A Vision of Shadows should’ve 100% stayed a 3-part series. The whole Darktail plot was infinitely interesting, and had they focused solely on that, I think it could’ve easily been the best arc in the franchise.
I'm only on the broken code book 2 but on my gosh it is so good so far I'm not a big fan of rootpaw/rootspring but bristlefrost is so good I hate her and stemleaf drama but besides that her character is wonderful shadowsight and the clans not really liking him was not the best plot point but besides that his character is alright so far i also don't really like how rootpaw/rootspring was always looming over bristlefrost but the broken code is alriggt so far
I was trying to find what books to sell so thank you. Also I have quit reading the books bc they were labeled as furry books and have actually gave me bad “furry habits”-I loved the books when I was younger tho and I think lionblaze could have been better
wow this book series seems to...like kinda sucks? Sounds like the only thing worth it for a casual reading is the firsts series and the rest is kinda a mess
One of my complaints with power of 3 is because cats do stuff out of character like cloudtail forgetting about brighthart when in the first arc he worked day and night for her to become a warrior
Haven't read any of these books since I was in 4th grade, thought there were only like 4 books back then, had NO IDEA there were this many!!! great video ^ ^
Ok the first three books in AVOS are pretty good, (other than the last three books which suck, there like filler books) But they wouldn't be last for me. Also can you make "Ranking Warrior Cats Clans" I would love to see your opinion! This is mine: Shadow, River, Sky, Thunder, Wind
Sorry for making more then one comment but I also disagree with the second arc being in number 3. It's better then arcs 3 and 4 (and dotc). I like Squirrelflight a lot, she's a funny little brat in this arc but also matures over the course of the arc. Leafpool is really boring, and so is Stormfur. Brambleclaw just feels like he's trying to be Firestar but is also just frustratingly stupid.
I absolutely cannot agree with Dawn of the Clans being number 2. The idea is cool, and First Battle is good for the most part. But Clear Sky is just so frustrating with how they deal with his redemption, and Grey Wing is even worse because most of his chapters are just him defending Clear Sky's actions. Thunder is alright though.
(edit: This is outdated and I will update it...eventually)
A Vision of Shadows should’ve 100% stayed a 3-part series. The whole Darktail plot was infinitely interesting, and had they focused solely on that, I think it could’ve easily been the best arc in the franchise.
AVoS was saved by Darktail being an excellent villain, and Needletail and Violetshine's friendship imo. But the second half was kinda lame.
I KNEW The Prophecies Begin we’re gonna be here🎉
TNP doesnt deserve the third place for me. the first three books are boring and reading Brambleclaw’s pov was… annoying.
A vision of shadows was a better arc then the last two generally in my opinion
I'm only on the broken code book 2 but on my gosh it is so good so far I'm not a big fan of rootpaw/rootspring but bristlefrost is so good I hate her and stemleaf drama but besides that her character is wonderful shadowsight and the clans not really liking him was not the best plot point but besides that his character is alright so far i also don't really like how rootpaw/rootspring was always looming over bristlefrost but the broken code is alriggt so far
I was trying to find what books to sell so thank you. Also I have quit reading the books bc they were labeled as furry books and have actually gave me bad “furry habits”-I loved the books when I was younger tho and I think lionblaze could have been better
wow this book series seems to...like kinda sucks? Sounds like the only thing worth it for a casual reading is the firsts series and the rest is kinda a mess
One of my complaints with power of 3 is because cats do stuff out of character like cloudtail forgetting about brighthart when in the first arc he worked day and night for her to become a warrior
Haven't read any of these books since I was in 4th grade, thought there were only like 4 books back then, had NO IDEA there were this many!!! great video ^ ^
For me this is my list:
I really enjoyed this! This video definitely deserves more views! I really like and agree with your opinions can’t wait to see more of your channel
Ok the first three books in AVOS are pretty good, (other than the last three books which suck, there like filler books) But they wouldn't be last for me. Also can you make "Ranking Warrior Cats Clans" I would love to see your opinion! This is mine: Shadow, River, Sky, Thunder, Wind
Sorry for making more then one comment but I also disagree with the second arc being in number 3. It's better then arcs 3 and 4 (and dotc). I like Squirrelflight a lot, she's a funny little brat in this arc but also matures over the course of the arc. Leafpool is really boring, and so is Stormfur. Brambleclaw just feels like he's trying to be Firestar but is also just frustratingly stupid.
I’ve only read the first series, the new prophecy and a bit of power of three
Favorite cats from each arc.
I absolutely cannot agree with Dawn of the Clans being number 2. The idea is cool, and First Battle is good for the most part. But Clear Sky is just so frustrating with how they deal with his redemption, and Grey Wing is even worse because most of his chapters are just him defending Clear Sky's actions. Thunder is alright though.
I loved The New Prophecy books, especially the last three. Meanwhile I read halfway through the first vision of Shadows book and quit
Mine: