MUSIC TEACH REACTS | 2000 | A Perfect Circle "Judith" | CLEANING OUT THE SHED EP 28
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 окт 2024
- On this episode of Cleaning Out The Shed, we go back to 2000. Check out David’s reaction to A Perfect Circle's "Judith".
If you enjoy the content, please LIKE the video, and don't forget to subscribe for more Music Shed reactions!
Check out the original video • A Perfect Circle - Jud...
For more information about David and the Music Shed visit www.musicshedc... or contact us at musicshedct@gmail.com.
Produced by Very Nice Industries veryniceindust...
Additional footage courtesy of pexels.com
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”
#APerfectCircle #Judith #COTS #MusicShed #reaction #musicTeacher 
Видеоклипы
Love this song. Paz’s hair tie is legendary
Right!?
Indeed
I look for it every time
The way she ties her hair and then it drops back in uhhhhh get outta here with that !
Sexy.
Paz putting her hair in a bun and seamlessly dropping back in is my fav part of the video she’s such a badass
Not just a woman bass player...
She's also the violinist
Her solo stuff is incredible, and now she's with the Pixies! Love Paz.
I was going to mention that she's the violinist in 3 Libras
The Drummer is Josh Freese ! He did play with Guns n Roses, Nine Inch Nails, Rob Zombie, QOTSA and many many more !
He recorded a couple albums with The Offspring too!
I think I blame Josh Freese for the inspiration that made me a drummer, the music he sessioned for DEFINED my adolescence... Seether, NIN, Evanescence, Avril Lavigne, The Offspring, Good Charlotte, and this! It's quite possible to say he defined the drum sound of the 00s.
@@visjordan4281 as a drummer of that era myself I totally agree!
The vandals also
Yes! Freese is highly underrated. I dig his style
A Perfect Circle. "The band Maynard's cheating on TooL with..." 😂 Sorry to break it to you, but Maynard has ANOTHER band, Puscifer. So musical monogamy is not one of his strong suits. 😁 All 3 bands are amazing in their own ways,and showcase different sides to MJK's genius. Love the channel!
Definitely need to see some Puscifer reactions in here!
And all three are insanely fantastic.
The song is about him voicing his distaste for religion in the context of his mother was very devout but was was paralyzed by a aneurysm when he was very young (11 I think it was) so he's saying you gave all of this to your God who then "left you broken down and paralyzed" "he did it all for you".
specificly its about how people of her church were telling her, that if she had believed more/prayed more/etc this wouldn't have happened. basicly saying that its her own fault for being not "good enough"
"He did it all for you" is Judith Marie speaking to her son, Maynard. She was such a devoted and selfless Baptist, everything she went through was to make him who he is today. Proof of her faith to the very end, at any cost.
@@jessacartel5973 Interesting. Didn't know that
@@jessacartel5973 given the context in the song it sounds a lot more like him saying to his mom that god did all these things for her. As in, her suffering came from God. That makes more sense in context.
A pity that you didn't pick up on the story behind the lyrics. Together with Tool's Wings for Marie and 10000 Days (Wings for Marie Part 2) they tell the story of his mother (Judith Marie). All of these songs are amazing and they give me goosebumps.
I’m with you…The “true” story behind these songs, makes it hard to imagine that it’s “real”….But, once you examine your own life, you realize it’s ubiquitous throughout humanity……Only, most of us lack the talent to confess it the way these artists do…
You should react to weak and powerless by a perfect circle 👌
Agreed react to weak and powerless
yess weak and powerlessss
I fourth this! Weak and powerless is beautiful!
Session drummer Josh Freese has recorded several thousand albums.
Doing that riff solo on keyboard made it sound like something Trent Reznor would use for a NIN outro lol.
Very accurate on the pick. It gives a crisper, more delineated striking of notes.
I appreciate being unable to stop during that last chorus... that last vocal by Maynard is just spectacular.
Billy, while working as Tool's guitar tech, approached Maynard and asked him to look at some of his songs. Instead of giving pointers and critique, Maynard basically said "we're starting a band." lol After working on the debut album, they asked Rob Halford (of Judas Priest) for his opinion. He listened to their tracks, then said if they released Judith as their debut single, they would sell a million albums. He was correct lol.
The song is about Maynard's mom, who had a stroke and was left paralyzed for 20 years before passing. Even though her own church disowned her, saying she deserved it because she wasn't a good enough Christian, she never lost her faith in God. This song expresses Maynard's frustration and anger at the organized religion and the god that would treat a believer like his mom was treated. This connects into the other songs 10,000 Days (about 20 years) and Wings for Marie.
Josh Freese is the genius madman beating the drums into submission. Paz Lenchatin is the enchanting bassist, formerly of the Pixies.
This is an evergreen song. I have heard it over a thousand times and I still love it.
The Outsider, The Hollow, Breña, Weak And Powerless, and Orestes are all amazing tracks from APC to check out.
you're on a level of musicianship that I could only hope to achieve but when you said "always wanting to learn" I really appreciated that and respected that statement. earned a new sub here my friend.
Thank you Mr. Hamburgler
For that hair tie scene, David Fincher had to speed up the recording of Paz putting up her hair to time it well with the music.
The end of this song gives me goosebumps even after hundreds of listens
Paz's hair tie up during the breakdown...😍
Josh Freese was the drummer and he is awesome, very underrated
Perfect Circle are the G.O.A.T. of 2000s Alt Rock
Recommend reactions to “3 Libras” or “The Doomed” by A Perfect Circle! Great songs!
I love how you just bust out the piano version at the end! Great reaction, David
Drummer is Josh Freese. He's amazing!! He plays on APC's first two records.
He's also played on countless amazing rock records from the mid 90s, into the 2000's and today, He was the go-to studio drummer of this era of rock music, and you've heard him more times than you realize.
The lyrics are actually very powerful. Judith is Mayard's mothers name, she suffered a stroke and was paralyzed the rest of her life but always remained a devout christian. He also has 2 songs from the Tool album 10,000 days that are dedicated to her. Wings for Marie (part 1), Marie is his mom's middle name, and 10,000 Days (Wings Part 2), 10,000 days or 27 years is how long she spend in a wheelchair until the time of her death.
Jimmy from ænima is part of that too
Puscifer is another Maynard's band. Check out The Humbling River for example.
One of my favorites 💕💕 thank you !!!
You should consider adding these bands to The Shed -
August Burns Red
Between the Buried and Me
Periphery
Love the band & Maynard....epic 🔥🤘🔥
My God. Song 10/10 Performance 11/10. Video Direction 10/10. Absolutely Incredible. Thanks for this reaction and analysis.
I think the drummer was in Devo. Everyone is attacking in the song. From vocals to drums, and bass. The guitars were finessed and fantastic.
Paz tying up her hair in the interlude was a super cool part.
The female bassit is Melissa Aufdemar(however its spelled)
She played and toured with other bands.including the Smashing pumpkins.she took over on machina after D'arcy quit.they both use a pick for bass by the way.
Also.
James Iha from the pumpkins is in this iteration of APC
As a carpenter, I can’t help but walk into a building and be stricken by the brilliance, or lack there of, in its construction…..I’ve never assumed what “import” this had “contextually”……After watching some of these reactors break down songs, with such proficiency, I wonder how others perceive my own contemplations about my field of work?….Anyhow, I’m jealous of their ability to instantly recognize a song, and dissect it…..BTW, Paz Lenchantin, will be forever endeared and respected for her work/art, as a member of APC….Mad respect for this collection of artists.
Fincher also directed fight club, gone girl, and seven. Some of my favorite films. He also directed the video for Only, by Nine Inch Nails.
I recommend The Outsider (live) and Three Libras (live). Both were on Jay Leno, I believe.
The story, with Billy Howardel, is that he was Tool's guitar tech for years, and slowly wrote this album over a decade. When Maynard heard the demos, he was immediately like "we're starting a band, this is amazing." I'm paraphrasing this whole story, but this record was definitely a labor of love, and one of the few records of this era that is truly timeless in rock. A lot of 2000s era heavy rock has not aged well, and is kind of cringe worthy, this is album is outside of time and a true classic.
Other women bass players of note Nikki Monniger of silversun pickups, D'Arcy Grestsky of smashing pumpkins. Lots of women bass players in rock music, they're all hot too.
Also Sean Yseult of White Zombie and my favorite, Tina Weymouth from The Talking Heads
Jo Bench for Bolt Thrower
Melissa auf der Mauer from the Pumpkins too.
emma anzai(?) from sick puppies is a great bassist as well.
Fucking BRILLIANT. Tool is a band like no other. Brilliant they are. I love all the Tool Albums and Perfect Circle Albums. First concert my husband took me too. 18 years ago. They opened up with Judith.
This is one of my all time favourite songs. I'm not heaps into the band I like alot of them but this song is fucking epic
for me on of the greatest drums section in a song ever created
The Outsider, Weak and Powerless, Thinking of You, The Package and Blue are all great songs to also check out from A Perfect Circle. Other vocalist is Billy Howerdel, who composed all the music. He was a guitar tech for Nine Inch Nails originally and wrote all this while on tour with them. Josh Freese is the drummer, and he's a living legend: Former Nine Inch Nails, The Vandals, Devo, Weezer, Guns N Roses, Suicidal Tendencies, Dwarves, and Queens of The Stone Age. He's done it all.
LOL just commented on the Schism Video about checking out Maynards 2/3 band A Perfect Circle. YAY! Now gotta do Maynards 3rd band "Puscifer" ENJOY THE RABBIT HOLE! Also more Deftones please
Josh is amazing, I saw them in 2005 and he played lefty cause he broke his leg so he switched his kit around so he could still play. Didn't miss a note.
"It's rare to see women on bass", Kim Deal, D'arcy Wretsky, Kim Gordon, Tina Weymouth, Josephine Wiggs.
I have some listening to do
How dare you forget Melissa Auf der Maur?!? /s
Yes !! One of my favorites songs of all time !!
How do riffs, get written. Brilliant, I've always refected on that in music. And yes the female energy playing bass!
Don't know if it was said, but the guitarist Billy Howerdel also sings in his other band Ashes Divide
A Perfect Circle is my favorite Maynard band. I love Tool but APC is my absolute favorite. Sheer brilliance.
Pleasure watching this
So many good songs from this band. Please try reacting to their song So Long, And Thanks For All The Fish.
Don't know if anyone else mentioned it but the band Sick Puppies has a female bass player!
Judith is Maynard's mother's name. The song is about how he can't understand continuing to have faith in God when horrible things keep happening to you despite you being a good person.
He is now, the Foo Fighters drummer.
James Iha (smashing pumpkins) and Matt McJunkins (30 seconds) part of the band too.
Loved your reaction. One band I think you will throughly enjoy, is a band The Contortionist. Particularly a song by the name of Reimagined
Josh Freese is the drummer and he's a bad ass session drummer. He also played on a 3 doors down album or two. He's been a pro since he was a kid. Amazing!
would love to see you react to their song Outsider - Stone and Echo Live at Red Rocks
Love the video, brand new sub, going back and watching a lot more and I love your style man. Keep up the great work!
Also I would love to see you tackle some of the bigger bands that for whatever reason never made it mainstream in the US. Things like Our Lady Peace - Superman's Dead (Canada) gained a little bit of popularity, but other bands like VAST (Touched would be the song from them to react to) have huge followings with unique sounds and no one knows about them. Like Porcupine Tree was barely a blip here but they have maybe the best drummer still alive today (Gavin Harrison) with a big British following and some incredible tracks like Trains and The Sound of Muzak I would love to see your take on.
And Karnivool from Australia 🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺
I Love this drummer too.... It's the little drummer boy, Josh Freese
Thanks for covering this song! Two other APC songs to consider: The Outsider, Orestes. Amazing!
Josh Freese crushes it on the kit. Badass
I think I wanted you to react to this one about his mom. His other band is Puscifer.
If you love the drums in this, I'd reccommend "The Package" by A Perfect Circle (of course). I feel like a lot of people sleep on the drums in it because of the "simplicity" (it isn't simple by any means but for non-drummers it seems passive, or thats the vibe I get from others) of the verses but when they get to the chorus' and the solo, mmmm that solo, I think you'd really enjoy it
Ooh, thank you for the heart!
I sense some Puscifer coming in soon... You're about to dive into a very deep rabbit hole which is the projects associated with MJK. Tool is just... well... nothing can ever be compared to them. I think my best possible description would be musical surgeons who dwell onto shamanism. But both APC and Puscifer are also incredible projects. You already went deep into the Jinjer rabbit hole, but this one you're about to embark, is an extremely deep one. you're in for quite the ride!
Mindless self indulgence has a female bass player. LynZ Way. She’s actually the wife of Gerard Way of My Chemical Romance. They’re an extremely unique band. Check out “Shut Me Up” by them. It Gets Worse or Ala Mode is great too. Bit more recent from them.
COTS idea: King Park by La Dispute. That sh*t is HARD.
YES! La Dispute is criminally underrated
You should do a Pusicifer song next! They just released a new album this past year.
YES...same bassist and drummer a lot of the time.
Please do anything by silversun pickups or circa survive!.
David Finches actually got his start making music videos I’m pretty sure. He directed Janies Got A Gun by Aerosmith in 89
Finally judithhh!!! 3 Libras next plsssss 🥺
I love this song my favorite song is Three Libras.
I heard a story, I believe it was from my uncle who used to tour with a band called "The Toll", about a guy who was about to play a show and he didn't have a slide but he wanted one. If I remember correctly, somebody gave him a lighter and he convincingly managed to pull off using a lighter as a slide for the show
Pointless comment, but chalk this up to one for the algorithm
I like to imagine he played a slow emotional ballad type solo, and he figured out how to use the lighter as a slide while also keeping the button depressed, thus doing his own "hold up a lighter" move to his own music in real time
Let's assume he wasn't using nylon strings, I suppose.....
Thanks for keeping up the good taste on music 😁, APC is amazing! Still!! You should check KARNIVOOL heheh 🤘
You could say a riff is the chorus but for guitar.
I played guitar with my fingers and bass guitar with a pick lol. Classical guitar was what I had in my house so finger picking just worked for that style. And pick for bass with my band because at local clubs it was hard for me to hear myself over my guitarist's amp. To be a broke teenager again with cheap equipment, you work with what ya got lol. I'd keep the treble down since the pick def took away from the deeper sound of the bass. I did things backwards I guess but it worked at the time.
Fun fact, Tim Alexander from Primus recorded the drums for this track despite their regular drummer being Josh Freese
What!!!! Really?? I had no idea about this... Who wrote the drums??
@@Obi_Wil_Kenobi I always assumes Tim wrote them. He’s one of my favorite drummers.
It's very him I can definitely hear that. I don't know him well but now you've said I can see the primus very talented drummer. Cheers for pointing that out to me. This is one of my all time favourite songs. I'm not heaps into the band or tool for that matter I like them both alot but nothing compared to how much I like this song
The guys wanted to release three libre's first as a single . But lead singer of Judas Priest told them you should release Judith first.
Dive into PUSCIFER, Maynard's other band If you want experimental Maynard. Everything from country to dub step to hard rock and electronica. Amazing harmonies with Carina Round.
Check out HUMBLING RIVER. 🤞✌
Hey man can you react to "too close to touch" 'sympathy' or 'Nerve Endings' not a lot of people know about this great band but I hope you will help them see the light
If you want to see more women bass players you should check out Sonic Youth and the Pixies. Loving the great content! Keep rocking!
Kickass Women in Rock: WHTE LUNG: the band features female drummer, bassist and vocals.
Dead Weight: ruclips.net/video/eri7Y9zrVaM/видео.html
Sister: ruclips.net/video/8fssAaJP8QY/видео.html
they are all good though
Hi! I would love to see your reaction to Maneskin, it's an Italian band that won Eurovision 2021 with a rock song, they're getting huge right now. I recommend you listen Torna a Casa, Le Parole Lontane, Coraline, and La Paura del Buio. Lyrics are in Italian but you should read the subtitles, they're amazing. I think you would like them :)
this is the only song on the album that has a swear word. probably to really drive it home. someone else already mentioned it: this song portraits his rage about the religious followers telling his mom, who was a devoted christian, that if she had a stronger believe in god, she wouldn't be paralysed.
If you like bass, do Primus. Les Claypool slappin da bass man.
Fun fact this is the only song on the album that has cuss words
Check out their song 3 Libras also. Puscifer has good songs too like The Remedy
Paz is an amazing bass player 🖤
Eric Clapton didn't play slide on Layla if that's what you're referring to, that was Dwayne Allman sitting in on Layla Eric Clapton invited him to sit in with him
Truth
This is a super group. Ppl that came together from other bands. Let’s u know how crazy Tool is. When talking about masters of their crafts.
Watched a few of your reactions and it’s all entertaining! But I had to instant sub you also when I seen your (what looks like) rug, I love that show.
Ew
Love Maynard, Tool and APC. Women bass players are sexy to me for some reason. When she ties her hair back, swings it in a head twirl and continues to kick ass on the bass= priceless.
The Package or The Noose live at Red Rocks.
Aw hell yea dude
I know its a pretty different selection compared to what you've been reacting to but you should try "hiroyuki sawano attack on titan wmid" its a track from, well, attack on titan but the production and composition is mind blowing!
anything by Hiroyuki Sawano 👍
What kinda head banging was that tho
We need a mushroom head react!!!!!!!
Ooh, love me some Maynard
A Perfect Circle is awesome! Please react to "3 Libras". :)
I personally use tortex greens for bass...but that's about as thin as I'd go.
when's the next 5 by?
For bands with only women playing rock I would suggest you to check out "Chemicals" by Conquer Divide
Puscifer - the remedy
You should listen to Talk Talk. Seeing as you are into jazz, I think you'd very much enjoy their albums Spirit of Eden and Laughing Stock...even if it's just to listen in your own time and not react to it.
Session drummer...that should explain it all.
Yeah. Maynard cheats a lot on Tool. Lol. Get to Puscifer “the remedy” next if you can.