Be sure to like, subscribe and turn on notifications! Follow on Twitch: www.twitch.tv/hoopsick Nightwish Reactions: ruclips.net/p/PLiT72mImvysMk2-j671tsnPs1RH6jUHG5
If you want some real heaviness, react to the song "Devil & The Deep Dark Ocean" from Buenos Aires 2018. The whole Band goes berzerk on this performance :D
I absolutely agree with you. I'm pretty sure the reason why many, myself included, like the acoustic version of "How's the Heart" over the album version is because Floor sounds so much better live. Plus their special effects and their stage presence as a whole just adds to everything. Need that added before it's a fair comparison.
All songs are where they belong. I will not change anything. The albums are always masterpieces to be heard in said format. The music arrangements they do for the albums us to exploit and explore the capacity of all sound variations and create a beautiful masterpieces. Then we have the live presentations, where all songs are rearrange for the specific live sound of their instruments. And their live energy is just overwhelming. I'm really looking forward for the songs of the new album to be played live, as they exploit their live potential fully. A lot of their songs from past albums sound a different live because of that, and that's the main reason most of the recommendations are always from their lives. Also because Floor wasn't in the originals so it might be strange to listen to one of their studio albums and then compare to their lives. But since she is the present sound so it's the way to listen to their, let's say, remasterized sound. I'm not getting into a debate of who is better. I personally prefer her voice and personality and what she has brought to the band.
Gotta love Floor growling 😈 I think you’ll like Ghost River from Waken & Devil and the Deep Dark Oceans and Slaying the Dreamer from Buenos Aires 😉 About the new album, just wait until they’re done live. Nightwish has so many genres and I can’t choose a favorite so I don’t know what I’d change.
These live songs also sound so much different on the album, they are really a band you should see live, and i think the new album songs will sound so much more spectacular live, so i can not make a choice, but Tribal and Shoemaker or Pan will knock your socks of live i guess
You're absolutely right; we have to wait for the first live performances to make any comparism. Knowing they are live on the TOP TOP Level I can't wait to see and hear the new album played on stage. I already know it will be stellar and Hoopsick you might change your opinion :-)
hey man give a look to Slaying the dreamer And if you like some heavy stuff check it out to Epica Sancta Terra (feat Floor Jansen) and Epica Consign to Oblivion live at Zenith
Floor's windmills alone make the songs better, thinking about all the other elements they bring when they perform , live versions are just unbeatable. Sooo entertaining to watch; I even watch people who watch Nightwish and share their joy. Crazy, crazy me. And I gotta add; I wish they always "film the entire show to immortalize" those special moments...
i wouldnt take one out no, but i am sure that some of the new album will be amazing live (tribal, pan, endlessness, noise) ...Nightwish is a live band always have been i think. btw i love Floors growls on this song :-)
Oh no... Nothing Will Be taken away, but from the new songs Shoemaker, Endlesness, Tribal and Noise must be added. Gig will be 3 hours, but that is perfect.
noise bahhhhh i would be much more happy with music or pan instead but i can bet u that one of them they ll add will be noise cause its the only one they have with a full video clip and that will be combining better to sales.... and also .... certainly they ll add the other that can easier fit mainstream and be played in radio.... How's the Heart?
Shoemaker won't be played live, as far as Tuomas is concerned. I don't think the shows will last 3 hours, Floor is amazing but the new songs are extremely difficult and demanding to sing, even her can't be singing on a world tour with 3 hours gigs and be perfect in all songs. Tuomas and the rest of the band are going to face the same old problem: wich songs they are going to play live. My guess is they said bye bye to the older songs in the Decades tour (that was the point, playing those oldies for the last time as a gift to the fans) and from now on they are going to focus on the new material + some classics (Nemo, GLS, Amaranth...).
@@j.f.l.bousquet1998 Don't you think the live show would allso be set up around the themes of Human. :ll: Nature.? I'm expecting to hear some older stuff that fits those themes. I want to see at least Planet Hell and Phantom of the Opera back on the setlist😎
3 words: Master Passion Greed. It's their heaviest so far, it's basically a diss track about their first singer's (Tarja's) husband. They go full on Thrash/Metalcore on that one. PS: it doesn't have a live performance as it is a diss track and they've moved on since.
@@itsnaxis349 yes of course, I rushed to Spotify the moment the album was out. But MPG is heavier for me, especially the "Take Her, Seduce Her" part, towards the end. Tribal has some sick riffs though
I can`t wait to see new songs live. And after that I`d decide, which songs I prefer live. It`s difficult to compare live shows with studio records. Especially when it comes to Nightwish
Nightwish seems to set a standard with their album recordings -- a high standard for sure. Then, when it's time to take things live, they say, "Okay, now we're going to blow that standard away."
Regarding live - we won’t know until they are actually able to perform them - but I am sure Tribal and Pan will be insane live. As a reference point, this song - Your’s is an Empty Hope, was one of the least popular on the EFMB album, but absolutely kills live. I expect the same to happen again this time around. They are known to amp up the energy/heaviness and strip out some of the more symphonic elements live. Gives the songs a different energy specific to a live show environment. And Floor has always been known as a good studio performer, but a once in a lifetime live performer. She simply destroys all comers when you throw her on that stage. True in her prior bands as well, which you should check out (After Forever, ReVamp) 🤘🤘
I love when Floor growls and this is one of my favorite songs. As for your question it is hard to answer because Nightwish always changes things when they play live... and they are freaking awesome live. I have at least 30 songs on just my favorite playlist of Nightwish, but from the new album I love Tribal, Noise and Harvest... so I would put one of those on my list...
My favorite performance of my favorite Nightwish song. So seamless and propulsive. Definitely do Devil and the Deep Dark Ocean and Slaying the Dreamer from Buenos Aires. Also I want my tears back, Buenos Aires...to see Floor go a little crazy (dancing) on stage. Great stuff.
Nightwish is best served live with all the rawness that studio versions don't have. That's not a bad thing because touring is more important than ever before for artists.
If you like heavy stuff you HAVE to react to Shudder Before The Beautiful live at Wembley Arena (same show) and Devil & The Deep Dark Ocean + Slaying The Dreamer live in Buenos Aires ;)
A Nightwish concert is a full experience. We have the heaviness, the soft ones, the folk/Celtic ones. It’s unbelievable to be there. The setlist is always so great and you have no idea how many others amazing songs and emotions they can bring to a live concert. 😎🤘🏼
Shudder before the beautiful, 7 days to the wolves, The poet & the pendulum - live at Wembley ( and for Marko and Troy - While your lips are still red @ Wembley). Slaying the dreamer, Devil and the deep dark ocean plus Dead Boy's Poem - Live in Buenos Aires.
Nightwish has been my favorite band since their Oceanborn album, and Human Nature is my favorite album of theirs. I learn a long time ago to just go on the ride they want me to go on. I think after you listen to more Nightwish, you will appreciate Human Nature more. But as everyone says, they don't have a bad song. Creek Marys Blood is a banger of a song and not many people ever talk about it.
For more hard-heavy-n-angry: Weak Fantasy, from any of the live shows in the last few years, and/or Master Passion Greed from the 2007 album (which you won’t find live but is still so worth the listen).
This one blew you away 😁...it's my favourite from their previous album. I still can't "get into" most of the songs on their new album, but I can't wait to see how they're gonna sound live! Live they are mostly on a whole new level.
This is a favorite song of mine. And Floor growling is just awesome. I think some of the new songs will sound great live. Tribal will sound amazing... more Floor growling. Pan and How’s The Heart will sound good too.
Love this! One of my favorites too! You definitely have to check out Shudder Before the Beautiful live @ Wembley! I like the live shows with Floor over new album songs too. Though I do really like the new album. Still so much more to rock out to live! 🔥🤙
"Shudder before the Beautiful" Live at Wembley.. If you listen to the six you've done as studio version, you'll realize the studio does them no justice.. When I listen to a studio version of their new songs, I end up sitting there imagining what they will do at this part on stage..
It would be hard to say, because frankly some of these live performances are so different from their album version. It is one of the only bands I think that are way better live than on the albums. So we will first need to see the new album performed live before we can make that judgement 😉
I’m so glad to see you enjoyed this song. It is one of my favorites. I discovered Nightwish last year after Floor appeared on Best Zangers in the Netherlands. I instantly fell in love with the band and got hooked immediately. I never listened to their previous albums, only to their live performances with Floor. I love their new album and can’t wait to see it performed live. For another heavier song I recommend Shudder Before The Beautiful, live at Wembley. Keep on riding the Nightwish train! 💕🤘 ruclips.net/video/7oQ8sNSYXmQ/видео.html
Smart and intelligent way to ask a question - whether the newest album is same great as previous. And does it match the greatness level Nightwish already has... Well - i think yes. I would definitely love to see a show with the songs from new album even if they replace some of the brilliant tracks from the previous. But... Not for the reason they are better. But because the band get joy from doing different things on stage. When you have such a brilliant discography that Nightwish has its really almost impossible to outshine the song-list you play. So what the band did - is a step aside. Not a step further, not a step back. I like the new album but it doesnt contain such powerful hits as you mentioned. But overall it feels very good as a concept record. And several tracks from this concept record will surely get a bombastic live version for sure.
Nightwish is best served live. When the new album makes it into the set list, the live versions will blow the studio stuff out of the water. It's just some sort of alchemy they have together when they're on a stage that they can't seem to quite get when they're in studio.
I think the fact they play songs from decades of work & growth translates into awesome live performances. Not all songs off each album are in their live repertoire, so if only a couple make it to the status of these ones live, then it’s a success. I suspect some of the new ones will be incredible live. I do think they need a 3 hour show to both showcase new & keep fans happy with classics. I do not want to replace just add add add more more more LOL
i do think it is time for "The Greatest Show On Earth - live from Tampere :) That is one of the greatest masterpieces i have ever heard, and you are definitely not gonna be disappointed
Can´t wait till you hear "I want my tears back" buenos aires 2018, this song is more like folk metal, but verry uplifting and catchy. Something different but worth it!
Yeah you have to remember that nightwish does live performance very diffrence then album versions. Its almost like they make a album just to get the quidance from it to there live performances. Almost as the album is version 1 and when they make a album tour they will evolve the it so at the end of the tour the album is compleate
to understand nightwish human nature. you need to experience Endless forms most beautiful. Nightwish - The Greatest Show On Earth Live - (Legendado PT/Br)
You can’t answer that question until you hear the new songs performed live. If you listened to the studio versions of the songs you have heard live, you might end up listing some of the newer songs higher. It’s comparing apples to oranges until you listen to them all in the same atmosphere. This is a question to be asked later down the road.
I would not take any out, just adding more ;) like "i want my tears back" live in buenos aires 2018, this song have the power of when im in a grey mood, turn it in a rainbow mood with big smile.
I would not know since they did not performed them live. It will be so much better. And you can not replace good songs... so... i would say lets wait, but Noise, Harvest, music, Hows the heart... they will all do well live.
Wembley opener "Shudder Before the Beautiful" is the way you open a show. In your list of songs to do that one is great. It opened their last album and opened the tour. The song is the shit, great harmonizing on that as well. Anyway, good stuff brother!
Good question -I can only answers your question with a question. I like your reactions to Nightwish but your new to Nightwish, I have listened to Nightwish for over 20 years and 1-my favorite Nightwish song is always the last one I’ve listened to. 2-anytime a new album is released every veteran Nightwish fan knows it’s going to be great, new and different but all of us are saying to ourselves can’t wait to hear this live, it’s going to be epic. So my question to you is listen to any of the 6 Nightwish songs you’ve heard live, listen to the album version. Then ask yourself which one would you like over the live version? Great job!🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
You have listened to only 6 songs. Nightwish can make a setlist for 4-5 concert with different songs and all beautiful like the other six. you don't know anything yet ;-)
I would only switch Ghost Love Score since they play it in every show. There also are some other songs in their usual setlist that I would switch with their new songs though. Next maybe The Devil And The Deep Dark Ocean (Buenos Aires 2018)
If you want a truly epic live experience, I absolutely love The Greatest Show on Earth from Wembley. Definitely long but well worth it as it shows off their incredible range in one song and the live show does not disappoint.
Yes I would , but you have to understand, a lot of us are on a whole different part of the nightwish journey than you, I've been a fan since I was a teenager, I'm 32 now! I've seen them many times and am requiring fresh blood to sink my teeth into! All Nightwish is so much more effective live as it shows all the elements in full light! A lot of their music is much more heavier live also and clearer with the atmosphere they want to create! If you hear the studio albums also you would see that live, it's so much more heavier and powerful! 🤘 Also wanted to mention, I feel you listening to the new album is such a leap to all the classics you've reacted to live, I think listening to songs like The Greatest show on Earth and The poet and the Pendulum will bridge the gap you have probably felt reacting to the new stuff 😊
Its a difficult question to answer, because we haven't heard any new songs live (obviously), so the way I went around this question was comparing the songs on their studio albums and to figure out what I preferred and how I would imagine the new songs would sound like live, and I think that I would replace "Story time" with Tribal, I can just imagine Kai going to town on those Drums, but if you ask me tomorrow I want to replace another song for Pan, and that's the thing about Nightwish what songs I love change depending on my mood, but right now I have a thing for Tribal & Pan. I you want to see another side of Nightwish, its not as heavy but still amazing I would suggest I want my tears back from either Wachen or Buone Aires 2018. I think that Tribal somehow will have some elements of that song live (Kinda hard to explain why :) )
I also wouldn't replace any of the songs, even after having listened to them for years already. And i also don't think a live performance of the new songs would change that.
Great reaction. To see Floor really growl you should listen to her previous metal heavy band Revamp the song Disdain from graspop (2010) i am sure you will love it. And with respect to the comparison New album and these old songs. Just wait till they have played the new album songs live. That's the magic of Nightwish LIVE
To continue with Wembley.. Shudder Before the Beautiful, 7 days to the Wolves, **The Poet and the Pendulum (Read the back story First) And watch it with Lyrics, also pause multiple times for copy right issues with this one. (This is a special one to the band and fans)**.
I think you should go for End of an era man. That's where you will find the real heavy stuff. Planet Hell, Wish I had an angel, Slaying the dreamer, Dark chest of wonders.
They are one of the few bands that always are better live than the album. The music is epic and made to perform live. Also sounds heavier. I think once we see some of the new songs live we will love them just as much. Think Tribal will be crazy live.
I agree with checking out Floor Jansen with After Forever and ReVamp. I highly suggest After Forever- “Dreamflight” at ProgPowert USA 2007. Phenomenal performance and amazing song. Also, the new album is incredible. I think “Pan,” “Tribal,” and “Music” will be incredible live. That new album must be listened to in order, and over several listens to be fully appreciated.
Well I think we have to wait before we can say that because I want to know how the songs are in al live peformance.. its not fair to compare a albumversion to a live version😉 when we hear them live I can tell you what I feel. Because I think that Tribel Live is sooooo good then I will putt that song over Ghost River.. but first I realy have to hear it live💋
Song of Myself has never been one of my favorites (unpopular opinion, I know), so that's the one I would trade, probably for How's the Heart, which is my favorite of the new Album. I agree however that it will be hard to tell how good they really are until the new songs are played live. Now for song/band suggestions to react to to keep things interesting :) - Epica : Sancta Terra ft Floor Jansen ruclips.net/video/cx22Yuj2nzg/видео.html - Floor Jansen & Henk Poort (Beste Zangers): The Phantom of the Opera ruclips.net/video/plCScjvDOJM/видео.html - Epica : The Phantom Agony ruclips.net/video/gpIEPdRXwYA/видео.html - Delain : The Gathering (with a surprise ;) )ruclips.net/video/buUX9cCWZbQ/видео.html - Amberian Dawn : River of Tuoni ruclips.net/video/40cLOS9Lr5k/видео.html - Ancien Bards : Impious Dystopia ruclips.net/video/Ujq1bBi7sYU/видео.html - Arion : At the Break of Dawn ruclips.net/video/QYzAUwCLgyk/видео.html - Dark Elements (ex-Nightwish Anette Olzon's band) : Songs the Night Sings ruclips.net/video/H-vyg5Vvg3I/видео.html - Dark Moor : Swan Lake (Yes, it's based on the Tchaikovski ballet) ruclips.net/video/7VWui4oDAF8/видео.html - Avantasia : The Scarecrow ruclips.net/video/LTyxnUZMA1k/видео.html - Within Temptation : Ice Queen ruclips.net/video/jpU5GBbAW5g/видео.html - Within Temptation ft Tarja Turunen: Paradise ruclips.net/video/Dy6MpsDPKts/видео.html - In This Moment : Black Wedding ruclips.net/video/fHAi_-DOy40/видео.html - Lacuna Coil : Nothing Stands In Our Way ruclips.net/video/Gtft6LqgFSA/видео.html - Powerwolf : Army of the Night ruclips.net/video/1zN7J64IeBo/видео.html - Tarja (ex-Nightwish Tarja Turunen) : Until My Last Breath ruclips.net/video/G-i4wUTtkZc/видео.html
Yes, you said something I already commented. The last album is very good, all songs are great, but only Noise would get into my Nightwish 15 favourite songs... And really, man, I see that you specially like the heaviest songs by Nightwish, so you SHOULD do EPICA. But please start with "Consign to Oblivion" and only then go to "Sancta Terra"... Greetings from Spain and stay safe and metal...
I would not replace any of these i think but until i hear the new songs live its not really a fair comparison. If u look at the studioalbums of old there is not many songs there u would replace any of these songs with either i would guess. Also these 6 songs i would probably keep in most situations anyway. I do think that Noise and Pan especially will be good live Also Tribal even tho its a bit short imo. Either way it will be interesting to see which songs from the new album they will use in their live shows.
4 года назад
You have so many great songs to enjoy and react to. They dont put out new albums too often so it's hard to name even a mediocre song. I've noticed though that I like different songs depending on my mood ofthe day
I love how some say that Floor can’t growl. First of all, newbs, Nightwish is not growling, its a different style. Secondly, each time she has the chance she proves she can do it like a pro.
I might get in a bit of trouble with my fellow NW army members, but I confess that I don't really listen much to their studio records. I have a few including the new one, but for me it's really their live shows that turned me into a follower. Any band able to pull off performances like these, both musically and visually, gets a big thumbs up from me :)
If you want a really good live song, check out "The Greatest Show on Earth" live Tampere 2015. In fact I think this was your first time hearing a song from Floors first studio album "Endless forms most beautiful" great album!!
I agree, this is one of the greatest. About the new album vs live shows: Remember, Nightwish (these days) always sounds better, and harder live. I would not want to replace any of those 5 songs :-) but since it is impossible to do 4 hour shows, here's how: Storytime -- > Noise will be at least as good live, I'd imagine actually even better. Romanticide -- > Tribal is as hard, and will be unforgettable experience with 10.000 people doing skeleton dance Ghost River --> Shoemaker, good song + that finish when Floor going 100% opera will blow your mind off in concert Song of Myself should always be in setlist, and Ghost Love Score cannot be replaced by any song, ever. I think you'd also like harder songs like Slaying the Dreamer (Buenos Aires), Dark Chest of Wonders (Tampere), Weak Fantasy (Wembley) Wish I had an Angel (Wacken) to start with... Or the just watch rest of the Wacken show :-)
I would say that we all need to hear songs from that new album on a live show first. For example Ghost Love Score isn't their best selling record yet it is arguably their most successful song (Live Wacken 2013) on RUclips.
Cannot answer that final question because I haven't heard new ones live yet. After that I can make up my mind. Nightwish is so different at studio albums than live...
You really should listen to: the poet and the pendulum. Also from this Wembley concert. And don’t forget: the greatest show on earth. From Wembley or Tampere concert. Floor also sings on a lot of albums of Ayreon. See Wikipedia.
Good stuff! These live ones are so good. More NW reaction coming i assume? 😎 About the live thing...In a little over 3 months their supposed to be playing here in Finland in a summer festival, end of July (Kuopio Rock) Its only 3 km from my place. Talk about a no brainer (tickets already bought)! I hope this coronavirus bullshit is not canceling that one. 🤘
Be sure to like, subscribe and turn on notifications!
Follow on Twitch: www.twitch.tv/hoopsick
Nightwish Reactions: ruclips.net/p/PLiT72mImvysMk2-j671tsnPs1RH6jUHG5
If you want some real heaviness, react to the song "Devil & The Deep Dark Ocean" from Buenos Aires 2018. The whole Band goes berzerk on this performance :D
Yes I love that performance 🤘
Slaying the dreamer is even better
@@painkiller666666666 Thats what happens when you get a stake through the heart!
Agree with that. Also "I want my tears back" is pretty heavy and also so uplifting.
Planet Hell is sick too
Agree with the sentiment that the new songs need the live treatment before they are really compared
I absolutely agree with you. I'm pretty sure the reason why many, myself included, like the acoustic version of "How's the Heart" over the album version is because Floor sounds so much better live. Plus their special effects and their stage presence as a whole just adds to everything. Need that added before it's a fair comparison.
100% agreed
All songs are where they belong. I will not change anything.
The albums are always masterpieces to be heard in said format. The music arrangements they do for the albums us to exploit and explore the capacity of all sound variations and create a beautiful masterpieces.
Then we have the live presentations, where all songs are rearrange for the specific live sound of their instruments. And their live energy is just overwhelming.
I'm really looking forward for the songs of the new album to be played live, as they exploit their live potential fully. A lot of their songs from past albums sound a different live because of that, and that's the main reason most of the recommendations are always from their lives. Also because Floor wasn't in the originals so it might be strange to listen to one of their studio albums and then compare to their lives.
But since she is the present sound so it's the way to listen to their, let's say, remasterized sound.
I'm not getting into a debate of who is better. I personally prefer her voice and personality and what she has brought to the band.
7 Days To The Wolves, also from this Wembley Arena concert. Will not disappoint! 🤘🔥🤘
Gotta love Floor growling 😈 I think you’ll like Ghost River from Waken & Devil and the Deep Dark Oceans and Slaying the Dreamer from Buenos Aires 😉
About the new album, just wait until they’re done live. Nightwish has so many genres and I can’t choose a favorite so I don’t know what I’d change.
Jeff Hollenbeck yep. Also waiting to hear the new songs live.
Maybe he should react to Planet hell End of an era as well.
He did gohst River befor the album go look in his list
Shudder before the beautiful wembley same show, awesome thanks 😊
These live songs also sound so much different on the album, they are really a band you should see live, and i think the new album songs will sound so much more spectacular live, so i can not make a choice, but Tribal and Shoemaker or Pan will knock your socks of live i guess
Yes, that's reght..
And i guess, the NIGHTWISH ARMY is here! 😂
You're absolutely right; we have to wait for the first live performances to make any comparism. Knowing they are live on the TOP TOP Level I can't wait to see and hear the new album played on stage. I already know it will be stellar and Hoopsick you might change your opinion :-)
@@tasminoben686 yep they are :)
Totally agree!
hey man give a look to Slaying the dreamer
And if you like some heavy stuff check it out to Epica Sancta Terra (feat Floor Jansen)
and
Epica Consign to Oblivion live at Zenith
The retrospect version of sancta terra ft floor.
Floor used to be in Revamp
Try :
Revamp - wildcard
Revamp - disdain
More heavy more growling
Very good advice
After forever Discord at US. Progpower Metal Festival, AF. Beyond Me. All AF. Are epic.
Floor's windmills alone make the songs better, thinking about all the other elements they bring when they perform , live versions are just unbeatable. Sooo entertaining to watch; I even watch people who watch Nightwish and share their joy. Crazy, crazy me.
And I gotta add; I wish they always "film the entire show to immortalize" those special moments...
i wouldnt take one out no, but i am sure that some of the new album will be amazing live (tribal, pan, endlessness, noise) ...Nightwish is a live band always have been i think. btw i love Floors growls on this song :-)
Oh no... Nothing Will Be taken away, but from the new songs Shoemaker, Endlesness, Tribal and Noise must be added. Gig will be 3 hours, but that is perfect.
🤣👍 3 hrs... Fine by me
noise bahhhhh i would be much more happy with music or pan instead but i can bet u that one of them they ll add will be noise cause its the only one they have with a full video clip and that will be combining better to sales.... and also .... certainly they ll add the other that can easier fit mainstream and be played in radio.... How's the Heart?
Shoemaker won't be played live, as far as Tuomas is concerned. I don't think the shows will last 3 hours, Floor is amazing but the new songs are extremely difficult and demanding to sing, even her can't be singing on a world tour with 3 hours gigs and be perfect in all songs. Tuomas and the rest of the band are going to face the same old problem: wich songs they are going to play live. My guess is they said bye bye to the older songs in the Decades tour (that was the point, playing those oldies for the last time as a gift to the fans) and from now on they are going to focus on the new material + some classics (Nemo, GLS, Amaranth...).
@@j.f.l.bousquet1998 ofc... Not totally serious... But as a fan... I could make it. Complete album live would be great anyways
@@j.f.l.bousquet1998 Don't you think the live show would allso be set up around the themes of Human. :ll: Nature.? I'm expecting to hear some older stuff that fits those themes. I want to see at least Planet Hell and Phantom of the Opera back on the setlist😎
3 words: Master Passion Greed. It's their heaviest so far, it's basically a diss track about their first singer's (Tarja's) husband. They go full on Thrash/Metalcore on that one.
PS: it doesn't have a live performance as it is a diss track and they've moved on since.
Yes this one is awesome!!
I agree it is a great song I wish they would do something more like it
Have you guys not heard Tribal yet? I'd argue it's a bit heavier than Master Passion Greed
@@itsnaxis349 yes of course, I rushed to Spotify the moment the album was out. But MPG is heavier for me, especially the "Take Her, Seduce Her" part, towards the end. Tribal has some sick riffs though
@@brent3522 that is fair lol
I can`t wait to see new songs live. And after that I`d decide, which songs I prefer live. It`s difficult to compare live shows with studio records. Especially when it comes to Nightwish
Nightwish seems to set a standard with their album recordings -- a high standard for sure. Then, when it's time to take things live, they say, "Okay, now we're going to blow that standard away."
Regarding live - we won’t know until they are actually able to perform them - but I am sure Tribal and Pan will be insane live. As a reference point, this song - Your’s is an Empty Hope, was one of the least popular on the EFMB album, but absolutely kills live. I expect the same to happen again this time around. They are known to amp up the energy/heaviness and strip out some of the more symphonic elements live. Gives the songs a different energy specific to a live show environment. And Floor has always been known as a good studio performer, but a once in a lifetime live performer. She simply destroys all comers when you throw her on that stage. True in her prior bands as well, which you should check out (After Forever, ReVamp) 🤘🤘
I would switch out Ghost river for Noise. Floors screaming vocals at the end of Noise will be insane live 🤘
SalvoSix Yes I second that! Also I would switch Song of myself for Tribal.
i read ghost love score in the first place and asked myself, if you are insane :D
LOL I think Floor love GLS the most it will not easily be replaced its just a classic
@@renskevanderhaagen5813 Love 'em both.
I love Floors floorgasm during the end of Tribal!! That will be amazing live.
I love when Floor growls and this is one of my favorite songs.
As for your question it is hard to answer because Nightwish always changes things when they play live... and they are freaking awesome live.
I have at least 30 songs on just my favorite playlist of Nightwish, but from the new album I love Tribal, Noise and Harvest... so I would put one of those on my list...
Slaying The Dreamer (Buenos Aires 2018)
"r u rdy for smth more heavy ?" try this : ReVamp - Disdain Live at Graspop (2010)
oh ves😙
If you‘d line it even heavier and faster: Devil and the Deep Dark Ocean in Buenos Aires.
Great reaction as always 🤘😎
Weak Fantasy from the Tampere concert is another great one
I was at the Wembley concert, 2018 and 2015, absolutely incredible band!
My favorite performance of my favorite Nightwish song. So seamless and propulsive. Definitely do Devil and the Deep Dark Ocean and Slaying the Dreamer from Buenos Aires. Also I want my tears back, Buenos Aires...to see Floor go a little crazy (dancing) on stage. Great stuff.
Nightwish is best served live with all the rawness that studio versions don't have. That's not a bad thing because touring is more important than ever before for artists.
If you like heavy stuff you HAVE to react to Shudder Before The Beautiful live at Wembley Arena (same show) and Devil & The Deep Dark Ocean + Slaying The Dreamer live in Buenos Aires ;)
A Nightwish concert is a full experience. We have the heaviness, the soft ones, the folk/Celtic ones. It’s unbelievable to be there. The setlist is always so great and you have no idea how many others amazing songs and emotions they can bring to a live concert. 😎🤘🏼
Shudder before the beautiful, 7 days to the wolves, The poet & the pendulum - live at Wembley ( and for Marko and Troy - While your lips are still red @ Wembley).
Slaying the dreamer, Devil and the deep dark ocean plus Dead Boy's Poem - Live in Buenos Aires.
Devil and the deep dark ocean- live Buenos Aires next!
Master passion greed, excellent choice for hoopsick ! Go for it !
I can never quite decide whether this or Storytime is my favourite. So much energy and passion.
🤘🤘❤️🤘🤘 Oh Yeah!!!!! 😁🤘🤘
Nightwish has been my favorite band since their Oceanborn album, and Human Nature is my favorite album of theirs. I learn a long time ago to just go on the ride they want me to go on. I think after you listen to more Nightwish, you will appreciate Human Nature more. But as everyone says, they don't have a bad song. Creek Marys Blood is a banger of a song and not many people ever talk about it.
Thank you so much for reacting to this song. One of my fave songs, so powerful, so heavy and to hear Floor growling - priceless! :)
For more hard-heavy-n-angry: Weak Fantasy, from any of the live shows in the last few years, and/or Master Passion Greed from the 2007 album (which you won’t find live but is still so worth the listen).
This one blew you away 😁...it's my favourite from their previous album.
I still can't "get into" most of the songs on their new album, but I can't wait to see how they're gonna sound live! Live they are mostly on a whole new level.
this bass and guitar combo is sick
This is a favorite song of mine. And Floor growling is just awesome. I think some of the new songs will sound great live. Tribal will sound amazing... more Floor growling. Pan and How’s The Heart will sound good too.
Love this! One of my favorites too! You definitely have to check out Shudder Before the Beautiful live @ Wembley! I like the live shows with Floor over new album songs too. Though I do really like the new album. Still so much more to rock out to live! 🔥🤙
"Shudder before the Beautiful" Live at Wembley.. If you listen to the six you've done as studio version, you'll realize the studio does them no justice.. When I listen to a studio version of their new songs, I end up sitting there imagining what they will do at this part on stage..
It would be hard to say, because frankly some of these live performances are so different from their album version. It is one of the only bands I think that are way better live than on the albums. So we will first need to see the new album performed live before we can make that judgement 😉
Господи, что Floor делает своим голосом!!! Она невероятная!
Awesome dude, great to see you doing these honest Nightwish reviews again! Keep up the great work mate!
I’m so glad to see you enjoyed this song. It is one of my favorites. I discovered Nightwish last year after Floor appeared on Best Zangers in the Netherlands. I instantly fell in love with the band and got hooked immediately. I never listened to their previous albums, only to their live performances with Floor. I love their new album and can’t wait to see it performed live. For another heavier song I recommend Shudder Before The Beautiful, live at Wembley. Keep on riding the Nightwish train! 💕🤘 ruclips.net/video/7oQ8sNSYXmQ/видео.html
Smart and intelligent way to ask a question - whether the newest album is same great as previous. And does it match the greatness level Nightwish already has... Well - i think yes. I would definitely love to see a show with the songs from new album even if they replace some of the brilliant tracks from the previous. But... Not for the reason they are better. But because the band get joy from doing different things on stage. When you have such a brilliant discography that Nightwish has its really almost impossible to outshine the song-list you play. So what the band did - is a step aside. Not a step further, not a step back. I like the new album but it doesnt contain such powerful hits as you mentioned. But overall it feels very good as a concept record. And several tracks from this concept record will surely get a bombastic live version for sure.
I’d switch She’s my sin for Pan or Tribal
Nightwish is best served live. When the new album makes it into the set list, the live versions will blow the studio stuff out of the water. It's just some sort of alchemy they have together when they're on a stage that they can't seem to quite get when they're in studio.
I think the fact they play songs from decades of work & growth translates into awesome live performances. Not all songs off each album are in their live repertoire, so if only a couple make it to the status of these ones live, then it’s a success. I suspect some of the new ones will be incredible live. I do think they need a 3 hour show to both showcase new & keep fans happy with classics. I do not want to replace just add add add more more more LOL
i do think it is time for "The Greatest Show On Earth - live from Tampere :) That is one of the greatest masterpieces i have ever heard, and you are definitely not gonna be disappointed
Can´t wait till you hear "I want my tears back" buenos aires 2018, this song is more like folk metal, but verry uplifting and catchy. Something different but worth it!
Great reaction. You've done enough Nightwish songs.to be a Lt. Colonel in the Nightwish Army.
Arrrrmy training Sir!
Subscribed and dinged. 🤘😛🤘
Yeah you have to remember that nightwish does live performance very diffrence then album versions. Its almost like they make a album just to get the quidance from it to there live performances. Almost as the album is version 1 and when they make a album tour they will evolve the it so at the end of the tour the album is compleate
to understand nightwish human nature. you need to experience Endless forms most beautiful. Nightwish - The Greatest Show On Earth Live - (Legendado PT/Br)
You can’t answer that question until you hear the new songs performed live. If you listened to the studio versions of the songs you have heard live, you might end up listing some of the newer songs higher. It’s comparing apples to oranges until you listen to them all in the same atmosphere. This is a question to be asked later down the road.
I would not take any out, just adding more ;) like "i want my tears back" live in buenos aires 2018, this song have the power of when im in a grey mood, turn it in a rainbow mood with big smile.
Nightwish- I want my tears back !!
Live Nightwish best Nightwish
I would not know since they did not performed them live. It will be so much better. And you can not replace good songs... so... i would say lets wait, but Noise, Harvest, music, Hows the heart... they will all do well live.
Wembley opener "Shudder Before the Beautiful" is the way you open a show. In your list of songs to do that one is great. It opened their last album and opened the tour. The song is the shit, great harmonizing on that as well. Anyway, good stuff brother!
Good question -I can only answers your question with a question. I like your reactions to Nightwish but your new to Nightwish, I have listened to Nightwish for over 20 years and 1-my favorite Nightwish song is always the last one I’ve listened to. 2-anytime a new album is released every veteran Nightwish fan knows it’s going to be great, new and different but all of us are saying to ourselves can’t wait to hear this live, it’s going to be epic. So my question to you is listen to any of the 6 Nightwish songs you’ve heard live, listen to the album version. Then ask yourself which one would you like over the live version? Great job!🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
You have listened to only 6 songs. Nightwish can make a setlist for 4-5 concert with different songs and all beautiful like the other six.
you don't know anything yet ;-)
Every time a fantastic ride.... Thx for this reaction Hoop.... great job as always... 👍
Master passion greed with Marco on vocals 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
If you hear....to Floor more heavy....check ....Revamp......live......enjoy....saludos from Chile......
If you cry....xheck......Tv duch...call..beste zangers.......and enjoy the best ...the most beautiful ...cover ever...of Floor......
I love this song along with Master Passion Greed (which is even heavier!)
I would only switch Ghost Love Score since they play it in every show. There also are some other songs in their usual setlist that I would switch with their new songs though.
Next maybe The Devil And The Deep Dark Ocean (Buenos Aires 2018)
If you want a truly epic live experience, I absolutely love The Greatest Show on Earth from Wembley. Definitely long but well worth it as it shows off their incredible range in one song and the live show does not disappoint.
Yes I would , but you have to understand, a lot of us are on a whole different part of the nightwish journey than you, I've been a fan since I was a teenager, I'm 32 now! I've seen them many times and am requiring fresh blood to sink my teeth into! All Nightwish is so much more effective live as it shows all the elements in full light! A lot of their music is much more heavier live also and clearer with the atmosphere they want to create! If you hear the studio albums also you would see that live, it's so much more heavier and powerful! 🤘
Also wanted to mention, I feel you listening to the new album is such a leap to all the classics you've reacted to live, I think listening to songs like The Greatest show on Earth and The poet and the Pendulum will bridge the gap you have probably felt reacting to the new stuff 😊
Tuomas knew what he was doing when he called Floor to fill in mid-tour. He knew exactly who he called.
Its a difficult question to answer, because we haven't heard any new songs live (obviously), so the way I went around this question was comparing the songs on their studio albums and to figure out what I preferred and how I would imagine the new songs would sound like live, and I think that I would replace "Story time" with Tribal, I can just imagine Kai going to town on those Drums, but if you ask me tomorrow I want to replace another song for Pan, and that's the thing about Nightwish what songs I love change depending on my mood, but right now I have a thing for Tribal & Pan.
I you want to see another side of Nightwish, its not as heavy but still amazing I would suggest I want my tears back from either Wachen or Buone Aires 2018. I think that Tribal somehow will have some elements of that song live (Kinda hard to explain why :) )
Tribal and Pan will be amazing live 🤘🏻I’m glad you liked this one 😌 Great reaction!
Oh yeah... She growls baby... She indeed does😅❤️❤️😁😁😁❤️
I also wouldn't replace any of the songs, even after having listened to them for years already.
And i also don't think a live performance of the new songs would change that.
The point is Nightwish are a live band. I really do like studio material but when they step out on stage they are a different animal. Great reaction.
Great reaction. To see Floor really growl you should listen to her previous metal heavy band Revamp the song Disdain from graspop (2010) i am sure you will love it. And with respect to the comparison New album and these old songs. Just wait till they have played the new album songs live. That's the magic of Nightwish LIVE
To continue with Wembley.. Shudder Before the Beautiful, 7 days to the Wolves, **The Poet and the Pendulum (Read the back story First) And watch it with Lyrics, also pause multiple times for copy right issues with this one. (This is a special one to the band and fans)**.
I think you should go for End of an era man. That's where you will find the real heavy stuff. Planet Hell, Wish I had an angel, Slaying the dreamer, Dark chest of wonders.
I 100% support this comment. :)
Please do The Poet And The Pendulum in Wembley. Just don't forget to read about the meaning of the song and to check out the lyrics. Great react!
They are one of the few bands that always are better live than the album. The music is epic and made to perform live. Also sounds heavier. I think once we see some of the new songs live we will love them just as much. Think Tribal will be crazy live.
I agree with checking out Floor Jansen with After Forever and ReVamp.
I highly suggest After Forever- “Dreamflight” at ProgPowert USA 2007. Phenomenal performance and amazing song.
Also, the new album is incredible. I think “Pan,” “Tribal,” and “Music” will be incredible live. That new album must be listened to in order, and over several listens to be fully appreciated.
Answer on your question is NO!!! Slaying the dreamer and Devil & the deep dark ocean, both from Buenos Aires, you would love that :D
I was surprised floor can growl, insane.... another proof shes the most talented vocalist on earth.
7 days to the wolves, live at Wembley ! It is perfect.
React to The greatest show on earth from Nightwish
Well I think we have to wait before we can say that because I want to know how the songs are in al live peformance.. its not fair to compare a albumversion to a live version😉 when we hear them live I can tell you what I feel. Because I think that Tribel Live is sooooo good then I will putt that song over Ghost River.. but first I realy have to hear it live💋
Also if you want to hear one of the most heaviest song of Nightwish, try Master Passion Greed. Marco is singing that song fully. 🤘😉
Song of Myself has never been one of my favorites (unpopular opinion, I know), so that's the one I would trade, probably for How's the Heart, which is my favorite of the new Album. I agree however that it will be hard to tell how good they really are until the new songs are played live.
Now for song/band suggestions to react to to keep things interesting :)
- Epica : Sancta Terra ft Floor Jansen ruclips.net/video/cx22Yuj2nzg/видео.html
- Floor Jansen & Henk Poort (Beste Zangers): The Phantom of the Opera ruclips.net/video/plCScjvDOJM/видео.html
- Epica : The Phantom Agony ruclips.net/video/gpIEPdRXwYA/видео.html
- Delain : The Gathering (with a surprise ;) )ruclips.net/video/buUX9cCWZbQ/видео.html
- Amberian Dawn : River of Tuoni ruclips.net/video/40cLOS9Lr5k/видео.html
- Ancien Bards : Impious Dystopia ruclips.net/video/Ujq1bBi7sYU/видео.html
- Arion : At the Break of Dawn ruclips.net/video/QYzAUwCLgyk/видео.html
- Dark Elements (ex-Nightwish Anette Olzon's band) : Songs the Night Sings ruclips.net/video/H-vyg5Vvg3I/видео.html
- Dark Moor : Swan Lake (Yes, it's based on the Tchaikovski ballet) ruclips.net/video/7VWui4oDAF8/видео.html
- Avantasia : The Scarecrow ruclips.net/video/LTyxnUZMA1k/видео.html
- Within Temptation : Ice Queen ruclips.net/video/jpU5GBbAW5g/видео.html
- Within Temptation ft Tarja Turunen: Paradise ruclips.net/video/Dy6MpsDPKts/видео.html
- In This Moment : Black Wedding ruclips.net/video/fHAi_-DOy40/видео.html
- Lacuna Coil : Nothing Stands In Our Way ruclips.net/video/Gtft6LqgFSA/видео.html
- Powerwolf : Army of the Night ruclips.net/video/1zN7J64IeBo/видео.html
- Tarja (ex-Nightwish Tarja Turunen) : Until My Last Breath ruclips.net/video/G-i4wUTtkZc/видео.html
Yes, you said something I already commented. The last album is very good, all songs are great, but only Noise would get into my Nightwish 15 favourite songs... And really, man, I see that you specially like the heaviest songs by Nightwish, so you SHOULD do EPICA. But please start with "Consign to Oblivion" and only then go to "Sancta Terra"...
Greetings from Spain and stay safe and metal...
Jumpin around my room like a crazy person! Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.......😈🔥👿😈🔥👿💋💕😈🔥👿!!!
I would not replace any of these i think but until i hear the new songs live its not really a fair comparison. If u look at the studioalbums of old there is not many songs there u would replace any of these songs with either i would guess. Also these 6 songs i would probably keep in most situations anyway. I do think that Noise and Pan especially will be good live Also Tribal even tho its a bit short imo. Either way it will be interesting to see which songs from the new album they will use in their live shows.
You have so many great songs to enjoy and react to. They dont put out new albums too often so it's hard to name even a mediocre song. I've noticed though that I like different songs depending on my mood ofthe day
I love how some say that Floor can’t growl. First of all, newbs, Nightwish is not growling, its a different style. Secondly, each time she has the chance she proves she can do it like a pro.
I might get in a bit of trouble with my fellow NW army members, but I confess that I don't really listen much to their studio records. I have a few including the new one, but for me it's really their live shows that turned me into a follower. Any band able to pull off performances like these, both musically and visually, gets a big thumbs up from me :)
If you were to listen to the studio versions of the 6 songs you like live you would be super excited to hear the new album live.
If you want a really good live song, check out "The Greatest Show on Earth" live Tampere 2015. In fact I think this was your first time hearing a song from Floors first studio album "Endless forms most beautiful" great album!!
I agree, this is one of the greatest.
About the new album vs live shows: Remember, Nightwish (these days) always sounds better, and harder live.
I would not want to replace any of those 5 songs :-) but since it is impossible to do 4 hour shows, here's how:
Storytime -- > Noise will be at least as good live, I'd imagine actually even better.
Romanticide -- > Tribal is as hard, and will be unforgettable experience with 10.000 people doing skeleton dance
Ghost River --> Shoemaker, good song + that finish when Floor going 100% opera will blow your mind off in concert
Song of Myself should always be in setlist, and Ghost Love Score cannot be replaced by any song, ever.
I think you'd also like harder songs like Slaying the Dreamer (Buenos Aires), Dark Chest of Wonders (Tampere), Weak Fantasy (Wembley) Wish I had an Angel (Wacken) to start with... Or the just watch rest of the Wacken show :-)
I would say that we all need to hear songs from that new album on a live show first. For example Ghost Love Score isn't their best selling record yet it is arguably their most successful song (Live Wacken 2013) on RUclips.
Cannot answer that final question because I haven't heard new ones live yet. After that I can make up my mind. Nightwish is so different at studio albums than live...
I think you'll enjoy "Last Ride of the Day" from Wacken, or "10th Man Down" live from Buenos Aires :)
You really should listen to: the poet and the pendulum. Also from this Wembley concert. And don’t forget: the greatest show on earth. From Wembley or Tampere concert.
Floor also sings on a lot of albums of Ayreon. See Wikipedia.
Good stuff! These live ones are so good. More NW reaction coming i assume? 😎 About the live thing...In a little over 3 months their supposed to be playing here in Finland in a summer festival, end of July (Kuopio Rock) Its only 3 km from my place. Talk about a no brainer (tickets already bought)! I hope this coronavirus bullshit is not canceling that one. 🤘