This might be the time for Wes Anderson to finally win his long overdue Oscar with his short movie, The Wonderful Story Of Henry Sugar. Finger cross he wins that trophy 🤞
I maintain the Academy has so much to properly restore short films and give them cinema distribution and exhibition. The amount of them unavailable is shocking.
I know it has little to no chance but I love Robot Dreams for Animated Feature. I haven't seen all of them but the Wes Anderson short I really enjoyed.
“Nai Nai and Wai Po” is pronounced as “Why Po”. It was directed by Sean Wang who just released a movie on Sundance “Didi” that got a lot of buzz! Hope that one wins!
It did catch my attention that in “Nai” they did do the “eye” sound, but then in Wai they switched it to “ey”. I figured both had the “eye” sound, since it’s a foreign language. Thanks for rhetorical clarification.
So Brian loves Across the Spider-Verse, and Cody loves The Boy and the Heron -- and I love both. The problem with choosing them that they are so completely, utterly different in intention and experience, and I love each movie for what it is -- one a non-stop actioner with both a heart and a brain, the other a bittersweet coming-of-age tone poem with the most gorgeous musical score I've heard all year. Whichever one ends up winning, a part of me will feel a little sad that the other one had to lose.
Thank you Brian & Cody!!! I really needed this video. I am leaning heavily on critics for help with my predictions for the short categories as none are really available in my country. I greatly appreciated Cody explaining what some of them are about & why he liked them for specific reasons.
I’ve seen all the live action short films so far. As much as I’m predicting The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar to win. The most impactful and best one I’ve seen of the 5 short films is Red White and Blue. That one for me was the more relevant and emotionally effective of the five.
i also don't get the excitement around the boy and the heron…it was kind of messy and even with its subject matter, i don't think it came together all that well
The biggest roadblock to The Boy and the Heron's success is that it's a PG-13 anime. The Oscars always tends to go with more family-friendly affair, the greatest advantage that spider verse has. They could actually pull a Toy Story 4 and give it to spider verse. The boy and heron is a film like princess mononoke, a PG-13 film that herron is being compared to alongside Spirited Away. It's going to be difficult for herron to win considering it wasn't nominated for an ACE Eddie award, which is crucial to the Oscar win. On top of that, they have their own awards.
I don't think Spidey is going to win the Oscar since the Academy already gave the first one the win and they traditionally don't reward animated sequels: Think of Shrek 2, Kung Fu Panda 2, Despicable Me 2, How to Train Your Dragon 2 and 3, Cars 2 and 3 (not even nominated), The Incredibles 2, Frozen 2 (not even nominated), Finding Dory (not even nominated), Puss In Boots The Last Wish, Ralph Breaks The Internet. Despite all the glitz and glam and whiz-bang colors of Spidey, The Boy And The Heron was much more substantial.
idk, a lot of these sequels aren’t even that good, and in those years, there was usually a movie that was leagues better that just so happened to be an original film. and in cases like shrek 2, that was going up against the incredibles, the alleged “best pixar film ever," according to many people, especially at the time. across the spiderverse is a case where it’s a sequel that actually lives up to the hype of the original and exceeds it tenfold (and is much, *much* more substantial than boy and the heron, don’t even go there 🤣🤣 (imho))
@@Cho0segoose toy story 3 was the end of the trilogy (just like the return of the king), moreover, it was nominated for best picture that year. With toy story 4 its kind of different thing, the only true contender for it was Klaus and i hoped for victory for Klaus, but it didnt.
2013 ”Brave”：Golden Globe, BAFTA ”Wreck-It Ralph”：Critics Choice, Annie, PGA → OSCAR WENT TO ”BRAVE" 2024 ”The Boy and the Heron”：Golden Globe, BAFTA ”Spiderman: Across the Spiderverse”：Critics Choice, Annie, PGA This is why "The boy and the Heron" will win
Wreck it Ralph lost the Oscar only because it wasn’t nominated at BAFTA. All Best Animated Feature Oscar winners are at least nominated at BAFTA. Spiderverse was nominated at BAFTA. Brave won the Oscar because it won ACE Eddie Award for Best Animated Feature. The winners of ACE Eddie Award wins the Oscar. Spiderverse will win that considering The Boy and the Heron is not nominated at ACE.
@@laurajones1773 There is another important rule; If an animated feature wins BAFTA and lose Annie, it never lose Oscar (Happy Feet, Toy Story 3 and 4, WALL･E, Brave, Encanto) At least one of these 2 rules definitely breaks this year.
@@お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuvacademy loves popular animated movies and it's pretty much domestic co.pared to globes and baftas... so spiderverse will break that rule
I love these videos! Please team up every year. I’m not a big fan of animated movies in general, but this discussion is getting me really excited about the Animated Feature category. I love an unpredictable race.
Netflix has two of the live action, Disney+ has two of the documentary shorts, and RUclips has some of the shorts. I had to rent 20 Days on Prime and Bobbi Wine is on Disney+
I'm rooting for Ninety Five Senses to win so that we can say the creators of Napoleon Dynamite won lol Wes Anderson's biggest challenge was getting the nomination considering they're very gatekeepy, so now the short is nominated I think there's no one stopping him to win
Right now I’m thinking Spider-Man. I think it’s very close, but I feel like Spider Man is more beloved and more accessible to watch than the Boy and the Heron
Spider-Man: Across the Spiderverse has Critics Choice, Annie, PGA, and was included in the AFIs Top Ten Movies of the Year (not an easy list to crack especially for animated films). The Boy and the Heron has Golden Globes and BAFTA...and is not a sequel (which seems to be frowned upon). I may be missing another award here. 🤔 I think I'm going with Spider-Man: Across the Spiderverse. But, I'm not confident 😕
I do think that Nai Nai and Wai Po short directed by Sean Wang will win I hope especially since he has his upcoming film Didi hitting theaters july which could help build momentum
My current GoldDerby predictions (as of 9.3): *Best Animated Feature:* 5. Robot Dreams 4. Elemental 3. Nimona 2. The Boy and the Heron 1. Spiderman: Across the Spider Verse *Best Documentary Feature:* (SUPERBET) 5. To Kill a Tiger 4. The Eternal Memory 3. Bobi Wine: The People's President 2. Four Daughters 1. 20 Weeks in Mariupol *Best International Film:* 5. Io Capitano (Italy) 4. The Teachers' Lounge (Germany) 3. Perfect Days (Japan) 2. Society of the Snow (Spain) 1. The Zone of Interest (United Kingdom) *Best Animated Short:* 5. Pachyderme 4. Our Uniform 3. Ninety-Five Senses 2. WAR IS OVER! Inspired By the Music of John and Yoko 1. Letter to a Pig [love for my people Tal Kantor and Amit Gicelter! 💙🤍] *Best Documentary Short:* 5. Island in Between 4. The Barber of Little Rock 3. The ABCs of Book Banning 2. The Last Repair Shop 1. Năi Nai and Wài Pó *Best Live Action Short:* 5. Invincible 4. Knight of Fortune 3. The After 2. Red, White and Blue 1. The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar
When it comes to Animated Feature I'm in the exact same boat as Cody. I want Boy and the Heron to win SO MUCH but I don't dare risk predicting it only to be disappointed like I was when it didn't get a score nomination.
True. The Academy snubbed Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio for score last year. Considering Spiderverse is a superhero film, the Academy snubbed a different superhero film The Batman last year.
As a high schooler I'm so sorry Brian, also I havent seen the shorts or documentary nominees but International Feature Will and should win: The Zone of Interest- UK Animated Feature Will and should win: Spider Man: Across the Spider-Verse
could someone technically beat The Zone of Interest? it wouldn’t make sense because it’s nominated for best picture and if another film wins it wouldn’t make any fricking sense
I feel like the only way would be that Jonathan Glazer did something criminal, in between the nominations and the voting closed on Tuesday. Something that would turn everyone against the film.
Let's also not forget Toy Story 4 only won Best Animated Feature at the Oscars while Klaus swept the Annie and won The Bafta and Missing Link won the Golden Globes. So, this category is unpredictable
I definitely think Anderson should win for The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar. In my opinion he should’ve won about 9 years ago for The Grand Budapest Hotel (suck it Iñárritu! I’m sorry that was mean), and Asteroid City should’ve been nominated for something this year, but meh. I also don’t think it was the best of those shorts but I can see why it got the nomination over my favourite (The Swan) because it kind of seems to represent all four of them, and it’s the longest.
One of the guys made the comment that some feel the actors in Henry Sugar are talking "at" you a lot of the time. Exactly! That turned me off. It made it feel pretentious.
I just don't understand the cynicism of this dude. War is Over is a uplifting film with a great message of Peace. Just stop being too cool for school dude.
Pulling for Letter to a Pig for animated short…95 Senses was truly one of my least favorite, did not buy the “cuteness” of the story at all. Could’ve been way better with some simple script changes. War is over would be okay, but pachyderme and our uniform are better imo
I aven't seen the other 3 nominees in the Best Documentary feature, but Four Daughters is one of the best films of the year, and so, so much better than 20 Days in Mariupol. I don't think the format of the latter with the voicever works that well. But it will win anyway over the superior movie because it's about the war in Ukraine. There's just no way that the Academy will instead give the Oscar to a movie about the experience of Muslim women.
@@daims8041 Editors guild is a big and important one for best animated feature race. The Boy and The Heron not being nominated is somenthing to look at.
@@JF-xy6dg maybe its because it was made in Japan and its japanese production (i dont know exactly, you correct me if im wrong). Its AMERCIAN guild of Editors
Engelbert:s The Shadow of Your Smile This song is from The Sandpiper in 1065 starring Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton. Immediately after that year in 1966, Elizabeth went on to win the Oscars for Who is Afraid of Virginia Wolf? some say the greatest Best Actress won ever even better than Meryl Streep in Sophie's Choice. ruclips.net/video/szNN5gk1pFo/видео.htmlsi=PIvFnjPDL24c-fcd I know you think Meryl Streep is the best. If I remember correctly, this view is from the American Film Instituted or someone affiliated with that organisation and I agree. With the current Oscar race, looking back at the past winners, I think Lily Gladstone is nowhere as compared to Emma Stone in terms of gargantuan of effort but her performance is somewhat similar to Olivia Coleman in The Favourite in terms of mannerisms. Plus Emma was also in that show plus she has won an Oscar before. If I am the voter I would pick Sandra Huller for something fiery like Elizabeth Taylor and something bottled emotions burst out like Meryl Streep and Sandra speaks foreign languages on the show Meryl Streep in Sophi's Choice. Dandra',s character also has many layers like Meryl and Elizabeth and it slowly gets peeled as the show progresses.
This might be the time for Wes Anderson to finally win his long overdue Oscar with his short movie, The Wonderful Story Of Henry Sugar. Finger cross he wins that trophy 🤞
I maintain the Academy has so much to properly restore short films and give them cinema distribution and exhibition. The amount of them unavailable is shocking.
I know it has little to no chance but I love Robot Dreams for Animated Feature.
I haven't seen all of them but the Wes Anderson short I really enjoyed.
“Nai Nai and Wai Po” is pronounced as “Why Po”. It was directed by Sean Wang who just released a movie on Sundance “Didi” that got a lot of buzz! Hope that one wins!
It did catch my attention that in “Nai” they did do the “eye” sound, but then in Wai they switched it to “ey”. I figured both had the “eye” sound, since it’s a foreign language. Thanks for rhetorical clarification.
Really enjoy your videos. Particularly enjoy when you and Cody discuss things.
So Brian loves Across the Spider-Verse, and Cody loves The Boy and the Heron -- and I love both. The problem with choosing them that they are so completely, utterly different in intention and experience, and I love each movie for what it is -- one a non-stop actioner with both a heart and a brain, the other a bittersweet coming-of-age tone poem with the most gorgeous musical score I've heard all year. Whichever one ends up winning, a part of me will feel a little sad that the other one had to lose.
Thank you Brian & Cody!!! I really needed this video. I am leaning heavily on critics for help with my predictions for the short categories as none are really available in my country. I greatly appreciated Cody explaining what some of them are about & why he liked them for specific reasons.
Same! I’m filling out my ballot and I’m lost in all of these categories.
I’ve seen all the live action short films so far. As much as I’m predicting The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar to win. The most impactful and best one I’ve seen of the 5 short films is Red White and Blue. That one for me was the more relevant and emotionally effective of the five.
What’s Red, White and Blue about?
@simplyrowen it is about a woman who has to travel out of state for abortion services. It has a wallop of an ending.
i also don't get the excitement around the boy and the heron…it was kind of messy and even with its subject matter, i don't think it came together all that well
The biggest roadblock to The Boy and the Heron's success is that it's a PG-13 anime. The Oscars always tends to go with more family-friendly affair, the greatest advantage that spider verse has. They could actually pull a Toy Story 4 and give it to spider verse. The boy and heron is a film like princess mononoke, a PG-13 film that herron is being compared to alongside Spirited Away. It's going to be difficult for herron to win considering it wasn't nominated for an ACE Eddie award, which is crucial to the Oscar win. On top of that, they have their own awards.
True. Spirited Away has a PG rating.
will you do a recap video of all of your predictions?
I don't think Spidey is going to win the Oscar since the Academy already gave the first one the win and they traditionally don't reward animated sequels: Think of Shrek 2, Kung Fu Panda 2, Despicable Me 2, How to Train Your Dragon 2 and 3, Cars 2 and 3 (not even nominated), The Incredibles 2, Frozen 2 (not even nominated), Finding Dory (not even nominated), Puss In Boots The Last Wish, Ralph Breaks The Internet.
Despite all the glitz and glam and whiz-bang colors of Spidey, The Boy And The Heron was much more substantial.
idk, a lot of these sequels aren’t even that good, and in those years, there was usually a movie that was leagues better that just so happened to be an original film. and in cases like shrek 2, that was going up against the incredibles, the alleged “best pixar film ever," according to many people, especially at the time. across the spiderverse is a case where it’s a sequel that actually lives up to the hype of the original and exceeds it tenfold (and is much, *much* more substantial than boy and the heron, don’t even go there 🤣🤣 (imho))
Toy Story 3 and 4 won this category. Spidey is winning all the precursors that are usually great predictors too. Hard to bet against that
@@Cho0segoose toy story 3 was the end of the trilogy (just like the return of the king), moreover, it was nominated for best picture that year.
With toy story 4 its kind of different thing, the only true contender for it was Klaus and i hoped for victory for Klaus, but it didnt.
academy loves populated aninated movies...it's also domestic so no
spiderverse wins every guild it needed to such as pga, cc, and winning ace
lmaooo most of those sequel movies you mentioned arent even in the same league as Spiderverse
Robot Dreams is wonderful.
2013 ”Brave”：Golden Globe, BAFTA ”Wreck-It Ralph”：Critics Choice, Annie, PGA → OSCAR WENT TO ”BRAVE"
2024 ”The Boy and the Heron”：Golden Globe, BAFTA ”Spiderman: Across the Spiderverse”：Critics Choice, Annie, PGA
This is why "The boy and the Heron" will win
Wreck it Ralph lost the Oscar only because it wasn’t nominated at BAFTA. All Best Animated Feature Oscar winners are at least nominated at BAFTA. Spiderverse was nominated at BAFTA. Brave won the Oscar because it won ACE Eddie Award for Best Animated Feature. The winners of ACE Eddie Award wins the Oscar. Spiderverse will win that considering The Boy and the Heron is not nominated at ACE.
@@laurajones1773 There is another important rule;
If an animated feature wins BAFTA and lose Annie, it never lose Oscar (Happy Feet, Toy Story 3 and 4, WALL･E, Brave, Encanto)
At least one of these 2 rules definitely breaks this year.
brave won eddies tho...boy and the heron didnt even make it in
@@お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuvacademy loves popular animated movies and it's pretty much domestic co.pared to globes and baftas...
so spiderverse will break that rule
I mentioned that above that Brave won ACE Eddie Award.
I love these videos! Please team up every year. I’m not a big fan of animated movies in general, but this discussion is getting me really excited about the Animated Feature category. I love an unpredictable race.
Give animation a chance. Sometimes, they are some of the best films of the year.
I can’t find any of these on any streaming services. Where did you see them? Please?
Netflix has two of the live action, Disney+ has two of the documentary shorts, and RUclips has some of the shorts. I had to rent 20 Days on Prime and Bobbi Wine is on Disney+
@@branagain thank you brunswick
I'm rooting for Ninety Five Senses to win so that we can say the creators of Napoleon Dynamite won lol
Wes Anderson's biggest challenge was getting the nomination considering they're very gatekeepy, so now the short is nominated I think there's no one stopping him to win
Can you please expound on the gatekeeping?
Right now I’m thinking Spider-Man. I think it’s very close, but I feel like Spider Man is more beloved and more accessible to watch than the Boy and the Heron
Spider-Man: Across the Spiderverse has Critics Choice, Annie, PGA, and was included in the AFIs Top Ten Movies of the Year (not an easy list to crack especially for animated films).
The Boy and the Heron has Golden Globes and BAFTA...and is not a sequel (which seems to be frowned upon). I may be missing another award here. 🤔
I think I'm going with Spider-Man: Across the Spiderverse. But, I'm not confident 😕
I do think that Nai Nai and Wai Po short directed by Sean Wang will win I hope especially since he has his upcoming film Didi hitting theaters july which could help build momentum
Red White and Blue and War Is Over deserve to win.
The shorts and Documentaries were nowhere to be found for me. Not even on theaters
Wait , I did see Society of the Snow. But can’t find any of the others 🙁
My current GoldDerby predictions (as of 9.3):
*Best Animated Feature:*
5. Robot Dreams
4. Elemental
3. Nimona
2. The Boy and the Heron
1. Spiderman: Across the Spider Verse
*Best Documentary Feature:* (SUPERBET)
5. To Kill a Tiger
4. The Eternal Memory
3. Bobi Wine: The People's President
2. Four Daughters
1. 20 Weeks in Mariupol
*Best International Film:*
5. Io Capitano (Italy)
4. The Teachers' Lounge (Germany)
3. Perfect Days (Japan)
2. Society of the Snow (Spain)
1. The Zone of Interest (United Kingdom)
*Best Animated Short:*
5. Pachyderme
4. Our Uniform
3. Ninety-Five Senses
2. WAR IS OVER! Inspired By the Music of John and Yoko
1. Letter to a Pig [love for my people Tal Kantor and Amit Gicelter! 💙🤍]
*Best Documentary Short:*
5. Island in Between
4. The Barber of Little Rock
3. The ABCs of Book Banning
2. The Last Repair Shop
1. Năi Nai and Wài Pó
*Best Live Action Short:*
5. Invincible
4. Knight of Fortune
3. The After
2. Red, White and Blue
1. The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar
When it comes to Animated Feature I'm in the exact same boat as Cody. I want Boy and the Heron to win SO MUCH but I don't dare risk predicting it only to be disappointed like I was when it didn't get a score nomination.
boy and the heron doesnt have the guilds support and domestic support as well
Spiderverse wasn’t nominated for Best Original Score either. That has a fantastic score.
@@laurajones1773 they both do; but the academy hates animation
True. The Academy snubbed Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio for score last year. Considering Spiderverse is a superhero film, the Academy snubbed a different superhero film The Batman last year.
Such an underrated channel!
Audience friendly is the key word.
As a high schooler I'm so sorry Brian, also I havent seen the shorts or documentary nominees but
International Feature
Will and should win: The Zone of Interest- UK
Animated Feature
Will and should win: Spider Man: Across the Spider-Verse
could someone technically beat The Zone of Interest? it wouldn’t make sense because it’s nominated for best picture and if another film wins it wouldn’t make any fricking sense
I feel like the only way would be that Jonathan Glazer did something criminal, in between the nominations and the voting closed on Tuesday. Something that would turn everyone against the film.
Let's also not forget Toy Story 4 only won Best Animated Feature at the Oscars while Klaus swept the Annie and won The Bafta and Missing Link won the Golden Globes. So, this category is unpredictable
Toy Story 4 won the Critics Choice, PGA and ACE Eddie Awards.
@@laurajones1773 oh right I forgot those
I definitely think Anderson should win for The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar. In my opinion he should’ve won about 9 years ago for The Grand Budapest Hotel (suck it Iñárritu! I’m sorry that was mean), and Asteroid City should’ve been nominated for something this year, but meh. I also don’t think it was the best of those shorts but I can see why it got the nomination over my favourite (The Swan) because it kind of seems to represent all four of them, and it’s the longest.
One of the guys made the comment that some feel the actors in Henry Sugar are talking "at" you a lot of the time. Exactly! That turned me off. It made it feel pretentious.
I agree that 95 Senses is the best of the animated shorts. But I agree that unfortunately War is Over will win.
Another fantastic video! Take a shot anyone they say "harrowing " ❤
I’m not a Wes Anderson fan, but I actually liked Henry Sugar.
I really want Studio Gibli to win another Best Animated Featurw Oscar.
They've been overdue another win in my eyes.
You should watch Io capitano
I don't know how much it matters but The After has beaten Henry Sugar in one award at least. Maybe is nothing, but who knows
I just don't understand the cynicism of this dude. War is Over is a uplifting film with a great message of Peace. Just stop being too cool for school dude.
Pulling for Letter to a Pig for animated short…95 Senses was truly one of my least favorite, did not buy the “cuteness” of the story at all. Could’ve been way better with some simple script changes. War is over would be okay, but pachyderme and our uniform are better imo
I aven't seen the other 3 nominees in the Best Documentary feature, but Four Daughters is one of the best films of the year, and so, so much better than 20 Days in Mariupol. I don't think the format of the latter with the voicever works that well. But it will win anyway over the superior movie because it's about the war in Ukraine. There's just no way that the Academy will instead give the Oscar to a movie about the experience of Muslim women.
Spiderverse has Annie, Critics Choice and PGA. Its safe to say that is getting the Editors guild too.
"Its safe to say that is getting the Editors guild too." - maybe because Boy not even nominated)
I also think it has the edge. But, we'll see.
@@daims8041 Editors guild is a big and important one for best animated feature race. The Boy and The Heron not being nominated is somenthing to look at.
@@JF-xy6dg maybe its because it was made in Japan and its japanese production (i dont know exactly, you correct me if im wrong). Its AMERCIAN guild of Editors
@@daims8041i mean I lost my body even got nominated when it's a french film
War is over was so bad. It was the worst of all of the shorts i watched. It is the dictionary definition of oscar bait
I saw the shorts documentaries.....I am betting on The ABCs of Book Banning.
The Last Repair Shop is going to win.
@@alokmishra4429 I would rank it 3rd.
@alokmishra4429 I hope so, it's much, much better.
Engelbert:s The Shadow of Your Smile
This song is from The Sandpiper in 1065 starring Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton.
Immediately after that year in 1966, Elizabeth went on to win the Oscars for Who is Afraid of Virginia Wolf? some say the greatest Best Actress won ever even better than Meryl Streep in Sophie's Choice.
ruclips.net/video/szNN5gk1pFo/видео.htmlsi=PIvFnjPDL24c-fcd
I know you think Meryl Streep is the best. If I remember correctly, this view is from the American Film Instituted or someone affiliated with that organisation and I agree.
With the current Oscar race, looking back at the past winners, I think Lily Gladstone is nowhere as compared to Emma Stone in terms of gargantuan of effort but her performance is somewhat similar to Olivia Coleman in The Favourite in terms of mannerisms. Plus Emma was also in that show plus she has won an Oscar before.
If I am the voter I would pick Sandra Huller for something fiery like Elizabeth Taylor and something bottled emotions burst out like Meryl Streep and Sandra speaks foreign languages on the show Meryl Streep in Sophi's Choice.
Dandra',s character also has many layers like Meryl and Elizabeth and it slowly gets peeled as the show progresses.