David Bowie/Eddie Vedder "Comfortably Numb"--A Fan Edit
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 фев 2016
- A fan edit that I made of the Gilmour/Bowie "Comfortably Numb" and the Waters/Vedder version.
I do not own the material in this video. No copyright infringement intended. 
Видеоклипы
![Eddie Vedder & The Earthlings - Purple Rain - Beacon Theater (February 4, 2022) [MULTICAM,SBD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rxkIKIMXbBI/mqdefault.jpg)
Doc: You've got 5 minutes to live.
Me: I want to hear Comfortably Numb.
Doc: But that's 7 minutes.
God: It's okay.
Oh this brings me to tears.
My brother sang this song to our father during his last hours.
@@sanverv1666 WOW what a tear jerker Sandra. What a beautiful song for Dad tho. Great choice.
Fantástico
You nailed it Molly 👍! Love
Deanna Kell and what a perfect reply!
I love how Bowie puts his own trademark on this song with his amazing and unique voice.. Vedder has that amazing baritone voice. Both voices complement them so wonderfully.
Bowie's not bad but all I heard was a guy singing out of tune on this one.
@j.franklin21 probably because he was dying.
EU. DISSE. A. VOZ. PARA. EDDIE. NÃO. PARA. DAVID BOWIE. E. QUE. EU. SAIBA. DAVID. NUNCA. FOI. GUITARRISTA. MAS. SIM. DAVID. GUITARRISTA DO. PINK. FLOYD. !!!!!!!
Eddie can sing ANY song and make it sound great.
And, make it his own. Great voice.
Eddie Vedder’s voice is just perfect for this. I remember getting goosebumps the first time I heard it.
Love it!
Me too! Never heard him before.
David bowie
Eddie veddie is perfect
And David's I love them both
David Gilmore's guitar solo touches all the sore places in my soul. What a wonderful version of a spectacular song.
My favourite solo of all time. This is a great version but for me the 3
2016 love at pompeii is the GOAT. Great line up on this song. Wow
This really is the best, isn't it? The production and Gilmore's guitar growl are awesome
My favorite from Pink Floyd. I tried to numb myself for years and years but never achieved comfortably numb. I relate to this song so much.
Both David Bowie and Eddie Vedder managed to make this song theirs. Eddie is always a satisfaction for ears and eyes. David Gilmour's solos are some of the greatest pleasures of life.❤
David Gillmor..One of the most recognized guitar solos in rock..It doesn't get any better than that.
Eternal Gillmour ❤
You butchered the spelling of his name bro
Totally agree
This whole collaboration is brilliant.
Goose bumps.
It doesn't get Eddie Vedder than that!
Gilmour, Bowie Vedder that's some music royalty together on stage right there
Words cannot describe the effect this song has always had on me ... a soul soaring, deeply yearning, transcendent epiphany that stretches on and on ... and with Eddie singing it takes it to the next level ... tears are still running down my face.
Same 🤧❤️
D A V I D
Couldn't say it better
no idea why but as soon as Eddie started singing tears flooded my eyes usually only Wish You Were Here makes me cry and Eddie Vedder never has
@@klummpskards5652 that is because it is literally not about an 'idea.' It is about feeling ...
In a perfect world, the guitar solo in “Comfortably Numb” would last an hour.
mastertuneman would never end... Gilmour is a fucking magician
Just simply majestic imho speaks volumes to the soul wish I was there David Gilmour legendary axemam wish I could play the guitar 🎸 like him awesome 😎
Pressing the like button more than once doesn't work like I want...
It's always playing somewhere
Maybe two!
Vedder has the perfect emotional voice for this one. WOW.
Yesss! True
RIP Bowie, thanks for sharing your talent and making the world a better place💕
I have always loved Bowie, was fortunate to have seen him in concert(s). I am now a grandmother of a 28, 21 and 18 year old (granddaughters). They all love Bowie, how amazing is that?
Spot on
Eddie is just incredible, the man nails every cover he’s ever done.
Pure Magic....Words cannot describe the beauty of this song....At 64 It still amazes me how music can touch my soul & and give me a sense of well being & Happiness that nothing else on this earth ever came close to! Thanks Guys.
Gary Corson
Your words could not be more perfect.
Blah blah blah old people Facebook post on RUclips blah blah blah
@@ptaav Go stick your head back up your ass, dipshit.
I get it.
@@ptaav old people music is real music. Sorry youngun.
This is my absolutely top favourite version of Comfortably Numb, I keep coming back to listen to this. Im always scared it wont be here anymore. Thank you for creating this, lifts every atom of me
And me 👌
And me !!
Download it 👀
I’m here with you 🎉❤
And me 😢
Eddie singing this great masterpiece gave me chills.
When you know the story of Bowie and the health problems that plagued him at that time, you can only admire this performance! He was diminished but chose this return on stage with intelligence as always. The text fits perfectly with the circumstances of his illness and his fragile voice, almost clumsy and like coming out of the grave, proves that Bowie is one of the greatest! Forever...
Raphaël Hénon So true
I agree...I dont recall seeing him again after that except on Ricky Gervais Extras (which was really funny) and maybe a few more interviews. Oh, and the "funny moments" on camera. His humor is even funny. Sorta corny, but that just makes me laugh more!
I love this so much.
Raphaël Hénon I know!!
Thank God he survived! We've lost too many to what this song represents! That being said, I could listen to it non-stop all day and night!
This confirmed it even more for me that although Eddie Vedder might not be always front page news, when he appears in tributes, everyone stops and says "wow thats Vedder"
Immortal
One of my favorite singers of all time. His voice is recognizable in any and every song that he is a part of
God, yes, Eddie's voice is amazing
Indeed! Amazing voice!
Perfect analysis
Eddie Vedder always puts his heart and soul into a song. He really outdid himself with this one though. Amazing!
Wow! Love Bowie and Eddie. This is incredible. Thank you to the person that put it together. RIP StarMan.
♥
It had to be the masterful Bowie. He was a creative genius and craftsman. With clear vision of what could be.
I love Eddie Vedder singing this song. It's a great classic but his raw emotion just brings me to tears it's so beautiful.
& David Gilmour is fantastic as always.
And Bowie of course
Yes! Bad of me to not mention them,
How can anyone get into a debate over who owns this rendition vocally? Clearly those people are listening with their ears. Vedder & Bowie, so different, so perfect. Genius pairing. Vedder bleeding the pain, Bowie stiff upper lip perfection , pure composure. And THAT solo.... every time I cry. Sublime brilliance by all, thank you x
Thanks
@@Moviebox424Did you really reply as if you were Eddie Vedder saying thank you? 😂😂😂😂
That's only because Pink wasn't well... she stayed back at the hotel!! Lol.
At 67-years-old, I am shedding copious tears of joy at the unquestionably fine art of this melody, the lyrics, and especially the bravura performances of the vocalists and instrumental musicians! It is gratifying to remember that this music moved me very deeply when I first heard it decades ago and continues to do so. Thank you immensely for this artful fan mix!
That whole album is impactful, and honestly describes what's happening in the world now in its current political climate. I'm 42 by the way.... to much great music is getting forgotten lately.
@@timm.6391 Your words are so very true, and welcomed. For such a young guy at 42, you have much better taste than most of my peers at 68!
46 yrs old
But at least i grew up listening to my grandparents, parents, brother s , friends....
And i also agree.....
I am nostalgic..... i woul like to travel back ...... al least i can do it listening to this fine piece of art.....
Art that shapes humanity....
Sorry for my english....
I am fluent in spanish and french.
@@raxatzelleitzelarhernandez9698 Your English (an extremely illogical and therefore difficult language to master if you weren't born into it; and even then, most Americans have no idea whatsoever how to speak English anywhere near correctly) is MUCH MUCH better than any of my later-in-life learned languages! Your ideas were completely understood by me, and very much appreciated!
Me too,it reminds me of being mentally unstable I feel that way everyday and I am 57,saw the wall tour when I was 15 I am struggling badly
I'd be happy to go out comfortably numb with Eddie singing me on my way. So privileged for him to share a wonderful song with David.
Have to say this version with Bowie, Vedder and Gilmore is outstanding! It touches me deeper than any other 8:12
Love this so much and have made sure to share it with all my rocknroll friends!
I have seen Bowie, Eddie and Pink Floyd in concert. This tops it all.
I love pearl jam, pink Floyd and David Bowie put them together and you have pure ecstasy!
I want to thumbs up but ill leave it at 69
I could not agree more.
Thank you all for the amazing music.......we all miss David Bowie so damn much it hurts.Gone but never forgotten David Bowie.
Thanks for your love and support I really appreciate
Many years ago I remember while reading a library book to my son in the background I was playing Bowie. My first memory was...why did I do that? Perhaps the damn book was so boring it was the only way to get through it. On the positive side, no wonder my son, my daughter and my granddaughters love Bowie. It must be inherited! LOL! I believe his music will live on as evidenced by my family (granddaughters are 18, 22 and 29). RIP StarMan, gone but your talent lives on.
This world is just that more empty without you, awesome David Bowie🥀
Two of my all time favorites collaborating on one of the best songs ever is pure bliss💜💜💜
Hello dear, how are you doing today? Nice meeting you here.
Eddie Vedder can sing anything, with anyone and make me cry.
The voice of an angel
The voice of a very sexy Angel 😂❤😇
Me too.....
He can. He is never outdone; not by Jagger, by Springsteen, by Beyonce, by any singer. His duets are truly amazing. As is all of his work.
AbbyNormal777 that is absolutely true for me as well!!
My 90 yr old father asked to die with this song playing and by God he got it!!!💖💖🥀🥀🥀🥀💖💖💖🥀🥀🥀
Perfect end. Bless
By God he did.
All my respects! Blessings!
Ann your father received his final comfortably numb feeling ...Sorry for your loss... I think that you had a cool father.
Well done your Da. 😊👍
Just came across this now in 2021.....wow, wow......wow. Gilmour never disappoints, Vedder hits it and reminds us how Bowie is missed....
Genios totales!!!! Eddie, David y Gilmour....impecables!!!!!!
Bowie forever
This song is magic. With Bowie , my eternal favorite and Vetter proving just how good he is as a singer. That guitar solo could go on forever. I love this song in every form.
Sorry...Vedder,not Vetter
@@sabrinadurando4498 sorry Sabrina, I am human and I made a mistake.
@@doreenmoore1134 Its kind of a big mistake.
Vedder...
Hey Daisy eat shi!
@@doreenmoore1134 Another misspell. It's shit, not shi.
Oh, that moment when Eddie starts! Pure pleasure.
Same here. I found myself in tears in an instant. He has the gift, the magic, the shining.
@@ElephantRage Just caused the 4 229 295th view...
Same. It amazes me his voice every time I listen to this one.
Gained a bit of a new found respect for Eddie. Chris Cornell was my always go to guy but Eddie just has the incredibly unique voice...
Yes.
Eddie sounded like he wrote it. No disrespect. The most comfortably numbing guitar solo ever.
I told ya his voice was on fire
David still has it.
Mike Patton I don’t want to like cause your at my favourite number
@@seeglines I've heard the original copy. I was just giving him a compliment 😂. Originals are hard to duplicate. That's why it's better to write new things. 👍
@@seeglines Compared to Bowie, Eddie Veder owns the song. There's something about the way Bowie interjects too much Bowie leaving that impression.
My compliments to whoever created this masterpiece. It is so emotionally beautiful. Unforgettable performance by both David Bowie and Eddie Vedder. Thank you for creating and sharing this.
His name is Roger Waters
The lyrics were written by Roger Waters and the music was composed by David Gilmour of Pink Floyd off their 1979 album, The Wall.
Eddie's voice is amazing
At 71yrs it makes me feel so sick that this great music is not known by all. Please come back.
Mate, I've just turned 40 and I work with young people, I'm doing my part to ensure music like this spans the generations... and trust me, dismal as it (the music industry) may seem sometimes, not all is lost!
I think of it this way. In the 1970s my parents preferred their 50s music. I had no use for it then. Now its roots rock and I cannot get enough. But in 2020 a song like this one by the seminal band Pink Floyd no matter how thrilling, magic and life changing is 40 years old. I waa 21 in 1979, now 62. How did that happen?! That 40 year time difference would equate to my grandparents big band music of the 1940s. Really no use for it in the 1970s. Now find it very well put together with charts that include a full brass section not just one sax and full of the amazing energy of youth. Comfortably Numb speaks to my high times before there were consequences. I stopped using in 1979. The only other band I can think of that transmits near the same feeling about a high for me is The Cure. Peace.
@@rickbangkok I absolutely love “Pictures of You!”
im 18 and just discovered this song and Pink Floyd as a whole recently and cant get enough of it
Really?? Get a life my dear. It's not too late!!
Comfortably numb (original): perfect
+ David bowie: masterpiece
+ Eddie Vedder: celestial, God's work
Amen to that my friend
@@patlyons1524 AMEN!
Perfect
Absolutely!
💜
Vedder KILLS it---so good!!
Hello dear, how are you doing today? Nice to meeting you here.
Eddie Vedder from 3:51-4:21....remarkable. The cameraman knew what he was capturing in the moment.
This is exactly what an eight minute anthem should sound like - from Bowie’s unforgettable intro to Dave Gilmour’s virtuoso performance with Eddie Vedder bringing it all together. An all time great which should make everyone’s top 10 all-time list.
I could listen to David Gilmour play for the rest of my life!!...what a gracious man! A true gentleman !!!!
Eddie has such a beautiful voice man.... one of the best singers of all time without a doubt
That's true
Anyone else feel this? - "When I was a child I had a fever, My hands felt just like two balloons" Gives me goosebumps remembering this as a child.
Always thought the lyric was swelt like two balloons 😂
Went to see David Gilmour in concert in Toronto for my 50th birthday. I felt more "The Child has grown, the dream is gone!"
@@mikeducas66 that’s awesome! I am completely jealous. Just to be clear… I am referring to an actual feeling as a child. I had a fever over 105deg and I literally felt like my hands were balloons. What’s even scarier is my grandmother insisted I sweat it out. Which thankfully I did. But yeah… the child is grown, the dream is gone. Comfortably numb man!
The actual word is tubaloons, which is small tuba that is shaped like a water bird. But it's a double play on words.
2019 I miss David Bowie ♥
we all do
Yes me too
Me too
💜🥺💜
@@snapdragonfly6652 feb 2020 , still not good
A thousand words can not describe what listening to that masterpiece feels like. This is what music is all about! Fantastic.
David Bowie my favourite singer and Eddie Vedder my favourite front man singing my favourite Pink Floyd song. Such talent. I must be in heaven 🥰😍
Thanks
Is that a new spelling? Lol, touching
Me too. Sublime
Miss Bowie so much. This song is a masterpiece from two perfectionists. Vetter is unbelievable. And that guitar solo, incredible.
Comfortably Nunb ❤will definitely live on 4 decades to come..I’m 70 & still & always luv it.
One of the most amazing songs by a band of which I saw live - sung by 2 of the most unbelievable singers .Pink Floyd ,David Bowie ,Eddie Vedder !!!!! 🙏🥺🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
This song just flattens me. Picks me back up and flattens me again. It's like a religious experience.
Gawd this is perfection. It is like Bowie's vulnerability is being countered with Vedder's vocal power!! Awesome!
Eddie is purely untouchable, such a flippin' amazing voice...can sing ANYTHING!
Aaron I agree!
Agree
Except redemption song lol :P
How about my old mans a dustman ?
Thanks
Brings tears to my 61years old eyes because I grew up with this and also saw(some) of this. This is MUSIC!
How is that every song sounds better with Eddie Vedder singing it? Amazing.
I love It too! Eddie's voice Is perfect for this song
Eddie Is perfect for every Song..
His voice makes Dream!
gilmours voice sounds way better here to me.
Nope, definitely not. He could never sing any songs from the Gods, he can't touch " the Hammer of the Gods"! I like Eddy, but go listen to him sing Throw your Arms Around Me with Mark Seymour, Mark just puts him to shame!
Eddie sings with his Heart and soul.that's why
My absolute favorite is getting comfortably numb while listening to Comfortably Numb. It really goes together very well.
Everything great and then comes the Gilmour solo as the finale.
Gives me chills
This is my all-time favourite song, I have the music notes to the chorus line as a tattoo. That guitar solo never fails to give me chills. The combination of Eddie Vedder and David Bowie with Pink Floyd, awesome. I miss David Bowie so much.
No two ways about it. Gilmour is a guitar god 🤘
Pure genius
I teared up. I'm not gonna lie
Eddie sings from the soul absolutely magic
It's astonishing, you can feel how it all comes from pure emotion.
Sings His Heart Out, Every Track!! Regynoble1
His voice causes a visceral reaction in me, everytime.
Always
He always dose
Love David Bowie and Eddie Vedder; two very beautifull voices. And on top of this the best song of Pink Floyd with David Gilmour on guitar; What a treat; thanks.
Two of the greatest vocalists sing one of the greatest songs ever
Eddie Vedder voice is so powerful, it's just like a cold surreal for me, something like a magnet that once you hear it you will stay just to listen to him.....
I love all 3 of them, but David Gilmour quite literally shines in this performance.
Coming out of a 3yr relapse on hard drugs and I find this. That Guitar solo makes me all week in the knees, seeing BOWIE is like the ghosts of better days gone by and as usual EDVED stands and delivers amongst some of the finest musicians to ever play rock n roll. Thanks to the Universe for PINK FLOYD and PEARL JAM...
I've said it before, and I will say it again: David Gilmour is one of the most underrated guitarists in rock. Excellent fan edit :)
You've said it, but don't do it any more. David Gilmour is not underrated. He is great. People who don't know that don't know music.
Rare talent
Word
I and many others think he is the best, Check out "The Gilmour Effect" on Ricke Beato's page.
Underrated?
an Italian poem reads like this, only with these few words:
- "I enlighten myself with immensity". The same sensation occurs to me every time I listen to "Comfortably Numb" solo's
Dario: Bene. Molto Bene. So fascino...Grazie K.L.
Dario: Yes yes YEASSS!!! 🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼
M'illumino d'immenso , very beautiful and musical in italian 💖
Mind blown. I’m transfixed by this. Absolutely transfixed. My father’s favorite song...on steroids. He would have loved this. Miss you dad. RIP
😥❤
Aaron lewis version Is pretty sweet. If you haven't heard it
Thank you!
may he rip
🥺
Sheer magic!! I got butterflies, chills and my heart skipped beats all at once!!
I love it when artists get together and co create a different version from something by Pink Floyd did. Bowie and Vedder were perfect. It brought back memories.
Thanks I love you
@@Moviebox424 your welcome. Hows it going?
So much talent , RIP David Bowie so miss you xx
Geraldine Mclaughlin .
Foi uma grande perda Pri Rock in Roll R.I .P .....
I was just wine cruising around youtube.....man I needed this...
Happy wine cruise!
I am Irish Whiskey Cruising. Always find the best stuff when I do that.
In Vino Veritas!
Ditto, my friend. This is an amazing find.
I'm on a 'all by my self' Corona birthday with a lot of beers RUclips session and came her randomly. Great choice RUclips!!!
Manaus
I didnt enjoy Bowie much on this, but Eddie Vedder owns it. Man, I'm glad I stumbled on this.
The Chameleon, grunge and the legendary guitarist...beyond words 😢
i love the way eddie truly feels the music
The sudden death of David really shocked me. One of the most creative people ever. Here with Eddie: awesome!
For a minute you had me thinking David Gilmour had died and I didn’t know it, as I was reading your comment during the David Gilmour solo. Then I realized you meant David Bowie. Phew!
Look at all the stunned young ones being introduced to oldies music at DG's magical solo guitar playing.
David Gilmore never fails to send chills down my spine
Whoever did this has my eternal love and respect. Thanks for such a jewel!
Thank you!
Jose Rodrigo Cortez Alvarez
It was Pink Floyd (with both Waters and Gilmore), Bowie and Vedder. They are who you have to thank.
Holy shit, that's fucking amazing.
Thank you!
Fan Komiksów it so is!!!!!
I agree.
That guitar solo was straight up FIRE!!👍🏻👍🏻✌✌
Davids voice is perfect! Ed performance perfect!
Wow, that was the balls. David Gilmour, Waters, Vedder and Bowie. Now that would be a show I'd stay all fkn week for!
I couldn't help comment on this. I am a music fan primarily Grunge, and I have to admit that I have never heard such an amazing version of the song. So tense! Such great voices! Thank God for covers!!! Bowie will live forever. Eddie rocks!!!
Excellent.
@Roy Lay I agree THIS IS DAVID'S SONG. And never forget RICK !!!!
@Roy Lay it's all good..thanks to everyone for this..they are all my favorites
That's not really a cover David wrote it
phoenixon this is what music has done since the beginning of time. Yeah, it takes you “there”, wherever your “there” may be.
It feels like hallowed ground.
It’s all so gorgeous and almost hurts it’s so beautiful
❤❤❤
Jesus. Who knew Bowie was sick then? But, as always, he rose above ALL of it, and gave a brilliant, beautiful rendition of this iconic song. Unforgettable.
8 minutes and 16 seconds of pure joy and goosebumps. Gilmour, Vedder and Bowie wow what a fantastic trio to sing together 😍
While Gilmour's guitar gently weeps. If we could only sit back and listen all day to this masterpiece.
Now back to work, slacker
I go through all my favorite saves at least twice a year! Bowie is fabulous but my heart is forever with Eddie!!!!
1000 Dank für dieses göttliche Herzerleben dürfen. Sei gesegnet, wir sind alle nicht nur im Herzen verbunden. Licht und Liebe 💗
This is one of the most powerful renditions of that solo by Gilmour I've heared so far. Then again, every one brings tears to my eyes. Always.
Love this from both unbelievable musicians with a heart of gold, as for numbskull who chose to justify their existence,by denigrating those who contribute to the world, you can always free us of your venom!!
Poor Bowie wasn't ready for those bright lights to hit him in the face! He sure backs up fast. I sure miss Bowie. 4 icons! And this song has always hit my heart so bad. Love it. RIP Bowie.
Some people are timeless no matter where or what their art form is.
Bowie and Eddie Vedder. I miss David Bowie so much and Eddie Vedder you keep on truckin' Dude! AWESOME! You guys lit my fire!
We have to not let Eddie die. We can't let him go like the others. We need to keep him alive.
Absolutely
THAT comment brought tears to my eyes.
I think he gets it, terribly sad that the others voices were stolen
Me too
It's a snowy day here in the northeast ...I think I will just turn on auto play and reminisce about days gone by and the musicians we have lost....and are forever grateful for the music they left us...LOUD LOVE
♡♡♡
This is one of the most amazing things I've ever seen! I graduated in 1992! Man talk about a gift! Bowie, Vedder and Gilmore... Sheer perfection💕 Everytime I hear it I've got.goosebumps through the entire thing!!! RIP David Bowie and thank.you so much for the gifts you gave us! Long live Eddie Vedder you beautiful man! Flawless... Gilmore .... Just Holy Sh*t!💕💕💕💕
I graduated 94 around same time as u . We grew up in one of best music generation I think n all around good times. I miss the 90s lol
At 62, I've been lucky enough to hear this live on stage many times over the years, it has always moved me to tears. Listening to this version has done just the same. Thank you.
Thank you for this wonderful creation. Bowie, Gilmour & Vedder = BRILLIANT
"..and then cut back to the Gilmour solo..." Homie.. HOMIE.. I love your brain. This is EXCELLENT.
Thank you!
Best fan edit of anything.
Thank you dude.
You're welcome!
Thank YOU!
Sean Ellis tkn You!
keyser soze awesome!!!.flawless!!!
I totally agree!
Eddie and David… saw them so often . This is a favorite ♥️♥️♥️. Both are/have phenomenal.
David for him as well as Eddie what he’s doing for humanity
This performance is absolutely amazing!