It's disgusting how many brands are doing this with their products. Giving us less product for higher price. I will definitely start looking at this and will not buy them anymore. There are loads of other alternatives
I've noticed too when a product is being reformulated - the list of ingredients always change 😏 I was using a couple of skin care products for years until... the packaging and products changed also. My skin is very sensitive and when I finally find something that makes my skin happy... I'm pleased ☺ Take care everyone 🌹
you are the only eviwer that has liked it... my concern is that Kaolin is a clay powder that dries skin out... great for oily skin and acne but not for dehydrated skin... it sucks oils and water out, and is used in facials and acne bc it purges out the impurities... great if you need that but not great if you are dry... I hate to say this bu i am just being objective: the side with the new version was less shiney, but i could see more of the fine lines directly under your eyes...and that is what i am looking for: a good undereye setting powder...
Thanks Gemma! The original is the only finishing powder I would use on my dry, mature skin. A truly phenomenal product. When I recently heard that Givenchy was reformulating this product, I went into a panic. I bought an extra box of #3 so that I would be well stocked if the new one missed the mark. I am so glad to hear your favorable review. Life is good again! 😁😉❤
You did an excellent job on this product comparison! Thank you for sharing such an in-depth comparison between the original and reformulated versions of the Givenchy powders. You taught me things that I didn't know about face powders in general. ❤️
The pressed powder still has talc in it. Another youtuber said that the Divin blanc givenchy powder still has talc in it and is a suitable replacement if you prefer the original
Thank you - I am afraid its being reformulated too, as I cant see the pressed version on Givenchys pages anymore - I hurried to purchase one in my local store to have as back up for my loose powder when I run out.
@@twoleftfeet9626 Yes, as I said "I hurried to purchase one in my local store to have as back up for my loose powder when I run out." :-D I am just assuming that this too is being reformulated, as its not available at Givenchy Beauty page anymore.
SAME! So sick of these reformulations. I am so glad Givenchy did a great job on this one! One note, the lids are not a good judge on this one. Givenchy does many seasonal packages.
Ok ...I expect you're aiming at a younger market BUT I simply want to say that I really enjoy and appreciate your videos ! Always unbiased and with throughly researched information regards products . Thank you for your content, always a joy to watch ! Beauty has no boundaries or age!!😄
Thank you for the in depth review! Breaking it down as you did was really helpful. I haven't been able to find it available yet so still waiting to try the new formula.
While the Givenchy Prisme Libre Powder has now become rather iconic in its loose format, I don't see much attention given to its compact format. I have both and while I enjoy the loose powder, I did not like travelling with it, so the compact came in handy for that and for my handbag if I wanted to touch-up. The mini version now available is what I travel with, the compact is still something I carry in my bag. I was wondering if you have any thoughts or experience with the compact version of Givenchy's Prisme Libre Powder?
I feel people are going to be very upset when they go buy it during the Sephora sale and see it on there face in the light that it looks like a highlighter on their face and under their eyes. I never was impressed with the original one, but I know it’s a OG for so many.
Hey Gemma! Did you notice that this exact powder is now being offered in a pressed compact?? Exactly the same color combinations, but in a pressed form. I bought two of them in my usual shades that I get in the loose powder numbers two and three and they’re great to take on the go and I feel are just as good. Take a look and maybe compare the pressed to the loose powder
I worked in the fragrance industry. Our customers; Unilever, P&G, etc, constantly wanted their fragrances reformulated, demanding the same fragrance but cheaper. Common practice.
Funny how other reviews state the opposite, now I don't know which side I am at 😅...i found an offer at the department store at 50% discount and bought It, we'll see.....
I remember when Lancome reformulated their teint idole ultra wear foundation. It was my ride or die and its never been the same since 😢 why do they do it?!
Great video. I'm also commenting to let you know that your "original" version was already reformulated some years ago. Yes I'm old lol. So, Voile Rose used to be a sparkly powder and that's the one that I fell in love with. It was reformulated to a matte powder around I'm guessing 2019-2021, it's hard to remember now. They took the sparkles out which made me so sad. Luckily I found some unopened older stock and was able to back up. So I highly suggest to anyone married to your version to stock up now before they disappear. Powder can last a very long time fortunately :)
Thank you! i just saw a review on instagram and the new one looked like a highlighter. Thank god thats not the case and its even a better formulation now!!!
@@misspeachbeach7687 I do think that’s the case if you pack tons of the product on, but realistically, with the amount I apply, you can’t tell much of a difference. X
Hi Gemma having a paler shade is really good news as it was too dark for my ultra pale skin before (for reference 00 in Dior forever foundation is my perfect shade match). Instead of the Givenchy powder I bought the Dior lavender powder and I really like it. It too has a slight luminosity that works for my dry skin. I previously used the hourglass ambient baked powder but they discontinued my shade ethereal light (I did buy a back up before it disappeared completely thankfully). A lavender powder is fabulous on pale cool toned skin and the new shade looks promising. I will investigate next time I’m in Edinburgh at the Givenchy counter and perhaps pick up the mini. Best wishes x
Prism Libre powder is an absolute ride or die for me, so very happy your review confirms all is well and the new one is even better, yay!! Thank you so much 🙏💪👏🙌👌😘🌹 xx
Thank you for the video! You gave me hope!! My heart was broken because another video was being shared all over showing the new formula to be a “highlighter”. Now I suspect it was a little exaggerated by over applying the new formula. 💖
I never tried the old formula, I just bought the new version, it is the worst powder that I tried, it is like eyeshadow, all shinny 😢 and it enhances the pores!!!
I honestly did not need another powder to do a similar effect on my skin as my hourglass powders. I was happy with the powder like it was. The package seems also cheaper to me without the embossing.
Thank you Gemma for such a great review of the New Reformulated Givenchy Prism Powder. I purchased the Mini in 3 off of their website about one month ago. Iam loving it, but now, I for sure will order the full size and make sure it’s the newest one. You always give us such great in depth reviews, thank you!
I never got the original because in the first advert splashed powder iver the models... Imagine her breathing that into her lung! And it contains tarc, no matter how everyone says it is the best. I got this new one in smaller size a month ago. One only needs a small pot for under eyes. It really is a game changer for powdering under eyes, brightening but not glittery, smooth and light.
They removed it because that misinformation has taken hold. They give people what they want whether it's necessary or not. It's the same for parabens. The link between parabens and cancer has been repeatedly debunked, but people believe it anyway, so companies took it out.
I've only tried shade 2 (satin blanc is the name, I think). I could see visible sparkles under my eyes. They were tiny, but they were there. :( I'm not sure if all shades are like that, though. This refers to the previous formula. I don't even think we have the new here in the US yet. So if the new one is worse in that respect, it's not for me. Which is too bad because it was gorgeous aside from the teeny sparkles.
The old formula not all of the shades had sparkles! In the old one the pastel and one of the darker skin shades don’t have sparkles. So I think 1 and 3. Sadly here in Europe they alrdy removed the old one. 😢
I am in the minority: the original Prisme Libre powder was AWFUL on me. No matter how little I applied, my undereyes looked dry, wrinkled and terrible, so I gave it to a young family member. With mica as the main ingredient, the new formula may be worth a try.
I never used it under my eyes as from what I understand it's a finishing powder as Gemma I see calls it as well. If you still have it maybe try it that way?
I was getting ready to rush out and stock up on a backup of the original... was so worried about what the changes might be... but after your thorough review... I am not sure anymore... maybe the new one will be a welcome change! Thank you for doing such a thorough comparison... greatly appreciated!!!!
So, with that increase of the price per gram, the price for 12 g has actually increased from £48.5 to £62.4. That is a significant raise. And fine, if the new formula is much better, but more costly to produce, it may be worth it, but I do really dislike how they try to hide the increase of the price by making a larger container. That is deceitful, and makes me dislike the company.
Estee Lauder LOVE LOVE LOVE reformulating and discontinuing products, I believe they do it on purpose but can't understand why. Great products have been removed and replaced with inferior products.
Talc is a problematic product and is potential cancer causing due to possible asbestos contamination. I am replacing all my talc based powders to mica for this reason. So I am happy Givenchy is moving away from talc.
Thank you for this! I had no idea they were reformulating it. I’m definitely going to try the new formula… curiousity is getting the best of me 😂 I’m so glad they’re adding more shades in the minis! Hopefully I’ll love the new formula 😬🤞
Ridiculous to reduce the amount and increase the price. They really think people are so stupid to buy after that. I will pass no matter if it turns my skin to 20 yr old version
Thank you for your insight! Haven’t tried this powder yet although it been on my wishlist for months! Really helped me to decide if I should buy the old vs new.
OMGOSH, I'm shocked!!!!! Thanks for the detailed information. I ordered a new one a couple weeks ago during the Givency Beauty Sale...now I need to go open it and see if it is the new one!!! I bought a blush as well :).
If the new formula has kaolin ( a type of clay mineral) instead of talc it will be more mattifying and oil absorbing than the original. I have very dry skin and don’t want anything removing any moisture. I don’t think it’s for me.
I think the re-formulation possibly has not reached the US yet? On Givenchy’s website it’s still the old version when the US site is selected. But if I select the UK site, the new formulation comes up.
I'm fed up with the manufacturers Changing the formula of different products. As if that wasn't annoying enough What makes me really mad is discontinuing products and even brands I used to love smashbox make up but no longer available in the UK .😢😢
I watched a video saying it’s a highlighter.. but honestly I don’t believe that creator anymore.. i saw she took your exact thumbnail!! W honestly I believe your video more since it’s a live application.
Oh no!. Well, I have 2 old loose ones and 2 old pressed ones. All in different colors. I have #4 and I have a really old one they don't make anymore #2 Beige Taffetta. I also have #2 and #4 in pressed. I am so light handed with my powder so I figure these 4 will last me for at least 2 yrs or longer. Hopefully someone will come out with a better formula.
Interesting. I just watched another reviewer come to exactly the opposite conclusion. I wonder if it is in part a difference in application? She applied both the old and new very liberally, but also with a poof (smaller than the one you used). You could see how much she was pressing in on each side whereas you seem to use a light amount. Might that be why her “new” side was very highlighter?
I stocked up on another powder AND will now only be using it on my under eyes. It's the only thing that keeps that area matte and not crease HUHUHUHU. The new one will be crap in photos especially to us 40somethings!!
Is the same thing happening to laura mercier powder?? The LM powder is on sale here in the states and i am contemplating picking a back up incase they reformulate it.
I’m confused by this review. Mine is a straight highlighter. I may have been using the original incorrectly by using it as a setting powder rather than a finishing powder so I will definitely switch my application and hopefully get better results, but the new one is just straight shimmery highlighter. Definitely returning.
I don’t understand why they change something that is so good. Givenchy also remade my favorite cologne, Ysatis, that I have been wearing for years. The new version is not the same and I am so disappointed. I wish they would bring the old formula back!
Well we in the Europe (I mean EU and within the EU market) knew this for months now. I think since January they literally pulled this from the shelves and was available only online until the stocks lasted. Now it is a talc fee bcs talc is on the WHO cancerogenous substances (in the labs on cells and animals, also in humans ovarian and endometrium cancer and might be lung as well, bcs it is a mineral that is find in the mines and while usually asbestos is there as well and could be additional factor, the analytic data from cohortes and case control studies and combined metaanalisis - so this is way more then obsvervational transversal study and biological plausibility, time sequence and some other Bradford Hill criteria is there - clinical trial will never ever happen bcs there is also 0 clinical trial that proves smoking causes cancer or that parachute saves lives - you can’t have a control group that you give cigarettes for many years or other where you throw ppl of the planes without any parachute - it is not ethical). So far data shows this is not recommended substance to use (and there is a reason why sometimes we actually need animals and cosmetics and the additives should be taken seriously as meds - and not be this grey area) due to existing data so far. You have also Blanc Divin shade still has talc it is the same old formula that matches previous shade 02 - Satin Blanc.
I did not find the new version to be as shiny as the influencers were saying. As a matter of fact I like the new version better. It’s not shiny on me at all.
I’d written talc scare before watching video. I think this may be the case. I have to use baby powder to help me transfer from wheelchair and they’ve changed it to cornstarch not nice but hopefully safer.
I've seen so many reviews about this powder and mainly from USA based content creators and I wonder, if something is wrong with the us formula, maybe mixed incorrectly?
I was reading the ingredients on mine, it says synthetic fluoriphilogpite I got the new version I’m so mad, I don’t wear make up, and this was perfect for me, my go to product. I do notice the difference but I thought it was just my imagination or a bad batch. So I started looking for the old version, all the reatailers in my country removed it and they’re are promoting the new version, may be it’s the givenchy policy.
This is truly so sad! Do you know if the pressed Prisme Libre Powder is still matte? I can see it still contains talc. Will that be good for setting under eyes?
I’ve just watched this video & when applying each powder the new powder is applied to the right side of Gemma’s face (right side of screen) & the new one to the left (with her facing the screen), it’s written on the screen. However when she is outside & showing the wear test she says it’s the other way round… the new is on the left & the new on the right? Can someone explain it to me please as my mind is boggling trying to work it out lol.
I was going to repurchase the FS on the next sephora sale but when i saw it was being reformulated i said il just get the mini again to compare once it hits the US site. I find this to be comparable to the HG veil but do not like that one under the eye since the Givenchy one is more matte. This one works better for lighter makeup days as well, so I’m just hoping to find the new one not to be too radiant to use under the eyes Sad to hear about the size reduction/price increase but interesting i just looked at my HG and it’s $50 10.5g, vs current Givenchy $60 for 12g so i guess now il definitely be paying more. I don’t think i even realized because I’ve had the mini for over a year at this pt, so even with a less value its not horrible but i wonder price on that and if it will be reduced from say 4 to 3g. I’m otherwise happy to see the larger logo with the shiny top matching the mini i wasn’t a fan of the matte cap but i don’t think we needed the component any larger lol
The packaging being slightly larger on the reformulation is a marketing tool so people will "think/perceive" they're getting more for the new price increase (despite that they're actually getting LESS!)😢
I’m sick sick sick of reformulating and giving us less and paying more. We need to stand up ladies. They will only listen if we respond!
Reformulated = ruined
Where can we get the original?
True! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
It's disgusting how many brands are doing this with their products. Giving us less product for higher price. I will definitely start looking at this and will not buy them anymore. There are loads of other alternatives
I've noticed too when a product is being reformulated - the list of ingredients always change 😏 I was using a couple of skin care products for years until... the packaging and products changed also. My skin is very sensitive and when I finally find something that makes my skin happy... I'm pleased ☺ Take care everyone 🌹
Not a fan! Everyone said no shimmer particles. Until you walk out side in the sun and see tiny sparkles everywhere!!
you are the only eviwer that has liked it... my concern is that Kaolin is a clay powder that dries skin out... great for oily skin and acne but not for dehydrated skin... it sucks oils and water out, and is used in facials and acne bc it purges out the impurities... great if you need that but not great if you are dry... I hate to say this bu i am just being objective: the side with the new version was less shiney, but i could see more of the fine lines directly under your eyes...and that is what i am looking for: a good undereye setting powder...
Thanks Gemma! The original is the only finishing powder I would use on my dry, mature skin. A truly phenomenal product. When I recently heard that Givenchy was reformulating this product, I went into a panic. I bought an extra box of #3 so that I would be well stocked if the new one missed the mark. I am so glad to hear your favorable review. Life is good again!
😁😉❤
I stocked up on the old version. I wasn’t alone, because it’s all sold out on Sephora Canada.
It's all sold out on Sephora USA too! As a matter of fact, as of later Aug., the new version is either ALL sold out as well, or not in stock yet.
You did an excellent job on this product comparison! Thank you for sharing such an in-depth comparison between the original and reformulated versions of the Givenchy powders. You taught me things that I didn't know about face powders in general.
❤️
The pressed powder still has talc in it. Another youtuber said that the Divin blanc givenchy powder still has talc in it and is a suitable replacement if you prefer the original
Thank you - I am afraid its being reformulated too, as I cant see the pressed version on Givenchys pages anymore - I hurried to purchase one in my local store to have as back up for my loose powder when I run out.
@@bratsj1 You should be able to find the pressed version at other retailers, depending on your country
@@twoleftfeet9626 Yes, as I said "I hurried to purchase one in my local store to have as back up for my loose powder when I run out." :-D I am just assuming that this too is being reformulated, as its not available at Givenchy Beauty page anymore.
@@bratsj1 I don't think it is. I bought one last week in the UK and it had talc in it
Nooooo! Why is nobody else talking about this?? Oh I’m so sad. Back to my OG Dior loose compact. Thank you for sharing!! ❤
SAME! So sick of these reformulations. I am so glad Givenchy did a great job on this one! One note, the lids are not a good judge on this one. Givenchy does many seasonal packages.
You have the best natural fingernails! Can you do a video on how you care for them and how you grow them so long.
Ok ...I expect you're aiming at a younger market BUT I simply want to say that I really enjoy and appreciate your videos ! Always unbiased and with throughly researched information regards products . Thank you for your content, always a joy to watch ! Beauty has no boundaries or age!!😄
@@TheMiewmiew thank you so much xxx
Thank you for the in depth review! Breaking it down as you did was really helpful. I haven't been able to find it available yet so still waiting to try the new formula.
While the Givenchy Prisme Libre Powder has now become rather iconic in its loose format, I don't see much attention given to its compact format. I have both and while I enjoy the loose powder, I did not like travelling with it, so the compact came in handy for that and for my handbag if I wanted to touch-up. The mini version now available is what I travel with, the compact is still something I carry in my bag. I was wondering if you have any thoughts or experience with the compact version of Givenchy's Prisme Libre Powder?
I feel people are going to be very upset when they go buy it during the Sephora sale and see it on there face in the light that it looks like a highlighter on their face and under their eyes. I never was impressed with the original one, but I know it’s a OG for so many.
Hey Gemma! Did you notice that this exact powder is now being offered in a pressed compact?? Exactly the same color combinations, but in a pressed form. I bought two of them in my usual shades that I get in the loose powder numbers two and three and they’re great to take on the go and I feel are just as good. Take a look and maybe compare the pressed to the loose powder
@@reganszczepanowska8272 the pressed powder hasn’t been reformulated yet so is still talc based xxx
I worked in the fragrance industry. Our customers; Unilever, P&G, etc, constantly wanted their fragrances reformulated, demanding the same fragrance but cheaper. Common practice.
I’m also finding this with food lol not only shrinkflation but the quality has disappeared,the recipe has changed 😤👍🏻
I have the old powder in the small .Hope this one comes in small because it least a long time Can’t wait to try it.
@@sandylay5831 it does x
Totally sold out Sephora Canada. Your review gives me hope I will like the new version 💜🇨🇦
It’s ByTerry all the way for my dry 65 year old skin.
Funny how other reviews state the opposite, now I don't know which side I am at 😅...i found an offer at the department store at 50% discount and bought It, we'll see.....
I remember when Lancome reformulated their teint idole ultra wear foundation. It was my ride or die and its never been the same since 😢 why do they do it?!
I love the new one, but perhaps could've just brought out a new one & kept old.
I didn't know it was being reformulated. So happy you made this video.
Great video. I'm also commenting to let you know that your "original" version was already reformulated some years ago. Yes I'm old lol. So, Voile Rose used to be a sparkly powder and that's the one that I fell in love with. It was reformulated to a matte powder around I'm guessing 2019-2021, it's hard to remember now. They took the sparkles out which made me so sad. Luckily I found some unopened older stock and was able to back up. So I highly suggest to anyone married to your version to stock up now before they disappear. Powder can last a very long time fortunately :)
Thank you! i just saw a review on instagram and the new one looked like a highlighter. Thank god thats not the case and its even a better formulation now!!!
@@misspeachbeach7687 I do think that’s the case if you pack tons of the product on, but realistically, with the amount I apply, you can’t tell much of a difference. X
Hi Gemma having a paler shade is really good news as it was too dark for my ultra pale skin before (for reference 00 in Dior forever foundation is my perfect shade match). Instead of the Givenchy powder I bought the Dior lavender powder and I really like it. It too has a slight luminosity that works for my dry skin. I previously used the hourglass ambient baked powder but they discontinued my shade ethereal light (I did buy a back up before it disappeared completely thankfully). A lavender powder is fabulous on pale cool toned skin and the new shade looks promising. I will investigate next time I’m in Edinburgh at the Givenchy counter and perhaps pick up the mini. Best wishes x
Prism Libre powder is an absolute ride or die for me, so very happy your review confirms all is well and the new one is even better, yay!! Thank you so much 🙏💪👏🙌👌😘🌹 xx
Thank you for the video! You gave me hope!! My heart was broken because another video was being shared all over showing the new formula to be a “highlighter”. Now I suspect it was a little exaggerated by over applying the new formula. 💖
I love the new and am not happy they reformulated!!! Thank you for the heads up! I had not heard!💜🇨🇦
Thank you for doing this review. I am going to try the new version eventhou it's more expensive. That seems to be the trend now.
In my effort to declutter, resisting buys (trying anyway) of versions of a product I already have and love!
I never tried the old formula, I just bought the new version, it is the worst powder that I tried, it is like eyeshadow, all shinny 😢 and it enhances the pores!!!
I honestly did not need another powder to do a similar effect on my skin as my hourglass powders. I was happy with the powder like it was. The package seems also cheaper to me without the embossing.
Shrinkflation is really starting to tick me off.
Me too! It's pure BS!, and just about EVERY company is doing "SHRINKFLATION" to their products while they rake in literally billions more in profits!!
Thank you Gemma for such a great review of the New Reformulated Givenchy Prism Powder. I purchased the Mini in 3 off of their website about one month ago. Iam loving it, but now, I for sure will order the full size and make sure it’s the newest one. You always give us such great in depth reviews, thank you!
I never got the original because in the first advert splashed powder iver the models... Imagine her breathing that into her lung! And it contains tarc, no matter how everyone says it is the best. I got this new one in smaller size a month ago. One only needs a small pot for under eyes. It really is a game changer for powdering under eyes, brightening but not glittery, smooth and light.
The minute I found out, I bought back ups! Not gonna lose my powder!❤
Yeah i remember hearing that talc is commonly derived near asbestos so this is why they have removed it I'm assuming.
They removed it because that misinformation has taken hold. They give people what they want whether it's necessary or not. It's the same for parabens. The link between parabens and cancer has been repeatedly debunked, but people believe it anyway, so companies took it out.
I've only tried shade 2 (satin blanc is the name, I think). I could see visible sparkles under my eyes. They were tiny, but they were there. :( I'm not sure if all shades are like that, though. This refers to the previous formula. I don't even think we have the new here in the US yet. So if the new one is worse in that respect, it's not for me. Which is too bad because it was gorgeous aside from the teeny sparkles.
The old formula not all of the shades had sparkles! In the old one the pastel and one of the darker skin shades don’t have sparkles. So I think 1 and 3. Sadly here in Europe they alrdy removed the old one. 😢
Thanks for clarifying everything! Now I can relax when it’s time to repurchase. Great and truly helpful review!
I am in the minority: the original Prisme Libre powder was AWFUL on me. No matter how little I applied, my undereyes looked dry, wrinkled and terrible, so I gave it to a young family member. With mica as the main ingredient, the new formula may be worth a try.
This was my experience.
Nooo, I’m with you ! It’s terrible 😞
I never used it under my eyes as from what I understand it's a finishing powder as Gemma I see calls it as well. If you still have it maybe try it that way?
The new formulation is far superior to the original !
Same with me, it was awful on me.....
Thank u for this review! This is my favorite product for dry skin.
I have the small old version, Hope I love the new one as much, I have dry skin.
I might have bought 3 backups when I heard of them reformulating😂
Thank you! I tried first a mini of the new formula and I have been anxious whether I am missing out on the old formula.
I was getting ready to rush out and stock up on a backup of the original... was so worried about what the changes might be... but after your thorough review... I am not sure anymore... maybe the new one will be a welcome change! Thank you for doing such a thorough comparison... greatly appreciated!!!!
I believe they've added kaolin to the new formula, that might be why you are getting a longer wear time
@@twoleftfeet9626 I believe so too x
As a retired beauty therapist we used to do face masks with kaolin and good for oily skins, so maybe soaking up the natural shine? I dk tbh 🤔
@@elainebines6803 Yep, this is exactly why I speculated that kaolin is giving the longer wear. Did you know it is also used to make explosives?
Great comprehensive review Gemma. Thanks so much for doing this for us 🥰
So, with that increase of the price per gram, the price for 12 g has actually increased from £48.5 to £62.4. That is a significant raise. And fine, if the new formula is much better, but more costly to produce, it may be worth it, but I do really dislike how they try to hide the increase of the price by making a larger container. That is deceitful, and makes me dislike the company.
@@Chihiro33333 it’s still £52 for the 10g. The price of the product doesn’t change just because it’s more money per gram. X
Estee Lauder LOVE LOVE LOVE reformulating and discontinuing products, I believe they do it on purpose but can't understand why. Great products have been removed and replaced with inferior products.
Talc is a problematic product and is potential cancer causing due to possible asbestos contamination. I am replacing all my talc based powders to mica for this reason. So I am happy Givenchy is moving away from talc.
I’m incredibly sensitive to talc so I’m excited to be able to finally try this powder! 🎉
Ive already stocked up on the old version.
Great information, thanks , I ll be buy the new one!
Thank you for this! I had no idea they were reformulating it. I’m definitely going to try the new formula… curiousity is getting the best of me 😂 I’m so glad they’re adding more shades in the minis! Hopefully I’ll love the new formula 😬🤞
Ridiculous to reduce the amount and increase the price. They really think people are so stupid to buy after that.
I will pass no matter if it turns my skin to 20 yr old version
Thank you for your insight! Haven’t tried this powder yet although it been on my wishlist for months! Really helped me to decide if I should buy the old vs new.
OMGOSH, I'm shocked!!!!! Thanks for the detailed information. I ordered a new one a couple weeks ago during the Givency Beauty Sale...now I need to go open it and see if it is the new one!!! I bought a blush as well :).
If the new formula has kaolin ( a type of clay mineral) instead of talc it will be more mattifying and oil absorbing than the original. I have very dry skin and don’t want anything removing any moisture. I don’t think it’s for me.
I think the re-formulation possibly has not reached the US yet? On Givenchy’s website it’s still the old version when the US site is selected. But if I select the UK site, the new formulation comes up.
Thank you for this. Good info. I already have a backup to the one I have open (both original version) and will use them but welcome the new one.
I'm fed up with the manufacturers
Changing the formula of different products.
As if that wasn't annoying enough
What makes me really mad is discontinuing products and even brands
I used to love smashbox make up but no longer available in the UK .😢😢
I watched a video saying it’s a highlighter.. but honestly I don’t believe that creator anymore.. i saw she took your exact thumbnail!! W honestly I believe your video more since it’s a live application.
The fragrance is a no go for me, I was hoping the reformulation would have removed it. Oh well, back to my Laura Mercier.
Oh no!. Well, I have 2 old loose ones and 2 old pressed ones. All in different colors.
I have #4 and I have a really old one they don't make anymore #2 Beige Taffetta.
I also have #2 and #4 in pressed.
I am so light handed with my powder so I figure these 4 will last me for at least 2 yrs or longer. Hopefully someone will come out with a better formula.
It always happens just after I buy a product lol
I don’t see this anywhere. Not in the attached link, or on the Givenchy website. Perhaps because I am in the US?
Interesting. I just watched another reviewer come to exactly the opposite conclusion. I wonder if it is in part a difference in application? She applied both the old and new very liberally, but also with a poof (smaller than the one you used). You could see how much she was pressing in on each side whereas you seem to use a light amount. Might that be why her “new” side was very highlighter?
I purchased several back ups of the original. Having mature dry skin I don't trust that the new version with kaolin will suit my skin type.
Is mica lighter in weights?
I stocked up on another powder AND will now only be using it on my under eyes. It's the only thing that keeps that area matte and not crease HUHUHUHU. The new one will be crap in photos especially to us 40somethings!!
Is the same thing happening to laura mercier powder?? The LM powder is on sale here in the states and i am contemplating picking a back up incase they reformulate it.
I’m confused by this review. Mine is a straight highlighter. I may have been using the original incorrectly by using it as a setting powder rather than a finishing powder so I will definitely switch my application and hopefully get better results, but the new one is just straight shimmery highlighter. Definitely returning.
I have seen other videos where they applied it and it looks like a higher
@@emmafagan me too! And mine looks the same. I’m surprised about this review!
I don’t understand why they change something that is so good. Givenchy also remade my favorite cologne, Ysatis, that I have been wearing for years. The new version is not the same and I am so disappointed. I wish they would bring the old formula back!
Luv ur videos no matter what ur doing!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Thanks Gemma love your vids 🥰
Well we in the Europe (I mean EU and within the EU market) knew this for months now. I think since January they literally pulled this from the shelves and was available only online until the stocks lasted. Now it is a talc fee bcs talc is on the WHO cancerogenous substances (in the labs on cells and animals, also in humans ovarian and endometrium cancer and might be lung as well, bcs it is a mineral that is find in the mines and while usually asbestos is there as well and could be additional factor, the analytic data from cohortes and case control studies and combined metaanalisis - so this is way more then obsvervational transversal study and biological plausibility, time sequence and some other Bradford Hill criteria is there - clinical trial will never ever happen bcs there is also 0 clinical trial that proves smoking causes cancer or that parachute saves lives - you can’t have a control group that you give cigarettes for many years or other where you throw ppl of the planes without any parachute - it is not ethical). So far data shows this is not recommended substance to use (and there is a reason why sometimes we actually need animals and cosmetics and the additives should be taken seriously as meds - and not be this grey area) due to existing data so far.
You have also Blanc Divin shade still has talc it is the same old formula that matches previous shade 02 - Satin Blanc.
Great review ❤
I did not find the new version to be as shiny as the influencers were saying. As a matter of fact I like the new version better. It’s not shiny on me at all.
I’d written talc scare before watching video. I think this may be the case. I have to use baby powder to help me transfer from wheelchair and they’ve changed it to cornstarch not nice but hopefully safer.
I was scared delighted it is ok.😂
I will worry the too fine powder absorb inside the skin layer which may not be good!
Oh what a great video.
Thanks for sharing that Gemma ❤
I returned, hated the perfume scent 😢
I've seen so many reviews about this powder and mainly from USA based content creators and I wonder, if something is wrong with the us formula, maybe mixed incorrectly?
Not a big fan of mica so im hopeful
Mentioning light reflecting pearls really concerns me. I love a matte look hate any 12:56 hint of shimmer
@@Kaz-xu5ot I didn’t notice the shimmer once the powder was on my skin. Hope that helps x
I’m a Chanel les beiges loose powder girl so I’m not sad
I was reading the ingredients on mine, it says synthetic fluoriphilogpite I got the new version I’m so mad, I don’t wear make up, and this was perfect for me, my go to product.
I do notice the difference but I thought it was just my imagination or a bad batch.
So I started looking for the old version, all the reatailers in my country removed it and they’re are promoting the new version, may be it’s the givenchy policy.
This is truly so sad! Do you know if the pressed Prisme Libre Powder is still matte? I can see it still contains talc. Will that be good for setting under eyes?
I’ve just watched this video & when applying each powder the new powder is applied to the right side of Gemma’s face (right side of screen) & the new one to the left (with her facing the screen), it’s written on the screen. However when she is outside & showing the wear test she says it’s the other way round… the new is on the left & the new on the right? Can someone explain it to me please as my mind is boggling trying to work it out lol.
You read my mind…how can you tell the new from the old?
Yey to removing talc 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼 I’m buying 🤩 I have reactions to talc so this is great news for me 🤍
Yaaay! Shout out to Meadowhall lol
I had no idea!!! Nooooo....Anyone know where I can still get the old formulation?
I was going to repurchase the FS on the next sephora sale but when i saw it was being reformulated i said il just get the mini again to compare once it hits the US site. I find this to be comparable to the HG veil but do not like that one under the eye since the Givenchy one is more matte. This one works better for lighter makeup days as well, so I’m just hoping to find the new one not to be too radiant to use under the eyes
Sad to hear about the size reduction/price increase but interesting i just looked at my HG and it’s $50 10.5g, vs current Givenchy $60 for 12g so i guess now il definitely be paying more. I don’t think i even realized because I’ve had the mini for over a year at this pt, so even with a less value its not horrible but i wonder price on that and if it will be reduced from say 4 to 3g. I’m otherwise happy to see the larger logo with the shiny top matching the mini i wasn’t a fan of the matte cap but i don’t think we needed the component any larger lol
The packaging being slightly larger on the reformulation is a marketing tool so people will "think/perceive" they're getting more for the new price increase (despite that they're actually getting LESS!)😢
@@lindabenson1764 yea i understand that, i work in pkg but it still cost them more to change the component
Is it the talc scare?
Noo ! I’m only finding out about this and it looks too shiny 😢