may not have had an MbP, strictly technically speaking. My main point was that SHE was, if not 100%, then 99% responsible for what went on with Maya. She used Maya as a prop in her fantasies of a one-in-a-history-of-the-World girl with a heroic "mommy" by her side. Just read those emails!
@@SK_TorON👍
Hello! How could she, when SS and JHACH filed a child abuser case, so she was no longer able to oversee and consent to her child’s treatment?
Tell me why the doctor was takint the girl off the meds then, prior to being told to? 🙄 i didnt know it was the doctors recommendation to wean off the meds to test the child. If that is the case, why did the doctor decide to place the child on the drugs to begin with? Obviously it took someone to place something in the doctor ear.
Im probably missing something. I mean i understand doctors test drugs out on patients, but it is usually one at a time to see what is helping. How did she manage getting on multiple drugs without any improvement, then decided we're going to take her off all them.
That’s right show that to trial for one system
The Attorney for the family plays dirty! He has wasted more time badgering witnesses asking the same question 10 different ways hoping to get a different response. Then he mutters something ignorant under his breath!
he gets away with a lot of bad behavior.
Did we watch the same cross examination? LOL
I agree with you. This Mr. Anderson is often wrong but never uncertain... I do hope the defense wins. Honestly, I would be impressed if the father decided to spare further damage to his children and withdrew the law suit. I know if won't happen, but I feel that healing their psychological trauma would be better for his children then a 200 million...
Agreed! Or says something ignorant out loud! But Dr. Sally handed his butt over on a Platter! I live for the moment 😂😂👏👏👏👍👍👍👍
@@TheUniqueme1Hi, I'm glad I wasn't the only person who found him obnoxious! And you're right Dr. Sally wasn't having it! It's funny bc I usually watch after they adjourn for the day & the Defense Attorney brought it up to the Judge & said others sitting @ their table make faces too knowing the Jurors are beside them & can hear & see them. So they must read the comments! I watched a video that the Jury won't see & it's Maya dancing exactly like the girl in the video twisting her body & playing with her hair like she was 18 & on stage! This was a couple of weeks after getting out of the hospital after one of her administrations. I was shocked that she had it posted! I deal with severe chronic pain & have had surgeries throughout my life to which I had to learn to walk again when I was young. Theirs so much I see that I don't believe & I've also worked in a hospital. I hope when this trial is over someone can access all the videos, pictures & documents as people will be surprised @ the real truth. The only statement I believe from Maya is the one she told the Nurse that her life is a lie. She's not this poor angel that was abused by everyone @ the hospital theirs so much more to it! Take Care! Ontario, 🇨🇦 P.S. If you watch every courtroom proceeding to the end after the Jury leaves you'll learn a lot more although the evidence won't be shown to the Jury. 🐾
I’m completely oblivious to what’s happening in this trial. I don’t have Netflix. So, I just a while ago. Woke up and this was on. I noticed by the comments. There are people for both sides in here. I know too, I’m probably in here by myself. But, if anyone reads this ? If you could clue me in at all. I’d appreciate it.
Maya has a rare pain condition where she was taking doses of ketamine to treat it, prescribed by a doctor. She was getting better. Then she relapsed and needed emergency care. Father took her to JH and they told the staff about her condition and the ketamine. The mother came in later telling them to give Maya ketamine so she can stop hurting. The staff felt she was being controlling and suspected munchausen by proxy or medical child abuse. The staff thought Maya was making it up and the mother was making her sick on purpose. There was a court order where the mother could no longer see Maya and the mother could only talk to her by phone only, supervised. After 3 months or so, the mother could not bare not seeing her daughter and being wrongly accused by the court and hospital, and committed suicide. More details but that is the gist. The hospital also said Maya was making it up, but was billing their insurance for the disease they thought she was making up. Dr Sally Smith was one of the top people in the abuse investigation.
I know this has nothing to do with the medical part but I haven’t seen the whole documentary I saw up until the father was speaking to the cop and I feel put the mother under the bus.
I wonder after this trial the lawyers and judge and lady go out for a beer. The judges parents
Have a Dr. And a judge for kids! Wow!!
Do you see these problems? Her knowledge over 19 years, no upgrade skill or knowledge, in eastern countries,Doctors or nurse always need go to class or offer your research paper submit to conferences team. Here no these updates, only limited experience.
So many comments here, trashing Dr. Sally Smith. How about we focus on those emails? Those are just… effin’ bizarre. Who composes emails written in the tone of their child and sends them to themselves? That’s unsettling.
Who's the Guy in the hrey suit and red t.shirt please,he looks out of place?
Dr. Sally Smith was actually spot on for the entire thing. Everything she said made perfect sense and the hospital saved this girl’s life.
Maya went into the hospital with CRPS, was charged for CRPS protocol treatments, and left hospital with CRPS diagnosis. They did not save her life, they were trying to disprove the CRPS diagnosis, and Dr. Smith was at the forefront of keeping this family separated.
Hospital staff submitted an abuse report, and child welfare officials closed it the same day after confirming Maya’s CRPS with her specialist.
It was only after Dr. Smith filed a second report, against Maya’s Pediatrician’s advice, that she used Munchausens by proxy to get a separation order.
@@dianealarcon8304 Taking ur child to be put in a ketamine coma which gives a 50% chance of death when the child is not even dying of cancer or any other fatal disease says it all. Oh and then to write a blog as if u r the child but ur really the mother. Come on, this isn’t rocket science. The mother was mentally ill. I’m sure she would have killed her child if not for the hospital. As a matter of fact, she asked for hospice to have lethal doses of drugs. Super dysfunctional family and sad the mother put her family through misery and then hung herself.
That’s not what the jury found. JHACH falsely imprisoned, her, battered her, subjected her and her family member to intentional emotional distress that led directly to Beata’s death by suicide, was liable of the wrongful death wrongful death of Beata, was liable for fraudulent billing, and two other issues.
And the family settled with SS and CB.
And terrible news from both of their pasts became public knowledge.
So, no.
That back owner know who I am.
Ohh, 15 mins , child abuse biggest scandle
I work my but off, never get any sents. See how easy she can get.
There is also a famous case in Texas who went through something similar with a hospital and the wife had a small baby CPS came in and removed the baby while he was latched on and feeding! It was all caught on tape and it's just heartbreaking and like this family there was no abuse just a system way to willing to take children from good parents... the Bright family in Houston tx there is even a podcast on the case called Do no harm
The Kowalskis are ALL manipulators
Perhaps you are the manipulator.
I hear victims of Epstain are too 😮😂😂😂