Is motorcycle VED fair? The recent budget’s impact on motorcyclists

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 дек 2024

Комментарии • 221

  • @theodavies8754
    @theodavies8754 День назад +60

    A pothole has to be 30cm wide and have a 40mm vertical edge to count as a defect.
    The roads aren't even car worthy let alone safe for motorcycles.

    • @chrispomphrett4283
      @chrispomphrett4283 15 часов назад

      North Yorkshire council must be getting sick of me flooding them with pot hole reports. Don't care what the size, if it's big enough to see, then I report it. Everyone should take a little time to do this instead of moaning. Chap at work fractured his cast ally rim, when I asked if he'd reported the hole...nope.

    • @theodavies8754
      @theodavies8754 14 часов назад

      @chrispomphrett4283 it doesn't get a job number if it doesn't count.
      Some months after it's been given a number, it might get repaired.
      I hit a pothole in July that had a ramp patched into it.
      I had oncoming headlights and didn't see it in time.
      It had a 5" vertical edge. I hit it at 40 mph and damaged my lower back.
      There will be more deaths and personal injuries,it's inevitable.

  • @CR-nm3nd
    @CR-nm3nd День назад +81

    Paying tax related to vehicle weight, car and motorcycles seems eminently sensible. Therefore there is no way this government would ever consider it

    • @PaulBissekerBushcraft
      @PaulBissekerBushcraft День назад +3

      electric cars weigh loads

    • @Sankara561
      @Sankara561 15 часов назад

      Should be a pay-per-mile charge banded by vehicle weight.

    • @TheOriginalCoda
      @TheOriginalCoda 15 часов назад +4

      What seems sensible on the initial consideration is entirely stupid in reality. Do you REALLY want to live your life looking at excel sheets to determine how much tax you'll pay on everything?
      Eventually you'll pay personal income tax depending on how many lbs you weigh, because they'll say it correlates to health-care cost or some such nonsense.
      Don't get sucked in!

    • @TheOriginalCoda
      @TheOriginalCoda 14 часов назад +2

      @@Sankara561 We need LESS complication not MORE.

    • @unconventional-rebel
      @unconventional-rebel 11 часов назад

      Lorries have paid VED related to axle weight to compensate for road damage for decades. The govt don't have to invent the wheel, just broaden out the categories.

  • @garyc7464
    @garyc7464 16 часов назад +19

    VED should be zero for motorcycles. We are part of the solution. And governments should be encouraging their use!

    • @melvynmanning9427
      @melvynmanning9427 11 часов назад +4

      Never gonna happen. They’re blind to any sensible promotions. We know that much.

  • @MrPete81
    @MrPete81 День назад +71

    Governments just don't like motorcycles, full stop :(
    Thank you for your efforts through MAG though, it is appreciated!

    • @FlowCharge
      @FlowCharge День назад

      this is the way and always has been, we are an unwanted, unloved, misunderstood and under-appreciated minority (and always have been). Such a shame.

    • @jfro5867
      @jfro5867 18 часов назад

      They don’t like us full stop. Nothing they do makes any sense nowadays.

    • @garyc7464
      @garyc7464 16 часов назад +2

      I've never known a government ever support motorcycling. They all say good things before they're elected, then renague on any useful promises. Though this Labour lot are the worst I have experienced. Vote Reform going forwards.

    • @jfro5867
      @jfro5867 16 часов назад +1

      @@garyc7464 100% yep. Wife & I voted Reform last election, came a close 2nd where I live. Next time we should get across the line.

    • @davejohnson3474
      @davejohnson3474 14 часов назад

      ​​@@garyc7464livingston and blair did there were motorcycle bays all over the place but now they've all been taken away

  • @69USD
    @69USD День назад +51

    My car does 25,000 miles a year at £30, my bike does 3,000 miles over 6 months at over £60. Doesn't make sense!

    • @TheOriginalCoda
      @TheOriginalCoda 14 часов назад +2

      I have 3 bikes that I do a combined mileage of about 5000 a year on. However, without doing the SORN dance, I'm expected to pay over £360 a year for that privilege.

    • @B2C2007
      @B2C2007 13 часов назад

      ​@@TheOriginalCoda Sounds like you would benefit from road pricing then.

    • @TheOriginalCoda
      @TheOriginalCoda 12 часов назад +1

      @@B2C2007 I disagree with permanent toll roads on principle

    • @unconventional-rebel
      @unconventional-rebel 11 часов назад

      My car tax is free yet weighs 6x more and averages twice the fuel consumption than my bike which costs £55. Is there any justification at all?

    • @melvynmanning9427
      @melvynmanning9427 11 часов назад

      Because…..the establishment would like bikes done away with. Over my dead body.

  • @SteveBernard42
    @SteveBernard42 День назад +43

    It’s unfortunate that successive governments have had no interest in promoting motorcycles. The scale of VED rates for bikes is obviously ridiculous…….except to the government. When have common sense and government ever been bedmates?

    • @233kosta
      @233kosta 23 часа назад

      'Tis sadly in line with inflation. And I mean REAL inflation, not those made-up figures they cram down people's throats every chance they get

  • @Liam1304
    @Liam1304 День назад +34

    Flip guys, here in New Zealand the government is putting our yearly registration for a 1 litre bike up to around 300 pounds and it's going to increase each year for the next few years. Governments don't want cheap, easy to park motorbikes. They want to get ICE vehicles off the road and our bikes are an obvious annoyance to this ideological position.

    • @miyrides1180
      @miyrides1180 16 часов назад

      How much is the fine for no rego

    • @Liam1304
      @Liam1304 16 часов назад +1

      @@miyrides1180 Not sure but it's certainly getting to the point where people will be taking the risk

    • @miyrides1180
      @miyrides1180 9 часов назад +1

      @@Liam1304 I'm in the UK,costs me $180 bucks tax for my speed twin,I have 3 bikes in NZ ,I only use them for the one month of the year when I'm there and it still costs me more there,the NZ gov hate motorcycles.they are seeyouentes

  • @jfro5867
    @jfro5867 18 часов назад +8

    If the Government were serious they would promote small capacity motorcycles (such as the Honda 125, Enfield 350’s etc) that do 100mpg, are physically small, practical, last forever, can be run on a shoestring. Genuine motoring for the masses.

  • @handsfree1000
    @handsfree1000 День назад +19

    We motorcyclists pay the most and in return get the worst deal, the centre of the road is never cleared of grit and mud (I live in a rural area) and shiney ironwork is nearly always in the centre of the road especially on a bend.

    • @garyc7464
      @garyc7464 16 часов назад +1

      Drains & fancy cobbles on the exit point of mini islands where I live. No thought about motorcyclists safety at all!

  • @martinoconnor4314
    @martinoconnor4314 День назад +15

    I've only got one bike left now, I sold the rest but I made sure to keep one registered as a Historic Vehicle so no tax or MOT.

  • @robreed2999
    @robreed2999 День назад +20

    The road tax on motorcycles is extortionate considering the 3rd world dirt tracks the government call roads 🤬 % support for MAG and British bikers 👍💪🏍⛽🇬🇧

  • @geoffdelve6291
    @geoffdelve6291 День назад +28

    my yaris hybrid only does 60mpg and currently pays no tax, i just sold a CB500X WHhich did 94mpg but paid £71 , my new MT07 does 67mpg and currently pays £117 , none of these costs in any way reflects there Co2 emissions

  •  День назад +13

    It should be £30 flat rate for bikes and £15 for learners

    • @oojimmyflip
      @oojimmyflip 5 часов назад

      damm dont buy a trike its even worse for an extra wheel😂

  • @martinrew9285
    @martinrew9285 3 часа назад +1

    Your argument is totally logical, and the reason I pay a paltry sum to be a MAG member. If we don't argue for our rights, no one else will. United we stand... Join MAG if you want to keep your right to ride, free and fair.

  • @pugsleyenoch1558
    @pugsleyenoch1558 День назад +14

    Just rejoined MAG

  • @vipertwenty249
    @vipertwenty249 День назад +11

    It's all about the income from tax for the government and that's about it. If you're looking for joined up thinking you really ought to know by now that no government does that.

  • @paulphillips8855
    @paulphillips8855 День назад +9

    Toyota Aygo less than half the cost VED and insurance yet double the wheels, a lot more weight and pollution compared with my 200cc scooter! Make it make sense

    • @wheater5
      @wheater5 3 часа назад

      Same thing here, comparing my Fiat Panda 1.2 @ £35 and my Suzuki Burgman scooter @£55, the latter only having done 7,500 miles since 2012.

  • @PurityVendetta
    @PurityVendetta День назад +6

    I'm sure we have an associated membership of MAG through our membership of the VJMC. I'd really like to read the magazine.
    I'm sure I remember a study many years ago imagining if the VED applied to vehicles were to be based on the damage to roads and emissions. As I recall the study concluded that the disproportionate damage and pollution caused by trucks compared with other vehicles would mean that all other categories would pay a fraction of what we actually do.
    Governments of all flavours and brands have always hated motorcycles for nothing more than ideological reasons.
    As always, good work MAG.

  • @MrTench8
    @MrTench8 День назад +21

    The early 80's saw massive strides forward in motorcycle design and performance. You can ride a tax and mot exempt bike now (40 years old) that is relatively "modern". You don't have to ride some old lamp post counter to take advantage of those financial benefits these days. Admitedly i am getting on in my years so i no longer hunger for the latest and greatest which is just aswell as i think new bike designs are heading in a too high tech direction so one of these 80's bikes restored is far more appealing to me at a fraction of the cost to run.

    • @John-cz2pe
      @John-cz2pe День назад +2

      Just bought an r100 1980 ,for the same reasons 👍

    • @daigriffiths399
      @daigriffiths399 23 часа назад

      @@John-cz2pe Yep. Five out of my six bikes are VED exempt (they vary from 1979 to 1983). The other one - a Royal Enfield 500 Bullet at Euro 4 standards, so very low emissions - is now £87pa compared to the £52 pa (I think) when I bought it new four years ago. That's more than my wife pays for the Clio sitting in the drive.

    • @unconventional-rebel
      @unconventional-rebel 11 часов назад

      I've got a 1978 GS750, with decent tyres it's only the brakes that are noticibly different to a modern mid range bike.

    • @MHLivestreams
      @MHLivestreams 11 часов назад

      @@unconventional-rebel stick a gsxr front end on

    • @chrisbateman3687
      @chrisbateman3687 49 минут назад

      Yup. My VF1000 is 1985 vintage. My GSX1100EF is also 1985 vintage.
      They're both quite capable machines, and, to my mind at least, much more usable than a 30k Ducati that you daren't ride or park anywhere.

  • @kevbaldwin9552
    @kevbaldwin9552 День назад +25

    If the government want to reduce congestion and emissions then make motorcycles tax free and encourage people to take to two wheels not two tone SUVs

    • @oojimmyflip
      @oojimmyflip 5 часов назад

      our suv weighs 1,400 kgs not 2 tons or even the five tons of some Landrovers. our 4 19inch x 255 tyres last 3 years a set at £85 a corner.

  • @tivvy-xf4kz
    @tivvy-xf4kz День назад +8

    In the dim and distant past it was decided the easiest way to do the VED was on CC.
    Since then motorcycles have got larger and it's hard to think that back in 1970 up till then most bikes were app 650/750 and the Honda 750 four had just been introduced.
    Again standards changed and emissions came into it but because of the 2 strokes bikes carried on in the same format.
    I'm sure the manufacturers will have the emission figures for all their models and a system based on that could be introduced.
    One caveat is that in the UK we are not subject to emission checks so that might open a can of worms at MOT time.
    I don't think it's a deliberate strategy to get bikes off the road they just never consider bikes when they plan this stuff.
    If wear and tear on the roads was the deciding factor all bikes should be free lol

  • @chrisstocks6892
    @chrisstocks6892 День назад +17

    My 4.25ton motorhome £165, my BMW r1150r over £110 both sorned when not in use on this countries shite roads, F them.

    • @chancergordy
      @chancergordy День назад +2

      Yep and if your motorhome is under 3.5ton it is twice the cost of a 3.5ton upwards.

    • @chrisrobinson860
      @chrisrobinson860 9 часов назад

      👍

  • @agrajag868
    @agrajag868 День назад +9

    Why aren't car drivers made to do as much training and stages of their license as bikes, are cars safer or easier to control.

    • @JustmeandB
      @JustmeandB 23 часа назад +1

      People who want to drive a car should have to ride motorcycles first for at least a year, maybe then they would respect the vulnerability and appreciate them more, just a thought, I may be wrong,

  • @nigelfisher3756
    @nigelfisher3756 День назад +7

    The trouble is we’re dealing with mindless bureaucrats and governments who largely don’t give a split second’s thought to the both the safety and cost of motorcycling. When was the last big protest march?

  • @rickconstant6106
    @rickconstant6106 День назад +6

    The main reason for the inconsistencies in the VED rates for cars is that different rules were in place at the time of first registration, and those rules have continued to apply, despite changes for later vehicles. This is fairer to people who chose a model of car because of favourable rates at the time, than moving the goalposts later. I chose my car 8 years ago because of £0 VED (less than 100 gm/km CO2), but they have now decided to start charging £20 from next year.
    I'm fortunate with my bikes, they are both Historic, and still have £0 VED (so far).
    It still doesn't make sense to have bikes paying more than cars, though.

  • @melvyn49
    @melvyn49 День назад +7

    The successive Government's of this Country, have no interest in Motorcyclists. Never have, and never will.

    • @jackn4853
      @jackn4853 День назад

      Why should they? The revenue raised off motorcycles is tiny. I've been riding for 48+ years. And, it's the Govt of the UK not just England.

  • @NooBiker
    @NooBiker День назад +17

    Basing V.E.D. on vehicle weight makes perfect sense.

    • @DaveHines1
      @DaveHines1 День назад +3

      But ! but ! That would penalise the EV brigade and their tanks 😝🤣

    • @EbenBransome
      @EbenBransome День назад +2

      @@DaveHines1 Actually no. Road damage is roughly as the fourth power of axle loading. Cars have hardly any effect. Artics and 18 tonners do the most damage and they would be heavily taxed.
      The difference between, say, a BMW electric 5 series (2.2t) and the highest spect straight petrol version (1.8t) is insignificant in road wear terms, and they are the same size.

    • @DaveHines1
      @DaveHines1 День назад

      @@EbenBransome not sure wether that’s directed at me or @noobiker , but if that is the case why is the road up to a bridge near me with a 3 tonne weight limit , the worst road for miles when it comes to pot holes , believe me there are enough bad roads here , but the one in question stands out above the rest

    • @EbenBransome
      @EbenBransome День назад +2

      @@DaveHines1 Because it's a weak bridge, different issue. There's one at Marlow that can't take Range Rovers.

    • @DaveHines1
      @DaveHines1 День назад +1

      @@EbenBransome Eh, nothing to do with the weak bridge , all that means is that there shouldn’t be any heavy vehicles going on that road but the road still gets trashed , that was my point

  • @CarrieWright-j5x
    @CarrieWright-j5x День назад +7

    It is Totally unfair !...Ridiculous when you consider some cars are free or £30 doing far more damage to the roads .My Triumph street tripple 765 is around £110+ and only covers a few thousand miles per year .

    • @RichO1701e
      @RichO1701e День назад +2

      no such thing as road tax, VED does NOT pay for the roads.

  • @6panel300
    @6panel300 День назад +4

    The only 2 things that make sense to me to do with pricing etc for road motorbikes in London, free congestion charge and bus lane usage on red routes. Everything is aimed to get rid of them it seems. I'll be joining mag next month.

  • @jimsadler8704
    @jimsadler8704 День назад +6

    Considering the decaying roads we have to put up with I think the government should pay us to use them.

    • @RichO1701e
      @RichO1701e День назад +1

      no such thing as road tax, VED does NOT pay for the roads.

    • @veronikaquick6738
      @veronikaquick6738 День назад +1

      @@RichO1701e Doesn`t matter - the comment mentioned decaying roads not tax.

  • @flatcapcaferacer
    @flatcapcaferacer День назад +5

    Logical and fair combined with government decisions shouldn't be used together. The other piece is you can never convince politicians who dislike you and think your vile to be fair and logical. Money would be better spent voting them out.

  • @daza3620
    @daza3620 16 часов назад +2

    Normally I keep my bike taxed all year round, I guess I will star to SORN it for winter moving forwards.

  • @charleshoward1475
    @charleshoward1475 3 часа назад

    Just happened upon your channel. I didn't realize Motorcycle Action Group was still operating. I recall taking part in one of your M.A.G runs in the early 80's A couple of bands and a party followed in Cornwall. It was brilliant and remains in the forefront of my memory. I've taken up two wheel riding again in the last two years. Had to renew my V.E.D Today, and I believe the cost had increased. Like everything else within this age we share, we receive little in return for the multitude of stealth taxation. Precious little on road quality or anything else. Thanks for sharing

  • @Malcolm99-l9q
    @Malcolm99-l9q День назад +5

    Government ved taxes are not fair. Unfortunately Governments have never cared.

  • @pw601
    @pw601 День назад +4

    VED, you can pay in lump sum or by direct debit.
    If you pay by direct debit, what's to stop you making SORN over the months you don't use the bike. For some this will work out cheaper than paying for 6 months.

    • @trevorphillips3055
      @trevorphillips3055 День назад +4

      I refuse to pay by direct debit because it costs more. I have 4 bikes, one, which is taxed during the winter, so it's available for use as required. The others I tax only during spring and summer. Sorn at the end of the month and you get a refund for each full month. I'm not paying more to pay by direct debit,they can swivel 😊.

    • @loonaticsrunningtheassylum
      @loonaticsrunningtheassylum 17 часов назад

      And to hell with those who commute all year round???

    • @trevorphillips3055
      @trevorphillips3055 16 часов назад +1

      @loonaticsrunningtheassylum Lets face it. Bikers are in a minority, particularly those that ride all year and commute. Governments have never cared about us and never will.

  • @irishflyer6377
    @irishflyer6377 11 часов назад

    Thank you for a great video and BTW we already pay per mile through 50% of fuel costs being duty and VAT.

  • @BachsRides
    @BachsRides 15 часов назад +1

    My diesel 2.0 is £30 a year, my 650cc motorcycle is £110. It's yet another tax on working and lower middle class people, like most other taxes. The govt should be encouraging motorcycling, it's far cleaner than car travel and would eliminate congestion if even a small % of drivers switched.

  • @niallsommerville9813
    @niallsommerville9813 День назад

    A sensible discourse on the subject (if anything successive governments can fall into the sensible brackets) that has convinced me to get involved and support MAG. I've sometimes felt that motorcyclists ride around with a big bull's eye on the back of our jackets and a very soft one at that, no offence intended to any scooter riders. Thank you.

  • @stuartjohnston1086
    @stuartjohnston1086 День назад +1

    Quoting the government website "From the second year of registration onwards, zero emission cars will move to the standard annual rate." It is confusing but I read this as, on 1st registration, an EV will pay £10 VED and then the normal rate from year 2, currently £190.

  • @eddiestevenson-kaatsch6306
    @eddiestevenson-kaatsch6306 21 час назад +1

    I think the discrepancy in VED on electric cars is driven by two factors. The first is that keeping EVs on the road longer is a good thing for the environment, so ought to be encouraged. The second is that most EVs in the higher tax range are luxury cars, and cost a lot of money... a bit like a big engined conventional car. Also they're owned by those with higher incomes, better able to be charged a higher amount. More recent EVs are becoming cheaper and in order to continue the uptake, need a bit of extra incentive to get us to take the plunge and increase the proportion of EVs to conventional cars that populate our roads. Not terribly joined-up thinking perhaps, but we are talking about politicians, aren't we!

  • @digger8180
    @digger8180 День назад +7

    Unfortunately this post is why you will not get younger bikers into MAG. I am coming up for 58, riding since I was old enough to do so. MAG whilst I agree with the majority of your campaings, the posts are like watching paint dry!

    • @nigelfisher3756
      @nigelfisher3756 День назад +2

      @Digger8180
      Bit harsh, that. What do you want the presenter to do….roll over, bark, drop his strides and twerk? Some idiotic youngsters might get a kick but surely anyone with an ounce of common sense know the subject (tax) can’t really be sexed up.

  • @j.t.jaeger1595
    @j.t.jaeger1595 День назад +11

    Labour don't want anyone on or in their own private transport and will make it so expensive accordingly.

    • @demonnick666
      @demonnick666 День назад

      It is what the wef wants. They control our government.

    • @trevorphillips3055
      @trevorphillips3055 День назад +2

      And lose all that revenue from fuel duty, vat on fuel, servicing and repair costs, and insurance premium tax? I don't think so.

    • @233kosta
      @233kosta 23 часа назад

      ​@@trevorphillips3055 Elitism overrides other goals. Always. They're "fully committed" to them right up until it's time to screw the poors, yet again.

    • @loonaticsrunningtheassylum
      @loonaticsrunningtheassylum 17 часов назад +3

      Not just labour,.. it's been spelt out in the UN documents. Don't be fooled into thinking theirs a saviour a different colour tie.... There isn't

    • @loonaticsrunningtheassylum
      @loonaticsrunningtheassylum 17 часов назад

      @trevorphillips3055 it's nothing about money.. they print that when they like. There a few un documents that spell it out. Private transport is to go.

  • @LaveryTribe
    @LaveryTribe День назад +2

    Motorcyclists worldwide seem to be in the cross hairs at the moment. Here in New Zealand, the government recently announced that our ACC (Accident Compensation Corporation) levy, which represents a significant portion of motorcycle registration cost, will be increasing by approximately 30% over the next couple of years.😡

  • @shardlake
    @shardlake День назад +5

    My bike now identifies as a VW Golf, they seem to have thrown darts at the wall to choose who pays what... Weight does make the most sense, which means the government will not consider it.

  • @brendanpells912
    @brendanpells912 Минуту назад

    It's 30 years since I last rode a motorcycle (Z200), but £57 sounds a lot. My 2015 diesel car will see it's VED go up from £0 to £20. But the fuel consumption is about the same as I used to get out of my GT185, even though it has 5 x more horsepower.

  • @scottvessey915
    @scottvessey915 18 часов назад +2

    A tenner a month to get my bike on the road? No problem.

    • @splodge57
      @splodge57 5 часов назад +1

      And if you take it off the road for winter and SORN it for 4 months you save £40.😊

  • @percyprune7548
    @percyprune7548 5 часов назад

    MAG member, and glad of it. My 60 m.p.g. car is 1/6th of my 77 m.p.g. bike (Kawasaki W800) VED. Crazy world. At least classics are Zero rated but for how long is anyone's guess.

  • @FlowCharge
    @FlowCharge День назад +3

    It's not fair for any vehicle; along with several motorbikes I have two cars which I drive very rarely (10 times less than the bikes) yet the VED is an order of magnitude higher. It makes no sense _at all_

  • @garymcbrearty5845
    @garymcbrearty5845 День назад

    As much as your arguement makes sense and i agree with them there is 1 thing 99% of all road users don't know, that is the number of non toll roads that are privately owned built & maintained that we use but are billed directly to the government. With this in mind I accept we should pay something to road use & upkeep but ask do any of us get our value for money? ( Yes that is sarcasm) . Those in power have seen fit to ignore bikes & bikers views for 50+ years, the only way VED could change in our favour would be campaign for deductions for 2nd 3rd or 4th vehicle discounts, not that that would help me personally as I'm a dying breed of a 1 vehicle only biker.

  • @bluehazeboy
    @bluehazeboy 13 часов назад

    As it stands at Xmas 2024, I have a ford focus ecoboost 1.0 at £35 a year,I also have a 1997 Suzuki 1200 bandit,that I had to pay£175 to TFL to get it ULEZ compliant & emits less co2 than the focus & I have to pay £117 a year.

  • @splodge57
    @splodge57 День назад +4

    I've been ridng bikes for 52 years and always paid road tax (VED or whatever else you want to call it.) As you showed it is easy and straightforward to find out how much you need to pay related to the size of engine of your bike. My 599cc was £84 now gone up to £87 per year. I find that perfectly acceptable. If I couldn't afford this relatively small cost I would be asking myself if I should be running a motorcycle.

    • @loonaticsrunningtheassylum
      @loonaticsrunningtheassylum 16 часов назад

      When you add all the rest of the times the government steal from us.. NO motorcycle VED is not acceptable when considering the stuff that costs next to nothing (because they happen to own one usually which makes it exempt.. funny that.. how criminals will be criminals) my bike does over 50 to the gallon, weights NOTHING so not damaging the roads, causes NO CONGESTION.. and costs £115+ a year.. that fkn great SUV milk fliats (ego taxi I call them) that only ever carries ONE PERSON weights 2.8 tons destroys the roads and CAUSES congestion costs less usually. Some may be more but generally not much.. the criminal government are crooks. They pretend that they need money to pay for thing THE PUBLIC WANTS/NEEDS. When in reality they're just laundering through be wars, foreign aid and friends and family businesses in my opinion... They need stopping and reminding they're SUPPOSED TO BE public servants.. they're just a criminal gang

    • @percyprune7548
      @percyprune7548 5 часов назад

      It's the principle of a VED rate of £20 for a 60 mpg car but well over £100 for a 77 mpg bike. The immoral pricing. Logically, the bike should be £15 and if govt. can allow £20 for a car then it can afford to take the same or less for a bike.

    • @splodge57
      @splodge57 4 часа назад

      That is to do with emissions not mpg. Most cars pay between £190 and £335. Like I said my bike is £84 for 12 months although I SORN it for 4 months so only pay for 8 months. Something you could not do in the past. After paying VED(😂) for the last 52 years I won't be losing any sleep over it now. I'm surprised MAG aren't still banging on about having to wear a crash helmet.🤣

  • @jimh5031
    @jimh5031 15 часов назад

    Tax related to vehicle weight is the fairest and least ambiguous method so lets push for a change.

  • @alcord2540
    @alcord2540 2 часа назад

    The tax on ice cars registered from 2017 is £100 more than those registered before that.That is probably the reference point for the electric bike changes.As it is i pay more tax for my honda nsc 50 than i do for my hyundai i10 1.25 litre car.Crazy!.

  • @SteveLawrance
    @SteveLawrance День назад +1

    Your proposal makes absolute sense to me, so how do we put pressure on the Government ? Your recent vid on your parliament visit didn’t give much hope…. How do we “up the anti”… ?

  • @nickturnbull4302
    @nickturnbull4302 12 часов назад

    It's quite easy to guess why VED is disproportionately high for motorcycles. Which form of transport has proportionally more accidents. Therefore which section of the motoring public costs the NHS more money? The Government wants zero road casualties. Which section are they taxing out of existence first?

  • @stewy62
    @stewy62 День назад +3

    Taxation gets more complicated every year in order to employ more and more civil servants, got it ?
    I never used to like Steve Baker, the ex Tory MP not the American motorcycle racer from the 1970’s, as he was far too right wing for me. He seemed to do a decent job as Minister of State for Northern Ireland but his stock rose with me when I discovered that he was a motorcyclist and involved in the Motorcycling All Party Parliamentary Group (MAPPG). For whatever good it did or not, it appears that the MAPPG is now defunct suggesting that there isn’t a single motorcyclist in Parliament. So it’s no surprise that the Government doesn’t give two hoots about motorcycles 🇬🇧

  • @theodavies8754
    @theodavies8754 День назад +4

    It's only ever about the money.
    Don't try to make any more sense of it than that.

    • @trevorphillips3055
      @trevorphillips3055 День назад

      I agree, and that's why we have the system we do. Depending on what you drive or ride, the ved is at a level that was dreamt up at the time for that vehicle, it's a mish mash that doesn't make sense.

  • @HPaulAdrian
    @HPaulAdrian 23 часа назад

    I go a level deeper and ask what most of us do not ask: why should a person pay a tax for something he/she OWNS?! We do not pay for our fridge, or our oven, or phone etc. We purchased those things with our winnings, which were already taxed! We payed VAT when we purchased the things. So why paying annually for something we own, it is ours?!

    • @loonaticsrunningtheassylum
      @loonaticsrunningtheassylum 17 часов назад

      Because criminals will be criminals (government) nothing but an extortion racket that the peasants let steal HUGE amounts of money from. And please don't give them any more Ideas about what to steal from us next.

  • @paulshenton6527
    @paulshenton6527 День назад +3

    I pay more ved for my motorcycle than for an EV car or 1 lire car

  • @neilallen7377
    @neilallen7377 14 часов назад

    Will this apply to electric bikes most of which seem to use pedals to assist the motor rather than the other way round

  • @cloudbasenirvana
    @cloudbasenirvana День назад +1

    EV road tax should be far more than ICE or motorbikes they weigh much more and do much more damage to the already unsafe (due to their state of disrepair) British roads

  • @DavidChaffe
    @DavidChaffe День назад

    Why are i am not getting OPEN ROAD mag a full member

  • @alandavies1725
    @alandavies1725 9 часов назад

    My new CanAm Spyder trike is classed as a Private Light Goods vehicle at £335 per year. Ouch!

  • @DavidChaffe
    @DavidChaffe День назад +4

    When i started riding the road tax for 750cc was £20

    • @RichO1701e
      @RichO1701e День назад

      Unless you started riding in the 1930s, no you didn't. "road tax" is a BS myth spread by ignorant morons.

  • @DJKav
    @DJKav 12 часов назад

    It's probably more to do with the amount of sales, more cars, and fewer bikes. So VED those few bikes more than the majority of cars.
    Maybe also the reason as to why the higher VED on 2017+ EVs, as that seems to be when more of them started selling. More of those on the road, more tax to be raised.

  • @pajownik
    @pajownik 14 часов назад

    The real issue is taxes in general. Whatever we want to buy, with our money, that was already taxed. We pay another tax, even though the person selling it to us paid tax too. After you die, your child will pay tax for inheriting things that were already taxed on multiple levels. If they are allowed to rob the whole population, do you think they will give a break to motorcyclists?

  • @mandrakejake
    @mandrakejake 9 часов назад

    The only fair change I see is to abolish VED. Fuel taxation is self regulating, as the more you need the more tax you pay. Why is a diesel fiesta less to tax than a 125cc motorcycle? There's no logic.

  • @Jones-xx2gc
    @Jones-xx2gc 10 часов назад

    I have a little Skyteam Monkey 125 that I use occasionally with my motorhome. I shouldn't do, but I really begrudge paying £ 20 when my wifes diesel car is £ 30.

  • @peterjarmesty1884
    @peterjarmesty1884 День назад

    The old system was fairer by taking into account weight and capacity!

  • @mojouk8935
    @mojouk8935 День назад

    I just bought a triumph 765 RS 2024 it does around 52mpg, how much is that going to cost me?
    Euro 5 188kg weight, should be cheaper should it not? and newer emissons reductions bloody thing cost me £11,650!!!

  • @tonymann8215
    @tonymann8215 3 часа назад

    Just had a tax reminder for my bike and car, euro4 Citroen C1, £20. Euro 5 Honda SH125, £25. ???

  • @TheAndropoff
    @TheAndropoff 9 часов назад

    VED should be by weight classification

  • @LindaGray-o7j
    @LindaGray-o7j 18 часов назад

    My son drives a VW Scirocco 2.0 tdi £30 yearly tax. I drive a VX Corsa 1.2 petrol £198 yearly tax.

  • @B2C2007
    @B2C2007 10 часов назад

    That's it? A weight based VED scheme? How convenient that motorcycles don't have to confront the intransigence of our bike's emissions. We're still on EURO5 that cars were on ten years ago and we won't move to 6 until the end of the decade (if they attempt harmonisation with passenger car Euro7 then it will make getting Hayabusas through EURO5 look like a picnic).

  • @rob6255-j4t
    @rob6255-j4t 17 часов назад

    This is the UK, nothing is fair , its
    simply a battle between government
    and citizens, why is it so difficult
    all the time . ?? R

  • @markbentley1544
    @markbentley1544 23 часа назад

    To be honest, you make too much sense. This is why nothing will change, and the government only wants our cash. Wait for them to add the luxury tax VED on motorcycles above £xxxx. sad times. Good to see our roads are improving with all this tax.

  • @garyhart6421
    @garyhart6421 8 часов назад

    VED is unfair Full Stop !
    Especially as it is not spent on the Roads.

  • @RichO1701e
    @RichO1701e День назад +2

    7:08 - why feed the BS myth about VED paying for the roads, aka, "road tax"?

    • @splodge57
      @splodge57 День назад

      It doesn't pay for the roads but it is a tax you pay to have a vehicle on the road. Hence it is called 'vehicle tax' on the government website and why many still call it 'road tax.'

  • @sgsuper1150
    @sgsuper1150 День назад

    I have an electric scooter. No point in a 50 mile range if i pay the same tax as a 125 with 200 mile range

  • @johnrocker2986
    @johnrocker2986 День назад

    Perfect it creates debate at all vehicle levels but it's simple for years all Governments have squandered tax payers money on various failed institutions and the UK in theory is insolvent so what ever you campaign around will fail, the UK's debt has to be cleared or there will be no tomorrow.

  • @turboslag
    @turboslag День назад

    Part of the reason for 2 wheel ved could be that the net tax income for the government is much higher on cars than bikes. That is, there are substantially more cars sold than bikes, so the government rakes in far more tax on sales of cars, the fuel they use, insurance, etc, than bikes. That doesn't explain the strange anomalies with EVs mentioned here though, given the governments mental obsession with net zero it would seem logical to incentivise people to buy EVs as much as possible. But as I predicted many years ago, if EVs ever become the majority, the loss of fuel duty and vat revenue caused would be unsustainable, so another tax would be needed, which is probably where road use pricing will come in. The government hasn't fully thought the loss of ice powdered vehicles through though. EVs will never engender the passion the enthusiast has for cars, bikes etc, with a proper engine. So, along with the loss of the vehicles themselves, will be the massive aftermarket for accessories, modification, tuning, customisation, diy maintenance, servicing, press, used market, etc, etc. EVs are nothing more than transport appliances, there will never be a collectors market or anything to do with improvement of them. So once they are 3-5 years old, they'll be scrapped, no one will want an old EV. Just like a old fridge, tv or washing machine, at end of useful life, off to the tip or recycler, not a single tear shed. And the loss to the economy will be huge. Not like now, where old bikes and cars are still being used and generating tax revenue in parts, upgrading, and restoration after as much as 120 years!!!

  • @goldilocks913
    @goldilocks913 День назад +3

    Errr… no

    • @williamhuxley
      @williamhuxley День назад +5

      Seems ludicrous that a bloody great EV SUV pays 'nothing' in proportion to its weight and carbon footprint making it, plus the amount of space it takes up, and the fact that there's only one occupant most of the time. They should be paying us motorcyclists!

  • @40mosher
    @40mosher 13 часов назад

    Why are electric vehicles paying less than ice? Electrics are usually heavier and to more damage. Ved is an eco tax!

  • @233kosta
    @233kosta 23 часа назад

    Battery electrics are little more than a greenwash. A poorly executed one at that.
    The battery part ensures they're no better environmentally over their (comparatively short) lifecycle than an old petrol car (especially one converted to run on something cleaner).
    Economically they don't make sense either. That DSR you mentioned is £17k new. That money buys you A LOT of bike if you don't insist on an electric motor, especially on the second hand market. If you spend it wisely, you'll have enough left over for many many years of fuel and tax too.
    This is a load of bollocks. They're not even attempting to hide their intentions any more.

    • @Flipflop324
      @Flipflop324 15 часов назад

      You are spouting Daily Mail BS. EVs have far far lower overall emissions over their lifetime. All the evidence is pointing to batteries out lasting cars. There are lots of EVs with 200,000 miles plus on the clock. My EV costs about 2p a mile to run. When i fill up my bike for £25 after a day out, that money would run my EV for a month.

  • @DavidChaffe
    @DavidChaffe День назад

    Should be free tax for motorcycles .The roads are a danger for motorcycles no council willing to repair the roads to british standard.Yes i am a member of mag but dont get the open road mag??????Why

  • @bwoo6223
    @bwoo6223 22 часа назад

    So my EV motorcycle will pay more than my car?

  • @peterrear2864
    @peterrear2864 16 часов назад

    It never has been or will be fair,life isnt fair

  • @weymouthjohn
    @weymouthjohn 13 часов назад

    But if VED was based on vehicle weight, EVs would come out badly which, again, isn't logical....unless I've missed something in your argument

  • @andyking6051
    @andyking6051 11 часов назад

    I bought an old bike so dont have to pay ved mot or ulez .

  • @MrChriss000
    @MrChriss000 День назад +1

    The gov. dont like bikes cos (most) dont drink petrol like cars, and petrol is ~ 50% TAX.
    It is currently 53p / litre tax on top of the petrol actual price then 20% vat on top of that total..
    Now coin sider how much time you save not stuck in jams and looking for parking the expenditure difference starts to mount up.
    Then there are the parking charges local gov's rely on. And congestion fees.. and enforcement cameras for this, that and the other.
    Basically the car motorist is the highest persecuted tax provider in the country and they dont like people avoiding that.
    Most people do not realise how bad the tax situation is in this country, they just keep voting for the same old CR4P.

  • @Michael-oc5zw
    @Michael-oc5zw 17 часов назад

    The chances of that are non existent, hell will freeze over first. All motorists are just an easy cash cow.

  • @davecarrera
    @davecarrera День назад +1

    I have heard that your doctor has powders for VED. Don't be shy 🙂

  • @keithrepton2937
    @keithrepton2937 13 часов назад

    Sorry can't reply on a postcard can't afford the stamp's.

  • @oojimmyflip
    @oojimmyflip 5 часов назад

    My Sons 2013 1.5 diesel euro 5 Dacia Sandero Car is zero Ved, none of this makes any sense at all. I have a 2019 1.5 Addblue diesel Citroen which is £165.00 ved the cars are the same weight and the Citroen has lower emissions output by 10 grams per kilometer, go figure.

  • @Polecat54941
    @Polecat54941 16 часов назад

    Electric cars are bigger and weigh more, not to mention the the devastation caused by their manufacture to the landscape in lithium mining areas.

  • @Fazerjon
    @Fazerjon 13 часов назад

    Who wants to ride a ticking time bomb in the form of these electric motorbikes? If you've ever seen these things catch & the trouble it takes to put them out you'll agree it's not safe - I'll never feel comfortable about these things

  • @davdave3470
    @davdave3470 13 часов назад

    Who cares? Haven't taxed my Yamaha for twenty years.

  • @stephensalt6787
    @stephensalt6787 14 часов назад

    This is easy to explain,as a motorcyclist you are classed as a potential subversive, a potential rebel of some sort. Plus the plethora of facial recognition cameras to follow and track our travels don’t work very well with full face helmets or bandannas over the face. Big brother wats to know everything.

  • @1973retrorabbit
    @1973retrorabbit День назад +1

    Your idea does sound good to me, but I'm not an EValgilist, EV cars are stupidly heavy and they'll all find themselves in with Land Rovers and other large SUV/ pick-up type vehicles... Amusingly, a lot of sports cars would drop to a lower bracket... 🤔

    • @EbenBransome
      @EbenBransome День назад

      My EV weights half as much as a Land Rover. I suspect I'd be paying just the same as anybody else with a 4 seater car with an 8 second 0-100kph.
      People seem not to realise all cars are getting heavier due to more stringent NCAP. In fact bikes are getting stupid heavy which puts me off these days.

  • @sholdfield
    @sholdfield 17 часов назад

    Could it be that motorists are voting with their feet and refusing to buy new evs, which buggers up their net zero target. Enter the new ev ved bribe…