"The West has lost the art of sharing power," says Kishore Mahbubani
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 май 2024
- Academic and former diplomat Kishore Mahbubani is the author of the provocative book “Has the West Lost It?”. The answer, he says, "is no or not yet. But I fear the West is about to lose it." Find out what the Asian century and the rise of China mean for Switzerland-and the world.
I'm 72-years old, and I have NEVER remembered a time when the US has ever enjoyed "sharing power."
That means you are too young ，sir. keep healthy and live long enough to witness this historical senario.
watercutter lan 😄 you are so full of wits .. we all need optimistic people with sense of humour like you who live in and accept Reality.
Joke: america is a friend who doesn’t bully others lol
watercutter lan if “sharing” means invading china and taking its lands then sure
America is a generous nation. She has helped former enemies Germany and and Japan to succeed after WW2. Last 20 years, she had helped China to be so successful as she is today.. that already speaks volumes about America.
I grown up in 80's in a small town in China, called ZhongGuan Village, when China was poor (it is still poor in my opinion because I have high expectation for my country). I did admire American and European life style and richness when I was a kid, and I acknowledge that the US is the most powerful dominant country in the world. I am totally fine and indifferent letting the US or any country be the No. 1.
But the point is, I never feel shameful or bothered about "we are poor now or we are no longer No.1". I never thought about this No.1 issue. I know a little about Chinese history, and I know our goal and our historical position in this world. The history of our civilization and culture give me confidence and a peace of mind. I will just do my part of work, be a decent civilized individual, as best as a Chinese can do, then our nation will be what it supposed to be, I don't care who is the No. 1, and everyone in this world deserve a better life, that's for sure.
Kishore is a gentleman who says things logically but very tenderly and try not to offend. But I will retranslate.
Because the West fails to confront the fact that just because you are born white, you do not earn the right of superiority. If the West fails to confront the superiority mentality, they will see the rise of China as a Yellow Peril of 12 Century. The worst mental block comes from the Angelo Saxon nations. If the mental block continues, it will lead to war. Kishore and other like minded scholars such as Martin Jacques are trying their best to avert the catastrophic event by talking to the wall.
Yes that’s what we call a bullshit artist in the west. Or a used car salesman. Or a horse trader
Yep
I have seen various aspects of the very old chinese cultures and intellectual systems. Would it not be a useful thought that there is a form of Chinese pluralism all of which happens "under the heaven" and is utterly complex, and that further thoughtful increase of such pluralism would create a buffer zone, where the adverse western minds can cool down and walk millions of miles, exhausting their crave of superiority?
The Western mind is curious and nosy. If it becomes interested enough, it will walk a million exciting paths. To create this effect, soft power is required.
But the powers of supremacy cannot be other than centrist. They will have to enforce their centrism on their own minds, that became aware of an exciting, diverse and multipolar world.
This will become a very interesting contradiction.
@@neovxr Thoughts on utopia is interesting. However the world is not flat from the Western point of view. Freedom Democracy and Equality are all sugar coatings to the human weakness. The jaundice view that the West sees is racial stratified world. Racial purification is the underlying philosophy for the Nazis and still in the DNA of the West. G7 AUKUS and the Five Eye Nations are all about the color of White.
@@estchu You are right, it exists, but a remarkable number of "white" people do not want it, or never wanted that, and they do not believe that they are "owned" by their race or nation and by their elites as if they were cattle.
Many leaders and journalists are riding on the vehicle of race (today more in the culturalist way), but at the same time hide behind idealist preachings.
One of the contradictions the West is crashing into, exists right within the "judeo-christian" paradigm, that had been used also as a colonial tool box, including domestic colonization of their own. But with what is happening in Ukraine, I am expecting a major falling-out. Remember history, it was among allegedly white ethnicities.
i am supporting a multipolar world. I want to reveal that the "West-Supremacy" full with hypocritic preachings of equality and rule based order, is on its way to fall back into White Supremacy. This insight is important and has aspects that are not trivial. It helps to deconstruct the official rationale. It is not even understood by most Westerners.
For thousand of years China and India have been sharing power and never had major conflicts
Now USA trying to creat conflict between both to gain own interest
Kishore is too nice: the West never had the art of sharing power.
@Akin Khoo: He does speak like a diplomat..easy to take.
He is a useless good for nothing.
@@timstim487 I kinda agree with u actually...
Because when you are a boss, you don't listen to employees hahahahaha
Agreed. History never shows the West willing to share power.
He is too polite
Does not matter if you adjust or not, reality is going to hit you hard.
Goose From Top Gun 😄😄 why are you so pessimistic about China? I can sense this is all cos of your hatred , without any logical reason . Please try to understand no achievement can be succeeded without being diligent. Let’s face it and be Real. Please don’t push anyone innocent away and outcast them especially these are the people who always receive you and others with open arms. The problem looks like it’s not that you are not Ready yet , it’s all becos deep down inside you, there lies your Pride and Dignity that tell you how to be compulsive therefore you “don’t want to be Ready”. Be Kind to One Another, quote by Ellen DeGeneres.
@@jackiechan7336 How has China been prospered and survived for the last 5000 years? It has always commerce which was and always based on Capitalism. The US and the Europeans never invented capitalism. The West or the US set up THE UN, WTO, WHO, IMG and other international institutions after WWII.
@@bojoondong5212 pl
respect to my Indian friends 🇨🇳🇮🇳
@More On Charvaka Agreed bro!
go china from india
Kishore is a Singaporean of Indian ethnicity
@Sheila Feng exactly this is what I keep telling my Indian friends
Hi is not Indian !
"The West has lost the art of sharing power,"
You can't 'lose' something you never had.
we have been sharing power with our allies from our beginning
@@1aikane4u ya, with suspicion and condition. and if they shared power they will make sure of it that it's 300% times of it's original cost.
When you take a realistic look at the enslaved world, the US has sacrificed so much blood and treasure to ensure freedom throughout the world.
We don’t have any colonies, we don’t have a caste system, we don’t, as China does, kill millions of its own citizens who think outside of the box. This globalist praises Switzerland as being this wonderful, peaceful, country that gets along with everyone, especially Nazi Germany.
He talks about sharing power? How about sharing responsibility.
Why does China and Russia, and to some degree, India play ball with these terrible dictators and human rights abusers.
He sounds like a racists.
The only times these socio/communists step up to the plate is when they are pressured to do the right thing
@@1aikane4uUS no colonies? Puerto Rico? Guam? Philippine? No caste system? Black saggreation of the 50s and 60s? China kill millions of her people you say well what about US nearly wiping out the red skins from the face of the earth?
Eu much?
Interesting points. Aside from the comparison of JFK versus Beijing airports as a sign of modern development, it also shows in their infrastructures, China has high speed trains throughout its country while USA is running their outdated slow trains. No matter what is said, China has helped African countries develop their infrastructures as well. We all know that there is a price to be paid for it, but that’s always been.
Of course US infrastructure has aged, we modernized pretty early. Also, if you think China is doing some altruistic stance by giving money to Africa, you haven't heard what's happening in at least Sri Lanka in particular. China is a huge bully just like the US, the difference is China acts as one under one person, the US gets fought on by it's own people by it's actions. One of those two nations have regret for their past for bad mistakes, while the other touts legends that they are the chosen ones.
Two very fundamental teachings of Confucius:
All race have the right to education
Only the wise rule
Dynasties of Ancient China followed these well,they lasted for centuries
And what percentage of the population of China could read during the life of confucius?
@@ronnieo9571 I know you can';t read Chinese, so go back and eat shit on street.
Ronnie O, in 500BC in European countries if there were any, way before Roman empire, there were schools in the Zhou dynasty, although they only small population that is getting education, but it was a start.
Ronnie O made a very good point, less than 1/10 of Chinese population can read during that time and stayed the same until 19th century. Western Europe moved ahead mostly due to getting more of its population educated, of course colonialism helps a lot.
Confucianism is also a state philosophy propagated by monarchs to control the populace. During the warring state periods, authoritarianism was systemic and largely down to the highly authoritarian past of the Zhou and Shang dynasties.
One beget another as leaders copied each other's meticulous methods of complete control.
Chinese warlords and kings have always been power hungry and never wanted to share power. This is fact from history. The only forward thinking Chinese is Sun Yat Sen. That's it.
The rest of you are just communist Marxist loving bastards. Which is of course a German's ideal, not really a Chinese one at all.
Leftist, freedom hating, Stockholm syndrome robots that hate religion and diversity. Marxism itself wants control and control over the family and the mind of men. You can shove that poisonous garbage back I your own country because it's not convincing the intellectuals in the west.
This guy should not be a diplomat, he should be a president.
Jingjing Zhao he was! The president of a top level university in Asia
*He was also the president of the UN security council (the most powerful council in the world) for two years.*
Not when they have Lee Kuan Yew as prime minister
He should be the Secretary General of UN
Let trumpet destroys the US but not the world, lol. Too arrogant
First of all, Thank you Mr.Kishore Mahbubani for your very intelligence acknowledgment.
We Indian's endorse his message time for Dragons and Tigers and Bears.
Today’s joke: america is a friend who doesn’t bully others lol
USA is nothing but a warmonger
You are probably at an American college, sharing our knowledge.
Don’t be so arrogant
He deserves to be a former diplomat in understanding each country's background correctly.
The interviewer is crappy..she keeps interrupting him. She is showing her western arrogance as what's discussed.she proves his point.
She did a great job.
@泫蓊余 this Indian is a Singaporean and a close associate of Lee Kuan Yew.
As a Singaporean, he lives among Chinese which makes up 90% of Singapore's population.
By the way, Deng Xiaoping and every Premier after him seeked advice from Lee Kuan Yew and Singapore on how to develop China since the 70s.
Singapore even allowed over 100k Chinese govt servants into Singapore to learn from them on how the build a successful and prosperous nation it has become today.
This INDIAN was part of Lee Kuan Yews close circle of distinguished politicians. He probably knows more about China & Chinese culture than you may ever know, even thought you are a Chinese.
Almost all his prediction's about China as written his books published since the 90s have came true.
its like thsi guy said 30 seconds about thats why A is A, then this interviewer interupts him, comes with "So that's about B, now lets move on to the topic of C.
LOL
Actually this is a type journalism where YOU take the a lead
@@mkkm8540 nobody is questioning her job of leading the interview, but at least let him finish his sentence first.
European discovered the world and turned all into colonies or semicolonies.
The discovered Australia, north America and turned them into Australia Commonwealth, USA and Canada respectively.
The great Chinese explorer Zhang He 50 yrs in 1500 AD before Christopher Columbus discovered America had sailed to the Southeast coast of Africa and returned home 7 times. His 200+ large ships feet had 20,000 crews. The largest ship's width was longer than the length of Columbus' 3-ship fleet Santa Maria which was the fastest.
Ming Dynasty had both the technology and wealth to colonize but always returned home.
That's is why the professor said the influence of China will gentle.
Mr kishore's books will sell very well in China!!! By giving a positive outlook on the rise of peaceful China in this interview!
Are you out of your brainwashed mind? China is a totalitsrianism communist regime. Your life is not your own. You are simply a piece of the government
Yes, Kishore is absolutely right that the world should prepare China and India to respect multilateral institutions like WTO, UN, IMF and etc..
Hope that China and India will not copy US's unilateral sanctions style to force another nation to comply.
What does that even mean? THe world should prepare China and India? China and India do what they wish. As for all of this bullshit here, its 99 percent Chinese trying to weaken Indian resolve to protect their territorial integrity, and the shipping in and around Indian waters.
@Akin Khoo I am sure India will continue to deal appropriately with China.
They will not be able to apply unilateral sanctions because there will be other 2 powers to stop them, I think Europe will become a country very soon as well.
@@ronnieo9571 , you need update, my friend. India is now more align to China than to US. Soon, both of them will be 100% best friend.
Western powers have to stop denying that China and India will be the top 2 economic powers in the world. But if you choose to continue dreaming, Asians will not stop you.
This century will mark the end of western powers world domination. It has been a good 200 years that create a better world and i am thankful for it. It's inevitable that China and India will continue the world domination and hopefully they are able to serve the world better than western powers.
Is this an attempt at Chinese soft power? You have a long way to go. I am sure India trusts you and looks forward to continued friendship. Kishore is reminiscent of someone we are all very familiar with who Churchill replaced. I am sure the rest of India isn't buying it.
Professor Muhbubani. You make so much sense:)
How can you lose what you never had?
Kishore Mahbubani analysis has proven correct! Asia led by China & India is returning to be the center of the world politically, economically, militarily, culturally & morally, that's a fact! Due to demographic & economic trends, it's coming and everybody knows it! ASIA RULES! ASIAN GLOBAL DOMINATION!
Wrong, and a bit silly to discuss China and India together as if they are some sort of allied block. Nothing is further from the truth. As far as Indian Military power, its biggest fear is Chinese military power. This will prove interesting as the Chinese Navy begins to roam.
@@ronnieo9571 : Do you have the authority to speak for the Indian Hindus ? You should identify your self first instead of talking more nonsense and bullshit.
China and India together? Not in this lifetime.
@@ronnieo9571 : You do not know about Chinese and Indian thinking so keep out of it. You must be a dark brown Filippino enslaved by the White Colonists for centuries.
@@gordonsek You are strangely obsessed by skin color.
A TRUE diplomat indeed!!! Too extreme views would choke off his bread & butter lines.....
The WEST never had any intentions to Share anything!!!
America will do what ever it takes as long as its in their VESTED INTEREST...... Kissinger 1970 !!!!
The world should be able to distinguish between MORE evil and the LESS evil.
Everything he said is right
Kishore is right when he says that both China and India were leading economies of the world till 18th century but due to colonisation they missed out on Industrial revolution. Now IT / communication revolution is taking place and both these countries are leading in this. Hence future is Asian.
It isn't because of colonization that we missed industrialisation but due to intense internal conflicts that got worse with external conflicts
AMAZING 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
THIS VIDEO IS SPOT ON.. TO THINK THIS WAS 3 YEARS AGO.. LOOK NOW 2022 HE WAS COMPLETELY CORRECT
Kishore Mahbubani was very prominent in his analysis. He has long ago predicted that China will rise to become the world number 1.
He's a communist boot licker. He hate people having freedom, wealth. He talks for IMF GEORGE Soros, scumbags in general.
Hates democracy, hates free elections, wants one party authoritarian dictators, net censorship. He is anti wealth and strong rich families. Only wants to prop up the oligarchical elite rich that reap much profit off the slave labor of Chinese workers.
Prominent? He's an insider who knows that the elites in America made a deal with Deng many decades ago that they will ship American manufacturing to China.
Sorry but all that ends now under Trump. So keep lamenting to share power, but NO WAY is America going to share any more IP and new tech to China under Trump and for the next 50 years.
You made your money, now piss off and try to develop your own. Don't talk garbage when you want a level playing field when you've been conspiring to steal IP and tech.
This woman has poor listening skills and cuts off this diplomat while he is speaking!!! Ugh. Let the man talk! I want to hear HIM speak.
Good insights
Hi Prof.Kishore Mahbubani🤩😎😍👨🎓
🍀🍀🍀🌹🌹🌹🌻🌻🌻
If you want to see a 3rd world airport you go to US’s JFK airport, if you want to see a 1st world airport, you go to Shanghai and Beijing’s. 😂😂😂
J-Mobi if you want to go to airport that doesn’t feel like an airport, go to Singapore where mahbubani is from.
this interviewer is freaking unbelievable, its like thsi guy said 30 seconds about thats why A is A, then this interviewer comes like So that's about B, now lets move on to the topic of C.
LOL
Interesting
great questions were asked.
I admire Switzerland. They managed to remain neutral and stay out of conflicts so that their people can enjoy peace and prosperity.
Switzerland the banker of looters and criminals of the African continent.
Not so lately. It took side in the current Ukraine Russia conflict.
250yo USA v 5,000yo China. No fight.
That has nothing to do with anything. Its a childlike remark. Winning is determined by a combination of hardpower and softpower. Neither of which does China currently have the upper hand, nor is it a guarantee they have it in the future. But keep talking about age. China was reborn the day they put Mao into power. Year one.
@@ronnieo9571 , if you study the rise and fall of great nations for the past 500 years starting from Portugal, it's sad to learn that whatever Kishore said make sense. Multilateral is the way to go in order to curb China and India power when they become number one and two.
US has to adjust and lead by example now to make multilateral works.
@@ahguchong8225 The United States does not have any need to attempt to curb Indian power. Why would the USA even attempt such a thing? India is not a threat to the United States or to U.S. Interests. It is obvious to anyone what threats India faces.
@@ronnieo9571 , we shall see, my friend. US is not used to share power with others for a century already. When China and India GDP exceeds US twice over, it's going to be hard for US to swallow. China and India will be calling the shots, not US. So, while they are still poor, it's better to set up a system where every nation respect multi lateral decision.
@@ahguchong8225 First of all you do not no squat about history. The United States was not barely even a World Power until World War I, and remained isolationist again, until attacked by Imperial Japan, and having Germany declare war on us at the same time. It is not the fault of the USA that we were the sole remaining superpower at the End of World War II, nor is it the fault of the USA the rise of totalitarian communism led by madmen such as your own Chairman Mao. The future is quite clear, and its happening right now, China will now have to deal with having far flung interests. Let see how you can handle it. Its new for the Chinese. Now stop wasting my time.
Westerners should really ask themselves why their own revered Plato and Socrates was so critical of democracy. They were the foremost philosophers of the very state that created Western Democracy, and yet they were so critical of it. Why?
Story, and wishes
Why not west will lost Because thy are Robing around Small and poor country Name of Democracy
Right bro
The Sri Lankan port wasn't a mistake at all. It's perfectly placed on the route between Africa and China. The Sri Lankans may not know it yet, but because of their location, they are going to be rich.
They are going to be prosperous under the Chinese rule.
There were claims the chinese helped to stop the sri lankan civil war - profit 1. Selling a lease of the port is for a certain amount of money, even if to cover a loan - profit 2. Sri lanka would likely to get to tax all commerce that occurs through the port - profit 3. Once the port is turned into a big business for trading between 1.5 billion chinese and 1.3 billion africans, sri lanka can take back the port after the lease expires - profit 4. The sri lankans will be so rich, and people won't under stand how they did it. I suspect the sri lankans themselves were let in on the secret.
Totally agreed. The Sri Lankans need to be more patient. They should wait & see that this port will eventually be the fueling/rest docks for the cargo ships between Africa, the Middle East & China. By 2030, it will probably gain 10%+ of its current traffic. By 2050, it may have 30%+ of the world's sea cargoes passing through. They will be very wealthy for such a small population.
That Sri Lanka Port will become the new Hong Kong of South Asia.
Rolls Royce was no.1 but now own by BMW. Things change with time. 😁
Doesn’t Volkswagon own BMW
Well said
Kishore Mahbunani is the best and Gordon Chang is the worst, if you know who Gordon Chang is. Gordon Chang made 99% wrongs in his prediction of China.
Arrogance doesn't make things no.1.The Chinese has a old saying.flower naturally smells good.😉
Professor Mahbubani has a very clear views and better understanding of the foreign policies better than some scholars in the west.
I have missed you on CGTV
To put things into perspective, US history since their independent is still shorter than the reign of the last dynasty of China.
Yeah, that is why Japan ripped through China's Asshole like no tomorrow killing thousands upon thousands of Chinese. Japan pounded that ass so hard, China is still upset about it. lol
@@comeseeyouinadifferentway7640 so has that prevented China from becoming what it is now? Japan can't even attack small north Korea let alone China. The Europeans are running to join China and Japan too. If Japan attack China now, what happened in Hiroshima will be a child's play.
@@alhassangangu4357 China is very weak militarily. China might have such a long history with all these dynasties, but the US is the only country in the world that has outpaced and out grew any other country in the world in such a short period of time. Many countries agree that what the US did is very unique. Just because China has a long sh*tty history, doesn't mean it is anything special.
@@comeseeyouinadifferentway7640 If China is weak militarily, Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan are even too weak and yet we pulled out from Vietnam where over 50,000 service man died for nothing. We are still in Afghanistan and Iraq. When are we pulling out? Let me know please since you seem to know more about US military industrial complex.
@@alhassangangu4357 Don't shift the argument away from China, focus on China. China has almost no military experience whatsoever, lots of people in the army are university students who will go in and out. Calling China a strong nation is a joke, speaking militarily.
What exactly is your point about the rest? That the US is still involved in certain areas fighting for years? Again, is the US fighting a war against the country or against terrorist groups within the country? Please clarify.
You are starting to shift the argument away from China for another argument you are creating.
No need buy your book, just download for free!
Are you serious? Please provide a link for the download. I only want to read the most important chapters. It will save me a trip to the public library to borrow it.
LOL you are funny
Friends are always better than enemies. 😉
I do remember when everyone said about Japan and Japan the next BLAH BLAH BLAH.
The truth is that there are so many issues in India for example. There are still so many anti India inside India elite. And remember one things, countries become what their elites want to.
Let's see
"China will shake the world gently " 😂😂😂
Very gently and Virusly
Very talented intellectual 😂😄
And your point?
For a hot girl she ask some good questions.
Debt trap may be real. Remember the Philipines's huge debt to the U.S. under President Marcos?...and its people been paying for it for a long time. The truth is it will take maybe even a century for a poor country to rid of debt.
KISHORE MAHBUBANI , YOU ARE SO WISE MINDED .
Make it clear, Europe was once conquered by Mongolian, not Chinese, and even earlier by the Turks. China was attacked and ruled by Turks and Mongolian as well, but pacified and mingled by Chinese civilization, not militarily.
So Chinese is no menace to world peace historically or even now. Rather it is a stabilizing stone to world peace and progress.
So far, battles fought by Chinese in the past 80 years were with the US only. Whereas the wars in the past 100 years found the involvement of the US.
Who is the devil, you judge!
Only small regions of Europe specialy in black sea area make you lesson
Funny. When were we conquered by Turkey？
What nonsense. The US was an ally with China against Japan during ww2, the largest ever war China fought in her existence.
The Americans put Mao in power after they decided not to support Generalissimo Chiang in the Chinese civil war after the Sino Japanese war.
The rest are just proxy wars during the Cold War.
I can see a lot of BS being spewed around
Lol and China was conquered by the Mongols only. No Turkic nation ever controlled China unless you consider all steppe people Turkic.
S水澹澹兮生烟 他說的是五胡亂華那時期吧，不過五胡打到最後都被漢人漢文化同化了... 還是個錘子的突厥人
yellow peril is real...i am chinese and have been practicing as a medical doctor in Australia , and I do sometimes discuss politics with my close white patients and surprisingly most of them think 1 day the chinese will come all the way into the south pacific to attack Australia.
It is like the man who cheated on his wife is always in fear of being cheated.lol....
That says much about the level of intelligence or lack thereof, of their thinking capacity.
18:48 - i dont like the reporter bluntly saying the China trigger debt trap in Africa, she is clearly just like how the Western media have the mindset that China have motive behind.
Kishore responded that "we have to get the data before make judgement"... is an example showing how neutral and rational he is about anything said on Western media toward China.
Just love The^Truth and He will set you free.
How I wish, He was my professor! Such a brilliant author, I can listen to him whole day.
".....since 1979, China haven't shot a bullet across it's border whereas USA has dropped 26,000 bombs on 7 countries....." made my day☺️.
Annexation of Tibet, Invasion of India by china, Massacre of tiananmen square we should all forget it right.
@@turbulantarchitect5286 every nation have its own internal crisis. Have you missed the words "across the border" & 1979?
@@lastsamurai7697 tibet was not internal crisis. It was a country. RIP Tibet! And India is "across the border". India is better model as it has not invaded any other country unlike any other country. People go missing in china, their government takes people and vanish them. For God sakes, how can people live in such dangerous country where government performs crimes.
@@turbulantarchitect5286 if Tibet was not internal crisis, how about Nagaland? Kashmir? The so called Naxalites? Asom? Punjab?.... Are they terrorist or freedom fighters to India according to you?
@@lastsamurai7697 right list all the states of India... 1 million Muslims detained in china... That's cool.. Someday they will detain you and you will know the monester... Good luck... My country doesn't need your judgements... We have tried un-united India... We were colonized after that. No one will break union of India. Pakistan was Indian territory but we donated it to the invaders of India for peace. China's original territory was only in the east china, tibet was annexed and it was sad. Such country should not given any role in world affairs let alone become a superpower.
LOL notice something try playback to 24:47 somebody stomach is growling.
up you go, spread the love
Very intelligent man!
Thanks for a very interesting video and so many thoughtful words!
Can we assume that we can fry eggs on the heads of the corrupt US egoistic political gangsters after confronting them with this cool and calm Mr Mahbubani?
terrible host, she keeps cutting kishore's reply and then skips to the next questions.
Yep.
if the future is Unity, you could have focused on the speech, rather than the host. I personally like her questions and we have plenty of proper dislikes on almost anything..........
@@experiencescotlanddifferen4910 Her questions are good no doubt, but it does no good when replies are cut short by her. Makes you wonder when even bother asking in the first place. After all, the speech is a result of the interview, hampered and limited by her.
I was about to say the same too
那个女记者直白是个冥顽不靈的西方人！
讓你親口承認你的國家衰敗 你能接受麼 百年的大清有承認過自己已經不是天朝上國了嗎 所以我到是不意外
历史是有惯性的。改变总是不容易。
我认为她很聪明，只是为了节省宝贵的访问时间而带一下节奏而已，她的问题都非常到位，而且可能有过到中国学习生活的经历，好像非常了解今天的中国。
Power can never be shared it would defeat the reason for acquiring power in the first place.
Highly relevant even up till now. We can see proxies even now in Taiwan and Ukraine.
Plastic Surgery?
Such a genius person with a clueless interviewer.. He might be very biredinterviewer.. He might be very bired
Has the West ever own the art of sharing power to begin with?
Comedy TV.
Love this guy.
He IS true in this aspect... the west loves to dominate, cheap tea... cheap goods... but the east really needs to take care of its own people more, Asia's obsession with white privilege is shameful.
However with ccp running china, Asia is stuck... now even china bank isn't able to pay its depositors and is demanding they return to unlock their cards... Asia needs to care for their own, not just the few entitled brats
next 20 years nobody know what is usa , is it a kind of fried chicken or a name of new model of bicycle
you will live to eat your words. Communism versus freedom? nobody trusts the chinese, except the brainwashed chinese.
the West has never lost it. since it has nvr shared.
America has lost perspectives 40million living in poverty.. the top %1have over 80% of the wealth we are going down we make nothing here anymore.. third world country coming soon rich an poor .. can’t run a economy that’s completely broken an unfair
US Military has the biggest budget in the world, 3 times more than that of China’s. USA is the biggest war mongor. USA started close to 30 wars against small and weak countries ever since WW2. USA bought millions and millions of refugees and death to these countries. Recently USA also illegally kidnapped a young lady from Huawei as a hostage in order to obtain money and 5G technology.
Yeah, USA made a shameful example in the world history.
Kidnapped? 5G is known to be able to conduct espionage on American data systems. There are valid reasons for the charge.
Also America literally supported Mao to win the battle against Generalissimo Chiang and helped finally kick the Japanese out of the entire Asian continent and pacific. Without the intervention Japan would have a Long term foothold on China to this very day.
You are all looking at America with rose tinted lenses. Yes there have been bad presidents and many of them are but Trump on the other hand wants to end all the wars and is the first populist choice since Eisenhower and the first good President since JFK.
Americans generally have good will to her trade partners and are always willing to grow and prosper together. It is the corrupt officials in Washington that will work for the mega corporations interest to foment war and help profit the military industrial complex
your ignorance is astounding!
Kishore is right .Asia is return.One day China,Russia became earth keeper of world.
US can learn from Olympics. When you are no good you may come out last, not to mention the second place.
If you loose sharing that means you don't care about others .future will show the lions of the world
what's with all the debt trap bs. u think we owe africans something so we need to make some kind of compensation to them? no one forced them to sign the contracts btw. if anyone, it's the west, who hold their investments as bargaining chips in exchange of political and economic gains. we told u what we were doing and what we planned to do along time ago and we keep telling u what our intention is. we r there to make money , which helps africans build their infrastructure and develop their economy, but our main goal is to profit. money or resources. u can work double shifts and pay back the debt so that your son won't have to worry about power shortages, or u can take half of the day off to fuck around and give us your mines. it's really your pick. u think u can try your luck somewhere else, be our guest.
Please tell us about HUAWEI.
Huawei lead the 5G tech n US is trying to crush it with their propaganda
?
I like the interviewer. Polite and professional.
Asking an American to be strategic and thoughtful is asking them to pull a gun to your head. Commodore Matthew Perry did exactly that to the Japanese in 1850s.
Haha. He is old boy from my school ! Up and On !
China and India were the biggest economy?!? What about Persian and Roman empires !!!???
If US is still adamant and can't learn, they will then pay a high price for the lesson.
Its natural that china and india develop.at atime when rest ofnthenworld should adjustbwith indias growth.u shiuld just understand and relieve ursledbof the personal pressure ur going thru.
The most cited lunch in the history of humanity is Mahbubani's lunch with Kissinger 30 years ago.
Russia should thank Europe for financing Russia in Ukraine war. USA should also thank Europe for supporting USA to instigate Ukraine war by repeatedly reneging on its promise over 30 years not to expand Nato eastward to threaten Russia.
Though Europe is picking up all the major bills, all the benefits go to Russia and USA. Unless Europe start developing its own mind. Cheers.
Mahbubani is a bit optimistic on Thucydides trap. I wish his prediction on Sino-U. S. relation is right.
@Akin Khoo "There's unlikely a war between the two biggest economy." That's why I said Mahbubani is optimistic. I think there will be a war between China and the US !
@Akin Khoo You may have second thoughts if Putin was in power in 1990.
China is fed up because their IP theft for 3 decades will be ending significantly under Trump. They have been copying and copying and getting American greedy oligarchs to use their resources and slave wage peasants to build at Low cost.
Now America finally no longer has globalist boot licker Politicians who will do the will of these so called global institutions, these American self serving Politicians are no longer selling out America for China's gain.
What is shocking to me that what America is doing is considered wrong by all these think tanks. When merely they are saying, hold on, let me stop cutting my own nose to spite my face. It is not up to global bodies to decide what other citizens want from their election of their leaders. Do these think tanks have no respect? Why are they lecturing peoples around the world and tell them what to do? They live in Ivory towers and work for their lobbyists and sponsors
The bully dose not realize how much its hated until there on the ground being kicked in !
要面對現實～中國是跟著美國的規則而掘起，再無任何一個能阻止。
中國只是回復大國地位，並一向對西方國家以前的植民搶地完全無興趣，我是中國人！
To face the reality - China is following the rules of the United States and no one can stop it.
China is only a reply to the status of a big country, and has always been completely uninterested in the rushing of the former farmers in the Western countries. I am Chinese!
O M G .....WHAT A GREAT ANALYST HE IS.....GREAT GREAT
Mostly agree with everything ! Main problem is the psyche of the Americans. But the US-behavior is at the moment so bad that many countries are ready to think more "Asian". China never did the first step in creating issues, they have learn the US that they don't need them. So they react softly, even they can play it very hard. China will show the world they don't look to master the world, just to be a good business partner. Very slowly the world, except the US, are realising it and the US will be more isolated, very stupid policy of the US.
China may positions itself as upholder of multilateralism and a responsible member of comity of nations and one who respects international rule of law whereas it has similar ambitions when it comes to influencing international world order, politics, economy and geostrategic presence
The Art of sharing power , The West have to give up some thing, may be human right. Then, Do we start using China currency, or develop a new currency., I think , The most beautiful Art of century,, and Why the West always have to be blame,
Hello Kishore. We are part of western Asia. Please come to Iraq and help Iraqis understand.
When China "shakes the world gentle" do you think policies will act counter productively if China perseveres international systems to be "unstable" or "chaotic" when really only the fundamental system of governance is in place. Will China force people to change? Hong Kong?
Dananja Aloysius HK is a SAR of China. If you have issues read Wikipedia.
The West sharing power ? Are you kidding Kishore ? If we live like the West we we will destroy our precious Planet
Whether the West likes it or not, power is returning to Asia. In fact, it is happening already. The West is in denial, and its response is to close itself off into cocoons. That will not help anyone. Even within the West, fields like STEM are dominated by citizens and immigrants with Asian and African backgrounds. Just take a look at the statistics provided by the US Department of Labor. But we will told that these statistics are fake.
@@paulnantulya African background? I don't see any Africans in STEM