I live in a third world country , basically i pirate online books for knowledge , it has been the only way up until maybe one day I'd get to buy physical books one day , i mean I am so jealous of those people who have barnes and noble 5 minutes away from their house and they never get anything
People don't understand that I just don't just want books to read them. Just having them around makes me feel better. Stacks of books on my desk or a paperback in my hands. I'm going to build a library like the beast from Beauty and the Beast. Books make me feel calm and safe. Their presence is magic.
I agree with you. My mom has worked in a library my whole life and the smell of all those books together is enchanting. The different ages and textures of the pages give a smell that is comparable to a choir's variation of voices.
Totally makes sense. I personally like paperback books for the feel to it, and so I can read them and keep them in a library, until I have a small library at home.
Yep. There’s something special about paperback that’s irreplaceable by e-books but considering the lack of space, e-book is my choice. Still hopefully one day I will have my own library full of paperbacks of my favs 🌻
paperback is god-tier. granted, i do a lot of reading books in digital form. but paperback hits different, the connection i make with the physical book i have on my hands is sacred. it's like the book grows with me, collecting stains and scratches and words scribbled along its passages. this sense of permanence is something i dream of looking back to and that any digital format cannot compare with. i'm nineteen and i'm too sentimental for my age haha
"digital vs physical books?" i would say just get whichever you can get/borrow for free. seriously, i feel that when i buy a book/e-book with my own money, i feel kind of obligated to finish reading it so i dont "waste" the money, even if i may not actually enjoy the book for what it is. but when i download a free pdf (from project gutenberg i dont advocate illegal e-books) or borrow from the library, i read for the enjoyment and the book itself rather than forcing myself to read it to milk every cent i spent on it. then if i like it i can go and actually buy the physical book if i want. that's just my way of doing it, so you do you. edit: phrasing and spelling (i spelt "gutenberg" as "glutenberg" lmao)
@@VandalVortex it doesn't hahaha i have an app for easier reading of books in pdf format and you can change brightness, background colour and many more!
I've recently changed up my whole philosophy(?) on books. Before, I used to buy books, read them once, and they'd sit on my shelf for years while I reread some of my favorites or moved onto new books. For me, it WAS about the prestige/accomplishment of having read so many books. I'd walk in to my house, see all the books I read, and I'd feel a little more intellectually superior because "wow I really have read a lot!" But recently, I've changed that. Instead of just buying books endlessly, I now will go to bookstores a couple times a year, pick out 3 or 4 books each trip, and bring them home, while reading everything else on e-book from the library. I then only keep the books that I really liked, that I'd actually reread again, and donate the ones that I wasn't really in love with to the library. (Especially in the case of the library e-books. I would only buy a physical copy once I know I LOVE it.) I did this for multiple reasons. 1. I love physical books. I need physical books, especially because I get anxiety over the idea that technology may not always be around, so if I don't have a physical copy, I may not be able to read it again. (Which is fine, because I reread books so much that it's actually a worthwhile investment to have a copy with me.) 2. I also like book shopping in stores and want to support my local book stores. Plus, it helps go back to fulfilling that need to actually have a physical copy with me. 3. I also believe in supporting local libraries (both by donation and by being active as a reader), so I try to do as much for them as I can. As a result, I've cleared out my bookshelf of all the books that I didn't love (I went from about 600 to 150), donated all the rest, and have been able to read more now that I'm constantly switching back and forth between e-book (which I can take everywhere easily!) and paperback (which I love reading in the comforts of my home). Also, it has really helped my library, as they were grateful to have so many YA novels, especially since no one ever seems to donate any. (Which, I guess, is expected, because most young people aren't used to donating books or aren't interested in it.) And now that I've done that, I actually find myself being MORE proud of all the books I've read, because if I can fill a bookshelf full of books that I LOVE, that inspired me, and I can keep growing that collection, that means that I've actually done more than just read a book. It means that I've read tons of books, and out of all the ones that I've read, I've gone through and selectively picked out the ones that meant the most to me, and that I've taken care of them and treasured them! So instead of saying which is better, why not both?!
From my teenage years onward, I've always had a collection of books. When my grandfather died, I got saddled with his 3000+ book library. As someone who has moved a lot (I've lived in 5 different countries, and moved over 35 times), I definitely see the advantage of an e-reader and the digital format. My kobo has about 1500 titles, and the ability to check books out from the public library over my device is fantastic as well. That said, I still love the look of the Harvard Classics, and other hardcover favourites on my bookshelf. In the end, both the traditional format and the e-reader are both still very effective at waking you up if you drop them on your face after briefly falling asleep.
the feeling of turning pages and feeling the texture of the pages really does something. i love the smell of books, I love being able to shut the book dramatically when things just *BOOM* in a book, you know what i mean. i sometimes love placing a book page open on my chest when things just get emotional or so happy. i love admiring the cover after I’ve finished reading. hardcover books with etched on titles really has my heart. nothing can ever replace physical books. i like digital reading too, it’s really convenient i do it often and it’s us adapting to the new technologies invented and we should make use of it but replacing physical books completely is not going to happen, digital books cannot give you the sense of warmth a physical book does and i always always prefer physical books.
My issue with e-books/pdfs is largely that I prefer to get away from screens when I'm reading a book. The experience of a physical book helps me to focus both on the content and on the act of reading. There is no navigating a digital menu, there is no temptation to switch to something else on the same device. I want to be able to flip through the pages like nothing when I need the index, or to reference something from a previous chapter. I also find it easy to forget the contents of a digital library. just some thoughts.
To me, a Kindle is so much lighter to handle with one hand while having the other hand free. Whereas with physical books, you're always fighting the pages from closing on you and performing amazing feats of finger gymnastics when attempting to drink a coffee with one hand whilst maintaining 'Infinite Jest' on page seven-hundred-and-something with the other shaky hand. Also, the ability to tap on any word and get a pop-up definition has been revolutionary to me. No more pulling the phone out every few minutes to google a word which takes you out of the reading zone. No more searching for glorious reading light. No more hiding-the-cover from people because you don't want them to know what you're trying to know. Above all, no more hand cramps.
I noticed that I am able to remember things better from a book if I read it in a physical format. And somehow it feels nostalgic for me. I'm happy you chose this subject. I guess that as long as we read something, that's what matters.
Digital Book = Alternative book for active readers who dislikes carrying a lot of stuff outside Hardback = Collection purposes Paperback = Old school book to go anywhere. (Still prefer this even though the digital book is a new alternative for active readers, I hate when I'm on my phone for a long time lol)
@@a.m.641 Isn't an ebook a type of Digital Book? I only use e-book when there's no stock left of paperbacks on both local/online bookstores that I could receive within days. Then I proceed on buying an hardback for my collection since I had read it on e-book.
as a classic literature admirer, physical books just put me there in the zone therefore i always buy my classics, but when it comes to other genres that i am quite reluctant if i will like them or not, i usually dont buy them unless i love them to an extent that i plan to re read them in the future, i buy them only if i have this kind of connection with them that will make me want to see them there on my shelf. my dream is to collect a whole library of books that embodies my life, so buying random books just look very unnecessary to me, and quite taxing as well.
Reading, for me, has always been an escape from screens. I spend so much time looking at a monitor or phone screen as is, so the thought of having to look at yet another screen to read fills me with dread.
I like to keep a physical book on the nightstand, so I can read a dozen pages before I go to bed. (Currently, it's Sedaris' essay collection) But e-readers are easier to deal with on the train.
I feel like the physicality of a book and the sense of obligation is sometimes good for certain types of readers starting off such as reluctant readers or people who don't read for enjoyment but want to get into it. I do agree that is easy to fall into the trap of viewing these acomplishments as trophies which is what I certainly did at one point. But as of now although my preference is physical books I am certainly happy to read on my kindle too, beacause at the end of the day it is the content that matters most :))))))
I love having the physical book, however, there is one major advantage of having a kindle (at least for me) and that is being able to look up words I don't fully understand just by tapping on them. (Dictionary function)
Loved this video! Never seen this stance put so clearly. You are totally right!. Also, since I switched to ebooks I am reading way more. I can read anywhere as the Kindle is very light, I can take it to the pool or to the beach and it wont get ruin, I can read in the dark, I can also read without hands! (you need the right cover for this) so I can read and eat or crochet or whatever at the same time. And dont get me started on the built in dictionary to read in other languages! After getting used to all the Kindle advantages I just found paper books too uncomfortable to read from. Sure they look amazing, but as you said they are trophies and with one glance anyone that visits you can know that you are a reader, an intellectual, but that's just ego food. But there is another side... having paper books motivates other people to read, get children curious about reading, and that's amazing!!!. So I propose we read the ebook and if we love it THEN we get the paper version and everyone wins: your ego, your kids, your friends, the author. Or well, at least that's what I will do when I settle down somewhere.
Mannnnnnn this is sooooo relatable!! When i read the paperback all i wanna do is finish it and put it on a shelf(as you said the "trap") contents of the book become somehow less important to me. Just to not get distracted by the cover and stuff i changed to the digital and tbh i am literally enjoying the content more than the physicality of the book.
I'm a theatre major and often times it's super difficult to get my hands on a physical script unless I drive over two hours to a specific bookshop or order online. I don't often use e-readers to read novels but it is a lifesaver when it comes to scripts. I end up reading about 3-4 a week in my spare time and it's so wonderful to be able to expand my knowledge on the world of theatre. I don't even have a kindle actually, I have the kindle app on my phone which makes it even more accessible. Gosh I'm so happy to have been born in a digital era for that alone
I’ve had 3 kindles in the past 10 years and they’re something I would never give up having, but this year I started buying physical books again and I feel like I’m a new reader. I like having the option of reading anything anywhere but holding a real book in my hands just motivates me to finish it - like what you said, if I’m reading a book on a kindle I just move on to the next one too easily if I don’t like it.
I am a slow reader, tech destroyed my ability to enjoy a book so I prefer ebook readers far better than books, just reading it on a digital screen is easier for me. Also, Its really convenient: I can get free (legal) ebooks and store thousands on them inside a single little device. Still, I really like paperback, and just their design and how they look on my desk is cool.
I know this is super weird, But when I smell new books that have just been bought I feel like I am getting high on some sort of drug. Yeah, you are right.
There’s nothing that can replace a physical book, but I have found a lot of freedom through renting ebooks from my library. There’s zero commitment, no money spent, no worrying if this book was good enough to be kept on my shelves. I’ve read a lot more and a broader range of books since using ebooks. Everything is at my fingertips. I’m a re-reader, so if I loved an ebook enough, I will purchase a physical copy since physical books are just irreplaceable to me as an avid reader!
In past I was against e-books to read on laptop/ipad because of them causing eyestrain after long sessions. Now after getting proper e-ink device, I don't really support paper books anymore. There are simply a series of advantages for e-reader device: convenient to annotate, motivation - all features of device are very refined to focus on content and eliminate disturbance, time to return to reading is really small, some of my paper books are abandoned as I've deliberately decided skip them - no problem for e-reader. Also I found out that using built-in illumination of e-ink screen does subtract from experience, so I keep it turned off constantly. Of course I really miss the book smell, and there is no way imitate it. Still some paper books can have chemical/unpleasant smell. And as for audiobooks the important rule for me is to listen only if properly focused and not doing something thoughtful simultaneously.
I used to be really snooby and only read physical books, but in the past four years I have moved 6-8 times. Packing books was such a pain so I switched to kindle last year and its been great
I like the feeling of a physical book, it motivates me to read. But I have read many books on my Kindle that I couldn't find on physical, so that's a clear advantage. The selection of physical books that make it to my country is not very diverse (usually bestsellers).
Here's my approach: I prefer physical books, but will generally follow whichever route is cheaper. When I'm looking for a certain book, I will almost always check my local used bookstore to see if they have it first. Most of my books come from there. If that doesn't work, and I'm dying to read that particular book, I'll check the price of shipping a paperback against an ebook's price and then buy the cheaper one, going for paperback if they're about equal. On top of this, I regularly check for deals on my phone on Google Play Books, as I've found that I've been able to get some stupidly cheap ebooks on there. I also borrow books quite a bit. This means that I regularly switch between the formats when reading. This approach works best for me because my situation is such that price is certainly an object for me, but not too much so, and also because I don't mind used books. No hardcovers though. Overly expensive and physically awkward to read. Screw that noise.
It's also worth adding that the built in dictionary on Kindle can make a big difference on your enjoyment of the book, especially for classic literature where the author might use words that are less common today.
For printed books, I have a lot to consider before reading them (condensed paperback are cheap but the font is too tiny and the format is squeezed, giant hardcover books are hard to hold, some paperback books can’t open flat, etc) whereas for ebook I usually could customize my font and format, and usually the legal ones have good format. However, I do realize that reading a good printed book does enhance the enjoyment I get from a book, but it’s just hard to choose the right one.
Going digital has made me save so much. I haven't bought any physical books after purchasing an e-reader - the only exceptions are the art or more technical ones. If I ever settle somewhere I might buy my favorite ones in the future, though
Books may not be difficult to acquire, but for sure they’re still symbols of status: the status of being “cultured” and the status of “being able to afford the pretty hardcover edition”, specially in booktube
I understand the appeal of physical books but I prefer digital format for environmental reasons (for when I buy, not borrow) and also because e ink is easier on my eyes. I can adjust the font and read while my partner is asleep without disturbing him. It’s also incredibly easy for me to check out books using my library and return them. I no longer waste time on books I’m not enjoying because there’s zero obligation to finish it. I didn’t spend money on it and I can just check out a new book to see if it’s more interesting to me.
A book is a book. I think whatever is convenient/affordable/available to people is what matters. I prefer the reading experience of a traditional paper book, but I often borrow ebooks or audiobooks from my library to read for the first time and if I really connect with the content I’ll invest in my own physical copy.
For me, it's a matter of convenience and experience. I've lost two separate houses to fires (yay, California living), and both times I lost beautiful personal libraries of physical books. So for now, I'm going almost entirely digital. I own a Kobo, which is tiny and light enough for me to take everywhere. I can fit a few hundred books on it at a time. I do enjoy the experience of holding a physical book, but this way, I can take my entire library with me in a time of emergency, and that's very important to me personally.
You’re right !!! Here I come free digital pdf books 📚 In all seriousness, I used to care about having a paperback copy, but I started to buy online books recently and my mindset has changed. I could care more now. If I enjoy a book, I will enjoy it in whatever medium I access it. I also, enjoy audiobooks, but I prefer seeing the letters and words for myself. I enjoy reading them out loud myself. Books are beautiful.
As you say, the important thing is the content of the book. For me, digital books are much more practical, however, the format is indifferent to me, I prefer digital ones of course, but I also understand the feeling that some comments talk about reading physical books, in the end you also have to take into account what that improves the experience, but I already stayed with the digital ones
Having physical books in a house means living with them, it's a different kind of connection. Also they create good discussions about them when friends and family visits the house and start looking at what I've got.
I've lived in 3 countries within 1.5 years, and the kindle saved my life. I only travelled with 2 suitcases, and could not have been able log all the books I wanted to read/buy with me. That being said, a physical copy hits different. Kindle reminds me too much of my phone, so I can't relax with it the same way I can with a physical copy. Also, let me add that digital formats have significantly increased the time I can spend with a book. Because of a chronic illness, I was unable to hold a book up for longer periods of time + my eyes can get really tired. Digital formats definitely increase the accessibility to books!
I like them all. For non fiction, I prefer ebooks (for better notes taking interface and immediately available search option). For fiction, I prefer paper books. For biographies and such, I use Audible while doing some chore, or painting. I have however gone 100% digital (off late) in an attempt to minimize my book management time (sun drying the books, dusting, arranging, relocating the silver fishes, et al.).
I used to be firmly in the physical book side of the argument. However, I'm more on the fence. I now want to own less material items and be more minimalist. At the start of this year, I started going to the library to borrow books rather than buying them. With lockdown closing the library, I read a lot of ebooks this year. When libraries reopened I started going back. If it's not available I'll get it for my kindle.
As someone who reads both kinds, i find myself really enjoying the paperback experience a lot as i feel connected to it but at the same time, digital books are so convenient that i read through the books so fast without knowing as i can bring them wherever i go, without having to bring a huge weight when i go out. So i say, BOTH
When I first started reading I started using the kindle app on my phone, a year later I decided to get the actual kindle device because I started reading a lot more. And because I read a lot more, I started going into bookstores because I just wanted to look at books but that just lead me to buying a physical book and enjoying it a lot more. I’ve got a mini library going on right now too :)
the first books that made me feel the magic of reading were physical books. in those days, physical books were the only ones widely available. and i will always relate the magical feeling to physical books most. over the years, i’ve read more and become more aware of my likes and dislikes. that same magic is harder to come by these days. and i don’t think it’s got to do with the fact that i’m reading more ebooks now. i’ve simply moved on along my reading experience and (hopefully) levelled up as a reader. i fall into the zone harder and it sometimes feel like i need to read a lot more books to find those that i like. so statistically, ebooks tend to feel more laborious than my early days of reading physical books. still, i try to avoid thinking that physical books are therefore better than ebooks. and the absence of clutter and ease of management of a digital library are absolutely worth it vs. the smell of ink and paper
My mom has worked in a library my whole life and the smell of all those books together is enchanting. The different ages and textures of the pages give a smell that is comparable to a choir's variation of voices. I do like the word wise aspect of digital books though. I can click on a word to get an exact pronunciation, find its origin and multiple meanings. Then I make note cards, all in one app. If I like the book enough, I buy the hard copy.
I have to move between college and my house every 3 months or so. Moving requires transportation between several bus stops/trains stops + airports. So digital copies ftw 😂 although I do keep several physical copies. I personally dislike reading paperbacks because it's hard to determine a comfortable position. You also have to be very careful in order to preserve the book's "freshness". I could throw my kindle across the room and it will still work fine without any visible sign of damage.
E-books are far easier to acquire and manage. I can read them on my phone or Kindle, and I can read them anywhere, just pulling it out of my pocket. Although, nothing compares to the experience of flipping through a physical book, especially when books have appendices, dictionaries and maps that supplement the story through constant reference. That being said, if I finish an e-book and it really resonates with me, I purchase a physical copy. As a trophy for my shelf, and because I can re-read it in physical form next time.
I prefer digital books. Easier to carry around and eco friendly at its best. Besides, it’s so much easier to buy one. You just click and start reading instantly literally anywhere. not to say it’s sometimes much cheaper.
I personally find physical books really captivating aesthetical objects, but, ethically speaking, I believe that digital books are the way to go, since they offer access to the text without the environmental impact of physical books.
Hi Robin. I'm a book person. I love my books. After university, and reading books for 12 years, I always fell back on my book seller here in Montreal. I curate books, that, yes, resonate with me. I spend countless hours walking the shop, looking and reading dust covers. During the Harry Potter series, our book sellers went to great lengths to get us into the shop at midnight for the next release. Books are life for me. A way to see the world in all its gory ugliness and beauty. I've got a pretty nice library of pretty books, that I've actually read. I don't just collect pretty covers. Each book is an experience, a destination. Pandemic has forced us onto the digital book seller site, which is really useful but not the same as wandering the stacks for hours. I need the pages, the smell and the feel of a book. Digital is so non-personal to me. Not the format I want to enjoy carrying in my backpack. I want the physical book !!
Also looking down on people who read digital books can be ablest, for some people who have dyslexia for example, it can be difficult to read a physical book because of the font size, the font used, the colour of the paper ect, all things that can be changed on an ereader making books more accessible to people like that.
I've been in the trap of physicality for years and have a bunch of unread books on my shelf. I got a Kindle recently and I've fallen in love with reading. I personally find better appreciation for the text, and my focus has driven far away from the way it looks. "Don't judge a book by it's cover". Yeah for me that's easier said than done. 😂 Also big books used to scare me.
reading in the phone was making my head aches and my vision was getting worse, so kindle was a good option. also, i’ve noticed that i read faster in these digital formats... like he said: reading is what truly matters.
i love physical books a lot, but i had to adapt to ebooks because of my rhinitis, that's when i learned that the important thing is the content and not just the beautiful cover. :)
I do both but I usually read things first on my Kindle (through Libby) and if I love it then I buy it. You can’t beat the convenience of reading on a Kindle. You can read whenever and however and be comfortable doing it. Also! No reason to have a bookshelf full of books you’re just “eh” about. Showcase the ones that paint a picture of who you are and what’s lead you there.
Over the past year, I've been buying almost exclusively digital books. There are a lot of reasons, but there are two primary motivators. 1. I've been doing a lot more focused reading for retention, using Kindle highlights, porting through various apps like Instapaper, Readwise, and compiling everything in Notion. It automates all of my notes and highlights in one place for review and further retention. 2. I have a big problem having a shipping company drag their trucks half way across the country to put a book in my hands. Bookstores around here aren't an option, so the footprint involved with me getting physical books makes me ill. With very few exceptions, I'll probably be removing all traces of physical books from my life in the near future. For what and how I read now, physical books are getting harder to justify.
At the end of the day, no version is superior to the other. I enjoy both formats. Ebooks are more accessible since I can carry plenty of them on my phone or tablet or laptop without occupying much space. So I can go on vacation for several weeks and take several books with me without worrying about a physical book or two taking up too much space in my suitcase. They also tend to be cheaper, if not free, more readily available, and eco friendly. But as someone in her late 20s who grew up reading physical books first, there is something about holding a copy in your hand, smelling the book (the older, the better), physically turning the page and feeling a sense of accoplishment as I see the number of pages read get higher and higher, and one side getting thicker, about putting a book down after having finished it. A physical book is also a cheap way to decorate your room/house. I personally use both. I get ebooks for the novels that I know I won't feel the need to reread, and physical books in novels that I know I will keep going back to, and as a result want to keep in my permanent collection
Usually I buy physical books that I know I'm going to re-read in the future. That's why it's important for me to atleast read few pages of the book or at least I have researched several information about the book before purchasing a physical copy of it. What I find is non-fiction and fictions books that hits hard and sort of have some relevance with my life is something I keep physically. While if it's just for the pure enjoyment of reading, I prefer the e-book copy as I know I am going to just read it in once.
Two things I truly appreciate about this video. One, you're giving permission to put down a book that isn't resonating with a reader rather than recommending they slog it out just to say they finished it. Life's too short for a completionist mentality when it comes to literature. Two, a vlogger who actually uses "resonate" correctly in a sentence. That is a rarity on RUclips for some reason, as "resonate" gets used often and almost always incorrectly by far too many vloggers. I would hit like twice for those two points if it worked that way.
as someone who is young and as everyone pretty telephone/social media addicted, i find my kindle pretty helpful because instead of scrolling through tiktok i can trick my brain in using a mobile device in kindle form. also ereader motivated me to read more and i read multiple books on there because many books are free and you dont have to run to bookstorw to buy a ebook.
When I had babies and needed to use only one hand to hold the device, read, and turn pages, an ereader was amazing. For years it was the cheapest way to go for books and perfect for travel. Prices have increased on ebooks since 15 years ago! If it's the same cost as a book, I'd rather buy a book then pass it on locally. Life gets busy with three children. I forget to charge it so it becomes a frustration. It's much more convenient to notice there is free time for extra reading, grab the physical copy, and sit to read. My kids prefer physical copies of books, too. A graphic novel on a kindle can't compare. I also couldn't imagine books like The Arrival by Shaun Tan or the Illuminae Files having quite the same impact in an ebook. We buy used books and it generally costs us less than ebooks. Both are great for different reasons and each reader will find what fits their life.
Back where I used to live buying books wasn't feasible. The prices were astronomical and there was barely any variety and a limited stock (I'm talking 4-5 copies per title), not to talk about the fact that there were _no_ hardcovers at all, only paperbacks; so I got used to reading digitally. Now I live somewhere where paperback and hardcover books are available and relatively cheap, but I got so used to reading e-books that I find that I have to really force myself and make a conscious effort to keep reading when it's a physical book. The only exception is for rereading a book I like, which means I probably decided on getting a physical copy, too.
actually this is exactly the strategy that i've been using for the lasr couple of years! i only buy books which cannot be found online, the ones with extraordinary illustrations or just stuff that i know is going to be a spectacular read. otherwise i go to the library or use the pdf/epub version :)
I read books to reduce my screentime. Picking up a kindle or ipad or iphone to read doesn't feel like a break. I also am the type of reader that needs a pen in hand to focus. I need to know I can write all over the book. If I don't feel like spending money on a book because I don't think I'll love it or won't write all over it, then I request it from my library. I like to buy secondhand from goodwills online too.
Personally, I'm just happy when people read. I read mostly ebooks because I travel alot. Space is always a problem and books are heavy. My Kindle has been a lifesaver for my arms and shoulders. It is also waterproof, nice for beaches!
I feel the reason why I love physical books (hard copy or paper) is in a way romantic. For me personally I love read a book and mark the pages with beautiful and meaningful quotes and add little notes in the margins - in a way hoping that in a later period of time someone - anyone will come across it and read the quotes, read the margins and understand my perspective, it’s to keep my ideas and perceptions immortal. I don’t know if this is me being a hopeless romantic but that is why I love physical copies.
physical books are like being surrounded by art, you actually fall in love with your personal library, and i also love the different sizes and types... I am at a screen all day every day, and find screens most excellent for short snippets of information, but once that info gets large, i need the book, as the screen kind of repels me. i think the kindles are great for travelling, or for reading easy fun literature, but once a thing gets hard, eg organic chemistry, philosophy, or even serious history, I just can't do this kind of thing on a kindle. Maybe it is my age and how i was introduced to reading. Another thing is, I get satisfaction from knowing where I am in a book, half way , nearly done or whatever, it is far more rewarding in that sense. Some books eg one I am reading right now is a book about the battles of Waterloo, and the book is beautiful to read, nice illustrations and maps, great colour of pages, beautifully made, and reading this book is a pleasure, it is kind of romantic. I also have some books on poetry by wordsworth and kipling and i love just flicking through until something catches my eye. I don't feel it would be the same on a kindle. I also used to love the throw around type paperback, but more recently for great books, I prefer the hard back. Its a bit like people who watch TV, like a big screen.... well, I don't have a TV set I either read or listen to the radio (radio is a major love of my life too) , so I like the hardback book on some occasions. Typical thowaway novels, would be great on kindle, and I don't make trophies of my books, I have them sorted in Banana boxes, plus my friends and peers would have heart failure if they realised the books I own, read and have read, you see I was one of those street kids, who was relatively intelligent and took to reading.... My close friends from youth are either in prison, on drugs or generally bums...but they were my family as a younger person, so I still keep in touch, although books have created an abyss between us, and I find that hiding who I am now is easier for everyone...I have nothing to prove to my friends, nor do I want to make them feel that I can't appreciate them any longer, as I know they offer me loyalty, trust, and even money if I needed it, I know where they came from and so am not quick to judge them...but I most certainly don't want to intimidate them or make them feel distant from me. Most of them don't have a single book.
Digital books are also more accessible. You can change the font and size of the text to suit your needs, and the book will only ever weigh as much as your e-reader, no matter how long the book is. These are great features for disabled people. Physical books do have the added benefit of resale value. If you buy a physical book and you don't like it, you can sell it / donate it / give it to a friend. With an ebook you don't like, your only option is to return it for a refund. So... swings and roundabouts!
Totally identify with what your saying regarding the distraction of the book itself- my solution for myself has been to start the book on kindle and if after reading it feel I want it in the physical realm, then I buy it😊📚📚📘📖📚
I like the idea of people having pretty books as trophies for their shelves. There are a lot more considerations before you can determine which is better for you a physical book or a digital book. If you like reading in the bath, for example, a paperback is less risky, you really don't want to drop your phone with your kindle app in the bath.... If I'm reading a novel I prefer the physicality of a paperback. If I want the information handy wherever I am, like with some non-fiction tomes (eg 21 Lessons for the 21st Century or Why we Sleep) then it is much easier to have them on my Kindle app than to carry a burden of paperbacks around. A physical book never needs recharging, you just need the ability to read, a light source (and possibly glasses if you need them)...you don't have to worry about a dead battery, you don't have to be worried about being distracted with notifications etc...
Thing about physical books, besides the romantic and sillier but still credible notions theres still a valid reason why I prefer them... They don't need a battery, they're easier to lend out, I don't have to stare at a screen that long and in some cases it'll give me the motivation to finish a book I've started because I can see how far I've gotten into it.
I use all formats. I love the portability of my Kindle. While doing chores or driving, I enjoy audiobooks. I tend to read fiction on my Kindle. I like the Classics and History books in physical format for my library, because I do reread them or reference them.
I prefer ebooks. I just don't like to have so much physical stuffs, it gives me anxiety. I'm too minimalist to collect pysical books and will have this urge to discard them anyway once I finish reading them.
I used to prefer reading from old books. but sadly its not really accessible for me as i'm severely sight impaired so i'm not able to read the print in books now so i read eBooks and listen to audio books now. I have been a user of an e reader since Christmas 2015 and they have been so helpful for me as i can change the size of the font, make it bold and use my e reader with the natural light yellow so i don't have any blue light.
I like collecting hardcovers, reading paperbacks, and traveling with a kindle. I don't often purchase books unless it's a classic where I intend to annotate, or an exclusive edition of something I loved. My go-to method of acquiring books is borrowing from the public library (some of them are open for curbside pick-up during the pandemic where I'm at, and there is an e-reader catalogue as well). I read from a kindle because it's convenient, but I rather much prefer a paperback :D
Personally I read most books as ebooks because of the convenience of just one click buying them. If i come across a great book I buy a physical copy to my collection
I find it easier to read on paper, because I feel like the page is easier on my eyes, I can focus more, and the tactile connection motivates me to actually read. Seeing the book sitting on my shelf or table reminds me that I want to read that one. It's all too easy for me to ignore, or forget about reading if it's on my phone.
And to that end, of reading for the sake of reading without obligation, superseding ebook, audiobook, physical book, the ultimate way to read literature is via library. Which nowadays libraries provide all three formats. I think the time limit for me on borrowed books helps to motivate me too. Either I read the book in 3 weeks (or 6 weeks with the renewal) or I'm done with it. It's especially good for my personal problem of feeling the need to finish any book I start. If it's really got me hooked I will go through the trouble of waiting the 24 hours to return to pick up the book or even place the book on hold! And if I've really truly fallen in love with the book, I will buy it to support the author/local bookstore as well as for that ol nostalgia of having a trophy (oh, and for the re-reads!).
Though I admit the simplicity of the digital formats, if I have the resources for it, I prefer the physical format. With digital formats, I always get this dreading sense of forgetting the content when the e-ink disappears. Also, I can't just flip the pages rapidly whenever I want to revisit a certain point in the book. Holding a physical book gives me that calmness and assurances that the book got my back. I hope this opinion of mine can be understood 😅
Both forms have pros and cons. honestly, I don't really care whether it's digital or physical form as long as I get access to the content of the book..
I'm the middle-of-the-road girl who loves both physical books (preferably hardbound). However, I also love ebooks and audiobooks. I use all formats for different reasons. When at home, curled up I prefer my physical copies, when out on the go I prefer ebook or when lying in bed I read ebooks on my phone but when I am here at my computer in the day doing my work (I'm a publicist) I listen to audiobooks. So, really there are actually three camps, the total physical loyalists, those who love ebooks, and then us middle-of-the-roaders! :)
This may be a little bit niche, but one of the things I like about having a paperback or hardback book is that if it’s in my hands or on my desk/table, it’s easy for people who have also read it to spot it and point it out. This can lead to some interesting conversations and discussions, which is always really fun. This isn’t really possible with a digital book. Obviously, I have multiple other reasons for preferring physical books, but I feel like this is a perk that some may overlook.
There was a pretty bad crash for Nook in October. It was a virus and people couldn't access the books they had purchased. People lost their wish lists, too. If a book is cheaper in e-format, then I will pay for it for a first reading. I prefer used paperback copies, so that I'm not out much money if the book doesn't work out - I just trade it back in. But if I absolutely love it, I buy a pbk reading copy and and then at my leisure, look for one in a nice binding and save up for that. That way I have something to mark up and take notes in, plus something I just enjoy having around me because it is beautiful and I know is good. I have never fallen into the trap of buying a book for its cover. I don't think many people do. Well, I take that back - I bought the anniversary edition of Fahrenheit 451 in paperback because it had a duplicate of the original cover. That was a fun find!
In defence of physical books, I have to argue that they are more than just words they contain, but an overall experience. I find the feeling of the pages against my fingers and the momentary stimulation I receive when I turn each page helps to regulate my senses and adjust my thinking - thereby focusing my brain. On top of that, there is just something timeless and sentimental about a physical book, whereas digital books lack character. Ultimately, I find reading e-books akin to a sterile, clinical experience rather than something to be relished.
There is always something romantic about paper books.
I live in a third world country , basically i pirate online books for knowledge , it has been the only way up until maybe one day I'd get to buy physical books one day , i mean I am so jealous of those people who have barnes and noble 5 minutes away from their house and they never get anything
About e-books as well, actually
Roman*
Yeah. And THAT, is the danger. And I'm speaking as a physical-book lover.
@@gamerjojo4591 I too live in a third world country. Can you tell me about those pirating sites? Or what apps you use?
People don't understand that I just don't just want books to read them. Just having them around makes me feel better. Stacks of books on my desk or a paperback in my hands. I'm going to build a library like the beast from Beauty and the Beast. Books make me feel calm and safe. Their presence is magic.
So true haha
so true. I just like seeing and structuring them every day
Probably cause theyre trees so you would be living nature
(edit: which is why you might feel comfortable around them,also cause they dont betray.)
I agree with you. My mom has worked in a library my whole life and the smell of all those books together is enchanting. The different ages and textures of the pages give a smell that is comparable to a choir's variation of voices.
Also add some Glock there for calm and safe presence
I don't have a house, so having e-books is kind of convenient, don't have to carry them from place to place.
Totally makes sense. I personally like paperback books for the feel to it, and so I can read them and keep them in a library, until I have a small library at home.
Yep. There’s something special about paperback that’s irreplaceable by e-books but considering the lack of space, e-book is my choice. Still hopefully one day I will have my own library full of paperbacks of my favs 🌻
I have a house and when I move, packing boxes and boxes of books is a royal pain in the a**
same!
ig before reading start working to get a house to stay 😂jk
paperback is god-tier. granted, i do a lot of reading books in digital form. but paperback hits different, the connection i make with the physical book i have on my hands is sacred. it's like the book grows with me, collecting stains and scratches and words scribbled along its passages. this sense of permanence is something i dream of looking back to and that any digital format cannot compare with. i'm nineteen and i'm too sentimental for my age haha
Just what i wanted to say but never could explain what was so special about paper books!!
i'm 19 and i feel exaaactly the same way. physical books are magic
wow you just summed it up
No such thing as "too sentimental", or at least, not with books
paperbacks truly are something else. nothing compares
"digital vs physical books?" i would say just get whichever you can get/borrow for free. seriously, i feel that when i buy a book/e-book with my own money, i feel kind of obligated to finish reading it so i dont "waste" the money, even if i may not actually enjoy the book for what it is. but when i download a free pdf (from project gutenberg i dont advocate illegal e-books) or borrow from the library, i read for the enjoyment and the book itself rather than forcing myself to read it to milk every cent i spent on it. then if i like it i can go and actually buy the physical book if i want. that's just my way of doing it, so you do you.
edit: phrasing and spelling (i spelt "gutenberg" as "glutenberg" lmao)
Same, Gutenberg and library genesis have always been best of my friends.
@@nottletottle yeah, even more so when the kindle book costs as much as the paperback version
Yes. Exactly... I was about to say... just go to the library. Sometimes they will even buy the book you are looking for.
I don’t think having that attitude helps authors make a living. If everyone just borrows books, writers won’t be able to support themselves.
@@josephvlogsdon hmm that's true, but i'll try to support the author when i really do like the book
"Paperbacks"
*knocks on hardback*
Bravo.
Personally There's just something about reading a physical book that can't be replaced by digital books
So true...
You are right. I can smell my books and sleep with them. I loved every good books I have. That's one of the difference .
I personally read the book as an epub first, and if i liked it, i'll buy the physical copy
@@Beige647 Why do people always talk about smelling books? I don't think I've ever done that.
@@samdobie6748 Hey!
Only those book lovers can relate... 😅
Without sounding like an ass, my intention is to read, so the format doesn't really matter to me 🤷♀️
Same :)
Yay!
Agreed. I have a feeling that people judge me for reading books on my phone tho. Idk why is it so weird for them hahah
same!!
@@planomery9831 Doesn't that hurt your eyes after a long time?
@@VandalVortex it doesn't hahaha i have an app for easier reading of books in pdf format and you can change brightness, background colour and many more!
Kindle is good for minimalists and people don't like to have too much stuff
this !
the portability is also a plus
I've recently changed up my whole philosophy(?) on books. Before, I used to buy books, read them once, and they'd sit on my shelf for years while I reread some of my favorites or moved onto new books. For me, it WAS about the prestige/accomplishment of having read so many books. I'd walk in to my house, see all the books I read, and I'd feel a little more intellectually superior because "wow I really have read a lot!" But recently, I've changed that.
Instead of just buying books endlessly, I now will go to bookstores a couple times a year, pick out 3 or 4 books each trip, and bring them home, while reading everything else on e-book from the library. I then only keep the books that I really liked, that I'd actually reread again, and donate the ones that I wasn't really in love with to the library. (Especially in the case of the library e-books. I would only buy a physical copy once I know I LOVE it.)
I did this for multiple reasons. 1. I love physical books. I need physical books, especially because I get anxiety over the idea that technology may not always be around, so if I don't have a physical copy, I may not be able to read it again. (Which is fine, because I reread books so much that it's actually a worthwhile investment to have a copy with me.) 2. I also like book shopping in stores and want to support my local book stores. Plus, it helps go back to fulfilling that need to actually have a physical copy with me. 3. I also believe in supporting local libraries (both by donation and by being active as a reader), so I try to do as much for them as I can.
As a result, I've cleared out my bookshelf of all the books that I didn't love (I went from about 600 to 150), donated all the rest, and have been able to read more now that I'm constantly switching back and forth between e-book (which I can take everywhere easily!) and paperback (which I love reading in the comforts of my home). Also, it has really helped my library, as they were grateful to have so many YA novels, especially since no one ever seems to donate any. (Which, I guess, is expected, because most young people aren't used to donating books or aren't interested in it.)
And now that I've done that, I actually find myself being MORE proud of all the books I've read, because if I can fill a bookshelf full of books that I LOVE, that inspired me, and I can keep growing that collection, that means that I've actually done more than just read a book. It means that I've read tons of books, and out of all the ones that I've read, I've gone through and selectively picked out the ones that meant the most to me, and that I've taken care of them and treasured them!
So instead of saying which is better, why not both?!
From my teenage years onward, I've always had a collection of books. When my grandfather died, I got saddled with his 3000+ book library. As someone who has moved a lot (I've lived in 5 different countries, and moved over 35 times), I definitely see the advantage of an e-reader and the digital format. My kobo has about 1500 titles, and the ability to check books out from the public library over my device is fantastic as well. That said, I still love the look of the Harvard Classics, and other hardcover favourites on my bookshelf. In the end, both the traditional format and the e-reader are both still very effective at waking you up if you drop them on your face after briefly falling asleep.
the feeling of turning pages and feeling the texture of the pages really does something. i love the smell of books, I love being able to shut the book dramatically when things just *BOOM* in a book, you know what i mean. i sometimes love placing a book page open on my chest when things just get emotional or so happy. i love admiring the cover after I’ve finished reading. hardcover books with etched on titles really has my heart. nothing can ever replace physical books.
i like digital reading too, it’s really convenient i do it often and it’s us adapting to the new technologies invented and we should make use of it but replacing physical books completely is not going to happen, digital books cannot give you the sense of warmth a physical book does and i always always prefer physical books.
My issue with e-books/pdfs is largely that I prefer to get away from screens when I'm reading a book. The experience of a physical book helps me to focus both on the content and on the act of reading. There is no navigating a digital menu, there is no temptation to switch to something else on the same device. I want to be able to flip through the pages like nothing when I need the index, or to reference something from a previous chapter. I also find it easy to forget the contents of a digital library. just some thoughts.
Not only is a physical copy convenient for an index, but also if there is a map, footnotes, or reference notes in a section at the back of the book.
To me, a Kindle is so much lighter to handle with one hand while having the other hand free. Whereas with physical books, you're always fighting the pages from closing on you and performing amazing feats of finger gymnastics when attempting to drink a coffee with one hand whilst maintaining 'Infinite Jest' on page seven-hundred-and-something with the other shaky hand. Also, the ability to tap on any word and get a pop-up definition has been revolutionary to me. No more pulling the phone out every few minutes to google a word which takes you out of the reading zone. No more searching for glorious reading light. No more hiding-the-cover from people because you don't want them to know what you're trying to know. Above all, no more hand cramps.
I noticed that I am able to remember things better from a book if I read it in a physical format. And somehow it feels nostalgic for me. I'm happy you chose this subject. I guess that as long as we read something, that's what matters.
Digital Book = Alternative book for active readers who dislikes carrying a lot of stuff outside
Hardback = Collection purposes
Paperback = Old school book to go anywhere. (Still prefer this even though the digital book is a new alternative for active readers, I hate when I'm on my phone for a long time lol)
Maybe try an e-reader?
@@a.m.641 Isn't an ebook a type of Digital Book? I only use e-book when there's no stock left of paperbacks on both local/online bookstores that I could receive within days. Then I proceed on buying an hardback for my collection since I had read it on e-book.
@@MeandBfriend Yes, it is, but I meant an e-reader (e-ink device) because of what you said about being on the phone for a long time
@@a.m.641 oh like those kobos got it!
Same here!
as a classic literature admirer, physical books just put me there in the zone therefore i always buy my classics, but when it comes to other genres that i am quite reluctant if i will like them or not, i usually dont buy them unless i love them to an extent that i plan to re read them in the future, i buy them only if i have this kind of connection with them that will make me want to see them there on my shelf. my dream is to collect a whole library of books that embodies my life, so buying random books just look very unnecessary to me, and quite taxing as well.
I read digital first. If I like the book enough, I'll get a physical copy. So most of the physical books I own are pieces that I honestly liked.
Omg same!
This.
Reading, for me, has always been an escape from screens. I spend so much time looking at a monitor or phone screen as is, so the thought of having to look at yet another screen to read fills me with dread.
I like to keep a physical book on the nightstand, so I can read a dozen pages before I go to bed. (Currently, it's Sedaris' essay collection) But e-readers are easier to deal with on the train.
I feel like the physicality of a book and the sense of obligation is sometimes good for certain types of readers starting off such as reluctant readers or people who don't read for enjoyment but want to get into it. I do agree that is easy to fall into the trap of viewing these acomplishments as trophies which is what I certainly did at one point. But as of now although my preference is physical books I am certainly happy to read on my kindle too, beacause at the end of the day it is the content that matters most :))))))
I love having the physical book, however, there is one major advantage of having a kindle (at least for me) and that is being able to look up words I don't fully understand just by tapping on them. (Dictionary function)
Loved this video! Never seen this stance put so clearly. You are totally right!.
Also, since I switched to ebooks I am reading way more. I can read anywhere as the Kindle is very light, I can take it to the pool or to the beach and it wont get ruin, I can read in the dark, I can also read without hands! (you need the right cover for this) so I can read and eat or crochet or whatever at the same time. And dont get me started on the built in dictionary to read in other languages!
After getting used to all the Kindle advantages I just found paper books too uncomfortable to read from. Sure they look amazing, but as you said they are trophies and with one glance anyone that visits you can know that you are a reader, an intellectual, but that's just ego food. But there is another side... having paper books motivates other people to read, get children curious about reading, and that's amazing!!!. So I propose we read the ebook and if we love it THEN we get the paper version and everyone wins: your ego, your kids, your friends, the author. Or well, at least that's what I will do when I settle down somewhere.
Mannnnnnn this is sooooo relatable!!
When i read the paperback all i wanna do is finish it and put it on a shelf(as you said the "trap") contents of the book become somehow less important to me.
Just to not get distracted by the cover and stuff i changed to the digital and tbh i am literally enjoying the content more than the physicality of the book.
I'm a theatre major and often times it's super difficult to get my hands on a physical script unless I drive over two hours to a specific bookshop or order online. I don't often use e-readers to read novels but it is a lifesaver when it comes to scripts. I end up reading about 3-4 a week in my spare time and it's so wonderful to be able to expand my knowledge on the world of theatre. I don't even have a kindle actually, I have the kindle app on my phone which makes it even more accessible. Gosh I'm so happy to have been born in a digital era for that alone
I’ve had 3 kindles in the past 10 years and they’re something I would never give up having, but this year I started buying physical books again and I feel like I’m a new reader. I like having the option of reading anything anywhere but holding a real book in my hands just motivates me to finish it - like what you said, if I’m reading a book on a kindle I just move on to the next one too easily if I don’t like it.
I am a slow reader, tech destroyed my ability to enjoy a book so I prefer ebook readers far better than books, just reading it on a digital screen is easier for me. Also, Its really convenient: I can get free (legal) ebooks and store thousands on them inside a single little device.
Still, I really like paperback, and just their design and how they look on my desk is cool.
Physical books, their smell is incompatible, nobody can deny that, in addition to that it is a bliss to carry a book rather than taking your kindle
I know this is super weird, But when I smell new books that have just been bought I feel like I am getting high on some sort of drug. Yeah, you are right.
I personally don’t like the smell of new books.
@@unbelibubble7864 that means you like the smell of old books? Isn't it?
I love the smell of old books. I also like how library's smell with old and new books together. It's intoxicating.
There’s nothing that can replace a physical book, but I have found a lot of freedom through renting ebooks from my library. There’s zero commitment, no money spent, no worrying if this book was good enough to be kept on my shelves. I’ve read a lot more and a broader range of books since using ebooks. Everything is at my fingertips. I’m a re-reader, so if I loved an ebook enough, I will purchase a physical copy since physical books are just irreplaceable to me as an avid reader!
In past I was against e-books to read on laptop/ipad because of them causing eyestrain after long sessions. Now after getting proper e-ink device, I don't really support paper books anymore. There are simply a series of advantages for e-reader device: convenient to annotate, motivation - all features of device are very refined to focus on content and eliminate disturbance, time to return to reading is really small, some of my paper books are abandoned as I've deliberately decided skip them - no problem for e-reader. Also I found out that using built-in illumination of e-ink screen does subtract from experience, so I keep it turned off constantly. Of course I really miss the book smell, and there is no way imitate it. Still some paper books can have chemical/unpleasant smell. And as for audiobooks the important rule for me is to listen only if properly focused and not doing something thoughtful simultaneously.
I used to be really snooby and only read physical books, but in the past four years I have moved 6-8 times. Packing books was such a pain so I switched to kindle last year and its been great
I like the feeling of a physical book, it motivates me to read. But I have read many books on my Kindle that I couldn't find on physical, so that's a clear advantage. The selection of physical books that make it to my country is not very diverse (usually bestsellers).
Here's my approach: I prefer physical books, but will generally follow whichever route is cheaper. When I'm looking for a certain book, I will almost always check my local used bookstore to see if they have it first. Most of my books come from there. If that doesn't work, and I'm dying to read that particular book, I'll check the price of shipping a paperback against an ebook's price and then buy the cheaper one, going for paperback if they're about equal. On top of this, I regularly check for deals on my phone on Google Play Books, as I've found that I've been able to get some stupidly cheap ebooks on there. I also borrow books quite a bit. This means that I regularly switch between the formats when reading.
This approach works best for me because my situation is such that price is certainly an object for me, but not too much so, and also because I don't mind used books.
No hardcovers though. Overly expensive and physically awkward to read. Screw that noise.
It's also worth adding that the built in dictionary on Kindle can make a big difference on your enjoyment of the book, especially for classic literature where the author might use words that are less common today.
For printed books, I have a lot to consider before reading them (condensed paperback are cheap but the font is too tiny and the format is squeezed, giant hardcover books are hard to hold, some paperback books can’t open flat, etc) whereas for ebook I usually could customize my font and format, and usually the legal ones have good format. However, I do realize that reading a good printed book does enhance the enjoyment I get from a book, but it’s just hard to choose the right one.
Going digital has made me save so much. I haven't bought any physical books after purchasing an e-reader - the only exceptions are the art or more technical ones. If I ever settle somewhere I might buy my favorite ones in the future, though
Books may not be difficult to acquire, but for sure they’re still symbols of status: the status of being “cultured” and the status of “being able to afford the pretty hardcover edition”, specially in booktube
I understand the appeal of physical books but I prefer digital format for environmental reasons (for when I buy, not borrow) and also because e ink is easier on my eyes. I can adjust the font and read while my partner is asleep without disturbing him. It’s also incredibly easy for me to check out books using my library and return them. I no longer waste time on books I’m not enjoying because there’s zero obligation to finish it. I didn’t spend money on it and I can just check out a new book to see if it’s more interesting to me.
A book is a book. I think whatever is convenient/affordable/available to people is what matters. I prefer the reading experience of a traditional paper book, but I often borrow ebooks or audiobooks from my library to read for the first time and if I really connect with the content I’ll invest in my own physical copy.
For me, it's a matter of convenience and experience. I've lost two separate houses to fires (yay, California living), and both times I lost beautiful personal libraries of physical books. So for now, I'm going almost entirely digital. I own a Kobo, which is tiny and light enough for me to take everywhere. I can fit a few hundred books on it at a time. I do enjoy the experience of holding a physical book, but this way, I can take my entire library with me in a time of emergency, and that's very important to me personally.
You’re right !!!
Here I come free digital pdf books 📚
In all seriousness, I used to care about having a paperback copy, but I started to buy online books recently and my mindset has changed. I could care more now. If I enjoy a book, I will enjoy it in whatever medium I access it. I also, enjoy audiobooks, but I prefer seeing the letters and words for myself. I enjoy reading them out loud myself. Books are beautiful.
As you say, the important thing is the content of the book. For me, digital books are much more practical, however, the format is indifferent to me, I prefer digital ones of course, but I also understand the feeling that some comments talk about reading physical books, in the end you also have to take into account what that improves the experience, but I already stayed with the digital ones
Having physical books in a house means living with them, it's a different kind of connection. Also they create good discussions about them when friends and family visits the house and start looking at what I've got.
I've lived in 3 countries within 1.5 years, and the kindle saved my life. I only travelled with 2 suitcases, and could not have been able log all the books I wanted to read/buy with me. That being said, a physical copy hits different. Kindle reminds me too much of my phone, so I can't relax with it the same way I can with a physical copy.
Also, let me add that digital formats have significantly increased the time I can spend with a book. Because of a chronic illness, I was unable to hold a book up for longer periods of time + my eyes can get really tired. Digital formats definitely increase the accessibility to books!
I like them all.
For non fiction, I prefer ebooks (for better notes taking interface and immediately available search option).
For fiction, I prefer paper books.
For biographies and such, I use Audible while doing some chore, or painting.
I have however gone 100% digital (off late) in an attempt to minimize my book management time (sun drying the books, dusting, arranging, relocating the silver fishes, et al.).
I used to be firmly in the physical book side of the argument. However, I'm more on the fence. I now want to own less material items and be more minimalist.
At the start of this year, I started going to the library to borrow books rather than buying them. With lockdown closing the library, I read a lot of ebooks this year. When libraries reopened I started going back. If it's not available I'll get it for my kindle.
As someone who reads both kinds, i find myself really enjoying the paperback experience a lot as i feel connected to it but at the same time, digital books are so convenient that i read through the books so fast without knowing as i can bring them wherever i go, without having to bring a huge weight when i go out. So i say, BOTH
When I first started reading I started using the kindle app on my phone, a year later I decided to get the actual kindle device because I started reading a lot more.
And because I read a lot more, I started going into bookstores because I just wanted to look at books but that just lead me to buying a physical book and enjoying it a lot more.
I’ve got a mini library going on right now too :)
the first books that made me feel the magic of reading were physical books. in those days, physical books were the only ones widely available. and i will always relate the magical feeling to physical books most. over the years, i’ve read more and become more aware of my likes and dislikes. that same magic is harder to come by these days. and i don’t think it’s got to do with the fact that i’m reading more ebooks now. i’ve simply moved on along my reading experience and (hopefully) levelled up as a reader. i fall into the zone harder and it sometimes feel like i need to read a lot more books to find those that i like. so statistically, ebooks tend to feel more laborious than my early days of reading physical books. still, i try to avoid thinking that physical books are therefore better than ebooks. and the absence of clutter and ease of management of a digital library are absolutely worth it vs. the smell of ink and paper
My mom has worked in a library my whole life and the smell of all those books together is enchanting. The different ages and textures of the pages give a smell that is comparable to a choir's variation of voices. I do like the word wise aspect of digital books though. I can click on a word to get an exact pronunciation, find its origin and multiple meanings. Then I make note cards, all in one app. If I like the book enough, I buy the hard copy.
I have to move between college and my house every 3 months or so. Moving requires transportation between several bus stops/trains stops + airports. So digital copies ftw 😂 although I do keep several physical copies.
I personally dislike reading paperbacks because it's hard to determine a comfortable position. You also have to be very careful in order to preserve the book's "freshness". I could throw my kindle across the room and it will still work fine without any visible sign of damage.
E-books are far easier to acquire and manage. I can read them on my phone or Kindle, and I can read them anywhere, just pulling it out of my pocket.
Although, nothing compares to the experience of flipping through a physical book, especially when books have appendices, dictionaries and maps that supplement the story through constant reference.
That being said, if I finish an e-book and it really resonates with me, I purchase a physical copy. As a trophy for my shelf, and because I can re-read it in physical form next time.
I prefer digital books. Easier to carry around and eco friendly at its best. Besides, it’s so much easier to buy one. You just click and start reading instantly literally anywhere. not to say it’s sometimes much cheaper.
I personally find physical books really captivating aesthetical objects, but, ethically speaking, I believe that digital books are the way to go, since they offer access to the text without the environmental impact of physical books.
Hi Robin. I'm a book person. I love my books. After university, and reading books for 12 years, I always fell back on my book seller here in Montreal. I curate books, that, yes, resonate with me. I spend countless hours walking the shop, looking and reading dust covers. During the Harry Potter series, our book sellers went to great lengths to get us into the shop at midnight for the next release. Books are life for me. A way to see the world in all its gory ugliness and beauty. I've got a pretty nice library of pretty books, that I've actually read. I don't just collect pretty covers. Each book is an experience, a destination. Pandemic has forced us onto the digital book seller site, which is really useful but not the same as wandering the stacks for hours. I need the pages, the smell and the feel of a book. Digital is so non-personal to me. Not the format I want to enjoy carrying in my backpack. I want the physical book !!
Also looking down on people who read digital books can be ablest, for some people who have dyslexia for example, it can be difficult to read a physical book because of the font size, the font used, the colour of the paper ect, all things that can be changed on an ereader making books more accessible to people like that.
I've been in the trap of physicality for years and have a bunch of unread books on my shelf. I got a Kindle recently and I've fallen in love with reading. I personally find better appreciation for the text, and my focus has driven far away from the way it looks. "Don't judge a book by it's cover". Yeah for me that's easier said than done. 😂 Also big books used to scare me.
reading in the phone was making my head aches and my vision was getting worse, so kindle was a good option. also, i’ve noticed that i read faster in these digital formats... like he said: reading is what truly matters.
Physical books all the way
Man thiae thumb nails are beautiful and simple. Everything about this channel is beauty with simplicity. Amazing. Keep it up bro
i love physical books a lot, but i had to adapt to ebooks because of my rhinitis, that's when i learned that the important thing is the content and not just the beautiful cover. :)
I do both but I usually read things first on my Kindle (through Libby) and if I love it then I buy it. You can’t beat the convenience of reading on a Kindle. You can read whenever and however and be comfortable doing it. Also! No reason to have a bookshelf full of books you’re just “eh” about. Showcase the ones that paint a picture of who you are and what’s lead you there.
Over the past year, I've been buying almost exclusively digital books. There are a lot of reasons, but there are two primary motivators. 1. I've been doing a lot more focused reading for retention, using Kindle highlights, porting through various apps like Instapaper, Readwise, and compiling everything in Notion. It automates all of my notes and highlights in one place for review and further retention. 2. I have a big problem having a shipping company drag their trucks half way across the country to put a book in my hands. Bookstores around here aren't an option, so the footprint involved with me getting physical books makes me ill. With very few exceptions, I'll probably be removing all traces of physical books from my life in the near future. For what and how I read now, physical books are getting harder to justify.
At the end of the day, no version is superior to the other. I enjoy both formats. Ebooks are more accessible since I can carry plenty of them on my phone or tablet or laptop without occupying much space. So I can go on vacation for several weeks and take several books with me without worrying about a physical book or two taking up too much space in my suitcase. They also tend to be cheaper, if not free, more readily available, and eco friendly. But as someone in her late 20s who grew up reading physical books first, there is something about holding a copy in your hand, smelling the book (the older, the better), physically turning the page and feeling a sense of accoplishment as I see the number of pages read get higher and higher, and one side getting thicker, about putting a book down after having finished it. A physical book is also a cheap way to decorate your room/house. I personally use both. I get ebooks for the novels that I know I won't feel the need to reread, and physical books in novels that I know I will keep going back to, and as a result want to keep in my permanent collection
the penguin classics lined up on the shelf behind you are SO satisfying
I remembered commenting about this in one of your videos 3 weeks ago. So glad you took the time to share us your opinion about it! Thanks!
Usually I buy physical books that I know I'm going to re-read in the future. That's why it's important for me to atleast read few pages of the book or at least I have researched several information about the book before purchasing a physical copy of it. What I find is non-fiction and fictions books that hits hard and sort of have some relevance with my life is something I keep physically. While if it's just for the pure enjoyment of reading, I prefer the e-book copy as I know I am going to just read it in once.
kindle if I want to read a lot of books in a short amount of time, physical if I want to have it as a trophy.
One of the best advocates for digital I’ve seen. Also, validating to know how many others feel the same attraction toward physical books haha
Two things I truly appreciate about this video. One, you're giving permission to put down a book that isn't resonating with a reader rather than recommending they slog it out just to say they finished it. Life's too short for a completionist mentality when it comes to literature. Two, a vlogger who actually uses "resonate" correctly in a sentence. That is a rarity on RUclips for some reason, as "resonate" gets used often and almost always incorrectly by far too many vloggers. I would hit like twice for those two points if it worked that way.
as someone who is young and as everyone pretty telephone/social media addicted, i find my kindle pretty helpful because instead of scrolling through tiktok i can trick my brain in using a mobile device in kindle form. also ereader motivated me to read more and i read multiple books on there because many books are free and you dont have to run to bookstorw to buy a ebook.
Love how amazon lets you download a sample of the book on kindle app. Especially being able to review the table of contents
When I had babies and needed to use only one hand to hold the device, read, and turn pages, an ereader was amazing. For years it was the cheapest way to go for books and perfect for travel. Prices have increased on ebooks since 15 years ago! If it's the same cost as a book, I'd rather buy a book then pass it on locally. Life gets busy with three children. I forget to charge it so it becomes a frustration. It's much more convenient to notice there is free time for extra reading, grab the physical copy, and sit to read. My kids prefer physical copies of books, too. A graphic novel on a kindle can't compare. I also couldn't imagine books like The Arrival by Shaun Tan or the Illuminae Files having quite the same impact in an ebook. We buy used books and it generally costs us less than ebooks. Both are great for different reasons and each reader will find what fits their life.
Dude you are amazing! I just started watching your videos and I have never found someone as interesting as you
Back where I used to live buying books wasn't feasible. The prices were astronomical and there was barely any variety and a limited stock (I'm talking 4-5 copies per title), not to talk about the fact that there were _no_ hardcovers at all, only paperbacks; so I got used to reading digitally.
Now I live somewhere where paperback and hardcover books are available and relatively cheap, but I got so used to reading e-books that I find that I have to really force myself and make a conscious effort to keep reading when it's a physical book.
The only exception is for rereading a book I like, which means I probably decided on getting a physical copy, too.
actually this is exactly the strategy that i've been using for the lasr couple of years! i only buy books which cannot be found online, the ones with extraordinary illustrations or just stuff that i know is going to be a spectacular read. otherwise i go to the library or use the pdf/epub version :)
I read books to reduce my screentime. Picking up a kindle or ipad or iphone to read doesn't feel like a break. I also am the type of reader that needs a pen in hand to focus. I need to know I can write all over the book. If I don't feel like spending money on a book because I don't think I'll love it or won't write all over it, then I request it from my library. I like to buy secondhand from goodwills online too.
And there's me who starts ebooks and enjoy it so much that I feel guilty that I didn't get the physical vertion of it.
True! Instant regret 😂
Personally, I'm just happy when people read. I read mostly ebooks because I travel alot. Space is always a problem and books are heavy. My Kindle has been a lifesaver for my arms and shoulders. It is also waterproof, nice for beaches!
Completely unrelated, but as a Chem major I’m LIVING for your shirt
I feel the reason why I love physical books (hard copy or paper) is in a way romantic. For me personally I love read a book and mark the pages with beautiful and meaningful quotes and add little notes in the margins - in a way hoping that in a later period of time someone - anyone will come across it and read the quotes, read the margins and understand my perspective, it’s to keep my ideas and perceptions immortal. I don’t know if this is me being a hopeless romantic but that is why I love physical copies.
physical books are like being surrounded by art, you actually fall in love with your personal library, and i also love the different sizes and types...
I am at a screen all day every day, and find screens most excellent for short snippets of information, but once that info gets large, i need the book, as the screen kind of repels me.
i think the kindles are great for travelling, or for reading easy fun literature, but once a thing gets hard, eg organic chemistry, philosophy, or even serious history, I just can't do this kind of thing on a kindle. Maybe it is my age and how i was introduced to reading.
Another thing is, I get satisfaction from knowing where I am in a book, half way , nearly done or whatever, it is far more rewarding in that sense.
Some books eg one I am reading right now is a book about the battles of Waterloo, and the book is beautiful to read, nice illustrations and maps, great colour of pages, beautifully made, and reading this book is a pleasure, it is kind of romantic.
I also have some books on poetry by wordsworth and kipling and i love just flicking through until something catches my eye. I don't feel it would be the same on a kindle.
I also used to love the throw around type paperback, but more recently for great books, I prefer the hard back. Its a bit like people who watch TV, like a big screen.... well, I don't have a TV set I either read or listen to the radio (radio is a major love of my life too) , so I like the hardback book on some occasions.
Typical thowaway novels, would be great on kindle, and I don't make trophies of my books, I have them sorted in Banana boxes, plus my friends and peers would have heart failure if they realised the books I own, read and have read, you see I was one of those street kids, who was relatively intelligent and took to reading.... My close friends from youth are either in prison, on drugs or generally bums...but they were my family as a younger person, so I still keep in touch, although books have created an abyss between us, and I find that hiding who I am now is easier for everyone...I have nothing to prove to my friends, nor do I want to make them feel that I can't appreciate them any longer, as I know they offer me loyalty, trust, and even money if I needed it, I know where they came from and so am not quick to judge them...but I most certainly don't want to intimidate them or make them feel distant from me.
Most of them don't have a single book.
Digital books are also more accessible. You can change the font and size of the text to suit your needs, and the book will only ever weigh as much as your e-reader, no matter how long the book is. These are great features for disabled people.
Physical books do have the added benefit of resale value. If you buy a physical book and you don't like it, you can sell it / donate it / give it to a friend. With an ebook you don't like, your only option is to return it for a refund.
So... swings and roundabouts!
Totally identify with what your saying regarding the distraction of the book itself- my solution for myself has been to start the book on kindle and if after reading it feel I want it in the physical realm, then I buy it😊📚📚📘📖📚
I like the idea of people having pretty books as trophies for their shelves. There are a lot more considerations before you can determine which is better for you a physical book or a digital book. If you like reading in the bath, for example, a paperback is less risky, you really don't want to drop your phone with your kindle app in the bath.... If I'm reading a novel I prefer the physicality of a paperback. If I want the information handy wherever I am, like with some non-fiction tomes (eg 21 Lessons for the 21st Century or Why we Sleep) then it is much easier to have them on my Kindle app than to carry a burden of paperbacks around. A physical book never needs recharging, you just need the ability to read, a light source (and possibly glasses if you need them)...you don't have to worry about a dead battery, you don't have to be worried about being distracted with notifications etc...
Thing about physical books, besides the romantic and sillier but still credible notions theres still a valid reason why I prefer them... They don't need a battery, they're easier to lend out, I don't have to stare at a screen that long and in some cases it'll give me the motivation to finish a book I've started because I can see how far I've gotten into it.
I use all formats. I love the portability of my Kindle. While doing chores or driving, I enjoy audiobooks. I tend to read fiction on my Kindle. I like the Classics and History books in physical format for my library, because I do reread them or reference them.
I prefer ebooks. I just don't like to have so much physical stuffs, it gives me anxiety. I'm too minimalist to collect pysical books and will have this urge to discard them anyway once I finish reading them.
I used to prefer reading from old books. but sadly its not really accessible for me as i'm severely sight impaired so i'm not able to read the print in books now so i read eBooks and listen to audio books now. I have been a user of an e reader since Christmas 2015 and they have been so helpful for me as i can change the size of the font, make it bold and use my e reader with the natural light yellow so i don't have any blue light.
I like collecting hardcovers, reading paperbacks, and traveling with a kindle. I don't often purchase books unless it's a classic where I intend to annotate, or an exclusive edition of something I loved. My go-to method of acquiring books is borrowing from the public library (some of them are open for curbside pick-up during the pandemic where I'm at, and there is an e-reader catalogue as well). I read from a kindle because it's convenient, but I rather much prefer a paperback :D
Personally I read most books as ebooks because of the convenience of just one click buying them. If i come across a great book I buy a physical copy to my collection
I find it easier to read on paper, because I feel like the page is easier on my eyes, I can focus more, and the tactile connection motivates me to actually read. Seeing the book sitting on my shelf or table reminds me that I want to read that one. It's all too easy for me to ignore, or forget about reading if it's on my phone.
And to that end, of reading for the sake of reading without obligation, superseding ebook, audiobook, physical book, the ultimate way to read literature is via library. Which nowadays libraries provide all three formats. I think the time limit for me on borrowed books helps to motivate me too. Either I read the book in 3 weeks (or 6 weeks with the renewal) or I'm done with it. It's especially good for my personal problem of feeling the need to finish any book I start. If it's really got me hooked I will go through the trouble of waiting the 24 hours to return to pick up the book or even place the book on hold! And if I've really truly fallen in love with the book, I will buy it to support the author/local bookstore as well as for that ol nostalgia of having a trophy (oh, and for the re-reads!).
Though I admit the simplicity of the digital formats, if I have the resources for it, I prefer the physical format. With digital formats, I always get this dreading sense of forgetting the content when the e-ink disappears. Also, I can't just flip the pages rapidly whenever I want to revisit a certain point in the book. Holding a physical book gives me that calmness and assurances that the book got my back. I hope this opinion of mine can be understood 😅
Physical. Can't beat the feeling of paper and a book cover in your hands.
I have to say that buying a kindle was one of the best decisions I ever made
Both forms have pros and cons. honestly, I don't really care whether it's digital or physical form as long as I get access to the content of the book..
I'm the middle-of-the-road girl who loves both physical books (preferably hardbound). However, I also love ebooks and audiobooks. I use all formats for different reasons. When at home, curled up I prefer my physical copies, when out on the go I prefer ebook or when lying in bed I read ebooks on my phone but when I am here at my computer in the day doing my work (I'm a publicist) I listen to audiobooks. So, really there are actually three camps, the total physical loyalists, those who love ebooks, and then us middle-of-the-roaders! :)
This may be a little bit niche, but one of the things I like about having a paperback or hardback book is that if it’s in my hands or on my desk/table, it’s easy for people who have also read it to spot it and point it out. This can lead to some interesting conversations and discussions, which is always really fun. This isn’t really possible with a digital book.
Obviously, I have multiple other reasons for preferring physical books, but I feel like this is a perk that some may overlook.
There was a pretty bad crash for Nook in October. It was a virus and people couldn't access the books they had purchased. People lost their wish lists, too.
If a book is cheaper in e-format, then I will pay for it for a first reading. I prefer used paperback copies, so that I'm not out much money if the book doesn't work out - I just trade it back in. But if I absolutely love it, I buy a pbk reading copy and and then at my leisure, look for one in a nice binding and save up for that. That way I have something to mark up and take notes in, plus something I just enjoy having around me because it is beautiful and I know is good.
I have never fallen into the trap of buying a book for its cover. I don't think many people do. Well, I take that back - I bought the anniversary edition of Fahrenheit 451 in paperback because it had a duplicate of the original cover. That was a fun find!
In defence of physical books, I have to argue that they are more than just words they contain, but an overall experience. I find the feeling of the pages against my fingers and the momentary stimulation I receive when I turn each page helps to regulate my senses and adjust my thinking - thereby focusing my brain. On top of that, there is just something timeless and sentimental about a physical book, whereas digital books lack character. Ultimately, I find reading e-books akin to a sterile, clinical experience rather than something to be relished.
"The content is the same, it's just the format"
"The medium is the message" McLuhan