Could Chinese military really invade Taiwan if US was neutral? Part 1/2
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 дек 2018
- This is the first video in a two part series, pitting People's Republic of China versus much smaller Republic of China. It analyzes the numbers and capabilities on both sides, as well the strategic implications stemming from the geography of the area. Air and naval war are discussed, with the invasion of the island of Taiwan left for the second video.
Part 2 is available here: • Could Chinese military...
Join us in War Thunder for free using this link and get a premium tank or aircraft and three days of premium time as a bonus: v2.xyz/WarThunderWithBinkov
Music by Matija Malatestinic
www.malatestinic.com
Want to help us make more videos? Consider becoming our patron. / binkov
Vote for country pairs you'd like to see in future videos in the poll, over at our website: www.binkov.com
You can also browse for other Binkov T-Shirts or Binkov merch, via the store at our website, binkov.com/
Subscribe to Binkov's channel for more videos!
/ binkovsbattlegrounds
Follow Binkov's news on Facebook!
/ binkovsbattlegrounds
![CENTRAL CEE - GEN Z LUV [VERTICAL VIDEO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VIbidJm9q34/mqdefault.jpg)
Join us in War Thunder for free using this link and get a premium tank or aircraft and three days of premium time as a bonus: v2.xyz/WarThunderWithBinkov
Nice, well I am a Hong Kong citizen, still I wish no wars for China and Taiwan.
Do India ,China ,Russia vs USA UK and France .
Please make a episode with the british empire vs the Russian back at the 1800s
Make video on Afghanistan vs Pakistan
HAHAHA, what do you mean a year? Chinese retired general said that can occupy Taiwan in 100 hours!
Never underestimate a man fighting for his home
Agreed, just look at the tenacious Soviets or resilient Vietnamese as historical examples.
@@cocotaveras8975 Yes
Indeed.
Same thing can be said for all nations
Yes
except he couldnt afford one
The only real war seems in the comment section here 😂
Capitán Salazar more people died in the comment section war than in ww2
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵 MAKE CHINA PAY ! Economic Distancing from China ! Lawsuits, China property confiscations, Moving manufacturing OUT of China !! US & Japan announce Move Is ON !
ruclips.net/video/lkhFz2F-hvo/видео.html&app=desktop
Anand Powerlifting screw you
AwesomeColum screw China
Communist Party China's Video Proof 😂😂😂Communist Party of China eradicates China Virus in China, and Western Imperialist Tourists take it back !
ruclips.net/video/kZgzyBe3jVA/видео.html
We recently had a discussion with Mike Green on what will most likely happen to markets if China invades Taiwan. First part is here: ruclips.net/video/0gzMMGEysBk/видео.html and the second part is here: ruclips.net/video/O9iSuvYnMpU/видео.html. Just something to add to what you guys already know. There's about semiconductors and why it's not the reason China wants Taiwan. What will happen to Europe and Russia, to the US? Also the effects on the supply chain, consumer goods, Euro, and USD.
We'll see what happens in part 2, but I think you're vastly underestimating the difficulty of mounting an amphibious invasion over open water against serious opposition. The US and Britain (along with other Allies) did this in WW2 but it wasn't enough to gain bare superiority, it required absolute air and naval supremacy to make it possible - and even then operations like D-Day were so touch-and-go that on June 6 Eisenhower carried in his pocket a prepared statement to give to the press in case the invasion failed and the Allied troops were slaughtered.
Taiwan wouldn't have to win the air and naval war, all it would have to do is have enough forces survive to make the crossing suicidal for slow, vulnerable transports. Just one or two surviving subs could easily sink a dozen transports carrying tens of thousands of men or vital equipment. And the fighting on the beaches would be hideous for the PRC. Read up on the horrible cost extracted by very outnumbered garrisons on Tarawa, Peleliu, and Iwo Jima against invasions supported by hundreds of ships and thousands of planes without a single enemy ship or plane in sight. Of course China won't run out of soldiers or tanks, but they might run out of ships to deliver them and keep them supplied for a grueling ground campaign against a highly skilled and motivated enemy fighting to defend his own country. And unlike the Allies in 1944-45, the PRC has no experience conducting amphibious invasions like this.
Taiwan loses every time, they just do, but China would get fucked up. The USA and nato are not letting that happen and China can’t stop us. We’d destroy China in no time flat. You don’t fuck with democratic countries. The USA has never been ok with that and we never will be. We will come, it will hurt, and we will kill you. Nobody will have fun. I hate war, it’s gross, but we win every time. Taiwan is an ally. If Taiwan wanted to lose, they still win
i think you might be grossly underestimating the military of germany in ww2.
it was THE world's superpower. it took basically the whole world united to stop them.
taiwan is just a rebel province of china.
it's like usa fighting against new york city.
china has a modern military. including submarine hunting helicopters, advanced aircraft, carriers, missiles, etc....
and it has everything in huge quantities.
twaiwan's air defenses would be taken out first, then special forces would be dropped from helicopters to take care of coastal defenses while submarine hunters do their thing, and then a massive invasion, with constant air support through air supremacy.
@@sabin97 Germany had Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria, Japan, Italy, and Vichy France but couldn't defeat Britain alone, nor could it defeat the Soviet Union, this is way before D-Day.
@@advisorynotice
you might wanna brush up on history.
italy was 100% useless in ww2.
japan was not allied with germany. they had a non-aggression pact.
romania hungary and bulgaria didnt help against england.
also england was NEVER alone usa was ALWAYS backing them. germany alone was graping(without the first g, but google gets triggered if you spell it correctly) england.
the drunken piece of sht churchill had to bend over and let usa take them from behind and destroy their future in order for usa to choose to intervene militarily.....because otherwise germany(on their own) would have conquered england.
and yes. operation red beard was doomed to failure.
the soviets have the most reliable ally one could ever hope for: the brutal russian winter.
@@sabin97 you're false on many occasions.
Italy, Romania and Hungary all provided important resources for Germany.
Romania and Hungary would send men to fight in Barbarossa.
The U.K was supported financially by the U.S, similar to how Germant was financially supported by Romania and Hungary and Japan as well and the USSR, the U.S.S.R fueled the German War effort.
America didn't intervene militarily in Europe until late 1942.
You're also forgetting that Sweden fueled Germany's war effort by the Iron ore industry which was very important, so much so a race towards Norway was developed.
Italy was useless but that wasn't my point, resources and intel Italy provided were crucial.
French high command being in shambles caused disaster and Pétain surrendered to not turn France into another Poland, if resistance continued Germany would take months to fully control France.
May I tell you during the Battle of Stonne One French tank destroyed 200 German tanks alone.
Anyways, you also state that the winter was U.S.S.R's greatest ally but that's also wrong, the winter did have some effect but generally speaking the Red Army did most of the work, German intelligence was very wrong about the size of the USSR military thinking they only had 170 divisions, but in reality they managed to raise 850 divisions during the invasion, the Ukranian massacre led to massive civilian resistance, and industries were thrown into Kazakhstan far behind what Germany could ever achieve, it is also general knowledge that Germany sucked at logistics and that would show a lot during their invasion of USSR, by the end of 1941, most German units weren't even capable of offensive operations, this is before the winter set it fully, the Siberian divisions won't be deployed until mid 1942, Yugoslavian resistance already was fucking up the German army and Soviet tanks were superior while the Kriegsmarine got dwarfed by the British Navy, the greatest German ship, the Bismarck, sailed for one day before getting spotted and wrecked. The battle of Crete showed great german incompetence and incapacitated their paratrooping capabilites. The north African compaign exhausted their resources further while they couldn't take one single town, Tobruk.
May I also add that rhe U.S lend lease would be accepted far after the RAF was sure in defeating the Luffewaffe and alr had produced enough aircraft to counter the Blitz.
So yeah you should do some revision.
I like how Binkov at the end of each video he says Binkov talks about hypothetical war but true peace is needed to keep us together. It reminds us war has a cost
No war has a cost too.
I prefer dirty words on the Internet rather than blood in the war.
As the old chestnut goes, 'Those who want peace are always prepared for war.'
@@carlwei7559 yeah
dumb people are everywhere, anyway
Video banned in China*
Rubbish
*cough* *cough* VPN
*RUclips BANNED IN IRAN*
*VPN*
@@antoniogramsci8217 china has a hardon for banning shit they dont like
I mean it shows China being able to easily remove the Taiwanese navy and airforce so if the whole site wasn't already banned, then there's a good chance this video wouldn't be banned either. Unlike Battlefield 4 for example where China itself gets destroyed by civil unrest.
This should be updated again now, since it might really happen just soon
especially now as well
Why not circle and blockage the island?theyll give up eventually
No, it will not. To costly.
@Tom Karen shitty logistics
now
Would you ever think about doing an updated version of this? With a more modernized Chinese military and new Taiwanese defense systems bought from the US.
By "neutral", I presume you mean "non-belligerent". The US would still trade with Taiwan and sell it weapons and munitions. Also, the US would supply Taiwan satellite intelligence, as we did to UK in the Falklands conflict, where we were also "neutral".
The word "neutral" is ambiguous. The US can be "neutral", yet give significant aid & support, which I presume we would do.
Actually, even america cannot win a war with china if it happens so close to mainland china (
@@hgfgadhgfgad7196 As much as I hate to admit that is true but that wouldn't come without a cost and if China does attack the US then they can do article 5 in NATO stopping all trade with China severally crippling China's economy which also cripples the worlds economy and not only that but Japan and SK might even join putting major pressure on China's military. So basically both sides are screwed militarily and economically.
Same as russia, right??
the simulation explains no use of trade or aid to taiwan, even if it would. "Neutral" meaning no interference.
@@dylian_ Is trade interference? Is selling arms interference? Is giving satellite intelligence interference?? Like we gave UK satellite info in the Falklands War, but we didn't "interfere".
All these armchair generals in the comments
The puppet general is the king of all armchair generals.
Keyboard warriors? Yes
Freedom of speech, fuck yes
The fake communist china, has no chance with the real China
"Glória ao CHEGA e ao grande líder André Ventura"
@@movimentopopularnacionalis3007
There are basically no Chinese on youtube
This is scary. I hope it never happens in real life.
Just wait
If it does the US wouldn’t be happy and considering it’s constant naval presence the Chinese would do a preemptive strike on their assets anyway considering how fast the US would side with Taiwan
World war 3? Maybe, maybe not, not entirely clear if other nations outside the local zone would be involved or involve themselves...the largest/most spectacular naval war in human history? Most certainly, a much greater naval war than that of the pacific theater in world war 2, the current holder of that very fun distinction
@@looinrims ww3 for taiwan is not worth it for the US, especially how the US is lacking interest in helping or to do anything unless it's compensated. My guess would be the Taiwanese will beg Japan for help and thus Japan will ask us to sit down and talk. Unfortunately I really don't think the US is interested in helping u less we get a piece of the pie but we will only keep the peace not engage in any fighting what so ever.
It will.
@@be4unvme it's like one of the center of Asia, and it has coasts in every side, plus, taiwan is important to the world economy as some of their stuff beat that of America, if china took It, iPhones wouldn't be advanced as now
Always fun to listen to. Well investigated and thought out
PRC: U me
ROC: No U me
Thank God someone here knows
Broke: PRC
Woke: ROC
@@user-xy1co3mv2b 爆氣仔 笑死
@@etipsbellum771 走到哪都可以看到這種低O兒欸
@@jugululu646
畢竟是女支生的 水準就是不同凡響
I'm sure the plan is to last long enough till Japan and US come to its aid, but a lot would depend on it having nuclear missiles to not be attacked in the first place.
China seems more than willing to pick a fight with the US, the nukes aren’t really going to stop it from wanting Taiwan, if they think they can get it away with it
Crimea style
South Korea has also shown interest in protecting Taiwan
@@wdwuccnxcnh7022 South Korea is not qualified......
@@user-kr9zn7jh3q South Korea actually has mandatory conscription for all men, they spend 2.4 percent of their gdp on defence. They’re certainly not as powerful as Japan but they’d have a rather large impact.
@@user-kr9zn7jh3q South Korea is highly qualified. Stop embarrassing your self over here by being a troll. Your name says it all why you say things like that. South Korea has the 6th most powerful military, it has the 3rd largess military, has a more advanced tank fleet, more advanced air force, a more advanced missile defense system, and has even more advanced amphibious landing capabilities and cruise missile technology than the Chinese. China would fight a three front war if South Korea, Japan, and the US support Taiwan. Korean soldiers are also way more competent and highly trained than Chinese soldiers.
A serious question is can Chinese army fight? I doubt it according to my understanding.
在拥有先进美制武器的台军面前不堪一击
@@theCornerOfChina 台湾南波湾，毕竟笔尖岛才是实质世界第二，美国爸爸不来也是吊打大陆
against their own citizens? YES
@@chengchaojin8419 不是诈骗岛吗
划江而治，划海峡而治，下一步是不是要划美国而治了?
China can attack Taiwan and win, without question, the issue is the price it will pay in its economy, standing in the world and casualties
Casualities? Why? You think there will be a real ground assault? Surround the island with ships, napalm their farms, soon they will start exchanging their island for some rice.
@@peiranzhang4283 hahahaha 😂😂😂😂😂
@@peiranzhang4283 nah in real life the us would not directly fight the chineese, but they would just sail a carrier battlegroup straight through whatever bloackade the chineese would set up and open up supplies to taiwan.
@@mikeetyson9000 I am saying that the Chinese military won't attempt a ground assault very early on, Chinese air forces and navy will just open up on any and all supply caches, and farms would be targeted a lot. Eventually the defenders on Taiwan will starve and surrender. And yeah, I think that is what US will do, try to break the blockade and send in food and supplies. And direct confrontation would be too costly.
@@peiranzhang4283 well the defenders wouldnt starve, they would lose homes and fields, the us would make sure they would stay in the fight, and if china were to attack the US during a humanitarian effort, the us would invoke article 5 crushing the chineese economy and forcing a chineese surrender.
the question is more how much of a fight Taiwan could put up ... i.e. how much damage can they cause before they are forced to surrender.
Kevin Miedema China would steamroll Taiwan tbh. Unless other countries join forces.
lol taiwan is a sitting duck Chinas defense systems wont allow taiwan to do any damage. all china does is one nuke and they must surrender
@@0wninguplz That's why we should arm Taiwan with nuclear weapons too. Nobody dares to touch North Korea.
Applechips they would, if the US let a democratic (albeit unofficial) ally like that go down our promises to protect our allies would be null and void, basically everyone in the region would lose faith in us and be forced to capitulate to Chinese desires
Danesovic They will eventually, given a game of probabilities if you look on into the next several decades if they don’t collapse inward on their own they’ll likely lash out to acquire food, especially if China loses interest in them at some point.
Great vids as usual.
I don't want to be too critical, but I don't like how these are always "But if x or y stayed neutral". I'd like to see what you think would/could happen if the PRC went into Taiwan if it had to deal with the U.S. too and all that.
And other potential allies were involved.
I guess I'm basically just asking for you to do a piece on full on ww3 at that point, though.
China's plan for invading Taiwan is to take control within 48hours, like a blitz. If China was successful in doing that, it would give US and allies not enough time to react. By the time US troops would reach Taiwan, china would already have annexed it. This is all based on the assumption that China can take control within 48 hours tho.
@@samuelren3405 hahaha, very funny though!
@@samuelren3405 It would take at least 3 weeks for the Congress to declare war so the US Navy can be authorized. US President can authorize the Marine Corps immediately, but we all know that's suicidal
@@NathanDrake0410 which means, if China can take over Taiwan in a few weeks, the US can't do shit about it?
@@samuelren3405 ruclips.net/video/q_gr3dtBaic/видео.html Don't listen to me, listen to Lee Kuan Yew. Yes, US can do some "shit". But what's the point, how many thousand of US soldiers do you plan to die for an island which is not US's core interest
Put the british empire vs the Russian empire in 1800s
India was the sultans strength or britishrrt
Look up Crimean war
Creative.
@@taoliu3949 yes but .A. with no allies and .B. the hole empire (both sides did not fight outside of Europe).
@@lahavmorris9919 There's no point to. Binkov has tons of simulation that takes place outside both states' core territories. There's no point on simulating Britain invading Russia if it's obvious it won't work and vice versa. That said, the war was not contained to just Europe, it was also fought in the Caucasus and the Pacific. The main battles were primarily in Crimea because that's where the major powers were closest to.
Respect for announcing paid promotion - interesting video concepts + transparency = subbed in under 30 seconds.
its the year 2021 now - we are still living in the pre China-Taiwan war days
Feel like we need an update on this video - seeing as they have entered a new stage and China has declared its intention of reunification.
Something to keep in mind is use of open roadways as a air liftoff and landing point
Realistically China has an 8 hour window to finish the invasion. Most Taiwanese war games last 8 hours cause that's the time for the air Force to arrive from the US.
Yep. Taiwan needs to stall china as long as they can because the allies will surely wreck China.
No, realistically, China can't invade Taiwan, because even if they do manage to invade Taiwan that quickly, the other nations would send an ultimatum to either voluntarily or involuntarily withdraw.
America is waiting for china to gave them reason to invade lol.
@@MillenniumEarl014, not if Russia joins in.
The US has been prepping this senario as if they're daring China to do it.
It's mainland China v.s. Taiwan. Plus this will be considered as a civil war, since 'officially' the war between PRC and ROC hasn't stopped since 1940s.
Rongxiang Zhi Officially, you meant by “PRC’s” official definition. You should type these key words in Google search instead of Baidu: ”Chinese Civil War”, and see where it goes(at least in the rest of the world considers it ended in 1949)
@@SageWangAdventures Yeah, dude. That's how people end wars, by "considering".
@@nathanDrake-nd I use the word consider because the rest of the word put 1949 as the end of war in their history book, whereas there's one specific country in the world still considers it civil war. So yeah if China considers it a civil war, then why not, the rest of human species considers it ended.
@@SageWangAdventures Well, if you really want to stop a war by "considering", at least involve the two parties in the conflict into the "consideration". And you know what? When two parties in a war "consider" peace, the sign something called a PEACE TREATY.
@@SageWangAdventures yes, "considering" is a good word, just like u consider Taiwan is a country, even though most the countries don't think so. So keep on considering, Taiwan is just living on considering!
It depend on how enthusiastic and committed Taiwan alliances reacted to China military provocation and diplomatic isolation.
Or sacrifice Taiwan to avoid WW3.
@@kevingutierrez9273 Sacrifice Taiwan to abandon freedom, democracy and human rights.🥱🥱
You searched for this... it wasnt in your recommendations
It was lol
It was 😂
Sadly, yes. Apparently, if PRC's military dare to invade the island of Taiwan, well we're here in the SEA will definitely fucked.
I love the way the thumbnail isn't "could tiwan win" it's "could tiwan survive"
Yeah, they’re outnumbered, out of position, outmatched technologically, outmatched economically, they have no advantage
It’s only survival and only within a year because it’s so easy for China, they just blockade Taiwan into surrender, but that would spark all out war
Yeah
It's hard to ever win against someone 60 times the size of you
Just destroy the 3 Gorges Dam - that's all they need to do...would knock China down and out.
@@globalpropertyinvestment not that easy 3 gorges dam is more than 1000 km away from Taiwan and they don't have nuke.
It takes a lot explosive to blow up concrete at that size
Hope binkov takes the nature in mind considering the shipping lanes are the most violitile in the word
We going to know real soon. This is hot on the horizon. Pick a side everyone. I’m on the side of free choices.
Until now this was "tinfoil hat" territory, seems eerily possible today
Glory! Victory! And freedom to the Taiwanese people! Soon China will be West Taiwan!
China will fall hard over this Virus they sent out into the world. Their loses will be extreme and still not gain a victory.
US better support free China.
I do not underestimate the taiwanese . Invading an island is as tough as it gets . At the end the outcome will depend on what the Americans will do. Is the us willing to lose some carriers and thousands of us sailor for Taiwan ?
Not counting in PLA Rocket force is just not serious. Everything else makes no sense.
PLA rocket force had 70 years 😂😂😂😂 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺WHO & China Virus Fallout ! Japan's Taiwan support does not give a FART for China & its propaganda👍👍👍
ruclips.net/video/BhS4EoRuC64/видео.html&app=desktop
Anand Powerlifting Grammar? Also your emojis make you look like a bot
Anand Powerlifting Well. It makes you look 12.
Well this comment is as thin as an anorexic model
Do the US vs California
Maybe Hawaii？
Texas is better, and I don't think fed will win.
Vincent Law Texas would kick Cali’s butt lol we have all the military bases
TOMAHAWK LACM vs The Dildo Division and Bong Brigade.
How about US vs Alaska
Do can mexico invade all of central america in a year
They wont win since brazil alone could beet mexico.
@@lahavmorris9919 good thing Brazil isn't in central america
@@lahavmorris9919 Central America not South America
Probably, if Uncle Sam doesn't have a problem with that
Oh. I didn't read it correctly.
Taiwan is fortunate that both the US and Australia are very likely to come to assist. Japan may get involved as well. There is an understanding, perhaps a fear, that if China does stupidly invade Taiwan we would be at war with China, and that Taiwan would find it has friends.
The main issue is that China does not have an amphibious fleet. The relatively few ships it has that can land tanks would be priority targets. Then there is the seldom discussed Taiwanese nuclear deterrent. In the late 80's / early 90's it was believed that Taiwan purchased several small nukes to help defend itself. If true, this could be why China has never settled the Taiwan issue.
Are you still dreaming ?
Weak up, This is 2021. No idea how advanced RUclips is, being able to allow blinds to use. So humane This app is.
do russia vs all the ex-soviet coutnries combined at the same time
now that would be interesting.
It would be interesting since Russia would have to cut off it's oil suppies to most of Europe. The pipes go through Eastern Europe and they wouldn't want to give free oil to the enemy combatants.
The war would need to be over relatively quickly to avoid their economy being crippled.
@@european-one Not really, the Russian economy would be cripeled, but all of Eastern European economys would be completly destroyed
@@boltmix7294 I treated that as a given. I don't expect Eastern Europe to fare well at all alone.
My point was simply the Russia couldn't sustain this for long, it would become a phyric victory if they allowed it to become drawn out.
Even worse if the pipeline is destroyed and now no country wants to take a new one
This is a great idea!
*XI JINPING WANTS TO KNOW YOUR LOCATION*
No he does not.
Tony theTrulyPuffy r/whooosh
@@cheese-milk5203 But is it, though?
100 acre woods
You know nothing.
What's scary is China has the population to level Taiwan and relocate enough people to rebuild and repopulate within a few years. That would be economic suicide so its unlikely.
Sad to know, how soon people forgot about the Vietnam war.... I guarantee you it will be bloody, as China, will not blink an eye Killing innocent civilians, in fact, they're doing it to their own population now. The western Media is no longer reporting their Human Rights Abuses since, their reporter's puppeteer's are being highly paid by their Chinese owners.
Very interesting indeed and well thought out. I pretty much agree with the analysis with the wildcard being loyalty of the Chinese troops which I don’t know a whole lot about. How would they feel killing fellow Chinese or do they look at the people of Taiwan with disdain?Of course they may simply follow orders To stay alive themselves?
It's not chinese killing chinese rather communists killing chinese
air vs air，navy vs navy，troops vs troops？
Even in the Department of Defence of ROC(Tiwan), this war is counted by days.
Taiwan, not tiwan
5 hrs, maybe
一年，这帮傻逼湾湾怎么这么敢想呢，00年李敖问台湾防卫部门负责人，他就说最多两周了
其实我反而很好奇这个视频作者为什么会有这样奇特的想法。中国共产党的有趣之处就在于，敢于搞中共和中共对着干瞧不起中共的人最后大多下场都不太好看，但依然有无数人义无反顾的继续搞中共，看不起共产党，瞧不起中国。这难道不滑稽？@@yangjing9401
@@ericy726 不需要好奇，要恰饭的嘛，他当然知道挡不住，但观众爱看啊
Great POV. Small pronounce error: penghu is peng-hu.
amazing video!
China doesn't have any amphibious landing experience. They tried and failed 3 times to capture kinmen island which is smaller and closer to the mainland
Maybe. But they are extreamly good at ballistic missile.
071 075
The Taiwanese straights are a very difficult expanse of water with a narrow invasion window for the Chicoms. A miscalculation in weather would spell disaster for the CCP/PLA.
At 5:30 what are the numbers 6093 and 1 - 3091 refering to? If its the count of nucl. submarine, that number appears way too high for me.
As far as on paper army size and capability comparison this is pretty good. But I’d suggest that it also take into consideration mainland’s policy on Taiwan, and also PLA’s tactic choices. The result will perhaps be different.
Mainland may want it to end as quickly as possible. And the Taiwan will want it to be dragged into months length effort.
You forgot Taiwan secret weapon. Bubbleistic missle and long range stinky tofu.
no, it’s
B O B A T E A
NO IT'S A BUBBLE TEA NUKE BRO
bubbletea and stinky tofu are from China....so 。。。。
@@mufasha stinky tofu is from China, but bubble tea is from Taiwan.
It was invented in Taichung(or Tainan) in 1980s
@@hareTom u r right!
Chinese civil war?
pt3. but it would be civil war turn proxy war
2.0
Would either Tibetian independence or Xinjing independence
@@ilikedota5 You say Pt.3 but it is more like Pt. 10000
Sharpe Zhao China is trying to take over Taiwan by political means, undermining their government and getting Taiwan to vote to unify with mainland China. That would increase China's military substantially as Taiwan has a pretty decent-sized navy and airforce. They probably won't even have to fire a bullet to take it over and Taiwan has some US technology. Interesting.
Dear Komissar Binkov! We need an update on this.)) The topic is getting hotter and hotter
Dont know if this is too much to ask but van you make one with other nations support of other nations to Taiwan. Thanks !
m60s being lightly armored is absolutely incorrect, they have some of the thickest CONVENTIONAL armor of any tank. The problem is that it doesn't have the more effective REACTIVE armor types of post 90s era tanks.
also I dont know why they ever stopped negotiations for abrams, or if it did fail why they didn't default to leopard acquirement instead.
iran vs turkey
Ok but, remeber to remove, Tanks,jets,corvettes,friggatees, submarines, Missile launchers, since those Are White european inventions
Why though? Iran has barely an army -- they can protect their homeland for a time and that would be it. Iran has no up-to-date Airforce fleet or Naval fleet. And a bunch of inaccurate ballistic missile strikes wont win a war against Turkey. They're battle-hardened, especially post 2010s.
Iran absolutely has an army. Over 500,000 strong. Not to mention proxy forces throughout the Middle East. And while their air forces are outdated, they are building some of the best anti-air defenses in the region. Naval strength is irrelevant due to geography.
@@stevenundisclosed6091
Iran really has no army
Iran is a media made spooky balloon to keep arabian gulf countries afraid and always pay to the US to protect them
We met them in syria and they can't even organise an attack without causing friendly fire casualties.
Screaming and shouting over the radio
The decision making chain is very VERY long and every officer is afraid to take the blame so they just go higher in chain of command till you reach a really high rank general for a matter that already ended
They are just out of date if they went against turkey
And you get the award for dumbest comment of the day. Congratulations.
Philippines just chillin until it gets involved
Do Pewdiepie vs T-Series as a Christmas special
What the..
I imagine him saying indian assets are older but more numerous
Proger13 10 “some maybe racist”
Nah fam, we’re literally Hitler
Forth Reich, lets go bois *fortnite dab*
nah we're not kids
@@MMenyan 16 here lmao
They can't, Remember Kinmen?
The Taiwanese Nationalist fought back against Chinese 3 times already and still won
That's just a small island, I shall also add
It’s different now. Nuke
actually that is the war between Chinese nationalist with Chinese communist
Jefferson Noguerra “nuke” isn’t an argument, you can’t conquer a radioactive wasteland, well you can but it’s completely useless
It's different now. Kinmen was back when the PLA was far less well equipped and a peasant conscript army with a small navy and air force. Now China is far better equipped but still taking Kinmen or any Taiwanese island would likely result in heavy casualties
Rise of nations players: *laughs in submarines*
Vinkovs great video
*China vs China ? wtf*
you sure this video posted in 2018?
This video is only 2 years old and China has added 15 Type 052D's and 1 Type 055 with 7 more fitting out to be commissioned next year or early 2022.
It's time for the US to start donating some old Tico's and Burke's to Taiwan!
Not long now till we can start measuring this guys accuracy in the region's conflict zones.
You forgot yun feng missiles and hsiung feng 2e missiles have a range of 1500km
Wow I didn't know Taiwan had islands so close to the mainland. Thx Binkov!
Some are literally a couple miles from the mainland. They use to have practically ritualized artillery duels decades ago where one side fires on the other on alternate days of the week. In fact many of the civilians on those nearby islands now entirely depend on. The mainland to make a living. That said, all outer islands would fall in a week, they are far too small and unsupported against a coordinated attack. The other factor is the moral of the roc military. It's not very popular with it's citizens owning to it's dark past as a dictatorial suppression force, many conscripts would rather run or surrender than fight what they see as a no hope war.
Schmidty
They are not part of Taiwan. The islands that are close to the mainland are part of the Fujian province of the ROC.
@@user-en3xy1gs5y when I refer to Taiwan it is as a nation. ROC is the proper thing to say. Whatever technicalities.
"In the end, there will be no one left" excerpt from All quiet on the western front.
Would there be a ASEAN vs China Episode?
这种视频竟然出自2018年，真让人惊讶，我还以为是1998年的视频呢……
因為傻逼年年有, 今年特別多
他们开心就好
这样的视频越多越好，SFA可以放假了。
看看这些呆瓜 意淫呢 笑死我了
肺炎🇨🇳
Turkey vs israel
Or spain ja marroko
Or austria vs czech
Or poland vs ukraine would be interesting
Ukraine before the civil war or during?
@@kainezillah
Before
I Think turkey win against israel, while it is much larger. Marginal Victory.
Spain vs marokko i would Way spain would probably win.
Austria vs czech I would consider both equell so its a draw.
And ukraine vs poland (ukraine before probably a draw, and Now I would say poland could eventuell take some ukraine land).
What so you guys Think?
Hamster Backe Turkey could not beat Israel the amount of training Israel has compared to turkey and amount of casualties Turkey is taking fighting against the PKK proves it even more also the amount of close ambushes the PKK posts on a daily basis also proves the cannot commit too a secure perimeter which is never good remember Israel fights like its gunna be her last war cause it will be if she looses as for a Turkey typical big army little training like Saudi Arabia fighting in Yemen just horrible
@@ravenmoore8432 PKK is hiding in caves that is why they are doing damage.
Israel can only win against incompetent tribal Arabs. They still havent met any real state.
On the other hand Turkey is currently hijacked by Jewish people and pro-Israel politicians. So there won't be a war.
@@hamsterbacke5962 Turkey fears Israel , they will never attack Israel , in fact no middle eastern country can even think of attacking Israel now, they know they will be vaporized easily .. and Israel actually wants them to attack so that they can capture their lands.
I love this guys clips, I just don't get the muppett! However, that muppet knows his stuff, must have had a long military career.
In the Great Muppet Wars.
Would love an update for this scenario, perhaps with updates and more realistic goals for China
Made in China vs. Made in Taiwan... Sooooo it comes down to who breaks first... As the saying goes..
The US would step in and this would escalate very quickly.
F-22s from Kadena AFB in Okinawa would make short work of China's bombers and fighter escorts.
Nathan Grier its funny seeing all the comments saying that china could take on the US alone. Makes for a good laugh.
@@mikhail2709 Like us to a bunch of farmers
@@morecopemorerope4372 and also how us could take on China alone
@@mikhail2709 Trump is killing there economy, but we are strong! this trade war we are wining!
日本人はみんな台湾は独立国家だと思っています！！！🇹🇼🇯🇵
お前頭大丈夫？
this means a state of war between the people's republic of China and the state of Japan，seriously。By the way，we wont attack our own land（sorry that i dont understand Japanese）
@koya 琉球，北海道。早已是独立的国家。
@@user-dt4oh7si5i 1938年意大利夺得世界杯 ，1939年澳大利亚大火 ，1940年东京奥运会取消， 1941年日本偷袭珍珠港。 2018年法国夺得世界杯 ， 2019年澳大利亚大火， 2020年东京奥运会取消， 2021年日本偷袭东京。哈哈哈他吗了个逼的
1938 Italy won the World Cup 1939 Australia fires 1940 Tokyo Olympics cancelled 1941 Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor 2018 France won the World Cup 2019 Australia fires 2020 Tokyo Olympics cancelled 2021 Japan's attack on Tokyo HHH,SHIT
The fact Taiwan would be utilizing World War II era tanks in the form of the M24 Chaffee makes this scenario all the more interesting. The tanks of old competing with the modern era.
You did not take it into account the short period of time in which the Chinese can invade Taiwan. The invasion will happen in April or October. They can move large fleets in that area only in these two four-week windows due to the restrictions imposed by the strait's weather.
I count you'll take in account this little but important detail in the second part.
Keep this great material!
Regards
That's true. More than that, I heard some Taiwan troops stop training if it is hotter than 32°C, summer is good for invading.
you sure summer is good? XD You seem to forget about the typhoons
@@Victor-hy9ux lol, my induction day alone was 38C. Please T
tell me where these troops that don't train in hot weather are stationed. I'm asking for research purposes...
Summer? It's good day to die in the ocean. That is why he said the invasion will happen in Apr or Oct.
You picked Typhoon season? The hardest fucking time of the year for china to invade? Goddamn you're an imbicile, join the navy and attempt to take up the position of warfare specialist, atleast you can study something.
Why do these simulation always leave out allies for simplicity when in reality that's almost impossible to happen.
Because the United States is uncertain about whether or not the United States is involved, the United States in history does not dare to provoke a powerful country, and China’s missiles can be launched into the United States.
gloabl xyz “the US in history does not dare to provoke a powerful country”. Uhhhh Cuban missile crisis?? Putting missiles in Turkey during the Cold War?
one year...man, you are genius...
Just watching this before ww3
Its going to be messy.
Protecting your country is better for your morale than invading.
Im not saying Taiwan would win, but keep this in mind.
Invade? no. Reclamation, yes.
Taiwan army is always on morale...I mean they are always high. Do you know they do drugs in their airbase?
its just overthrowing your governement bruh, much as KMT did in 1911 (which is a great part of chinese history, dont take me wrong). PLA soldiers are trained to have great morale and strong will. brain-washed, if u will, but they are determined, and taiwan soldiers are not.
Dang theres a war down in the comments
pretty silly to think that this would take much more than a week
Hey, Binkov, are you going to make a video about Taiwan's new submarine?
Got leaked to PLA already
there are US battalions stationed at south Korea , Japan, Singapore and Guam. if the invasion occurred reinforcements will arrive within the next 3 hours. trust me the Chinese is not that stupid.
The US doesn’t recognize Taiwan a country, so what is the cause for the US to interfere Chinese Civil War?
Hoàng Nguyên The US is going to lose if the war happened within the West pacific region.
I don't see possibility that Congress and Trump will help Taiwan... Not worth at all
Hoàng Nguyên ,Vietnam war was a good memory
Hoàng Nguyên Vietnam and China? That is interesting. Vietnam has took too many islands that belongs to China already.
The conditions of sea straits between China and Taiwan would heavily favor Taiwan because the seas are rough and covered with fog most of the year.
Half year is too long for a war, Midway just take 2 days and win. Same as nowadays sea war.
Midway was a lot smaller and involved a lot less troops on both sides. Not to mention, the Japanese and US military were both fully mobilized by Midway. It takes months at the minimum to mobilize for a war, which is why Binkovs 6 month analysis isn't unreasonable. Even if the PRC mobilize before attacking, it would be noticed and the ROC would react accordingly. That's why Binkov doesn't simulate premobilization, because there really isn't much difference control wise to stimulate it.
Landing troops is one thing resupplying them getting off wounded is another.
It's civil war……
why use ballistic missile when we have thousands of expiring rocket propelled artillery rounds
cause it require long range rocket to reach that far, taiwan and china are close, but not that close. few rocket has the capability to shpot more than 200km
@@johnson7156Almost every chinese short range missile has a range of at least 300km. Their mid-range missile go 1250km+. Long range missiles would be a bit overpowerd with a range of around 15,000km
@@jakebeaker4243 bullshit lmao.... do some research or simply just google. u are talking like a moron here
@@johnson7156You should do some research before throwing insults, that's embarassing. The information provided above is backed up by the CSIS Missile Defence Project. missilethreat.csis.org/country/china/
Btw long range 'rockets' (LOL) do not exist in any military. Don't try to hide your incapacity for rational thinking by being an asshole. You should rather stay quite in order to not attract the attention of people with a functioning brain.
@@chinesepowerl9525 so what?
We need an updated take on it with hybrid warfare
Given current events, probably time to do an updated version of this. I think infiltrators and Chinese sympathizes with play a role of espionage and sabotage.
I gotta to say, back in 1949, KMT had a petty good chance LOL
😂I don't know what mean is the video like Taiwan vs China.
dude... the KMT lost like a piece of shit in mainland China, that's why they retreated to taiwan. If only they declared independence during the 1970s when America still has diplomatic alliance with taiwan...
不可能的，那是毛泽东的时代
You just had me realize how easy it is for China to invade Korea.
Gordon Sherriff-Smith Well, China only has less than 300 but that would be more than enough to devastate the US, also the new inter continental missiles that can deliver them in 30 mins, the US wouldn’t be that dumb (or would they lol). But in the end, I just hope no war ever happens. 血濃於水, blood is thicker than water, I just hope we don’t have to start killing each other again
That’s gonna be a difficult invasion.
You don’t know the tradition Republic of China army.
There are no easy invasions over open water with serious opposition. And China has never pulled one off in modern history.
please updated new ver. of this
Seems like the imformation is out of time now.
Can the United States invade Hawaii?
hilarious XD
That's precisely how we got Hawaii
Worth noting PLA ground force has MRLS covering all Taiwan's airports and SAM bases with guided rockets ranged above 300km and tactical missiles above 570km. This practically neutralises all Taiwan's air defending measures at a very low cost without even using PLA air force or rocket force. Hence it is pretty obvious that no Taiwan's warships, helicopters and tanks can survive in wartime as of the rapid loss of air defence. Actually PLA is preparing for a war against possible US intervention but Taiwan's resistance.
Ozsharpener CCP vs US Navy........CCP gone!
This wouldn’t be Desert Storm. This would be WW3
US wins.
@@genetung8590 Your tiny brains with such limited IQs wouldn't think a WWIII can be a H-bomb war and Taiwan might be the first place to be neutralized before the entire globe being totally reset. You are so pathetic!
Make vedio analysis malaysia singapore part 2...that is long tern war
it's a miracle1taiwan army can resist one month .
Taiwan will resist the reunification of the mainland China until the last blood of the last American is exhausted.
@@leliu1493 说中文好了真的是
believe me,the military in Taiwan will rebel and surrender soon