Sitaram Yechury: Communism’s Last Hope In India | Rare Interviews | Crux Files

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
  • From working on building the coalition government in the mid-nineties to leading the CPI(M) since 2015, Sitaram Yechury has become one of the Left's most well-known faces in India today. Here’s a look at his journey from CBSE topper to CPI(M) General Secretary through a series of rare interviews.
    #SitaramYechury

Комментарии • 1,5 тыс.

  • @tusharpatil3358
    @tusharpatil3358 4 года назад +636

    Every one has Family Doctor but he has Family Interviewer Mr Karan Thapar....😂😂😂😂

    • @HS-td2jy
      @HS-td2jy 4 года назад +64

      Modi ji: Bas dosti bani rahe 🔥

    • @quire6646
      @quire6646 4 года назад +16

      Actually everyone has Karan as fam interviewer

    • @flyingafrinak6958
      @flyingafrinak6958 4 года назад +24

      Destroyer of moodiji😄😄😄

    • @flyingafrinak6958
      @flyingafrinak6958 4 года назад +2

      Modi saab modi saaab... 😄😄😄

    • @Czar_2017
      @Czar_2017 4 года назад +8

      @durga ganta nah your argument is bs bc he gave Chidambaram and many other a very hard time

  • @sathyanarayanan4171
    @sathyanarayanan4171 4 года назад +267

    *India will be either centre to left..centre..centre to right.. no extreme left or extreme right can suit India's diversity*

    • @comradebrother7411
      @comradebrother7411 4 года назад +45

      Are you a liberal....because the liberals are the ones who destroyed india.....

    • @rajeshinterpretations
      @rajeshinterpretations 4 года назад +29

      What is BJP? Is it not right wing extremist party??

    • @ishiable
      @ishiable 4 года назад +75

      @@rajeshinterpretations ypu know what right wing or left wing extremism is???
      They fucking kills everyone.
      Bjp is centrist slighly leaning towards right.
      Same for congress in left.
      But communist party is extremely left.
      Thats why they are left out of India lol

    • @abhayn1895
      @abhayn1895 4 года назад +49

      @@rajeshinterpretations bro do you what right and left is.Rights are more conservative,they don't want change and and firm with the roots.Bjp is right but isn't extreme.you can take yesterday's hindu succession act(amendment)an extreme right would have never tolerated that.At the same time abrogation 360 is a systematic change.History proves that extreme rightist avoid such reforms also the NRC and caa excluding minority of other countries was a soft right act.Triple talaqs abolition was a left act.One needs to understand bjp is right leaning but the same time open for changes

    • @MatrixP777
      @MatrixP777 4 года назад +8

      @@comradebrother7411 liberals are centric if you see those left wing calling themselves liberals.. youre just brainwashed

  • @jayasree6722
    @jayasree6722 4 года назад +320

    He is comparing his 100year ideology to 3000 years Veda ...

    • @jayasree6722
      @jayasree6722 4 года назад +73

      @@agneebh23 3000 years old doesn't mean it written in 3000 years ago... it has the experience of 3000 years not written as single piece...if you are a Indian read any one of them you will understand that it's nothing to do with religion it's just information current generation can also use .
      And read communist manifesto and thus capital you will understand the dept Vedas have over this narrow idiology of communism...I am not saying vadas are perfect it also written by human...

    • @jayasree6722
      @jayasree6722 4 года назад +40

      @@agneebh23 Vedas say questions everything....so I choose that and as I say it's not perfect....

    • @jayasree6722
      @jayasree6722 4 года назад +26

      @Arjun Sharma communism is creation of slaves for the elite...the defects in Hindustan can be changed (question every thing is the Piller of hindusam )but communist idiology can't change...

    • @JJ-hm9ni
      @JJ-hm9ni 3 года назад +3

      @@jayasree6722 why cannot it change?the manifestos were also written by humans and can be modified if shortcomings are seen

    • @jayasree6722
      @jayasree6722 3 года назад +3

      @@JJ-hm9nibasics can't be changed killing political enimy, is one of them so what your saying...? (But basic of Hindusam is question everything)

  • @bhagyaharilal4927
    @bhagyaharilal4927 4 года назад +107

    Coorporates will not fund them .

    • @shekarnt
      @shekarnt 4 года назад +43

      Funding them is "suicide".

  • @tusharpatil3358
    @tusharpatil3358 4 года назад +58

    6:10....Face palm movement to sitaram 😂😂😂

    • @KuchBhi-xs5oe
      @KuchBhi-xs5oe 3 месяца назад

      Bro didn't expect that one coming

  • @Ashishkumar-ui8rp
    @Ashishkumar-ui8rp 3 года назад +51

    I simply can't get it
    "Is there any sense of being communist in a democracy " .

    • @ayush885
      @ayush885 3 года назад +25

      If they win in any state ( Kerala ), they impose extreme checks and balances on private corporations, and try to take everything under state control.
      This does improve the healthcare and education of the state, but it also scares away private corporations, thus creating unemployment. It is sustainable if the state receives funding from outside, but not if the state needs to generate its own revenue.

    • @yatha3024
      @yatha3024 3 года назад +3

      @@ayush885 the economy depending on money coming from outside is not sustainable at all

    • @ayush885
      @ayush885 3 года назад +3

      @@yatha3024 Kerala and WB aren't sustainable. The communist governments have destroyed these two states which were once the richest regions of India.

    • @Chaos_152
      @Chaos_152 3 года назад +6

      @@ayush885 have you ever studied history dude. When India got independence Kerala was the poorest state of India, even appearing in New York Times newspaper and now it is substantiate

    • @sanketghorpade9805
      @sanketghorpade9805 3 года назад +2

      @@Chaos_152 le jharkhand and bihar and west bengal which faced the worst famine in the human history -- mai job chod du?

  • @RS7o7
    @RS7o7 4 года назад +58

    SITARAM ACHURI IS POLITICAL MORAN,, COMMUNIST IS CLOSED CHAPTER IN INDIAN POLTICS WHICH IS GOOD SINES TO INDIAN POLTICS..

    • @rajat_x_x_x6818
      @rajat_x_x_x6818 4 года назад +9

      bro spelling toh thik likh leta lol

    • @rajatmishra4889
      @rajatmishra4889 4 года назад +3

      But the rise of RSS is not good sign for Indian democracy

    • @rajatmishra4889
      @rajatmishra4889 3 года назад

      @Studies Only if it is at 1st place then it will be at last also........the rise and fall happen in democracy...

  • @malaykumarnayak2335
    @malaykumarnayak2335 2 года назад +29

    Communist ideology be like:- a outdated cheque on a bank Crushing Bank 😂

  • @mechietech5176
    @mechietech5176 4 года назад +25

    He is an intelligent guy, although red isn't my color, but we must pay close attention his thoughts and remarks

  • @sherlockholmes6345
    @sherlockholmes6345 4 года назад +56

    They are not going anywhere, at least in Kerala.....It's because in my state they are the leading players in religious and cast politics. And they are in favour of capitalism.

    • @JJ-hm9ni
      @JJ-hm9ni 3 года назад +11

      They are in favour of capitalism??They are waiting for the neoliberal order to collapse onto itself

    • @aathirapillai4788
      @aathirapillai4788 3 года назад +9

      @@JJ-hm9ni No No you don't get it. what he meant was they favor capitalism in the family, or beneficial to the family ..If it's for people's good please don't count communists..

    • @rawmist
      @rawmist 3 года назад +4

      എന്നെങ്കിലും രക്ഷപെടും കേരളം 👀

    • @xiijinpingthesupremeleader1349
      @xiijinpingthesupremeleader1349 2 года назад +2

      @@rawmist Kerala will survive forever, but not the communist party.

    • @rawmist
      @rawmist 2 года назад

      @@xiijinpingthesupremeleader1349 hope👀 youth full sfi de purake alle keralathil

  • @rajatmishra4889
    @rajatmishra4889 4 года назад +3

    Sitaram Yechury is good leader

  • @himanshusingh-er7dd
    @himanshusingh-er7dd 4 года назад +34

    He is actually china's last hope!

  • @socialistsolidarity
    @socialistsolidarity 2 года назад +3

    Long live the Communist Party of India ☭ 🚩✊🏽

  • @AB-jw3mz
    @AB-jw3mz 4 года назад +30

    his name should be immediately changed to JIANG MAO YECHURY to be in sync with his belief system. Or PENG XI YECHURY if he wants to roll with the times.

  • @SKD1947
    @SKD1947 3 года назад +16

    A great, mature parliamentarian👍🌸

  • @frederickjohn2327
    @frederickjohn2327 4 года назад +6

    Comrade sitharam Yechuri 💓🚩

  • @themastibazz
    @themastibazz 4 года назад +5

    👏We👏need👏new👏leaders👏

  • @harikishoreanimireddy8153
    @harikishoreanimireddy8153 4 года назад +5

    I have a question for him if he doesn't believe in God why didn't he change his name (he has the liberty to do) to Lenin/Stalin/Mao, etc...or He didn't change his name to dominate the debate when required with his name?

  • @pkrpkr9816
    @pkrpkr9816 16 дней назад +1

    Sitharam..❤

  • @parvadhami980
    @parvadhami980 2 года назад +1

    6:00 Kanhaiya Kumar realised this and hence, he joined Congress from the CPI.

  • @akbrahma7739
    @akbrahma7739 3 года назад +1

    Growing up in a communist state, I can say onething, Communism is not for the weak hearted, a left chairman must rule with an iron fist, using terror and discipline if needs be. USSR was strongest under Stalin who used terror and splintered under the liberal Gorbachev. Similarly under Jyoti Basu, no one in Bengal had the guts to question the government, unless you wanna go missing, under the liberal Buddhadeb Dasgupta, the party crumbled and withered away. If the All India Communist party's reigns would've been given to Basu instead of this clown, India would've been a red country today.

  • @akarshshekhar5233
    @akarshshekhar5233 3 года назад +3

    Communism has no hope in India.

  • @ajaxhost6950
    @ajaxhost6950 4 года назад +34

    China : haha humara betaa !! Humara beta !!

  • @adarshsasindran6214
    @adarshsasindran6214 16 дней назад

    Rest in Power Comrade.

  • @wanderer4693
    @wanderer4693 4 года назад +17

    SOON THIS PARTY WILL BE WIPED OUT FROM INDIA .

  • @frenzyking4649
    @frenzyking4649 4 года назад +5

    Lal salam❤❤❤❤❤

  • @dipanjandasgupta6170
    @dipanjandasgupta6170 4 года назад +4

    Wish youtube had laugh react

  • @thebrownengine9222
    @thebrownengine9222 3 года назад +529

    Interviewer: Why are you selectively secular against Hindus?
    "But my name is Sitaram"

    • @thebrownengine9222
      @thebrownengine9222 3 года назад +72

      @Apoorv Lawande and then you meet the fate of rinku Sharma in secular india

    • @itsAreeb
      @itsAreeb 3 года назад +12

      @@thebrownengine9222 Delhi police have clarified it was not anything communal

    • @thebrownengine9222
      @thebrownengine9222 3 года назад +73

      @@itsAreeb and the police also said it wasn't a communal lynching of aklaq. He was suspected of trying to steal a bike. But because he was peaceful he got the attention and now when someone intolerant gets killed, no one cares and people like you who ignored the police on aklaq now become the flag bearers of police justice.

    • @itsAreeb
      @itsAreeb 3 года назад +6

      @@thebrownengine9222 stop misleading people there is even an Wikipedia article on akhlaq mob lynching
      You can even watch vox's documentary on mob lynching

    • @thebrownengine9222
      @thebrownengine9222 3 года назад +47

      @@itsAreeb you are my living proof. You prove me right. Believe the police but only in certain situations. My secular India ❤️

  • @pk9392
    @pk9392 4 года назад +325

    the ias officer prophecy indeed became a reality

    • @vivekghodvinde
      @vivekghodvinde 4 года назад +70

      I was searching for the same. And u r the first to talk abt it.
      IAS officer was absolutely right.
      CPI talks abt progressive thiking bt make no progress in their way of thinking and ideology.
      No wonder they are going downhill.
      And i don't see young minds accepting their ideology except in JNU and JU.

    • @harishkiran3663
      @harishkiran3663 4 года назад +43

      @@vivekghodvinde They are hand in glove with islamic extremists and even have an ex SIMI member as minister in Kerala, importing quran from UAE illegally along with gold smuggling, narcotics and terror funding!

    • @savithajagadeesh2139
      @savithajagadeesh2139 3 года назад +7

      @@harishkiran3663 what nonsense!

    • @yash-lu7qp
      @yash-lu7qp 3 года назад +1

      @@vivekghodvinde Is Kerala in JNU or JU?

    • @vivekghodvinde
      @vivekghodvinde 3 года назад +4

      @@yash-lu7qp are u trying to be sarcastic or what ?

  • @vadirajsreedhara5075
    @vadirajsreedhara5075 4 года назад +348

    His own daughter counting dollars in USA
    She is professor in some us university
    Why can't she come to india and teach in govt schools?
    Bigot comrades

    • @flyingafrinak6958
      @flyingafrinak6958 4 года назад +44

      Bhakths who danced for howdy modi should also return

    • @anuragyaparlaaa
      @anuragyaparlaaa 4 года назад +38

      Its him who's in politics not her.
      He has not stopped his daughter to form her own opinion and that is what's most important here.

    • @sayamsiddha5852
      @sayamsiddha5852 4 года назад +7

      You say that as you jail professors in India?!

    • @indirasawhney7301
      @indirasawhney7301 4 года назад +70

      @@anuragyaparlaaa he couldn't even convince his own daughter about his communist ideology. How will he even convince other Indians?😂😂😂

    • @mylifemyrule4580
      @mylifemyrule4580 4 года назад +17

      I mean what does he have to with where his daughter works?
      You know Mr. Sitaram Yechuri does not look like a strict father who wants to stick to the principles of patriarchy and control her daughter's ambitions

  • @the_dead_poet7829
    @the_dead_poet7829 4 года назад +274

    As a life-long student.of history, I find these CRUX files very informative and of course entertaining... Very good job done,.all your videos in this series are perfect. 10/10

    • @amishbhadwa7104
      @amishbhadwa7104 3 года назад +4

      They are Baised towards BJP
      They don't show news Which Go against BJP

    • @gottlobfreige1075
      @gottlobfreige1075 3 года назад

      Agreed!

    • @jayeshmonlbs
      @jayeshmonlbs 3 года назад

      @@amishbhadwa7104 ji

    • @user-vh1gc1ct6z
      @user-vh1gc1ct6z 2 года назад

      @BBTG Official Kanhaiya Kumar always exhibits हग (hug) life

  • @goribmanus3284
    @goribmanus3284 4 года назад +438

    I am from West Bengal and I am sure that CPI will not get any seat in state election...

    • @venkateshvs8952
      @venkateshvs8952 4 года назад +35

      True bro

    • @Inversed00
      @Inversed00 4 года назад +63

      Elect anyone, but please remove didi

    • @goribmanus3284
      @goribmanus3284 4 года назад +53

      @@Inversed00 yes bro...I am also not happy with her administration...There is great chance in 2021 election that she will loose..

    • @binayakbanerjee4238
      @binayakbanerjee4238 4 года назад +18

      @Dupe Shots Her party's policy is very much similar to that of the communists.

    • @vivekpandit2190
      @vivekpandit2190 4 года назад +16

      @@binayakbanerjee4238 ummm I think she is female version of bjp

  • @rl1900
    @rl1900 4 года назад +403

    Well the prophecy By that IAS officer has certainly came to be true

    • @Suryapoosarla
      @Suryapoosarla 3 года назад +23

      @@guts2008 may be you need to watch again..

    • @itsAreeb
      @itsAreeb 3 года назад +17

      @Ajey Chahal woo to you who can't even tolerate others political beliefs

    • @omkar1275
      @omkar1275 3 года назад +37

      He brought it to himself should have listened to IAS officer and adopted China like Communist model with Capitalism playing main role!! But certainly now he is Irrelevant Even his star Model Kanhaiya lost badly 😂🤣

    • @bloodwargaming3662
      @bloodwargaming3662 3 года назад +8

      Lol 🤣🤣🤣 kya kuch bhi .alll the ultra capitalism countries have problems like 3rd world ones just it is not shown

    • @itsAreeb
      @itsAreeb 3 года назад +2

      @Antares what's problem with being a communist and a Hindu

  • @sreenath.3510
    @sreenath.3510 4 года назад +353

    China's last hope in India!!!
    Is right.

    • @sreenath.3510
      @sreenath.3510 4 года назад +4

      @Keshav 😃

    • @arpitsingh4120
      @arpitsingh4120 4 года назад +12

      Not china... RUSSIA. Russia brought communism in India.

    • @arpitsingh4120
      @arpitsingh4120 4 года назад +2

      SubhrD Deb yes, same. Back when it was all soviet union.

    • @sreenath.3510
      @sreenath.3510 4 года назад +23

      @@arpitsingh4120 China too conspires with Indian communists.Even recently Cpm backed china in Doklam and ladak standoff.

    • @architjain8715
      @architjain8715 4 года назад +5

      @@sreenath.3510 And not surprisingly, many of the opposition leaders followed them.

  • @vaibhavgupta7584
    @vaibhavgupta7584 4 года назад +244

    asks him any question:
    But my name is Sitaram

  • @himanshupatel9633
    @himanshupatel9633 4 года назад +260

    No hope for communism in a democracy, Great regime on paper but worst regime to follow. He is really educated but influenced by wrong regime because he only studied it but he needs to know that these utopian regimes will never survive in India.

    • @Kumar-fg1cj
      @Kumar-fg1cj 4 года назад +15

      haha.....there is hope in communism ask china

    • @ishiable
      @ishiable 4 года назад +43

      @@Kumar-fg1cj china is communist??
      Educate yourself.
      Thier parties name is communist party.
      BUT CHINA IS SOCIALIST AND CAPITALISTIC ECONOMY.
      Not communust
      They still believe in communism.
      But they know they cant develop with fully communist economy, everybody knows communism is worst for development

    • @Kumar-fg1cj
      @Kumar-fg1cj 4 года назад +9

      @@ishiable thank you .....but still their government have the vision to make China a superpower country till 2035. This is what a stable government can do . which only can happen in communist countries.

    • @sandipanbhowmick8214
      @sandipanbhowmick8214 4 года назад +29

      @@Kumar-fg1cj democracy is far better. Democracy allows us to enjoy the freedom.
      US Vs USSR is biggest example that Democracy and transparency in system can win over communism

    • @abhinavbaad3075
      @abhinavbaad3075 4 года назад +4

      @@Kumar-fg1cj at the expense of freedom , India better be soft power democracy than super power with communist

  • @pratyushshrivastava2647
    @pratyushshrivastava2647 4 года назад +250

    IAS officer at 5:52 was soooooo right.

    • @piyush8372
      @piyush8372 4 года назад +23

      He at 12:37 is also sooooooo right.

    • @piyush8372
      @piyush8372 4 года назад +4

      @Aditya Kulkarni Give yourself a couple of years. It will take time for people like you to get a hold of whats actually going on.

    • @piyush8372
      @piyush8372 4 года назад +6

      @Aditya Kulkarni Which communist text have you read..? You seem to know a lot about these "Commies".

    • @piyush8372
      @piyush8372 4 года назад +4

      @Aditya Kulkarni Forget history read english first. And i know i don't need to talk to someone who starts off with "i don't need to read". Read, even if you are reading manusmriti, read, not for me but for you.

    • @143varunsherke2
      @143varunsherke2 4 года назад +23

      @Aditya Kulkarni tell me the name of atleast one developed country which is communist.

  • @KrishnaKishorealisetty
    @KrishnaKishorealisetty 4 года назад +44

    He is saying, he studied all Vedas. It takes nearly to 32 years to study only, not to completely understand. May be this fellow studied in a hurry to complete. That is the problem.

    • @The-Cosmos
      @The-Cosmos 4 месяца назад +1

      Have you yourself read them?

  • @suryanarayanav3309
    @suryanarayanav3309 4 года назад +36

    So BA and MA in economics and still a communist? What economics are they teaching 😂

  • @nikhilisatitagain
    @nikhilisatitagain 4 года назад +66

    5:52 That guy was true, fortunately or unfortunately

  • @editpapa9671
    @editpapa9671 4 года назад +373

    the real development of a country shows the happiness of their own people but can't say about Communism because Communism always grows on the loss of people.

  • @imtiaz7063
    @imtiaz7063 2 года назад +6

    People in India are now facing the consequences of extreme capitalism. Rich got richer ,the wealth of Indians has gone into few elites. If communism is outdated why China is the world's second largest economy?

    • @AtheistNationalist
      @AtheistNationalist 9 месяцев назад +3

      Anyone who thinks China is communist should go back to 9th grade and pick up a history book

    • @KuchBhi-xs5oe
      @KuchBhi-xs5oe 5 месяцев назад

      China has more private companies than India Chinese military industry is owned by private people don't know which comrade said you china is communist

  • @thebrownengine9222
    @thebrownengine9222 3 года назад +15

    13:03
    The party has a democratic vote
    They vote out communism 😂

  • @sreeinsreedhar1931
    @sreeinsreedhar1931 4 года назад +15

    Lal Salam Comrade ❤️

  • @bahubalilangdatyaagi8664
    @bahubalilangdatyaagi8664 3 года назад +14

    I want this man's confidence to have a pony tail without hair on his head 😊😂

  • @white4392
    @white4392 4 года назад +10

    Well I grew up in calcutta west bengal, I have seen ups and downs of communism in west bengal. I carry huge respect for Jyoti Basu, Buddhadeb Bhattacharya and other political leaders like subhas Chakrabarti, Anil Biswas, somnath somnath Chatterjee. Well I grew up in a left culture. Anyway I am not a member of any Communist parties.
    Honestly saying why communism faild in India because of there are too many roots, division, too many parties, like CPI/CPM, too many democratic front, forword Bloc, even there are too many labour unions as well.
    So it's a hell of a confusion. You guys need to change this. In current situation updation is much required.
    You have to aligned in one.
    You guys need to be more nationalist, I never seen any communist leaders like sitaram yachuri, Prakash Karat, Jyoti basu, Vijayan, D.Raja, Buddhadeb Bhattacharya never comments on Indian defence, Army. Like Cuba, Vietnam, china do.
    Main thing needs to be followed forget what revelution happened in 1918. You have to stop thinking what USSR did, how America lost veitnam.
    You have to show and you guys should lecture about many indian revelutionery like bhagat singh, master da Surya Sen, Ganesh Ghosh etc. They used to believe in communism.
    Well another thing is that you guys should focus on Indian communism.
    Forget foreign communism like Vietnam, Cuba.
    Also note you have to give chance to youth as well, that is the main thing.
    Still in west bengal biman basu, Surya Kanta Mishra,they are holding the seats. No new faces in politburo. You have to analyse why vast students from jnu, Jadavpur presidency University, delhi university who used to follow SFI,All india student federation where they going after they passed out from university. Why these left ideology students are not getting attrected in politics.
    Also please be precise like you guys showing anger and protesting for George Floyd but you guys don't do how chinise are showing brutality in Hongkong and South China sea. This is hypocrite things
    These are the simple things needs to work on.

  • @RameshR-to5xn
    @RameshR-to5xn 3 года назад +6

    ലാൽ സലാം സഖാവേ 🔥🔥🔥🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩

  • @abhinavbaad3075
    @abhinavbaad3075 4 года назад +57

    His utter silence on china is just thing not to believe on communism .
    He literally defended Tiananmen Massacre in JNU. Watch his scoopwhoop interview if you don't believe.

    • @sumanbaral8457
      @sumanbaral8457 4 года назад

      And I dont understand why would democracy and its brokers in India have never demanded an apology from colonial powers for killing millions of people and enslaving generations and on ?? (Koreans have made Japanese do that)
      They will never cause they have been trying to enslave their own people in the name of democracy and parliamentary system...
      Democracy: native version of colonialism and slavery

    • @abhinavbaad3075
      @abhinavbaad3075 4 года назад +5

      @@sumanbaral8457 😂😂 democracy can change regime communism can't change regime eg . North Korea , china.

    • @pulkitkumar449
      @pulkitkumar449 4 года назад

      @@sumanbaral8457 are you fool

    • @flyingafrinak6958
      @flyingafrinak6958 4 года назад

      Why modi is silent about china?

    • @flyingafrinak6958
      @flyingafrinak6958 4 года назад

      Modi cannot utter the word china

  • @anandms7537
    @anandms7537 4 года назад +80

    @6:02 we Indians need really this kind of intelligent IAS officers who has tremendous amount of knowledge in economics

    • @anirudhakulkarni9134
      @anirudhakulkarni9134 3 года назад +12

      No need of Economic knowledge,we just need to reason everything...and not follow it blindly falling for emotions

    • @KuchBhi-xs5oe
      @KuchBhi-xs5oe 3 месяца назад

      We also need to learn from countries who have implemented communism or socialism and failed miserably we should educated ourselves on other countries economic policies and their history and learn from it

  • @o17sagnikdas11
    @o17sagnikdas11 3 года назад +22

    In West Bengal, Left has got 0 seats out of 294 assembly election seats in 2021. In this state left was in power for 34 years (1977-2011).They have destroyed the lives of the people of Bengal. So they got a grand prize from us 😊😊😊

  • @bileyroy9609
    @bileyroy9609 4 года назад +4

    Neither communism nor capatalism Gandhism is the best solution to India

  • @DeepakKumar-uj6br
    @DeepakKumar-uj6br 4 года назад +13

    Yes we saw how it worked for india economically for 40years.. and how it worked for west bengal 😂😂😂... I wonder how this guy can even say communism is future with straight face 😂

    • @TheFutureBeat
      @TheFutureBeat 2 года назад

      it is the future the capitalist empire will collapse soon

  • @vrooms12
    @vrooms12 4 года назад +10

    Yechury your weakness was having Karat as Party Secretary, he is a rudderless ideologue.

  • @imnobd8757
    @imnobd8757 9 месяцев назад +14

    Communism will never die, even if we die, we'll die fighting the fascist BJP, A BETTER WORLD IS POSSIBLE

  • @alviprasadabburu5226
    @alviprasadabburu5226 4 года назад +12

    Rupashree nanda and karan Thapar only interviewed sitaram...

  • @suhaspatil2053
    @suhaspatil2053 4 года назад +43

    Mr modi and Mr shah has shown right place for Cpm and Mr Yechury 😶

  • @abuthahir6056
    @abuthahir6056 4 года назад +49

    Iam from Kerala
    The first place where communsium came through democracy
    Cpi and cpim have very good history in Kerala even BJP also salute that.
    Now days also they build 3 laks of home by life mission for poor people
    They build government schools and hospital for people not temple and masjid
    In this corona season they give food for everyone by community kitchens
    Covid 19 treatment is completely free for everyone and everyone are equally treated here that why we flatten the curve

    • @abuthahir6056
      @abuthahir6056 4 года назад

      Lisern what American media's says
      ruclips.net/video/7AGI6qVVmpo/видео.html

    • @abuthahir6056
      @abuthahir6056 4 года назад +11

      Land reform bill is introduced by ems Nabuthirpadu he passed that bill in assembly but nehru government overthrow cpi government .(greatest black mark) and after cpi again come into power ,c Achudhamenon was implement that low which put end to the fudal system

    • @Sweatcheck69
      @Sweatcheck69 2 года назад

      Communists are worst than Traitors because they'll kill anyone standing in their way. Communism means even your thoughts belong to the Party. CPIM has more Allegiance to China than India. These commie scum live in India but suck on China

    • @martinsam8787
      @martinsam8787 2 года назад +3

      @@abuthahir6056 so congres too ruled kerala so many times they had 4 cheif minsters what is the contribution of Congress led UDF in kerala

    • @bluecolour8889
      @bluecolour8889 2 года назад +10

      Not communism, say anti-hinduism. First Indian lefties should atleast properly know the meaning of 'leftism'

  • @bastabbiswas3885
    @bastabbiswas3885 3 года назад +14

    Topper in CBSE, President of JNUSU.
    His senior communist comrades are his professors !
    Of course he will be topper.

  • @abhijeetshetty5950
    @abhijeetshetty5950 4 года назад +32

    Idk why even I am seeing this video.

    • @siddhantsingh7606
      @siddhantsingh7606 4 года назад +3

      Because he's so obscure to the masses that no common man know about him in the north

    • @ayushsrivastava1672
      @ayushsrivastava1672 3 года назад +4

      It's actually interesting to see the mindset of your opponents. You get to know much more about them

    • @KuchBhi-xs5oe
      @KuchBhi-xs5oe 5 месяцев назад

      I see videos on leftist because comments there are more interesting and attention catching than ancient leftist leaders like seriously almost all left leaders look like they met Lenin personally

  • @rahulsabale6526
    @rahulsabale6526 4 года назад +23

    India can not be developed without aggressive economic programs. We need all sorts of reforms but while doing this i pray for the presence of strong communist leaders. I know communism is useless when given power to implement development programs but what they are good at is pointing at faults and raising issues that affects the common man on ground level who is residing in bharat and aspires to be a part of india.

  • @bantaibabafan1167
    @bantaibabafan1167 4 года назад +60

    The communist govt of west bengal and kerala have implemented the land reforms act well, panchayath system etc .

    • @dawndusk1082
      @dawndusk1082 4 года назад +3

      Well said

    • @shekarnt
      @shekarnt 4 года назад +5

      So in Karnataka. Congress government under devaraj urs.

    • @subscriberwithoutanyvide-rq5ym
      @subscriberwithoutanyvide-rq5ym 4 года назад +16

      *By taking away lands from other people without even paying them

    • @gokulpunnikrishnan4380
      @gokulpunnikrishnan4380 4 года назад +6

      Not really bro, land reforms act was finally implemented in kerala by congress front . CPI had been with congress back then while CPIM was on the opposite front. So technically congress + CPI front implemented it. CPIM the dominant communist party now had been on opposition back then.

    • @gokulpunnikrishnan4380
      @gokulpunnikrishnan4380 4 года назад +4

      @@subscriberwithoutanyvide-rq5ym how did it become higher caste's land ? Land ceiling is one of the basic feature of social justice. Higher castes who kept education and professional jobs for themselves for centuries are now unabashedly whining that those were their land. They are ignorant about the historical fact that those lands had been cultivated by bahujans as a kind of forced labour without even getting wages.

  • @frenzyking4649
    @frenzyking4649 4 года назад +9

    Lal salam❤❤❤❤

  • @ajaytjosephyourmentor8773
    @ajaytjosephyourmentor8773 4 года назад +29

    A pragmatic politician, but yet to contest in a parliamentary election 🤔

    • @vaibhavsrivastava655
      @vaibhavsrivastava655 4 года назад +14

      Electoral politics is not something that left believes, they believe in dictatorship of proletariat that's why hypocrites like sitaram can't win an mp seat.

  • @comradebrother7411
    @comradebrother7411 4 года назад +9

    I had a look in the comment section and I discovered that people don't know the differences between maoism and Marxism....

    • @vertex_gaming
      @vertex_gaming 4 года назад +4

      both are failed. without freedom you're nothing

    • @vertex_gaming
      @vertex_gaming 4 года назад +5

      communists are the murderers.
      Stalin killed 1.5 crores. Mao killed 3 crore people.

    • @vertex_gaming
      @vertex_gaming 4 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/LNml4ZyfwOo/видео.html

    • @xeno4162
      @xeno4162 2 года назад

      @@vertex_gaming 20 million die under capitalism every year, you realise how many unjust wars were waged by these capitalist nations and how many innocents they killed?
      Don't come at me with casualties

    • @KuchBhi-xs5oe
      @KuchBhi-xs5oe 3 месяца назад

      Both are trash and both policies lead to death toll of total of 110 million (conservative figures) actual figures might be 130-140 million

  • @rajmovies89
    @rajmovies89 4 года назад +8

    Make video about Pinarayi Vijayan

  • @pundlik9012
    @pundlik9012 4 года назад +13

    pls we want a video on manohar parrikar. we loved him and he was also very influential
    **thank you crux **

  • @ninjaman5229
    @ninjaman5229 3 года назад +39

    6:14, wow! Loved the way he said "I AM AN IAS OFFICER"😎

    • @foryou1080
      @foryou1080 3 года назад +2

      @Sachin then why sitaram didn't answer?

    • @spacegarage6826
      @spacegarage6826 3 года назад +1

      @Sachin logic is chutiyapa in the eyes of leftists anyway

    • @Sweatcheck69
      @Sweatcheck69 2 года назад

      @@foryou1080 Because the IAS officer destroyed Yechury in one go. Communists are worst than Traitors because they'll kill anyone standing in their way. Communism means even your thoughts belong to the Party. CPIM has more Allegiance to China than India. These commie scum live in India but suck on China

  • @awesomevideo5525
    @awesomevideo5525 3 года назад +9

    In scoopwhoop interview he told "he is loyal to china than india. End of story. No more discussion on this 😂

    • @ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ
      @ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ 3 года назад +2

      Is that real? If so then he's the worst kind of ideological leech...

    • @hyronium5752
      @hyronium5752 3 года назад +2

      @@ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ no bro in india there is A BIASED hatred against cpim

    • @ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ
      @ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ 3 года назад +3

      @@hyronium5752 There's biased hatred against every party. That's part and parcel of politics. No sympathies for politicians...

    • @ankitaharwal5886
      @ankitaharwal5886 2 года назад

      ​@@hyronium5752 cpim created by kgb, no respect for them

  • @Machaivelli
    @Machaivelli 4 года назад +19

    The man who singlehandedly ensured that commies are wiped off from india thanks to clinging onto his own utopia
    People like us who want commies to GTFO from the country certainly applaud his hidden talent 😂😂😂

    • @Sweatcheck69
      @Sweatcheck69 2 года назад

      Communists are worst than Traitors. CPIM has more Allegiance to China than India. These commies scum live in India but suck on China

    • @toiletmemes4937
      @toiletmemes4937 Год назад

      👍👍❤️❤️

  • @karanraj9237
    @karanraj9237 2 года назад +3

    You have ruled 35 long year in West Bengal dumped the Bengal in dustbin of poverty

  • @bantaibabafan1167
    @bantaibabafan1167 4 года назад +26

    Communism is still there in kerala and the previous communist govts did excellent job and they have played an imp role in making kerala as one of the best states in india

    • @dawndusk1082
      @dawndusk1082 4 года назад +3

      💯

    • @bantaibabafan1167
      @bantaibabafan1167 4 года назад +2

      @Shashank Royal t let them laugh . If u r not aware of that then i can't do anything😋

    • @bantaibabafan1167
      @bantaibabafan1167 4 года назад

      @Devesh Gupta yes .just give me a list of all the negative things about kerala.
      Its comparatively the safest state in india and the most peaceful state.i do't certificate from u people because i know about my land better than u😂

    • @bantaibabafan1167
      @bantaibabafan1167 4 года назад

      @Guru let them go .they hav the skills to do the job .so they r going

    • @bantaibabafan1167
      @bantaibabafan1167 4 года назад +1

      @Guru unemployment is a major problem here .so they r going.that's the reason why the people in kerala has big homes(not every one).kerala is most densely populated man.

  • @satabdeesahoo
    @satabdeesahoo 17 дней назад +2

    may he rest in peace

  • @akhilgeorge444
    @akhilgeorge444 4 года назад +10

    3:08 ... Dhey namude CM..

  • @niranjankumar-hv9hh
    @niranjankumar-hv9hh 3 года назад +2

    Then how come ldf is still ruiling kerala??wat special ..any mallu there??sangis dont reply

    • @sudarspkd
      @sudarspkd 3 года назад

      Simple ,Communal appeasement and exploitation aided by clueless Congress.

  • @TKV007
    @TKV007 4 года назад +46

    A leader of vision with the spirit of great India is yet to be born.

  • @harilapadarosa2188
    @harilapadarosa2188 4 года назад +11

    Pinarayi Vijayan says Hi

  • @swastikshrivastava939
    @swastikshrivastava939 4 года назад +56

    Keeping apart the Communist Idealogy.
    He's a well read and a learned person and since for a healthy functioning democracy, it is important for all voices to be heard, he's a good voice from the left. Happy Birthday Mr. Yechury may you live a long life.

    • @k.bhavithkumar5708
      @k.bhavithkumar5708 4 года назад +5

      Yeah ,he is only gud when in opposition.
      If they come into power they themselves will try to remove opposition.

    • @shrikantyadav9248
      @shrikantyadav9248 4 года назад +2

      You are totally right.

  • @opedsk
    @opedsk 12 дней назад +2

    Under his great leadership the party was reduced to only Kerala 😆

  • @jajgandhi7947
    @jajgandhi7947 4 года назад +10

    The communism of india is good for our country's development

    • @acchamthavir8488
      @acchamthavir8488 4 года назад +6

      Can you name one developed communist country??

    • @NehaThakur-hm8nl
      @NehaThakur-hm8nl 4 года назад

      @@acchamthavir8488 cuba .china ,even ussr (russia) r some example of developed countries

    • @k.bhavithkumar5708
      @k.bhavithkumar5708 4 года назад +5

      @@NehaThakur-hm8nl idiot.
      Cuba is not a developed country.ussr is a classical example of failed communist nation.
      Speaking of china,yes china developed inbterms of econimic ,infrastructure and also uplifted a lot from poverty.however living in china is like living in a golden cage .u hav all the facilities yet u are a caged bird without freedom.if u want that type of development u can choose china.

    • @acchamthavir8488
      @acchamthavir8488 4 года назад +3

      @@k.bhavithkumar5708 I agree with you on cuba and russia.. but china is a namesake communist.. in worlds 100 wealthiest person more than 25 are from china.. if its a communist nation then how its possible🤣🤣

    • @acchamthavir8488
      @acchamthavir8488 4 года назад +1

      @@NehaThakur-hm8nl cuba developed seriously🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @shubhamgiri1926
    @shubhamgiri1926 4 года назад +25

    Bang on💥💥 ...When an IAS speaks

  • @indradeb8482
    @indradeb8482 4 года назад +7

    Except for Tripura and Kerala there r some follower left for the left. Otherwise it's a failed story Comrades!

    • @anesh.red.comrade
      @anesh.red.comrade 4 года назад

      @Guru No you are wrong about it, communist party not against private firms, they said In current context of heavy unemployment in India , government sectors are not enough ,need private sectors involvement also.

    • @anesh.red.comrade
      @anesh.red.comrade 4 года назад

      @Guru This quoted text from 2014 election manifesto Cpi(m)
      "Encouraging small and medium enterprises in labour intensive sectors with adequate incentives, infrastructure support and sufficient credit from banks
      • Protecting of domestic industry from indiscriminate lowering of import duties and takeover of existing Indian companies by foreign companies; Encouraging the private sector to invest in manufacturing and services sectors; providing incentives to the private sector linked to job creation and R&D efforts"
      www.news18.com/news/politics/cpim-promises-full-employment-public-investments-in-its-manifesto-675790.html
      What you say?

    • @anesh.red.comrade
      @anesh.red.comrade 4 года назад

      @Guru CPI(Marxist) are follows Marxian thoughts with Leninist party structure.As per Marx " The only thing that doesn't change is change "
      So people who never changes according to time/by surrounding change is not a Marxist. The kerala goverment itself formed KIIFB a formed state registered company and taking foreign investment to build infrastructures. But CPI(M) opposed fdi in certain sectors mainly for central owned sectors recently coal mining sectors.
      I studied about Cuba, recently Venezuela , they nationalize all private firms socialist model by Chavez, without analysing properly, but failed ultimately due to deep steap in oil in world market , America,CIA imperialism.

    • @haripriyav1868
      @haripriyav1868 4 года назад +1

      Absolutely correct... I am also from kerala.. I am backing you...

    • @anesh.red.comrade
      @anesh.red.comrade 4 года назад

      @Guru Do you really like communism, or do you want to correct it, then join in a communist party and please show them right way towards socialism..
      Are you capitalist or a mixed economy supporter.
      You mentioned about kerala leaders, whose sons does not following communist principles, you may be right, but as a independent person ,it's their interest to join in party and work for people , it is not correct ,if any father compels his son to do so.
      Communists always against liberalisation. Economic liberalisation leads to corruption, black market.

  • @prakashparashar2920
    @prakashparashar2920 4 года назад +20

    I voted BJP but on so many occasions I like to hear Mr Yechury... He has struggled a lot for his party.
    A true warrior!!

  • @anandsh127
    @anandsh127 4 года назад +2

    Friends, naam rakh lene se koi country communist nahi hoti like Russia or China.
    Today China is the biggest supporter of Capitalism. Aur ye communism ideology bilkul bhi nahi h.
    Ese toh Hitler ki party ka naam Nazi #Socialist party tha aur socialist vale usne kya kaam kiye jara batana??
    Kaam se judge karo naam se nahi.
    Communism isliye fail hui bcz Human nature me greed hai. Kisi country ke resources uske har citizen me equally divided hone chahiye ye communism ka main point hai but ye practical nahi h and ideal hai I know that.
    Still I will say "Communism is the highest form of humanism".
    If one is communist one has to be democratic also.
    Trust what I have said. I am an MA graduate in Political Science from Panjab University Chd.

    • @comradebrother7411
      @comradebrother7411 4 года назад +1

      Exactly.....you described everything well

    • @vertex_gaming
      @vertex_gaming 4 года назад

      You said it right. but they're not loyal to India.
      ruclips.net/video/LNml4ZyfwOo/видео.html

  • @arjo302
    @arjo302 4 года назад +9

    Our pride

  • @s.vraman6009
    @s.vraman6009 4 года назад +2

    Bina communism ke hi USSR super power ho gya tha na?
    Cuba ka example saamne hai. Vietnam ka bhi.

    • @s.vraman6009
      @s.vraman6009 4 года назад

      @Keshav kya baat kar raha hai?
      Padh ke aao bhai.

    • @guts2008
      @guts2008 4 года назад

      @@s.vraman6009 tum padho chutiye . china aur vietnam capitalist dictatorship hain

  • @bikashray237
    @bikashray237 4 года назад +4

    It's interesting how Mr yechury is blaming rss (@12:55) for converting india to a hindu rashtra by throwing out democracy and secularism(which i believe is somewhat true) but does not mention his own ideology of the communists which wants to overthrow democracy by revolution(i.e. complete violence). Hypocrisy at it's best.

    • @swastik4302
      @swastik4302 3 года назад +5

      We communist always stand for democracy but Liberal Democracies are democracy only for the Rich.....That is why so many "democratic" governments have such high economic inequality....Like your role model USA

    • @xiijinpingthesupremeleader1349
      @xiijinpingthesupremeleader1349 2 года назад

      @@swastik4302 if there is no other ideology other tham communism , then how exactly is this supporting of democracy. Democracy allows room for various ideologies to have a say among the masses, which is why communists hate it, cause they don't want any ideology other than their own( I don't blame them only, basically every ideology thinks the same way).

    • @laba3423
      @laba3423 Год назад

      @@swastik4302 still when your ass will burn you will run to usa not china

  • @adhiplodh8571
    @adhiplodh8571 5 месяцев назад +2

    Long live revolution

  • @vishnuprakshs1243
    @vishnuprakshs1243 4 года назад +4

    You should provide ha ha 🤣 reaction also with like and dislike buttons

  • @rezinhussain4994
    @rezinhussain4994 4 года назад +8

    We ll come back strong 😍

    • @abhinavagrahari3972
      @abhinavagrahari3972 4 года назад +8

      So you must be athesit and dont belive in allaha and quram

    • @rezinhussain4994
      @rezinhussain4994 4 года назад +5

      @@abhinavagrahari3972 I believe in Science 😉 Encyclopedia is my holy book?
      Anything more u wanna know?

    • @guts2008
      @guts2008 4 года назад +4

      @@rezinhussain4994 no your holy book should be das capital not science . because communism is fiction not science jihadi

    • @rezinhussain4994
      @rezinhussain4994 4 года назад +5

      @@guts2008 who the hell are you to decide my book🤣

    • @shravangupta4828
      @shravangupta4828 3 года назад

      No you will never.

  • @Sam-pq5qs
    @Sam-pq5qs 17 дней назад +2

    RIP COMRADE😢😢

  • @chumbenthung9342
    @chumbenthung9342 17 дней назад +2

    Red salute 🌹

  • @SatyendraVarma
    @SatyendraVarma 4 года назад +7

    very cool credentials, whatever his work maybe his character is very cool.

  • @shashwatkauraw8085
    @shashwatkauraw8085 Месяц назад +2

    We need communism

  • @karthikshinde6739
    @karthikshinde6739 Год назад +1

    Lol salam😂😂😂

  • @muhammednajeeb1278
    @muhammednajeeb1278 4 года назад +3

    Many says Communism is a failed ideology...Just Look at Kerala and see how they rise and become best state in India

    • @bantaibabafan1167
      @bantaibabafan1167 4 года назад +3

      People just want to talk negative about this party without understanding the contributions by the left

    • @emperorhirohito3676
      @emperorhirohito3676 2 года назад +1

      These fools organised a stike against computerisation of firm..

    • @xeno4162
      @xeno4162 2 года назад

      @@bantaibabafan1167 Exactly, some don't even realise how big Socialism as an ideology really is, it has so many variations that are very different.

  • @sakethsai5557
    @sakethsai5557 4 года назад +3

    whats wrong in india becoming a hindu rashtra where hindus population is more than 80% should we become a islamic country though their population is 15-18% bjp can develope all religions equally but parties like cpi and cpm and congress dont care of hindus though we are majority which is a blunder mistake and india cannot develope

    • @angryfang
      @angryfang 11 месяцев назад

      Arey hindu rastra banane ke chakar mein tumlog baki dharm ka aur dalits ka sarvanaash karwaoge

  • @mohmayamukt
    @mohmayamukt 4 года назад +6

    Common comment and belief - communism is good but we can’t practically apply it so it fails all the time like in china n all. Nothing is perfect we will see impacts of capitalism after 20-30 yrs when largest democracy in the world have a huge gap in capital between some rich people and majority poor people. Then we will say what’s the option for poor people in this country then communism as a concept we will surely miss. Best option is always a balance between them and show them we vote for a person who do good for society not for there agenda of hindutva or communism.

  • @shark7n10
    @shark7n10 4 года назад +22

    Communism in china and Communism in India are totally 2 different entities people here keep comparing them!

    • @anandms7537
      @anandms7537 4 года назад +14

      Communism in China works for china by capitalism, communism in India also works for china through blocking and protesting aginast various industries in India which made India to depend on china

    • @Chairman_MaoZedong
      @Chairman_MaoZedong 15 дней назад

      Communists of china are han nationalists, they don't oppose han culture.

  • @pranav1972
    @pranav1972 3 года назад +1

    That Red flag should come down 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

    • @crewmate6105
      @crewmate6105 3 года назад

      When you say Indian flag i hope u didn't mean about BJP or conRss

  • @abhishekunni2433
    @abhishekunni2433 4 года назад +10

    Keep on dreaming when we have Pinarayi.

    • @22.chriskevin18
      @22.chriskevin18 4 года назад +3

      Do communists believe in stealing gold? Nte ponnu mwone nammich 🙏😂

    • @abhishekunni2433
      @abhishekunni2433 4 года назад +1

      @@22.chriskevin18 ente ponn aliya, rashtriya karr akumbol thattipp vettipp ond avum. 😂 Ath inherent ann.

    • @crewmate6105
      @crewmate6105 3 года назад

      @@22.chriskevin18 ഇപ്പൊ ഇത് ആരും പറയുന്നില്ല എല്ലാ ആരോപണങ്ങളും പൊളിഞ്ഞു 🤣🤣