She literally said “how many Jewish homes were taken by Germany”. So she’s basically saying if hitler did it to us why can’t we do it to the Palestinians.
@Cease AndDesist how is that remotely relevant in generalizing all of Palestinians during that time? So a mufti that was politically motivated to prevent the extermination of Palestinians in their homeland is all of a sudden in the only source you apply. But I guess you forgot or Israel doesn’t teach this; what about the thousands of Palestinians who opened their homes (literally) to take care of Jewish refugees? So many older Palestinians that were born before the establishment of Israel always talk about how they would feed, cloth and shelter Jewish refugees and that the Muslim, Christian and Jewish population all lived together side by side. Of course no one wants to talk about those Palestinians. You guys only want to talk about the Palestinians who were brave enough to fight back the illegal colonial ethic cleansing of their people and homeland. Palestinians opened up their homes to Jews and has no issues living side by side with Jews. Generally, Palestinians began conflicting once the Jews that moved to Israel violently and forcefully evicted 1million Palestinians out of their homes and murdered and raped tens of thousands of innocent Palestinians including elderly, children, pregnant women. That is when the Palestinians began “hating” Israelis. So our mufti that was so happy to work with the nazis did substantially less damage to your population than your whole apartheid state that was built on the ethnic cleansing and murder of innocent indigenous Palestinians and illegal colonial settlements and land you claim belongs to you while you quote history books like the Bible. Regardless of the history, it is irrelevant and should not a dictate weather an indigenous group of people; for over 2000 years should be expelled or not. This view is widely accepted among numerous respected historians and intellectuals. This conflict is insanely complex and there is an infinite amount of factors that play a role into not only the understanding of the conflict but the solution to peace.
He is getting better. His older content was a bit more bias towards Palestinians. I think he’s taken the viewer feedback well and working on his content.
@@Nadine8730 Harvard-trained historian Howard M. Sachar writes that from 1922-1946, 100,000 Arabs entered the country from the surrounding lands. Winston Churchill added that, "[d]espite the fact that they were never persecuted, masses of Arabs poured into the country and multiplied until the Arab population grew more than what all of world Jewry could add to the Jewish population." Creating a 22nd Arab State out of a lone Israel is an injustice. Carving a 45th Muslim country at the expense of the sole Jewish nation in the world is a crime!
@@AsterixObelixNL According to zionists it is. But when u question their violence they will point at their commandments which says something different :D It is unbelievable that people can defend them. All their answers makes 0 sense and deep inside they know it. They simply dont care and are racist af.
@@AsterixObelixNL no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HISalvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to mIake atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
“It’s just ours” or “our bible says it’s ours”. Do they understand how reductive and immature that sounds? If a Palestinian says the same thing are you not just as bad as they are? Why should I believe you and not him? They also seem to get way more offended by questions than the arabs which is weird. It is interesting how the settlers blame Israeli policies as much as Palestinian though.
You think God promise is reductive and immature?? Sorry dude, we're believers. And God did promise Israel to the people of Israel. Palestinians can't say the same because even in their OWN Quran, their God didn't promise Israel to them. Actually some will say that in their Quran, the people of Israel and their right on the land are mentioned there. Since the bible is God words, We can totally rely on it. And Israel policy and government is garbage. Wish we could have changed it. Palestinians tho, are not to blame because of our leaders stupidity.
@@hanna319 Yes I do. It’s your book not mine. I say god doesn’t exist, if he doesn’t exist how can he give you land? Don’t try to use religion to justify bad behaviour.
@@reubenmcmurray4377 I don't justify any behaviour based on the bible. I justify the Jewish RIGHT on Israel. Whether YOU believe in God or not is irrelevant, Jews and Muslims believe in their books and they are the ones who live there, and whether you like it or not, many of them are religious people who believe in God. forcing your disbelief on the people, won't solve the conflict. But why not, go ahead and force your policy on Israel, you can't tell the Palestinians what to do, because we both know they hate the west and will never listen to you , only we, Jews are stupid enough to try and try again. And as you probably know, Israel is not a religious country. So they don't base their right on Israel based on their bible. So you cab calm down
@@reubenmcmurray4377 thank you great white westerner for scolding the poor natives on the quality of their arguments when asked a silly question. You are totally not a condescending sc hmuck.
Even Israel's own Supreme Court (let alone the International community ) regards the occupation as illegal. Labour member of parliament, Yossi Sarid, expressed concern: 'Resistance breeds repression, which strengthens resistance, thus unleashing more repression, and one day we Israelis will look at ourselves in the mirror and be unable to bear the cruel and repulsive image reflected in it. We want not only to liberate Palestinlians from military domination but also to liberate ourselves from its effects."
No they don’t the court has only ever rules on specific land claims if it had ruled against settlements period there would be no settlements you mouth breather
@@oolooo history is replete. And thousands of years with dozens of generations changing over a land does not give you right to it by showing up one day and killing those living on it so you can occupy it. This is like an American Indian or Mexican walking into a house in Texas and dragging the home owner out into the street and killing him for their home. Is that legal?? Is that moral? That’s savagery. There was a time in history for savagery. Are you saying these occupiers are alone allowed to exercise savagery with impunity? Society has a way of dealing with those that don’t obey common law.
@Eti Camaroff The Almighty expelled the people for their disobedience and evil ways (sound familiar?) and cast them out into the diaspora. Never to return. Even practicing Jews indicate as much and are against Zionism. International Law does not require sovereignty in the absence of it it will recognize the presence of indigenous people and respect their rights. Sounds fair right? It is because it was written in sight of all the abuses carried out against such peoples throughout history.
@@WorldReserveCurrency the Torah is very clear that strangers will build the ancient Israelite’s walls. And that Magog will invade the land of Israel and loot & spoil peaceful farmers who are inhabiting the land (also not native but still dwelling there). The Torah also describes what it will be like when the Israelites return to the land- it will be peace flowing like a river and no wars happening, lions laying with lambs etc and it lists the nations from which the Israelites will come from. None of which are in Europe.
Kudos to Corey for having the courage to ask thorny questions in a land of conflict. I think too many people take it for granted, not contributing in any way but harshly criticizing his style. I find that attitude extremely shameless.
It's like some of the settlers learn to Prepare made up reasonings for themselves as they grow older, cause the younger one's reasonings are basically meaningless!!
@@rxtr664 no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
This is one of the best Corey videos dude. He was asking questions in a pressing way and did not back down. And actually confronted the Israeli settlers.
German stealing land is immoral but doing same to Paletinians is okay even when they are against International Law CZ WE ARE PROMISED THE LAND BY TORAH i got it
@Eti Camaroff > had its tanks on Israel's border So what? That's still Egypt's territory. > just because someone strikes first doesn't mean that side started the war LOL, that's literally what it means to start a war.
Between 1st April 1948 to 14th May 1948 and before any Arab soldier had even set foot into Palestine. Zionist militias had already taken over 220 towns through over 90 violent massacres. During that time the Arabs had officially declared war on the Zionists, the Zionists’ violent methods of ethnic cleansing were already largely underway. You can’t claim it was a ‘counterattack’ when you were the aggressors who initiated the violence when over 65 thousand armed Zionist soldiers attacked 2.5 thousand unarmed Palestinian farmers and villagers, way before the Arabs had declared war. What did you expect, your brutal methods of ethnic cleansing would go unnoticed?
It doesn't make any sense to claim my ancestors or people of my nation lived there 2 or 3 thousands years ago so now this land belongs to me and my nation. This stupidity has to end. Are we people with conscience?
It wasn't only the Arabs who had a desire to conquer other lands but literally every powerful empire (Roman Empire Normans, British just a name few). But taking away a country by claiming my ancestors lived there some thousands years ago is just absurd
@יואב דניאל I understand that Jews were not safe in most places other than like Morrocco and Iran, but don't you think the way Israel settled into those lands was inhumane and immoral? Obviously there is much more to the conflict, as Iran and the U.S. are also at conflict in a way. But as an iranian who hates the regime and even some arabs, including palestinians, because some view us negatively, objectively even with my prejudices I still view the situation as unfair and disgusting tbh.
Exactly. everyone’s house or the area where we live was once inhabited by other people. Does that make it right for their descendants to come and tell us : get out of my house, my ancestors used to live here 3000 thousand years ago. Does that make it right for them to ethnically cleanse and displace millions of Palestinians just because they inhabited that land 3000 year ago ? The zionist plan for the Middle East or so-called Greater Israel includes The annexation of Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Egypt, Lebanon and Syria. So their god promised them 7 lands 🤣🤣 They want to displace over 200 Million people so that they could feel satisfied, how greedy and cruel.
@@zuhriddinnishonov6867 Palestine is a made up word by the Romans it was a never a country that's a fact of history Jews on the other hand did have Kingdoms in Israel. Jews have consistently inhabited Israel since 1601 B.C.E. It's ok to drive a good chunk of their population out of their homeland but when the people who drove them out get driven out all of a sudden there's a problem? Your comment is absurd.
@Eti Camaroff spoken like a true land stealing zionist.camaroff you should look into where you come from really because it's not where you're at now.You come from the east,unwanted gypsies. You have not a drop of real ethnic Jewish blood as in the ones from the Old Testament.Rev.2:9 3:9 prophesized your kind long ago.
@@maximusdecimusmeridius5500 shut up you idiot. Jews are indigenous to the land, DNA proves it. Israel , the largest homecoming of an exiled indigenous population back to their homeland in history. Biblical prophecy said Israel would be reborn as a nation in one day!!!! It happened !!!
@@muhammadisdeadjesusisrisen4216 you obviously didn't get to the last of the New Testament?? But I see in your name that you are a believer in Jesus Christ so I do not want to argue with a brother in Christ.Synagogue of Shatan as Revelation 2:9&3:9 tells us.
@@muhammadisdeadjesusisrisen4216 Do You Believe In Christ or the fake scientistism that has perpetuated so many lies contrary to what scripture tells us.?
Why do they believe "God gave the land ( of Palestine) to the Jewish people" and seek to deny the Palestinian claims but no other ethnic people in the world make similar claims. The pope doesn't say God gave the Christians Rome, Vishna does not say "God gave India to the Indians" . The most they can say is historically as an ethnic group or civilisation that they had lived in this area for an extended duration and have an affiliation or identification with the region , just like the Italian people have a greater affiliation to Italy than the French.But to claim the land was given to them by God is a bit of an (unprovable) stretch.
@@dogbert52 The ancient Greeks and Romans called it Palestine. Palestine is a Greek name. Isn't it odd that Arabs from Yemen, Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Mecca and Medina came to Israel and decided that they want to be named after the Greek islanders, who came to the Levant from Crete.
You cannot debate with these people. They are no different than the kkk. They want and right-wing Fascist Ethno State for Jewish people only. Zionism is not only Rascist its Fascistic too.
So by the people's logic in this video, all mankind possess the right to claim a land in Africa because our ancestors once lived in there then had migrated all over the world. Thus it is totally moral to kick a Kenyan farmer out of his land and settle down.
Whats wrong with jews live in palestine there are 2 milion palestinians live in israel and no body have problem with that. Think again what is closer to aparthide
@Shayne Meidle so what do you remember about Exodus or Babylon? Do Jewish people make up a different human kind? Is that what you are claiming? Because you saying ''The Jewish people have the birth and history of their people all in Israel'' makes me think they are not Homo-Sapiens and started to evolve somewhere near Jerusalem.
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ You know the comment I made has nothing to do with the fact that the two communities live together. It is about some settlers justifying forced eviction of Palestinians out of their properties. They are trying to reason their settlement based on the chapters about promised lands in Torah but theproblem is the rest of the world doesn't believe what you believe and when they oppose it, some of you regard it as apartheid. A little emphaty please.
@Shayne Meidle I didn't claim otherwise and do accept Jewish people are one of the ancient nations of the region. The problem begins when you talk as if the revelations in Torah are absolute and the whole world (non-Jewish) should accept them as constitution. Do you want UN to take Torah as guide to resolve the conflict and allocate all Canaan land among Jews in accordance with Jewish doctrine? Speaking of cultures, who gives the authority to decide which culture is superior over the other? Okay assume that Arab culture is not as ''great important'' as Jewish culture. Does that give some settlers the right to steal properties of other ''not great and unimportant'' ethnic groups. These pretty much reminds me of Aryan race theory that Nazis used slaughtering Jews. Guess what, at the end it didn't work out great for everybody.
Its not only immoral against Palestine its immoral against nature and wild life just look how did they build settlements on mountain's you can feel their shame when they r talking and trying to make sense to be there.
@shani isreal what does it means take the land of Jews? Why it should be to jews? And if you really read the history away from bible, you will realize that most of Palestinian were Jews before Christianity and Islam... At the end It's not anyone land and you don't deserve to be there more than Palestinian and it doesn't make any sense to keep those immoral activities against nature.
@shani isreal what does it mean Judah 3500 years ago? Don't tell me you are saying that u are same? 😝 neither it was exist or not you can't claim this and as I know some of Israelis who started to move there after Zionists ideology weren't even Jews, otherwise most of Palestinian started to follow Jesus and some started to change their religion after the Islamic occupation to avoid paying Jizziah or Oppression by Islamists and some of them stayed Jews till this Day. Bro most of you even Black Africans? Or Blonde People? What does it relates to Middle east? or Palestine
@@dogbert52 Just imagine yourself living near a lake and someday you wake-up then you find it disappeared, or Just Imagine yourself as Animal and someday you find a settlements instead of your place.. Then u move to another place until u don't find where to go, bro you are the most criminals people I ever seen in my life, You oppressive others, taking their homes, attacks Nature, destroying builds, killing kids, insulting others, I don't understand what sick of ideology do you have, u are doing all this by the God name since Bible creation but there is no god who accept all those barbaric activities against humanity..
There is no such thing as "settlements." There is no such thing as "West Bank." And there is no "occupation." These are all absurd made-up terms meant to set your opinion before you even got to think for yourself. What there are, are Jews and Arabs, in Judea, Samaria and elsewhere in Eretz Yisrael. There are Jewish towns in Judea, and there are Arab towns in Judea. What is this sick perversion of justice and morality, to ask "is it moral for Jews to live in Judea"? Can you imagine asking Frenchmen if it's moral for them to live in France? or any other people? These is antisemitic, and if you believe that, you are auto-antisemitic. Have you considered asking Arab Israelis if it's moral for them to live in Israel?? No, right?? Because Israeli Jews aren't bigoted supremacists who are opposed to the presence of others near them. Here are the questions which should be asked: Is it moral to label Jews' presence in their homeland 'illegal occupation?' Is it moral to obligate Israel to give up parts of its land that it gained in defensive war, back to the aggressors (which is the opposite of what international law says)? Is it moral to blame Jews in the fact that bigoted supremacists are offended by their presence? Is it moral to accuse Jews of being a barrier to peace instead of the other side's bigotry? Is it moral to exploit Jews' innocence and ignorance and make videos like these? Arabs who have a problem Jews live in Judea can get the f*** out of there. Those who don't are welcome to stay. This is the only correct opinion!!!
@@yacobyourfriendlyneighbor228 Ask other minorities than yours in Israel, they'll all concur Jews are very welcoming. Now guess where the problem is stemming from :)
@@yacobyourfriendlyneighbor228 "Have you ever heard of conversions?" Conversions are exceptional amongst Jews, don't confuse with islam where ALL are converted.
I’m relatively good at reading people’s body language, but even Stevie Wonder can see that these people know what they are doing is wrong just by their nervous disposition and by trying to waffle their excuses out
“Israeli”: the land is ours we had it 3000 years ago, our bible said this. “Israeli” also: War that expelled Palestinians is since 1948, long time ago they have to move forward...
@Shayne Meidle they were expelled. They were attacked by the zionist militias supported by the British. They were defending their lands. You are the ones who came from Europe and other countries to build a country on their lands.
@Shayne Meidle 68%?? Can you mention your resources that give these numbers? Anyways what is your point? If the “israel” story is correct, jews also left the land thousands of years ago, what gives them more right than Palestinians to come back to the land? Shouldn’t they move on also?
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ Jews living in Palestine are there to stop the country from existing on the 1967 borders. If they would live under Palestinian Authority it’s not wrong. Btw there are 2 million Palestinians living in occupied Palestine. They live their before your grandparents came from Poland.
Of course no, Russians claimed that land already. Similarly Israelis have claimed the current land of Israel in fair wars, which includes the West Bank. The arab aggressor countries lost those lands to Israel. They gifted Sinai to Egypt and Gaza strip to "palestinians" ie. egyptian arabs who were living in that area, and expelled all the jewish settlers from there. The gaza egyptians thanked them with Hamas and rockets.
@@fordmustnagisbestcarath5046 The Hebrews themselves invaded Canaan back then and established a kingdom which didn't last very long and they were never alone on that land, so it's not their home then according to your logic
The one guy overtly states he wants to “encourage” Palestinian emigration. How sad. Truly morally sickening. Yet we give them BILLIONS in cash every year to a wealthy developed nation. It is apartheid.
Does any people who have some rusty coins in another country have the right to go there and kick out the natives ? Does the modern world accept that logic?
@Shani Israel The Romans left in Palestine more archeological remains than you. So, let the Italian people come and settle too in Palestine. Why not? This logic opens the door to everyone to claim another people's country.
@@chugalongway01 Oh, man, you thus have a great justification to build a settlement in Palestine. That's enough to kick the natives out of their homes, in which they lived for centuries, and don't care at all about the international law, because the only law which is recognized there is the law of the jungle.
"if i don't steal your house , someone else is gonna steal it " Jacob the Brooklyn jew Mai 2021 Replying to the 2nd man who said that we bought the lands , fool someone else buddy
If I will become jew, my question is, should I go there and claim that god promised this land to us, Do you think israelis will accept my reasoning and lete live there?
I love how each side has a “script” they fall into. “It was never theirs”. Then when it conflicts like well they were here when we came. The computer melts down.
@יואב דניאל ok occupier, your religion tells you to walk around carrying machine guns intimidating little children and make people walk through checkpoints 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 wake up from your fantasy
many people will chose to be ignorant to the moral implications of their actions because if they were not ignorant they would have to face the consequences of their actions and that would be to hard for them. nothing in life is black and white! some settlements can be immoral. lets not pretend like some of the settlements arent hurting Palestinians. all you must do is listen to their stories and see how many of them live. we must not cause harm to any person blindly. if Israel wants to succeed as a country it needs to see the ways in which Palestinians are being hurt by some of the ways the government is carrying things out. no one should expect Palestinians to be nonviolent and peaceful when everyone refuses to accept that they are largely suffering under occupation.
When I read western everyday news about Palestinian conflict, they always say, it's complicated. So I always just assumed, both sides commit war crimes or something. But now when I have read Arabic sources, or human rights associations sources, it's not complicated at all. Israeli government commits crimes against humanity towards Palestinians. Sure, individual Jews living in Israel don't have anything to do with it, they are not responsible. But what Israeli government does is pure and simply ethnic cleansing, it is not complicated at all. Why is this not in western everyday news?
You read western news. Then you read Arabic sources. What about Jewish/Israeli sources? Also, if the Israeli government is "purely and simply" ethnic cleansing, then how come the Palestinian population just keeps on growing? I do appreciate that you understand we individuals living in Israel don't have anything to do with it, I really do. Not just anyone does that. But this "ethnic cleansing" and "not complicated at all" claims are complete and utter lies - It IS complicated, and the Palestinian side commits far more war crimes than the Israeli government. Example: Hamas DELIBERATELY targets civilians with rockets, whereas Israel targets Hamas facilities and equipment that they deliberately hide among civilians. Thus, any civilian casualty is on Hamas' hands, not Israel's. The examples are endless, but hopefully you get the idea. Listen to the Israeli side as well, not just the Arabic sources; only then you'll be able to construct a rational, unbiased opinion, based facts, numbers, and statistics.
In 1947/1948 85% of Palestinians were ethnically cleansed from the land that became Israel. Until today they live in refugee camps. The Israeli law forbids them from going back home. The Israeli government confiscated their land and properties. The ethnic cleansing continues today using Israeli law to ethnically cleanse Palestinians from the land Israel conquered in 1967.
It amazes me how these people just blindly justify ethnic cleansing with statements so profoundly incorrect so thoughtless so evil without a prang from their conscience... other wise loving people some off them.( All though I know question this) The Jewish people must crave out a place in their heart for the appressed people of Palestine. What your doing to them is not unlike what Nazi Germany did to your grand parents. You ultimately will destroy yourselves you have lost your humanity.
What the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians is *very* much unlike what the Nazis did to the Jews and you do their cause no service to make such a hyperbolic comparison.
@Shani Israel Palestine is a place. It's on the map. You could have a Palestine Passport. People have lived their for thousands of years family's mothers fathers children. Your pathetic little history listen will not save you from what we all know to be true Ethnic cleansing of the people of Palestine. See they exist you cant change that, yet you hide behind it's ours as you murder, imprison, maim, and steal the homes of these brave people Your nothing more than gutless cowards.
@@edwinlucianofrias1643 Slower moving, but no. What is Gazi other than the Warsaw Getto people gunned down murdered man women and children trapped zero rights of their own you people have lost your minds.
Israel captured the westbank in a defensive war from Jordan. If Israel want to annex the land and be part of Israel,it's up to them. so what's wrong if israelis want to move there? it's theirs already. If you stated a war,but you lost and loose your land,don't complain nor demand to give it back.it's your fault.
That's a poor logic to justify what cannot be justified. "So what's wrong..." what's wrong is that contradicts the international law and the UN resolutions. Are you one of those who don't care about the international law. If so, then every country can do whatever it wants and the world would be a big zoo.
@יואב דניאל I think most of the Palestinians can be satisfied with a state on 67 borders. But The problem is that most people in the other side see the West Bank as part of their territories, and that's why peace is still difficult to be attained.
Palestinian inside the land.. the war with the "neighbours" were at the border.. they dont started the war.. they were massacred, and ethnic cleansed from the start
It is truly staggering how insane some of these people are and to what lengths they go to twist the words to fit their narrative. The woman @ 7:20, insane!
6:31 Pakistanis are NOT Arabs, they use the Arabic script, but speak Urdu. Not all Muslims are Arabs, just like nit all Arabs are Muslim. That’s be like lumping me, a English-speaking person from the US, in with Italians cause the script I use is Latin and we are both Christian-majority countries.
@Mohamed Syed Ahmar AbdAllah Then I'm not that impressed, you see. Arabs or not, still antisemitic as all hell. Israel is not an enemy state to Pakistan in any real way, yet still your passports have that disclaimer
A LESSON FOR PALESTINE 🤔📚 Just a thought. Go to South Africa. Ask the Africans (the Khoisan, Xosa, Zulu etc) how they feel about the white citizens ( the Afrikaans and the British) in their country. Ask the Africans if the would want to dispossess them? Ask the whites if the live in some state of constant fear owed to socio-political tensions between blacks and whites? The Jews in Israel are like the blacks in S.A. The Palestinians are like the Afrikaans and the British citizens in S.A. The best the Palestinians can do is the same thing the whites in S.A have learnt to do. Collaborate with the natives. Constant antagony will get you nowhere. ruclips.net/video/2ll-0WUGR7A/видео.html
12:45, the dude said that there is no notion of Jerusalem in the Quran, just to later say that in the original religion of Islam, the jews are the eternal people. Sounds contradictory.
@Eti Camaroff I can't understand you what does it relate to Islam and why do u drop bullshit reasons in every comment, Palestine isn't Islamic case it's Humanity and logic you took their land with bullshit pretext like bible and some history claims doesn't relate to present israeli who call themselves as Jews.
@@rachel-po5rm no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
I am thankful that you found the last woman in this piece to talk to. A question would be: for Israelis, Would you offer full citizenship to Palestinians, while for Palestinians would you accept citizenship in a one state (Israel) solution. Another question: Given the history of violence and the ongoing bloody conflict - how can all sides (because there are many variations and even divisions within groups) - build trust. hint, the answer is not - it's up to other guy because my side is never the aggressor and we're the only one with a legitimate beef. Also maybe there is no answer.
Putting aside illegal/immoral; building settlements in and between Palestinian towns makes it impossible to establish a Palestinian state. The question to Israelis: what do you want to do with the Palestinians? continue with the current apartheid status quo? give Palestinians citizenship and end the jewish majority? Repeat 1947/1948 "independence war" where 85% of the Palestinians were expelled from the land that became Israel?
There is no such thing as "settlements." There is no such thing as "West Bank." And there is no "occupation." These are all absurd made-up terms meant to set your opinion before you even got to think for yourself. What there are, are Jews and Arabs, in Judea, Samaria and elsewhere in Eretz Yisrael. There are Jewish towns in Judea, and there are Arab towns in Judea. What is this sick perversion of justice and morality, to ask "is it moral for Jews to live in Judea"? Can you imagine asking Frenchmen if it's moral for them to live in France? or any other people? These is antisemitic, and if you believe that, you are auto-antisemitic. Have you considered asking Arab Israelis if it's moral for them to live in Israel?? No, right?? Because Israeli Jews aren't bigoted supremacists who are opposed to the presence of others near them. Here are the questions which should be asked: Is it moral to label Jews' presence in their homeland 'illegal occupation?' Is it moral to obligate Israel to give up parts of its land that it gained in defensive war, back to the aggressors (which is the opposite of what international law says)? Is it moral to blame Jews in the fact that bigoted supremacists are offended by their presence? Is it moral to accuse Jews of being a barrier to peace instead of the other side's bigotry? Is it moral to exploit Jews' innocence and ignorance and make videos like these? Arabs who have a problem Jews live in Judea can get the f*** out of there. Those who don't are welcome to stay. This is the only correct opinion!!!
@@ok1634 My question is about the practical situation on the ground. I see your opinion is for the Palestinians to "f*** out of there" (no Palestinian will accept giving up their land to outside settlers). I hope there are Israelis who have more enlightened view. It is people like you who keep the conflict and suffering going.
@@dogbert52 So your suggestion is to expel all remaining Palestinians from their land? I wonder why no one thought about solving the south african apartheid by expelling all blacks from south africa, after all they have the rest of Africa to live in. Preposterous!
What it "Israelis"? Every other Joe has another opinion. Some want to live in one state peacefully, some want two states - to each his own. Some would like them to go away but know this is impossible, some small minority actually think it might happen. Almost nobody wants to kill anyone. And now ask Palestinians the same question - you may be surprised
@@ahmedkhalid9648 لا تكونن مثلهم حدثنا محمد بن عبد العزيز، حدثنا أبو عمر الصنعاني، من اليمن عن زيد بن أسلم، عن عطاء بن يسار، عن أبي سعيد الخدري، عن النبي صلى الله عليه وءاله، قال: «§لتتبعن سنن من كان قبلكم، شبرا شبرا وذراعا بذراع، حتى لو دخلوا جحر ضب تبعتموهم»، قلنا: يا رسول الله، اليهود والنصارى؟ قال: «فمن ثنا أحمد بن يونس، حدثنا ابن أبي ذئب، عن المقبري، عن أبي هريرة رضي الله عنه، عن النبي صلى الله عليه وءاله، قال: «§لا تقوم الساعة حتى تأخذ أمتي بأخذ القرون قبلها، شبرا بشبر وذراعا بذراع» - [ 103] -، فقيل: يا رسول الله، كفارس والروم؟ فقال: «ومن الناس إلا أولئك
don't forget that before 1947 jews were living in this aera too, jordan's expel jews in 1949 until israel free the land in 1967, and at this time, it was not question of palestine or palestinian people
@@philippesitbon9743 no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
Totally different. Lands in the West Bank, are by all parties agreed that it belongs to Palestinians. These settlement are illegal. Sheikh Jarrah is part of Jerusalem. Internationally, its recognised as no man's land. But Israel think all of it is theirs, Palestinians think half of it is.
@יואב דניאל no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
@@mohammadzaid1221I do not know, I do not think that there is a group of strangers who came from all parts of the earth to steal the lands of Myanmar and expel its inhabitants
@@amanjain4005 no I was talking about the military coup , the rohingya thing is like 4 years old no-one cares about it. I mean as Indians we both know how little our Twitter trends went for Myanmar people who are like our cousins but for Two middle eastern nations whose people are no way related to us , people went on a deathmatch .
Not Palestine, rather The Nation State of The Jewish People, Israel Not the West Bank,rather Judea and Samaria Not settlements, rather Jewish Communities Thank you, HaShem for returning your people Israel to its borders as you promised us.
The arrogance and vanity of some Israelis. They came as refugees, put their state where people lived and expelled them and now claim everyone lives in peace in the Westbank. Palestinians "had the same rights" as them, no conflict, good people. No words...
They all know it is immoral but can't bring themselves to accept it. Humans are weak and if you were offered an opportunity to live in land you consider this holy many would snatch at it. The few people who would give up the opportunity are truly selfless and have my absolute respect.
@dont talk rubbish why would it refer to me? Atheists have no reason to believe in an objective morality and cant prove it from atheism. Christians believe a man died for them. It doesn't take long to come accross incest or genocide in the old testament so jews are no different. Liberals, well look at today. There are people identifying as inanimate objects and changing their ethnicity through plastic surgery. Islam comes out on top. You're talking rubbish mate
Genesis 17:8, G-D gave the holly land to Abraham and his descendants. The descendants of Abraham are Isaac and Ishmael. Ishmael is the father of Arabs...so G-D gave the holly land to Arabs too, not only Hebrews.
@@roeeparienty7365 nobody cares . Your religion is just copied from Sumerian mythology. Like all abrahamic religions. You all believe myths, fables , and fairytales. You are not a “chosen people “ you are not special. You are like everyone else. Live together and stop being so full of yourselves. If religion is true and god has a “chosen people “ then that makes god racist. The Bible also says that the earth is flat. 100% a book of lies. Y’all need to stop these bs beliefs. Religion is hopefully going to die soon.
Aside from Hebron, no Palestinians ever had to leave their house because of a settlement. If you k ow the history of Hebron, 1929,then you will u derstand why this is an exemption. Thus, no settlement was ever build on la d, that belonged to a Palestinian person, Or was used as farmers land etc. There are some areas, which were sold from Arabs to jews before 1948. Also houses is east jerusalem, like sheikh. They legally belong to Jewish people, as they were bought. Their owners today live in Jordan, Have built them selfes a couple of houses from that money. If Palestinians would cooperate, and not attack, everything would be possible.
The Germans in the thirties also claimed that the Jewish people tried to wipe them out. In the light of that, was it immoral for them to live in their houses and on their land and harvest their "olives"?
There is no such thing as "settlements." There is no such thing as "West Bank." And there is no "occupation." These are all absurd made-up terms meant to set your opinion before you even got to think for yourself. What there are, are Jews and Arabs, in Judea, Samaria and elsewhere in Eretz Yisrael. There are Jewish towns in Judea, and there are Arab towns in Judea. What is this sick perversion of justice and morality, to ask "is it moral for Jews to live in Judea"? Can you imagine asking Frenchmen if it's moral for them to live in France? or any other people? These is antisemitic, and if you believe that, you are auto-antisemitic. Have you considered asking Arab Israelis if it's moral for them to live in Israel?? No, right?? Because Israeli Jews aren't bigoted supremacists who are opposed to the presence of others near them. Here are the questions which should be asked: Is it moral to label Jews' presence in their homeland 'illegal occupation?' Is it moral to obligate Israel to give up parts of its land that it gained in defensive war, back to the aggressors (which is the opposite of what international law says)? Is it moral to blame Jews in the fact that bigoted supremacists are offended by their presence? Is it moral to accuse Jews of being a barrier to peace instead of the other side's bigotry? Is it moral to exploit Jews' innocence and ignorance and make videos like these? Arabs who have a problem Jews live in Judea can get the f*** out of there. Those who don't are welcome to stay. This is the only correct opinion!!!
You are absolutely right - this is not logic - it’s First and foremost based on belief in G-d and His Torah . After that , we can discuss historical claims and war claims. But bottom line this is based on belief in G-ds promise in the Torah. This is the reason why initially many Torah observant Jews were angered by the reinstatement of the Land - because it was outwardly done for reasons other than the religious belief and Torah laws- Deep down it’s all based on belief in G-d and the promises in the Torah-and that’s why there’s nothing to argue about - plain and simple. You either belief or you don’t You either ridicule religion or your don’t
jews can live in Judea, as they did before , living in a peaceful coexistence with palestinians as they used to do in the past , until zionists mischaracterized and forcibly deteriorated previously peaceful relations.
@@h.f3544 Jews can live in Judea as long as they keep their numbers low and live under a Muslim ruler because it’s Muslim land. And how did it become Muslim land? A Muslim army conquered it! 🤣
@@h.f3544 "jews can live in Judea, as they did before" There is 2 millions arabs in Israel mainland and you are complaining for every jew living in Judean Mountains. You are fooling only yourself here.
The girl that stated Arabs are what? If she's claiming to be a jew, decendant of Isaac, Ishmael was his brother. With that said, Arabs are your genealogical brothers..., but then again I argue with own my blood brothers, but never to this extent.
The guy at 4:00 isn’t correct. Jews weren’t the majority but there were always a minority presence in the land. I don’t agree with the action of building settlements in the WB
@@allahuakbar3010 what's up with your comments? you keep repeating yourself, Zionism is not even a religious movement so that's not the reason Israel was established where it is.
Well, the person in the thumbnail of this video... ruclips.net/video/d9aQARe-Ftg/видео.html Says the settlements are like a cancer for Israel but he still lives there (at the time.) Apparently he’s a camel breeder which I thought too interesting not to mention.
Most settlers are religious so it's natural they speak of god and the bible, I'm not sure why all the surprised comments. I'm Israeli and not religious at all, I would never live in the West Bank.
@@Adler2935 Is it a fact that settlers have to kill Palestinians or forcibly remove them from their homes in order to live in the WB? I hear a lot of complaints about how the Israelis keep _building more settlements_ so why are they bothering to build settlements when they’re kicking Palestinians out of where they live? Why not just live in _those_ houses?
Ok, I'm halfway in. One question. How can you return to a land/property that WAS yours & then reclaim it? If someone here was honest & said/says "look, it's a war,ok?... and we're winning", then I would understand this ( not agree, understand ).
@Pablo Diablo There has been a continuous Jewish presence in Israel since the end of the last Jewish-Roman war in 135 CE. The Jewish Zinati family, from the village of Peki'in, trace their unbroken presence in the land from the end of the last Jewish Commonwealth -- that is, nearly 2, 000 years ago! No Arab family can make this claim. Here, see: ruclips.net/video/9Gkm7DOTa7Y/видео.html
they literally wanted to make a jewish state on top of an already existing nation and people, do you know how outrageous that sounds, you can’t call this a two sided war, it’s an oppressive colonization with resistance, today’s israel has no history it’s just a colonization. the kingdom of israel form 5000 years ago is literally palestine, the citizens just converted form judaism to islam, fuck these lies
that’s not fair, they don’t give the Palestinians an Israeli citizenship after the occupation, nor do they acknowledge Palestine as a country, I mean choose one , this is just cruel and inhumane
@Larry T no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
@@allahuakbar3010 and Hamas spends donation money on weapons instead of rehabilitating Gaza. The world is filled with shit heads on every side buddy, deal with it and stop pointing fingers, pointing fingers dont solve nottin.
It's immoral to pontificate and threaten - using the moral leverage (on behalf of a mob of assassins) - the People from Israel from living in the very heart of Medinat israel which is Samaria and Judea. Jews in Judea and Arabs in Arabia. This is the only reasonable recipe for peace, other than a decisive victory for Israel in the next total war launched by the Arabs. Whoever wants to live in Israel in Peace, can do that, of course, no matter which is his/her creed. Israel guarantees freedom of religion to everybody, and freedom of language and costumes. Ten major religions are currently present and totally free to practice in israel. Terrorist on the contrary, are not. Shalom.
It be like the African American's deciding that S Africa is their ancestors homeland and using that notion to force all the white ppl off of their land. And then to make it even crazier, to say that some god promised them that land. The whole thing sounds so silly to an educated atheist.
Most of these answers are incredibly depressing. The young man on the train is the exception. The others come across as thoughtless, self righteous and ignorant. No introspection, no self doubt, no questioning. No attempt to see things from the Palestinian point of view.
Hi I really love all your videos and I have questions im really interested to hear the answers to I would really appreciate it if you would want to use them in your future projects! Question to Palestinians: if you could go back in time to 1948 would you prefer to agree to Partition plan and Establish a country in the lands the UN gave you? Or would you still prefer to go to a war so all the land will be yours? For the Arab Israelis who served/serving in the IDF: what your family and your friends think about you serving in the IDF? Are there was sometimes problems with it? Are you feel equally to the Jews who serving with you?
The palestinians just wanted their own state so they would not have to live under Jewish law. The didn't want to have all the land to themselves. The Palestinians and the Arabs had been living side by side for thousands of yrs in that land. Many were friends. And many still are today. But there are these far right Israeli's who are racist against and believe they're superior to their Palestinian neighbors. They are the one's who want all of jerusalem and many outposts along the West bank to belong to Isreal. They are the one's causing trouble.
@@gerri577 but they could had a state in 48 they rejected the partition plan while Israel agreed that's why started the war can you tell me what was the reason they rejected it? Honestly asking... And by the way there are always people who will be racist and far right kind of people in both sides both in Israel and in Palestine but there will always be people who would want peace and accept the difference. It all about education, as an Israeli I know that in secular schools they really try to teach about accepting the difference that everyone is the same and that peace is something possible. But the religion schools education is really different so I don't know what they learn there... I would just say there are more than 100 organizations in Israel today that try to promote peace between Jews and Arabs so there are a lot of people who do really try to change our point of view of each other.
i have a better idea : WE BURN ALL RELIGIOUS TEXTS FOR EVER AND EVER AND EVER that includes ALL of them : hindi, muslim, christian, tibetean the whole bloody lot must go now ! We have near death experiencers now who we should be examining and stop all the ancient bullshit ideology which are ALL AND SUNDERS CULTS !! ALL OF THEM NO EXCEPTION! I searched this for over 20 yrs now and that is my conclusion. All these texts were written by MEN who sought to DOMINATE ! They all established slavery, caste systems and brutal suppression ALL OF THEM no exception with Buddha maybe the worst of all with his non acceptance of soul . disgusting old texts.
the "Palestinians", as Arabs, have 349857239045793472394 other Arab or Arab-friendly countries they can go to including the United States. The Jews have ONE country.
The Zionists are carving an Arab Hitler with their own hands. Like the statue of David sculpted by Michelangelo Good job, all to appease Anglicans in the West
If ive learned anything its that both sides dont want this to end. They will fight forever over land. However one side has big guns and healthcare sponsored by the largest military in the world, whose own citizens dont have healthcare.
I'm not a Palestinian but that's an easy question .. a nation state as we know it now is a relatively new construct that colonial powers introduced so I could easily say there was no Israel either .. But anyways there were most features of an organized state before 1948 like infrastructure, universities, railways etc... It wasn't all desert and shit More importantly, there were people too lol .. But lets say there was no state .. does this give Israel the right or make it moral/ethical to displace people and ethnically cleanse them from a land/houses they lived on for centuries (The Nakba) ?? .. Also was it ever moral to ethnically cleanse the native Americans given they had no state either !!?
Why do Lebanese think lebanon is their land when there was never an independent state called lebanon before 1950 ? Because they are people who always lived there and farmed there lands despite who is ruling them lebanon and syria are new states but syrians and Lebanese and palestinians are not new people they are the natives who deserve to have self determination in their own lands they have always lived in
"If it is not tempered by compassion, and empathy, reason can lead men and women into a moral void.” [Karen Armstrong,Twelve Steps to a Compassionate Life]
@@Linda43 The league of nations was abolished. The British transferred the whole issue of Palestine to the United Nations in 1947, even before ending their mandate.
@@mohamedmostafa1375 The British didn't create the Mandate or its stipulations. It just enforced them. The UN has never canceled the stipulations of the Mandate. It just has chosen to ignore it for political reasons. My original post still stands.
@@Linda43 All the UN resolutions regarding to the Arab Israeli conflict have practically changed the mandatory charter of the British. There is already a different situation.
it was also legal once i purchase a human being and put them to labor until their die. just because something is legal does NOT mean it is right or ethical. In this case, the expulsion and ethnic cleansing is BOTH ILLEGAL AND UNETHICAL
Bullshit.. palestinian never had an army.. while jews before 1948 already got their own air force.. how come palestinjan that living inside by the sea declared a war at the borders??
She literally said “how many Jewish homes were taken by Germany”. So she’s basically saying if hitler did it to us why can’t we do it to the Palestinians.
Hypocrites
The Palestinians helped the Germans this is justice
@@asher8754 how?
@@asher8754 i wish we did..
@Cease AndDesist how is that remotely relevant in generalizing all of Palestinians during that time? So a mufti that was politically motivated to prevent the extermination of Palestinians in their homeland is all of a sudden in the only source you apply. But I guess you forgot or Israel doesn’t teach this; what about the thousands of Palestinians who opened their homes (literally) to take care of Jewish refugees? So many older Palestinians that were born before the establishment of Israel always talk about how they would feed, cloth and shelter Jewish refugees and that the Muslim, Christian and Jewish population all lived together side by side. Of course no one wants to talk about those Palestinians. You guys only want to talk about the Palestinians who were brave enough to fight back the illegal colonial ethic cleansing of their people and homeland. Palestinians opened up their homes to Jews and has no issues living side by side with Jews. Generally, Palestinians began conflicting once the Jews that moved to Israel violently and forcefully evicted 1million Palestinians out of their homes and murdered and raped tens of thousands of innocent Palestinians including elderly, children, pregnant women. That is when the Palestinians began “hating” Israelis. So our mufti that was so happy to work with the nazis did substantially less damage to your population than your whole apartheid state that was built on the ethnic cleansing and murder of innocent indigenous Palestinians and illegal colonial settlements and land you claim belongs to you while you quote history books like the Bible. Regardless of the history, it is irrelevant and should not a dictate weather an indigenous group of people; for over 2000 years should be expelled or not. This view is widely accepted among numerous respected historians and intellectuals. This conflict is insanely complex and there is an infinite amount of factors that play a role into not only the understanding of the conflict but the solution to peace.
people often give corey shit for being aggressive with palestinians but he was just as forward with the jews in this episode
Yeah, I think he is leveled.
lol he is so soft with the palestinians
He is getting better. His older content was a bit more bias towards Palestinians. I think he’s taken the viewer feedback well and working on his content.
He’s pretty fair. This channel is pretty good.
@iamshweta96 I am bias as well... i am israeli... but in the end of the day hes doin very important job!
When was the last time a thief admitted she was a thief ?
The Land belongs to the Jewish People.
@Kat Ballou you’re just proving this comments point 😂 you would never admit you stole anything
@@Nadine8730
Harvard-trained historian Howard M. Sachar writes that from 1922-1946, 100,000 Arabs entered the country from the surrounding lands. Winston Churchill added that, "[d]espite the fact that they were never persecuted, masses of Arabs poured into the country and multiplied until the Arab population grew more than what all of world Jewry could add to the Jewish population."
Creating a 22nd Arab State out of a lone Israel is an injustice. Carving a 45th Muslim country at the expense of the sole Jewish nation in the world is a crime!
*GOD PROMISED*
me a car in bible so now I am gonna steal it
@@geozap4518 lies lies lies I’m not going to waste my time arguing with zionists
When you say it wasn't theirs make sure to give back America to real Americans as well as Australia
@יואב דניאל fighting is just?
@@AsterixObelixNL According to zionists it is. But when u question their violence they will point at their commandments which says something different :D It is unbelievable that people can defend them. All their answers makes 0 sense and deep inside they know it. They simply dont care and are racist af.
@@AsterixObelixNL no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HISalvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to mIake atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
@@boatengineer6275 They are racist people.
@יואב דניאל war and conquering is not moral. God will make sure you reap what you sow.
I believe God gave me the wealth and money of all my neighbors, now I am going to take it from them by force to prove my godly point. Brilliant.
Google "isla mic conquest of MENA"
@@dogbert52 Yes, history happened, what is your point?
@@JonathanMartin884 just ignore the parts that are uncomfotable. Be a good jihad supporter.
@@dogbert52 So, instead I should support occupation? Great comeback.
@@JonathanMartin884 keep supporting isis hizbulla iran etc. Very progressive virtue signal.
“It’s just ours” or “our bible says it’s ours”.
Do they understand how reductive and immature that sounds? If a Palestinian says the same thing are you not just as bad as they are? Why should I believe you and not him?
They also seem to get way more offended by questions than the arabs which is weird.
It is interesting how the settlers blame Israeli policies as much as Palestinian though.
You think God promise is reductive and immature?? Sorry dude, we're believers. And God did promise Israel to the people of Israel. Palestinians can't say the same because even in their OWN Quran, their God didn't promise Israel to them.
Actually some will say that in their Quran, the people of Israel and their right on the land are mentioned there.
Since the bible is God words, We can totally rely on it.
And Israel policy and government is garbage. Wish we could have changed it. Palestinians tho, are not to blame because of our leaders stupidity.
@@hanna319 Yes I do. It’s your book not mine.
I say god doesn’t exist, if he doesn’t exist how can he give you land?
Don’t try to use religion to justify bad behaviour.
@@reubenmcmurray4377 I don't justify any behaviour based on the bible. I justify the Jewish RIGHT on Israel.
Whether YOU believe in God or not is irrelevant, Jews and Muslims believe in their books and they are the ones who live there, and whether you like it or not, many of them are religious people who believe in God.
forcing your disbelief on the people, won't solve the conflict.
But why not, go ahead and force your policy on Israel, you can't tell the Palestinians what to do, because we both know they hate the west and will never listen to you , only we, Jews are stupid enough to try and try again.
And as you probably know, Israel is not a religious country. So they don't base their right on Israel based on their bible. So you cab calm down
Even without God's promise, the bible talks about Judea and Israel kingdoms, and these are facts no one is even arguing about
@@reubenmcmurray4377 thank you great white westerner for scolding the poor natives on the quality of their arguments when asked a silly question. You are totally not a condescending sc hmuck.
There's some real shamelessness going on here.
Shameless is everyone writing in the questions, especially the US since the US is all stolen land.
Even Israel's own Supreme Court (let alone the International community ) regards the occupation as illegal.
Labour member of parliament, Yossi Sarid, expressed concern: 'Resistance breeds repression, which strengthens resistance, thus unleashing more repression, and one day we Israelis will look at ourselves in the mirror and be unable to bear the cruel and repulsive image reflected in it. We want not only to liberate Palestinlians from military domination but also to liberate ourselves from its
effects."
So you will abide and support all of the israeli supreme court desicions? Cool.
No they don’t the court has only ever rules on specific land claims if it had ruled against settlements period there would be no settlements you mouth breather
@@dogbert52
His point went over your head like a fresbee.
Nice quote at least someone there who can actually still think and self reflect.
The Israeli supreme court actually decided that there is no problem with that, but think whatever you want
When in germamy take jew home this is immoral ...but when jew settlers take palestinian home this not immoral!!!
Who is crazy?
They doesnt take home of palestinians they build their own homes in palestine
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ seriously man? Go google your friend Yaacob the Zionist thief living in Shiekh Jarrah. He’s world famous
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ they took the homes in West Banks. Illegal Jewish settlers
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ how come they dont mention that the nazis and jihadis were and are allies.
@@dogbert52 so were Zionists
There are Jews that say these Israelis are misinterpreting the Torah and shouldn’t be stealing the land.
How is going back to your land stealing it ?
@@oolooo history is replete. And thousands of years with dozens of generations changing over a land does not give you right to it by showing up one day and killing those living on it so you can occupy it. This is like an American Indian or Mexican walking into a house in Texas and dragging the home owner out into the street and killing him for their home. Is that legal?? Is that moral? That’s savagery. There was a time in history for savagery. Are you saying these occupiers are alone allowed to exercise savagery with impunity? Society has a way of dealing with those that don’t obey common law.
@Eti Camaroff The Almighty expelled the people for their disobedience and evil ways (sound familiar?) and cast them out into the diaspora. Never to return. Even practicing Jews indicate as much and are against Zionism. International Law does not require sovereignty in the absence of it it will recognize the presence of indigenous people and respect their rights. Sounds fair right? It is because it was written in sight of all the abuses carried out against such peoples throughout history.
@@WorldReserveCurrency the Torah is very clear that strangers will build the ancient Israelite’s walls. And that Magog will invade the land of Israel and loot & spoil peaceful farmers who are inhabiting the land (also not native but still dwelling there). The Torah also describes what it will be like when the Israelites return to the land- it will be peace flowing like a river and no wars happening, lions laying with lambs etc and it lists the nations from which the Israelites will come from. None of which are in Europe.
_"There are Jews that say these Israelis are misinterpreting the Torah'_
Who? Name them or shut the F* up!!!
Kudos to Corey for having the courage to ask thorny questions in a land of conflict. I think too many people take it for granted, not contributing in any way but harshly criticizing his style. I find that attitude extremely shameless.
@@Batman12-f9u When was palestine ever a free independet land?
@@Batman12-f9u british mandate. Educate urself
@@dogbert52 British Mandate of Palestine, not Israel. Just because it was under occupation doesn't mean it didn't exist. Educate yourself.
@@ammaryasser90 ah. So you know about the lie of "palestine the independent state" . Good.
@@dogbert52 Where's the lie in saying it is an independent, occupied state?
It's like some of the settlers learn to Prepare made up reasonings for themselves as they grow older, cause the younger one's reasonings are basically meaningless!!
Would any reason make jihadis less likely to st ab je wish babies?
@@dogbert52 You just proved his point.
@@dogbert52 Seriously, that's some dumb shit right there
@@rxtr664 no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
@@jasonkemmerer5654 Lol, whatever, dude
They are trying hard to convince themselves,
For their actions.
Tatakae Tatakae
Fight fight
Freedom for Palestine 🇵🇸
Justice will be achieved at the end, and Palestine will be free🇵🇸
Palestine is a fake country
This is one of the best Corey videos dude. He was asking questions in a pressing way and did not back down. And actually confronted the Israeli settlers.
yess
and not just assume stuff about them without ever even seeing their face
أكثر ما يهدد الإسرائيليين هي هذه الجملة :
خرجنا قبل 2000 سنة لدينا حق العودة.
خرجوا قبل 80 سنة ليس لهم حق العودة..
@@abouzrawmd 100% 👍👍👍
Make a t-shirt saying “Lama Lō?”
@@jeunesseeternelle9803 למה לא?
Yes, please do! I'd buy that in an instant :D
German stealing land is immoral but
doing same to Paletinians is okay even when they are against International Law
CZ WE ARE PROMISED THE LAND BY TORAH
i got it
Also 08:10
> they started 6 day war
LOL
if you attack a country and lose, dont cry when you lose land
Judea is the land of the Jews. Another false equivalence from your side, this is all you can provide anyway.
@Eti Camaroff > had its tanks on Israel's border
So what? That's still Egypt's territory.
> just because someone strikes first doesn't mean that side started the war
LOL, that's literally what it means to start a war.
Between 1st April 1948 to 14th May 1948 and before any Arab soldier had even set foot into Palestine. Zionist militias had already taken over 220 towns through over 90 violent massacres. During that time the Arabs had officially declared war on the Zionists, the Zionists’ violent methods of ethnic cleansing were already largely underway. You can’t claim it was a ‘counterattack’ when you were the aggressors who initiated the violence when over 65 thousand armed Zionist soldiers attacked 2.5 thousand unarmed Palestinian farmers and villagers, way before the Arabs had declared war. What did you expect, your brutal methods of ethnic cleansing would go unnoticed?
It doesn't make any sense to claim my ancestors or people of my nation lived there 2 or 3 thousands years ago so now this land belongs to me and my nation. This stupidity has to end. Are we people with conscience?
It wasn't only the Arabs who had a desire to conquer other lands but literally every powerful empire (Roman Empire Normans, British just a name few). But taking away a country by claiming my ancestors lived there some thousands years ago is just absurd
@יואב דניאל I understand that Jews were not safe in most places other than like Morrocco and Iran, but don't you think the way Israel settled into those lands was inhumane and immoral? Obviously there is much more to the conflict, as Iran and the U.S. are also at conflict in a way. But as an iranian who hates the regime and even some arabs, including palestinians, because some view us negatively, objectively even with my prejudices I still view the situation as unfair and disgusting tbh.
Exactly. everyone’s house or the area where we live was once inhabited by other people. Does that make it right for their descendants to come and tell us : get out of my house, my ancestors used to live here 3000 thousand years ago. Does that make it right for them to ethnically cleanse and displace millions of Palestinians just because they inhabited that land 3000 year ago ?
The zionist plan for the Middle East or so-called Greater Israel includes The annexation of Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Egypt, Lebanon and Syria. So their god promised them 7 lands 🤣🤣
They want to displace over 200 Million people so that they could feel satisfied, how greedy and cruel.
Actually at minute 7, that is Gush Etzion, owned by jews before 1948
@@zuhriddinnishonov6867 Palestine is a made up word by the Romans it was a never a country that's a fact of history Jews on the other hand did have Kingdoms in Israel. Jews have consistently inhabited Israel since 1601 B.C.E. It's ok to drive a good chunk of their population out of their homeland but when the people who drove them out get driven out all of a sudden there's a problem? Your comment is absurd.
"No one is going anywhere, we are all stuck here. We must find a way to live together ".
@Eti Camaroff spoken like a true land stealing zionist.camaroff you should look into where you come from really because it's not where you're at now.You come from the east,unwanted gypsies. You have not a drop of real ethnic Jewish blood as in the ones from the Old Testament.Rev.2:9 3:9 prophesized your kind long ago.
@@maximusdecimusmeridius5500 shut up you idiot. Jews are indigenous to the land, DNA proves it. Israel , the largest homecoming of an exiled indigenous population back to their homeland in history. Biblical prophecy said Israel would be reborn as a nation in one day!!!! It happened !!!
@@maximusdecimusmeridius5500 Spoken like an ignorant jealous clown going nowhere in life!
@@muhammadisdeadjesusisrisen4216 you obviously didn't get to the last of the New Testament?? But I see in your name that you are a believer in Jesus Christ so I do not want to argue with a brother in Christ.Synagogue of Shatan as Revelation 2:9&3:9 tells us.
@@muhammadisdeadjesusisrisen4216 Do You Believe In Christ or the fake scientistism that has perpetuated so many lies contrary to what scripture tells us.?
Why do they believe "God gave the land ( of Palestine) to the Jewish people" and seek to deny the Palestinian claims but no other ethnic people in the world make similar claims. The pope doesn't say God gave the Christians Rome, Vishna does not say "God gave India to the Indians" . The most they can say is historically as an ethnic group or civilisation that they had lived in this area for an extended duration and have an affiliation or identification with the region , just like the Italian people have a greater affiliation to Italy than the French.But to claim the land was given to them by God is a bit of an (unprovable) stretch.
Actually, very few Israelis say that. Mostly the religious settlers say HaShem gave them the land.
God is a matter of belief.
For me it's just the land of our ancestors that was stolen from us and we took it back.
Simple as that.
Even the othman turks which occupied it never called it "balastin". Only the brits . 1917 till 1947. 30 years.
@@dogbert52 The ancient Greeks and Romans called it Palestine. Palestine is a Greek name. Isn't it odd that Arabs from Yemen, Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Mecca and Medina came to Israel and decided that they want to be named after the Greek islanders, who came to the Levant from Crete.
You cannot debate with these people. They are no different than the kkk. They want and right-wing Fascist Ethno State for Jewish people only. Zionism is not only Rascist its Fascistic too.
So by the people's logic in this video, all mankind possess the right to claim a land in Africa because our ancestors once lived in there then had migrated all over the world. Thus it is totally moral to kick a Kenyan farmer out of his land and settle down.
Whats wrong with jews live in palestine there are 2 milion palestinians live in israel and no body have problem with that. Think again what is closer to aparthide
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ you forgot that there is 3.5 million living under occupation and 2 million living in an open air prison
@Shayne Meidle so what do you remember about Exodus or Babylon? Do Jewish people make up a different human kind? Is that what you are claiming? Because you saying ''The Jewish people have the birth and history of their people all in Israel'' makes me think they are not Homo-Sapiens and started to evolve somewhere near Jerusalem.
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ You know the comment I made has nothing to do with the fact that the two communities live together. It is about some settlers justifying forced eviction of Palestinians out of their properties. They are trying to reason their settlement based on the chapters about promised lands in Torah but theproblem is the rest of the world doesn't believe what you believe and when they oppose it, some of you regard it as apartheid. A little emphaty please.
@Shayne Meidle I didn't claim otherwise and do accept Jewish people are one of the ancient nations of the region. The problem begins when you talk as if the revelations in Torah are absolute and the whole world (non-Jewish) should accept them as constitution. Do you want UN to take Torah as guide to resolve the conflict and allocate all Canaan land among Jews in accordance with Jewish doctrine? Speaking of cultures, who gives the authority to decide which culture is superior over the other? Okay assume that Arab culture is not as ''great important'' as Jewish culture. Does that give some settlers the right to steal properties of other ''not great and unimportant'' ethnic groups. These pretty much reminds me of Aryan race theory that Nazis used slaughtering Jews. Guess what, at the end it didn't work out great for everybody.
Its not only immoral against Palestine its immoral against nature and wild life just look how did they build settlements on mountain's you can feel their shame when they r talking and trying to make sense to be there.
@shani isreal what does it means take the land of Jews? Why it should be to jews? And if you really read the history away from bible, you will realize that most of Palestinian were Jews before Christianity and Islam... At the end It's not anyone land and you don't deserve to be there more than Palestinian and it doesn't make any sense to keep those immoral activities against nature.
@@sweetapple7455 its immoral against the galaxy! How dare the decolonize their land???
@shani isreal what does it mean Judah 3500 years ago? Don't tell me you are saying that u are same? 😝 neither it was exist or not you can't claim this and as I know some of Israelis who started to move there after Zionists ideology weren't even Jews, otherwise most of Palestinian started to follow Jesus and some started to change their religion after the Islamic occupation to avoid paying Jizziah or Oppression by Islamists and some of them stayed Jews till this Day. Bro most of you even Black Africans? Or Blonde People? What does it relates to Middle east? or Palestine
@@dogbert52
Just imagine yourself living near a lake and someday you wake-up then you find it disappeared, or Just Imagine yourself as Animal and someday you find a settlements instead of your place.. Then u move to another place until u don't find where to go, bro you are the most criminals people I ever seen in my life, You oppressive others, taking their homes, attacks Nature, destroying builds, killing kids, insulting others, I don't understand what sick of ideology do you have, u are doing all this by the God name since Bible creation but there is no god who accept all those barbaric activities against humanity..
@@sweetapple7455 just imagine a hoard of ar abs coming from arabia and claiming israel is their land. Imagine that.
The amount of denial with this nation is astounding.
There is no such thing as "settlements."
There is no such thing as "West Bank."
And there is no "occupation."
These are all absurd made-up terms meant to set your opinion before you even got to think for yourself.
What there are, are Jews and Arabs, in Judea, Samaria and elsewhere in Eretz Yisrael. There are Jewish towns in Judea, and there are Arab towns in Judea.
What is this sick perversion of justice and morality, to ask "is it moral for Jews to live in Judea"? Can you imagine asking Frenchmen if it's moral for them to live in France? or any other people? These is antisemitic, and if you believe that, you are auto-antisemitic.
Have you considered asking Arab Israelis if it's moral for them to live in Israel?? No, right?? Because Israeli Jews aren't bigoted supremacists who are opposed to the presence of others near them.
Here are the questions which should be asked:
Is it moral to label Jews' presence in their homeland 'illegal occupation?'
Is it moral to obligate Israel to give up parts of its land that it gained in defensive war, back to the aggressors (which is the opposite of what international law says)?
Is it moral to blame Jews in the fact that bigoted supremacists are offended by their presence?
Is it moral to accuse Jews of being a barrier to peace instead of the other side's bigotry?
Is it moral to exploit Jews' innocence and ignorance and make videos like these?
Arabs who have a problem Jews live in Judea can get the f*** out of there. Those who don't are welcome to stay. This is the only correct opinion!!!
@@ok1634 The Israelis aren't supremacists?? 😂😂 Nice joke.
@@ok1634 All Jews are native to Judea? 😂🤣😂 Have you ever heard of conversions?
@@yacobyourfriendlyneighbor228 Ask other minorities than yours in Israel, they'll all concur Jews are very welcoming.
Now guess where the problem is stemming from :)
@@yacobyourfriendlyneighbor228 "Have you ever heard of conversions?"
Conversions are exceptional amongst Jews, don't confuse with islam where ALL are converted.
I’m relatively good at reading people’s body language, but even Stevie Wonder can see that these people know what they are doing is wrong just by their nervous disposition and by trying to waffle their excuses out
They also don’t care.
Exactly.
So shame
Absolutely,they know they are wrong
1st one was a former Olympic mental gymnast.
So funny!
@Leon Damour they didn't learn from history. They took advantage of it
*realizes her similar ideology to nazis*
"Talking about this makes me angry"
“Israeli”: the land is ours we had it 3000 years ago, our bible said this.
“Israeli” also: War that expelled Palestinians is since 1948, long time ago they have to move forward...
@Shayne Meidle they were expelled. They were attacked by the zionist militias supported by the British. They were defending their lands. You are the ones who came from Europe and other countries to build a country on their lands.
@Shayne Meidle 68%?? Can you mention your resources that give these numbers?
Anyways what is your point? If the “israel” story is correct, jews also left the land thousands of years ago, what gives them more right than Palestinians to come back to the land? Shouldn’t they move on also?
@Shayne Meidle steal the thunder? What you call israel stole a complete land. Anyways, we both no this will never end.
Whats wrong with jews living in palestin?e there are 2 milion palestinians living in israel and no body has problem with that.
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ Jews living in Palestine are there to stop the country from existing on the 1967 borders. If they would live under Palestinian Authority it’s not wrong.
Btw there are 2 million Palestinians living in occupied Palestine. They live their before your grandparents came from Poland.
0:55: "how many Jewish homes were taken by the Germans?" You act also like the Nazis. Thanks for the trues....
You shut the fuck up jews settelers in istael dont take homes of palestinians they build they own homes in palestine
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ "You shut the fuck up" The real face of the Zionists. Aggressive land robbers. I don't argue with that. below my level
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ yep build their own homes... right ontop of the rubble of Palestinian homes they demolish
@@הדוקטור-צ2מ Yeah they do. They evict Palestinians from their homes and make them homeless. I mean this stuff is happening right now.
@@Slovenčia1000 your user name indicates that you are a massive fan boy of jihado nazism .
At some Point The Mongols were spread trough all of the Russian territory can they claim this land theirs now ?
Of course no, Russians claimed that land already.
Similarly Israelis have claimed the current land of Israel in fair wars, which includes the West Bank. The arab aggressor countries lost those lands to Israel. They gifted Sinai to Egypt and Gaza strip to "palestinians" ie. egyptian arabs who were living in that area, and expelled all the jewish settlers from there. The gaza egyptians thanked them with Hamas and rockets.
no because they invaded that land its not their home, their home is mongolia. and jews' original home is judea
@@fordmustnagisbestcarath5046 The Hebrews themselves invaded Canaan back then and established a kingdom which didn't last very long and they were never alone on that land, so it's not their home then according to your logic
@@ronaldraygun3386 So you don't accept international law?
@@abdulhaqq7559 didnt last very long? they were still here in the 4th century
The one guy overtly states he wants to “encourage” Palestinian emigration. How sad. Truly morally sickening. Yet we give them BILLIONS in cash every year to a wealthy developed nation. It is apartheid.
Does any people who have some rusty coins in another country have the right to go there and kick out the natives ? Does the modern world accept that logic?
@Shani Israel
The Romans left in Palestine more archeological remains than you. So, let the Italian people come and settle too in Palestine. Why not? This logic opens the door to everyone to claim another people's country.
I have a 2000 year old Roman Coin from Palestine. It’s my land title that trumps the fairy tales in the Bible.
@@chugalongway01
Oh, man, you thus have a great justification to build a settlement in Palestine. That's enough to kick the natives out of their homes, in which they lived for centuries, and don't care at all about the international law, because the only law which is recognized there is the law of the jungle.
@יואב דניאל
Before Judah there were the ancient Egyptians.
@@tl8231
Ah, when the logic fails, the military card starts to speak.
Yakub disliked this video.
"if i don't steal your house , someone else is gonna steal it " Jacob the Brooklyn jew Mai 2021
Replying to the 2nd man who said that we bought the lands , fool someone else buddy
Living proof with a the deed in hand NO ONE paid us for the land that was seized.
he’s from Long Island!
If I will become jew, my question is, should I go there and claim that god promised this land to us,
Do you think israelis will accept my reasoning and lete live there?
@Kat Ballou I guess you didn't get my point of view, . It's so sad that you're the one don't think first 🤣
@@reskie0009 lol what do u expect from a people they are believing that they are chosen by god above 7.9 billions human.
@@princeadeel6256 strangly thats exactly what the koran calls ar ab muzl imz . Chosen. Lol
A BANGLADESHi not practicing Muslim and his father get the citizenship in Israel they claim they convert themselves to Jew
@@dogbert52 well Qur'an don't say you have higher authority then a non-Muslim it's more like Torah non-Jews don't count as humans
I love how each side has a “script” they fall into. “It was never theirs”. Then when it conflicts like well they were here when we came. The computer melts down.
question for israelis: Why do israelis put their religion first and humanity second? why is inhumane treatment being justified by religion?
@יואב דניאל you religion has humanity. you who practice it don't have any and therfore you corrupted your religion and god doesn't even like you
@יואב דניאל ok occupier, your religion tells you to walk around carrying machine guns intimidating little children and make people walk through checkpoints 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 wake up from your fantasy
@יואב דניאל this is an example of how jihadonazis see all non jihadis as subhumans.
@@Desfleeding exactly👏👏
many people will chose to be ignorant to the moral implications of their actions because if they were not ignorant they would have to face the consequences of their actions and that would be to hard for them. nothing in life is black and white! some settlements can be immoral. lets not pretend like some of the settlements arent hurting Palestinians. all you must do is listen to their stories and see how many of them live. we must not cause harm to any person blindly. if Israel wants to succeed as a country it needs to see the ways in which Palestinians are being hurt by some of the ways the government is carrying things out. no one should expect Palestinians to be nonviolent and peaceful when everyone refuses to accept that they are largely suffering under occupation.
Imaginary landlord in the sky gave it to us.
No need to watch the video really.
if someone feels unable to answer will say simply i am not a political
This colonizers if they apololitical then they're lying bc their wholes lives are based on politics
The last woman got it: if people attack you in a war, and you push them back then the conquered territories are yours. It makes sense.
When I read western everyday news about Palestinian conflict, they always say, it's complicated. So I always just assumed, both sides commit war crimes or something. But now when I have read Arabic sources, or human rights associations sources, it's not complicated at all. Israeli government commits crimes against humanity towards Palestinians. Sure, individual Jews living in Israel don't have anything to do with it, they are not responsible. But what Israeli government does is pure and simply ethnic cleansing, it is not complicated at all. Why is this not in western everyday news?
*GOD PROMISED*
me a car in bible so now I am gonna steal it
*"If I don't steal your house then someone else will"*
Yaqub an Israeli Settler from NEW YORK USA
You read western news. Then you read Arabic sources. What about Jewish/Israeli sources?
Also, if the Israeli government is "purely and simply" ethnic cleansing, then how come the Palestinian population just keeps on growing?
I do appreciate that you understand we individuals living in Israel don't have anything to do with it, I really do. Not just anyone does that. But this "ethnic cleansing" and "not complicated at all" claims are complete and utter lies - It IS complicated, and the Palestinian side commits far more war crimes than the Israeli government. Example: Hamas DELIBERATELY targets civilians with rockets, whereas Israel targets Hamas facilities and equipment that they deliberately hide among civilians. Thus, any civilian casualty is on Hamas' hands, not Israel's. The examples are endless, but hopefully you get the idea. Listen to the Israeli side as well, not just the Arabic sources; only then you'll be able to construct a rational, unbiased opinion, based facts, numbers, and statistics.
In 1947/1948 85% of Palestinians were ethnically cleansed from the land that became Israel. Until today they live in refugee camps. The Israeli law forbids them from going back home. The Israeli government confiscated their land and properties.
The ethnic cleansing continues today using Israeli law to ethnically cleanse Palestinians from the land Israel conquered in 1967.
@@RonDozy *For Jewish Israel Sources*
You need to go back to West a land where most settlers like Yakov came from
It amazes me how these people just blindly justify ethnic cleansing with statements so profoundly incorrect so thoughtless so evil without a prang from their conscience... other wise loving people some off them.( All though I know question this)
The Jewish people must crave out a place in their heart for the appressed people of Palestine.
What your doing to them is not unlike what Nazi Germany did to your grand parents.
You ultimately will destroy yourselves you have lost your humanity.
What the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians is *very* much unlike what the Nazis did to the Jews and you do their cause no service to make such a hyperbolic comparison.
@Shani Israel I love you, Shani. You’re awesome.
@Shani Israel
Palestine is a place.
It's on the map.
You could have a Palestine Passport.
People have lived their for thousands of years family's mothers fathers children.
Your pathetic little history listen will not save you from what we all know to be true Ethnic cleansing of the people of Palestine. See they exist you cant change that, yet you hide behind it's ours as you murder, imprison, maim, and steal the homes of these brave people Your nothing more than gutless cowards.
@Shani Israel Your wee history lesson is a fabrication it's made up and meanless as a growing number of us around the world know
@@edwinlucianofrias1643
Slower moving, but no. What is Gazi other than the Warsaw Getto people gunned down murdered man women and children trapped zero rights of their own you people have lost your minds.
It takes the strongest people to admit their wrong doings , But the voice of peace must the loudest
*GOD PROMISED*
me a car in bible so now I am gonna steal it
Israel captured the westbank in a defensive war from Jordan.
If Israel want to annex the land and be part of Israel,it's up to them.
so what's wrong if israelis want to move there? it's theirs already.
If you stated a war,but you lost and loose your land,don't complain nor demand to give it back.it's your fault.
That's a poor logic to justify what cannot be justified.
"So what's wrong..." what's wrong is that contradicts the international law and the UN resolutions. Are you one of those who don't care about the international law. If so, then every country can do whatever it wants and the world would be a big zoo.
@יואב דניאל
I think most of the Palestinians can be satisfied with a state on 67 borders. But The problem is that most people in the other side see the West Bank as part of their territories, and that's why peace is still difficult to be attained.
Palestinian inside the land.. the war with the "neighbours" were at the border.. they dont started the war.. they were massacred, and ethnic cleansed from the start
Long live palestine Jerusalem 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🙏
They are so brainwashed and living in denial it’s just sad at this point.
It is truly staggering how insane some of these people are and to what lengths they go to twist the words to fit their narrative.
The woman @ 7:20, insane!
You can say the same for both sides, imo the pro palestinian sides are crazier saying they want to kill all jews and shit.
@@wngdhssr Except one side lives under an illegal and brutal military occupation!
Look up Eran Efrati's interviews on the subject.
@@300ZCorradoVR6Z would it matter what they said? Would any word or fact make you any less genocidally antisemitic?
@@dogbert52 Typical response from someone who denies their existence and who clearly doesn't understand what a semite actually means!
@shani isreal How mature of you!
6:31 Pakistanis are NOT Arabs, they use the Arabic script, but speak Urdu. Not all Muslims are Arabs, just like nit all Arabs are Muslim. That’s be like lumping me, a English-speaking person from the US, in with Italians cause the script I use is Latin and we are both Christian-majority countries.
Alright, chill, nobody said you are
YEAS I WAS GOING TO SAY THE SAME THING
You guys still have "valid for all countries in the world except Israel" on your passports, right?
@Mohamed Syed Ahmar AbdAllah Then I'm not that impressed, you see. Arabs or not, still antisemitic as all hell. Israel is not an enemy state to Pakistan in any real way, yet still your passports have that disclaimer
A LESSON FOR PALESTINE 🤔📚
Just a thought. Go to South Africa. Ask the Africans (the Khoisan, Xosa, Zulu etc) how they feel about the white citizens ( the Afrikaans and the British) in their country. Ask the Africans if the would want to dispossess them? Ask the whites if the live in some state of constant fear owed to socio-political tensions between blacks and whites?
The Jews in Israel are like the blacks in S.A. The Palestinians are like the Afrikaans and the British citizens in S.A. The best the Palestinians can do is the same thing the whites in S.A have learnt to do. Collaborate with the natives. Constant antagony will get you nowhere.
ruclips.net/video/2ll-0WUGR7A/видео.html
12:45, the dude said that there is no notion of Jerusalem in the Quran, just to later say that in the original religion of Islam, the jews are the eternal people. Sounds contradictory.
dude jews were known
That dosnt contredict each other. Whats your point?
@Eti Camaroff yes. Conversions happen you know, besides the Quran says that you will be defeated as a jewish people
@Eti Camaroff I can't understand you what does it relate to Islam and why do u drop bullshit reasons in every comment, Palestine isn't Islamic case it's Humanity and logic you took their land with bullshit pretext like bible and some history claims doesn't relate to present israeli who call themselves as Jews.
@@rachel-po5rm no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
I am thankful that you found the last woman in this piece to talk to. A question would be: for Israelis, Would you offer full citizenship to Palestinians, while for Palestinians would you accept citizenship in a one state (Israel) solution. Another question: Given the history of violence and the ongoing bloody conflict - how can all sides (because there are many variations and even divisions within groups) - build trust. hint, the answer is not - it's up to other guy because my side is never the aggressor and we're the only one with a legitimate beef. Also maybe there is no answer.
These people have never been told "no"
Putting aside illegal/immoral; building settlements in and between Palestinian towns makes it impossible to establish a Palestinian state. The question to Israelis: what do you want to do with the Palestinians? continue with the current apartheid status quo? give Palestinians citizenship and end the jewish majority? Repeat 1947/1948 "independence war" where 85% of the Palestinians were expelled from the land that became Israel?
There is no such thing as "settlements."
There is no such thing as "West Bank."
And there is no "occupation."
These are all absurd made-up terms meant to set your opinion before you even got to think for yourself.
What there are, are Jews and Arabs, in Judea, Samaria and elsewhere in Eretz Yisrael. There are Jewish towns in Judea, and there are Arab towns in Judea.
What is this sick perversion of justice and morality, to ask "is it moral for Jews to live in Judea"? Can you imagine asking Frenchmen if it's moral for them to live in France? or any other people? These is antisemitic, and if you believe that, you are auto-antisemitic.
Have you considered asking Arab Israelis if it's moral for them to live in Israel?? No, right?? Because Israeli Jews aren't bigoted supremacists who are opposed to the presence of others near them.
Here are the questions which should be asked:
Is it moral to label Jews' presence in their homeland 'illegal occupation?'
Is it moral to obligate Israel to give up parts of its land that it gained in defensive war, back to the aggressors (which is the opposite of what international law says)?
Is it moral to blame Jews in the fact that bigoted supremacists are offended by their presence?
Is it moral to accuse Jews of being a barrier to peace instead of the other side's bigotry?
Is it moral to exploit Jews' innocence and ignorance and make videos like these?
Arabs who have a problem Jews live in Judea can get the f*** out of there. Those who don't are welcome to stay. This is the only correct opinion!!!
I think they should do to them what poles and czech did to germans after ww2.
@@ok1634 My question is about the practical situation on the ground. I see your opinion is for the Palestinians to "f*** out of there" (no Palestinian will accept giving up their land to outside settlers). I hope there are Israelis who have more enlightened view. It is people like you who keep the conflict and suffering going.
@@dogbert52 So your suggestion is to expel all remaining Palestinians from their land? I wonder why no one thought about solving the south african apartheid by expelling all blacks from south africa, after all they have the rest of Africa to live in. Preposterous!
What it "Israelis"? Every other Joe has another opinion.
Some want to live in one state peacefully,
some want two states - to each his own.
Some would like them to go away but know this is impossible,
some small minority actually think it might happen.
Almost nobody wants to kill anyone.
And now ask Palestinians the same question - you may be surprised
This could be hours long & I'd STILL watch it.
Actually, would be great to see that if possible?
2:50
مَثَلُ الَّذِينَ حُمِّلُوا التَّوْرَاةَ ثُمَّ لَمْ يَحْمِلُوهَا كَمَثَلِ الْحِمَارِ يَحْمِلُ أَسْفَارًا ۚ بِئْسَ مَثَلُ الْقَوْمِ الَّذِينَ كَذَّبُوا بِآيَاتِ اللَّهِ ۚ وَاللَّهُ لَا يَهْدِي الْقَوْمَ الظَّالِمِينَ
سبحان الله وكأن الاية تصفهم تماما
@@ahmedkhalid9648 لا تكونن مثلهم
حدثنا محمد بن عبد العزيز، حدثنا أبو عمر الصنعاني، من اليمن عن زيد بن أسلم، عن عطاء بن يسار، عن أبي سعيد الخدري، عن النبي صلى الله عليه وءاله، قال: «§لتتبعن سنن من كان قبلكم، شبرا شبرا وذراعا بذراع، حتى لو دخلوا جحر ضب تبعتموهم»، قلنا: يا رسول الله، اليهود والنصارى؟ قال: «فمن
ثنا أحمد بن يونس، حدثنا ابن أبي ذئب، عن المقبري، عن أبي هريرة رضي الله عنه، عن النبي صلى الله عليه وءاله، قال: «§لا تقوم الساعة حتى تأخذ أمتي بأخذ القرون قبلها، شبرا بشبر وذراعا بذراع» -
[ 103]
-، فقيل: يا رسول الله، كفارس والروم؟ فقال: «ومن الناس إلا أولئك
I lived along Israelis and Palestinians in the West Bank because it was cheap.
don't forget that before 1947 jews were living in this aera too, jordan's expel jews in 1949 until israel free the land in 1967, and at this time, it was not question of palestine or palestinian people
@ViceroyHaq21st you are the best liar i never seen ahahaha "palestinian" was the jews zionists until 1948...
@@philippesitbon9743 yes jews lived in the british mandate of Palestine, zionism back then was about freeing Palestine
@@philippesitbon9743 no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
Shakespeare mentioned Palestine. Golda meir carried a Palestinian passport
@Shani Israel nobody cares about Hebrews. Don't you have con*e*tration cam*s to be in?
It's an immoral question to ask Jews since the whole land of Israel belongs to Jewish people.
Maybe corey isnt exactly je wish?
the title should be changed to 'The face of fascism'
hey corey can you go to sheikh jarrah and do some questions there as well
He’s scared
Totally different. Lands in the West Bank, are by all parties agreed that it belongs to Palestinians. These settlement are illegal.
Sheikh Jarrah is part of Jerusalem. Internationally, its recognised as no man's land.
But Israel think all of it is theirs, Palestinians think half of it is.
Yess!! Please!
@@preetjitsingh328 why isn't there a proof of the Palestinian people's existence before the 1900s?
@@elio3950 say what? 😂
Hey Muslims used to pray towards Jerusalem first and then Mecca. Clear in the Quran...the Ethiopian guy doesn't know what he's talking about.
Why did they prey towards Jerusalem?
@יואב דניאל no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
Why do we care so much about Israel and Palestine while there is Myanmar in Crisis ?
Religion.
@@edwinlucianofrias1643 1.7 billion and 17 million . Got it.
@@mohammadzaid1221 What do those numbers represent?
@@mohammadzaid1221I do not know, I do not think that there is a group of strangers who came from all parts of the earth to steal the lands of Myanmar and expel its inhabitants
@@amanjain4005 no I was talking about the military coup , the rohingya thing is like 4 years old no-one cares about it.
I mean as Indians we both know how little our Twitter trends went for Myanmar people who are like our cousins but for Two middle eastern nations whose people are no way related to us , people went on a deathmatch .
Not Palestine, rather The Nation State of The Jewish People, Israel
Not the West Bank,rather Judea and Samaria
Not settlements, rather Jewish Communities
Thank you, HaShem for returning your people Israel to its borders as you promised us.
Ok colonizer
@@SomeoneSomewhere-el3cl
End Arab Colonization of Eretz Yisroel
@@Linda43 this is our land. Go back to europe
@@SomeoneSomewhere-el3cl
Jews are from Jewdea
Arabs are from Arabia
@@Linda43 Palestinians are Canaanites
Convoluted rationalization and denial as a defense mechanism rather than being able to stare at the bare truth for what it is ...
Torah and Bible are real estate documents mmmkay!
Massive projection of jihadonazi culture on others.....
The best thing about this video was that it was obvious all of them knew it was wrong deep down and were trying to justify. That gives me hope.
Sorry what I get from this is. They know it’s wrong they just don’t care.
It is written, "It's our land.." lol 🤣😂
“It is known.”
ruclips.net/video/foqUPiwMiOM/видео.html
The ultimate argument winner.
@shani isreal What is he saying? I don't speak hebrew.
Rabbi Ben Artzi is not the messiah!!!
@shani isreal You should send me the link to the video of Rabbi Ben Artzi in English. I don't speak Hebrew. BTW I am not a Russian. 😂
The arrogance and vanity of some Israelis. They came as refugees, put their state where people lived and expelled them and now claim everyone lives in peace in the Westbank. Palestinians "had the same rights" as them, no conflict, good people. No words...
How can they care about morality, if they think that the WB is just a stepping stone in an ongoing project?
They all know it is immoral but can't bring themselves to accept it. Humans are weak and if you were offered an opportunity to live in land you consider this holy many would snatch at it. The few people who would give up the opportunity are truly selfless and have my absolute respect.
@dont talk rubbish dont talk rubbish
@dont talk rubbish why would it refer to me? Atheists have no reason to believe in an objective morality and cant prove it from atheism. Christians believe a man died for them. It doesn't take long to come accross incest or genocide in the old testament so jews are no different. Liberals, well look at today. There are people identifying as inanimate objects and changing their ethnicity through plastic surgery. Islam comes out on top. You're talking rubbish mate
Genesis 17:8, G-D gave the holly land to Abraham and his descendants. The descendants of Abraham are Isaac and Ishmael. Ishmael is the father of Arabs...so G-D gave the holly land to Arabs too, not only Hebrews.
What does Genesis 17:19-20 say which is after that passage?
Yeah but when you continue to read or kicks Ishmael and give this promise to Isaac,just read all the chapter
@@roeeparienty7365 nobody cares . Your religion is just copied from Sumerian mythology. Like all abrahamic religions. You all believe myths, fables , and fairytales. You are not a “chosen people “ you are not special. You are like everyone else. Live together and stop being so full of yourselves. If religion is true and god has a “chosen people “ then that makes god racist. The Bible also says that the earth is flat. 100% a book of lies. Y’all need to stop these bs beliefs. Religion is hopefully going to die soon.
@Alex ayaad that's from our Torah, ya ytt bitch
@@tarekj5951 you butthurt, bruh
Aside from Hebron, no Palestinians ever had to leave their house because of a settlement.
If you k ow the history of Hebron, 1929,then you will u derstand why this is an exemption.
Thus, no settlement was ever build on la d, that belonged to a Palestinian person,
Or was used as farmers land etc.
There are some areas, which were sold from Arabs to jews before 1948.
Also houses is east jerusalem, like sheikh.
They legally belong to Jewish people, as they were bought.
Their owners today live in Jordan,
Have built them selfes a couple of houses from that money.
If Palestinians would cooperate, and not attack, everything would be possible.
How is it immoral to live on piece of land that was conquered from a group of people that tried to wipe you out?
The Germans in the thirties also claimed that the Jewish people tried to wipe them out. In the light of that, was it immoral for them to live in their houses and on their land and harvest their "olives"?
@@stream2watch the ar abs and nazis were allies.
@@dogbert52 That has no bearing on anything I wrote. Please try to emulate a person with an IQ level higher than 85 when you spout stuff online.
@@stream2watch slaty for getting exposed as jihadonazi :) yum yum
@@dogbert52 Is that some kind of Pidgin you are speaking now. I am not from Papua New Guinea. Please try a lingo we both can understand.
It's embarrassing how they can't argue in a logical coherent way
There is no such thing as "settlements."
There is no such thing as "West Bank."
And there is no "occupation."
These are all absurd made-up terms meant to set your opinion before you even got to think for yourself.
What there are, are Jews and Arabs, in Judea, Samaria and elsewhere in Eretz Yisrael. There are Jewish towns in Judea, and there are Arab towns in Judea.
What is this sick perversion of justice and morality, to ask "is it moral for Jews to live in Judea"? Can you imagine asking Frenchmen if it's moral for them to live in France? or any other people? These is antisemitic, and if you believe that, you are auto-antisemitic.
Have you considered asking Arab Israelis if it's moral for them to live in Israel?? No, right?? Because Israeli Jews aren't bigoted supremacists who are opposed to the presence of others near them.
Here are the questions which should be asked:
Is it moral to label Jews' presence in their homeland 'illegal occupation?'
Is it moral to obligate Israel to give up parts of its land that it gained in defensive war, back to the aggressors (which is the opposite of what international law says)?
Is it moral to blame Jews in the fact that bigoted supremacists are offended by their presence?
Is it moral to accuse Jews of being a barrier to peace instead of the other side's bigotry?
Is it moral to exploit Jews' innocence and ignorance and make videos like these?
Arabs who have a problem Jews live in Judea can get the f*** out of there. Those who don't are welcome to stay. This is the only correct opinion!!!
If I ask you to prove me that my shirt is red, you will be very embarrassing to give me a logical and coherent arguements
Logic and theism does not go together.
You are absolutely right - this is not logic - it’s
First and foremost based on belief in G-d and His Torah .
After that , we can discuss historical claims and war claims.
But bottom line this is based on belief in G-ds promise in the Torah.
This is the reason why initially many Torah observant Jews were angered by the reinstatement of the Land - because it was outwardly done for reasons other than the religious belief and Torah laws-
Deep down it’s all based on belief in G-d and the promises in the Torah-and that’s why there’s nothing to argue about - plain and simple.
You either belief or you don’t
You either ridicule religion or your don’t
How is it immoral for a jew to live in Judea ?
jews can live in Judea, as they did before , living in a peaceful coexistence with palestinians as they used to do in the past , until zionists mischaracterized and forcibly deteriorated previously peaceful relations.
@@h.f3544 Jews can live in Judea as long as they keep their numbers low and live under a Muslim ruler because it’s Muslim land.
And how did it become Muslim land? A Muslim army conquered it! 🤣
based
@@edwinlucianofrias1643 no, it was not conquered, jews left the lands in a massive exodus
@@h.f3544 "jews can live in Judea, as they did before"
There is 2 millions arabs in Israel mainland and you are complaining for every jew living in Judean Mountains. You are fooling only yourself here.
The girl that stated Arabs are what? If she's claiming to be a jew, decendant of Isaac, Ishmael was his brother. With that said, Arabs are your genealogical brothers..., but then again I argue with own my blood brothers, but never to this extent.
We all know what ar abs do to their brothers. From libya to yemen to iraq.
The guy at 4:00 isn’t correct. Jews weren’t the majority but there were always a minority presence in the land. I don’t agree with the action of building settlements in the WB
*GOD PROMISED*
me a car in bible so now I am gonna steal it
*"If I don't steal your house then someone else will"*
Yaqub an Israeli Settler from NEW YORK USA
@@allahuakbar3010 what's up with your comments? you keep repeating yourself, Zionism is not even a religious movement so that's not the reason Israel was established where it is.
U would think that if they thought it was immoral they wouldn’t be illegal settlers...
Well, the person in the thumbnail of this video...
ruclips.net/video/d9aQARe-Ftg/видео.html
Says the settlements are like a cancer for Israel but he still lives there (at the time.)
Apparently he’s a camel breeder which I thought too interesting not to mention.
Most settlers are religious so it's natural they speak of god and the bible, I'm not sure why all the surprised comments. I'm Israeli and not religious at all, I would never live in the West Bank.
@Shani Israel would you kill an innocent Palestinian family for that or force them out of their homes?
@@Adler2935 Is it a fact that settlers have to kill Palestinians or forcibly remove them from their homes in order to live in the WB?
I hear a lot of complaints about how the Israelis keep _building more settlements_ so why are they bothering to build settlements when they’re kicking Palestinians out of where they live? Why not just live in _those_ houses?
@@Adler2935 they don't kill, no. If they kill they will go to jail, but they do harras, at least the ones who are extremists.
@@Adler2935 why are you supporting cannibals and ped ophiles?
Ok, I'm halfway in.
One question.
How can you return to a land/property that WAS yours & then reclaim it?
If someone here was honest & said/says "look, it's a war,ok?... and we're winning", then I would understand this ( not agree, understand ).
08:42
Ok, someone said it!
@Pablo Diablo
There has been a continuous Jewish presence in Israel since the end of the last Jewish-Roman war in 135 CE. The Jewish Zinati family, from the village of Peki'in, trace their unbroken presence in the land from the end of the last Jewish Commonwealth -- that is, nearly 2, 000 years ago! No Arab family can make this claim. Here, see:
ruclips.net/video/9Gkm7DOTa7Y/видео.html
*BECAUSE*
*GOD PROMISED*
me a car in bible so now I am gonna steal it
*"If I don't steal your house then someone else will"*
Yaqub an Israeli Settler from NEW YORK USA
they literally wanted to make a jewish state on top of an already existing nation and people, do you know how
outrageous that sounds, you can’t call this a two sided war, it’s an oppressive colonization with resistance, today’s israel has no history it’s just a colonization.
the kingdom of israel form 5000 years ago is literally palestine, the citizens just converted form judaism to islam, fuck these lies
*"If I don't steal your house then someone else will"*
Yaqub an Israeli Settler from New York USA
*Yaqub the land grabber*
He was repeating her words. It was sarcasm.
In the end, the land will be returned to its Jewish owners.
The Shimon HaTzadik neighborhood is Jewish ✡
Yacov rambsel debunked new York.
@@Linda43 *He clearly used the word STEAL*
@@Linda43 you have no shame in you lying
that’s not fair, they don’t give the Palestinians an Israeli citizenship after the occupation, nor do they acknowledge Palestine as a country, I mean choose one , this is just cruel and inhumane
Native tribes in America need to reclaim this entire country. The proof, they were actually here when it was taken.
Yup. Israel is kind of like a reservation in the middle of a colonized area. From morroco to iraq , a tiny NJ sized reservation.
@@dogbert52 I was speaking on their ideology. It can be applied here. The only thing is, most of the Native tribes in America were annihilated.
it will be an embarassing moment for me, the day i have to awnser GOD for my life. but it helps me to know, this goes for everyone. good luck!
@Shani Israel quoting ur fake religious book and using it as a justification is the most retarded thing anyone can do
@shani isreal 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Omg what just religions do to people's minds
@shani isreal hahahahahahahaha 😂😂😂😂😂
@Larry T no true lasting real peace can ever be achieved by human means. it is only by being transformed by SHAR SHALOM IE THE PRINCE OF PEACE IE YESHUA HA MASHIACH (Gentiles know HIM as Jesus CHRIST) only by becoming transformed through faith in HIM can anyone have and show real, lasting , true peace. may all here trust in HIM and find Eternal Life and Salvation.
@shani isreal hasham is false as allah is false use ur fukin brain you tool
Judea and Samaria was freed from the illegal occupation of the Jordanians.
Might as well ask ISIS “isnt establishing a caliphate wrong?”
We all should return to monke and restart.
Al shababa and Boko Hammas says it's halal.
*Every body condemns ISIS*
Nobody condemns Zionists in fact they gave US taxpayer money to Zionists to kill children's in Gaza
@@mohammadzaid1221 u seem like a civilized dude, where you from? And a cultured mem0r on top of that.
@@allahuakbar3010 and Hamas spends donation money on weapons instead of rehabilitating Gaza. The world is filled with shit heads on every side buddy, deal with it and stop pointing fingers, pointing fingers dont solve nottin.
Just divided into three countries:
1. For Arabs Only
2. For Jews Only
3. For Coexist Arabs and Jews who want living in Peace Together 👍👍
It was planed 1947 jews agreed arabs did not
22 a rab states.
1 je wish state.
And the ar abs want it too.
It's immoral to pontificate and threaten - using the moral leverage (on behalf of a mob of assassins) - the People from Israel from living in the very heart of Medinat israel which is Samaria and Judea. Jews in Judea and Arabs in Arabia. This is the only reasonable recipe for peace, other than a decisive victory for Israel in the next total war launched by the Arabs. Whoever wants to live in Israel in Peace, can do that, of course, no matter which is his/her creed. Israel guarantees freedom of religion to everybody, and freedom of language and costumes. Ten major religions are currently present and totally free to practice in israel. Terrorist on the contrary, are not. Shalom.
What's more moral than people living on their ancestors' homeland?
2000 years ago is not valid you have to look at recent history and the arabs live in palestine and should not be opressed and deprived of their rights
It be like the African American's deciding that S Africa is their ancestors homeland and using that notion to force all the white ppl off of their land. And then to make it even crazier, to say that some god promised them that land. The whole thing sounds so silly to an educated atheist.
@Eti Camaroff i think the jews are also many different people's from many different lands.
Most of these answers are incredibly depressing. The young man on the train is the exception. The others come across as thoughtless, self righteous and ignorant. No introspection, no self doubt, no questioning. No attempt to see things from the Palestinian point of view.
To be honest, the young man on the train was pretty depressing too 🤦
What about the third guy who said he brought the holy land? Is he lying?
Hi I really love all your videos and I have questions im really interested to hear the answers to I would really appreciate it if you would want to use them in your future projects!
Question to Palestinians: if you could go back in time to 1948 would you prefer to agree to Partition plan and Establish a country in the lands the UN gave you? Or would you still prefer to go to a war so all the land will be yours?
For the Arab Israelis who served/serving in the IDF: what your family and your friends think about you serving in the IDF? Are there was sometimes problems with it? Are you feel equally to the Jews who serving with you?
The palestinians just wanted their own state so they would not have to live under Jewish law. The didn't want to have all the land to themselves. The Palestinians and the Arabs had been living side by side for thousands of yrs in that land. Many were friends. And many still are today. But there are these far right Israeli's who are racist against and believe they're superior to their Palestinian neighbors. They are the one's who want all of jerusalem and many outposts along the West bank to belong to Isreal. They are the one's causing trouble.
@@gerri577 but they could had a state in 48 they rejected the partition plan while Israel agreed that's why started the war can you tell me what was the reason they rejected it? Honestly asking...
And by the way there are always people who will be racist and far right kind of people in both sides both in Israel and in Palestine but there will always be people who would want peace and accept the difference.
It all about education, as an Israeli I know that in secular schools they really try to teach about accepting the difference that everyone is the same and that peace is something possible.
But the religion schools education is really different so I don't know what they learn there...
I would just say there are more than 100 organizations in Israel today that try to promote peace between Jews and Arabs so there are a lot of people who do really try to change our point of view of each other.
True they were perfectly happy if Jews would live under Muslim law but not vise versa.
@@gerri577 perfectly happy to want oxygen. But only the oxygen in your lungs. Not the 22 other ar abs states . Lol
i have a better idea : WE BURN ALL RELIGIOUS TEXTS FOR EVER AND EVER AND EVER that includes ALL of them : hindi, muslim, christian, tibetean the whole bloody lot must go now ! We have near death experiencers now who we should be examining and stop all the ancient bullshit ideology which are ALL AND SUNDERS CULTS !! ALL OF THEM NO EXCEPTION! I searched this for over 20 yrs now and that is my conclusion. All these texts were written by MEN who sought to DOMINATE ! They all established slavery, caste systems and brutal suppression ALL OF THEM no exception with Buddha maybe the worst of all with his non acceptance of soul . disgusting old texts.
Its been called Palestine since the literal beginning of history. What a goofy bunch.
the "Palestinians", as Arabs, have 349857239045793472394 other Arab or Arab-friendly countries they can go to including the United States. The Jews have ONE country.
There are more jews in NY alone than there are in Israel , genius.
The Zionists are carving an Arab Hitler with their own hands.
Like the statue of David sculpted by Michelangelo
Good job, all to appease Anglicans in the West
If ive learned anything its that both sides dont want this to end. They will fight forever over land. However one side has big guns and healthcare sponsored by the largest military in the world, whose own citizens dont have healthcare.
Yes
It's suck when you think about how many american pay taxes but don't even get equal feedback
*GOD PROMISED*
me a car in bible so now I am gonna steal it
@@hatasakuta8012 Speaking About Americans
*"If I don't steal your house then someone else will"*
Yaqub an Israeli Settler from NEW YORK USA
largest military in the world = Arab propaganda checks out
@@davidtrak2679 america definitely has the largest military force in the world fuck face
Question to Palestinians: why do you think the land of Israel belongs to you when there was never a Palestinian state in the history of humanity?
I'm not a Palestinian but that's an easy question .. a nation state as we know it now is a relatively new construct that colonial powers introduced so I could easily say there was no Israel either .. But anyways there were most features of an organized state before 1948 like infrastructure, universities, railways etc... It wasn't all desert and shit More importantly, there were people too lol .. But lets say there was no state .. does this give Israel the right or make it moral/ethical to displace people and ethnically cleanse them from a land/houses they lived on for centuries (The Nakba) ?? .. Also was it ever moral to ethnically cleanse the native Americans given they had no state either !!?
Why do Lebanese think lebanon is their land when there was never an independent state called lebanon before 1950 ? Because they are people who always lived there and farmed there lands despite who is ruling them lebanon and syria are new states but syrians and Lebanese and palestinians are not new people they are the natives who deserve to have self determination in their own lands they have always lived in
Because their clan chiefs and immams tell them. If they wont repeat the lie , their own clans will dispose of them.
@@mariamahmed-ei8js Exactly, very important point.
Denial all over the place
your destiny is very obvious to us, and you even proved it for us, so carry on
"If it is not tempered by compassion, and empathy, reason can lead men and women into a moral void.”
[Karen Armstrong,Twelve Steps to a Compassionate Life]
" The whole land of Israel belongs to the Jewish people, Including lands won in war for security reasons " The British Mandate of 1922
I don't think that the British could say something like that. Even if they said it, they had no right to decide the fate of other countries.
@@mohamedmostafa1375
The League of Nations gave the British the Mandate.
The League of Nations was the forerunner to your beloved UN.
@@Linda43
The league of nations was abolished. The British transferred the whole issue of Palestine to the United Nations in 1947, even before ending their mandate.
@@mohamedmostafa1375
The British didn't create the Mandate or its stipulations.
It just enforced them.
The UN has never canceled the stipulations of the Mandate. It just has chosen to ignore it for political reasons.
My original post still stands.
@@Linda43
All the UN resolutions regarding to the Arab Israeli conflict have practically changed the mandatory charter of the British. There is already a different situation.
I don't understand why they are being questioned about something they were allowed to do legally, according to history after WW2.
@@houssamkabakebe6285 I think the Balfore Declaration was signed and agreed upon. I don't remember all the details, I cannot spell it either, sorry.
it was also legal once i purchase a human being and put them to labor until their die. just because something is legal does NOT mean it is right or ethical. In this case, the expulsion and ethnic cleansing is BOTH ILLEGAL AND UNETHICAL
@@Bashirbros I meant that it is disturbing to see that now they're being judged, after they were allowed.
@@Bashirbros slavery was abolished in israel in 1948. When the IDF forced bedouin slavers to free the abeed. Hurray to the IDF right?
The answer is a simple YES.
Bullshit.. palestinian never had an army.. while jews before 1948 already got their own air force.. how come palestinjan that living inside by the sea declared a war at the borders??
שבת שלום ומבורך
חודש טוב ומנחם לכל עם ישראל
I stand with Palestine oop
@@munaadan5454
I stand with Narnia 😄