2024 Titan 18 HX vs Scar 18 Benchmark Battle! 15+ Tests and Games Side by Side, Display Test, More!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 авг 2024
- The Battle of the Behemoths!! The MSI Titan 18HX is the most expensive retail spec'd laptop money can buy, but is it worth paying the extra for the premium feaures compared to the Scar 18? Today, we will benchmark the 270W TDP i9-14900HX and RTX 4090, play 10 games, test the 4K MiniLED display, 128 gb ram, 4 TB SSD, and answer any questions you all have! You can buy the MSI Titan 18HX here: newegg.io/ncb170c953
The 2024 refresh for the Asus Strix Scar 18 has arguably the best 18" display in any big gaming laptop with 240 hz QHD+ MiniLED with 2048 local dimming zones and over 1000 nits brightness--it doesn't get much better than this! I am also excited to test out the i9-14900HX for the first time in a bunch of games to see how much performance improvements there have been. Buy Scar 18: go.magik.ly/ml/1znkx/
The above affiliate link(s) help financially support me and my team, so thank you very much if you use them. But as always, no pressure to buy anything. I hope I can help everyone find a laptop they will love!
You can find links to buy all RTX 4000 series laptops on my 2024 Gaming Laptop Ranking List: listium.com/@GizmoSlipTech/80...
Throttlestop Download: www.techpowerup.com/download/...
MSI Afterburner: www.msi.com/Landing/afterburn...
HWINFO64: www.hwinfo.com/download/
My 4K/1080P 240 hz Projector: go.magik.ly/ml/1rerp/
Nanoleaf LED Lights on Wall: go.magik.ly/ml/17k61/
Check out my written reviews: gizmoslip.tech
Join GizmoSlip Discord: / discord
Check out Illuvium Game: link.illuvium.io/Gizmo
00:00 - 2024 Titan 18 HX vs Scar 18 Benchmark Battle!
01:25 - Intro to Listium
02:08 - Top 10 Deals
02:58 - Asus Strix Scar 18 Quick Overview
04:04 - MSI Titan 18HX Quick Overview
04:58 - Quick Comparison - Razer Blade 18
06:46 - Quick Comparison - Lenovo Legion 9i
07:56 - Quick Comparison - Alienware M18 R2
08:52 - Quick Comparison - Acer Predator Helios 18
14:08 - Weight Comparison - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
18:38 - Display Test With Spyder5 Elite (QHD+ 18” 240Hz MiniLED) - Strix Scar 18
28:22 - Display Test With Spyder5 Elite (4K+ 18” 120Hz MiniLED) - Titan 18HX
42:35 - Side-by-Side Display Comparison with Examples - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
48:07 - Side-by-Side Bloom Test Comparison - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
51:02 - Side-by-Side Build Quality and Flex Test - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
54:15 - Side-by-Side Hinge Comparison - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
58:47 - Design Comparison Side-by-Side - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
01:08:15 - Software Comparison - Power and Profiles - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
01:19:20 - Software Comparison - RGB Settings - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
01:28:13 - Speaker Test Comparison Side-by-Side - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
01:37:30 - Fan Noise Test Comparison - Max Fans - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
01:41:30 - Fan Noise Test Comparison - Extreme Performance/Turbo Auto Fans - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
01:51:59 - Cinebench R23 10-Minute Benchmark Side-by-Side (i9-14900HX) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:01:29 - Cinebench R24 Benchmark Comparison Side-by-Side (i9-14900HX) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:02:16 - AIDA64 Memory Test Comparison Side-by-Side - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:06:38 - CrystalDiskMark SSD Comparison - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:12:27 - Time Spy Benchmark Side-by-Side (i9-14900HX, 4090) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:21:45 - Baldur’s Gate 3 Side-by-Side (QHD+, Ultra, DLSS Q) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:26:55 - Cyberpunk 2077 Side-by-Side (QHD+, RT Ultra, DLSS Q, FG On, RR On) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:33:35 - Dead Space Side-by-Side (QHD+, Ultra, DLSS Q) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:43:35 - Dragon’s Dogma Side-by-Side (QHD+, Ultra, RT On, DLSS Q) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:48:10 - Dying Light 2 Side-by-Side (QHD+, HQ RT, DLSS Q, FG On) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:52:29 - God of War Side-by-Side (QHD+, Ultra, DLSS Q) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
02:59:15 - Hogwarts Legacy Side-by-Side (QHD+, RT Ultra, DLSS Q, FG On) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
03:08:18 - The Last of Us Part 1 Side-by-Side (QHD+, Ultra, FSR3, FG On) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
03:14:59 - Starfield Side-by-Side (QHD+, Ultra, FSR3, FG On) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
03:20:55 - The Witcher 3 Side-by-Side (QHD+, RT Ultra, DLSS Q, FG On) - Titan 18HX vs Scar 18
03:27:47 - Final Summary - MSI Titan 18HX vs Asus Strix Scar 18 
Игры
You turned the vsync on in TITAN 18HX in Dead Space...TITAN was stuck to its 120hz and cannot get any 1 FPS higher than that, you should notice this bruh
Amazing battle Brandon! This is an incredible amount of work - live and raw with regular disucssions with chat. Truly an impressive feat. At the end of the day, I must admit I'm in love with the Titan!
Thnks bro for exelent compare of this 2 beasts
Thanks for this!
Very nice video, I selected MSI Titan 18 despite all these laptops. Even in silent mode this laptop using 80W GPU and no noise at all and if you want go for 200MHz boost that's crazy. Also I like your pauses within video appeals to me as tired off youtubers continuously speaking clearly shows its paid.
The fps graph on the MSI is just insane, the flattest I've ever seen
Yeah, really impressive, especially for hogwarts
titan 64 gb 4000 mhz works, what is the situation when there is only 32 gb,
I would be very happy if you answer
In my opinion it is possible to make a big difference because of raid 0 on the Titan and much better read and write speeds, but it doesn't make sense to be that huge . Great comparison as always🙏
You could add a comparison between the I/O Ports connections of the two laptops.
Does the titan have a 40gbps Port like TB4 or USB4 through USB-C?
thanks Gizmo :)
I want to know which is best gaming laptop in 2024
It may not be a good idea to put laptops next to each other. They have side ventilation, so they may be operating at higher temperatures than expected and adjusting performance.
Anyway, great job, anyone would like to have one of those beasts!😃
1% low FPS actually affects the game experience very much, especially when the FPS reaches 100+, this will be the only factor that affects smoothness, when 1% low drops, the game will seems laggy. Even you have 200FPS for average but 50FPS for 1% low, the game will still feels stutter
Gaming test should also record 1% low FPS to the result, this is important
Scar need a driver update. Thats not normal. I got mine yesterday . The new model with 64gb ram. I paid $3799.00 microcenter store
in scar 18 2024 the ssd's should be in raid 0 as well, no? mine is and I reached the read mark of 10551 in diskmark, why yours reach just 7k?
I think mine came with 1x 2tb ssd. Might be sold slightly differently
The 18-inch MSI Titan is the perfect example of you paying a lot more money and get diminishing returns or minor improvements. I’m frankly not surprised by the performance result, the MSI Titan is literally the best gaming laptop in existence and comes at a steep price.
Ah, These guys are right, dead space was locked to 120 with vsync on. Thats why you only seen about 80% utilization. May want to make a note of that.
Asus scar 18 2024 have Pantone validated display which is best for creators ❤ no others laptop have in this specs
+
Blade 18?
19:50 I don't even have these options on my 2023 Scar 18 4090. My System Configuration only consists of WinKey/ROGKey/Touch Pad/Boot Up Sound/Power Panel Saver....Am I doing something wrong?
u will have everything including panel overdrive. The only thing scar 18 2023 doesnt have is the multizone one cuz its IPS panel, the 2024 one is using mini-LED so it has that function
Excelente
Scar VS Alienware -- It's time.
What about warzone &, modern warfare 3 ???
48:07 The bloom difference is what is pushing me to the ASUS 18, as now I can’t unsee it on the titan. I love OLED screens, my friend has the ASUS Proart with the ,killer OLED. This I think to me is the closest to that in 18 inch gaming laptops. The refresh rate also does helps the decision too, even though I absolutely prefer the build and look of the Titan with the glass palm rest touchpad and overall materials.
Never mind saw how much of a fingerprint, palm prints magnet the glass on the MSI is…
Can you do an undervolt video on the scar 18?
Yes, in bios fot sure
Definitely waiting for this ever since I got this device
is razer blade 18 good for long hours of gaming?
not really but they got very hotter gpu and cpu
@@ihorlysiuk then i am going with asus g16
The MSI's frametime graph is so flat in every game, it's uncanny
Scar 18 or msi titan ? 2024
good for value bring scar g sync feature more better way than titan 18 but titan has more 270w pwer than scar
You would need to a little special to buy one of these
Review lenevo loq ryzen 7 8845hs , Rtx 4060 , 2k screen please
@@MikeMike-gj9vg bro go and see his community he what laptop he will review in his next videos
Wow. Can i win the msi titan?
MINECRAFT!?
Can you Play it? . . . THAT is the Question...( But I really want see the comparison with the current new Blade 18 300hz & the MSI Raider 18, ..is it a Toaster Oven???
I have the Blade 18 300Hz model and it runs very cool but the performance is the same as my Blade 16. Razer is only allowing only like 205-210W Package TDP
Gizmo points to the scar with 99% gpu utilization, sees cpu utilization is 24% and says the scar in TLOU is cpu bound. 🤦🏼♂️ Come on gizmo.
Timestamp? 😂
Dead space msi you v-sinc not of man ist on end limit fps 120 bro
I've had both of these laptops. Kept the MSI. The Titan screen was definitely brighter. Soeakers are better on Titan, keyboard is better, cooling is better, fps(can't really compare that as i play only in 4k but I'm sure it's better. Build quality on Titan is WAY better. 4k for a plastic piece of crap like the Asus is crazy. You can get a razer for that.
This is the kind of feedback I've been looking for, more info pleeeeeease
@@jorgegonzalez3103 What else you tryna know man?
But it’s just insane to pay that much for gaming laptop like msi Titan 18 😂
@@deadshot9946 It ain't a lot of money to me. We live two very different financial realities.
@@user-rp3ul4sh6dtrue but i mean if i had that much money i would just buy a 4090 desktop for even less lol
I am getting another 5-10% better results than this Titan with cheap optimized MSI GP78HX 13980HX 4090
OC?
can you tell us about ur optimizations? I have 4090 13980hx in scar 16. running undervol of 0.150v and thats it
Desktops use too much electricity
so what, they are silent and 50% faster easily. SILENT AS FUCK. I hate my strix 16 4090 for loudness and selling this piece of turbine shit.
@@bartman2395 They're silent because they're so massive, immobile, and impractical that fan noise is miniscule in comparison; and that 50% metric is only achievable with a 4090 Desktop which by itself consumes more power than every laptop released this year.
@@bartman2395 I went overbudget with my m980m ... My GT 72s motherboard power jack went bad. I went over $50 dollars and that's a tank of gas to me.. I got 4060 on a i9H, touchscreen
@@bartman2395 I cut my electricity budget, I went with a 4060 HP ENVY i9 gaming touchscreen 2k 120 hz.. i bought 64 Gb of RAM and a Samsung 980 pro and a SK . you might need to thermal paste it.. I squeezed 20 grams mx-4 tube just two days ago.. it is in my channel .
@@bartman2395 lololo
I'm a clown and I like clown mode
🤡
For linux user 500 Euro Laptop