Yes, obviously our family ancestors in Europe were smart enough/lucky enough to get the heck out of these places and maybe go into the countryside. Or just be in remote areas and not come out during that mess.
A certain immunity is always present for some people, and many religious practices are simple hygiene bases. Somebody figured out that having dirty hands make people sick, so god tells you to wash your hands, same with the circumcision and removing the blood of the butchered animals etc. They did not know how, but they know something was bad and they fund a solution.
I don't blame them for thinking it was the end of the world. It must of felt like that. Especially since the world population was way lower then , so that who died was a huge % of world population...
@@getmeouttahere3595 I mean over 15000000 people died of covid. Still a large number. Covids a wake up call cause there's plenty of diseases with pandemic potential that have a much higher virulence and covid only had a 0.06 percent mortality rate. Mers is a coronavirus and has a 30 percent mortality rate. H5N1 is a bird flu and has a 60 percent mortality rate in infected cases. Those are just tiny examples, there's so many viruses and bateriums out there with pandemic potential.
The longer episode was great! I really appreciate you putting in that extra effort to make it almost 40 minutes. I listen these videos while at work and it really helps the day go by while also satisfying my need for new information. Thank you so much!
@Katarina Love - Sadly , offering up conspiracy theories and insufferable republican rage grievance hysterics. Much like the superstitious behavior of the dark Ages. Insufferable. ☄️
As he stated there where people who thought it wasn't as bad as the stories being told, sounds like there where definitely deniers but eventually it's going to be hard when 80% of the population gets dumped in the ground disrupting food production, destroying trade, emptying cities and making the continent look like its Judgement Day.
I couldn’t imagine how it felt to be in those Italian cities during this plague there was so much death in the air it probably was almost palpable. Those Italian cities were cities of the dead
Almost? They say the stench of death was so vile you could smell it before even reaching the cities. Lots of dead, rotting, poorly buried bodies. This added to the circle of rats and fleas. It worsened the plague. In countries where burning the dead is a regular practice, the plague wasn't as fast spreading. Because the bodies werent lying in the streets as rotting vectors for rats, fleas and disease. Eventually Christians caught on and started burning bodies and items too.
People in those days would've had a much different relationship with death than we do today. Even outside of epidemics of disease, death was everywhere. Even kings struggled to live to 50 years old. Families were very close. You would've lived with your parents until you were married and even after that, you likely didn't move far. Most people had probably watched multiple relatives get sick and die by early adulthood. Few diseases had known medical cures. You either recovered or you didn't. This kind of existence makes it easy to understand why medieval people sought such a close relationship with God.
I really enjoyed this episode. I thought at first "hmm a plague docu I'm sure it won't be much different to the others but I'll watch", but it really is different to the others. We never hear about the individuals or the little instances. I also enjoyed a longer video
People still get it all the time, we just have antibiotics to knock it out now. I actually caught it from cat saliva (so my pediatrician at the time said) because I’m a dumbass that spends 75% of my day snuggling cats. I didn’t develop disgusting buboes, but my lymph nodes did swell up all over my body, which I’d never seen any but the nodes in my throat swell before (or since). Including in my groin area, which I’ve never seen during any other illness I’ve had in life. It scared the shit out of me. I don’t even remember very much of the two weeks I was sick, other than laying in the library in my parents home on a bed in very low light and being kind of delirious a lot of the time. It’s a bizarre memory. I suppose I was in a feverish haze the whole time. It was the fucking PITS.
Such a bullcrap about cats...Probably your filthy ancestors were those who blamed jews for black death spreading.Kind of peeps who need to blame somebody ... By the way cats of the time were killed in masses been accused by the church for been Satan servants . I don't have any ampathy for filthy aggressive folks lived in Europe that time.Good that they were wiped out of the face of the Earth
How could a parent not tend to their child. I would tend to my children and if my children died, i would prefer i go with them. How sad, especially for the young children. My kids always just wanted mom when they were little and didnt feel well.
It's the consequences of a completely demoralised society collapsing, combined with a last ditch effort at self-preservation. Remember that by then these people had already been trough hell, most of their families where probably dead, their crops rotting on the fields and their animals long gone (if not by plague then by theft or carnivorous animals like bears or wolves) food production was disrupted and cities where not functional because a large part of the population was gone. They where truly living is a time so terrifying we can't imagine it.
I have watched plenty of documentaries on the plague, this is by far the best produced, most informative and entertaining one. Love the format and citations, it really helps you imagine that point in time. Thank you!
It was so bad and so memorable to Western culture that we know it simply as "the plague". The simple term "the plague" even hundreds of years later and everyone still knows what's being referenced.
Yes, Please! I loved this format. There is just no way to convey the horror of the black death, but the facts you provided are chilling. I wonder why Italy was hit disproportionately hard by the black death and then covid. Could there be a common cause there? Anyway, keep up the good work.
Commercial and highly densely populated areas are breeding ground for epidemics. Plenty of Chinese nationals live in northern Italy, where C19 exploded in early 2020.
My guess would be simply geography. Italy being where it is, a major central port for trade and travel from Europe, Africa, Asia, and the Middle East. If they had closed it all off from foreigners, Italians might have had a better chance.
Actually the British isles were the worst hit. The plague there was even more virulent that in other places. Also the plague was probably the even worst in asia but we don't really have much info from that time in Asia besides that it started there.
Another great, informative episode and brilliant narration!! We are also treated to a longer episode so we can really get our teeth into it! Hope all Medieval Madness fans are well and wishing you all love, luck and peace. Love from loyal fan xxxx
Can you imagine being the guy that solved this shit by telling the people to "stay at home and social distance"? I mean, it did safe the Pope, one of the most influencial people of the era...
This is a very well put together video. Thank you for your channels awesome content. Did the black death ever make it to south America? Or medieval Russia/Japan/Australia? Do we know? I've just not noticed those regions being mentioned with the black plague.
It didn’t arrive in the New World until European immigrants did. Then, the poor Native Americans were wiped out (estimated 90% mortality for the two American continents) by various Old World diseases to which they had no immunity at all, unlike Europeans of the time, and modern ones. Experts think that smallpox was the biggest killer, but there were many others, like plague. Sadly, few really cared enough about these people to diagnose and record specific diseases and mortality numbers, it all has to be estimated.
Man, a post apocalypse survival game, after The Black Death would be cool. Going from tavern to tavern, having to find something to survive, avoiding some of your former neighbors, I would defiantly play that game.
Found this vid cause of you! Also yeah never understood why some people are attracted to living like rodents in a massive complex of human industrial landscape
I don't have anything constructive to add other than I found this extremely informative, very enjoyable to watch and thank you for taking the time and effort to create this. Great work!
When the narrator said the plague moved at 5 miles per day I got chills down my spine, that’s an astonishing level of movement for a disease, that’s definitely not normal. I’d agree with scientists and historians, it was some hybrid disease that just ran amok and devastated everywhere it went.
Astonishing ? Any disease now adays can be in China , Europe , Russia , Asia and Africa all in the same day bye just hopping on a plane. Imagine if we had a disease that is just as virulent and even more contagious with no cure nowadays.... The world wouldnt be able to survive. We would be thrown back to medieval times. Scary stuff...
it would be interesting to see a video on misconceptions about the black death, so many ppl i talk to seem to think that the plague doctors of the 17th century were from the 14th century outbreak for example
If I am ever tempted to complain about my situation, I often think of these times. I am grateful to be where I am and I am grateful for the bravery of those who overcame this.
You did a truly excellent job on this video, and I can't tell you how much I appreciate the parts of your presentation that discuss Africa and Asia. Most plague documentaries never discuss Asia at all, and the reality is that China got absolutely pummeled by the plague, and they kept decent records about it. Places like Kazakhstan and Iran got it, too, but their records aren't as detailed as the Indian and Chinese records. It's a really important part of understanding this disease and this specific outbreak, and a lot of people just ignore it. I pointed that out once on someone else's plague video, and he reminded me that Ukraine is in Europe. I was like, thanks, buddy, I actually knew that. My point was that you left out half of the story in favor of only talking about Europe. He stopped talking to me after that. I get that kind of thing a lot when I ask to have more non-European history, isn't that strange? Something that fascinates me is that we basically just confirmed what caused the Black Death outbreak. When I was in college, there was still quite a bit of debate about what the underlying cause was. A few people really thought it was smallpox, which... I'm sorry, I'm pretty sure people back then knew what a smallpox outbreak was. It was a daily issue in their lives. No one was like "uh oh, everyone has smallpox", everyone who wrote about it was saying "what the hell, is God mad at us, is this the end of days". We were only able to confirm that Y. pestis was the cause of the outbreak in 2010. Even more recently than that, we confirmed that Y. pestis was also the cause of the Justinian Plague. It's kind of freaky that it popped up a couple of times in Europe, smacked India around for a couple of decades, laid low for about a thousand years, and then came back and took a quarter to a third of everyone. It never went away, either. In places with rodents and inadequate sewage systems, floods come with plague. You could get it in the good old USA just from swimming in the wrong pond. Lucky us, we have very effective treatments. It just makes me wonder if something like H1N1 is going to come back in a few hundred years and lay waste to humanity again.
Well, to be fair, the title of this video ends with, "…Ravaged Europe," so that's explicitly the topic of the video. Also, "The Black Death," is the name given _specifically_ to the mid-14th Century Y. pestis pandemic _in Europe._ Now I only learned, in the past decade or so, that The Plague came to Europe due to Mongol biological-warfare, which the Mongols, in turn, had contracted in China, then carried across the Eurasian Steppe due to their expert use of horses for rapid travel. I was not, however, aware that China was ravaged by it - I thought it was simply endemic in China and that the Chinese had immunity that Europe didn't. I was also unaware that The Plague made its way into South-Asia. Would love to hear more about what was happening in East and South Asia, including per-capita death rates compared to Europe, and what it was called in these other locations.
What a great comment this was. Very interesting about the 2010 outbreak and the fact it is Y.Pestis that was responsible and not a 'mystery' anymore. Now you say we have very effective treatments? You seem to be in the know, would you share with us what effective treatment there is today about it?
It tried this time but modern medicine & hygiene, & nutrition made a difference. Read an article the other day that said the overwhelming majority of fatalities in the US were >65. I believe COVID was much worse in other nations but it was bad enough here. Think about it, a million people, just gone in a year.
@@starcrib That's a real concern & this is why. Viruses mutate all the time. Usually it's a degradation of the DNA, but once in a blue moon it mutates in a way that makes it stronger or unrecognizable to the immune system. That's very bad. What happened to the chickens? Theres a chance it could happen to us.
My ancestors on my father's side were somewhat noble Scots of fairly ancient ranking, and my ancestors on my mom's side were sorta high ranking Craftsmen who worked their way into power, and it constantly impresses me that both families are so ancient and they both survived the Black Death *multiple times*. Come to think of it... I don't tend to get sick that often, and when I do it's very brief. Incredible stuff.
Folks didn’t go a lifetime without washing their hands! Since a lot of communal dishes were eaten with the hands, it was considered polite to keep them clean. And they had soap!
People did not consider dirt to be "dirty". Soap was used for cleaning things, not people. Those who washed dishes and clothes probably had the cleanest hands anywhere, until they next took a dump. The nobility may have dined off plates that were clean looking, but they were handled by servants who were not. Women died from puerperal fever because doctors would go from dissecting a corpse to examination of pregnant women and childbirth without washing their hands, despite clear evidence that doing so virtually eliminated the hazard, on the argument that "doctors are gentlemen, and gentlemen's hands are clean". It's hard for us to imagine, but dirt, urine, faeces, manure... all of those things were considered "natural", even beneficial (food needed manure to grow properly, how could it be bad? The Lord God had made the first person from clay; how dare ye wash yourself of what God hath rendered ye in all his glory!). People went months without bathing... clothes for nobility were complicated, many-layered and time consuming to remove and replace. High nobility had dressers to assist and even they didn't disrobe every day. The poor didn't often have a bathtub, and filling such a thing was a huge effort, requiring twenty or more trips to the town well, heating at least a quarter of the volume over a fire. The result was that when bathing was partaken, the entire family used the same water, one after the other, man first, then wife, then kids, last was the baby, who was dunked in what must have been by that stage a lukewarm cesspool of oily soup, with bits of unwiped faeces, sweat, manure, and the odd blob of pus from a burst boil. That's where the saying "don't throw the baby out with the bathwater" comes from. The water would have been opaque, and unless it was a rural area with a stream with no settlements upstream, the water to begin with would have probably deposited as many germs as it removed; by the time the baby was fished out of it, drinking a single drop would have been likely to cause severe illness. Exposing a small cut to it could risk loss of that limb. It's hard for us to imagine such a world. It's likely that bathing was viewed as dangerous. People would have noticed that a cut that had been healing ok, suddenly, within hours after bathing, reddened, throbbed... within days it festered, suppurated, spread into an open wound, and sometimes, resulted in the death of tissue below the infection and needed amputation. Honestly, I am thankful to live now. I know that in the future there will be medical advancements beyond our capabilities but probably not beyond our understanding. Public health saw it's greatest leap with the provision of microbially near sterile water the knowledge that hands that looked clean, were not. Even when we wash our hands for 20 seconds, they're still filthy for such purposes as surgery. I'm sorry, but almost no one, after the first minute of life after being born in the middle ages, was ever clean enough to safely eat with their hands ever again. There would have been the odd madman who insisted on getting naked and standing under a waterfall for 20 minutes, scrubbing himself with his hands until he had cleaned off the sacred earth that God had used to make him, but that's about it. Everyone else would have made you or I sick, literally and figuratively, if we could have stood the stench long enough.
I know we like to make fun of medieval Europeans for being superstitious, but if a disease swept through and wiped out 50-70% of the world population now I think most people would think or at least behave as if the apocalypse was upon us.
This was so interesting. Thanks for your hard work in putting this long one together for us! One thing I was totally unaware of, was how the Jewish population was used as scapegoat for the plague. They really can’t catch a break huh..
I can't believe I've never heard of your channel! I have at least a 100 history RUclipsrs on my subscriptions, but now I have 101! Lol awesome work, making a subject so talked about feel fresh
The last two years were a pandemic. A pandemic is the term used for a disease that spans the entire developed world. Considering that Covid-19 was spread over the entire developed world and even made it out to super remote areas, it definitely fits the description of a pandemic. An epidemic is the term used for something that only covers a certain area, hence why the Black Death isn't considered by all historians to be a pandemic, as it didn't affect the rather advanced civilizations of America at the same time it affected Europe. A lot of Asia was also spared and same goes for Africa, so it was more of an epidemic than a pandemic. As for the Covid-19 Pandemic, it is still waay too early to conclude anything. The mutated SARS virus, which caused the pandemic, had some pretty serious variants at first. Sure, you wouldn't really get sick if you were younger... At least not the first couple of times. But if we take the Alpha, Beta and Delta variants as examples, then they were all capable of infecting any part of your body and cause irreversible damage to your tissue, meaning your body would break more and more down after each infection. The Delta variant could possibly also infect the brain itself, making it capable of causing all kinds of extra trouble. And we haven't even talked about what SARS itself is, nor that the original SARS virus doesn't have a cure of any form, what so ever. SARS stands for Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome, which, translated to normal English, means it is 100% capable of killing people. Unlike the common cold, SARS usually infects the lower respiratory system, which means the lungs and the regions surrounding the heart. I don't think I have to explain why that is seriously bad. Now add SARS_CoV_2, the mutated variant of SARS itself, which caused the pandemic and which has the ability to infect any part of the body and you have a virus that's already deadly on its own, but now it can also infect any system in your body, including the heart itself. But wait, there's more! Not only is it incredibly dangerous just by the above description, it also possesses a gene that allows it to suppress the cells warning signal to the immune system, which basically lets it infect a huge part of the body, before the immune system realizes it has been tricked. The SARS_CoV_2 virus is, as it's name implies, a member of the Corona Virus family (because their structure looks like a crown... at least in the eyes of a biologist). That's one hell of a problem, because that means it mutates often. As in, very often. One of the viruses that causes the common cold, is also a member of the Corona virus family and the same counts for normal influenza. Protection against the latter actually requires a new vaccine every single year, because it mutates so frequently. This SARS variant is worse. It mutates every couple of months, meaning there's constantly a new variant we aren't protected against. In fact, the vaccine won't even cover the new variants that will arrive this winter. I was offered a 4th jab at the doctors office about a week ago (which I accepted). Which brings us to a talk about what this actually is and why we haven't been able to just "kill" it yet. We haven't been able to kill it, because a virus isn't alive. It literally doesn't live and we can't kill something that isn't alive in the first place. The problem with viruses is, that they're small bits of genetic code, protected by a protein shell, which our immune systems first have to break through, before they can destroy it. That quickly becomes problematic, when the virus mutates faster than our bodies can adapt, making it literally impossible for us to ever be properly protected against it, hence why we need constant vaccines, as vaccines are the only weapon we have against it, but vaccines won't help someone who's already infected. Viruses work by reprogramming the cells of the body, converting them from their task of keeping you alive, and into becoming virus factories. You won't experience any symptoms of infection, before there's been enough infected cells to either alert the immune system or activate the virus method of spreading to other hosts (for Covid, that would be through the air and/or bodily fluids). We also aren't done with the pandemic. It's not over yet. Omicron can still infect every part of your body, although it usually stays in the upper respiratory system, such as your nose, mouth and throat. But it still has all the genes to fuck up the human body, big time. Including the same gene the Delta virus have, which may be able to let it infect the brain. Normally the Corona virus family can't survive the summer months, hence why we've gotten a break during this time of year. Normally. Around mid June, a new variant was discovered. A variant that allows the SARS variant that causes Covid, to survive during the summer months and infect us in those months too, basically screwing us over all year round. There's no medicine against this virus. There's only the vaccine and the guidelines. Follow them and you decrease the chances of the virus spreading, as it needs a host in order to multiply. Leave it without a host for 24 hours and it disintegrates and becomes harmless. Hence why distance and face masks are a good idea during when at events with many people. Sanitizer also destroys the virus, hence why that's a guideline too. And an updated vaccine is of course the best method of protection against it, but it won't be the entire package. A vaccine can only provide a percentage of protection and that percentage will never be 100%. I also want to clarify that what I've written here, isn't fear mongering. I haven't taken this from generic media articles, but from what I was able to find of scientific news regarding the virus during the past 2 years, as I have had and still have, a genuine interest in learning more about biology.
@@Arterexius super detailed reply. It makes sense. The only thing I would criticise is that the best immune system protection seems to come from being injected, which is risky. So injections first to give some protection, and hopefully then if you do get it you'll recover and have even better protection. Until the next variant! :-) Unfortunately I heard a BBC news morning presenter the other day say something along the lines of "the vaccines don't seem to be stopping this variant". I thought the vaccines don't stop it at all but what they do is give you some protection by having your immune system primed to be ready for the virus. I thought the vaccines just give you immunity from severe illness so that if you get it you don't become severely sick. Is that right? I do wonder if the world got together and picked a certain date and everybody agreed to a one month lockdown if we could actually stop it? If we plan for the lockdown say in 1 years time and everybody would agree we would have enough food etc and be ready and pick our bubbles and we would stay in one location for 1 month. Would that work? Would we be free of it?
This was so good! Thank you for taking some of the great advice I’ve seen posted with the background music and making the videos longer! It’s so appreciated. Not sure if this is possible or not but for a video idea I would love to hear any written first hand experiences from someone who has lived through the plague or just the medieval time period in general, such as a journal or a diary. Another idea- medieval machinery?
Wonderful episode as always! 🤩I love learning and devouring any material about the Black Plague; I even wrote my final term paper on art during the plague waves. Brilliant research James 💖👏✨
Very nice presentation. As far as I can see the period of the black death had little to do with the renaissance which was already occurring before and survived despite the plague. The medieval ages were a time of enlightenment. Calamity happens. Humans persevere.
I find it funny that the same country from which the third major Black Death plague also gave us the current coronavirus pandemic! :P Also, it looks like The Nazi Genocide was not the only Jewish Holocaust to take place!
0:48 Of course they thought it was the end of the world, I don't think that is ignorant I think that some people thought COVID was the end of the world so of course the people who lived through the plague thought it was the end of the world
I love your show. I’m American, here in Florida. It’s a funny story, but my Grandmother was “ Bubo” to us. We pronounced it Buh- Boh. Anyway, it all came about because my eldest brother was being taught about Buffaloes by my Grandmother. He couldn’t say “ Buffalo “, just “ Bubo”, so that was her name for all of the grandchildren. She wasn’t the nicest person ( neither am I, admittedly). However, it was really ironic when I learned about what the sores were called during The Black Plague.
I don't want to offend you but I just watched your documentary and now I am watching the one which BBC made seven years ago. And now I am dissapointed because you stole almost the whole story, which wouldn't be problematic since it is a history and you can't change history. But you stole whole sentencies which are exactly the same, "Italy was Frontline of Europe" just as example. Im not saying your documentary is not good, im just pointing out you stole another work and presented as yours and even didn't bother to hide it. Very sad man.... Edit: you citating the Giovanni Boccaccio which is also showed in BBC, you used idea that wathcing someone or just thinking about deasie you could get ill....just sad man
What a horrendous disease. It’s repugnant that parents abandoned their sick children. If my child was that sick I’d tend them in order that I might die with them.
My daughter cleans with thieves oil, so l learned a bit about it's bubonic background. Apparently, when caught robbing the afflicted the judge asked how they avoided the disease. They wore the beaked masks filled with the essential oils used in today's cleaning product.
Actually a lot of women who survived benefitted from the plague because of the shortage of workers and services available many actually had their own businesses.
I appreciate the mention at the finale which states the Black Death's cause as a mystery. We have been lead to believe that we now "know" it was bacterial. The manner in, and the speed at which it spread seems to me that it was probably viral. It's interesting how badly "we" freaked out over COVID, and the mortality rate was at most 0.1%, while influenza was roughly 2.0%. Can you imagine an illness with a 30.0% mortality rate? Medieval Europe lived through that! Staggering!
It’s been well established for over a century that it is caused by the bacterium Yersinia Pestis. Recent research suggests that bites of body lice may also be a vector of transmission- given how medieval families would often share a bed and not launder their clothes, may explain the rapid spread.
Yersenia Pestis still survives. There's usually a couple cases a year in the US. It is a bacteria transmitted primarily by fleas or other rodents(such as prairie dogs). But it can go pneumonic, such as COVID did. It's no match for modern antibiotics though. Thank God.
I think we "freaked out" over covid because we know about the black death and there was a chance that it could be just as deadly. Thank goodness for modern technologies it was not.
@@jetsandthebombers coronavirus was never anything like as dangerous as the plague. With no treatments or vaccines at all, it would still not have had a comparable death rate. Leftists believe a lot of covid myths. Democrats who were polled said they believed it had a 40% death rate. Utterly false.
This world is merciless and cruel. I think the only reason that we continue to have children is that young people don't know any better until it's too late. I love both of my kids but I do look on them as the most selfish act of my life.
They had enough writers survive with enough of a sense of humor that not even the plague stopped them from their sardonic tendencies toward tragedy. Interesting how much written material exists in Italy from the time, but relatively little exists in other languages at the time.
btw when you find a "gn" in an Italian name, e.g. Agnolo, it's pronounced: Aknee-olo basically, the "g" is silent, a good example maybe "Espagnol" = Spanish, you pronounce it: Espa-knee-ol
Can I just say I really like the addition of the more modern photos and video clips. They somehow pin the events in reality. It’s easy to lose the truth of the medieval period within its own artwork and texts.
The people comparing this to our current situation is both frustrating and embarrassing. This is, literally, and I'm using that by the definition, hundreds of times worse in practically every way. I honestly called it in March of 2020 and still rub it in everyone's face when I see them. In other news, looking at the wiki page for history's biggest plagues has told me that south-central China should be vacated. Well.... maybe not, considering how I pretty much advocate a black death tier plague to hit us at this point
Will you still advocate for it if you get it and die? That's the test of character. Too many people who say this have nothing to say or backpedal when I ask if they would keep that same energy if they or people they like are infected/die.
@@Volundur9567 First of all, no matter what I, personally say, it won't change the cringe overreaction in this comment section and all the others. Second, at worse your grandma and a good friend dying (at worse) is not even comparable to all your neighbors dying; if you cant conceptualize that then you are delusional
@@roninref5152 Their comment was response to you saying "I pretty much advocate a black death tier plague to hit us at this point". You didn't respond to anything they said; only things they didn't.
The plague bacterium is still present in our environment. They believe it has bacterium blooms, throughout history or in times when Famine or other diseases were becoming epidemic portions. This would weaken the immune system and one form or another to take hold. Tuberculosis out breaks history works like this. Both the plague and Tuberculosis are still active and outbreaks still happen. In poverty areas, both can caused contained outbreaks still happen but are rarely measured to the masses to not cause panic and out attitudes to the homeless or those living in extreme poverty aren't really allowed to intermingle with the rest of society.
No one at my school talked about that aftermath you said. The fact people were left with houses, terrains. People no longer believed or stayed under his hers masters governmnt and parted away looking for independence, I can surely feel that good vibe from it.
You forgot the carts that collected the corpses. A man would ring a bell and call "Bring out your dead! Bring out your dead!" I saw it in a documentary.
The issue I have with the narrative of the bodies being catapaulted is that, being a port, the ship rat would be well esconsed in Caffa itself anyway. It is likely there would have been Plague there before the bodies were catapaulted. Gabriel De Mussis was on one of the galleys that left Caffa, and was crystal clear in his testimony that there were no Plague cases on his ship from Caffa to Genoa. That doesn't mean that one of the other seven galleys did not have Plague cases. If they did, they would have died before they reached Genoa. It is the rats that would have spread it into Genoa. It should be noted that Venice had Plague every year, being a very busy port city and getting goods from around the world. So Plague would have opened at least two fronts in Italy,
My sister and brother-in-law are both Pharmacists working in our local NHS hospital. The Pharmaceutical Society is the overseeing body registration ( the Pharmaceutical version of the BMA) and useless, costing over £230 annually. This year it has been reported that the NHS is haemorrhaging -thos staff group (who have to get a MSc involving University study of 5 years). This is because of stress, a ridiculous level of workload, disagreeing with the things such a transgender clinics peddling irreversible harm. A recent Psychologidt has been brought into the Department to tell staff that birb out is not a thing or related to the role!!! What chance do kids have when the mental health team are denying such realites!!! The woke mind virus is genuinely worrying and needs stopped asap. Common sense needs reinstate!!! Also significantly low pay comparative to other outside jobs within the private companies attracts Pharmacists who are completely disalusioned with the NHS and incompetent Management. Such a shame 😫😓😭😭
banking and usary were a major part of this. debt slavery had caused much of Europe to be in bankruptcy and public works and sanitation had stopped and turned cities into waste dumps.
I'm amazed when I think about how many of us are more than likely descendants of people who survived the plagues throughout history
Yes, obviously our family ancestors in Europe were smart enough/lucky enough to get the heck out of these places and maybe go into the countryside. Or just be in remote areas and not come out during that mess.
Speak for yourself, I'm exclusively descended from people who died in the black death.
All of us...
DUHHH!!!!!!
A certain immunity is always present for some people, and many religious practices are simple hygiene bases. Somebody figured out that having dirty hands make people sick, so god tells you to wash your hands, same with the circumcision and removing the blood of the butchered animals etc.
They did not know how, but they know something was bad and they fund a solution.
I don't blame them for thinking it was the end of the world. It must of felt like that. Especially since the world population was way lower then , so that who died was a huge % of world population...
I mean think of how fucked everything got when COVID hit and that killed about 0.1% of the world population.
Must have*
I mean, look at how some people reacted during covid lol
Exactly what would you think of you lived through that ❤ horrific experience
@@getmeouttahere3595 I mean over 15000000 people died of covid. Still a large number. Covids a wake up call cause there's plenty of diseases with pandemic potential that have a much higher virulence and covid only had a 0.06 percent mortality rate. Mers is a coronavirus and has a 30 percent mortality rate. H5N1 is a bird flu and has a 60 percent mortality rate in infected cases. Those are just tiny examples, there's so many viruses and bateriums out there with pandemic potential.
The longer episode was great! I really appreciate you putting in that extra effort to make it almost 40 minutes. I listen these videos while at work and it really helps the day go by while also satisfying my need for new information. Thank you so much!
RUclips dave paulides missing 411
@Katarina Love - Sadly , offering up conspiracy theories and insufferable republican rage grievance hysterics. Much like the superstitious behavior of the dark Ages. Insufferable. ☄️
@@starcrib !?
Its good to know how things happened, to know how to survive ,if possable
Yup, 👍 I listen when driving to and from work thank you
I'm not trying to be funny. I really do wonder were there plague deniers back then.
Lol. I imagine there were people who didn't believe it until they saw it for themselves.
There will always be a section of humanity who believe "If it doesn't happen to me, it doesn't happen."
The people in Italy partying like it’s 1999 may have been somewhat in denial.
As he stated there where people who thought it wasn't as bad as the stories being told, sounds like there where definitely deniers but eventually it's going to be hard when 80% of the population gets dumped in the ground disrupting food production, destroying trade, emptying cities and making the continent look like its Judgement Day.
Exactly where the feminists were in Nowhere
I couldn’t imagine how it felt to be in those Italian cities during this plague there was so much death in the air it probably was almost palpable. Those Italian cities were cities of the dead
Almost? They say the stench of death was so vile you could smell it before even reaching the cities. Lots of dead, rotting, poorly buried bodies. This added to the circle of rats and fleas. It worsened the plague. In countries where burning the dead is a regular practice, the plague wasn't as fast spreading. Because the bodies werent lying in the streets as rotting vectors for rats, fleas and disease. Eventually Christians caught on and started burning bodies and items too.
I'd surely choke to death from the stench alone! Not to mention the disease itself.
@@kittye8340 Or London and Paris, for that matter.
@@sergpie Yes. And Rome and Naples
People in those days would've had a much different relationship with death than we do today. Even outside of epidemics of disease, death was everywhere. Even kings struggled to live to 50 years old. Families were very close. You would've lived with your parents until you were married and even after that, you likely didn't move far. Most people had probably watched multiple relatives get sick and die by early adulthood. Few diseases had known medical cures. You either recovered or you didn't. This kind of existence makes it easy to understand why medieval people sought such a close relationship with God.
Oh RATS! It's the plague! Let's FLEA this place!
🤣
👏
Too soon, bad taste.😮
So well and informatively presented, I didn't notice when 40 minutes had passed
You didn't notice the rash of ads?
@@RideAcrossTheRiverRUclips Premium moment
I really enjoyed this episode. I thought at first "hmm a plague docu I'm sure it won't be much different to the others but I'll watch", but it really is different to the others. We never hear about the individuals or the little instances. I also enjoyed a longer video
Bc this channels awesome
Well said.
People still get it all the time, we just have antibiotics to knock it out now. I actually caught it from cat saliva (so my pediatrician at the time said) because I’m a dumbass that spends 75% of my day snuggling cats. I didn’t develop disgusting buboes, but my lymph nodes did swell up all over my body, which I’d never seen any but the nodes in my throat swell before (or since). Including in my groin area, which I’ve never seen during any other illness I’ve had in life. It scared the shit out of me. I don’t even remember very much of the two weeks I was sick, other than laying in the library in my parents home on a bed in very low light and being kind of delirious a lot of the time. It’s a bizarre memory. I suppose I was in a feverish haze the whole time. It was the fucking PITS.
you survived and learn and became stronger which is important
Spending all day cuddling with cats? Sounds perfectly normal to me. You don’t need to swear, though, to get your points across.
@@kimberlyperrotis8962 Jesus, you must be fucking fun to hang out with
@@kimberlyperrotis8962 very nice comment.
Such a bullcrap about cats...Probably your filthy ancestors were those who blamed jews for black death spreading.Kind of peeps who need to blame somebody ...
By the way cats of the time were killed in masses been accused by the church for been Satan servants .
I don't have any ampathy for filthy aggressive folks lived in Europe that time.Good that they were wiped out of the face of the Earth
Omg, I love this extra long video! I never found a video that explained this much about how it spread
How could a parent not tend to their child. I would tend to my children and if my children died, i would prefer i go with them. How sad, especially for the young children. My kids always just wanted mom when they were little and didnt feel well.
It's the consequences of a completely demoralised society collapsing, combined with a last ditch effort at self-preservation.
Remember that by then these people had already been trough hell, most of their families where probably dead, their crops rotting on the fields and their animals long gone (if not by plague then by theft or carnivorous animals like bears or wolves) food production was disrupted and cities where not functional because a large part of the population was gone.
They where truly living is a time so terrifying we can't imagine it.
Excellent work. I was throughly impressed with the presentation. Thank you!
I have watched plenty of documentaries on the plague, this is by far the best produced, most informative and entertaining one. Love the format and citations, it really helps you imagine that point in time. Thank you!
Absolutely immersive and informative. Loved every second despite the grim information within.
It was so bad and so memorable to Western culture that we know it simply as "the plague". The simple term "the plague" even hundreds of years later and everyone still knows what's being referenced.
The idea of catapulting dead bodies into a city you want to invade is both horrifying and oddly hilarious.
😂
Yes, Please! I loved this format. There is just no way to convey the horror of the black death, but the facts you provided are chilling. I wonder why Italy was hit disproportionately hard by the black death and then covid. Could there be a common cause there? Anyway, keep up the good work.
Commercial and highly densely populated areas are breeding ground for epidemics. Plenty of Chinese nationals live in northern Italy, where C19 exploded in early 2020.
My guess would be simply geography. Italy being where it is, a major central port for trade and travel from Europe, Africa, Asia, and the Middle East. If they had closed it all off from foreigners, Italians might have had a better chance.
@@CleoVonGemI completely agree.
Actually the British isles were the worst hit. The plague there was even more virulent that in other places. Also the plague was probably the even worst in asia but we don't really have much info from that time in Asia besides that it started there.
Nothing is more dangerous than a population that is under the terror of a pandemic and the throes of ignorance. 💔
COVID wasn't as bad as people state. It had a 1 percent mortality. Bubonic plague has an 80 percent mortality.
No one is talking about Covid here@@Styxswimmer
But as it stands, there were a lot of moronic right wingers during covid. No shock there.
Finally a channel where I can enjoy everything medieval. Thank you for such incredible videos and hope to watch more of "Medieval Madness",
old man
Another great, informative episode and brilliant narration!! We are also treated to a longer episode so we can really get our teeth into it! Hope all Medieval Madness fans are well and wishing you all love, luck and peace. Love from loyal fan xxxx
Can you imagine being the guy that solved this shit by telling the people to "stay at home and social distance"? I mean, it did safe the Pope, one of the most influencial people of the era...
This is a very well put together video. Thank you for your channels awesome content. Did the black death ever make it to south America? Or medieval Russia/Japan/Australia? Do we know? I've just not noticed those regions being mentioned with the black plague.
It didn’t arrive in the New World until European immigrants did. Then, the poor Native Americans were wiped out (estimated 90% mortality for the two American continents) by various Old World diseases to which they had no immunity at all, unlike Europeans of the time, and modern ones. Experts think that smallpox was the biggest killer, but there were many others, like plague. Sadly, few really cared enough about these people to diagnose and record specific diseases and mortality numbers, it all has to be estimated.
Man, a post apocalypse survival game, after The Black Death would be cool.
Going from tavern to tavern, having to find something to survive, avoiding some of your former neighbors, I would defiantly play that game.
you should play a D & D campaign based on this time! 😊 it would be perfect!
@@zosoart
Agreed, and in my opinion, scarier as it's based on a 'real life' event in our history.
@@zosoart you haven't done this?
There is a game on steam called black death which is basically that
@@zosoart That's a great idea, though it would take a special DM to get that set up, someone willing to put in the time and effort to research.
so, we've known since the 14th century to avoid crappy cities 🤣🤣
Found this vid cause of you! Also yeah never understood why some people are attracted to living like rodents in a massive complex of human industrial landscape
Now European cities are dumping grounds for the worlds unwanted
I don't have anything constructive to add other than I found this extremely informative, very enjoyable to watch and thank you for taking the time and effort to create this. Great work!
This is one of the best documentaries I've ever watched. Thank you for all the work you put into it.
I am seeing parallels between then and now. The more things change, the more theybstay the same.
Men change nations fall and rise, but war never changes.
Oh shut up
...why do jews keep going back to germany lol.
Anything a jew does is always money first religion second
You'd think after being kicked out of 110 countries (multiple times), you'd learn you're not wanted. 😂
Brilliant video! How heartbreaking that parents didn't care for their sick children or any family member for that matter. A very dark period of time.
When the narrator said the plague moved at 5 miles per day I got chills down my spine, that’s an astonishing level of movement for a disease, that’s definitely not normal. I’d agree with scientists and historians, it was some hybrid disease that just ran amok and devastated everywhere it went.
Astonishing ? Any disease now adays can be in China , Europe , Russia , Asia and Africa all in the same day bye just hopping on a plane. Imagine if we had a disease that is just as virulent and even more contagious with no cure nowadays.... The world wouldnt be able to survive. We would be thrown back to medieval times. Scary stuff...
it would be interesting to see a video on misconceptions about the black death, so many ppl i talk to seem to think that the plague doctors of the 17th century were from the 14th century outbreak for example
If I am ever tempted to complain about my situation, I often think of these times. I am grateful to be where I am and I am grateful for the bravery of those who overcame this.
You did a truly excellent job on this video, and I can't tell you how much I appreciate the parts of your presentation that discuss Africa and Asia. Most plague documentaries never discuss Asia at all, and the reality is that China got absolutely pummeled by the plague, and they kept decent records about it. Places like Kazakhstan and Iran got it, too, but their records aren't as detailed as the Indian and Chinese records. It's a really important part of understanding this disease and this specific outbreak, and a lot of people just ignore it. I pointed that out once on someone else's plague video, and he reminded me that Ukraine is in Europe. I was like, thanks, buddy, I actually knew that. My point was that you left out half of the story in favor of only talking about Europe. He stopped talking to me after that. I get that kind of thing a lot when I ask to have more non-European history, isn't that strange?
Something that fascinates me is that we basically just confirmed what caused the Black Death outbreak. When I was in college, there was still quite a bit of debate about what the underlying cause was. A few people really thought it was smallpox, which... I'm sorry, I'm pretty sure people back then knew what a smallpox outbreak was. It was a daily issue in their lives. No one was like "uh oh, everyone has smallpox", everyone who wrote about it was saying "what the hell, is God mad at us, is this the end of days". We were only able to confirm that Y. pestis was the cause of the outbreak in 2010. Even more recently than that, we confirmed that Y. pestis was also the cause of the Justinian Plague. It's kind of freaky that it popped up a couple of times in Europe, smacked India around for a couple of decades, laid low for about a thousand years, and then came back and took a quarter to a third of everyone. It never went away, either. In places with rodents and inadequate sewage systems, floods come with plague. You could get it in the good old USA just from swimming in the wrong pond. Lucky us, we have very effective treatments. It just makes me wonder if something like H1N1 is going to come back in a few hundred years and lay waste to humanity again.
Well, to be fair, the title of this video ends with, "…Ravaged Europe," so that's explicitly the topic of the video. Also, "The Black Death," is the name given _specifically_ to the mid-14th Century Y. pestis pandemic _in Europe._
Now I only learned, in the past decade or so, that The Plague came to Europe due to Mongol biological-warfare, which the Mongols, in turn, had contracted in China, then carried across the Eurasian Steppe due to their expert use of horses for rapid travel.
I was not, however, aware that China was ravaged by it - I thought it was simply endemic in China and that the Chinese had immunity that Europe didn't. I was also unaware that The Plague made its way into South-Asia. Would love to hear more about what was happening in East and South Asia, including per-capita death rates compared to Europe, and what it was called in these other locations.
What a great comment this was. Very interesting about the 2010 outbreak and the fact it is Y.Pestis that was responsible and not a 'mystery' anymore. Now you say we have very effective treatments? You seem to be in the know, would you share with us what effective treatment there is today about it?
It tried this time but modern medicine & hygiene, & nutrition made a difference. Read an article the other day that said the overwhelming majority of fatalities in the US were >65. I believe COVID was much worse in other nations but it was bad enough here. Think about it, a million people, just gone in a year.
How about H1-N1 in 5 / 10 Years - ? BRACE YOURSELF. we are living in the age of Pandemics. 🌬🦠🌏🌎🌍💣
@@starcrib That's a real concern & this is why.
Viruses mutate all the time. Usually it's a degradation of the DNA, but once in a blue moon it mutates in a way that makes it stronger or unrecognizable to the immune system. That's very bad.
What happened to the chickens? Theres a chance it could happen to us.
I dont get how "rub some human poop on it" became a "cure" back then. I cant even imagine the thoughts behind that.
Some thought, sadly, that like will treat like, thus a stinky gross wound should be treated with something just as bad or worse.
This really puts covid into perspective.
This is fantastic! I learned more than I ever knew about this subject, thank you so much for your time and effort. It really paid off! 🤜🏼
My ancestors on my father's side were somewhat noble Scots of fairly ancient ranking, and my ancestors on my mom's side were sorta high ranking Craftsmen who worked their way into power, and it constantly impresses me that both families are so ancient and they both survived the Black Death *multiple times*.
Come to think of it... I don't tend to get sick that often, and when I do it's very brief. Incredible stuff.
Good genes 👍🏻
Well if they or their offspring had er survived they wouldn't be anyones ancestors.
Literally anyone alive now with more than 50% western European heritage can make that exact claim, with varying degrees of "I rarely get sick".
Folks didn’t go a lifetime without washing their hands! Since a lot of communal dishes were eaten with the hands, it was considered polite to keep them clean. And they had soap!
People did not consider dirt to be "dirty". Soap was used for cleaning things, not people. Those who washed dishes and clothes probably had the cleanest hands anywhere, until they next took a dump.
The nobility may have dined off plates that were clean looking, but they were handled by servants who were not.
Women died from puerperal fever because doctors would go from dissecting a corpse to examination of pregnant women and childbirth without washing their hands, despite clear evidence that doing so virtually eliminated the hazard, on the argument that "doctors are gentlemen, and gentlemen's hands are clean".
It's hard for us to imagine, but dirt, urine, faeces, manure... all of those things were considered "natural", even beneficial (food needed manure to grow properly, how could it be bad? The Lord God had made the first person from clay; how dare ye wash yourself of what God hath rendered ye in all his glory!).
People went months without bathing... clothes for nobility were complicated, many-layered and time consuming to remove and replace. High nobility had dressers to assist and even they didn't disrobe every day.
The poor didn't often have a bathtub, and filling such a thing was a huge effort, requiring twenty or more trips to the town well, heating at least a quarter of the volume over a fire. The result was that when bathing was partaken, the entire family used the same water, one after the other, man first, then wife, then kids, last was the baby, who was dunked in what must have been by that stage a lukewarm cesspool of oily soup, with bits of unwiped faeces, sweat, manure, and the odd blob of pus from a burst boil. That's where the saying "don't throw the baby out with the bathwater" comes from. The water would have been opaque, and unless it was a rural area with a stream with no settlements upstream, the water to begin with would have probably deposited as many germs as it removed; by the time the baby was fished out of it, drinking a single drop would have been likely to cause severe illness. Exposing a small cut to it could risk loss of that limb.
It's hard for us to imagine such a world. It's likely that bathing was viewed as dangerous. People would have noticed that a cut that had been healing ok, suddenly, within hours after bathing, reddened, throbbed... within days it festered, suppurated, spread into an open wound, and sometimes, resulted in the death of tissue below the infection and needed amputation.
Honestly, I am thankful to live now. I know that in the future there will be medical advancements beyond our capabilities but probably not beyond our understanding. Public health saw it's greatest leap with the provision of microbially near sterile water the knowledge that hands that looked clean, were not. Even when we wash our hands for 20 seconds, they're still filthy for such purposes as surgery.
I'm sorry, but almost no one, after the first minute of life after being born in the middle ages, was ever clean enough to safely eat with their hands ever again. There would have been the odd madman who insisted on getting naked and standing under a waterfall for 20 minutes, scrubbing himself with his hands until he had cleaned off the sacred earth that God had used to make him, but that's about it. Everyone else would have made you or I sick, literally and figuratively, if we could have stood the stench long enough.
I know we like to make fun of medieval Europeans for being superstitious, but if a disease swept through and wiped out 50-70% of the world population now I think most people would think or at least behave as if the apocalypse was upon us.
This was so interesting. Thanks for your hard work in putting this long one together for us! One thing I was totally unaware of, was how the Jewish population was used as scapegoat for the plague. They really can’t catch a break huh..
They were used as scapegoat for everything... Jews were often wealthy and wealth makes your neighbors jealous.
Øåpååøpåpåøåø
They've also been kicked out of 110 countries
Lol there’s a reason they can’t catch a break. They´re not victims
@@DobBylan_ Indeed, a people are not persecuted and kicked out of countries for thousands of years without reason.
Just to clarify the dire situations, 30 - 60% of the world died because of the black plague, that would be almost 2.5 - 4.64 billion.
I can't believe I've never heard of your channel! I have at least a 100 history RUclipsrs on my subscriptions, but now I have 101! Lol awesome work, making a subject so talked about feel fresh
So interesting and so devistatingly sad. Your documentaries keep getting better and better.
I fell asleep to these. Glad I found this channel.
Interesting to get some perspective about an actual pandemic. Our response over the past two years has been as absurd as it has been ineffective.
A covid denier whinging on a plague video. How original 🤡
It was very effective in destroying the economy and creating widespread poverty.
Based and common sense pilled
The last two years were a pandemic. A pandemic is the term used for a disease that spans the entire developed world. Considering that Covid-19 was spread over the entire developed world and even made it out to super remote areas, it definitely fits the description of a pandemic. An epidemic is the term used for something that only covers a certain area, hence why the Black Death isn't considered by all historians to be a pandemic, as it didn't affect the rather advanced civilizations of America at the same time it affected Europe. A lot of Asia was also spared and same goes for Africa, so it was more of an epidemic than a pandemic.
As for the Covid-19 Pandemic, it is still waay too early to conclude anything. The mutated SARS virus, which caused the pandemic, had some pretty serious variants at first. Sure, you wouldn't really get sick if you were younger... At least not the first couple of times. But if we take the Alpha, Beta and Delta variants as examples, then they were all capable of infecting any part of your body and cause irreversible damage to your tissue, meaning your body would break more and more down after each infection. The Delta variant could possibly also infect the brain itself, making it capable of causing all kinds of extra trouble. And we haven't even talked about what SARS itself is, nor that the original SARS virus doesn't have a cure of any form, what so ever. SARS stands for Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome, which, translated to normal English, means it is 100% capable of killing people. Unlike the common cold, SARS usually infects the lower respiratory system, which means the lungs and the regions surrounding the heart. I don't think I have to explain why that is seriously bad. Now add SARS_CoV_2, the mutated variant of SARS itself, which caused the pandemic and which has the ability to infect any part of the body and you have a virus that's already deadly on its own, but now it can also infect any system in your body, including the heart itself.
But wait, there's more! Not only is it incredibly dangerous just by the above description, it also possesses a gene that allows it to suppress the cells warning signal to the immune system, which basically lets it infect a huge part of the body, before the immune system realizes it has been tricked. The SARS_CoV_2 virus is, as it's name implies, a member of the Corona Virus family (because their structure looks like a crown... at least in the eyes of a biologist). That's one hell of a problem, because that means it mutates often. As in, very often. One of the viruses that causes the common cold, is also a member of the Corona virus family and the same counts for normal influenza. Protection against the latter actually requires a new vaccine every single year, because it mutates so frequently. This SARS variant is worse. It mutates every couple of months, meaning there's constantly a new variant we aren't protected against. In fact, the vaccine won't even cover the new variants that will arrive this winter. I was offered a 4th jab at the doctors office about a week ago (which I accepted).
Which brings us to a talk about what this actually is and why we haven't been able to just "kill" it yet. We haven't been able to kill it, because a virus isn't alive. It literally doesn't live and we can't kill something that isn't alive in the first place. The problem with viruses is, that they're small bits of genetic code, protected by a protein shell, which our immune systems first have to break through, before they can destroy it. That quickly becomes problematic, when the virus mutates faster than our bodies can adapt, making it literally impossible for us to ever be properly protected against it, hence why we need constant vaccines, as vaccines are the only weapon we have against it, but vaccines won't help someone who's already infected. Viruses work by reprogramming the cells of the body, converting them from their task of keeping you alive, and into becoming virus factories. You won't experience any symptoms of infection, before there's been enough infected cells to either alert the immune system or activate the virus method of spreading to other hosts (for Covid, that would be through the air and/or bodily fluids).
We also aren't done with the pandemic. It's not over yet. Omicron can still infect every part of your body, although it usually stays in the upper respiratory system, such as your nose, mouth and throat. But it still has all the genes to fuck up the human body, big time. Including the same gene the Delta virus have, which may be able to let it infect the brain. Normally the Corona virus family can't survive the summer months, hence why we've gotten a break during this time of year. Normally. Around mid June, a new variant was discovered. A variant that allows the SARS variant that causes Covid, to survive during the summer months and infect us in those months too, basically screwing us over all year round.
There's no medicine against this virus. There's only the vaccine and the guidelines. Follow them and you decrease the chances of the virus spreading, as it needs a host in order to multiply. Leave it without a host for 24 hours and it disintegrates and becomes harmless. Hence why distance and face masks are a good idea during when at events with many people. Sanitizer also destroys the virus, hence why that's a guideline too. And an updated vaccine is of course the best method of protection against it, but it won't be the entire package. A vaccine can only provide a percentage of protection and that percentage will never be 100%. I also want to clarify that what I've written here, isn't fear mongering. I haven't taken this from generic media articles, but from what I was able to find of scientific news regarding the virus during the past 2 years, as I have had and still have, a genuine interest in learning more about biology.
@@Arterexius super detailed reply. It makes sense. The only thing I would criticise is that the best immune system protection seems to come from being injected, which is risky. So injections first to give some protection, and hopefully then if you do get it you'll recover and have even better protection.
Until the next variant! :-)
Unfortunately I heard a BBC news morning presenter the other day say something along the lines of "the vaccines don't seem to be stopping this variant". I thought the vaccines don't stop it at all but what they do is give you some protection by having your immune system primed to be ready for the virus. I thought the vaccines just give you immunity from severe illness so that if you get it you don't become severely sick. Is that right?
I do wonder if the world got together and picked a certain date and everybody agreed to a one month lockdown if we could actually stop it? If we plan for the lockdown say in 1 years time and everybody would agree we would have enough food etc and be ready and pick our bubbles and we would stay in one location for 1 month. Would that work? Would we be free of it?
I realize this is a serious production, but Monty Python’s Holy Grail kept crossing my mind as you narrated.
This was so good! Thank you for taking some of the great advice I’ve seen posted with the background music and making the videos longer! It’s so appreciated.
Not sure if this is possible or not but for a video idea I would love to hear any written first hand experiences from someone who has lived through the plague or just the medieval time period in general, such as a journal or a diary.
Another idea- medieval machinery?
If you'd like to hear some first person accounts check out Voices of The Past.
Maybe Petrarch?
Wonderful episode as always! 🤩I love learning and devouring any material about the Black Plague; I even wrote my final term paper on art during the plague waves. Brilliant research James 💖👏✨
It wasnt the first time biological warfare was used but otherwise good video
What was the first? In rome?
Well done lad! This was professionally done and a great watch 😃. You deserve far more subs and recognition 👏🏾
Quality content, world history is often so disturbing.
Thank you for this. Very easy to understand the trajectory of it, because of the way you covered it.
The poor Jews get blamed for just about everything!
Very nice presentation. As far as I can see the period of the black death had little to do with the renaissance which was already occurring before and survived despite the plague. The medieval ages were a time of enlightenment. Calamity happens. Humans persevere.
I find it funny that the same country from which the third major Black Death plague also gave us the current coronavirus pandemic! :P
Also, it looks like The Nazi Genocide was not the only Jewish Holocaust to take place!
Yeah history is kinda on a loop rn.
0:48 Of course they thought it was the end of the world, I don't think that is ignorant I think that some people thought COVID was the end of the world so of course the people who lived through the plague thought it was the end of the world
I love your show. I’m American, here in Florida. It’s a funny story, but my Grandmother was “ Bubo” to us. We pronounced it Buh- Boh. Anyway, it all came about because my eldest brother was being taught about Buffaloes by my Grandmother. He couldn’t say “ Buffalo “, just “ Bubo”, so that was her name for all of the grandchildren. She wasn’t the nicest person ( neither am I, admittedly). However, it was really ironic when I learned about what the sores were called during The Black Plague.
I don't want to offend you but I just watched your documentary and now I am watching the one which BBC made seven years ago. And now I am dissapointed because you stole almost the whole story, which wouldn't be problematic since it is a history and you can't change history. But you stole whole sentencies which are exactly the same, "Italy was Frontline of Europe" just as example. Im not saying your documentary is not good, im just pointing out you stole another work and presented as yours and even didn't bother to hide it. Very sad man....
Edit: you citating the Giovanni Boccaccio which is also showed in BBC, you used idea that wathcing someone or just thinking about deasie you could get ill....just sad man
What a horrendous disease. It’s repugnant that parents abandoned their sick children. If my child was that sick I’d tend them in order that I might die with them.
I would tend to my kids ,I couldn't desert them because they had plague
My daughter cleans with thieves oil, so l learned a bit about it's bubonic background. Apparently, when caught robbing the afflicted the judge asked how they avoided the disease. They wore the beaked masks filled with the essential oils used in today's cleaning product.
Great episode, well structured and an atmosphere that is very fitting. This video was great
Actually a lot of women who survived benefitted from the plague because of the shortage of workers and services available many actually had their own businesses.
I appreciate the mention at the finale which states the Black Death's cause as a mystery. We have been lead to believe that we now "know" it was bacterial. The manner in, and the speed at which it spread seems to me that it was probably viral. It's interesting how badly "we" freaked out over COVID, and the mortality rate was at most 0.1%, while influenza was roughly 2.0%. Can you imagine an illness with a 30.0% mortality rate? Medieval Europe lived through that! Staggering!
It’s been well established for over a century that it is caused by the bacterium Yersinia Pestis. Recent research suggests that bites of body lice may also be a vector of transmission- given how medieval families would often share a bed and not launder their clothes, may explain the rapid spread.
Yersenia Pestis still survives. There's usually a couple cases a year in the US. It is a bacteria transmitted primarily by fleas or other rodents(such as prairie dogs). But it can go pneumonic, such as COVID did. It's no match for modern antibiotics though. Thank God.
We have a couple cases out here in Wyoming & Colorado.
The pneumatic plague is the one that frightens me. It’s very fast.
I think we "freaked out" over covid because we know about the black death and there was a chance that it could be just as deadly. Thank goodness for modern technologies it was not.
@@jetsandthebombers coronavirus was never anything like as dangerous as the plague. With no treatments or vaccines at all, it would still not have had a comparable death rate. Leftists believe a lot of covid myths. Democrats who were polled said they believed it had a 40% death rate. Utterly false.
You did a great job explaining the Black Plague . !
Very interesting video, I'd certainly welcome more like it!
Those ignorent people back then handled the pandemic better then Trump did.
This world is merciless and cruel. I think the only reason that we continue to have children is that young people don't know any better until it's too late.
I love both of my kids but I do look on them as the most selfish act of my life.
@bruh bruhson Just dumbassess then...?
Wait til there's a plague of haemorrhoids, then you'll know the true meaning of suffering!
The Opium traders must have made a killing!!
I’m sorry but what? They would go on without washing their hands for a LIFETIME? 🤨🤨🤨🤮
Give or take once in evey 50 years or so, i think.
finaly another episode of how to die in medieval period :))))) love these shows
Absolutely addicted to your channel now! Just amazing videos! 👍🏼👍🏼
What a great documentary!! Thanks a lot for your effort, really awesome job. Keep it up!!
Leave it to Italians to compare mass graves to lasagna.
They had enough writers survive with enough of a sense of humor that not even the plague stopped them from their sardonic tendencies toward tragedy. Interesting how much written material exists in Italy from the time, but relatively little exists in other languages at the time.
19:30 = Does anybody remember when “THE HISTORY CHANNEL” did a Mini Series on “THE BLACK DEATH”??? “GOOD WATCH”!!!!!
btw when you find a "gn" in an Italian name, e.g. Agnolo, it's pronounced: Aknee-olo basically, the "g" is silent, a good example maybe "Espagnol" = Spanish, you pronounce it: Espa-knee-ol
This is scary, and to think it still exists out there, we're just somewhat medically advanced(if that's the term?)
It can be easily treated with antibiotics now.
How crazy it was, to be standing and throwing dead bodies like a cannonball.
Appreciate these informative videos!
Very interesting. I thought I knew a bit about the black death but I certainly learnt a lot more.
Can I just say I really like the addition of the more modern photos and video clips. They somehow pin the events in reality. It’s easy to lose the truth of the medieval period within its own artwork and texts.
An excellent, thought provoking & enlightening documentary! Thank you & Well done.
The people comparing this to our current situation is both frustrating and embarrassing. This is, literally, and I'm using that by the definition, hundreds of times worse in practically every way. I honestly called it in March of 2020 and still rub it in everyone's face when I see them.
In other news, looking at the wiki page for history's biggest plagues has told me that south-central China should be vacated. Well.... maybe not, considering how I pretty much advocate a black death tier plague to hit us at this point
Will you still advocate for it if you get it and die? That's the test of character. Too many people who say this have nothing to say or backpedal when I ask if they would keep that same energy if they or people they like are infected/die.
@@Volundur9567 First of all, no matter what I, personally say, it won't change the cringe overreaction in this comment section and all the others.
Second, at worse your grandma and a good friend dying (at worse) is not even comparable to all your neighbors dying; if you cant conceptualize that then you are delusional
@@roninref5152 💯
@@roninref5152 Their comment was response to you saying "I pretty much advocate a black death tier plague to hit us at this point". You didn't respond to anything they said; only things they didn't.
Superstition is alive and well.
The plague bacterium is still present in our environment. They believe it has bacterium blooms, throughout history or in times when Famine or other diseases were becoming epidemic portions. This would weaken the immune system and one form or another to take hold.
Tuberculosis out breaks history works like this.
Both the plague and Tuberculosis are still active and outbreaks still happen. In poverty areas, both can caused contained outbreaks still happen but are rarely measured to the masses to not cause panic and out attitudes to the homeless or those living in extreme poverty aren't really allowed to intermingle with the rest of society.
You mentioning ambergris made me think of the Futurama episode where fry drinks 100 cups of coffee
I would just drink myself into oblivion too.
Definitely like these documentaries! It would be great if you could do one more in depth of peasants lives.
Today much of Great Brittany doth suffer terribly from Torius Pestus, it has been a 12 yr pox upon many houses.
Awesome stuff as always. Will you be making more videos on medeival warfare?
No one at my school talked about that aftermath you said. The fact people were left with houses, terrains. People no longer believed or stayed under his hers masters governmnt and parted away looking for independence, I can surely feel that good vibe from it.
You forgot the carts that collected the corpses. A man would ring a bell and call "Bring out your dead! Bring out your dead!" I saw it in a documentary.
I saw it with my own eyes. i am still having nightmares.
Well, with COVID we didn't reach that stage...
And one guy cried out: But I’m not dead!
And the cart driver carried a club for when the dead person says they aren't dead.
And he maned the cart Borris and Borris was known to have said "I have become death destroyer of worlds"
Poland wasnt so afected by the plague only a freacking quarter of the population 😮
It is cool that we now know that God was punishing Venice for their platform shoes.
I think we can forgive them for believing it was the end of the world. Imagine living in that time yourself, what would you have thought?
Brilliant documentary 💯🔥
The issue I have with the narrative of the bodies being catapaulted is that, being a port, the ship rat would be well esconsed in Caffa itself anyway. It is likely there would have been Plague there before the bodies were catapaulted. Gabriel De Mussis was on one of the galleys that left Caffa, and was crystal clear in his testimony that there were no Plague cases on his ship from Caffa to Genoa. That doesn't mean that one of the other seven galleys did not have Plague cases. If they did, they would have died before they reached Genoa. It is the rats that would have spread it into Genoa. It should be noted that Venice had Plague every year, being a very busy port city and getting goods from around the world. So Plague would have opened at least two fronts in Italy,
It doesn’t remain a mystery what caused the plague. It was Yrsynia pestus.
My sister and brother-in-law are both Pharmacists working in our local NHS hospital. The Pharmaceutical Society is the overseeing body registration ( the Pharmaceutical version of the BMA) and useless, costing over £230 annually.
This year it has been reported that the NHS is haemorrhaging -thos staff group (who have to get a MSc involving University study of 5 years).
This is because of stress, a ridiculous level of workload, disagreeing with the things such a transgender clinics peddling irreversible harm. A recent Psychologidt has been brought into the Department to tell staff that birb out is not a thing or related to the role!!! What chance do kids have when the mental health team are denying such realites!!! The woke mind virus is genuinely worrying and needs stopped asap. Common sense needs reinstate!!!
Also significantly low pay comparative to other outside jobs within the private companies attracts Pharmacists who are completely disalusioned with the NHS and incompetent Management.
Such a shame 😫😓😭😭
Very informative video ... I enjoyed watching the video ... Thank you for sharing ...
banking and usary were a major part of this. debt slavery had caused much of Europe to be in bankruptcy and public works and sanitation had stopped and turned cities into waste dumps.