With any such timeless, beautiful, near-perfect number as your starting point/original, this would always be a HUGE ask. And, IMHO, you’ve done a great job!!!!
I remember the first time I heard you guys perform this song live, and was completely blown away. I'm a Pink Floyd fan from WAY back, and VERY picky about anyone covering one of their songs, but this was absolutely brilliant.
Love everything about it. That girl voice makes it so interesting together with main vocalist. Piano solo instead of guitar one so original. Love it. Hope you gonna get succesfull cuz you guys deserve it. ;) Peace
I started this video and saw some of the complaints in the comments and thought I might turn it off a minute or two into it, but this is actually a really great and different take on the song. I don't think this version needs Gilmour's guitar solos, that's what the original is for. Anyway, great singing and playing here. I love the combination of voices.
Just discovered this Reno band playing at Mt Rose yesterday. I've heard Eric Anderson before and was impressed...the addition of these other artists is even more impressive! Nice job guys!
While I long for the hectic master guitar at the end... even after the first note... this version took me on a journey into the depth of the lyrics... to a place I crave and run from. Just brilliant.
Saw you perform at a house concert in Santa Maria recently, you opened for Glen Phillips of Toad the Wet Sprocket, and I became an instant fan! The Novelists ROCK!
I've always said i'd like to hear this with proper high third and low third vocals..AMAZING!! When you hit the first chorus... goosebumps. Thanks for sharing!
OMG... the voices.... erm... god damn it, whats the english expression for multiple sung tunes... the setup, uh, harmony.... whatever .... just amazing. I´d love to copy it!
That girl can harmonize beautifully. What a voice!
His voice is PERFECT for pink floyd!
The beauty of the harmony , lies within it's simplicity.
best cover iv ever heard
dont get the same feeling with the piano
the guitar solo is always heavenly
It needs both. It begs for both.
It's hard to bend those piano keys
Kids... take note.. this is what real musicianship is.
This video should have millions of views already! Easily one of the best comfortably numb performances.
even without an electric guitar, the song is still BEAUTIFUL!! Great Cover!
One of the best Pink Floyd covers I have ever heard
Nice!! I love the backing vocals, especially the girl's.
Wonderful work! I love, love, love Megan Slankard, too! Awesome stuff! xoxo
My God what a beautiful thing! Come play here in Brazil !
These harmonics... beautiful!
I will always love the original the best but this has totally blew
my mind, this is something else. Totally unbelievable.
Haha the pianist looked like he was having the best time of his life. Thats called passion.
Coming from the pianist, thanks!
Eric Andersen I love your music. Thank a. Lot
Eric Andersen yeah really nice man !!
that's because he's playing the best song ever......and he's really having the best time in his life
you can't feel any other way playing this song
beautiful versión......congrats...
With any such timeless, beautiful, near-perfect number as your starting point/original, this would always be a HUGE ask. And, IMHO, you’ve done a great job!!!!
Chiunque canti questa canzone è da ammirare. Bravissimi!!!!!!!
Great cover and interpretation. This definitely stands on its own feet. Well done!
Fully agree with you on that!
I remember the first time I heard you guys perform this song live, and was completely blown away. I'm a Pink Floyd fan from WAY back, and VERY picky about anyone covering one of their songs, but this was absolutely brilliant.
great spirit thrown in
Love everything about it. That girl voice makes it so interesting together with main vocalist. Piano solo instead of guitar one so original. Love it. Hope you gonna get succesfull cuz you guys deserve it. ;) Peace
Thank you
I started this video and saw some of the complaints in the comments and thought I might turn it off a minute or two into it, but this is actually a really great and different take on the song. I don't think this version needs Gilmour's guitar solos, that's what the original is for. Anyway, great singing and playing here. I love the combination of voices.
Deserves way more views.
understatement of the year
Perfect!!
I am a huge Pink Floyd fan. That has to be the best cover version that I’ve ever heard. (Standing ovation to you )
From another lifelong fan, thank you.
Loved the piano solo!
Perfect , enjoy this song.
This is just a fantastic cover!!!!!! Speechless !!
Only a Word: wanderful!!🔝
Gosh, such harmony!!!...
Absolutely phenomenal...
How does this not have millions of views
loved it to the core..but still ..wish there was a lead solo!...awesome guys...lotta love
Just discovered this Reno band playing at Mt Rose yesterday. I've heard Eric Anderson before and was impressed...the addition of these other artists is even more impressive! Nice job guys!
I have never heard a more beautiful and original cover of this
Delightful, thank you!
While I long for the hectic master guitar at the end... even after the first note... this version took me on a journey into the depth of the lyrics... to a place I crave and run from. Just brilliant.
That piano work is top notch
Amazingly haunting or hauntingly amazing? Thank you for that!
Absolute great performance
Wow. Best cover of this song EVER!
downright emotional and amazing. I hope you guys play in CT
Just incredible. Really enjoyed this!
That was killer I liked the piano solo too
This is the best Comfortably Numb cover I've ever heard!! :)
Beautiful, so so good
what a beautiful and majestic song. omg
Saw you perform at a house concert in Santa Maria recently, you opened for Glen Phillips of Toad the Wet Sprocket, and I became an instant fan! The Novelists ROCK!
great cover of one of the hardest songs of all time!! keep it up.
wonderfull !! how nice! Great Version........I loved it.!!
this is amazing
So well done.... brilliant !
Beautiful! Thanks from Brazil.
Outstanding!
You put your print on it. Respect.
awesome voice love this cover
Not many can play this song and do it epically...and they did it...
Curious cover great solo piano
the best Comfortably Numb cover
tremendous version! hope you come to NJ!
Congratulations guys, that was AMAZING
Extremely well done
That was so beautiful. Wow.
Much appreciated.
great song...great group.....amazing piano solo......
+KULT OF SERPENTHYS Thanks for the kind words! Glad you like the piano solo!! :-)
yes ..is amazing...thanks for this great moment
Wow, great version.
Beautiful... Just beautiful!
Awesome acoustic cover version ! Love it !!
Merci, c'est une jolie reprise!! Le piano qui remplace la guitare électrique donne du charme à cette superbe chanson! Bravo
WOW... Great cover...
Outstanding.
Essa canção é incrível...cada cover mais lindo que outro
harmonies are very good !!!
I've worked with a few PF cover bands and you guys are great
VERY well done!!! Love ur voices. Do u tour in California? Would love to see u live.
Great sound
That is absolutely beautiful. Inspired me to do this with my band. Great work :)
if you wanna hear the epic guitar solo just listen to the original. this is something different
Just fantastic,, I on the other hand loved the Keys Great harmony ,, very well done,, just Fantastic kodi
Great cover of a great song. Thank you for sharing.
I forgot how much I love this. :)
this is great, a very deferent handling with this timeless music
wonderful cover guys
Awesome, simply love it ♥
MAGNIFICO
this sounds beautiful
I've always said i'd like to hear this with proper high third and low third vocals..AMAZING!! When you hit the first chorus... goosebumps. Thanks for sharing!
Mike Hericks Much obliged.
Hooo! Those harmonies!!
OMG... the voices.... erm... god damn it, whats the english expression for multiple sung tunes... the setup, uh, harmony.... whatever .... just amazing. I´d love to copy it!
amazing cover ! I really loved it !
this gave me shivers it was so good. love the harmonies! and the stand up bass effect
best cover I ever heard of this song - really great. Everyone is perfect with his part!
thats amazing guys
Beautiful cover
great cover - love your harmony
What a great version I’m such a pink floyd snob . well done guys
Thank you, Paul.
Too good!!
this is not a bad cover! Not great but surely not bad! This is my most favorite all time song so i can be hard on covers of this one!
This was beautiful. I love alternate takes on a familiar theme. You are "The Novelist".
GREAT!
Hauntingly done, beautiful arrangement!